Is the conservative movement turning against itself?
Victor Davis Hanson warns of a growing civil war within the American right as disagreements over President Donald Trump, the war in Iran, Tucker Carlson, and the future of MAGA threaten to divide the conservative coalition.
In today's VDH Daily Brief, Victor joins Jack Fowler to examine the political legacy of Charlie Kirk, the loss of influential conservative voices, and the increasingly bitter disagreements among Republicans over American foreign policy.
Victor discusses why he believes Charlie Kirk was essential to mobilizing young conservative voters, how Tucker Carlson's changing political positions have affected the MAGA movement, and why the term "neoconservative" is being misused in debates over Trump's military strategy.
He also explains the difference between prolonged nation-building and the decisive military interventions he associates with Trump's Jacksonian foreign policy. While defending aspects of Trump's approach to Iran, Victor strongly opposes deploying American ground troops or attempting to rebuild the country through another extended occupation.
But the stakes extend beyond foreign policy.
Victor argues that conservatives are losing sight of major constitutional debates, including the Electoral College, the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact, Supreme Court expansion, the Senate filibuster, and potential statehood for Washington, D.C., and Puerto Rico.
Are divisions within the Republican Party putting the broader conservative movement at risk?
Watch the full discussion with Victor Davis Hanson.
Chapters 00:00 – Charlie Kirk's Legacy and the Conservative Movement 03:05 – The Loss of Rush Limbaugh and Tucker Carlson's Changing Role 05:13 – A Civil War Inside the American Right 05:30 – Trump's Iran Strategy and the Neoconservative Debate 07:54 – Why Victor Challenged the Neoconservatives 10:12 – Trump Was Never an Isolationist 11:40 – Why Conservatives Are Divided Over Iran 13:19 – The Case Against Another Endless War 14:16 – Victor Warns Against Sending Ground Troops Into Iran 15:53 – The Fight Over the Electoral College 19:14 – The National Popular Vote Interstate Compact 21:10 – Could Democrats Expand the Supreme Court? 23:13 – The Future of the Senate Filibuster 24:34 – Washington, D.C., Puerto Rico, and Statehood 25:28 – Victor's Final Warning to Conservatives
Frequently Asked Questions
*Why does Victor Davis Hanson believe the conservative movement is divided?*
Victor points to disagreements over Trump's foreign policy, particularly Iran, as well as conflicts among influential conservative commentators. He argues that these internal disputes are weakening the movement's unity.
*What does Victor Davis Hanson say about Charlie Kirk?*
Victor credits Charlie Kirk with bringing younger Americans into conservative politics, challenging established universities, and helping organize voter registration and turnout in competitive states.
Does Victor Davis Hanson support Trump's military strategy in Iran?**
Victor distinguishes Trump's approach from prolonged military occupations and nation-building. He defends decisive military action in principle but criticizes aspects of the Iran campaign and strongly opposes deploying American ground troops.
*Why does Victor criticize the term "neoconservative"?*
Victor argues that the term has a specific historical meaning and should not automatically apply to anyone who supports military intervention. He distinguishes traditional neoconservative nation-building from the limited, decisive military operations he associates with Trump.
*What does Victor say about Tucker Carlson?*
Victor describes Tucker Carlson as a once-prominent voice in the MAGA movement whose changing positions have contributed to disagreements within the conservative coalition.
*What is the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact?*
The compact is an agreement among participating states to award their electoral votes to the winner of the national popular vote once states representing at least 270 electoral votes have joined. Victor expresses concern about its implications for the Electoral College.
*Why is Victor concerned about Supreme Court expansion and the filibuster?*
Victor argues that future Democratic majorities could attempt to expand the Supreme Court, eliminate the legislative filibuster, and pursue other structural changes that he believes would shift the country's political balance.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
The speaker analyzes the current state of the American conservative movement, contrasting \"Jacksonian\" decisive foreign policy with neoconservative nation-building. The discussion also warns of a strategic effort by the Democratic Party to permanently alter the U.S. constitutional framework to secure an unbreakable legislative and judicial majority.
There's a lot of Charlie Kirk talk.
I wonder what your take is on the consequence of his death.
Your thoughts on what Chris Rufo said
and any commentary you want to make about Dave Chappelle.
I think everybody's sick of it.
I really do.
One thing about Charlie Kirk,
he would go on these campuses,
and his whole mission in life,
and he was an autodidact.
He tried to learn and speak,
and he did two things that people keep forgetting.
He said, I don't believe that higher education
is worth the money as it's presently constructed,
and I'm going to listen to Hillsdale videos,
or I'm going to take online courses.
I'm going to educate myself.
He called me a couple of times and asked, what should I be reading?
And he was very sincere.
And then he said, I will go into places like the Oxford Debate Society,
where we supposedly
have the smartest people in the world,
and I'll go head-to-head with the president of
the Oxford Debating Society.
If you watch that debate, he wiped them off the floor.
And he would debate anybody.
He didn't care about the degree.
He was trying to tell people.
That education is education.
It doesn't have to be synonymous
with an ideologically tainted universe.
And if it is, that ideologically tainted universe needs to be reformed.
So he tried to reform it.
And number two, he told young people,
Anger at college and the way you're being indoctrinated,
your anger at the way of the
New Green Deal and all of the open border
that stifle economic prosperity, that is okay.
The conservatives are not old fuddy-duddies.
They are the counter-revolution party.
Just like your grandparents in the 60s thought it was hip
and cool to question the establishment,
So now it is.
Hip and cool for you to question the establishment, because
the establishment is Hollywood, entertainment, professional sports,
the media, the administrative state, K-12, academia.
That is the establishment.
So you are completely right to be a youthful critic of that.
And that was a new message, and it had enormous effect.
And he just wasn't an abstract, you know.
A podcaster like I am,
or a philosopher like some people think they are, he was a pragmatic
person. I think if you take him away from the swing states
and the voter registration and get
out the vote, then you get something like the midterms.
I think his loss was not completely,
but it had an effect in this election.
And he was talking about affordability before the left was,
about housing and debt and things like that, the young people.
So they thought that he was an existential threat.
But there were other losses, too.
Thank you.
I don't think—I like Buck Sexton a lot and their show,
but I don't think anybody has ever replaced Rush Limbaugh.
That was a terrible blow.
He was getting 20 to 30, 40 million a week,
people listening to him, religiously.
And he was a masterful entertainer.
...podcaster and radio host, so that hasn't.
Tucker, at certain times of the year,
election cycles, breaking news,
was getting five million people every night for five,
you know, not every night, but I mean every night
that there were those news spikes, and that is a
force multiplier.
You lost Rush, and you lost Charlie Kirk, but the loss of Tucker...
Who I think you could argue
was the most prominent MAGA conservative on television at one time.
This was a double whammy because he didn't just cease to exist,
like tragically Charlie, Kirk, and Rush.
And I don't mean, I'm glad that he didn't.
I'm glad that he's healthy and alive.
But what I'm saying is that...
He didn't just exit the scene or retire.
He became an antithetical force.
So he was telling people,
basically his message now is I have been brainwashed.
I got into it.
I went to Mar-a-Lago.
I was on Air Force One.
I hung out at the White House.
I had Trump's cell phone.
I was intimate.
I had power.
But I was completely wrong.
I was wrong on Israel.
I was wrong on...
Soleimani, Baghdadi, all that stuff that I didn't say anything about.
I was wrong on all of it.
And that was a loss as well.
And I could go on for five or six other podcasters
who have kind of said, you know, I'm surprised now, Jack.
I don't want to mention names because I want to unite people
because of the common threat.
But if you go on to X or some of these social media,
there's a civil war now.
And the people...
And it's not even breaking down Vance people versus Rubio people.
There are people who are saying that the fact you went
into Iran means you're a neocon and you're horrible.
I want to remind everybody, neocon means new conservative.
And it came in in the 1990s, 1990s and 1980s.
And it was identifiable.
With a number of former prominent leftists
or Democrats who joined other Republicans
in wanting a muscular foreign policy.
So I'll give you some examples.
There was something called the Project for a New American Century.
Remember that, Jack?
And they were formed to be more aggressive.
So they said, we didn't do well in the Gulf War
in the extent that Saddam Hussein is still there
and the no-fly zones of almost a decade are not working.
The French and British peeled off.
So we're going to make a new century.
They were kind of arrogant.
So there was Robert Kagan and Fareed Zakaria,
David Frum, Richard Perle,
a lot of the people in the think tanks.
And Bill Kristol was one of my most prominent.
I was going to say, don't forget little Bill.
Yeah, little Bill Kristol.
I don't mean that by his stature, but his intellectual stature.
Yes.
Somebody who said he was the intellect of the Republican Party,
and I can't think of one book he wrote by himself.
Can you?
He's never written a book.
No.
I've written as many books as he's written.
Yes, more.
So anyway, my point is,
That they then advocated to remake the new, to remake,
everybody loved them after the statue fell.
90% of the American people said this was great
that we got rid of Saddam Hussein.
Finally, he was hosting 9-11 terrorists.
He was the source of all the disruption.
And then Afghanistan had gone well.
We got rid of it in six weeks.
Karzai was supposed to be the new mandala.
Remember that?
And then it went downhill with insurrection.
So that was discredited.
But that was who those people were.
They wanted to put boots on the ground and nation build.
And they were, let me say this very carefully, because I was trashed
by many of them when I wrote a book in 2003 called Mexifornia,
calling for legal-only immigration and closing the border
because we were creating a massive tribal movement,
salad bowl, and rejecting the melting pot.
And who...
...said that I was basically a...
James Q. Wilson, one of the great neoconserv...
Oh, really?
Yes.
Yeah.
Yes.
And where did he write that?
In Commentary magazine.
Yeah.
And I was shocked by it
because I had been writing for Commentary and it wasn't even
a fair thing.
He basically said I was a nativist and...
So, what I'm getting at,
the neoconservative people were leftists who...
Foreign policies were anti-communist, that was their big thing,
but they had not really changed on their other issues.
They were not really against affirmative action.
Some were, some weren't. They were for open borders, they really were.
And, um, I was asked to write an article, uh,
for City Journal in 2002, and I called it
Mexifornia. That was the, the,
that was the basis for the book that followed. And some of the editors
questioned why I was saying this,
because they thought that the open borders, this was at
City Journal. And then Myron Magnin,
who was a wonderful person, called me and said,
you know, nobody had really questioned this idea that we need labor
and it's the melting
pot and give us your tired and poor,
but you're writing from firsthand experience. And I think
that this is really valuable.
So he was a supporter of something that there were members
of the editorial staff that were worried.
So what I'm getting at is when the J.D. Vance
people say there's a bunch of neocons,
the people who said, they said two things.
Donald Trump was never an isolationist.
You guys are probably isolationists, but you didn't say anything,
I can't remember, when he went in and killed Soleimani.
I don't remember that anybody said that he was a neocon,
Trump or the supporters, when he got rid of Baghdadi.
Had he bombed before for several weeks?
Yes.
He bombed Iraq and Syria to get rid of ISIS.
Did he confront Russia?
Yes.
He bombed and killed,
he allowed our forces to kill about 300 to 400 Wagner group people
who attacked them.
Did he go into Maduro?
Yes.
But they all had one thing in common.
They were Jacksonian.
They were quick.
And they were decisive and no one had a problem.
Even the isolationists
who might have objected didn't have much resonance.
So when he went in last year
and he bombed the nuclear facilities for 25 hours, there
was some anti, there was a lot of opposition,
but not a lot of opposition in the sense that
it hurt his polls.
He was very popular still.
Because it was just off.
The reason why people were against the war was,
and they keep saying, well, everybody was always against the war.
I looked at the Republican polls the other day.
They weren't against the idea of going into Iraq quickly as before
and getting out as one-offs, the Jacksonian.
The reason that people are fighting now is after 38 days,
it was pretty much decimated.
And we could have done a little bit better,
a lot better planning to keep Hormuz open.
But it's open now, and we can keep it open.
And we could have ignored Turkey and said,
don't tell us that we can't arm the Kurds.
This is an elemental threat.
We're going to do what we want and arm the Kurds
and other people if they wanted to be armed.
And then we could have.
Sanctioned a lot.
So could have, should have, would have, yes.
But the point was what really,
when you want to look at where the opposition grew, it started
in April and March, and it started to get really widespread.
And what was the complaint?
The complaint was, it'll take a couple more weeks.
These sanctions are so bad, it's crippling, they'll be broke.
We're going to have a modus of understanding.
A Memorandum of Understanding. We're almost close to a deal.
Witkoff came back. It's almost going to be done.
And that was what it was. And people said, either do it or get out.
And that was an understandable response.
But my point is that there wasn't a civil war when he did all
of these other things and intervened because they were Jacksonian.
Don't tread on me. No better friend, no worse enemy.
And they were all successful.
This one.
The verdict's out.
It is in the same spirit in the sense that when I hear,
as I have been, I've had people get, and I, as I said last time,
I think I'm going to kind of retire from these podcast
or TV discussions when you're interrupted and you can't finish,
such the passions are so high.
But when people say invoke Vietnam, 58,000 dead, 10 years to
Seven months where there's 23 dead
and $54 billion is less than the aggregate amount
of stuff we left in Afghanistan by Joe Biden,
if you count the infrastructure embassy and
everything, $180 billion probably over the whole occupation history.
But it's nothing like that.
And we haven't had any ground troops.
I will be the first person to say, do not,
I have, don't put ground troops in that hellhole.
Do not do it.
Do not put any ground troops.
Even though there's military utility, do not do it.
Do not try to nation-build.
Do not get some dictator or don't get the Shah's son and then coach him
and then parachute him in.
Don't do that.
Just, if you want to have a,
I think it would be good to have a democratic council in exile
and talk to them, but let them make it up.
It's their country.
All right.
So this idea that neocons have taken over the Trump movement,
and that is a euphemism, I think, from Jews.
It's for Jews, yeah, exactly.
These people who said that we should take out Iran
were the people that were Jacksonians.
They want a closed border.
They want deportations if it's done in a way
that's politically non-injurious to the MAGA movement.
And you and I talked about it, Jack,
when Kristi Noem was dressed up like she was and we had Corey around
and strutting and we're going to do this and this and this.
It was counterproductive.
It wasn't done in a way.
If you sum up what the American people wanted,
they wanted a closed border with zero...
Illegal immigration, and then they wanted to go to sleep at 11 at night
and wake up at 6 in the morning and say, we deported 5,000 people
who were criminals and another 3,000 who were here illegally.
That's what they wanted. They didn't want to see it.
Victor, we'll end the show with Becerra, but let's just talk about some
of the troubling things with the elections, and that's
the Democrats gaining complete control, trifectas, governorship.
House, Senate, in Pennsylvania, picking up Pennsylvania, Michigan,
Arizona, Wisconsin, Nevada, well, I don't know if I'm reading Axios,
but it says here, those victories could give Democrats enough political
power to push the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact past
the threshold needed to take effect.
And that compact is, well,
whoever president wins the national vote, our state
will cast its electors for the winning candidate,
not necessarily if the president won our state.
So troubling, Victor,
because the electoral college is important to our republic.
To discuss this, everybody, you've got to remember,
the Democratic Party, as it's now composed, its center,
this Islamist, does not believe in the Constitution.
Or I should say, they only believe in the Constitution
when it's useful for them.
So there are certain key issues that they want to be changed
because they feel now that it favors them.
But remember, they're guided by two points.
What is useful for us now?
And the Constitution is either good or bad
depending on whether it helps us now.
So let's take four of those issues.
Jack just mentioned the Electoral College.
They have no intrinsic anger philosophically
with the Electoral College, except in the
modern period, something that rarely ever happened in the 19th
and 18th century, George
W. Bush won without the popular vote.
Then Donald Trump won in 2016 without the popular vote.
That was two times, 2000 and 2016.
And at that point, they said the electoral college is bad.
But we have the amendments of the Constitution
are predicated on following a protocol.
That's in the Constitution, the Electoral College.
So, and why is it in there
because of a bunch of people that hated Democrats?
No, because they felt that the rural essence
of the United States was important and they
didn't want candidates campaigning to the extent they did,
but they didn't want populations
in Boston, New York, Philadelphia at that time having inordinate.
Control over the frontiersmen
and people farming in the Iowa and Tennessee Valley, etc.
That was one.
They were also afraid that you would have voter fraud
in a national election.
But if you disperse the voting into what would become 50 states at the
time, 13, then it would be harder for a cabal to control the vote.
I could go on, but you read the Federalist Papers.
A lot of these people like El-Sayed have never read them,
so he comes to this country, his parents do,
and then he starts lecturing us on the Electoral College.
So they don't want to go through the Constitution
because it requires a vote, two-thirds in the Congress,
and to have three-quarters of the states to amend it.
Okay.
They're not going to get that.
So then they dreamed up this idea that if you capture the assembly
and the state senate, state assembly, state senate,
and a blue state or a purple state, and they vote and say,
our law says we shall respect the national vote, not the state vote.
We're not even going to try to amend the Constitution.
So now that we have, I think, Jack,
we're up to 34 or 33 governors.
So now the left is giddy because they have enough votes
in state legislators to get over 270 electoral...
Two hundred and seventy.
Electoral votes to nullify it.
What I'm getting at is they're going
to say now that our states are going to vote.
Not to reflect what Indiana's vote or California is,
we're going to go to the national vote,
which we think will be always Democratic.
It wasn't in 2024.
And therefore, the states that retain
the Electoral College will not have enough vote
to do it.
That is unconstitutional.
And I think the Supreme Court will rule against it, except number two.
The Supreme Court is not mentioned
in the Constitution other than there shall be a
Supreme Court and a Chief Justice.
Okay, so from 1789 to 1869,
basically 100 years, more
or less when an administration
changed from a Whig to a Democratic Party, then they packed the court.
They added their people.
And people got sick of it.
So they had a reform movement after Lincoln's death and during Andrew.
So let's just codify it at nine justices.
So that's where it is.
And when it was the Warren court,
I grew up with a bunch of farmers that were conservative.
And every time I saw them, they said, oh,
my gosh, Earl Warren banned school prayer.
Earl, can you imagine this, Victor?
You pull over a guy, and he's speeding, and he's a criminal,
and you have to give him his Miranda rights.
Can you believe that? So they were angry at this left-wing court,
which was basically there from about 1960 to all the way
into the Nixon administration for 20 years. And finally, it became
Balance back and forth, and now it is more conservative.
So they want to pack it,
and they think they can pack it when they get a veto-proof Congress.
And they think, given history,
that when you get a Bill Clinton defeat, when you get a
red wave, I should frame it that way, in 1994,
or you get a red wave in 2010, it takes four
or five or six years, I should go by elections,
four or six years to reverse it.
So they feel that these margins are so big
that even if they lose seats in the House
and Senate, but win the presidency,
the next democratic socialist Islamist, and that's
who it will be in president in 2028, will have a democratic.
Congress. And the first thing they will do is pass
a legislation saying that we're going to add
10 or 15 new justices and they will all be left wing
and there will be nothing you can do about
it because when they get the presidency, they will end the filibuster.
Filibuster is the third
thing they want. It's not in the constitution.
It's by tradition and practice in the Senate
and goes back 200 years. Nobody wanted to end it because they thought
If you end it, it will boomerang on us.
Now, remember, some of you are going to say,
well, they have a majority now, Victor.
So in January, the senators will vote to get rid of the filibuster.
No, they won't, because they don't have the presidency.
Why would they end the filibuster
so that they could pass legislation over a minority
that banned the filibuster to ban the Republicans delaying it
when the president will veto it
anyway?
And they can't override the veto because they don't have 60 votes.
However, when they get the presidency,
which they think they are going to do in 2028,
They will go to their third element of this four package,
get rid of the Electoral College
by unconstitutional means, pack the court,
as I said, and end the filibuster when they
get the presidency.
Then they can ram it through and the Republicans can't stop it.
Fourth, let in two new states.
Washington, D.C. is 80% Democratic.
It's in the Constitution that it
is going to be a federal conglomeration.
It is not a state.
That's so that they didn't.
The founders were very clear.
They did not want a particular state controlling
the federal government.
They didn't want a governor telling the president of the United States,
hey, I am a Whig and you're a Democrat
and I'm going to make it bad for you.
The police won't do this or this.
We're going to.
So they made a federal.
That is in the Constitution.
They're going to try to override that by packing the court.
If they pack the court, they can do whatever they want
because these justices, as we have seen with immigration law,
they will just vote what the left tells them to do.
And then if they bring Puerto Rico in, they will have four senators.
And in their thinking,
they're going to have a veto-proof Senate forever.
And they're going to have a Supreme Court
for the next 50 years that's left wing.
And everybody should get that in mind.
And because now the right is blaming this and that and you and he.
But you all have more in common than you do with these people.
And they are staging a counter-counter revolution.