These Are The Dumbest Draft Decisions In NFL History
Oct 19, 2026
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis video examines the most disastrous draft decisions in NFL history, ranking them by the cost in draft picks, money, and professional reputations. It highlights how overconfidence and the pursuit of \"certainty\" often lead general managers to overpay for players who ultimately fail to deliver, contrasting these busts with the unexpected success of late-round picks.
One team traded its entire draft for one running back.
Another paid three extra picks to move up one spot,
taking a quarterback over Patrick Mahomes.
A third paid three firsts for a quarterback
who started four games,
then turned to the draft's last pick.
These are the dumbest draft decisions in NFL history,
ranked by what they cost.
Picks, money, jobs.
The second team's quarterback found out like this.
I didn't even get a phone call, just heard my name called.
Every one of these came down to one phone call.
So how do people paid millions to make that call
get it this wrong?
Ahead, you'll meet a coach who promised
to jump in a lake and did.
A team that tried to claw back millions
from its own number one pick and ended up paying him more.
And a team that said no to an entire draft.
We start with the cheapest mistake on this list.
April 26th, 2003.
Minnesota holds the seventh pick.
And, its coach said later, the owner wants to trade down.
Back then, teams got 15 minutes to make a first-round pick.
The Vikings phone in a trade with Baltimore with about 32 seconds left.
Baltimore never confirmed it.
The clock runs out.
Then the room notices the team logo on ESPN's broadcast hasn't changed.
Vikings executive Rob Brzezinski, years later.
We're all sitting there in the draft room, just watching on TV.
all hell broke loose.
Jacksonville jumps in and takes Byron Leftwich. Carolina
takes Jordan Gross. The Vikings finally pick ninth.
Thousands of fans at the
Vikings draft party booed. The pick?
Kevin Williams made six Pro Bowls. The
league added phones and staff at the draft table.
The most embarrassing call
on this list was also the cheapest.
The next general manager made the same kind
of pick three years running.
The Lions took receiver Charles Rogers second
overall. With the very next pick,
Houston took Andre Johnson. Rodgers broke his
collarbone twice, and Detroit later cut him.
The next two years, Detroit spent
high first-round picks on receivers again.
Three straight drafts! That season,
about a thousand Lions fans marched on Ford Field,
dressed in the visiting
Bengals orange, demanding the general manager be fired.
Millen later said he
wanted DeMarcus Ware, and got talked out of it.
To Sports Illustrated, he put it
this way. I had DeMarcus Ware on the phone and what a dope I was.
Millen was fired three games
into his eighth season.
The Lions finished 0-16, the first team ever to do it.
When it was over,
Millen went on NBC and took the blame. His words?
You take the hit and move on. Green Bay holds the
second pick and takes an offensive tackle from Michigan State,
Tony Mandarich. Sports Illustrated
had already put him on its cover, shirtless, in front of a setting sun.
Then he walked into an airport store.
The whole top shelf around the whole store
was that issue next to each other,
like probably 50 of them.
Before the draft, Packers GM Tom Brotz told
the Tampa Tribune about the steroid rumors.
Our information is good.
Years later, Mandarich admitted he used steroids in college.
He says he stopped before the combine.
Now guess, how many of the top five picks
that year made the Hall of Fame?
Four.
Troy Aikman, Barry Sanders, Derek Thomas, and Deion Sanders.
The one who didn't went second.
Then Sports Illustrated put him on its cover again.
Sports Illustrated reported that Chargers GM Bobby Beathard
closed this deal from a payphone in Steamboat Springs, Colorado.
The trade moved San Diego up one spot to number two.
That guaranteed it would get Peyton Manning or Ryan Leaf,
whichever the Colts left. Beathard's take on the price?
Did we overpay? Shoot, we all overpay in
this game now. For everything.
On draft day, Leaf said he was looking forward to a 15-year career,
a couple of trips to the Super Bowl,
and a parade through downtown San Diego. The day after a brutal
loss to Kansas City, a reporter asked him about cursing
at a TV cameraman. Leaf screamed at him.
You've probably seen the clip. Don't talk to me, all right?
Knock it off! Junior Seau pulled him
away. Leaf is the name everyone knows,
but another team once held the same pick and decided it didn't
want it. Cleveland hired Paul DePodesta
of Moneyball fame to help run its draft. The plan?
Collect picks. So the Browns traded the second pick to Philadelphia,
which took Carson Wentz.
On draft night, they traded down again.
A year later, Cleveland took Miles Garrett first overall.
Then it traded the 12th pick to Houston,
which took Deshaun Watson. Before that draft,
after a miserable season,
head coach Hugh Jackson said it wouldn't happen again.
I'm not going 1-15.
No. Well, I'll be swimming in the lake over there somewhere.
That season, the Browns went 0-16.
Sashi Brown, who ran the plan, was fired with the team still
winless. Months later,
Jackson waded into Lake Erie with his staff and owner Dee Haslam.
We're going to cleanse ourselves.
Five years after that draft,
Cleveland paid three first-round picks for Deshaun Watson,
then guaranteed him $230 million.
That's about $46 million a year for the quarterback it could
have drafted with that 12th pick.
A month before the draft, the 49ers paid three first-round picks
to move up to third. They didn't say who.
On draft night, Kyle Shanahan, John Lynch,
and Jed York huddle around a phone.
On the line, Trey Lance.
You got a hunch for a while?
Oh, man, I didn't know, coach.
You wouldn't tell me nothing.
Lance started just four games for San Francisco.
The fourth ended on a cart with a broken right ankle.
Dallas got him for a fourth-round pick.
San Francisco turned to its last pick
from the following year's draft.
Guess where Brock Purdy went?
Dead last.
Number 262, Mr. Irrelevant.
Three years after that draft,
Purdy signed an extension worth $265 million,
the last pick in the draft.
John Lynch, who made the trade, on Brock.
Yeah, we got lucky on Brock, but sure, that set back our team.
Washington wanted Robert Griffin III so much,
it gave the Rams three first-round picks
and a second to move up the board.
GM Bruce Allen, yes, the same Bruce Allen from our Gruden video, said,
We understand it was a heavy price, but when you bought your home,
you probably wanted to pay a little less too.
Would you pay that for a rookie quarterback?
For one season, it worked.
Griffin was Offensive Rookie of the Year, January 6th, 2013. Fourth
quarter of the playoff game, a low shotgun snap.
Griffin lunges for it, and his braced right knee
buckles. That day, the Washington Times sports editor asked why he
was still out there. Kirk
Cousins, a fourth round pick in that same draft, finished the game.
You might remember his phone
call from one of our earlier videos.
Mike Shanahan, the coach, was fired after a 3-13 finish.
That collapse turned the last first-round pick Washington owed
the Rams into the second pick
overall. The Rams turned those picks into eight players.
CBS still said everyone lost.
Chicago holds the third pick. It trades up one spot.
To move up a single spot, the Bears handed
San Francisco three more picks,
including a third rounder the next year. The Bears general manager,
Ryan Pace, told ESPN's Mike and Mike what scared him.
And you look up and all of a sudden there's
another team on the clock with the two pick.
And, you know, you'd regret that for a long time.
Mitchell Trubisky sat in the green room. He told the NFL's cameras,
I'm not hearing anything. It's been silent.
Then Roger Goodell read his name. Remember what he
said at the top, no phone call. Patrick Mahomes went 10th.
One of the picks the Bears gave away
became Alvin Kamara. Trubisky was not a flop.
The Bears won their division with him in his second
season. But within five years of that trade,
Pace and his coach Matt Nagy were both fired.
The next team didn't trade up at all.
It already had the first pick. Oakland took Jamarcus Russell
first overall. Calvin Johnson went next to Detroit.
Adrian Peterson went seventh. Russell held out for
48 days. On opening day, Johnson scored a touchdown in Oakland,
while the Raiders' top pick sat
unsigned. Then he signed, with more than $30 million guaranteed.
By the Associated Press's
math, each win cost the Raiders more than $5 million.
September 30, 2008, Alameda. Al Davis
sits under a big desk lamp to explain why he fired Coach Lane Kiffin.
Behind him, an overhead
projector shows a letter to Kiffin.
The letter said, I do realize that you did not want us to
draft Jamarcus Russell. He is a great player.
Get over it and coach this team on the field.
Davis on Kiffin. It hurts because I picked the guy.
I picked the wrong guy.
Three years after drafting him, the Raiders released Russell.
Then they went after him
for money they had advanced.
They settled, and the Raiders paid him about $3 million more.
The top spot goes to a single trade made by Mike Ditka.
He died on October 9th at 86. A Hall of
Fame tight end and the coach who won the Bears their only Super Bowl.
This is about one decision,
not the man. Ditka had said in public
that he would trade his entire draft for Ricky Williams,
the Heisman winner from Texas.
It's April 17, 1999.
Cincinnati is on the clock at number three,
and New Orleans wants the pick.
The Saints offer their entire draft, plus future picks.
Would you have taken it?
Cincinnati asked for more.
First-round picks for the next three years.
ESPN's Ed Werder reported Mike Ditka's answer.
As Mike Ditka put it, their request was outrageous.
The Bengals kept the pick
and took a quarterback from Oregon, Keely Smith.
He won three games as an NFL starter.
At number four, the Colts passed on Williams.
Back in New Orleans, Ditka lit a cigar, live on ESPN.
Then Washington, holding the fifth pick, said yes.
Paul Tagliabue made it official.
There has been a trade involving this fifth pick in the draft.
The Saints gave up eight picks.
Everything they had left in that draft,
plus a first and a third the next year.
That future first became the second pick overall.
Washington took the deal and got Champ Bailey and LeVar Arrington.
ESPN the magazine put them on its cover that summer.
Ditka in a tux, Ricky in a wedding dress.
That spring, Ditka had told fans,
we're going to win the Super Bowl.
The Saints went 3-13.
Days later, Ditka, the general manager,
and the whole coaching staff were fired.
Ditka understood why.
You bring in Ricky Williams, and it doesn't work out.
Ricky Williams, years later, on what he would have told Ditka.
And I would have said, don't do it.
Here's where I land.
Ricky Williams wasn't the problem.
Telling the whole league you'll pay a full draft for him was.
So how do people paid millions make a call this bad?
It isn't that they knew too little.
It's that they were sure.
Ryan Pace said it himself.
If you have conviction on a player, you go get him.
Because the alternative is, you don't know.
Many of these teams paid extra to buy certainty.
A whole draft.
More picks.
A move up the board.
The cheapest pick on this list
was the last pick in its draft, Brock Purdy.
His own general manager called it luck.
In 2026, the Raiders took
a quarterback first overall again, Fernando Mendoza.
Their first first-round quarterback since Jamarcus Russell.
Before the draft, owner Mark Davis told the team's website,
but we've had that position before, and it didn't work out.
Every April, somebody picks up that phone.
Which draft night call would you add to this list?

