Less than one month out now from the oral arguments in the assault weapon ban cases and Cook County is up to some dirty tricks. Washington Gun Law President, William Kirk, discusses the motion to moot the Viramontes case altogether and have this case removed from the Supreme Court's docket. There reason is as ridiculous as one might think it will be but is there a chance that this works? That's what we discuss today so that you can be armed with education.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
William Kirk of Washington Gun Law discusses Cook County's attempt to dismiss the assault weapon ban cases (*Kaya v. Cook County* and *Grant v. Higgins*) before the Supreme Court. The county argues that the remaining petitioners lack standing because their desired firearms are not AR-15s or are not primarily for self-defense, a move Kirk views as a desperate and unlikely-to-succeed legal tactic.
Hello again, everyone. Welcome to Washington Gun Law TV.
I'm Washington Gun Law President
William Kirk. Thanks for joining us.
It has been a fascinating week, to say the least.
We are over here getting some sanity,
breathing in the freedom back here at our studios in
beautiful Post Falls, Idaho at North Idaho Arms America.
We're going to talk about the
pending assault weapon ban case coming up before
the United States Supreme Court on December 2nd.
And it appears that the folks over at Cook County
are getting really, really desperate.
They'd like to see this case go away. I think I know why.
But today, let's get you all educated about
the most recent filing as we talk about
the last-ditch effort to end the assault weapon ban case.
Okay, America, we are talking about the pending oral arguments in both
Viramontes v. Cook County as well
as Grant v. Higgins currently set for December 2nd.
Now, we already did this video right here where we said,
hey, listen, actually Viramontes is going
to have to have his name changed on the case
because it is now going to be called Kaya v. Cook County.
Why is that? Because Mr. Viramontes
has voluntarily withdrawn from the petition.
The folks over at Cook County, however, think that, well,
that probably means that this entire case should just be thrown out,
that the case is now moot,
and there's no reason for the Supreme Court to hear it.
Is that likely to work? No.
And even if you could moot the Cook County case, let us remember that
there is still Grant v. Higgins out there consolidated with this case.
Now, with Mr. Viramontes removing himself
as one of the named petitioners,
Mr. Kaya goes to pole position.
And apparently, Cook County has a problem
with Mr. Kaya's selection of firearms
and questions whether or not he should even be party to this suit.
Prior to his motion for dismissal from the case,
Roberto Viramontes had standing to press this appeal.
In district court, Viramontes maintained that he
was a Cook County resident who sought to own a Smith & Wesson military
and police AR-15-style semi-automatic rifle.
Okay, that's true. But what's the problem with Mr. Kaya? Well...
Unlike Viramontes, petitioner Christopher Kaya,
the other individual petitioner, does not appear to have standing
to litigate the question presented to this court.
Kaya has not stated he wishes to own an AR-15.
Instead, he wants an industrial military
industries Galil semi-automatic rifle.
In district court, petitioners took care to explain
that the IMI Galil weapon is not an AR-15 style weapon.
Okay, so what Cook County is saying is because Mr. Kaya wants to own
something that's not labeled an AR-15, this case now becomes moot.
However, if you recall,
the issue presented in both of the consolidated cases is
whether the 2nd and 14th Amendments guarantee the right
to possess AR-15 platform and similar semi-automatic rifles.
Okay, now some of you may
or may not be familiar with the firearm that Mr. Kaya wants.
I would gladly show you an image here,
but Google and YouTube would absolutely crap itself.
We have linked it up down in the description box below,
but you will see that it looks like most
of your standard AK platform semi-automatic rifles.
Unfortunately, Cook County here believes...
While the Cook County Ordinance applies to AK-47 style weapons,
the question presented in this court is specifically limited
to AR-15 platform and similar semi-automatic rifles.
The court did not grant review
on petitioner's broader argument that Cook County's ordinance
is facially invalid under the Second Amendment.
Accordingly, Kaya has no personal stake
in the question on which the court granted cert,
O'Rourke.
And this is an argument that you get
when the attorneys for Cook County know absolutely
nothing about the operation of firearms, much like you get.
From state legislators, when the legislators know absolutely
nothing about the operational or functionality of firearms.
Because, again, Cook County pleads.
Should petitioners disavow their prior statement
and argue that the IMI Galil weapon is similar to an AR-15,
the record would not support that about-face.
There is no record facts concerning whether
the IMI Galil weapon operates similarly to an AR-15.
But you see, the insanity does not stop here,
because Cook County believes that the Second Amendment
only protects arms that can be used for self-defense and nothing else.
They are also quick to point out...
Kaya may be an unsuitable petitioner for another reason as well.
Unlike Vera Montes, who stated that he intended
to use his AR-15-style weapon for self-defense,
Kaya stated in district court that he was most likely
to use the IMI Galil at the range, to be honest.
And then to add insult to injury, Cook County,
with a straight face, argues that,
hey, listen, he doesn't need this IMI Galil.
He has other firearms that he can use
for self-defense, so we can ban this one.
Because they literally state,
He explained that he would use the weapon
for self-defense only if the other two guns he owns,
a handgun and a different permitted
semi-automatic rifle, are out of commission.
Okay, so is this likely to work? Probably not, okay?
And here's why. Is that the record below
doesn't really matter. Because if the Supreme Court actually
was interested in having a really
well-developed record in this particular case,
they wouldn't have taken VeraMontes nor Grant.
As a matter of fact, of the five cases we
were tracking all the time on WGLAM,
the two with the least developed record
are the two that actually got accepted. Secondly,
Take Vera Montes, throw the whole case out of the equation altogether.
Other than a bunch of people wasting hundreds
and hundreds of hours on briefing for a case
that no longer exists, let us remember
that Grant v. Higgins still exists, and Eddie Grant
is alive and well and a very capable named petitioner.
Don't know when to expect a ruling
from the United States Supreme Court.
We do imagine that it would likely come out
on either an orders list or a separate order
related to that.
We will obviously very carefully.
Keep track of what's going on with that.
The motion by Cook County, Illinois is linked up down below
so that you won't have to take our word for it.
You can just geek out on it for yourself.
Now, if you've got any questions about this
or anything else related to what's left of our Second Amendment rights,
you guys should know how to get a hold of Washington Gun Law by now.
But if you don't, that's okay.
That information is down there in the description box.
If you've got an idea for a video that
we should be doing around here, cool.
You're going to click on that link right there
and tell us all about it.
If you want to subscribe to our monthly newsletter,
Find out about all the cool stuff
they won't let us talk about here
and meet all of our new sponsors.
There's a link in the description box for you to do that.
And then finally, and most importantly,
let's everyone remember that part of being
the lawful and responsible gun owner,
like we talk about all the time here,
is to know what the law is in every situation,
how it applies to you in any instance
that you may find yourself.
From beautiful Post Falls, Idaho,
here at North Idaho Arms,
thanks for watching and stay safe.
Well, what I appreciate as a lawyer
is that the criminal justice system as a whole is
a very inhumane place.
In many ways, they've taken humanity out of the equation.
Thank you.
Explain to me why it's
so important that you consistently inject humanity back into the
equation and how important that is to us here at Right to Bear.
You know, I've always lived by the saying
that people don't care how much you know
until they know how much you care,
and that's just who we are, and that's the culture that
we stand behind, and when we have an opportunity to pray
and to make a difference in those
we serve, it's just fulfilling to me,
and somebody said not long ago, they said, you
know, you'll get too big after a while,
and you won't be able to do that, and I said,
well, we'll just find more people to serve them
because that's the culture we stand behind.
That's who we want to be. We don't want to be transactional.
We want to be relational.
And we'll forever be that right to bear.
When we say pure peace of mind, we mean it.
The Right to Bear Legal Defense Network.
You will always have a confidential call with a real attorney.
There are no cap limits for either criminal or civil cases.
It covers all forms of self-defense from a fist to a firearm,
from a fat lip to a dead body.
You are covered.
You will have some of the nation's most passionate
and competent defense attorneys representing you.
And right now, if you go to ProtectWithBear.com and you use
the promo code WGL, you're going to get 10% off for pure peace of mind.
Nothing beats the bear.