The Dirty Tricks Agents Are Using To Get Your Medicare Plans
2 Video Views·Dec 19, 2024
"Medicare is confusing enough. If agents, whose responsibility is to help guide people to the best plan for them, are marketing with false promises, hounding seniors with phone calls and door knocking, and pushing inappropriate plans for commissions, that's a problem.
In this video, I go over the Dirty Tricks agents are using to convince people to call them for their Medicare help. "
This video is dedicated to my partner and good friend Philip Pei who last evening I learned
passed away while on a fishing trip. He exemplified everything good in this video
and he fought against everything bad. I love you brother, you are sorely missed.
Feds seized more than a million dollars from a company they say ordered and shipped test
kits to people who never ordered them billing medicare costing taxpayers thousands. It's a
tough pill to swallow. More than 100 million bucks spent for senior citizens medicare bills
is gone. Humana settled a 90 million dollar lawsuit over alleged medicare fraud. NBC News
investigation into medicare advantage those medicare approved plans offered by private
companies. Millions use them but we found they routinely reject claims for necessary care.
Hospitals are dumping medicare advantage plans. If you have a medicare advantage plan
and you have to go to the hospital you might want to call the hospital first and see if they will
accept money from your insurance company. The american health care system is shattered and
fragmented in a way that harms you the patients more than anyone else and the hope was that
medicare the government program for seniors would be less complicated, less corruptible,
less expensive and less infuriating for seniors when dealing with their health care coverage into
retirement. Unfortunately and many of you can attest it is not less complicated and the medicare
maze causes fear and anxiety for many. The different financial incentives of powerful
entities like hospitals, pharmaceutical companies, insurance companies, the federal government cause
serious problems around how health care in this country is delivered to you by these massive
multi-billion dollar companies and the politicians in their pockets. There is a level of helplessness
that we feel knowing that we can't really have any say or control over these faceless corporations
or the government officials that we see on tv who promise the world every election cycle
but that we never meet in real life. I'm going to make the argument that there is another group
that you need to be equally aware of. This group is different, they are closer to you,
they're on the front lines with you and they can directly impact how you understand the medicare
system and influence the health care decisions that you are able to make as you meet with them
face to face. This group I'm referring to actually includes people like me. They are the insurance
agents of the world, the professionals who are licensed to represent and advise on insurance
plans meant to protect you from the gaps in original medicare coverage. I struggled to
make this video because I'm about to expose several secrets that I don't think many in our
world want revealed but this most recent annual enrollment period has frustrated me to the point
where I feel like I need to say something. The problem I feel with health care in general and
medicare more specifically is the fear-mongering that exists to prey on seniors. For most of your
life you have had an HR person to help you with your one, two, or three different plan options
within your company. Once you retire you're kind of thrown to the wolves with dozens of plan options,
structures, the alphabet soup of medicare letters, and being on your own without a helper. That is
where an agent should come in and help you not scare you. From October 1st through today when
I'm recording this, which is the last few days of the annual enrollment period in December,
4,988 people have reached out to me through our website in some form or directly to me through
email. It's a unique way to learn what you, the medicare beneficiary, are experiencing as you try
to navigate the health care maze and what some agents out there are doing. Because I'm closest
to this group, the agents, it makes me more upset. We should know better. We should do better. Most
of the independent agents that I know and interact with, whether they are partners of mine or not,
are professionals who are doing their best to do what is right for you no matter what. I'm going to
use the term agent. Agent and broker are interchangeable for our purposes in this video.
You have captive agents. These are agents who are employed by one insurance company and they can
only offer that one insurance company's plans. You also have independent agents. These are not
employed by any individual insurance company. They can represent several different insurance
companies and plans. Agents may be a solo operation. They may be part of a smaller
local agency. They may be part of a slightly larger agency helping several states or they may
be one of thousands upon thousands of agents working in massive call centers across the country.
I am biased and I acknowledge that, but I feel many of the massive medicare call centers are
involved in some of the worst marketing practices out there and they are hurting medicare beneficiaries
and I'll get to those tactics here in a minute. The next thing you need to know about insurance
agents who help with medicare is that they are paid by the insurance companies, not by you. In
fact, if an agent receives commissions from an insurance company, he or she is not allowed to
accept any payment from you, period. So hypothetically, if I accept commissions from an
insurance company and you reached out and you said, Eric, I just want to pay you $100 to consult me
on my medicare decisions and then I will do the rest, I would be in violation of the law and I
could lose my license if I were to accept. We cannot take your money. Remember this. It will
be important later when I show you one of the many tricks going on in this space. Agents can help you
shop and compare different plans. Plans you may have heard of like a medicare supplement plan,
also known as a medigap plan, or medicare advantage plans, prescription drug plans,
dental, vision, hearing, and long-term care plans. Now the perk of having an agent who believes in
service is that your agent can get involved on your behalf between you and the insurance company
or the hospital systems and they can shop for plans for you every year as the medicare landscape
changes, which it does every single year. But I'm now going to transition into the financial
incentives for agents based on the types of plans they offer, more specifically medicare supplement
plans and medicare advantage plans. So buckle up because this is where those of you who are
approaching medicare or you're already on medicare will see a lot of information on these topics,
including on this channel and other channels that are out there. These incentives contribute to not
only how much information some entities are willing to share with you, but what specific
information they are telling you around these plans that may or may not be the full picture.
I would be willing to bet that if you've spent any time here on youtube researching supplement
versus advantage plans you will have seen or heard some entities warning about the evil
advantage plans and the corrupt agents offering them. Well I think it's time that you learned the
full story. To understand an agent's financial incentives you need to know how an agent becomes
licensed and what plans he or she is allowed to offer. To become licensed there is a state
insurance license exam. You take the test to prove that you know the basic functions and rules of
insurance. It's not what I would describe as terribly difficult when comparing to something
like the bar for attorneys, but it takes some studying and an understanding of how health
insurance works along with ethical matters related to this industry. To maintain this license you
need to take continuing education courses and pass tests every few years. If you're familiar
with a real estate exam and continuing education courses I'd say it's similar to that. Once you
have this license in most states you can now go to an insurance company that offers medicare
supplement plans, fill out their contracting paperwork, and then you usually need something
called errors and omissions or E&O insurance. Now you can start offering medicare supplement plans.
That's it. You can earn commissions when you sell supplement plans and in a minute I'll share what
those commissions look like compared to medicare advantage plans, but that is the process to offer
supplement plans. To offer medicare advantage plans there is a whole lot more work that needs
to be done. First you still need that state health insurance license. Next you need to pass what is
called AHIP, which if you're in the presence of an agent who has done this and you say AHIP
you just might see their eyes start twitching like you're saying the name of he who must not
be named. AHIP stands for America's Health Insurance Plans and it is the training course
that goes over even more rules, regulations, and standards for offering medicare advantage plans
and part D prescription drug plans. At the end of this course you need to pass the exam with a 90%
or higher score. You're allowed to take the AHIP three times meaning if you don't pass with a 90%
or higher in three attempts you need to pay more and re-enroll in the course materials,
but some insurance companies will not even allow you to offer their plans if you fail the AHIP
three times in a given year. But passing this only serves as a prerequisite to being allowed
to complete even more certifications because now you need to get certified with every single
insurance company that you want to be able to offer individually. They all have their own portals
and their own tests on their plans. So I just want to point out that for an agent to offer even a
single medicare advantage plan or part D prescription drug plan is much much more difficult
than an agent who offers supplement plans only. If this feels like an advantage plan commercial I
promise it's not. There are a lot of financial games that are being played here but you need
to understand how we get to them. And if you have an agent who can offer both supplement and
advantage plans and not only just offer one company of each but offer different supplement
plan insurance companies and many different advantage plan companies they've done a whole
lot more behind the scenes than what I think most people realize. And if they want to be licensed in
several states you guessed it even more tests even more costs and even more hurdles to make this
possible. This all ties into the financial incentives and marketing tricks for agents and
this is not going to go the way that I think most people think it will. I'm going to start with the
supplement plan incentives and tricks because we've all heard about the advantage plan side but
for some reason you don't hear much on the supplement side and just because you don't hear it
doesn't mean it's not there. So let's talk about the supplement plan commissions and the service
that comes with those commissions. Supplement plan commissions are set by the insurance company
that offers the supplement plans. The amounts vary widely anywhere between 5% to 30% but for
illustrative purposes let's say that an insurance company will pay a commission to the agent
of 20% of the monthly premium cost. The average monthly premium for a plan g nationally in 2024
was $150 per person per month. 20% of that is $30 per month or $360 per year. There are states where
the plan g premium costs are double that and other states where they are closer to $100.
So where you live will impact this math problem pretty significantly. Because supplement plan
insurance companies can control these commissions there are several structures that can happen here.
Some companies will pay a commission for as long as the client stays on the supplement plan.
Some will pay a commission percentage for let's say five years and then they will taper down
lowering the amount each year until it's around that 5% number for the rest of the client's life
on that plan. Or some companies have the commissions tapered down to zero after a few
years. Remember supplement plans do not cover drugs dental or vision so if your agent helps
you with each of those there are commissions that are built into most of those plans as well
bumping the total commissions a little higher. The monthly premium amounts for these plans are
and in 2025 the vast majority of Part D plans no longer offer commissions to agents who help.
This has resulted in most agencies limiting their Part D support. They just can't. Part D
historically takes the most time and the most resources to help and while the Part D commissions
were not big think maybe five to ten dollars a month it was at least something to help with
the overhead and the cost associated with being able to help. Now with how this system is set up
think with me for a moment about the life of an agent who only offers supplement plans does not
help with Part D prescription drug coverage and works in a state where it is difficult to switch
to a different supplement plan which is most states. What are the incentives? First put everyone
on a supplement plan. They cannot offer advantaged plans and if you can only offer a Ford you will
not inform people about a Chevy a BMW or a Tesla. In fact if supplement plans are the only option
they can afford any other option is presented as either less desirable or downright evil. Number two
put everyone on the insurance companies that offer decent plans and a long tail on commissions.
Number three if it's hard to switch in your state which again in most states it is the incentive is
to never need to provide service for you into the future because once you pick a supplement plan
you are essentially stuck on that plan unless you can pass medical underwriting. What we need to be
very clear on here is realizing that these are real incentives but also understanding that not
all agents behave this way. A few bad apples cause issues for everyone else but we also need to
acknowledge that these bad apples do in fact exist and this is where I get upset because I believe an
agent's responsibility is to guide you through all of your options not bias your choices and
especially not cause fear and anxiety to half of all medicare beneficiaries based on selective
information. So if you see marketing information out there from people or organizations who only
offer medicare supplement plans or they're saying things like they never recommend medicare advantage
plans or they point out that anyone who does offer advantage plans is only doing so for ill-intentioned
motives here's a little cheat sheet into what's really going on around those specific messages.
These messages are coming from one of five types of agents. Number one they live in an area that
does not have medicare advantage plans. Alaska you're a great example. Advantage plans are not
available in Alaska. Other rural parts of America you're another example. If an agent lives in these
areas and they help people in these areas I have absolutely nothing against them offering just
supplement plans because that's all that's available. Advantage plans aren't available.
This group is not the problem they are not the ones marketing information all over the country
because they are focused on their own applicable region. The second group they legitimately have
what they feel is an ethical problem with medicare advantage plans to where they refuse
to offer them to anybody but that is okay we can have different opinions we can have different
experiences others may have been raised or trained differently or they have different experiences
with each of these plans as well. I have nothing against a person having an ethical dilemma and not
offering something they don't believe in. I would hope that they would at least inform clients that
there are other options out there and just so that we are all clear there are people and maybe some of
you watching who cannot get a supplement plan. This may be because you have medicaid and neither
us nor insurance companies are allowed to place people with low incomes and medicaid on supplement
plans. This may be because you cannot afford a supplement plan even though you are above the
medicaid limit. This may be because you are pre-65 and you live in a state where supplement plans are
not available to you yet. This may be because you went with an advantage plan first and now your
health will not allow you to pass medical underwriting to get on a supplement plan or this
may be because you do not want a supplement plan knowing full well the differences between the two.
So there's a relatively large group of people who flat out cannot or do not want a supplement plan
at this point. Agents in this category who ethically refuse to offer anything other than
a supplement plan cannot help some of you other than referring you to another agent who can which
I hope they do. Okay the third group is where I start to have issues and the issues get progressively
worse going up from group three to group four to group five and the issues lie in the intent
knowingly misleading others. The third category would be those who could not pass AHIP and could
not pass the insurance company certifications so they cannot offer advantage plans for that reason
or they got dropped from the insurance companies who offer advantage plans because of that agent's
unethical behavior and now all they can offer are supplement plans because of their own
incompetence. This one is a bit harsh this is a very small group but it does exist. The fourth
group would be agents who only offer supplement plans because they do not want to handle the
service aspects that come with real medicare guidance. I have had agents tell me this to my
face we only offer supplement plans because we want to be able to set them on the plan
and then never hear from them again. I get about a dozen people a week who reach out to me who are
on supplement plans their costs have risen dramatically and they tell me our agent has
disappeared he or she put us on this plan a few years ago they didn't tell us about anything else
and now they are gone they are not answering our calls emails or texts they will not help us. That
agent is probably still getting paid his or her commissions to help service that person yet they
are not doing the actual service this makes me sad this makes me upset. Okay the fifth and final
category is an interesting one it includes agents who offer both supplement plans and advantage
plans but they spend much of their time in their marketing efforts bashing advantage plans as a
way to generate more business where they still end up putting people on advantage plans. During this
time of year when I'm releasing this video it is the end of the annual enrollment period where
people who are already on medicare are allowed to switch their advantage plans or their drug plans
I've already mentioned I've had about 5,000 interactions with people in that nine week
period. Of the agent complaints that I get most frequently it is agents in this category more
than any of the others and there's a very sneaky thing that is happening here multiple people this
week have sent the following situation they reach out and they are working with a different agency
one that happens to have a relatively large youtube channel and one that likes to point out
how bad advantage plans are when they reach out to the agency the person on the phone wouldn't even
mention supplement plans they would only discuss advantage plans when supplement plans were brought
up by the caller the agent brushed them aside and they focused on the advantage plan saying that
that is what this person needs one of the individuals who reached out to me stood out
because there are instances in our line of work where someone would do fine on either a supplement
plan or an advantage plan I genuinely believe that they would be happy either way but there
are others who are more clear-cut examples of one or the other and in this particular case
it was as clear a you should be on a supplement plan as any case we've ever seen no one should
have been recommending an advantage plan to this individual in this particular instance because of
the providers that they wanted to see and they were in a time where they could get a supplement
plan without needing medical underwriting and yet they were only presented an advantage plan
from an entity that spends a decent amount of time publicly bashing advantage plans
now I don't know this agency personally many of the bigger channels I have some degree of
connection with or familiarity with where I could reach out to them or I could message them directly
I don't with this one otherwise I'd ask what the deal was now remember agents typically work with
agencies the bigger company that has several agents and the face of the agency here on youtube
may feel a certain way or present these topics and their beliefs on these topics but when you
reach out you aren't dealing with the face you're dealing with other employees if those employees
do not share the same feelings or compensation structures things like this can happen and if
this is the case I would hope that there would be more training given to those who are taking
the calls from people who call in because of the videos being put out there I'm not blaming the
face of that channel which is why I'm not mentioning this channel by name but with many of
these channels not all but many of them they are making videos and then their team responds to the
outreach as long as the training of those answering the calls are in line with the presenter we don't
have an issue when they are not we do this channel works a little differently if you fill out a form
on theretirementnerds.com it comes to me personally I put my personal email address in every video
description it's not an employee it's not some sort of an AI feature I make the initial outreach
to every one of you who fill out a contact form and I'm a real life human being who will personally
make introductions to my partners who are licensed for your state if you are watching this and you
have reached out not knowing that it was this mug who is emailing you surprise the reason why this
last group those that bash advantage plans as a marketing tactic but end up offering advantage
plans anyway I feel are doing a disservice to you the person watching as well as the entire
agent community at large who are open and honest about both options is because the messaging is
being portrayed as a noble intent but the messaging and subsequent behavior is not noble and I'm not
focusing on any particular channel or agency at this point it's any agent that is engaged in the
tactic of bashing advantage plans to offer advantage plans here's another trick to understand
if you are already on medicare and you have already been on a plan whether that's a supplement plan
or an advantage plan and you reach out wanting help from someone who is not your agent the only
way for that agent who is not your agent to get compensated is to convince you to switch off what
you already have and in most cases away from that insurance company entirely so not even to a
different plan within that same insurance company but to a completely different insurance company
altogether a quick story when I tell you that I have partners who I work with and I trust with
my life one of those partners are the ones who brought me into this industry and taught me nearly
everything I know my mom who followers of this channel know passed away this last year was on
medicare when I started at this other company she had used a different agent because I was not
licensed or even in the medicare industry when she became eligible for medicare several years ago
she wanted to support her son in his new role and so she met with the president of that company
he was kind enough to sit down with her and review her supplement plan with me in the room
he told her Barbara you are on an excellent plan if I told you to move or any other agent tells you
to move it would be because they are trying to earn a commission off of you switching your plan
I think you are in a great spot and we are here to help you if anything comes up there are incredible
agents out there including this mentor of mine not all agents are doing what I'm about to show
you and what I have shown you none of my official partners are doing what I'm about to show you
so here is the switching tactic scare the living daylights out of everyone who has an advantage
plan which is about 51 of everyone on medicare right now out of fear they call in asking if
can switch to a supplement plan whether that is better for them or not if they are in a state or
situation where they can switch easily great the switch is made commissions are earned a little
known factor on supplement plan underwriting there are several insurance companies that pay an agent
an underwriting bonus of between 25 and 200 if you put a client on a plan as they pass medical
underwriting so even more dollars if the person calling in is in a situation where they cannot get
on a supplement plan the news is delivered that they can't switch but hey let's look at that
advantage plan you're on maybe there's a better fit and if they can convince you to switch
commissions earned the bashing of advantage plans by some entities is not because they live in an
area that doesn't have them it is not because they ethically refuse to offer them it is to scare those
on advantage plans into calling and still placing them on advantage plans just different advantage
plans there have been numbers of studies on this and it is ingrained into us as humans fear is the
number one way to get attention to get clicks to get people to take action quickly and to sell
whether it's a product or an idea if you are afraid you are more likely to make quick decisions
this applies to medicare it applies to any other advertising or messaging you see the next most
effective way to get people to click share and make decisions make them angry bashing advantage
plans happens to do both rather effectively there is an important need to educate those who were put
on advantage plans inappropriately which i am getting to and bashing improper agent sales tactics
is completely fine in my opinion as evidenced by this video but if we selectively pick information
to scare those on advantage plans into calling and still place them on advantage plans it just
doesn't feel right to me here's another big problem that happens in this category of agents and the
previous that fourth group remember how i told you that i cannot accept payment from you if i'm
receiving commissions from an insurance company there are agents who say we will help you get a
supplement plan but we will not help you with part d drug coverage either because of time or
because they don't get commissions that's not the real problem for me here is the real problem
these same individuals or companies say but we have a third party partner company that will help
you with your part d drug analysis you just need to pay that entity a fee for their help
that entity can't put you on a part d plan but they can review your medications and they can
give you recommendations and because that entity isn't receiving commissions they can legally
collect the fee okay it starts to get a little bit more shady there are examples where this third
party company that is collecting the fees is actually owned by the same individuals who on
the agency who told you it doesn't offer part d help so they sent you to another company that they
own to collect the fee that the agency legally cannot collect and before 2025 that consulting
company would use the same agency to place these people who paid the fee on the drug plan that pays
so the classic double dip how's that for business sense it's highly unethical and there's a case for
illegal as i'm sure you can imagine i am not a fan of this approach and yet these types of companies
will tell you it's the advantage plan folks who are the problem as i said i understand agencies
who cannot help with part d my partners can't handle everyone just coming to them for part d
only and not the other things like supplement plans so we made a video that is a detailed
step-by-step tutorial on how to find the lowest cost drug plan through medicare.gov it shows
everything that we see and it will always be free no consulting fee required here are two more tidbits
of information on the supplement plan side of the incentives that i'd be willing to bet that most
people who aren't in the industry do not know in the insurance world and in other industries there
are companies that will offer incentive trips place enough business with them and they will
take you and your plus one on an all expense paid trip to exotic locations insurance companies
cannot offer incentive trips based on advantage plan sales supplement plans can now not all
supplement plan companies do this in fact not even the majority do but there are others that
most definitely do and our supplement plan moral high ground just got chopped down a little bit
on the flip side another sad reality with supplement plans and the agent community is
that there are states and most states in fact where the supplement plan insurance companies
are not required to pay agents a commission if you get a supplement plan during a special
guaranteed issue window for example something that has happened a lot this year you've been
on an advantage plan and your advantage plan went away you can now get on a supplement plan with no
underwriting which is great in most states and with most insurance companies in those states
the agent who helps you with that supplement plan gets zero in commissions or for those states where
you have something like a birthday rule or an anniversary rule where you can switch supplement
plans more easily low or no commissions go to your agent we have helped dozens if not hundreds of
people over the last nine weeks do this with no financial incentive to do so the point here and in
many of my videos is that the advantage versus supplement debate is not as black and white as
many people want you to believe as you hear information about both try to take a step back
and understand whether that information is presenting as much as possible about both sides
or just focusing on the pros and cons of one or the other for their own personal incentives here's
another awful sales tactic that i want you to know about that involves both supplement and
advantage plans but it leverages the supplement plan dialogue there are different marketing rules
when it comes to supplement plans and advantage plans an agent cannot initiate an outreach to
sell you an advantage plan or a part d drug plan without your express permission to contact you
about them you need to confirm that you want to discuss these plans before an agent can talk about
them with you an agent cannot cold call you to talk about advantage plans an agent cannot knock
on your door to sell advantage plans now i would be willing to bet that most of you who are near
65 years old are super confused by what i just said because your phone is ringing 10 20 30 times
a day from medicare telemarketers and you did not give them your permission to contact you
so even with rules in place many call centers and agencies just don't care if you fill out something
on their website there is probably some small print somewhere that counts to let them harass
you i think it's stupid i think it's inappropriate now to even have that conversation and present
plan specific information about advantage plans or part d prescription drug plans
all agents must have you sign what is called a scope of appointment this is a form where you
give permission to an agent to talk about certain plan options with you it does not obligate you to
work with that agent it protects you an agent cannot discuss plans if you do not mark that
you want to discuss them if you mark part d plans only and you do not mark advantage plans the agent
cannot talk to you about advantage plans in that conversation but guess when they can bypass all
medicare supplement plans did you know that there are mobile apps available to some agents that will
show a map of your area it will point out your address and it will let them know that your
address has somebody eligible for medicare living in that home so that the agent can walk over to
you knock on your door and present supplement plans the agents if they are compliant but again
there are people out there who just don't care about compliance but let's assume that they are
compliant they will talk to you about medicare supplement plans only because they legally can do
that and they cannot talk to you about advantage plans yet where this changes is if you bring up
advantage plans and it is not hard for an experienced sales agent to start a conversation
with a typical medicare beneficiary exclusively focused on supplement plans and it would not take
them long to be able to say the right phrases to get that individual to ask them about advantage
plans and now the door is open so to review supplement plans are easier for agents to get
licensed to sell if the agent is not helping with part d drug coverage and in a state where switching
is more difficult which is most states supplement plans require much less service supplement plans
are legally less regulated to market and supplement plans serve as a great way to get you to bring up
advantage plans now i take a lot of heat through the comments section from people who hate advantage
plans who seem to think that i push them solely because i do not exclusively bash them i do not
push advantage plans i just told you that my mom was on a supplement plan i get accused of this
because the vast majority of marketing around supplement plans is pointing at higher agent
commissions that i will talk about and networks that i have talked about and prior authorizations
that i have talked about at length on this channel what is not shared with you is what
i have just shared with you about the differences in supplement plan licensing laws service
requirements marketing regulations and incentives i get asked this all the time what is the ratio of
our clients who go with supplement plans versus advantage plans and the answer depends on the
state that you're talking about and even down to the zip code you can watch my state videos that
go over all of these different reasons but in most areas of the country it is around 65 supplement
plan and 35 advantage plan there are specific areas of the country where this shifts to more
around 50 50 because of the plan availability and the switching rules to give you context nationally
21 percent of medicare beneficiaries choose supplement plans 51 percent choose advantage
plans we're nowhere near those numbers you'll notice that the national numbers do not add up
to 100 that is because the rest go with something like original medicare only so no other plans
fehb tricare for life or some other secondary coverage just as a quick note we can't really
help you with the fehb va or tricare for life plans themselves we help a lot of veterans with
va or tricare for life coverage find plans that are built for them that are outside the va or
tricare for life or federal workers who don't want their fehb plans for their own reasons and they
want the regular supplement plans or advantage plans but if you're wanting to pick up an fehb
plan or keep the fehb plan or get details around tricare for life coverage that's all handled
through opm for fehb or the postal benefits it's handled through the va for va benefits and
it's handled through tricare for tricare coverage those specific plans themselves aren't handled by
agents but back to the point neither me nor my partners push advantage plans we don't push
supplement plans either we believe that if we share as much information as possible in a way
that is as clear and transparent as possible you know deep down which option is better for you
from there we can help you shop around different options based on what you need but we're at least
willing to share the reality of both rather than skewing one or the other by limiting your access
to information now having said all of that about supplement plan agent incentives now let's
transition to the advantage plans if you see a commercial running about medicare this time of
year the odds are very high that it is advertising a medicare advantage plan and there are reasons
for that massive call centers are running these ads in hopes that you will call the number on
your screen if you are new to medicare they will point out the shiny advantage plan for you if you
are already on medicare they will look at your current plan and i'd be willing to bet that they
will magically find an advantage plan that they deem better for you that is not your current plan
because if you switch commissions earned i have outlined in several videos how advantage plans do
not supplement original medicare they replace original medicare they do come with a bundle of
other things like drug coverage dental vision hearing and others and those are what are pitched
in the commercials the ads say something like you get all of the benefits of original medicare
plus you get extra benefits that you are missing out on with just medicare most of you who watch
this channel already understand this and you see right through what's going on i was at lunch today
with my dad at a place that had tvs and the entire lunch had medicare ads running which are hard for
me to ignore while eating with my dad i counted nine medicare advantage commercials in the 60
minutes or so that we were there all of these ads go directly to either a national call center with
agents or insurance companies themselves these phone agents will more than likely place you on
an advantage plan without education around supplement plans how do i know i've called them
i have had partners who called them and recorded the conversations they would be funny if they
weren't so seriously frustrating the commercials from actual insurance companies themselves are
hoping that you call directly into that insurance company and then they can put you on their plans
and bypass the agent commission remember supplement plan commissions are set by the
advantage plan commissions are set by the federal government not me not agents not the insurance
companies here is the chart for 2025 advantage plan commissions this is public information it
is not some big secret and if it was well now it's not supplement plan commissions are much
harder to track down and are not public information advantage plan commissions are right here in most
states if you are new to medicare meaning this is your first time signing up and if you go on
that is what initial is referring to here in the chart initial commissions are $626 that is for the
year in connecticut pennsylvania and washington dc that first year commission is $705 in california
and new jersey it is $780 renewal refers to every subsequent year so year two that you are on the
plan or years three four and onward in most states it is half so $313 for the year connecticut
pennsylvania and dc it is $353 for the year california new jersey is $390 our group doesn't
work in puerto rico and the virgin islands but you can see the numbers here you can also see
that these increase a little bit each year those higher first year commissions are what are brought
up on an advantage plan incentive debate and they are real a lot of agents are pushing advantage
plans who are targeting what are referred to as t65s meaning people who are turning 65 this gives
an advantage plan a unique selling opportunity because if you get an advantage plan when you
first turn 65 and you first go on medicare you get a 12 month trial right this means that you
can try out that plan and if you don't like it switch back to original medicare and a supplement
plan within that 12 month window agents will use that trial right feature to get people into the
advantage plan and earn that commission and it's sort of like a money back guarantee where if you
don't like the plan you can just switch before the year is up and that gets more people into
advantage plans this specific trial right only applies if you go on an advantage plan at your
65th birthday not if you do so later there is another trial right where if you go on a supplement
plan when you first go on medicare it doesn't have to be your 65th birthday but it's when you
first get medicare and then you want to try an advantage plan later you can do so and you have
a 12 month window to try it out before you could switch back to your existing supplement plan and
you can only do this once you can't keep jumping back and forth with this type of trial right now
for clarification if you are already signed up on an advantage plan and you switch to a different
advantage plan whether with your existing agent or a new agent the commission is the renewal
commission not the initial one again which again is why the t65s are what these call centers and
agents are really after this is another reason why you will see a lot of marketing and information
out there telling people that they have to take medicare at their 65th birthday even though
millions of people do not and should not take medicare at 65 go watch a video that looks like
this for clarification there so your existing agent isn't really incentivized to bounce you
around from one advantage plan to another to chase renewal commissions because they aren't
higher between different insurance companies in regular circumstances unless insurance companies
will often offer agents and agencies incentives if they hit certain numbers or a bonus or maybe
the insurance company will help pay for some marketing costs again this is not going to make
me popular but these offers happen all of the time there are rules that were put out there that
tried to put an end to this but it was put on hold after lawsuits were filed saying that cms
overstepped which in my opinion they did and it involved more than just what i'll share here
but these incentives are being looked at very closely by the federal government i have several
partner agencies who refuse insurance company incentives period i have others that refuse
insurance company incentives if any volume metrics are a requirement meaning if the offer is here's
to help with marketing but we expect 50 policies from that or else you have to pay us back the
partners say no we're okay the other part of this chart that i showed you are part d commission
numbers but they are pretty much not real at this point as 85 or so of the part d insurance plans
announced that they are no longer offering any commissions to agents after these 2025 numbers
were released so our advantage plan first year commissions higher than supplement plans yes
even when including supplement plan dental vision and hearing commissions are advantage renewal
commissions higher than supplement plan commissions not necessarily but they can be
for supplement plan g and in some cases plan n with many insurance companies it can be very
close especially if dental and vision plans are thrown in there as well for other supplement plans
with other insurance companies advantage plans will be higher are the service requirements for
an advantage plan agent actually doing his or her job generally higher each year than supplement
plan agents who do not help with part d yes now those commission numbers you see rarely all go to
the agent on both sides supplement and advantage remember we're talking about the agencies that
have agents there is usually some sort of a commission split where the agency gets a percentage
of that to help cover overhead offices other service staff computers software systems and
support and a percentage of that goes to the agent helping or other agencies have it structured in a
way where their agents get a set amount or hourly wage or salary or it doesn't matter what plan
they put clients on they're paid the same there are strengths and weaknesses to every compensation
model but those are some ways in general that agents that work within an agency are paid now
just like my never recommend advantage people out there the same criticism goes to agents who never
recommend supplement plans and these ideas are coming from one of three types of agents number
one they are captive agents who only work with one insurance company and that insurance company only
offers an advantage plan just as a quick example there are others but kaiser does not work with
independent agents if you want a kaiser plan which is an advantage plan you work with a kaiser
agent that will help you with that that agent doesn't represent any other company except kaiser
i have nothing against agents employed by a company and helping people who are reaching out for that
specific plan i do think that their hands are tied because if a plan that they offer is not the right
fit they can't offer others but being an employee is different than representing several different
plans number two they are in an area or work with a certain demographic of people where advantage
plans are the right option there are agents who specialize in those who have medicaid and medicare
as an example or you can watch my video on the best states for medicare advantage plans and see
certain areas that have insane advantage plans even in these areas though i think that it's
important that a supplement plan should be offered and explained or third the agents are in fact
chasing those short-term higher advantage plan commissions if an agent or an agency are in this
line of work for the short term meaning that they want to get as many people as possible on their
books and potentially sell their business in a relatively short amount of time advantage plans
all day long this is what most of the call centers are doing they buy insane amounts of leads they
call people like crazy they put people on advantage plans and hope that they don't need to service
those clients into the future meaning there really isn't any outreach to help you the next year big
waves of seasonal workers are hired during this annual enrollment period and then they are fired
as soon as it's over they aren't worried about you referring your friends and family for help
because our marketing strategy is not organic growth it is paid growth through tv ads mailers
online ads and outbound call centers let's talk about the long-term incentives of an agent or
agency if an agency or an agent is looking to be in this business for the long term meaning we are
going to actually get to know you and your family we are going to be there for you not just when you
first go on medicare but for the rest of your life shoving everyone into a plan that is terrible
for you all for that higher first year commission for advantage plans or the lower service
requirements for the supplement plans is probably the worst strategy i can think of i would have
one good year and then go out of business because people who shouldn't be on an advantage plan will
have a terrible experience and they'll go to a different agent who will get them off of the bad
plan and then lower the revenue people who can't afford supplement plans will leave to advantage
plans i already referenced the cars and i'm going to do it again i'm aware of the stereotypical car
salesman but just go with me on this example let's pretend i offer all types of cars trucks and suvs
and someone comes to me and says eric i want to go fast i want to look sexy i only want to have
two seats i have a two hundred thousand dollar budget and i want a shiny new yellow corvette
i would hope to say okay just understand that you can't fit a family in here you're going to be
tempted to go too fast and have a higher likelihood of speeding tickets and any speed bump or curb that
is higher than half an inch you're going to want to make sure that you're aware of these if they
understand this and they still want the corvette they got what they want knowing the risks and i
would likely make a higher commission on that than a budget kia minivan however let's say that
a different person came to me and said eric i have a family of six i want something that can hold all
of us on a long road trip across the country it has doors that don't swing open because my kids
keep hitting other cars and parking lots i want good gas mileage i want a high safety rating and
my budget is around forty thousand dollars if i heard all of this and i said you know what i got
just the car for you a brand new 2025 670 horsepower two seater 185 000 z06 corvette
i'd say that i have a listening and an incentive problem there are instances where the plan for
somebody happens to be the one with the higher commission there are also instances where the
plan for somebody is a lower commission or zero commission even more importantly if i give you
crappy service you will not refer the people that you trust to me for help this is organic growth
instead of paid growth it's not just us but many agencies out there do not pay for advertising we
aren't running commercials we aren't running facebook or youtube ads we don't have an
outbound call center we do not buy leads from marketing organizations so that we can pester
and hound and harass people that is not how we and many other independent agencies out there
prefer to do business and frankly i think that those that do are a problem any agency is much
more stable and much better off if we do what is best for you you are then happy not just that first
year on your plan but every year after that and then hopefully you trust us enough to send your
friends and your family who will ask you who your kind and thoughtful and attractive medicare helpers
are we have found that for every person that we take care of well we get between 5 and 20 plus
referrals from their friends and family this is why we don't care what plan you go on this is why
this entire channel and this entire video is built to show you how everything works the good
the bad the wonderful the ugly for both sides because if you are educated on how this really
works and you understand how this crazy insurance world works you can make decisions that will
protect your health and your finances much more effectively whether you work with us or you go
work with someone else even our competitors most agents and agencies understand this idea most of
the independent agents that i know out there whether they are official partners of mine or not
working tirelessly to make sure that their clients are taken care of they're making sure that their
clients are on the right plan each and every year they are intervening on that client's behalf if
the insurance company or the providers or the hospitals are having issues others do not feel
that way and they employ the tactics that i've covered in this video if you have an agent you
trust please use him or her we are not in the business of stealing people from other hard
working agents i've told hundreds of people over the last nine weeks please work with your agent
all of our collective partners have told thousands over the last nine weeks to stay on their existing
plans don't switch even though we aren't paid to tell you to do this but because it's the right
thing to do and i know countless other agents out there who are doing the same thing often this comes
from friends or clients who have watched a misleading video and who are scared that something
bad is going to happen to them based on incomplete information if you're watching this and you do not
want to work with an agent and you want to do all the shopping and comparing and research and the
time on the phone or the internet i can understand the apprehension behind whether or not the agent
or agency that you would work with will have the same standards that you expect i still think that
using an agent is the right idea but i am biased in this if you do want to use an agent interview
them ask them if they offer both supplement and advantage plans ask them if they offer multiple
supplement plan insurance companies and multiple advantage plan insurance companies i personally
wouldn't look for an agent that offers all options number one because it's impossible
they're insurance companies that do not work with independent agents i mentioned them before but
kaiser is an example they only offer and accept their own plan but there are others besides kaiser
second their insurance companies that frankly we don't want to offer or get contracted with we
don't feel that they have the plans or a track record that is worth recommending so i wouldn't
go in asking if they represent all plan options rather ask how many companies that they offer in
your area and how many do they represent i would also pay attention to how they interact with you
do they listen to you do they understand your health your finances your preferred providers
and present options or do they just push you into a plan without bringing up others remember there
are people out there who cannot get supplement plans who do not realize that they can't get
supplement plans and when this is shared with them they get upset thinking that the agent is unethical
for not offering a supplement plan partially because they watch some of these videos bashing
advantage plans without context if you're one of these individuals now hopefully you have some
context we have covered a lot of information here did i cover everything no it's impossible i hope
this video helps unwind some of the web and pull back the curtains for you on the medicare marketing
and agent world i hope this channel helps you feel more at ease with your medicare decisions
i can't help everyone one-on-one but i can help as many people as possible through these videos
i saved this for the end because it's not the point of the video but if you watch this and you
feel that our approach represents someone that you would like to work with you can reach out to me
every form submission goes directly to me my email address is also in the description of this video
if you fill out any form on our website you will not be hassled you will not be bombarded by phone
calls you will not be spammed i have not turned over my website to ai or automation it makes my
work-life balance a little hectic but it at least protects those of you who trust us enough to reach
out know that you will not be harassed if you download one of our free guides we send you that
guide that's it i will not try to sell you on anything else if you want our help you control
that conversation if you are new to this channel at the end of every video i leave a secret codeword
to help me with comment management if you aren't new to the channel you know what time it is if you
made it this far the secret codeword is fishing my partner and friend who i mentioned at the
beginning philip pay was an avid fisherman and he passed away doing what he loved thank you for
spending this much time with me seriously i appreciate you this will definitely ruffle some
feathers but i hope that you found value in it i'm working on a few more videos focused on exposing
the pharmaceutical side of medicare hospitals and providers and the insurance companies themselves
so subscribe to follow along with those videos here is a video that goes over in detail the
cost differences between medicare advantage plans and medicare supplement plans for 2025
i will see you over there

