-The Sopranos Analysis _ Dysfunctional Comedy.

Humour Den
20 followers
1 Video View·Nov 16, 2022
You just saw two actors have an entire conversation saying only A and the other responding B.
Mitch Christopher, you want to give it a try?
A.
If you had to describe The Sopranos to someone who'd never seen it, what would you say?
I'm guessing you'd use the words mafia and drama and violence and stuff, but would you
use the words funny or sitcom?
I'm guessing not, and yet it is a show packed with a lot of great humorous moments.
This is not a mafia drama like The Godfather where everybody moves silkily smooth across
the screen, where by just sitting still with a cigar in their mouths they look like the
height of intimidation and coolness.
The Godfather gives the mafia this operatic feel that the characters in The Sopranos are
striving after.
They talk constantly about The Godfather and tie it closely to their identity and cultural
roots with this idealised romantic feel that they all want to be like Michael or Vito Corleone,
but they're nothing like them.
Tony Soprano is technically a man running around in his dressing gown, losing his temper
at everything, a man who struggles with panic attacks and feels like he inhabits a world
of idiots.
In the sense he doesn't have solid, reliable foot soldiers who he can trust to get the
job done.
He doesn't get to feel cool because Christopher is never above descending into immature stupidity
and shooting the foot off a shopkeeper because he wasn't served first, and Paulie's an old
man who drivels on about nothing.
You look at ladies' johns, you could eat maple warm and ice cream from the toilets.
Eh, there's exceptions.
Even Silvio has his moments of pettiness.
These aren't glamorous gangsters, they're smart people, but also kind of idiots trapped
in this constant squabble with each other where, if only they knew how to communicate
better, they might achieve so much more.
Some I gotta confess, what are you doing?
Getting my wine in position to throw in your damn face.
Ralph Cifaretto and Johnny Sack were supposed to be incredibly close friends, for example.
Ralph made a joke about Johnny's wife's weight, and suddenly they're both set on
murdering each other.
This isn't a world of opera-style mob bosses.
The fact we see them trying to cling to an idealised past that probably never truly existed
in the first place, that disconnect between their expectation and the reality the show
depicts provides a lot of comedy here.
I think we both empathise with and laugh at the sheer stress and frustration Tony feels.
Nothing he trusts people to do ever gets done right, those who work for him often cause
more problems than solutions as they all constantly fall into family arguments, make childish
mistakes and run to Tony wanting him to solve it all.
Take the episode Pine Barrens.
All Tony asks Paulie and Chris to do is collect a regular weekly payment that Silvio would
normally collect, only he's sick.
That's it.
A regular payment this man's happy to pay, only he's Russian and Paulie can't help
insulting him and they end up fighting and then Chris and Paulie beat him to death before
making a hash of burying him, getting lost in the woods, losing a shoe in the snow and
almost freezing to death, calling Tony for help over something two grown powerful men
should be able to handle on their own.
That is the plot for a comedy, isn't it?
Two urban gangsters who make a complete mess of the simplest job and then end up stuck
outside their comfort zone in nature, that on its own would make a great comedy film.
They squabble like children with each other, Paulie tries to make a shoe out of a bit of
carpet they find in a deserted van and their constant desperate phone calls completely
ruin Tony's date with his girlfriend.
Now let's also consider the family element of this show, a show whose tagline is family
redefined because The Sopranos in some senses takes the typical average American family
sitcom then says let's remove the laugh track, make the family a mob family, add in some
violence and some high stakes and in many ways this is a family sitcom about a dysfunctional
family that can't help fighting over everything, where you have people like Janice who'll steal
the prosthetic leg from her mums carer, Carmella who'll play the righteous good christian
and then demands Tony's blood money to buy jewellery, an incredibly vindictive and manipulative
mum then two kids who are struggling to try and not fall into this world they're surrounded
by.
Olivia's funeral scene sums it up best, a moment where the family should come together
yet you've got Janice putting on a performance about sharing warm and cherished memories
of a woman they all hated, Meadow robotically repeating the stock phrase at least she didn't
suffer to anyone who offers condolences, Christopher high off his head talking nonsense and Tony
standing there with gritted teeth thinking is this what my life is now, is this the mad
reality I inhabit.
But there is a point to all this I'm saying beyond just oh The Sopranos is a bit like
a comedy.
The point is there's this wonderful paradox at the show's heart which is in some ways
summed up by this mix between ridiculous sitcom and tense, incredibly serious drama.
It starts with the fact all the comedy is quite endearing and life-affirming in its
own weird way.
Seeing this dysfunctional family, I hate the word dysfunctional by the way but it's the
easiest word to explain the point.
Seeing this dysfunctional family we recognise some parts of our own families that relate
to it and we remember we're all basically flawed idiots who struggle to communicate
effectively half the time.
Even the supposedly coolest of cool humans, these godfather-like types are actually just
petty childish idiots, the same as the rest of us.
Even Tony is never above it, and it's funny because that's what humanity is.
We enjoy spotting all the contradictions and hypocrisies in everything these characters
do, it makes them fun.
These flaws make us care about them rather than hate them.
We understand perfectly how stupid and impulsive Christopher can be and we like him for it.
Carmella, where her righteousness could be annoying, here it's endearing because the
flaws and hypocrisies are so obvious.
The way she runs about trying to play happy housewife and good christian with all the
other mob wives becomes comical when we also see the violent truth their husbands grapple
with to earn that money.
It's comical in general how much they all talk about the importance of love and family
and they hug and pat each other on the back constantly and yet will also have no hesitation
blowing each other's brains out the very second there's any dispute.
It sounds completely dumb of me to say, and you might disagree, and I've not even seen
the final season of the show yet, but I find The Sopranos an incredibly life affirming
show, at least in that sense.
It tells us everybody is flawed, everybody is hypocritical and childish and do dumb immature
things without even realising half the time.
That's humanity and we can laugh at it.
Somehow all their faults, or okay most of them, are endearing.
We realise our own faults aren't things we have to feel shame and hatred for but we can
laugh about them the same way.
We can look upon our flawed selves with some sense of affection.
But that's sort of a paradox because it's a completely stupid thing for me to say.
What am I talking about?
How can this be a life affirming show?
How can we find their faults endearing?
These are people who do brutal horrific stuff.
We shouldn't look on them with affection surely, we should hate these people.
But we don't.
We're very much like Dr. Melfi in that sense, charmed by them, believing in an inherent
goodness that we hope can be found and brought out.
But should we believe?
Tony is a man that'll sit up at night and care for a sick horse, he's a man who will
cry when the ducks in his swimming pool leave.
We're charmed, we care for him and feel affection, despite also being disturbed by the horrible
stuff he regularly does.
And so this should be a very serious, sad, horrible drama about the violent deaths people
have to suffer for the sake of trivial blood money and the immature whims of egotistical
men.
That should be the most depressing show ever.
Not only seeing so many lives get wrecked, but knowing they're wrecked for no real meaning
or purpose beyond petty squabbles.
This should be tragic.
And yet it's still sort of an endearing comedy that makes us laugh, even when we probably
shouldn't, we can't help feeling a level of warmth and care.
And that's my point, that's how I see the show, humanity is fun and lovable and endearing
even when it probably shouldn't be, that's just life, we don't walk around as detached
emotionless blobs, we find humour amongst the seriousness, compassion amongst the horror,
we take a tragic drama and naturally turn it into a comedy.
These absurd characters full of absurd contradictions, we ourselves are just as absurd in caring
for them, that kind of is the comedy, or maybe it's not, maybe I'm just getting carried
away, I find it a nice thought though, we can't help finding something to feel affection
for in even the ugliest of places.
The Sopranos is great, arguably the best drama of all time, certainly up there in most people's
top 10s, top 5s and also arguably up there as a comedy as well.
The fact the show manages both comedy and drama so seamlessly, two polar opposites that
should clash and yet somehow find a unified mix that compliments them both is wonderful.
A wonderfully, wonderfully written show where the flawed world of these gangsters becomes
a microcosm for life and humanity as a whole.
Let me know what you think, good or bad, I haven't seen the final season yet so I don't
know if that'll completely batter everything I've said here, but like it if you like this
video, give it a like if you want in-depth videos on the Sopranos because I'm thinking
I could do that because there is an absolute ton in this show worth talking about in depth.
But yeah, subscribe if you fancy it, support me on Patreon if you want that little bit
extra, but otherwise, hopefully see you next time.
