The Buckeye Institute's Rea Hederman Jr. has released a report titled "Net Zero Climate Control Policies Will Fail the Farm," detailing the negative impact such policies will have on American agriculture and food prices. Hederman emphasizes that adherence to the Paris Climate Accords and the adoption of ESG mandates will lead to increased operating costs for farmers, estimated at an additional $65,000 per farm annually, and a corresponding rise in annual grocery bills for families by approximately $1,300. Citing real-world examples such as Sri Lanka, where similar policies resulted in doubled food prices and widespread shortages, the report warns of similar consequences in the U.S. The Buckeye Institute recommends withdrawing from the Paris Climate Accords, revoking funding and tax credits related to net zero policies, building anti-ESG coalitions, and promoting education over government mandates for sustainable farming. Hederman describes these policies as an economic war on farmers and urges the adoption of market-driven solutions over top-down governmental control.
@EconomicWarRoom
[Music]
Ray hman Jr is executive director of the
economics Research Center and vice
president of policy at the Buckeye
Institute in this role heerman over SE
Buckey's research and policy output
prior to joining Buckeye he was director
and founding member of the center for
data analysis CDA at the Heritage
Foundation where he served as the
organization's top number cruncher under
his leadership the CDA provided
state-of-the-art economic modeling
database products and original studies
now there's a new report out from
Buckeye it is net zero climate control
policies will fail the farm so we're so
glad to have Ray in the economic War
Room welcome sir thank you for having me
Kevin you know you've got a great report
it encapsulates a lot of things that we
talk about here in the economic War Room
higher food prices World economic Forum
control you know the whole eat less meat
and more bugs and then the farmers
revolting in Europe so it's a powerful
study um I got a preview of this report
at a recent conference we want to take a
bad good beautiful approach so we talk
about the problem then just like your
report you talk about some solutions and
then we'd love to talk about the be
beautiful future that we can have
together if we follow the good
recommendations and restore Liberty to
America so let's start with a problem
what caused Buckeye Institute to pick up
uh this paper on Net Zero climate
control and the farm well you know
everybody pictures Ohio is a
manufacturing state but like many states
we have a robust agricultural sector and
we've looked at the policies that have
come down from the Biden Administration
and we realize this is going to impact a
lot of our fellow Ohioans and fellow
Americans and places you don't expect
and that's at the family dinner table
quite simply day one his first day of
office President Biden rejoined the
Paris climate Accords which forced his
administration to start proposing a
swath of new regulations that would
hammer the agricultural sector by making
every aspect of farming more expensive
and that's because Farmers rely on cheap
affordable Energy natural gas from
everything from powering their tractors
to making fertilizer and when you make
all farm costs more expensive well that
means Americans are going to be paying
more for food at their table if they can
get the food because a lot of farmers if
you make it too expensive they just go
out of business they don't want to
continue so I've got here A A Farm
operating expenses under ESG we talk
about ESG all the time it stands for
environment social governance but it
really is a Progressive grab bag of
things ideas that they've had that they
want to force on the American people
that the market wouldn't otherwise
accept uh can you quantify you're a data
guy quantify for us the difference in
operating cost from what they are today
to what they will be under ESG yeah what
the top line is the average Farm 6 750
acres of corn farm will be paying about
over a third more an operating cost each
year because they're being forced to ABY
by these policies that's
$65,000 to farms and the cost increased
costs come from the fact that fertilizer
is going to be costing about 29% more uh
because a lot of that will be banned
from the fact that natural gas can no
longer be used to reduce fertilizer we
know for example that you know Farmers
have to use propane you know to dry out
grain crops so they can get to the table
so the farming industry you know not
everybody can Farm you know it's a very
technical it's very complicated and
unfortunately a lot of the methods that
modern farmers use to produce the crops
that we enjoy are going to be either
more expensive if not outright banned
under a lot of these regulations that
are going to happen under ESG and Net
Zero policies you know I I've seen the
studies uh free market capitalism
brought down poverty to the lowest level
that's ever been in history well it uses
energy to accomplish that and
essentially these ESG policies are
eliminating energy you know so you can't
make fertilizer out out of solar cells
so I look here you've got a chart it
says the operating cost and you
mentioned it
$192,000 are the current cost for the
average Farm versus
$257,000 that could put some Farmers out
of business yeah no absolutely I mean
the concern has to be if you're the
typical American Family Farm you know
you think back you know to Farm a you
know you had country singers talking
about defending the American way of life
these are the Farms that are going to be
really pressured because they're going
to have their everyday cost of Simply
farming going up and then we also have
indirect costs that the farmer is going
to have an harder time having to fill
out all these forms and regulations and
if you're a family farmer you know you
know how to dry your crops you know how
to milk your cows filling out you know
the ESG compliance forms well that's
something you may have to hire another
accountant so you're going to lose time
being able to spend with your wife and
children so you know the consequence
that we see is not only is food going to
cost more for American families but
you're going to see a lot of these
Family Farms sell out give up their way
of life sell out to big companies and
simply go out of business so what will
the cost be in grocery bills uh you've
Quantified that as well yes so we looked
at we took the Staples of how much do
the American Family spend and we found
that it's going to cost about $1,300
annually or 15% more each year and Kevin
families have been shocked at how much
grocery prices have gone up in just the
last couple of years you know you're
sitting there saying you know milk has
gone up eggs have gone up the price that
we find in this report is on top of the
inflation that's going up and because we
know that certain farming practices are
more under the gun Farm prices are going
to go up differently for beef for
example which will almost double per
pound you know the price of butter is
going to go up by about
25% because we know that those farming
practices are going to be more adversely
affected Under The Net Zero regulations
now it's an incredibly thorough report
you've got a list of price increases of
us groceries American cheese up 78%
sugar up 43% pork up 28% spaghetti 133%
chicken
39% uh bread 7% butter 24% I mean the
this kind of price increase on top of
what we've already had to go through uh
from the excessive inflation that's been
created that that's devastating to an
American Family absolutely and so what
we've seen is like what is this going to
take the place of and so we found is
that families are going to have to give
up uh that's basically equivalent of a
mortgage pavement that's equivalent to a
Year's worth of gasoline so families
going to have to sit and make hard
choices of how they're not going to be
spending their money maybe they can't
take a vacation maybe they can't save
more for retirement maybe their kids
have to go another year without new
clothes these are the type of choices
that are being faced every day by
American consumers because the policies
are coming out of Washington fewer Farms
higher food prices and Kevin quite
frankly it wouldn't surprise us that
some Farm crops are simply unavailable
because farmers can no longer produce
some at the prices people can pay yeah
there's no question about that and this
isn't conjecture you've you talk about
and when we come back from the break I
want you to talk about Sri Lanka because
they've actually experiences so this
isn't just well we're projecting this
might happen or whatever we've seen a
realworld example around the world uh
where they've adopted all the same
policies we're adopting and the net
impact on food prices and Farmers so
when we come back from the break tell us
about Sri
Lanka oh hi I'm Kevin S and I'm here to
tell you about coffee well not really
but I'm going to use coffee to
illustrate my point here we have several
different coffees each with its own
unique characteristics first we out
instant coffee this coffee pretends to
be coffee but it's not really coffee at
all it's a fraud plus it tastes terrible
I'm out next we have W coffee their
coffee actually tastes pretty good until
you find out that when you drink it you
have to admit that you've oppressed
other coffees in the past Insanity I
might next we have bigte coffee now
these guys used to encourage folks to
share with others what they thought
about their coffee but now if you say
you don't like big Tech coffee they'll
take away your coffee
pot I'm out this brings us to Patriot
mobile coffee right this is one big cup
of Truth and freedom there's no fraud
here Patriot mobile is America's real
Christian conservative wireless provider
Patriot mobile gives back millions of
dollars every year to organizations that
are on the front lines fighting for our
freedoms patr mobile offers the best
Nationwide 4G and 5G coverage on the
same network as the other major carriers
so you'll get the same great coverage
along with 100% us-based customer
support while knowing you are supporting
a company that shares your conservative
values switch to patriotmobile today by
visiting patriotmobile tocom or call 972
Patriot in uncertain times finding
stability in the economy can feel
challenging but what if you could
navigate economic volatility while
honoring your biblical values at Timothy
plan they believe believe this balance
is possible Timothy plan filters its
volatility weighted ETFs and family of
mutual funds through a Biblical pro-life
and Pro-Am lens so you can see
competitive returns and moral
responsibility helping you to weather
the economic storms with Timothy plan
align your Investments with your values
while adapting to our everchanging
culture since 1994 Timothy plan has been
recognized leader in biblically
responsible investing Timothy plan your
bridge between faith finan in the future
visit Timothy plan.com or call 1 1800
Tim plan or 1800
[Music]
846-7560 climate control policies will
fail the farm he just scared me silly
because he showed how much prices are
going to go up Farmers may be going out
of business that consumers uh strapped
even further with with bad food
inflation and it's not conjecture this
is actually happened somewhere in the
world can you tell us about that yeah so
a few years ago Sri Lanka said we're
going to abide by these Net Zero
policies and so they outlawed nitrogen
fertilizer well where does nitrogen
fertilizer come from and most
Manufacturing countries it comes from
natural gas the hydrogen from nital gas
is used to produce the fertilizer so
when uh Sri Lanka got rid of nitrogen
fertilizer the crop yields plummeted and
so as a consequence we have seen Sri
Lankan food prices double we've seen
shortages of food in Sri Lanka and we've
seen the number of people families in
Sri Lanka simply go hungry because
there's not enough food going up you
know farmers use fertilizer to increase
crop yield and more abundant food means
people aren't going hungry and so when
you're outlawing far efficient farming
practices that we've seen the
consequence is there less food available
and Kevin one other note I mean it's not
just Sri Lanka we can look at we can
look at Europe Europe has enacted
similar of these policies on Net Zero
they've closed about 70% of n nitrogen
fertilizer factories and has a
consequence farming practices have gone
up about 50% and food prices gone up 42%
so I think our report is taking a look
at what could happen in America given
the examples we see in the rest of the
world and you see it very dramatically
you've got some great charts in the
report you see in Sri Lanka there you
know up to 2022 prices are very stable
and then boom they adopt these policies
and they ramp up very quickly same thing
with Europe and you see in electricity
prices which are essential you have to
have electricity uh the the carbon price
of of uh the input and output prices so
when they put the inputs and the outputs
both of them going in tandem I mean
they're highly correlated there's
there's no question that this is the
cause of this no absolutely not and so
you take a look again how many
fertilizer plants have closed in Europe
and that's one of the reasons farmers in
Europe are so upset because the prices
have gotten so high they don't have
access to the fertilizer they can't
produce the crops they need to sustain a
living the other thing that we're seeing
in Europe right now quite frankly is
imminent domain where government saying
to make sure that we're hitting our
Target emissions under Net Zero in the
Paris climate Accords which the Biden
administration had the United States
rejoin you have governments in Europe
saying we're going to take over Family
Farms we're going to euthanize Dairy
herds to reduce methane emissions and
these are the type of policies it takes
to make the green New Deal agenda that
we're seeing pregated in DC today yeah
my father's uh aunt and uncle had a
dairy farm in Oklahoma and I couldn't
imagine the government coming in and
we're going to kill a bunch of your cows
we're just going to wipe them out it
would have destroyed their ability to
farm it would have uh all the economics
would have changed dramatically it would
have reduced this supply of milk but
that's you know the cynic in me says
that's actually some of the purpose so
that they can drive everybody to big
food and no local farming well that's
absolutely you know a a a point that we
make in this paper right you know the
fact is that the Netherlands has said
we're going to spend a billion dollars
taking over Farms dairy farms uh we have
stories coming out of Ireland that they
were going to euthanize kill over a
million cows to hit that and we've seen
a lot of outcry I mean you think about
Ireland you know known for beer and Cary
bow butter and Irish cheese you know and
all of a sudden they're saying well
we're going to get rid of one of our
main Staples of Agriculture that just
shows a lot of really the type of
sacrifice say people must make to hit
these mandated targets coming from
government and it's just shocking I
think when people think about how their
lifesty is going to change fewer Family
Farms paying more at the food table and
having to probably switch and substitute
away from Goods like beef you know to
Alternatives and that's what we've
unfortunately seen in a lot of other
countries that people simply don't have
access to the food they desire no and
that's no question and it's coming from
The Nanny State top down uh the aidea
that I know better than you I mean this
is the same government that told us salt
was bad then salt was good then coffee
was bad then coffee was good hey let the
free market make the choices that's what
reduced poverty uh but this top- down
mandated government control is going to
create poverty and it's going to destroy
our diets and so I love the report that
you go in and quantify for example the
carbon price of fertilizer and grain
drying explain how that impacts what we
eat yeah sure so F fertilizer is one of
the of the main inputs that farmers use
nitrogen fertilizer is used mostly for
corn the predominant food staple here in
the United States and so when you're
sitting there and you're saying natural
gas we're not going to drill as much
we're going to regulate how much natural
gas that can be produced we're even
going to shut down some factories the
consequence is fertilizer costs jump
dramatically as I said you know we
estimate fertilizer going up 29% other
estimates including the world economic
Forum said fertilizer prices are going
to increase by over quarter due to Net
Zero policies and again we've seen so
many fertilizer plants shut down in
Europe that Europe is now investing in
the United States bringing fertilizer
back then now they're putting tariffs on
it that has an huge impact on how a
farmer can produces crops and how many
crops he can raise per acre the other
aspect again is grain drying you know
because you need your grains dried so
they can be easily transported or
converted to feed stock propane is the
primary way that farmers are used to dry
their crops and again you're putting
higher prices higher cost on fossil
fuels that mean grain drying is
increasing dramatically that all adds up
to
$65,000 more per Farm uh operating costs
again up over a third and farmers are
going to pass on so much of that cost to
the families to the tables because you
know they can't simply eat this cost
themselves we know from economics right
that you know when you're driving on up
inputs on a producer that cost will get
passed on to the end consumer and that
means American families pay more no
question and you've got diesel price
increases uh carbon price increases all
these things impact Farmers but this
really dumb part about this and I I use
that word uh not lightly it absolutely
fits here is that we have been reducing
our carbon emissions uh in the United
States and yet now we're going to starve
the farmers and starve the people from
the feed stocks that they need and and
everything that they need and we're
going to be removing food from the
supply when we're already meeting the
climate initiative guidelines that
that's absolutely right Kevin we've seen
the United States because we've been
able to switch to Natural Gas a cleaner
fuel source we've been able to sit there
and reduce our carbon gases we've been
emitted while maintaining a decently
strong economy with a way of life and
the problem is when the government's
starts interfering with markets like
that that has a lot of negative
Downstream consequences for American
people yeah well we're going to need to
take another break when we come back
we'll finish wrap up on this and then
we'll talk about what we ought to do
about it because you've got some
incredible Solutions in the net zero uh
climate report we'll come back we'll
talk
Solutions here's a $10 bill it's got the
picture of Alexander Hamilton on the
front of it you know it's kind of sad
when I was 10 years old I everything
that I could buy for a dollar now costs
it's about $10 that's the cost of
inflation it's just paper it's not
backed by anything you can't exchange it
for gold and silver you used to but you
can't do that anymore and that's
unfortunate you know Pirates wouldn't
accept this Pirates they wanted gold and
silver Patriots the founders of this
nation also wanted gold and silver coin
in fact they put a provision in the
Constitution 17 words that said States
could only make gold and silver coins
tender within the states that's why I
wrote this new book pirate money cing
the founders hidden plan for economic
Justice and defeating the great reset it
will explain exactly the history of
money and exactly why gold and silver
coins can be made Modern with new
technology and a useful monetary system
piraty
book.com we've been talking with Ray
from the Buckeye Institute about the
fact that farmers costs will go up 32%
they've got all the data they support it
in their in their new paper that's out
uh if we adopt all of these new rules
that the Biden Administration is pushing
and the family's grocery bills will go
up
$1,300 a year on top of all the other
inflation that we're already seeing so
here's my question do we need these
Draconian climate policies is that what
we have to do to save the planet or
maybe this is just bureaucracy run a
muck no I think it's bureaucracy money
run a muck because if you take a look at
our emissions they are going down while
the economy is growing and so our
current solution is working we're seeing
people voluntarily making choices that
they want to do to protect the
environment you know and Farmers
consider themselves a lot of time
stewards of the earth so they want to
adopt practices that takes care of the
land because if they make their land
less productive they harm their land
that means they're going to produce
fewer uh crops the following year and
they're going to be hurting their own
income so farmers have every incentive
to take care of the soil to take care of
the water and make sure that we have
good air yeah and there's no question
and I think that the climate science is
not settled despite what we've been told
you know and there's a lot of flaws in
the data for example the heat island
effect and so many other things that are
we warming are we not warming but
they're just cramming it down our
throats even when the data doesn't seem
to support it but one thing that I think
is settled if you make it harder for
Farmers to produce food prices will go
up if you take away fertilizer you'll
have lower yields in your crops those
things just seem obvious and true yes
absolutely and Kevin those are the
direct costs and I know you've done a
great job pointing out the harms of the
ESG movement and I think one of the
things we talk about in the report is
how ESG is impacting the way farmers can
get access to bank loans get access to
credit that's kind of the indirect cor
approach because now farmers are having
to report what their emission standards
are right and so when farmers are
getting a bad ESG score under some of
these rules that means they're not going
to be able to replace farm equipment
that means they're not going to have
access to to seeds that's one of the
reasons you'll see in the report beef
prices cost more than other types of
grain crops because these lower ESG
scores are going to impact the farmers's
ability to do their job to be able to
harvest to be able to take care of their
animals and that I think is a pernicious
Innovation we've seen coming out of
government that's been affecting
everything from retirement portfolios to
investment Decisions by state
politicians and now we're seeing it's
going to impact how we score farmers and
how they're doing you could actually
describe this as an economic War by
government and Rural governments on the
farmer and
Farms absolutely I mean in American
agriculture is still an important part
of the American economy we export
hundreds of billions of dollars of farm
Goods around the world and I think you
know higher prices here in the United
States is alarming but just as alarming
as what I think is going to happen to
countries that don't have as a strong as
a rich agricultureal sector are we going
to see more countries like Sri Lanka
that are going to be struggle to feed
their family because they're not going
to be able to have the food much less be
able to pay for it yeah and the irony of
all this is that will worse for the
environment people may uh we need to
have more children we need to burn coal
we need to do all sorts of things to
respond so the the environmental effect
is likely to be negative uh at the same
time that we hurt people so there's
seven different uh recommendations that
I pulled one of them is withdraw from
the Paris climate Accords I think that's
pretty obvious uh two revoke as much of
the Ira's Net Zero funding and tax
credits as possible explain that one
sure you know when uh the B
Administration passed you know their
so-called a poorly named inflation red
reduction act they knew that this is
going to have a big impact on Farmers so
they threw $43 billion do of subsidies
into the Department of Agriculture to
try to entice Farmers you know to be
able to adopt these policies you know I
think a lot about you you know Ronald
Reagan you know when government sees
that great quote you know when
government sees something you know taxes
if it doesn't work regulate it and then
if you kill it then subsidize it that's
a lot of what's going on right now is
you're jacking up prices on agriculture
so you're trying to throw government
subsidies we know the end result is
higher inflation again higher prices on
American families higher taxes to pay
for it we should get rid of those
subsidies we don't need to move forward
in that direction let the market work
save taxpayers money and have the
federal government stop
spending yeah no and what you're talking
about is if we don't do that we'll have
socialized Farms big farm big
corporations and the government owners
everything okay number three this is
obvious Congress must build bipartisan
anti-g Coalition I believe in that uh
then you said Pro number four proactive
and targeted ESG bans we're totally in
agreement with that uh number five pass
laws preventing ideological ESG
investment and lending we've talked
about that a little bit number six
corporate and shareholder response to
ESG metrics explain this one yeah so you
know what we're looking at right now is
that there's a great quote that came out
that basically said cows are the new
coal from an ESG fund manager right and
so basically saying we're going to look
in a valuate cows and score them has
been poorly as we did Cole a few years
ago so there's a lot of concern I think
at the lens that a lot of these
companies are looking at where they're
tipping the scale against certain types
of farming prices and really endangering
what I think is a staple of the American
economy and the food that we eat number
seven promote good affordable farming
practic at the local level describe that
one yeah well you know Farmers right now
are always willing to be Innovative and
the crops that they grow and so we want
to make sure is that there's incentives
in place that farmers know for example
if they want to go to noil for example a
slightly more organic less impact on
their land they know how to do that
education is a better policy than
Governor mandates and we believe that
Farms are kind of the heartland of
communities and so farming practices
that work best in Ohio may not work as
well in Southwest Texas and so we need
to make sure that standards are adopted
State byst State Community instead of
this National one-size fits-all where
everybody is simply not an Iowa or
Nebraska corn farm yeah if you show good
practices and it will lower the cost of
farming increase the yield it will lower
prices to Consumers education is the
answer and free market choice is the
answer so I love the conclusion of your
report it's it says uh government
climate control policies wiconsin the
Paris climate Accords the inflation
reduction act and ESG guided mandates
carry a hefty price tag we just need to
educate Americans and you've done that
in this fabulous report so I love what
you're doing here congratulations to the
Buckeye Institute for bringing this out
um I'm so grateful where can people
learn more about the Buckeye Institute
you need to come to our website Buckey
institute.org named after the Ohio State
Buckey proud Representatives here in
Columbus Ohio this a great organization
it's something you ought to be
supporting they're bringing real
information thank you Ray for being here
we're going to summarize all this in our
free economic battle plan you can get
your copy at economic warroom.com
remember what we see as a Marketplace
our enemies view as a battle space this
is Kevin Freeman from the economic war
[Music]
room