The Mansion by William Faulkner - (The Snopes Trilogy) Book Summary, Analysis, Review

William Faulkner
2 followers
The jury said guilty, and the judge said life, but he didn't hear them.
And we are back with Mink and the Gang for The Mansion by William Faulkner today.
Didn't it feel like this book should have been all Mink and just be like, phlegm who?
He began working on this December 13th, 1956, maybe.
There's kind of like a kludgy part when it comes to his journal entries.
But he says, I am now working on the third volume, which will finish it.
All right.
So so he knew this was going to be the final of his Snopes trilogy.
And when I think we talk about the Snopes trilogy, it's kind of it's usually when you
think about a trilogy, it's just like part one, part two, part three, right?
Like you have a new hope, you've got Empire Strikes Back where nobody wins, and then you've
got the Jedi where you have, you know, like the purging and the catharsis, right?
Yeah, the good guy wins.
Faulkner is never the same.
He loves to revisit tales.
And there's all these discrepancies about, well, how how old was the character being
off by even a whole decade between books to very minor things about how long, you know,
phlegm owned a hat, stuff like who really cares, guys.
But Faulkner knew when he published this, that he was deliberately messing up his stories
from the from the past, the other two of the Snopes trilogy.
And when asked to fix it, he just said, I like to think of the world I created as being
a kind of keystone in the universe.
My last book will be the doomsday book, the golden book of Yachna Patafa County, but then
refused to go back to fix his his his book.
He just said, go back and fix the old books like this is going to be it.
This is going to be my cornerstone of my career.
I love how it perspective doesn't matter in all the books that we've read.
Perspective is like, well, this is the way I see it.
And that's the way the book's going to be told at this point of view.
So when you have, you know, Mink, you get Mink's point of view and literally his interpretation.
And when you get phlegm, you get phlegms.
And if they lie and the books, quote, are wrong, then that's OK, because it's imitating
real life.
And I love how Faulkner did that.
And he wasn't going to apologize for writing realism.
And I think that's what make these books so amazing.
And you can get so engrossed in them because they they feel real.
It's like they are the soap operas of soap operas before soap operas were a thing.
Well, you don't level with me here because because a lot of people in critics to love
the Hamlet, like people love the Hamlet, the town and then the mansion.
OK, decent follow up.
But I think the what a lot of people would call repetition hurts their experience.
But let's let's admit this.
When we look at like if you were Faulkner going through this experience and you have
this story, but you weren't 100 percent sure you're trying to work it out.
Right.
And isn't that true of any author?
They're trying to work out their story as they're writing this book.
And Hamlet turns out great.
It's hilarious, but it's small people.
It's small problems, small debts, and even a small story just being confided to this
Frenchman's band.
Sure.
And then we go to the town, right, which picks up where it ended.
Right.
But in usual Faulkner fashion, we're going into a bigger town and we have lots of backstory,
but we we get the rise to power with phlegm.
Right.
And then cut cut at at the mansion scene at the end, which is a beautiful ending and good
ending to a movie.
I think almost the Empire Strikes Back.
But what's weird is it encapsulates a lot of the Hamlet, too.
A lot of the Hamlet is brought in and recontextualized.
Now when we look at the mansion, it's not like a third part.
It literally is taking all of the Hamlet and all of the town and again, recontextualizing
it, putting it at a different point of view, which I think is exhausting for some people.
It's very clear that Faulkner saw a different truth and re-examined why people are the way
that they are.
And I think that's what the mansion does is it's an attempt at Faulkner to explain why
these people are the way that they are because he didn't get it right in the first two novels.
That makes sense.
I can accept that.
I guess it just it doesn't make me enjoy this book anymore.
I liked it.
And thinking about that gives it better meaning of what he was trying to attempt.
But for me, I felt like if Flemeth died in the town, and instead of this one, I felt
like more of the story could have been about his alleged daughter.
The story could have been more about Mink.
And we could have had not closure, because we don't get that with the Snopes family,
but that Flem's legacy could have lived on and more stories could have been told.
I guess I was just I wanted more.
I enjoy these characters.
I enjoy this universe, the Snopes universe.
I wanted more shenanigans.
And I thought that the mansion was going to give me more Hamlet.
And I think that maybe if Flemeth died early in the book, or again, in the previous book,
we could have gotten that.
And so I felt like it was I think you used the word stale.
It just felt a little stale.
Mm hmm.
And I don't disagree with anything that you've said.
I had similar feelings, but I'm trying to not justify why you should like it.
Right?
Because because how you're going to feel is how you're going to feel.
It's the idea of, you know, Faulkner put this story aside for what 17 years, you know, wrote
the first one in 1940.
Next one, what, 57?
This one in 59.
So so 20 year, almost 20 years.
Yeah.
And and here's the thing is, he starts looking at these characters from different points
of view.
And you can't really do that with with with being in a box in a character, because because
when the author is exploring a character's mind, he's living in their head, right?
He's becoming them almost.
And Faulkner needed to understand this whole town.
He needed to create the peoples of Yakima-Petawa County to better understand that when he's
writing this new American capitalism coming in about looking out for oneself, doing what
it takes to get ahead, because you can rise in social class now.
What did that do to all the other people?
What did that do to all the other farmers and the people who were run over in the path?
I think it took Faulkner a long time to understand that himself.
Do you think he ever truly did?
Because I feel like he's walking down the streets and in his mind, and he's seeing the
different Snopes characters and he's seeing the water tower, he's seeing the mansion
and he's he's seeing the stores and the streets and the, you know, the the cars that are coming
in or he's imagining, well, what happens when I bring a car into this one trick pony town?
Do you think he really had it that far mapped out?
Or that was kind of maybe like you said, the excuse before is, I'm just kind of winging
this and I'm going to make mistakes.
But these characters are living beings in my head.
And so I'm going to do the best that I can with what I know of them up to this point,
because I don't think he had them fully fleshed out.
He only knows up them up to this certain point.
No, no, he absolutely didn't.
He's you know, there's those there's those scientists that spend all their time.
It depends on the type, too.
But they spend all their time on the formulas, on the theoretical, working it out in their
mind because maybe maybe it demands it.
Maybe maybe you need to have that for whatever you're testing.
And then there's those scientists that are like, like, OK, well, I can add this and it's
such a chaotic system, I can only change one thing at a time, which is good science, too.
Don't get me wrong.
But but the idea of those that are more into trying than theorizing everything, Faulkner,
I think, is a trier.
He needs to introduce this one character to bounce it off the town, to bounce it off his
morality system and to question things rather than work out this thousand character epic
piece in advance before writing the first word like like he's testing it as he goes,
I feel like.
That makes sense.
I could see that of going from the Hamlet lays the groundwork, then you get into the
town and you have a few new characters and things open up and broaden.
And then I feel like he saw the success of the Hamlet and said, I think I'm going to
rein it back in a little bit and start addressing a few issues that I saw and worked out.
So I guess that makes sense.
I can see that.
I like that.
So let's talk about make.
Right.
He's probably the most energy that you get in this in terms of the narrative energy.
He brings the most to the table, I think, in the story and in the previous books.
He's to me rather 2D, right?
He's just there.
He's plot.
He's interesting.
He's interesting, but I don't see through him.
And it's in this story that we really get an idea for me in terms of the real struggle
of of planting the fences and working off the cow and how it wasn't it wasn't about
the money.
It was it was all about fairness, how he was born poor and some people are born rich and
that ain't fair.
And here comes Houston, who's a little bit more well to do and taking advantage of him
just to rub his nose in it with that pound fee.
It ain't the fee.
It's the fact that he had so much more to give the the noblesse oblige, like he should
be giving more because he has more and he doesn't.
That's not fair.
And they talk about how it's fairness that really just drives mink into the psychotic
rage, which, you know, hey, let's do a slow clap for a man that has a 35 year grudge,
but doesn't even have an idea of how Flem could have actually helped him.
I love mink story of I feel like Faulkner is creating the idea of the American dream
before maybe it was actually realized of the, quote, 1950s American dream of the, you know,
post World War Two soldiers coming back and getting what they thought was going to be,
you know, the American life, I feel like is embodied in mink that he's going to pull himself
up by the bootstraps, which we know is literally impossible, but he's going to do it because
he's going to combat the fairness.
Right.
And mink is somebody that I think is is that American identity of driving forward no matter
what the cost.
Do you think by making him more visible that if he just drove ahead at Ford with no characterization
really kind of like Flem in a sense, like Flem's very background ish, particularly through
some of these like the town and even like to an extent like the Hamlet, the way he stood
behind the fence and watched the auction, even though you knew he was pulling the strings
behind it, you you paint him as a villain, but maybe a hero sometimes, but you don't
there's there's a lack of characterization there.
And if that was just mink, like in the earlier books, you kind of don't like the character
that much by by telling his story.
You know, there's that famous quote that you can't hate a person close up.
Do we?
Is that the trick?
Are we empathizing with someone who's a murderer?
His lawyer calls him a snake, like his family's almost invisible to him like they don't even
exist.
He's obsessed with with this idea of killing his own family member.
Do we sympathize with the devil?
Do we sympathize with like that Machiavellian that'll do anything to get his way because
you can't hate someone close up?
You hit the nail on the head.
The idea that somebody is up in your face, it's really hard to be combative when you're
talking to somebody over the phone.
It's really or keyboard warrior.
It's really easy to be tough, right?
But now that mink is up in our grill and you see where he's coming from, it starts to give
you a little bit of sympathy and empathy.
But I think you mentioned it.
I think he's more like almost an antihero, right?
You know he's a bad person, but you want him to kind of succeed because he's been wronged.
So you and all of our friends out there that do the Faulkner in August experience with
us.
Thank you and apologies for being late to this.
But for all of us that read the book Sanctuary by William Faulkner last year, we saw Miss
Reba, right?
We also saw Clarence Snopes.
We see a much more empathetic look now at mink, right?
Like we're giving him a 3D.
We're giving him a reason because can you really really be a villain if you're a product
of someone doing wrong to you or you're on, you know, being treated unjustly and Miss
Reba almost gets a little bit more of a friendly look now as opposed to in Sanctuary.
But Clarence Snopes still is the unscrupulous man, the man that I mean, like he was literally
in the KKK, right?
Like this is a guy that that Faulkner decides not to have the sheets pulled back on.
Why pull the sheets back on mink and Reba, but not on Snopes, the Clarence Snopes?
I think it's a generational thing.
I think that Faulkner is looking at the South and we've talked about how he's painting the
picture of the South persona, so to speak.
And I think that he's trying to put forward the best foot forward of what it means to
be a Southerner, even this far after the idea of Southern hospitality and the South is kind
of gone because it's being integrated into more of a whole of our country in this one
little piece that's maybe still trying to hold on to the old ways of life.
They can't anymore.
And they represent this, Reba and mink represent this, where Clarence represents the old way
of life and that's just not going to be able to stick around anymore.
So there's no reason to draw more light on the misgivings of the South.
We're going to move forward with the youth of the South.
And I think that's a really good way to look at it, like at a broad level.
If we zoom in even more, when we look at these characters and this new way of life,
we're talking about how you pull yourself up by the bootstraps, we're talking about
this new American capitalism, and I call it new American capitalism because capitalism
is a very broad term and obviously it can mean different things in different countries.
Obviously like Japan, much more cliche, or not cliche, clicky with how and when they
choose to do business with whom.
In America, it's very whatever gives you the best profit, the most gain, broad stroke
comment, right?
But particularly in the early 1900s.
How do we view Phlegm in this picture?
Because he's the one that does it without morality.
Whatever is the best, he will sell out his own family members as opposed to some of those
Southerners like Armistead, like Miss Reba, Mink, even to an extent, like that do have
likes.
Maybe let's take Mink out of that picture.
Pretend I didn't say Mink.
Yeah, I don't know if Mink works.
But these other characters have some compassion, they have some feelings for it.
Do you think there's something to be said there about how maybe Faulkner was leery of
where America was going with its greed, with its unfettered approach to get ahead even?
Maybe that's why he put Phlegm in the background of almost all the stories.
I mean, he is a main character, but he's the guy behind everything.
And that's, quote, corporate America.
He's without maybe morals or he has scrupulous morals.
He is all about a buck.
He is about moving things forward regardless of who it hurts.
He doesn't really care about people, I don't feel like.
Or he does only when it suits him best.
And that's kind of what we think about when we look at the negative aspect of corporate
America.
You think of a corporation or a CEO, whatever one pops in your head.
I think that's kind of what Faulkner was going here with Phlegm 70, 80 years ago.
Well, I wonder, you said something there about the background.
And we have motivations sometimes that are driving us.
And let's be honest, sometimes we do things just to look good.
And we see more than ever that Phlegm is doing some things just for appearance or just for
trying to almost like come off a different way.
If we look at it from like a car perspective, if you remember, remember like the Prius when
it first came out, sold like hotcakes, right?
Everybody wanted the Prius because it looked futuristic, like it was the hybrid.
It made you appear as if you're doing really good and such.
And then Camry started to do it.
And all they did was take the old Camry and just slapped a little hybrid symbol on it.
And at the time it didn't sell, right?
Because it didn't have the appearance of what it was coming off to be.
When Phlegm's coming at the story, you know, some critics have called out that maybe Phlegm
was just done.
He knew that he had done wrong.
And he's just putting on this appearance of trying to appear like a more decent guy or
like he was trying to help Mink, even though deep down inside, he was just trying to get
his own way.
He was just trying to survive, in a sense.
And even this ridiculous idea of dressing him up, what did they call him, Mother Hubbard
in a sun bonnet, like later on in the story, like that was pretty funny.
It was it was meant to look ridiculous, but it's all about dressing up your motives in
a sense.
Phlegm is the middle-aged man that finally gets Facebook and had always wanted recognition
for all the times he volunteered or gave money or helped at a homeless shelter.
And he's the one taking selfies of, look at all the good deeds that I've done.
And he's the one that's posting everything out there to see how glamorous and great and
wonderful his life is.
But when he goes home, he's sitting by himself with a drink, stewing and fretting and so
miserable.
He is the everything's great on the outside, but everything's terrible on the inside guy.
Yeah.
I mean, he got the mansion, he got the wealth, he got the bank job at the end of the town.
Then what?
Right.
His his wife committed suicide.
His daughter hates him.
Like to your point, like he did all of this to gain that public success only to have private
failure.
I mean, that brings back to your point, though, actually, of when I think about it, I know
we're kind of going in loops here, but he had all of that, the corporate success.
And he's the most unhappy, miserable and probably dies the least successful out of everybody.
Maybe you were right that this is a cautionary tale that Faulkner is giving us, that he was
worried about what it meant to have that American dream.
So the next section, right after this, we have the Linda section, Linda, Linda, Linda.
It's such a strange section to me because it's like, it's like almost like Eula, Jr.
She's got a different back story, right, in terms of this, you know, this engagement and
it gives an excuse to go to New York and it's kind of fun.
She goes off to the war, loses her hearing and that that that shell blast when she's
an ambulance dryer, her husband dies in war, again, a lot of wars in all these books.
I wonder why he chose all these generational war stories, but she comes back and again,
just like Eula with this, this fawning or tempting of Gavin, tempting the man, the prosecutor,
if you will, and in him returning nothing but paternalistic love, in a sense, like it's
not desire or passion in the truest sense, it's, it's almost like this desire to protect
someone.
And that almost like rings true with me on like the level of just like, like, like when
we think about things being passed down, like in, in how America used to work, can you really
pass down these things?
Like, does Linda feel the need to carry on her mother's legacy or, or how would you interpret
Eula jr here?
I want to go back a few things there he hit me with a lot.
So first, I think with the war, I think that Faulkner is saying there's no way that something
like these horrific wars could not have influenced these people in some shape or form, whether
they were actually out there on the front lines, or whether they were at home, you know,
building bombs, bullets and blankets.
It had to influence them somehow, physically, psychologically, whatever.
The other thing, I think, with, you know, Miss jr here is, I think that Faulkner, he,
he struggles, I think, to write women.
And we saw that, you know, with her mom.
So I don't know if she is a carbon copy.
Because it felt like he was doing a lot of the same thing.
So he said, Hey, it worked in my first book, why don't I just do it again?
Because she does feel like she's making the exact same mistakes.
Or maybe he's saying, we don't learn sometimes from the mistakes of our parents.
And we continue to make the same mistakes.
I think this is heading towards kind of like my theory of this novel.
We're not there yet.
But give me give me one more second before we get there.
Okay, I'm going to loop back a couple things that we just talked about.
Here's a quote from Bratliff.
He's speculating.
He says, if I was an 18 year old gal, which would I rather have my mother publicly notarized
as a suicide, or publicly condemned as a whore.
So that idea of protecting, we've talked before about the protection of the southern bell.
And is that really the situation?
I don't know.
But but here's a word that that we just talked about with phlegm, that that appearance to
the public versus the private failure.
And you'll notice in this quote, my mother publicly notarized as a suicide, or publicly
condemned as a whore.
Notice the usage of the word public twice, right?
And Faulkner doesn't duplicate himself, unless he's trying to make a point most of the time,
right?
Yeah.
What does it say that these characters care more about their external definition than
their than their actual internal representation?
Oh, yeah, yeah.
That's deep.
I also look at it as, you know, suicide is probably something very personal, right?
It's a it's a choice that person's making, because of something wrong, they feel wrong
with themselves, some inadequacy, where being labeled or condemned a whore is something
public is doing to you.
So one's internal and one's external.
But they're, they're framing it here, Faulkner's framing it here, as both of these are something
that the public will look down upon.
They're, they're reacting to each other.
Yeah.
And there's, there's, this is my theory of this novel.
There's this one quote, it's minor, but it's what resonated with me.
So you're stuck with me explaining it.
All right, hit me.
It says, this is when they're when Gavin's talking about fighting the Germans and such,
we're talking about ideas.
He says, they are all still glorious, still splendid.
It's the word mystical that's wrong.
The music and the ideas both come out of obscurity, darkness, not out of shadow, out of obscurity,
obfuscation, darkness.
Man must have light.
He must live in the fierce, full, constant glare of light, where all shadow will be defined
and sharp and unique and personal, the shadow of his own singular rectitude or baseness.
All human evils have to come out of obscurity and darkness, where there is nothing to dog
man constantly with the shape of his own deformity.
So to me, the way that we're, you know, when they talk about being drawn towards the light
and these things coming out of the shadows, it's the way characters define themselves
against others.
They're the same way that Faulkner couldn't write the Snopes until he defined how they
reacted and impacted the other members of Yaknupatapha County, of Jefferson City.
He needed to see how when we impact each other, how that changes society, how that changes
how we feel and how important it is to how we treat each other.
It's an entire justification of the amoral problem that Phlegm brings to the table, not
because of the gains and material pluses that he gets.
It's the physical, emotional harm he causes upon others, the emotional turmoil of reacting
to others and chasing the light without the fear of how much it can hurt other people.
Do you think that because Faulkner took so long to write this, that as to your point,
that these characters are affecting him?
I think someone in fact, someone impacted Faulkner in his personal life.
Okay.
We've talked before about the leak diaries.
Those are when, I think it was the Stone's House when he'd go over there, he'd read them
and it would talk about how people mistreated slaves.
People talk about how this book is allegedly less political, allegedly less race conscious.
It's got its moments.
You can't escape that with a Faulkner piece, but it's how angry he got at that when he
saw how people were mistreated.
Not that he escaped it fully, even himself, like humanity, there's an element of wanting
to cause harm.
There's an element of wanting to create value too, that I think it infuriated him.
He writes that into these characters, how characters have this desire to be loved, but
also to destroy at the same time.
You have, when you even look at the presidents of this bank, we've talked about this multi-generalization
of Eula Eula Jr.
Is that the only example of that?
No.
Right?
You had Sartorius was the original bank president, made a black man drive him to the bank every
day.
And then Despain did the exact same thing, made a black man drive him.
And then Phlegm does the exact same thing.
It's the way that these people see what other people do and either react or don't react
and continue to pass down these things, whether it be Eula to Linda or these bank owners to
other bank owners, whether it be also the hotel owners, how the hotel started with an
H, was it the Hudson's, I forget they're now Holston's, the way that they pass down their
traditions to how they run this hotel.
So when Snopes comes along, Snopesism even, and takes away tradition, it takes away the
human element.
That's when that hotel is destroyed almost.
Do you think that Snopes is really taking away human tradition or he's just redefining
it as Faulkner is looking around America today and the South and seeing everything redefined
as technology is coming in and changing jobs and capitalism is changing and the technology
has changed how people are communicating and we've talked about him introducing cars and
how that just revolutionized transportation.
Do you think that's maybe a little bit more of it?
I think, particularly in some of his other books, like when we did the reverse, I remember
how he had that idea of modernity killing nature, almost being opposed to it, how it
encroaches and pushes things back and how when you do return to nature, there's a good
element to it.
Faulkner clearly fell into that trope, if you will.
You talked even also about communication there.
There's something to be said about how he chose for Linda to not be able to communicate
on some levels, right?
She can't hear anymore.
So she can't hear, but she can read.
She can talk, but she can't hear back.
It's this interesting relationship between her and Gavin as a result that their communication
has changed even, where he can write to her and she can talk to him, but that's the circle
that the two go about communicating.
I think Faulkner has a very complicated view of humanity.
We do talk a lot about the broader strokes of things, but it's also there's a very
microscopic view we need to take of these things too, I think.
I never really thought about that one with Linda.
I thought it more of she can't hear and maybe now is the time that finally Phlegm wants
to step up and be a dad, because he doesn't know if it's his daughter or not, so he's
kind of been absent her whole life, and now that he wants to maybe kind of be present,
she can't hear him.
I thought it was that, but I like that.
I think it can go either relationship or maybe both relationships.
I think we started talking a little about the political thing there.
There's clearly a political angle with Linda too, the way that she's pushing for black
education, the way that she's a communist.
That's very topical at the time too, I guess, in a sense.
It's hard for me not to see that she is believing in something and pushing her views out into
the world, and it's the way, when we talk about these lights and the shadows, society
reacts to her.
They shun her.
They're trying to shut down her ideas.
They're shutting down her discourse.
They're shutting down her way of communicating with the world, and her way of communicating
with the world, obviously, is very different without the ability to hear anymore, that
it's changed from the first 20 years of her life to how she has to communicate, so when
she does try to push for better, what she thinks is better, you have the world pushing
back on her.
I can't help but imagine that has to destroy her too, just on an emotional level.
Wasn't that kind of the way that, I mean, Faulkner would have seen our history, is we
always seem to take two steps forward, one step back.
After the Civil War, things were going really well, and we seem to be pushing forward progressively,
and then we fall back in the late 1800s, and then in the early 1900s, we start moving forward
really fast, and women get the right to vote, and we have the roaring 20s, and things are
going really good.
Then through the 30s, we take huge steps back, and then in the 40s, we have the war, and
it happens over and again.
60s, we take huge steps forward, 70s back, 80, big steps forward, 90s back, big steps
in the early 2000s, and now we're taking steps back.
This is a cycle that our country has gone through for hundreds of years, and I think
that Faulkner just does a good job of nailing it in this one character, and epitomizing
it of how women seem to be affected by this over, and over, and over again, to almost
a sad comical level.
You know what's interesting is you bring up these generational problems, and so often
we think of problems of the person or problems of the heart, but there are problems that
just are bigger, they exist.
Slavery and racism is a bigger problem than one person's decision.
It's this movement of problems, and kind of like if you take a really out there example
of just like original sin, with the idea that you didn't cause, like that sin wasn't
yours, it was humanity's sin, but it's passed down.
All of a sudden you're born with this sin that you didn't even do per se, you inherited.
Here's all these problems that can exist in our society, the racism, the problems with
how we care for one another and such, that are passed down to us, that aren't even caused
by us, but become problems.
There are problems.
Right.
Well, because remember, there's that character that was like Tud Nightingale or something
like that, where he was like ready to like go to fists, because he wanted to defend that
the earth was flat, and that his father, or no, that I generally wasn't a coward.
And his father died because of like inflexibility or something like that, it was the idea that
he couldn't change.
Yeah, well, I think that kind of comes back to like our main character, our antihero,
I guess we're going to call him is phlegm of he's the one that can't seem to change,
even though he's making the most changes in the town and the hamlet with the mansion.
And it just this guy, it cracks me up.
And I guess I wanted more or less of him or less or more of him.
I don't know.
Yeah.
You'd think this last section, like the phlegm section would be all about him, but it's kind
of a very mink story still to where, if you ever read Don Quixote, like in high school,
30 years ago, yeah, like, like Faulkner was a huge fan of Don Quixote, restoring chivalry.
And we almost have two characters that I question, could these be the Don Quixote days of the
story?
Because mink goes on this very, like, crazy adventure with with JC Goody Hey, again, JC
Jesus Christ.
There's that original sin and, you know, religious references, but he was picking cotton.
He's buying a gun.
He's traveling like he's all over the place on these adventures to restore fairness, because
because phlegm didn't save him.
So that's not fair.
And that's his his journey is to say that code of fairness, as opposed to Gavin, who
is protecting Eula, and then thusly protecting Linda, and he goes on all these adventures
getting a sidekick and even like with Ratliff, that they'll do whatever it takes to protect
the chivalristic code of how women need to be protected, that there's almost kind of
like these little mini Don Quixote stories, where characters will die on their hills to
restore the honor and code by which they live.
When it comes to mink and Gavin, I kind of thought of mink as he's the redemption story,
where he starts low and you kind of root you want to root for him to like turn things around.
You don't necessarily hate him.
I mean, he's not a good person necessarily, but he's redeemable, right?
He's redeemable.
And Gavin is starts off, I feel like the goody little to shoe, and he's the the knight in
shining armor, but he never lives up to his expectations.
And I feel like that kind of parallels Don Quixote a little bit.
Do you think when we get to this end here, where finally, you know, for whatever reason,
the bodyguard leaves just so happens to leave that night, we get our entry, we got our entry
with finally getting, do we call this catharsis?
Do we call this justice?
What do we call mink finally killing phlegm for not saving him without without even being
able to articulate why he should or ought to have saved him or how he could have even
saved him?
I should say, after all these years, do we feel relief now that we finally seen mink
be a 3d character and you feel like he needs to be righted?
And phlegm stays in the background with this amoralistic code?
Do we feel good at phlegm being murdered?
I didn't.
I mean, I'm not for one for murder.
I'm a lover, not a fighter.
But I feel like what is it like the after so long, the crime just they won't charge
you for it anymore.
I feel like it's been long enough.
And I felt like if if there I feel like there's a lack of communication here.
And then maybe that's what Faulkner was was trying to point out.
If mink had just talked to phlegm, and seen how miserable he was, mink and Riley would
have been happy to be like, you know what, you got your upcomings, old man, I'm actually
happy you're miserable and your life is terrible.
Because letting him live in his misery probably would have been the best punishment for phlegm.
And showing that mink is living a better life and took the high road.
But I think because Faulkner knew people, mink was never going to make that choice.
That that was not in him.
And that's not in a lot of us to forgive.
That just that's part of the original sin in human nature is we are very, very slow
to forgive as people sometimes.
I think Ratliff said it best because he speculated that, that phlegm was ready.
Phlegm thought he was ready to die and that he deserved it.
And that's why he didn't resist mink as much as he could.
Even though you have this like, really tense final scene, like you said, I think this book
could have just been mink and I probably would have enjoyed it better if it was just mink.
And yes, agreed.
It culminates in this final scene and it just it feels very tense because it's almost like
that modern horror where when we cut to the Ratliff and Gavin scenes, we don't know where
mink is.
He's out there.
Evil is coming.
Right?
Danger is coming.
But I also sympathize with that danger.
I want that danger to happen because it resolves this problem or does it?
Because at the funeral, what do we see?
We see more Snopes just pop right up.
You take out one Snopes, boop, boop, boop, boop, out of the woodworks they come.
It's hilarious.
Well, isn't that the way of kind of life?
I think that Faulkner was trying to say that no matter how much you try to eradicate something,
something else is going to replace it.
Whether this be the technology, the communication, capitalism, corporate greed, racism, bigotry,
sexism, whatever it is, something else is going to come in and replace it.
And you're going to fight against that.
So our fight is never done.
Just like him trying to fix these stories is never done.
Right.
Well, and another thing that kind of plagued this story for me is just the short story
putting the by the people, which is the Clarence Snopes section, the hog pawn or something
like that, like it, which is the, the Rez Snopes with metal fill.
Like these are short stories that are injected that I just don't know.
They felt like side quests to me.
They didn't, they didn't fully bring in what I, what I wanted in a, in a Snopes finale.
I guess I tolerated it in Hamlet because they were entertaining and there was value in them
here.
It was, it just became more and more difficult to bring those into the story and not feel
like I'm getting a major cutaway in the middle of an action scene, I guess, in a sense, like
I needed to just stick with mink, I needed to stick with phlegm, I needed to stick with
those themes.
And they, they just took me too far away and even having like a little like, Hey, I wrote
that story called the sound and the fury.
And by the way, I kind of wanted to add a few things at the end.
It just felt like thrown into me a little bit there.
Yeah.
I was a little confused about all of these offshoots as well, because I know that to,
to use your terminology, when we have a side quest, I want it to not necessarily impact
the overall larger story, but it needs to have some meaning for one of the characters.
So if, you know, in our analogy here of, you know, side question, video games or whatever,
the side quest gives you something to propel the story forward, or it gives your main character
some motivation, and it didn't seem to do that.
And this is where my major gripe with the story besides I wanted more mink and because
I liked how his character was growing, and I felt like the phlegm part was tacked on.
But my main issue was, yeah, the side quests, it felt like Faulkner really was struggling
with this book, and was just padding his his words, you know, his word count.
And that was a little bit of frustrating, especially after coming off the lull that
I felt was the town, I thought, all right, I'm going to get my Empire Strikes Back here
in the third book, finally, and I just didn't get that.
And I think the overall trilogy is fantastic.
But I think that is only because of the really strong start with the Hamlet and the peaks
and valleys that I had throughout reading the mansion, but it's more Faulkner.
So of course, I'm going to enjoy it either way.
Was Faulkner right about some of these things about how, how we should be wary of unfettered
greed, or how we can cause harm to each other?
Is there?
Is there a truth to how these people react to how these people fear and create danger
and harm, and not focusing so much on the beauty and love that we can give to each other
like like is, is there a true element of truth to these stories?
Oh, of course.
I think if you just look around you, of our corporate greed, if you look at materialistic
greed, how, you know, everything is just about what I can buy, how fast I can get it, I want
it now, everything has to be instant.
I think he was trying to say, you need to slow down a little bit and appreciate those
finer things in life, and the people you have in life are going to mean a lot more to you.
As we look at Phlegm, and he didn't appreciate the people in his life, he was always trying
to get over everybody, even, even his, you know, daughter who may not have been his daughter,
like he wanted to do the right thing, but he ended up even doing that.
And I think that this very much is a cautionary tale for all of us, not just, you know, that
the South or that ideal of the South, but Faulkner was trying to, trying to, to broaden
our horizons of being better people.
Well, I will say this, it was, it was not my first round with this story, it was definitely
a second round, and it obviously took us a lot longer.
This was supposed to be a three month journey, it took us five, not because the stories were
bad or anything like that, it was more just about personal things that came in.
But I will say this, anytime I read a Faulkner, I still try to take these lessons from it
and apply, like, what do I need to do differently?
Because that's what I think literature is supposed to do, it's supposed to make us ask
those questions, besides just being expiring or escapism, it should be asking us questions
about, am I living my life the best way that I should?
And if there's one lesson I can take away, I think you nailed it on the head there about,
you know, I do need to do a better job of just caring about the people and recognizing
that my search for light should never create a shadow on someone else's experience to kind
of quote, like, you know, like that, that my thesis for this book, when I read that
one quote, there's just something about how we're so interconnected, that we just always
need to be mindful of that.
And I think that's probably the most important part for me when I read these stories is,
is characters that drove into themselves ended up being the most lonely.
One last thing, because I love how you worded that.
But it got me thinking about this idea that caring for the people that are in your lives,
because sometimes we want everybody in the external, we kind of talked about that in
our discussion here, is we always worry about all what everybody thinks, instead of just
those few people that are closest to us.
And what happens when we don't look at those few people that are closest to us, all the
snopes just keep popping up, all the randoms.
So it doesn't even matter.
Care about those, take care of those that are closest to you, and don't worry about
the rest.
See, Faulkner even knew it back then.
This is a lesson that people really need to get on board with, I feel like nowadays,
especially with modern social media.
If that realization didn't earn a like and subscribe from you out there, I don't know
what was.
But that was beautiful.
That was beautiful.
Playlist down below of other Snopes talks of ours, obviously, playlist 40 plus long
of other Faulkner videos and talks that we've had.
What book would you love to see us cover next?
And thank you again for the patience for any of you that have stuck around this long, as
well as our friends that read this as the Faulkner in August with Brian and Roz and
Greg and Alan and all of our friends out there.
It's been a journey, and I apologize that it's taken us so long to catch up.
We couldn't join in at the same time.
But you know, I think that's part of the reality of just being a human being and seeing each
other and being patient with everybody.
So appreciate everybody out there.
My name's Minuna.
Peace.
Be kind to each other.
