These NFL Teams Paid Millions And REGRETTED It Almost Immediately
4 Video Views·Oct 12, 2026
Six weeks after the Falcons guaranteed Kirk Cousins $100 million,
they drafted his replacement.
The Atlanta Falcons have selected Michael Penix.
While Atlanta was on the clock, Cousins' phone rang.
The team was taking a quarterback.
Not him.
These are 10 contracts NFL teams regretted almost immediately,
ranked from bad to worst.
And Cousins is only number four.
So here's the question.
How does a team plan a franchise contract for months
and regret it this fast?
On every one, we'll run a regret clock,
from the day the deal was struck to the moment it went wrong.
Ahead, a team that paid a draft pick to get rid of its quarterback.
A superstar whose first real game
as a Jet lasted about three minutes of game time.
Guess how many snaps he played?
A deal that went wrong in days.
And the owner behind the top spot, who gave his own deal a verdict.
Le'Veon Bell sat out a full season
rather than play on Pittsburgh's tender.
Then, the Jets gave him $27 million guaranteed, and Bell tweeted,
I'm back in the green, baby. Let's get it.
Two months later, the Jets fired the general manager who signed him.
The same day, the Daily News reported
that Coach Adam Gase absolutely did not want to sign Bell.
As a Jet, he never had a 100-yard game.
After the season, Gase was asked if he wanted Bell back.
He's under contract for three more years. You can ask Joe tomorrow.
Think about that.
A coach is asked about his running back,
and he points at somebody else.
Bell quote-tweeted the clip with a gif from the office.
Remember that sentence. You'll hear it again.
Months later, the Jets cut him and got nothing back.
But the next team paid extra to get out of its deal.
Houston signed Brock Osweiler before it really knew him.
Owner Bob McNair later admitted,
We didn't know Brock well enough.
Thursday night in Foxborough,
Houston is shut out by a rookie making his first NFL start.
Back home, the crowd boos him.
His high pass is deflected
and picked off by Jalen Ramsey, who runs it back.
Next drive, another interception.
Second quarter, he's benched.
Backup Tom Savage jogs on to a huge ovation and wins it.
And the fans here in Houston go nuts!
Exactly one year to the day after he signed,
Houston traded him to Cleveland
and attached a second-round pick to get rid of him.
Houston wanted out.
The next team offered a way out, and the player said no.
Washington gave Albert Haynesworth
the most guaranteed money ever promised to
an NFL player at the time. At his introduction he made a promise of his
own. But you know during
that game I'll make sure he knows I'm the best player.
His clock stopped at his debut against the Giants.
The cameras kept finding him
on the sideline bent over out of breath.
Then new coach Mike Shanahan arrived and
Haynesworth's 21 million dollar bonus was coming due.
Washington offered a way out
leave and give up the bonus. He kept the money.
Next came the conditioning test. He
passed the first shuttle,
then took a bathroom break of about 10 minutes. Told
to start over, he couldn't finish.
It took days to pass. Washington suspended him
without pay, then traded him for a fifth round pick.
It paid about 35 million
dollars for six and a half sacks.
Another record contract. This one comes with a
second record. Philadelphia gave Carson Wentz,
coming off significant injuries,
the most guaranteed money in NFL history at the time.
Owner Jeffrey Lurie opened the news conference.
I couldn't be more pleased that Carson's going
to be our quarterback for many more years.
Then it's draft night, and the Eagles take
a quarterback in the second round, Jalen Hurts.
The Inquirer quoted the Eagles' Howie Roseman.
We want to be a quarterback factory.
Lambeau Field.
Wentz is benched in the third quarter.
Hurts comes in, and on fourth and long,
he rolls right and throws a touchdown.
Then, the Eagles traded Wentz to the Colts
and took a $33.8 million dead cap hit, a record
at the time.
A record for guaranteed money, a record for dead money.
Same player, 623 days apart.
Next, a team we've already met on this list.
The Jets are back.
After Bell, the Jets wanted a bigger name,
and Aaron Rodgers wanted them.
My intention was to play,
and my intention was to play for the New York Jets.
To get him, the Jets paid in draft picks.
At his introduction, he talked trophies.
I noticed walking in this morning
that that Super Bowl III trophy is looking a little lonely.
He took a pay cut to sign a new deal, $75 million,
all of it guaranteed.
Monday night, the anniversary of 9-11 at MetLife Stadium,
his first regular season game as a Jet.
Minutes before kickoff,
Rodgers sprints out carrying the American flag.
He played four snaps.
On the fourth snap, Bill's pass rusher,
Leonard Floyd brings him down, a torn left Achilles.
The Jets won in overtime,
but he never played again that season.
He came back the next season and started every game.
The coach and the general manager
were both fired before it ended.
The Jets released him.
Owner Woody Johnson called it a good experiment
that just didn't work out.
Divide what they paid him by his wins as a starter.
About $12.5 million a win.
Number five more than doubles it.
He went to Pittsburgh, where the Steelers won the AFC North.
The Jets kept the bill.
One more quarterback belongs near this list.
He lasted a little longer.
Jacksonville gave Super Bowl MVP Nick Foles
what NFL Network called
the richest contract in franchise history.
It's everyone's dream, whoever grew up wanting to play football,
to have a franchise believe in you.
It went wrong on opening day.
Foles throws a touchdown
as Chiefs defensive tackle Chris Jones lands on him.
No flag.
A broken left collarbone.
11 plays into the season.
A sixth-round rookie, Gardner Minshew, took over.
Foles never won a start in Jacksonville, then was traded.
Now the heavyweights, all bigger contracts than anything so far.
And at the top of the list, a team gave up three first-round picks
before its new quarterback played a snap.
The Giants signed Daniel Jones just before the franchise tag deadline,
with $82 million guaranteed.
The good feeling didn't last.
His first game on the New Deal?
Dallas shuts them out, and Jones is sacked seven times.
HBO's cameras get inside the Giants' front office.
General Manager Joe Shane asks whether Jones is their guy
or whether they need to pivot.
Later in the same episode, he says this.
Same sentence, different team.
Here's where I land.
When a team has to remind people a player is under contract,
it's already looking for the exit.
Draft day, the same day Cousins' phone rang,
Shane calls New England about moving up for a quarterback.
I think we're pretty happy with the game
that we're sitting here playing.
The Patriots stayed put and took Drake May.
Months later, Jones was benched, then released at his own request.
He won three games as a starter on the deal.
That's $27 million in guaranteed money per win,
more than double Rodgers' rate.
The next quarterback found out on draft night, by phone.
Back to that phone call.
His agent said, that was the first we heard.
Put yourself in his shoes.
You sign the deal, and weeks later,
your team calls to say it's drafting a quarterback.
In Netflix's Quarterback, Cousins described how it felt.
Then it got worse.
The NFL found Atlanta broke its anti-tampering rules recruiting him
and took a fifth-round pick.
Later, the Falcons benched Cousins for Michael Penix Jr.,
the rookie they drafted.
The next day, he faced reporters.
I didn't forget how to play quarterback.
The coach and general manager who signed him were fired.
Atlanta released him, and he landed with the Raiders.
Atlanta drafted his replacement within weeks
and was still paying part of his salary two years later.
And that isn't even the fastest.
Number three went wrong in days.
Denver traded a pile of picks for Russell Wilson.
Before he played a regular season game, they gave him an extension.
Wilson said it wasn't about how much,
it was about how many Super Bowls they'd win.
This one went wrong in 11 days.
Back in Seattle on Monday Night Football,
Denver loses fumbles at the goal line.
Then, trailing with seconds left,
Coach Nathaniel Hackett sends out a 64-yard field goal try,
instead of letting the quarterback they just paid throw.
Wide left.
The crowd chants,
Geno! Geno!
Yeah, they wrote me off. I ain't right back, though.
That was September 12th.
Hackett was fired that December.
Under the next head coach, Sean Payton, Wilson was benched.
Wilson said that during the bye week, the team told him he'd
be benched unless he changed his injury guarantee.
It definitely hurt. It was a little blow.
Payton said the move was meant to get a spark on offense.
Then Denver released him and took an $85 million dead cap hit,
a record at the time.
Pittsburgh signed him for the league minimum.
Imagine being Denver's cap manager.
For that one season, your team paid him
about 31 times what Pittsburgh did.
Denver's dead cap record lasted two years.
Number two broke it.
Same date as Wilson, two years later,
September 12th, Thursday night against Buffalo.
Tua lowers his head on a scramble, goes down, and stays down.
The diagnosis was a concussion, at least his third since 2022.
The next season, coach Mike McDaniel benches him
for a seventh-round rookie, Quinn Ewers.
And Tua will be the emergency third.
Soon after, McDaniel was fired.
Then Miami released Tua and took on an NFL record dead cap hit,
breaking Wilson's $85 million, $99.2 million.
Atlanta signed him for the league minimum.
That year, Miami owed him about 44 times what Atlanta paid him.
His head coach in Atlanta, Kevin Stefanski, used to coach number one.
March 2022.
Cleveland sends Houston three first-round picks,
and more, for Deshaun Watson.
Then it gives him $230 million, every dollar guaranteed.
At the time, the most guaranteed money ever given to an NFL player.
Even Ravens owner Steve Bisciotti said,
I don't know that he should have been the first guy
to get a fully guaranteed contract.
Cleveland's own owner will give his verdict on this deal.
Here is what came with the deal.
More than two dozen women, most of them massage therapists,
accused Watson of sexual misconduct.
Lawsuits alleged it.
He denied wrongdoing at his first press conference as a Brown.
I've never assaulted any woman.
I never disrespected any woman.
Texas grand juries declined to indict him, and he was never charged.
He settled most of the civil suits.
When the trade happened, at least 22 were still pending.
Then the league's discipline.
Retired judge Sue L. Robinson, the disciplinary officer the NFL
and the Players Union appointed jointly,
found that Watson violated
the league's personal conduct policy and suspended him.
The league appealed.
The side settled on an 11-game suspension,
a $5 million fine, and mandatory evaluation and treatment.
Then the football.
19 starts in his first three seasons,
and the last of them ended with a torn Achilles.
Then came a re-rupture, and a whole season missed.
By guaranteed money and draft picks combined,
it's arguably the most expensive quarterback bet in league history.
The owner from the opening, Jimmy Haslam, gave his verdict.
We took a big swing and miss with Deshaun.
By 2026, Browns fans were booing him at home.
He was asked about it.
It's a disrespectful thing.
So how does a team plan a contract for months and regret it this fast?
It doesn't regret what it learned.
It regrets what it already knew.
Cousins was coming off a torn Achilles.
Bell's coach reportedly did not want to sign him.
Watson arrived with lawsuits still pending.
The warning signs were there before the signature.
The money could not buy these players the job,
or the city, or the right to be the answer.
Kirk Cousins learned that in a phone call,
while his team was on the clock.
Which contract would you add to this list?

