#History#Secrets In October 1871, three hundred and eighty feet beneath the south side of Wilkes-Barre, Pennsylvania, a laborer dressing the bottom of a coal face in the Baltimore vein struck something that sang. Twenty men took three days to clear the coal away from it. It was a blacksmith's anvil, fifteen feet long, its face eight feet and one inch above the floor, worn from edge to edge by the strokes of a hammer as wide as a dishpan. The coal around it was unbroken.
The mine boss struck it once to hear if the iron was cracked. Three slow blows came back from below, from no place where any mine had ever been driven. The colliery smith worked out a sum on the side of a powder keg. Under the anvil the engineer found stone footing blocks on four scale-tree stumps, cut off level, and for six working days the crew uncovered the rest of a forge.
A clerk named Amos Stark kept the file for thirty-eight years. At the back of it are two sheets copied from the notes of Jeremiah Curtin, who recorded the Seneca at Cattaraugus in 1883, and what an old woman of the Snipe clan said when she heard what the iron was standing on. The Seneca already had a name for it: Genonsgwa, the Stone Coats.
Why did every later mine map show a barrier of untouched coal around the old east gangway of Number Four, and why does no document explain it?
In 1871, miners in Pennsylvania discovered a massive iron anvil and a prehistoric forge embedded in 300-million-year-old coal. The site featured colossal tools and footprints of a giant smith, defying geological logic. Despite evidence of a supernatural origin linked to Seneca legends of the \"Stone Coats,\" the company sealed the site, leaving only fragmented records and folklore.
The blacksmith had to climb a ladder to reach the anvil.
His name was Jacob Reinhold.
He had sharpened picks and shod mules for the Wilkes-Barre Coal
and Iron Company for 11 years,
and on the morning of the 24th of October, 1871,
he stood in a chamber cut out of the coal,
380 feet beneath the south side of Wilkes-Barre,
Pennsylvania, with one hand on the rung of a mine
ladder, looking up at the tool he had
used every working day of his life.
The horn was there, as thick as a hogshead at the root,
and running out to a point.
the flat working face was there and the narrow waist and the broad
foot near the heel was the square hole where a smith drops the stem
of his cutting tools in every line it was a blacksmith's anvil
it was fifteen feet long its face stood eight feet and one inch above
the floor the company's engineer put its weight at sixty tons
around it stood a dozen men in felt hats with their lamps raised
and not one of them could see the top of it from where he stood
Reinhold climbed. On the face he found what
the men had told him he would find.
The iron was pale and rough, and it was covered from edge to edge
in shallow round hollows, each one fourteen inches across, overlapping
one across another until almost none of the original surface remained.
A smith does not need those explained.
Every anvil in the world wears the marks
of the hammer that works on it.
These were the marks of a hammer with a face as wide as a dishpan,
and they numbered in the thousands.
He came back down the ladder
and stood beside the iron with his arms hanging loose.
Then he showed the engineer where his knuckles fell.
An apprentice learns it in his first week.
The face of the iron belongs at the knuckles of the man who works it.
Reinhold stood five feet and nine inches tall,
and his knuckles hung thirty-one inches from the ground.
He took a stub of pencil and worked the proportion
on the side of a powder keg, and then he worked it again.
The man who set this anvil
at his own knuckles had stood eighteen feet tall.
that was the smaller of the two problems the chamber around him had
not existed ten days before it had been solid coal part
of the great bed that the valley's miners called the Baltimore vein
and the anvil had been inside it
nothing had been pushed in from above no shaft or crack led down to it
on every side the coal's thin bands met the iron and ended there
without a fracture and over the top of it they bent very slightly
the way snow bends over a buried cart.
That coal is about 300 million years old.
It is older than the first dinosaur by something like 70 million years.
The mine boss had struck the anvil once,
five days before Reinhold ever saw it,
to hear if the iron was cracked. It rang for a long time.
Then, from somewhere under the valley,
from no place where any mine had ever been driven,
three slow blows came back.
Those facts survive because of a clerk.
Amos Stark was 26 years old in 1871,
and he kept the papers for the state's newly created
Inspector of Mines in the Luzerne district.
The inspector's printed report for that year
gives this colliery a single line.
East Gangway closed on account of bad roof.
Stark knew it was not bad roof
because he had gone down and looked.
So he opened a file of his own, marked it No. 4 Slope, East Gangway,
and for the next 38 years he kept adding to it,
long after anyone had asked him to.
The Colliery Day book went into it, and the engineers copied letters,
and the blacksmith's sum on a sheet torn from a tally pad,
and at the very back,
two sheets sent to him from Western New York in the summer of 1883.
They are a copy of something written down by Jeremiah Curtin,
the field collector for the Bureau of Ethnology,
who was at that time recording the oral traditions of the Seneca
on the Cataraugus Reservation, near the village of Versailles.
A railroad surveyor at his boarding house had described
to him a great iron block out of the Pennsylvania coal,
and Curtin repeated the account to an old woman
of the snipe clan named Sarah Halftown,
who had already given him a good deal of what he knew.
She was seventy-eight years old. She had never been in a coal mine.
She had never been within two hundred miles of Wilkes-Barre.
She listened to all of it, and then she asked one question.
She asked what the anvil was standing on.
The surveyor had not told anyone what it was standing on.
The Seneca already had a name for it.
It is printed in the Bureau's own volume,
among the accounts Curtin collected,
spelled a little differently from one page to the next.
Genons W.A.
In English, the Stone Coats.
What Sarah Halftown told Curtin that afternoon about the Genons Gua
is not in the printed volume, and the reason it is not there
is on the sheet at the very back of Amos Stark's file.
Michael Gawne was 86 years old
when he described the first sound of it to a man with a notebook
in a kitchen in Plains Township in the winter of 1934.
The man was George Cawson, a former newspaper reporter
who had spent years going through
the anthracite towns collecting the songs and lore of the mines.
Most of what Cawson collected went
into a book called Minstrels of the Mine Patch.
This did not. Cawson's notes reached the Wyoming Historical
and Geological Society in Wilkes-Barre,
and they were filed with Amos Stark's box.
In October of 1871, Gorn was 23.
He had come from County Mayo at fifteen,
and he worked as a labourer, which in the anthracite
country was a precise word.
The contract miner drilled the coal, fired it down, and was paid
by the car. His labourer loaded what fell,
and was paid out of the miner's own pocket.
Gawne's miner was a Welshman
from Merthyr Tydfil named David Prosser, forty-four years old,
who sang while he drilled, and had buried a brother two years before.
They worked for the Wilkes-Barre Coal and Iron Company, one
of the larger concerns in the lower valley, in its number four slope,
on the south side of town near Solomon's Creek.
The slope is an inclined road driven down along the coal bed itself,
and at the bottom the miners drove a level tunnel called
a gangway out along the bed in each direction.
The Baltimore vein on that side of Wilkes-Barre is flexed and rolled,
ten feet thick in one heading, and more than twenty in the next.
In the summer of 1871 the East Gangway ran into a swell,
and the mine boss was pleased, because a swell meant coal.
The mine boss was Thomas Penn Hale,
fifty-two years old, from Camborne in Cornwall.
He had gone down the tin mines at ten
and crossed to Pennsylvania when the tin failed,
and he kept the colliery day-book in a square, patient hand.
Cars, powder, props,
and every man who was late and why all went into it.
The book survives in Stark's box with its cover gone.
On the morning of Monday the 16th of October, 1871,
the Pennsylvania papers were full of Chicago,
which had burned to the ground the week before.
In the East Gangway, 1,140 feet from the foot of the slope,
David Prosser had fired two holes at the end of the previous shift, and
Michael Gorn went in ahead of him to load what they had brought down.
The vein there stood 23 feet from floor to roof.
When the loose coal was cleared,
the labourer took a pick to dress the bottom of the face,
low down, a little above his knee.
Sixty-three years later he told George Corson
that the pick jumped in his hand and that it sang.
He used that word.
This went on after he had stopped moving.
He felt it in his teeth.
He stood still with the pick in his hands
and the note went on going away from him down the gangway.
Behind him, a long way off, he heard a driver stop his mule.
Prosser came up with his lamp.
The two of them scraped the broken coal aside with their hands,
and under it there was a surface that was not black.
It was the dull, pale grey of old iron, with hardly any red in it,
and it curved up and away from them into the bottom of the vein.
Prosser put his palm flat on it.
It was the first and only time
that Gorn ever saw him stop singing on a shift.
Penhale's entry for that day runs to four lines,
and the page still carries somebody's thumb in coal dust.
Iron in the east face at 1140.
Not ours.
Coal is tight all around.
No break.
Stop the place and put the men to clearing.
That phrase, no break, is the one he kept returning to.
A mine boss spends his life reading ground.
Anything that gets into a coal bed from outside leaves a wound,
whether it is a lost tool, an old prop,
or a forgotten working from a previous generation.
Penhale went over that face for three days with a lamp held against it,
and he found no wound.
the thin bright bands that run through the Baltimore vein like
the lines in a stack of paper reached the iron
and ended on the far side they resumed
at the same height above it they rose a little and settled
as if whatever lay on top of them had come down soft and slow over
a very long time stopping a paying place was not a small decision for a
man in his position because nothing in that valley had ever been free
The Wyoming Valley is a long trough, about 20 miles from end to end,
with the north branch of the Susquehanna River running through
the bottom of it, and a wall of mountain on either side.
Under that trough, the coal lies in folded beds,
in places 2,000 feet deep.
It stuck out of the creek banks.
Around 1769, a Connecticut blacksmith named Obadiah Gore,
one of the first settlers to push into the valley,
tried the black stone in his forge and found that it would burn,
if it was given enough of a blast, far hotter than charcoal.
So the first man known to have put this coal
to work in the valley was a smith at his fire.
By 1871, the valley floor was a line of breakers.
Great black wooden towers where boys as young as eight sat astride
the chutes picking out slate with their bare fingers,
and Welsh, English, Irish
and German miners went underground by the thousand.
What that cost was on record by then.
On the 6th of September 1869,
the wooden breaker at the Avondale Colliery in Plymouth,
built directly over the only way in or out of the mine,
caught fire and fell burning into the shaft.
A hundred and ten men and boys suffocated below.
When the rescuers finally reached them,
they found fathers lying with their arms around their sons behind
a wall they had tried to build against the smoke.
Most of them were Welsh. David Prosser's younger brother,
Rhys, was among them, and Prosser helped to carry him up.
Avondale is the reason Amos Stark had a job.
In 1870, under the weight of that disaster,
the Pennsylvania legislature passed a law
requiring every anthracite mine to have a second way out,
and it put state inspectors over the mines to enforce it.
The law was widely ignored and often weakly enforced,
but it did one thing that matters here.
It meant that for the first time somebody outside
the companies was entitled to walk into a gangway
and write down what he saw.
It took twenty men those three days to take the coal away,
timbering as they went, because twenty-three feet
of unsupported coal is not a thing a sensible man
stands under. What came out of the bed,
a little more at every shift, was a form that each of them knew
and none of them was willing to name first the horn came clear
on the Tuesday by noon on the Wednesday the waist
was open curving in beneath the face in a great smooth arch
on either side tall enough for a man to stand in
Gaunt told Corson that the men stopped talking somewhere around
then one of them finally took his hat off
and said to nobody that his father had one of those in Kerry about
the size of a loaf they finished on the Thursday afternoon
The anvil stood clear on the floor of its new chamber,
fifteen feet from the tip of the horn to the end of the heel,
and the crew stood around it with their heads back.
In the dust around its foot,
Gorn noticed that the coal was full of small, dark, curved flakes,
like the scales off a fish,
thousands upon thousands of them,
lying in a wide ring.
He swept up a handful and showed it to Prosser,
who did not know what it was.
He put it in his dinner can to show to the colliery smith.
Penhale sent his report to the office in town that evening,
and then he stayed behind.
Every man underground in that valley had brought his dead
and his beliefs with him,
and on this one point they did not agree.
Thomas Penhale came from a country where
everybody knew about the knockers.
In the Cornish tin mines, the small tapping heard behind the rock
was the sign of something at work in the load,
and an old hand would tell a boy to follow it,
because it led to good ground and away from bad.
A miner left a crust of his dinner on a ledge
for whoever was doing the tapping.
Penhale still did it, at fifty-two, and he did not think it was odd.
David Prosser's people in South Wales called them the Coblenau,
and they thought much the same,
that they were small and busy and well-disposed,
and that a man who heard them should be glad of it.
Prosser had heard knocking at Avondale,
or he had talked to people who said they had,
and he did not like to discuss it.
Michael Gawne's mother, in Mayo, had believed something else.
In her house, a knock with nobody
at the door meant a death was on its way,
and there was exactly one rule.
If it came in the night and someone asked who is there,
that person would be the one who was taken.
Nobody answers.
So when Penhale picked up a ten-pound sledge that Thursday evening,
after the shift had gone up and only four men were left in the chamber,
his reason was perfectly sound.
His concern was whether the iron was cracked through,
because a cracked casting could be broken up and hauled away in pieces,
and sound iron could not be moved at all.
He also said, and Gorn remembered this because of how he said it,
that he would like to hear how it answered.
In Camborne that was a joke.
Gorn, who was holding the lamp,
told him what his mother used to say.
Penhale smiled at him, not unkindly, and swung.
The note was deep and round and very long.
It seemed to Gawne that it started in the iron
and then moved into the floor.
It took a slow count of twenty to die,
and when it was gone they could hear
water dripping back along the gangway.
Penhale nodded, satisfied, and bent to put the sledge down.
The first blow came while he was still bent over.
It was low and far away,
as though something had been dropped down a well on the other side
of the county. There was a space of one slow breath,
and a second came, and after the same
space, a third. Each one arrived up through the soles of the boots,
a moment before the ear caught
it. Then came the water again, dripping.
Nobody spoke for some time. The nearest workings on the
vein in that direction were more than half a mile off,
and had been idle since the Friday.
In his day-book, he wrote,
Struck the iron once at end of shift,
Answered three from below,
And on the next line, in smaller letters,
There is nothing below.
There was one more thing about that number,
And it was Gawne who said it, on the climb out.
On number four slope, as on most slopes in the valley,
The hoist was run by signals wrapped on a pipe or rung on a bell.
One rap meant hoist, and two meant lower.
Three meant men on the car, take care.
Penhale told him to shut his mouth, and he did.
The engineer came on the Monday.
Edwin Lathrop was thirty-three, a Connecticut man
who had learned his trade running lines for the Lehigh Valley Railroad,
and he had the cool, polite manner of someone
who has been called out to a great many marvels
and has found a loose timber behind each of them.
He measured everything first, from a ladder the men knocked together,
and he reckoned that no means
the company possessed could get it up the slope in one piece.
He heard out Penhale's account with his head on one side.
Then he took a hand hammer and tapped twice on the heel of the anvil,
the way someone tests a wheel.
This time they did not have to count to twenty.
Three blows came, nearer than Penhale's and heavier,
with coal dust sifting out of the timber, lagging at each one.
Lathrop kept copies of his letters
to the New York office in a letterpress book,
and that night he copied this one.
He said he had no account to give of the noise and would offer none,
and that he had sent for the colliery's blacksmith.
Jacob Reinhold came down the slope on the Tuesday
with his leather apron over his arm.
He was forty-six, a Pennsylvania German from Berks County,
with no opinion on knockers or coblenau.
He knew iron.
Lathrop's letter describes him as a person of no education,
and then spends two pages on what he said.
He took the flakes in Gorn's dinner-can first,
turned them over with a finger, and laughed
out loud with surprise.
That was forge-scale, the skin of oxide
that jumps off hot iron under the hammer, and a
smith sweeps it off his floor by the bucket.
To leave that much of it, Reinhold said,
someone had worked at that spot for longer than he
had been alive.
He put his whole forearm into the nine-inch square hole near the heel.
He climbed the ladder, spread his hands in one of the hollows.
And then he reckoned the hammer in the only way he had,
against the sixteen-pound sledge in his own shop.
A man three times the height of an ordinary man
is some thirty times as heavy, and his sledge is two.
That came to close to five hundred pounds.
Then came the knuckles and the powder keg.
The sheet in Stark's file is a fair copy Reinhold made afterward,
at the clerk's request, in a big square German hand.
thirty-one inches goes into sixty-nine as ninety-seven goes
into two hundred and sixteen below it in Lathrop's neater writing
is one line i have been over the arithmetic and find no fault in it
there is a thing smiths do between blows when the hammer comes up
from the work a smith lets it fall on the bare face
and bounce once or twice to keep the arm loose and hold the time
every one of them has a pattern and a good ear can name
a man two farms away by nothing else reinhold's was two light taps
and a heavy one he had been doing it for thirty-four years
and he no more thought about it than about how he walked he had
a two-pound hand-hammer in his fist
he climbed back up the ladder because he wanted one more look
at the hollows near the heel and as he stood on the top rung
his arm did what it had always done light light heavy light light
heavy light light heavy he heard what he had done and he stopped
Lathrop, below him, looked up. Penhale took a step back from the iron.
For as long as it would take to say the Lord's Prayer,
nothing at all happened, and Gaunt,
who had been told to hold the foot of the ladder,
began to breathe again.
Then it came up through the ladder into his hands, light, light, heavy.
It was slow and it was unhurried,
and there was no mistaking it for an echo, because an
echo arrives at once and comes back weaker.
This had waited, and it was louder than Reinhold's own.
It went through the pattern three times exactly as he had.
On the last heavy blow, a thin curtain
of coal dust dropped out of the timbering
and settled across the smith's shoulders.
Lathrop's letter records the rest in one sentence.
Reinhold laid his hammer down on the iron
as gently as if it were an egg,
came down the ladder, took up his apron, and left by the slope,
and he stayed away for two days.
An engineer can stop at that point and be remembered as a sensible man.
Lathrop's instructions were to report whether
the iron could be broken up and got out.
Breaking it would mean heavy blows in any case.
On Thursday 26th October,
he set two heavy men from the shift on planks at the sides of the face,
each with a twenty-pound sledge,
to strike it in turn as hard and fast as they could,
twenty blows between them, while he pressed his head to the waist
and listened for the buzz of a crack.
Men on the planks stopped at twenty. For a moment there was nothing.
Then the floor of the chamber lifted under them.
Penhale's entry for that day has been gone over twice with the pen,
as though it did not look right to him the first time.
Twenty blows. Answer came from under us.
Floor rose and threw the men down.
Floor split from the iron to the east rib.
Smoke from the split. Two men hurt, not badly.
Gorn was knocked flat on his back with his lamp out.
He told Corson that there were three heavy strokes from below,
and that the second opened the ground
with a sound like a plank breaking.
When somebody got a light going,
a crack ran through the clay floor
from the foot of the anvil to the rib,
more than twenty feet long, and wide enough to take a man's arm.
Out of it, thin and slow in the lamplight,
came a grey smoke, for about as long as it would take to fill a pipe.
Every man in the chamber knew that smell, and there was no gas in it.
Prosser said it first, and he said it in Welsh,
and then he said it again for the others.
It smelled of a forge in the morning, of hot iron and quenching water.
No one struck the anvil again from that day on.
But the crack gave Lathrop what he needed,
because it let him see under the thing.
A coal bed always rests upon a layer of soft grey clay,
which the miners call the bottom,
and the geologists call the underclay.
It is the old ground itself, the soil in which the
swamp forests of the coal age were rooted before they fell,
and, over a span of time
no one can really picture, turned into the black rock above it.
lathrop had the men clear back the clay around
the anvil's foot to find out how far down the iron went it did
not go down at all it stood on a footing there were blocks
of dressed grey stone each the size of a steamer trunk fitted edge
to edge beneath the foot and squared on their upper faces
under the blocks carrying them at the four corners were four
round masses of black stone each about five feet across standing
in the clay with their roots still running out from them
Each one had been cut off level, and the bark was on them.
It had left its print in the surrounding coal, a clean,
regular pattern of small diamonds, row upon row, like a lizard's hide.
Lathrop knew that pattern, and so does anyone who has ever
walked through the coal-age room of a natural history museum.
It belongs to the scale tree, Lepidodendron,
which stood more than a hundred feet high in those swamps,
and vanished from the earth long before the first dinosaur.
It was not the trees that held him there
with the lamp, it was the saw line.
Four living trees had been chosen for their spacing,
and taken off at one height, and the height had been checked.
and a stone footing had been laid across them
and then the anvil had been set on it the way any smith sets
his anvil on a sawn block for the spring in it whoever did that had
been standing in a living forest on that clay when it was soft
Lathrop's letter to New York that night has one sentence underlined
this was not lost here this is where it was put then he did something
for which the company never forgave him he took the crew off coal
For six working days, on company wages,
the men of No. 4 stripped the floor of the old forest.
Penhale kept the record,
just as he kept the record of props and powder.
Read straight through, those six entries
are the strangest pages ever written in a colliery day book,
because their tone never changes.
Stark numbered them in red ink, one to six, and added nothing.
The first day produced one arm of a pair of tongs,
lying aslant in the clay beside the footing,
handle and gripping end together, snapped at the rivet.
It measured nine feet. Four men could raise one end.
The second day they found the trough, twenty feet long,
and cut from one block of the same grey stone,
sunk level with the old floor, and packed full of coal.
Reinhold had come back by then.
he looked at it with his hat in his hand and called it a slack tub
a smith plunges his hot work into one to harden it when the men had
dug out the coal the bottom of it was lined with a crust of scale
as thick as a boot sole the kind of crust that takes years to build up
in a tub the third day they found the hearth beyond the trough
it was a ring of stones cracked
and burned twenty-five feet across and the bed inside it
was a compacted grey ash with black clinker through it
through a gap left in the ring for the purpose ran
an iron pipe three feet wide at the mouth lathrop had to ask what it
was Reinhold told him it was the tuyere the throat through
which the bellows blows the fire a man could have crawled up it
The fourth day gave them the path.
From the fire to the iron, the clay had been wet
when the forge was working, and it had held what walked on it.
There were prints of a bare foot, one over another, going and coming,
worn so deep along one line that they had made a trench,
the way cattle make a trench going down to water.
Every smith wears such a path,
carrying the hot work back and forth ten thousand times.
Penhale measured the clearest of them three times,
and wrote the figure three times.
Each was thirty-three inches from the heel to the end of the great toe,
and each was sunk five inches into clay
that took a man's boot only as deep as the sole.
Gawne took off his boot. He told Corson he did not know why.
He set his bare foot in the heel of the print,
and his toes did not reach the arch.
The fifth day gave them nothing but cars of clay,
and an open floor behind the hearth with a pair of post-holes in it,
where Reinhold said a bellows would have stood.
The sixth day was the second of November, and Michael Gawne was the one
who found them, because he had been given the last corner to clear.
They were on the bellows side of the hearth,
in a patch no larger than the floor of a small kitchen.
He brushed the clay with his hand, as he had been shown,
and the marks in it were so ordinary
that for a moment he was not sure they were anything at all.
They were footprints. Barefoot,
a little over ten inches long,
and dozens upon dozens of them, a small area worn hollow
by someone who had spent long days standing in one place,
shifting from one foot to the
other, and now and then stepping back to haul on something overhead.
He sat back on his heels and held the lamp out.
Then he took off his boot again.
He told Corson it fit.
He told him that he stood there, with his one foot in that place,
in the Baltimore vein, for a good
while before he thought to call anyone.
He had an idea, he said, of how it was to stand all the day
at another person's work, in another person's place,
and of who gets to go home after it.
he had come from Mayo at fifteen
and he had been a labourer for eight years he thought about the one
who had stood here and whether any one had asked him Penhale's entry
for that day is the shortest in the book other prints
by hearth man's size Reinhold came and looked and went away
Amos Stark came into the matter because two men had been hurt.
Under the new law, an injury underground had to be reported,
and on the 3rd of November the inspector sent his clerk out to No. 4
to write up a floor heave in the East Gangway.
Stark rode down the slope in his good coat with a form to fill in.
He stayed nine hours.
He was shown all of it by Penhale, who said very little,
and by Lathrop, who could hardly stop talking.
By then Lathrop had written the longest letter of his life.
it said that an ancient working forge lay complete at the bottom
of the Baltimore vein just as it had been abandoned it asked
the directors to send for Professor Joseph Leidy of the academy
of natural sciences in Philadelphia and for a photographer
and to leave the coal in that swell alone until they had come
The reply reached Wilkes-Barre by wire on the 4th of November,
and a copy of it is in the letterpress book.
It mentioned neither Leidy nor a photographer.
It told Lathrop to close
the East Gangway forthwith by a permanent stopping
and to resume work to the West,
and it asked him to report to New York by the 15th.
There is no need to imagine anything sinister in that.
The directors of a coal company in 1871 had a railroad to feed
and a price to hold,
and they had just been told by one of their own employees
that a producing gangway should be handed over
to a professor from Philadelphia
on account of a blacksmith's arithmetic.
The inspector, when Stark laid his notes on the desk,
read them through and asked whether the stopping would be sound.
Told that it would, he wrote the words bad roof in the report,
and he told his clerk he had better things to do.
Stark took his notes home.
The men built it between the 6th and the 11th of November,
some 200 feet back along the gangway from the chamber,
where the coal was solid on both sides.
It was a double wall of brick and mortar,
with the space between packed with mine rock and clay.
Penhale ran the job with six men, Gorn and Prosser among them.
Three things came out first,
and each of them left in the hands of the man who wanted it.
Edwin Lathrop took paper.
On his last day he spread a sheet of drafting cloth across
the clearest of the great prints
and drew around it with a soft pencil, full size,
every toe. He folded it in eight
and carried it off in his instrument case.
It would be twelve years before he showed it to anyone.
Jacob Reinhold took iron.
he asked Penhale for the broken arm of the tongs and Penhale
who wanted none of it left in his mine and could not say why sent it up
on a flat car at the end of a shift it took six men and a mule
to get it from the slope to the smith shop Reinhold laid it up across
the rafters above his forge where it stayed as long as he kept the shop
it never went in the fire in that valley where a rail left in a wet
gangway would go red in a month it took no rust Michael Gawne took clay
The evening before the wall closed,
he went back along the gangway by himself with a pick,
a spade, and a wooden powder box.
He found the worn place on the bellows side of the hearth,
and he cut out one print, slowly,
working around it from all sides, in a single block the size of
a bread box. When Corson asked him why, in 1934,
the old man looked at him as though he had asked
something foolish. Somebody ought
to get one of them out of there, he said.
Then the last course of brick went in,
and No. 4 went back to work on the west side of the slope.
What became of those men is in the file,
too, because Stark went on asking.
Lathrop reported to New York,
and his position with the company ended in the spring.
He spent the rest of his career running lines
for railroads in the western part of New York State,
and he would survey anything but a tunnel.
Thomas Penn Hale stayed on as mine boss for seven more years.
The men noticed that he had stopped leaving his crust on the ledge.
Every few months the day-book has
a short entry at the foot of the page,
always the same words.
Pass the stopping. Quiet.
Then in the spring of 1874, one time only, pass the stopping.
Not quiet. He did not write what he had heard.
Jacob Reinhold kept his forge for another twenty-two years,
and his apprentices remembered it as a peculiar shop.
he took his anvil off its oak block and bedded it down in a box
of dry sand and he wrapped a length of log chain around its waist
which is a thing smiths sometimes do to kill the ring
but he did it long before anyone complained
he trained himself out of his own pattern at forty-six years old
as a man trains himself out of a stammer it took him about a year
his boys said that they never once heard his hammer touch the bare
iron Michael Gorn went on working underground for less than a year
He got a job driving a team for a brewery, married a girl from Plains,
and raised seven children, and he told hardly anyone.
His grandchildren knew only that the old man,
who never raised his voice or his hand,
could cross a room faster than anyone alive
if a child began tapping on a stovepipe with a spoon.
David Prosser never spoke of it either.
He had taken nothing from the chamber and had laid brick
on that wall without a word, and the singing did not come back.
The men knew he had carried Rees up the Avondale shaft,
and they knew what the Welsh in that valley believed about
the small tapping behind the rock,
that it was kind, and that it could be spoken to.
On the night of the 18th of December,
1871, five weeks after the war went up,
the fire boss made his rounds before the morning shift,
testing for gas with his lamp.
Going along the east gangway,
which he had no great reason to do, he came to the stopping.
Penhale copied his report into the daybook word for word.
Prosser's dinner can and hammer at the stopping set down neat.
brick is sound mortar is sound bright mark on the brick
at knee height where it has been struck a good deal Prosser
is not in the mine he was not at his house in Plymouth either
his wife waited for him there for thirty-one years
the company searched the workings for two days and it found nothing
and it entered him in the books as having left the district
Stark went to see the wife in January,
and she showed him the coat Prosser had gone out without,
in the middle of that winter, and the good boots.
Stark made a note of it, he drew a line under the note,
and for some time after that, there is nothing more in the file.
The next paper arrived in August of 1883,
in an envelope from Versailles, New York, addressed
in the neat hand of a man who had once been a company engineer.
Versailles is a small village on Cattaraugus Creek,
at the edge of what the Seneca Nation still holds,
some 200 miles northwest of the Wyoming Valley.
Jeremiah Curtin came there in 1883 for the Bureau of Ethnology.
That summer he sat day after day with the older people of the
reservation, taking down in English what they were willing to tell him.
His collection was later joined
with texts recorded in Seneca by J.N.B. Hewitt,
a Tuscarora scholar at the Bureau,
and the Genonsgwa appear all through the printed volume.
Edwin Lathrop was 45 that summer,
running a line along the creek
for a branch railroad that was never built,
and he had taken a room at the same boarding house as Curtin.
It was 12 years since he had left the coal country.
One evening, he told the Bureau's collector about the anvil.
Curtin, who collected everything,
wanted to know what the Seneca would make of it,
and a few days later he repeated the account,
leaving out the names, to Sarah Halftown.
She had given him several of his Genonsgwa accounts already.
She had raised her grandchildren at Cattaraugus,
after being moved there as a girl.
Curtin's page says that she heard him out,
sewing, and that when he had finished,
she asked what the iron was standing on. He said he did not know.
She said he might ask, and she went on sewing.
He went and asked.
Lathrop, who had signed nothing
but had kept his word to the company for twelve years,
stood in the door of the boarding-house
for some time before he answered.
He said stone blocks.
He said that under the blocks there were four trees, cut off level,
and he went up to his room
and brought down a folded piece of drafting cloth.
Curtin carried that back the next day,
and this is the part of his page
that Lathrop copied out for Stark in full.
The old woman, Curtin wrote, was not surprised,
and she laid her sewing down.
She said that her mother's father had been at Wyoming in the war.
The war, at least, is on the plain record.
The valley lay within the country the Six Nations claimed by right,
and the Seneca, the westernmost of the Haudenosaunee,
whom the French and the English called the Iroquois, knew it well.
In July of 1778, Seneca warriors under the war chief Sayenkarakta
came down the Susquehanna with British rangers
and fought the Connecticut settlers there,
in what has been called ever since the Battle of Wyoming.
The next year,
On the orders of George Washington,
the army of General John Sullivan marched through Seneca
country and burned some 40 towns,
with their orchards and their standing corn, and that
winter thousands of refugees starved
and froze around the British post at Niagara.
The treaties that followed took nearly everything in stages.
It took a long fight in the courts of the 1840s
to keep Cattaraugus and Allegheny at
all.
And in 1965, the Kinzua Dam flooded some 10,000 acres of Seneca land
and forced out around 600 people.
The water is still there.
So are the Seneca, with a government of their own,
on the same two territories.
Her mother's father came back through
that valley a winter or two after the battle,
in a hard frost, with a small party,
and they camped in a deep ravine at the head
of a creek on the South Mountain,
and they did not make a fire, for fear of being seen.
He put his head to the hard ground to sleep,
and through it, against his ear, he heard
someone working, slow and heavy, a long way down,
as a man would pound corn if the pestle
was a great deal too big for him.
He asked the oldest man in the party,
and the old man said yes, that was them, they
worked in the cold because they worked in the fire,
and that was why a person heard
them best in a hard frost when the ground was tight.
they were under all that country the printed accounts
of the Genonsgwa should be taken as they stand
because they are the record, the Stonecoats are people of the frost
and the cold one account Curtin took down opens
by saying that in the old time when men got lost
while hunting it was supposed the Stonecoat had eaten them
they go about in clothing of stone
and in one telling a Seneca man coming upon their camp
at night sees the stone clothing leaning up against a tree
With its owner lying on the ground beside it.
They are not the work of the creator.
He says so himself.
In a line Curtin recorded.
I did not make the stone coats.
Someone else made them.
And they have two strange habits that recur.
A stone coat cannot look up.
When he has lost a man he takes out of his pocket a finger
and lays it on the palm of his hand
and the finger rises and points.
None of those accounts mentions iron or a forge.
Anyone weighing this file should bear that in mind.
Curtin asked her whether the Genonsgwa were smiths.
His page says she looked at him for a time,
as if this was a white man's question,
and said they took off their coats to work.
A person could understand that much from the old accounts.
Why else would anyone hang his coat on a tree?
she said that there had been people with them and she held her hand
out flat at about her own height some had gone with them to tend
the fire in the time of the great trees when everything there was low
and wet she did not know how and she did not say that it was by force
the old accounts she pointed out have a man
and the stonecoats becoming good friends ever after
because he gave back the finger friends was the word they used she said
and curtain might write it down that way
Then she gave him the rule, which was short,
and which she said every child at Cattaraugus used to know.
Hear it, and be still. Dig somewhere else. Do not answer.
Curtin asked what would become of anyone who did.
His page gives her answer,
and Lathrop's copy gives it on a separate sheet, set apart by itself,
which Stark kept at the very back of the file.
it did not reach the printed volume.
When Hewitt came to edit Curtin's material,
he worked with great care,
correcting and rewriting the manuscripts and matching them
against what he had himself recorded
in the Seneca language in the autumn of 1896.
A single page in English, from one speaker,
describing a forge that appears in no other
version, about a find that no scholar had ever seen,
is exactly what a careful editor leaves out.
No original of Curtin's page has
been identified among the papers at the Smithsonian.
All that exists is the copy that a railroad surveyor made
for a clerk in Wilkes-Barre,
and it should be weighed as what it is.
Amos Stark read it at his desk,
in the inspector's office, on a hot day in August.
He had told no one outside that office about the four stumps.
He got down his own notes of 1871, to make sure of the number,
and he sat with them until the light went.
He did what a careful clerk does next,
and he took it to the best authority available.
In the 1880s, the Second Geological Survey of Pennsylvania
was mapping the anthracite fields under Charles Ashburner,
a young man of great ability,
and in 1885, Stark sent him a summary
of the whole case without the Seneca page.
Ashburner's reply is courteous and three pages long,
and nothing written since has improved on it.
The coal measures, he wrote, are full of ironstone.
Masses of iron carbonate grew inside the beds as they hardened,
some of them many feet across,
and they will turn a pick and ring under it.
Layers of coal do bend over such a mass and close beneath it,
for the simple reason that the soft peat compacted
around something that would not compress,
so that draped bands prove nothing about what came first.
Certain of these masses develop a texture called cone in cone,
with rows of shallow overlapping cups that any untrained eye might take
for the marks of a tool. Stumps of the scale tree stand
in the floor of nearly every mine in the valley,
and the casts of them fall out of the roof and kill men every year.
as for the blows from below deep ground under heavy mining
moves it settles and shifts sometimes with a violent bump
that can throw men off their feet and split a floor and water
and gas under pressure can knock in old workings for days on end
a modern geologist would add one thing Ashburner did not press
anthracite is coal that has been cooked the heat
and pressure that folded these mountains drove off nearly everything
but carbon and it is very hard to see how a print
in soft clay could survive that with its toes intact
No iron has ever been recovered from the Baltimore vein
that any laboratory has been allowed to test.
The anvil, if it stands anywhere, stands behind a wall.
Stark filed it and made no comment.
A concretion does not have a heel and a square hole,
but then Ashburner had not seen it,
and Stark had seen it only once, by lamplight, at twenty-six.
Three objects could settle it.
As far as can be learned, the tracing went to a niece in Rochester.
The arm of the tongs lay over Reinhold's rafters until
his son moved it to a barn in Hanover Township,
where the family last reported it in 1938,
and it has not been produced.
Gawn's block of clay was in a tea chest in Plains in 1934,
when George Cawson held it on his knee.
Cawson's note says it had dried as hard as a brick.
He describes a human print, a grown person's,
barefoot, with the toes spread from standing.
If that clay came from where Gawn said,
It comes from a floor laid down about 300 million years ago.
Nobody with an instrument has ever examined it,
and the family is not obliged to let anyone.
Stark's last addition to the file is dated 1909,
the year he retired, and it is a tracing of a mine map.
By then the Baltimore vein was being worked out across
the whole south side of town,
in the grid of rooms and pillars that fills every sheet
in the state's mine map collection.
Coal companies leave pillars of solid coal between properties,
and those are called barrier pillars, and the law expects them.
On that map, one such barrier sits by itself,
in the middle of a single company's ground,
with no property line anywhere near it.
It is shaped like a rough circle, about 600 feet across,
around the Old East Gangway of No. 4.
Across it, a draftsman has lettered three words.
Barrier. Not approached.
Stark found that every later map he could get hold
of showed the same circle,
whichever company had drawn it,
and he could not find one document explaining why.
He died in 1917, and his widow gave the box to the Society.
Down in the workings the rule went
on without anyone needing the reason.
Cawson heard it in the 1930s from old Poles
and Lithuanians who had never heard of number four.
Do not rap on a pipe for no reason. If something raps back, keep still.
Then the water came. On the 22nd of January 1959,
at the Knox Coal Company's river slope in Port Griffith,
a heading driven too close beneath the Susquehanna broke through,
and the river poured into the mines
in a whirlpool that swallowed railroad cars, and twelve men died.
That date is usually remembered
as the end of deep mining in the valley,
though the state's own engineers point out that water
and falling demand had been closing collieries
for years. The pumps stopped.
One after another, and the valley's old workings
are connected from end to end.
Over the following decade,
the water rose through all of them, room by room,
until it reached daylight and came up into basements and streets,
and emergency boreholes had to be sunk to let it out.
It still runs.
On Solomon's Creek, near Lee Park,
close to where the old No. 4 slope went down,
millions of gallons a day come out of the ground,
orange with iron, and go down to the river.
So everything that Stark's map shows is now full.
Those miles of rooms are a single body
of still water under a city, in the dark,
and anyone who has struck a pipe
in a flooded cellar can say what water does for a sound.
In 2014, two of the old boreholes on Solomon's Creek collapsed,
and new ones were drilled.
A technician, who was asked not to be named,
had a pressure logger hanging in the mine water at the time,
a small instrument that records the level every few seconds.
her interest was in flow what she noticed on the printouts
was that about a minute after each day's drilling stopped
the record showed three small rises in the water evenly spaced each
a few hundredths of a foot she put them down to the rig they went
on for weeks no larger after ten hours of drilling than after one
Then, on the afternoon that the drill string reached the old workings
and the steel casing was hammered home, she got something else.
There were two small rises, and a large one,
then two small and a large, then two small and a large again.
She kept that sheet in her desk.
She told a local historian about it only much later,
once she had come across Reinhold's sheet at the Society,
along with a note about his hand hammer.
The last two boreholes on the plan were sighted elsewhere.
The stated reason was access.
There remains the sheet that Lathrop copied out by itself,
and it is set down here as he set it down.
Curtin asked what would become of anyone who answered them.
The old woman took up her sewing again.
She said,
You have it written already, in what I told you.
They cannot look up.
A stone coat does not hunt by looking.
He takes out the finger, and it stands up on his hand and points.
What you people call knocking is that finger.
All this time they have not known
who was walking around over their heads,
and they have not cared, and rock keeps a sound small.
But anyone who strikes their iron has told them where he is.
And she said,
they have never come up to get anybody they have
no need you people keep on digging down and every room you cut
is one more road and you leave them all open she said they
were not angry that a smith is never angry with the iron
their fire is still lit it has been a long time since the ones
who stood at it for them went away to the hills and they have
been working alone ever since they answer whoever knocks she said
for the same reason that anybody calls out
when the work is heavy and he is short of hands.
Lathrop's copy ends there.
Under the last line, in pencil, undated,
Amos Stark wrote two letters,
DP, that is the file.
The society still has the box.
The water still comes out at Leigh Park,
and the creek bed there is orange for a long way down.
Whether there is an anvil standing in that water on four stumps,
with a ring of scale around it,
cannot now be determined by anyone.
The wall was built well, and it has been under water since the 1960s.
The Seneca at Kataraugus have their own accounts of the Genonsgwa,
which they are under no obligation to share,
and which were old before there was a Wilkes-Barre.
If you grew up over a mine,
your family may have had a rule of this kind.
A pipe nobody tapped. A place nobody dug. A sound that nobody answered.
Rules like that are written down almost nowhere,
and the comments under this video are one
place they could be.
Subscribing keeps these files coming,
and if you ever find yourself far below ground
with a hammer and an idle minute,
it may be worth remembering what an old woman said over
her sewing on a summer afternoon at Cateraugus.
Rock keeps a sound small.
Keep still and let it.