The fighting method of most soldiers: one-handed spear and shield

Eternal Shield
2 followers
5 Video Views·Jan 30, 2026
How did soldiers fight with the commonest historical weapon combination: one-handed spear and shield? Nobody knows, but here you see me describe one way they might have done it, with the help of HEMA enthusiasts in Germany.
Hello, I'm here with Marianne at the Tremonier Fechtschule,
which is a fight camp, a HEMA camp, near Dortmund in Germany.
And I've been teaching one-handed spear.
Now, why would anyone use a one-handed spear?
Because as we all know, swords and axes and maces,
they're all much cooler and more popular weapons to learn in HEMA.
Well, one of the reasons that you might want to use it is to re-enact
how most people used to fight in the past.
Because throughout the Stone Age people fought with spears,
and then the Bronze Age started, and that went on for century after century
of people fighting with spears and shields.
You look at pictures of Sumerians, Babylonians, and all the rest of it,
and spear and shield, they love it.
And then the Iron Age started, in which case
one-handed spear and shield was the most popular weapon.
Then you got to the Ancient Period, in which case it was one-handed spear and shield.
And then Early Medieval Period, it was one-handed spear and shield.
And you begin to see a pattern, right, throughout the entirety of the past,
this has been the main weapon used by a soldier against another soldier.
So I think it's reasonable to imagine that there was a good reason for that.
They weren't all idiots, so this must work.
And yet, if you ever hold a spear in two hands, like this,
and generally I would put my strong hand, my right-handed, in front,
you'll find that you can be quite vigorous with it,
and you've got a lot of power and so forth.
And if you hold a spear in one hand, everything's so much slower and weaker,
and you might think, well, this is rubbish.
Well, you only ever use a one-handed spear in conjunction with a shield.
So it's this combination that's really good.
Now, before I get into the business of hitting people,
I'm going to talk about the way that one might hold a spear.
Now a lot of people conjecture that this is the way to hold a spear.
And I would agree that this is the best way to hold a spear if you're just about to throw it.
If I want to throw this as hard and as far as I possibly can,
this is where I will hold it, in the middle, at its point of balance,
with my palm towards me and the thumb pointed towards the rear.
OK, so I'm going to call this the overhand grip.
But in melee, if I want to hang on to my spear and fight opponent after opponent,
there are lots of really big drawbacks.
Now the biggest advantage of this big long stick is that it's long, it's reach.
So if he's got a sword, or axe, or a mace, or whatever,
and I've got a spear, I should out-reach him.
But if I hold it in the middle here, actually by the time I'm in range of him, he's in range of me.
What's the point of having this big long stick if I don't make use of its range?
I can't thrust very far forwards because of the problem of the way my wrist works.
You may be anatomically eccentric, but I can imagine that you're probably similar to me,
in that you can cock your wrist that way, towards the little finger,
a lot further than you can cock it the other way, towards the thumb.
I can get maybe 75 degrees that way, and maybe 15 degrees on a good day that way.
I have actually hurt my wrist yesterday doing a knife disarming class, so I'm not quite at my peak.
Anyway, this comes into play.
So as I try to thrust horizontally, very quickly I run out of suppleness in my wrist.
If I just carry on with my arm now, that happens.
I can't get any further than that, it just goes down into the ground.
If I want it to carry on, I have to drop my shoulder out of position.
I got a little bit more there.
If I want to go further than that though, I have to then drop my whole body.
This is really, really awkward.
So reach is a big, big problem.
And you're just throwing it away.
Another thing is, this is the point of balance,
which is likely to be actually shifted forward a bit,
because the heaviest bit of a spear is the spearhead.
So most of this is sticking out the back.
There's a great big counterweight.
So, if my opponent adopts this stance against me,
so if you come at me, right.
Now, if I knock that, the back end of his spear is acting as a counterweight.
It's making it easy for me to do this.
It's really easy for me to knock his spear out of the way.
So all that counterbalancing spear out the back is to his disadvantage.
And another thing is parrying.
Actually, if you could try, yeah.
So, I'm going to attack him.
Actually, drop the shield for a moment.
Right, so I'm going to attack him with an underarm thrust.
And how can he parry?
How can you block it?
You've got that, yeah, and that's it.
You've got one movement.
It's short, it's weak.
If I try to resist it, I will probably win.
Because I've got a ... much stronger spear position here.
I can go in.
And even if it works, how can he now counter-attack?
His spear point's pointing over there.
It's not threatening me in the slightest where I could come back and attack again.
The underarm has far more options that way.
Plus direction.
I can stab down at him, and that's it.
I've got one attack direction, which is down.
So he's only got one to worry about.
But underarm I can stab in all sorts of different directions.
Including, if I want to, I can go high.
If I want to get up here, I can just do that.
It works absolutely fine.
And that's almost a stronger thrust.
And if I shift my hand back here and brace with my elbow,
I can hold the spear like this all day.
This doesn't take much effort.
And look how much range I've got now against the guy with the overarm spear.
I'm hopelessly out of his range.
So this has lots of advantages.
One being, look how much volume of air I can sweep in front of me,
so I can actually usefully parry.
And this is hugely important if I'm in a group.
So if there's a guy here, and there's a guy here,
I can keep them safe by blocking the spears of several guys in the opposing line
that might threaten them.
So as a team member here, I'm really useful.
Whereas here I can't sweep anything like as big an area.
I can only do so weakly.
Don't forget also that on the back end of a spear you generally had a sharp ferrule.
So there's a sharp point on this end.
Now if I'm keeping it here, it's reasonably safe for me and for the guy behind me.
But if I'm holding it like this, and it's being knocked all over the place,
that spear, you could have someone's eye out with that.
Dangerous.
OK, so this is why I say that most of the time they probably use spears like this,
and I can very easily get him in the foot.
So I can constantly threaten his foot.
Whereas with his, with the overarm, my feet are either out of range, or...
You can see I'm going to win this fight, there's no contest.
When it comes to threatening feet, I can threaten low and go high,
fate one way, I've got so many more options.
And I can parry and counter.
This is just a much, much better way of using a spear.
Now this is not particularly long.
I'm 6'3", so this is maybe a 6 foot 6 stick.
Typically a spear would be more like 8 feet long,
in which case the contrast with this is even greater.
And you can rake spears of the enemy, threatening a huge volume of air in front of you.
Right, so now that's why you would use your underarm.
Now with a shield, I can threaten down there,
in which case if he drops the shield in order to block,
look how much of himself he's exposing.
If I'm a member of a team, I do this.
OK, I don't get him, but one of my teammates now gets him.
He's exposed there.
So perhaps the guy to my right, ... he was standing here,
and he's watching what's happening, and he goes,
Aha! And he gets him.
So when you're fighting in a line with many, many people,
it's almost never the guy opposite you who gets you.
But I can constantly be threatening him and forcing him to defend himself,
move about, and keeping him busy.
Which by so doing I'm keeping the guys next to me safe from him,
because he's busy defending himself from me.
And all the time I'm not actually intent on killing him,
I'm in my peripheral vision, I'm watching the guy two to his right.
Because I reckon that he's waiting for an opening further down the line,
and when he goes for it, I can go, Ha! Like that.
I can maybe threaten him and skewer that guy there.
Right, there was, oh yes, now.
One thing however that we can demonstrate with one-handed spear and shield
is that for dueling it's rubbish.
Let's duel!
Okay, right.
So we come in, and actually, if I go that way, you can see that.
If I go that way you can see it.
I can blind him temporarily.
This fight could go on forever.
And in the Iliad when the heroes duel, they start off with spears,
but they quickly throw them.
Oh, nearly got in there.
They quickly throw them, and they go in with their swords.
The previous evening I had staged an experiment to demonstrate this point.
More science now as I demonstrate how much better sword and shield is when dueling.
I got a glance to the ankle.
He got a sword in the belly.
Not in the belly, in the back.
Slash across the belly there.
Just a leg hit, granted, but we were taking all hits as fight ending.
You're not fertile any longer.
Doesn't get much closer than that, but a miss is a miss.
The point of this is not to show you that I'm great,
but to show you that my weapons give me a massive advantage.
Not a great hit by me, I'll admit.
So, one-on-one, sword and shield beats spear and shield almost every time.
However, when closing with a group of spearmen,
the swordsman will expose his flanks to the spears of the men either side of him.
Alright, I'm going to kill this guy, this mean looking guy in the black hoodie.
Okay, at no time was I ever killed by the guy I was fighting.
Nope, people noticed that. I was always killed by someone else.
My sponsor for this video is ExpressVPN, and I'm rather glad to be sponsored by them again.
I'm also a little bit surprised, but also a little bit impressed given how,
shall we say, candid I was in an earlier video about certain limitations of VPNs.
So, what's that? What is a VPN, and what has it got to do with spears?
Well, stay tuned for what it's got to do with spears.
But as for what it is, well, it's a virtual private network.
You see, you exist with your computer in your home somewhere, or your office, or wherever,
and you send a message via your internet service provider,
via loads of different nodes to the website you're trying to access,
and then the message comes back via loads of different nodes.
But you don't know where those nodes are, you don't know what's going on.
It's the vast interweb out there of interconnected, you know, nodes.
If the message can't get through via that node, it reroutes and goes via another,
and that's what keeps it all working, and it's pretty impressive really.
But some people like to feel a little bit more in control,
and they also don't like the whole of the web knowing where they are in the world.
Well, with ExpressVPN, when you log on you can pretend to be from some country
where actually you're not, and this has various advantages.
But why should you pick ExpressVPN as opposed to some other VPN?
Well, it's fast, as in the name, ExpressVPN.
It's in 94 different countries around the world, which is quite a lot to choose from.
And of course being in lots of places around the world means,
think of those nodes again, you know, that it's easier to make it fast.
They have 24-hour, seven-day-a-week customer support.
And, maybe this is the clincher, if you go to www.expressvpn.com
stroke lindybeige, or click the link in the description, which is much easier.
I don't know why everyone just doesn't do that.
Anyway, then you can get three months for free.
So that's got to be good, so maybe that'll, you know, that'll tip the balance of your decision.
Now, some countries block content on certain websites,
or perhaps they put that content behind a paywall.
So pretending to be from another country is one way to get round these restrictions.
It could be that there's something which is viewable in Germany,
but because of copyright issues you can't view that video, say, outside of Germany.
But if you pretend to be in Germany via a VPN, then you can get to see the content.
And if you have something like Netflix, you know, one of those many available alternatives,
those streaming services, many are available,
then you may feel that after a while you've seen them all,
you've seen everything you're interested in, you thought,
I thought there was a lot more on this streaming service, I'm a bit disappointed.
It's only, I've only been binge-watching for eight months straight,
and now I feel I've seen everything I want to see.
Well, if you pretend to be from another country,
then you get to see what Netflix, or some other available service,
is showing to those people in that country.
And you might see loads more new and interesting stuff.
And that might be what I tend to use it for.
But anyway, what was I supposed to say?
Oh yes, I'm also supposed to say that it works on all sorts of different operating systems.
There's Windows, of course, and Android, and Linux.
And for those of you who love spending money for some reason, Macintoshes.
It works on all those various different routers.
Yes, that's right.
I'm British, so I say router.
It does sound very strange to us when Americans talk of routers,
which conjures in our minds people running away in panic from a battle,
or more commonly a tool for putting gouges in a piece of wood.
You can get modern motorised ones.
I'd like to think, I'd like to think that very few of my fellow countrymen
have been so stupid as to try to connect a router to their computer.
That's not fair.
I can't see one of the many available streaming services.
It's not working.
Yes, you've connected a router to your computer.
He said to connect a router.
Yes, he was American, he meant router.
And you're stupid.
Yes, a bit of a digression there.
Oh yes, and what has ExpressVPN got to do with spears?
It's got an S in it.
And a P and an E, and nothing, sorry.
Right, so here we have two shield walls.
We're going to fight each other.
And one thing that I think people liked about this formation
is that it involved an awful lot of not dying.
Observe how we do not all drop dead immediately,
because our shields and our spears keep us safe.
Now, observe also how this brute with a particularly long spear is menacing me, menacing me.
Whilst I'm defending myself, I'm looking at that guy, because he was open.
So there was my target.
I'm looking at this guy to my right, thinking,
ah, I see an open guy to my right.
But I keep that guy safe by raking it down, raking it down.
Don't you dare.
Don't you dare hit my friend.
Okay, me doing the same with their fellows.
And still, we're all still sort of alive.
Now, let's try to kill each other.
For faces, because that would be dangerous.
Once you're close, the spear is a liability.
Let's demonstrate that.
So we get back to where we were.
If, um, if, let's do your left a bit.
Right, oh no, this guy here has just died.
There is now a gap in our line.
And maybe I was busy over here and didn't notice it.
And maybe one of their guys thinks, oh look, a gap.
Let's charge into that gap.
He charges, ah, that's it, he drew his sword.
And argh, argh, I'm dead.
Argh, argh, argh.
The point is that he has to go to something slower.
If I'm up against this guy, and I managed to get past him,
and I still got a spear, this is a really slow turn,
and he might come.
This length of the spear is a huge liability.
And if this is a formation of troops with other ranks here,
being in a formation with this great big long thing is just an invitation to be killed.
And whilst I'm on that topic, there is an idea commonly cited
that the way people fought was not only with, we'll go to this,
overarm, but was with push of shield.
So they would actually come right up to each other,
and they would chug like this, push, push, push, push.
Okay, stop guys, stop.
I can swap over here so I can talk to the camera.
Can you take my place?
Right, I put it to you, this is an untenable position.
Why doesn't he just spear me in the face?
Why don't I just spear him in the face?
Or the guy behind him in the face?
In fact, why don't I just ditch this entirely,
draw my knife, and kill him, and kill him?
Well, one reason is he might do it faster.
When you're that close to someone,
the first person to go to a shorter weapon wins.
And in the ancient world, people didn't have much neck protection.
So ancient Greeks just pushing against each other like that.
There'd been an awful lot of slit-throats in the first few seconds of the battle,
and people are not suicidal.
When people fight normally,
the normal thing you do is you get to about range,
and then you hit, and then you prod.
So this is how I think most ancient battles happened.
I don't think they just crashed into each other,
though we can demonstrate what happens when we try that.
Most of the time I think they came to measure,
and then there was a prodding match.
We read in history after history that battles lasted hours, sometimes all day.
And you can't have thousands of people fighting constantly all day,
and no one dying, unless they're doing something that's really keeping them safe.
Like not being within a weapon range of the opposition,
and hiding behind big heavy shields,
and being in deep formation so that when you get tired at the front,
you can be replaced by a fresh guy behind you,
and the battle can carry on.
I said we'd talk about bashing through.
So what we can do is form up on the biggest psycho,
that's you by the way, the biggest psycho in the unit,
and he charges in, and they decide to keep him alive.
He gets through, and does he kill them all?
He might have.
And the point is it is possible to smash through a formation
if you form into a wedge, a Schweinberg, a boar's head.
It is possible, but against spears,
the guy at the front has got to be one hell of a psycho.
Because as he goes forwards,
he's got spears coming at him from very, very likely to be skewered.
And don't forget, in a large battle there's a second rank.
So even if he smashes past these guys,
he's got the second rank, and maybe the third, fourth, fifth to worry about.
So most people are not in a hurry to die,
so most people will not go smashing in to a formation.
There is, of course, one big exception to this,
and that is the guys who were using these.
In the height of the Imperial period,
you had professional, heavily armoured legionaries with the pilum.
And they would, we believe,
throw the heavy pilum at maybe this sort of distance, just a few yards.
And then all they've got is a short sword.
And they have to get in.
It's vital, but they're so professional that they're completely convinced
that the guys either side of them are going to follow them in.
Because if one goes in on his own, he's dead.
But if they all throw their pilum at close range,
and then immediately charge to a short sword, gladius range,
then maybe you can start stabbing, stabbing, stabbing,
destroying the enemy, and winning the day.
So if you've got a highly trained professional army of guys
who absolutely have confidence in the guys next to them, that can work.
But in the later Roman period they stopped doing that,
and they also had less professional armies.
And I do not think that these two things are coincidental.
Super slowly, guys. No, nothing above the chest for hits, okay?
And we're just prodding, okay? We're just prodding.
This is just an experiment. We're all playing nicely.
When I was teaching, I got people to first try without shields or masks.
Later we tried with shields, although we didn't have quite enough for everybody.
Listen to the clacks of the spears as well as the thuds against shields.
The spears are doing a lot of the defending.
After a few goes we were able to ramp up the aggression a bit,
and people started to show some initiative.
This was an exercise in threatening the front foot of your opponent.
The main point I wanted to get across was to not plant all your weight on your front foot,
because you have to keep it mobile.
Actually parries with your spear will usually keep your foot safe.
And if someone does keep thrusting at your foot,
you can try stamping on his spear to break it.
But that wasn't an option for us.
So now everyone wearing masks.
People were allowed to feint low and go high for the face,
or feint high and go for the foot.
I don't think anyone got hit in the foot.
The foot is a small mobile target down on the ground,
and hard to reach without exposing yourself.
Not many face hits either, mind.
Thighs, torsos and shoulders tend to make the best targets.
Now I want to draw your attention to an absolute cracker of a hit.
Note that this chap has fallen back a bit behind the rest of his line,
so he's not giving much cover to his neighbour here.
This chap spots the opportunity and with one accurate jab, bam, dead centre of head.
Let's see it again.
Oh, marvellous.
Now one of the glories of a centre grip shield
is that you can hold it way out in front of you
and defend a very large volume of space in front of you.
But there is a drawback, which is that if I whack the outside of it,
it opens it up for another guy to take advantage.
So that's another thing you can do.
But I do not believe people would ever really smash into opposing shields with much force,
which is something that reenactors try because they've got blunt, safe things.
But of course if this is a sharp spear and that's a wooden shield,
that's a really great way to get your spear stuck.
So I think most of the time they were actually just prodding,
not hard enough to get their spear stuck.
They're just constantly threatening because they wouldn't want that to happen.
And that's one of the problems with another, thank you gentlemen,
with another conjectured way of fighting.
Because with this overarm technique what you can do
is throw it forwards and then catch the end like that.
Of course as soon as you do catch the end it's going to fall down
unless you're incredibly strong.
Some, for instance the lizard killers that the ancient Greeks had,
they do have a couple of bridges that you might be able to catch reasonably easily.
Otherwise the normal spear just has a spike on the end which is quite smooth.
So there's no physical evidence that they ever did that.
But there is a possibility you could do that sort of spearman and catcher technique.
We cannot experiment with this safely however,
because there's just no way with a full-weight stick you can safely,
even if they've got fencing masks on,
I would not want people throwing these full speed, full weight straight into people's faces.
So we cannot try that one out.
Personally I think that someone probably did try that.
They saw an opportunity.
If they were perhaps defending a wall and they felt safe for a moment,
and they saw there was someone who was just out of reach,
but maybe if they did that they could get him, then maybe they did it.
But I can't myself believe that was ever the main way of using spears.
As soon as you've recaptured the spear,
you're so weak and vulnerable having to get it back.
On the other hand, with an underarm technique,
I can very quickly retreat to half distance.
So if someone is looking as though he might break through the line through a gap here, let's say,
I could perhaps go to half distance,
and I can threaten low and high with this very effectively.
Incidentally, if you've got it overarmed,
the threat from low and high is much weaker and slower, and just rubbish.
Now then, we've got three against three here.
I would say that with three people it's worth forming a shield wall.
With two though, with two I'd say it's time to go to some other weapon like your sword.
With unequal numbers, one side can have a longer line,
and of course threaten the flanks of the other.
And what tended to happen was that people would duck behind their shields.
So I want to keep my shield to my left, he wants to keep his shield to the left,
and so ancient armies tended to wheel about a bit in this direction,
because no one wanted to expose themselves.
So that's a common thing that's written about in the sources,
where large formations of troops tended to wheel around like that,
with each guy trying to stay behind his shield safely.
In aid of science, I experimented by pitting one-handed against two-handed spears.
The one-handed should have won,
and probably would have in a world that had missile weapons in it.
But these haemophiters were all fixated on the person in front,
and the team with the shields did not take full advantage
of how vulnerable the shieldless fighters are from their sides.
We tried twice, and the two-handed team won both times,
but had a much harder time of it the second time,
after I'd given the shieldies a bit of a talking-to.
You have to attain the skill of attacking using your peripheral vision.
Okay, I'm deaf on this ear now.
