The Dumbest Ways NFL Teams Blew Games They Should Have Won
2 Video Views·Oct 15, 2026
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis video examines some of the most catastrophic coaching and player mistakes in NFL history, highlighting games that were lost due to poor decision-making, lack of discipline, or inexplicable play-calling. From premature celebrations to ignoring the clock, these errors often led to immediate firings or permanent changes in how the game is played.
Dumbest call I've ever seen.
And I'm sorry, but I can't believe the call.
That cost us that game, and I put that fully on me.
They don't have a timeout. What are they doing?
These are the dumbest ways NFL teams blew games they should have won.
One coach makes this list three times.
Two calls got coordinators fired the next morning,
and one is the reason the kneel-down became standard.
It starts in November 1978.
Giants up five, 31 seconds left, Eagles out of timeouts.
Fall on the ball, and it's over.
Instead, Giants coordinator Bob Gibson calls a run.
Freeze it.
We'll finish this one at number one.
So how do teams still blow games like this?
Number 10, the Bears lead Washington by a field goal,
and there's one play left, a Hail Mary.
Look at Bears cornerback Tyreek Stevenson at the snap.
He is not watching the ball.
He's facing the stands, waving at Washington's fans.
Jaden Daniels heaves it.
Noah Brown pulls it down in the end zone.
A 52-yard touchdown.
Bears coach Matt Eberflus said afterward they'd practiced
that play a hundred times.
Stevenson's apology on X was short, and the last line says it all.
Remember Washington.
It comes back.
Number nine is a decision.
January 2022.
The Bills lead Kansas City by three with 13 seconds left.
The Bills boot it deep, not squib it.
Patrick Mahomes needs two plays, that's all.
Harrison Butker kicks the tying field goal and in overtime,
Josh Allen never touches the ball.
Buffalo's quarterback watches the whole thing from the sideline.
We can just execute better and that starts with me
and goes all the way down.
Two months later, the owners voted to rewrite playoff overtime
so both teams get the ball.
Now pause it and call this one yourself.
October 2026, London.
Jake Elliott's field goal puts the Eagles up
by a point with eight seconds left.
Nick Sirianni jumps and pumps his fist.
A touchback is the safe play.
Instead, they kick it into play.
Amir Abdullah returns it 53 yards.
Cam Little hits from 57 to win it.
At the end of the day, I didn't make the right decision,
and it cost us the game.
Two coaches, two kickoffs, and both blame themselves.
That same Sunday, in another stadium,
another coach was about to top it.
He's coming up.
Number eight, the Browns lead the Chiefs by two
with four seconds left.
Cleveland's Dwayne Rudd wraps up quarterback Trent Green.
The clock reads triple zeros.
You'd probably celebrate, too.
Rudd rips off his helmet and throws it.
He thinks he's won,
except Green had flipped the ball to lineman John Tate,
who was running downfield.
The play was still alive, and a helmet toss is a penalty,
and a game can't end on a defensive penalty.
So Kansas City gets one more untimed play.
Morton Anderson kicks the field goal.
Chiefs 40, Browns 39.
And Dwayne Rudd goes down as making one
of the biggest mistakes in Cleveland Browns history.
Nobody outsmarted him. He celebrated a win that hadn't happened yet.
Number seven, Thanksgiving Day.
Snow and sleet at Texas Stadium. Dallas leads Miami by a point
with 15 seconds left. Pete Stoyanovich lines up for a field goal.
Jimmy Jones blocks it. The ball
comes to rest on the turf.
Dallas has won, unless a cowboy touches that ball. Take a guess what
happens next. Most of the Cowboys are celebrating.
Leon Lett is running at it. He slides into it in
the snow, and he touches it. Now it's a live ball.
Miami takes over at the one-yard line.
Stoyanovich kicks a 19-yarder to win it.
Here's the rule. Don't touch it. Lett looked back on it
years later. Dallas won the Super Bowl that season anyway.
He got off easy. Number six. The 2020 Jets
are 0-11. They haven't won a game all year.
Now they're seconds from their first. Think about what
that team wants most in the world. One win.
Third down. Jets defensive coordinator Greg Williams
calls an all-out blitz. Cover zero. Man coverage everywhere.
Nobody deep to help. That leaves rookie
cornerback Lamar Jackson alone on receiver Henry Ruggs.
One rookie. One receiver. Nobody behind him.
Derek Carr lets it fly. A 46-yard touchdown with five seconds left.
And it's not like cover zero.
there's a time and a place for cover zero.
That thing sure ain't it. Cover zero means no safety,
no net, no plan B. Even safety Marcus May said afterward they needed
to be in a better call at
that spot. Williams was fired the next morning.
Remember that. It's happened before. Number five,
a Saturday night playoff game in Cincinnati.
Linebacker Vontez Burfict just picked off
Landry Jones and Cincinnati leads the Steelers by one with the ball.
This game is won. Then
Jeremy Hill fumbles, late in the fourth quarter.
Pittsburgh gets the ball and Ben Roethlisberger
returns on an injured shoulder.
All Cincinnati needs is one more stop. A fumble you can live
with. What comes next, you can't. Count the flags with me.
Burfect hits Antonio Brown in the head.
Flag, 15 yards. Brown is concussed and the game stops
while he's treated. Then the Bengals' Adam
Pac-Man Jones goes after Steelers assistant Joey Porter.
Another 15. And now if this is just a
penalty against Cincinnati. They're just going
to make this a chip shot field goal and lose their
season over it. Pittsburgh went from near midfield
to field goal range on penalties alone. Chris
Boswell kicks the winner with 14 seconds left.
Number four isn't one game. It's one man, three
times. Dan Quinn. First time, 2015, his rookie year in Atlanta.
The Falcons are down four, fourth and
goal from the one. Quinn kicks the field goal.
His plan is a stop, then the ball back, then another
kick. The ball never comes back. They lose by a point.
Second time, Super Bowl 51. The famous
number is 28 to 3. But the real mistake comes later.
Up eight, in field goal range, a kick
makes it a two-score game.
Instead, a sack, a holding penalty, a punt. New England wins in
overtime. Third time, same Sunday as London, different stadium.
Washington and the Giants
are tied in overtime. Washington is in field goal range,
12 seconds left, no timeouts. Spike the
ball and the kicker gets his shot. Instead, it's a pass play.
Daniel scrambles. They can't get the
spike off in time. The clock hits zero, a tie.
Quinn rips off his headset and slams it down.
And that is my responsibility. Nobody else.
Do the math. The one time he needed to go for it,
he kicked. The two times he needed the kick, he never got it.
Washington's own co-owner put it
plainly, on X. Told you Washington would be back.
Number three, the Raiders tie it at 24 with 32
seconds left. By the last play of regulation, overtime looks certain.
Unless somebody gets
creative. Rhamondre Stevenson takes a handoff and runs.
He pitches to Jacoby Myers. Pause
it right there. What's the smartest thing Myers can do?
Nothing. Fall down. That's the
whole job. Instead, Myers throws
a lateral backward across the field. Chandler Jones,
a former Patriot, picks it off.
He stiff-arms Mac Jones to the turf and goes 48 yards for
the touchdown.
It's picked off!
Once you give it to me, I'm smart enough to know the score was tied,
so I just got to be smarter with it.
Afterward, Mac Jones took the blame.
He said he had to tackle the guy, and they play for overtime.
Fair.
But the fix was even simpler.
All Myers had to do was fall down.
Number two, the Super Bowl.
Jermaine Kearse makes a juggling catch,
and Marshawn Lynch runs it to the one.
New England doesn't even call a timeout.
Seattle lets the clock bleed down.
Second and goal, 26 seconds left, a timeout in its pocket,
and standing in the backfield is Lynch.
You're Pete Carroll.
What's your call?
Here's what Seattle calls a pass, a slant.
Undrafted rookie Malcolm Butler jumps the route
and intercepts it at the goal line.
Game over.
You've got Marshawn Lynch in the backfield.
You've got a guy that's been borderline unstoppable
in this part of the field.
Some smart people defended the logic.
With one timeout, a pass wastes a down
without burning your last one.
Here's where I land.
You have Marshawn Lynch and one yard to go.
You hand him the ball.
Days later, Carroll gave it a name.
Notice the word he used, result.
It was the worst result of a call ever.
Quick hits.
The Packers are up late in the NFC title game.
Seattle tries an onside kick, and Brandon Bostick,
a blocker, tries to catch it.
And Bostick couldn't.
Matthews could.
Dallas runs a quarterback draw with no timeouts,
and the clock dies at the spot.
This is going to work out.
The Giants, tied late, punt to Deshaun Jackson,
and he takes it back as the clock runs out.
Bad, but none of them is number one.
Number one.
Back to Giants Stadium and the play we froze.
The Giants have already fallen
on the ball once, now it's third and two,
and Gibson, up in the press box, sends in the same run call.
Down on the field, the players know it's wrong.
they beg quarterback Joe Pisarcik to change the play.
He won't.
Gibson had reprimanded him for changing a call the week before,
so he runs it.
Listen to the Eagles' radio call.
Pisarcik can just fall on the football,
and there is nothing the Eagles can do.
And Pisarcik fumbles the football.
The snap came early, and the ball
bounced off Larry Zonka's hip.
Herman Edwards, an undrafted cornerback, went 26 yards.
Eagles quarterback Ron Jaworski summed it up.
Gibson was fired the next morning.
He never worked in football again.
He moved to Florida and ran a bait shop.
Thirty years later, ESPN finally got him on the phone.
Here's why it matters.
Almost at once, teams started putting a man deep behind
the quarterback on kneel downs to guard against exactly this.
That's victory formation.
That fumble made the kneel standard.
And almost every close game you've watched since ends
with the quarterback on one knee.
Fired the next morning.
Remember number six?
Greg Williams knows the feeling.
Decades apart, the same ending. None of these was bad luck.
Everyone was a choice in a game that was theirs to win.
Gibson's mistake made the kneel-down
standard. It fixed the play.
It never fixed the people making the call. Which one is the dumbest?
What did we miss? Tell us in the comments.

