The Contrarian
5 Video Views·Jan 28, 2025
This video is brought to you by Squarespace. From websites and online stores, to marketing tools
and analytics, Squarespace is the all-in-one platform to build a beautiful online presence
and run your business. Throughout the many videos I have created, you have seen my studio,
you've seen me work, you've seen the paintings on which I work, and you have seen the work that I
do. But what you have not seen is what I see when I'm actually working. That is, the process of
conservation from my perspective. So for this video, I figured let's flip it on its head
and strap a camera to mine, put on some binaural recording microphones, and give you the sights
and sounds of conservation as I see them. And it all starts with this beautiful W.M. Keith painting,
or at least I think it's a beautiful painting, because I cannot imagine that this painting was
supposed to be as brown as it is. It doesn't really seem plausible that the artist wanted
this to look that way. Now whether this is just an accumulation of surface grime, dust, dirt, tobacco,
smoke, or soot, or some sort of surface coating, varnish, or shellac that has just really darkened
over time, remains to be seen. But before I can find out those answers, well I have to get this
painting out of the frame. And initially I see that a patch has been applied to the back of
this canvas, which indicates that it's been worked on in the past. Now I'm going to be using a pair
of wire snips to remove these very impressive steel tacks. At about an inch long, they are some
of the biggest I've seen, probably seven or eight ounces. And I have to take some care to remove them
because they're heavily embedded in this wood, and I don't want to destroy either the stretcher
or the frame, because that would create more work for myself. Now I'll save these for some project
in the future, maybe. Now removing the canvas from the frame, I have to be really careful, because as
I go ahead and take a look at it, well, it's pretty clear that it's got some structural damage.
We can see one whole tacking edge is completely separated at the fold, and that's something that
I'm going to have to address later on. But before I can do that, I have to separate the canvas from
the stretcher. And so I'll take my tack pulling tool, and I'll start to remove these old tacks.
And as I do this, I notice that there is no sign of old tack holes,
meaning that while this painting has been worked on, it doesn't appear to ever have been removed
from the stretcher, which means that the work may not have addressed all of the issues.
Just something to keep in mind.
And once I have removed all of these tacks, I can separate the canvas from the stretcher.
And I'm always going to be careful when I do this, because as I pull up on the stretcher,
I notice that it's not releasing, which indicates that maybe I've missed some tacks.
Sure enough, there's a little flap here that has some hidden tacks.
So after poking myself in the finger, I will remove these other tacks that I hadn't caught
before. Now imagine if I had just tugged on this stretcher until it came loose. Well,
I probably could have damaged these little pieces of canvas, or even worse,
ripped the painting itself. So being careful, being deliberate, and not making assumptions
that just because I thought I removed all the tacks, all the tacks were gone, is pretty critical.
But now we can see the canvas comes right away from the stretcher. And looking at the stretcher,
it's in really great condition. It's a little dirty, but there's no damage,
which is great, because I can reuse it. Now, when I take a canvas off a stretcher,
I'm always prepared to find, well, gross things in between the stretcher and the canvas.
And in this case, it's really no different. There's a lot of dust, dirt, some little old
insect shells and spider parts, which always give me the heebie-jeebies. But I don't use a
vacuum here, because I think it's too aggressive. Just a simple brush and removing it is fine. I
don't see any reason to take any unnecessary risks. Now, it is really a shame that this canvas
has a square patch on it, because it's really giving squares a bad name, and they are pretty
awesome. I mean, Squarespace. Am I right? So how awesome is Squarespace? Well, it's the comprehensive
one-stop to get you online with your own website. And whether you're interested in their thousands
of award-winning, gorgeous, mobile-friendly templates, or you just need something simple
for your business. Or maybe you just want to tell your own story with the blog. They've got you
covered with search engine optimization, analytics, apps, and tools. You can even mobile edit your site.
And if that sounds like a lot to take in, well, don't worry. They're not going to leave you
hanging. Squarespace has a forum full of thousands of users just like you, answering questions and
helping out. In fact, Squarespace will even help you find and register your own domain. The starting
point for all of your website dreams. So head over to squarespace.com for a free trial. And when
you're ready to launch, go to squarespace.com slash Baumgartner to save 10% off your first
purchase of a website or domain. Now, I could simply leave this canvas patch on and remove it
later after the cleaning. And sometimes I do that when I know that the patch or old structural
repair is absolutely critical in maintaining the integrity of the painting through the next steps.
So if this were a huge tear, I may leave the patch on during the cleaning process.
But in this case, it's not a huge tear. And I suspect that it's really, really minor. And so
I'm not terribly concerned about the canvas falling apart when I do the cleaning.
What I am concerned about is a bump underneath the canvas while I am doing the cleaning.
And the edges of this patch could telegraph to the front. And as I'm going over it with solvent
or solution, detergent or surfactant, whatever, it could create a mark. And that would be something
that I don't want to happen. So I'm going to remove the patch now. Now, this old patch has
pretty much deteriorated. And the glue has also failed. And that's actually a nice change of pace
because recently I've had to work on a lot of projects that have fought me every step of the
way. And while that is kind of par for the course, getting a small patch that comes off fairly
easily with the glue that has mostly deteriorated, well, it's easier. And who doesn't like easy?
So after the patch is removed, I'm going to take a cotton ball with a liquid enzyme solution,
and saturate this cotton ball and place it on the old adhesive. And based on the age of this repair
and what I could deduce from the powdery adhesive, I think that this is most likely an animal-based
product, either hide glue or rabbit skin glue. And so the application of this enzyme will cause
the glue to swell, become soft, and then using my scalpel, I can very easily scrape it off.
Again, much nicer than, oh, I don't know, Elmer's glue. So sometimes old traditional materials,
even though they fail, are conservators' best friend because they're much, much easier to
And we have plenty of information about how to deal with these materials, so it doesn't come
as a surprise. I can remove the excess adhesive, and then with another cotton ball, remove any
remaining residues, and, well, just like that, in the matter of, what, a minute and a half or two,
that patch and the old adhesive is gone. Pretty easy, huh? Now on to cleaning.
I did make some small tests, so I am aware of what is on this painting, and it turns out that
it is not surface grime. It's not dust, dirt, tobacco smoke, or any of that. It's shellac,
and a lot of it. I mean, lots of shellac, probably several coatings. And I mentioned that the
painting had been worked on in the past, and maybe the old varnish was just shellacked over,
and maybe over again and again. But as we start to remove it, oh, look at that. I mean,
that is just super exciting. I've said it before, and I will say it every single time I clean a
painting and remove an old discolored varnish. It is just super exciting to see what lies beneath.
Now, why shellac was used on a painting? You know, I don't have any real reason, but my guess
is that shellac is ubiquitous. You can find it just about anywhere, and it's commonly used
on furniture in homes. And so people may be familiar with how to use it, whereas
traditional varnishes are a little bit more esoteric, and people who aren't in the arts
may not know how to use them. But one of the problems with shellac is that unless it is a
high, high quality shellac, a really blonde or white shellac, it has a yellow or orange tint to
it. And low quality shellac, while it is not only orange, it also degrades with exposure to UV light
much faster than pure blonde shellac. And so over time, it starts to get yellow, then orange,
then brown, then really brown, and then really, really, really brown. And while that may be
desirable in furniture or hardwood flooring or in homes where a patina is desired, with fine art,
we don't want that. I mean, we don't want this beautiful blue sky to be brown. Nobody can make
an argument that that is a good outcome. Really, nobody can. And so removing this old discolored
shellac reveals, reveals the best of what we find when we do conservation. It reveals a painting
that has a whole range of color, a real dynamism to it. Just this little strip in the sky, we can
start to see hints of clouds. We can see that the sky isn't monotone. It's got blues and greens,
even some grays in it. It makes the painting dynamic. It makes it interesting. And it,
well, obviously, makes it beautiful. These clouds are creamy white clouds that we've all seen a
and they make the sky feel full. Removing this varnish is just super, super satisfying. I don't
think there will be a day when I get tired of removing old discolored dirty varnishes.
It's just kind of the best part of the job. And as I come to this really bright turquoise spot,
hey, look at that. There are even some birds in the sky that were totally obfuscated by that old
shellac and varnish. And so not only did it change the whole tenor of the painting,
we couldn't even see details like these birds. And while cleaning the sky is obviously the most
exciting and bright part of the painting, maybe it's the showstopper, that doesn't mean that
cleaning the foreground or the trees or the dirt is any less important. Because even though it is
brown and dark green, it's not just one amorphous blob of color like it was with this old shellac on
it. There's a lot of variation in color that Keith used. There's delicate brushwork. There
are highlights coming through these trees that just can't be seen with this old coating.
And so yeah, cleaning the sky is like super, super exciting because we go from brown to blue.
But cleaning the other parts of the painting are just as exciting because we start to get a full
sense of the space. The painting gets volume. It gets almost three-dimensional when we can start
to fill out the rest of it. And so I always, always leave the signature for last. And the
that I do that is that after cleaning the entire painting, I have a really acute sense of the
stability of the paint. I understand if there are any colors that are fugitive or more vulnerable
to the solvents. I've experienced how this surface coating is removed, and so I understand how much
time it needs with a swab, what kind of pressure I need to use. So gathering all that data means
that cleaning the signature is going to be easier. And cleaning signatures is always tricky
because sometimes artists thin out their paint to make it flow better, and that can make the
signature more vulnerable. So I will clean around the signature, inching up to it just on the edge,
and then I'll hit one or two letters, just the edge, and see if they're stable. And if they are,
like in this case, I can go ahead and fully remove the surface coating. If they're not,
I may weaken my solvent to remove some of the surface coating, but it is not uncommon to leave
some of the old varnish or shellac on the surface of a signature just to be safe, because we don't
want to do any damage there. And here we can see it says W. Keith, just like on the frame and the
provenance. It's always nice when there's one signature that matches the provenance.
With all of that old shellac removed, I noticed that the painting had several planar distortions.
And you would be forgiven if you don't know what that means, because you probably don't speak
contrived conservator. Planar distortions are things that disrupt the plane of the painting.
In English, bumps, dents, ripples, and waves. And we want to remove all of those so that the surface
is flat and we can see the texture of the paint, the impasto. And also because once a varnish is
applied, it's going to enhance those distortions. And we use the hot table to achieve this.
Using moisture, heat, and pressure, we can relax the canvas, set it into a new state,
and then permanently keep it in that state. And so I will place the painting on an absorbent
cotton blotter paper. I will surround it with cotton webbing that leads to the corner of my
hot table where there is a hole and a tube connected to a vacuum pump that will extract
the air in this envelope. I'll tape it all down to make sure I have a nice tight seal,
which is really important because I don't want this pressure to be released midway through the
process. And then once I have this envelope or sandwich all completed, I can turn off the heat
because the table has been warming up while I've been doing this, and turn on the vacuum pump.
Now the air is going to be extracted from this envelope through that cotton webbing to the corner
through the aluminum to that hole and that hose. And it's going to provide consistent
downward pressure on the painting. And I can modulate that with a dial.
Now I'm going to let the painting cool, and that's going to take, oh, about 45 minutes,
give or take. And keeping pressure on it will make sure that when it cools, it stays in that flat
state. Now once it is fully cool, I'll transfer it over to another table, place it under weights.
Yep, just a simple cinder block in between two pieces of sheet rock, which is basically just
gypsum board, underneath some felt and blotter paper, and leave it for a couple days and let
it acclimatize. And when it comes out, well, it is flat. The back of the canvas is flat, which means
that any impasto, any texture of the paint, can now sit proud. All of those dents and ripples and
waves and even the cracks in the paint can be brought down. So it's a really simple but really
effective way of returning the painting to a state that the artist had it in when they completed the
work. And now I can start thinking about repairing the structural issues. Before I do any work, I'm
going to lay down a piece of siliconized PET film or just non-stick mylar. And this ensures that
during the strip lining process, the painting doesn't get adhered down to the table because
that would be oh so very bad. Now these pieces of the original tacking edge have completely detached
because the canvas is dry and brittle. And in this case, it's important to differentiate between doing
a reinforcement and a strip lining. A reinforcement is with silk organza, and a strip lining is with
Belgian linen. In this case, because the tacking edges are detached, I'm going to use Belgian linen.
And this is a lesson in not throwing things away, because I have a bin of scraps of strip linings
that I have used in the past. And most of these are really small, and so they don't really have
much utility except when you have a small painting. And so instead of having to cut more canvas,
spend all of that extra time, and create more waste, I can use pieces that were otherwise
destined for the trash and not waste time or materials. And I assure you, these were not a
plant. This is just scrap. Now I also keep scraps of the adhesive film, and generally I like to use
one long piece cut from a roll. But because Julian forgot to order more adhesive film and
didn't have any, he has to turn to his scrap bin. And again, keeping the scraps is really helpful
because it bailed me out in this situation. Luckily, it's a really small painting, so I don't need a ton
of adhesive film. But if I didn't have this scrap bin, well, I'd be up that proverbial river without
that proverbial paddle. And this adhesive film is both solvent and heat activated.
And so I could expose this tacking edge to some solvent and then press this adhesive film into it
cold, and it would bond. And that's critical when the painting can't receive heat. Let's say it is
an encaustic or a delicate material. But in this case, the canvas and the paint and all of the
materials are heat tolerant, so I can use an iron to apply the adhesive film down to the canvas.
I'll remove the backing from the adhesive film, and then again using my iron, I will start to tack
this Belgian linen canvas in place. I'm going to apply heat starting at one end and just going
over the area to make sure that there is a good bond. And then once I've moved past, I will take
a weight with a little oak block underneath and place it on. Now, you may notice that this is a
different weight that I normally use, and that's because one of my viewers saw me using those pieces
of steel and thought to themselves, oh my gosh, Julian's going to drop that weight and it's going
to go right through a painting. Well, yes, I have dropped the weight, never through a painting, but
almost always on my toes. And let me tell you, a 10 pound steel weight with sharp corners and
sneakers, that is not a recipe for success. And so this viewer saw this problem and in their home
machine shop milled up this piece of steel with this absolutely gorgeous brass handle and sent
it to me. And I love it. It is now one of my favorite pieces of kit that I have in the studio.
Now, I use that block underneath the steel weight to make sure that as the canvas dries, there is
no distortion because we just did a whole procedure trying to get rid of those planar distortions and
we don't want them to come back. And now on to the repair of that little tear. And it is really
little. I mean, it's maybe a centimeter long, so I don't need to do anything extravagant. And I've
chosen to do bridging. And that's where these little strips of Belgian linen are laid perpendicularly
across the tear, kind of like sutures, and they will hold that tear down and together. Now, this
canvas isn't going to be under so much tension that this tear could run like in a nylon stocking,
but we want to make sure that it doesn't open up when we go to fill in the paint loss on the front
or that it opens up with micro expansion from humidity changes. And so bridging will hold it
together and hold it flat, so it's a nice lightweight way of repairing a tear. And I don't have to use a
patch. So after applying a little adhesive, I can use a tool, a bent dental tool, to lay down these
little strips of Belgian linen fibers. And through the magic of high-speed editing, about seven
minutes condensed into, what, seven seconds, all of the bridging has been laid down. I've applied the
adhesive. I've pressed it down with my fingers. And then I'm going to apply a piece of siliconized PET
film so that nothing sticks, a piece of felt to pad that bump, and then the weight. And I'm going
to let it sit here for a day or two to let it dry. I'll check on it every now and again. And after a
couple of days, it's dry. I can remove the weight, remove the felt, remove the film, and the hole or
tear is repaired. And now the painting is ready to go back on the stretcher. And if we look at
this stretcher, it still has the paper tape on it. And normally I would remove this paper tape
because it just is gross and it doesn't need to be there. But the client gave me explicit instructions
to not remove the paper tape. And while I don't necessarily agree with it, that's what they want
and that's what they get. Now there is some writing on the paper tape and I suspect that's why the
client wants to keep it there. I don't think that that writing is original because that paper tape
is usually applied by a framer. But it's not my painting, so I follow the rules. Now stretching a
painting is pretty simple. Tacks placed in the center of each edge. And once they're there,
I'll flip the painting to the other side, pull it taut, and apply some more tacks on that side.
And what I'm doing is trying to get the center of the painting taut without any waves or
distortions. And if there are waves or distortions or slack, I'm going to move them to the corners
where it's easier to compensate for them and where the keying process has more effect.
Now this is a very small painting, so it is a very quick stretching process, which I like.
Sometimes it's nice to not have to spend a lot of time stretching a painting. Now once I have
gotten all of the tacks in, I can start to trim off the excess canvas. And this is something that's
actually pretty important because if I didn't trim it off and I just folded it in, it would bulk up
these corners. And it doesn't seem like a lot, two, four layers of canvas, but it can add up and it can
create, oh, an eighth of an inch at each corner. And an eighth of an inch and an eighth of an inch is a
quarter of an inch. And now all of a sudden the painting doesn't fit into the rabbit of the frame and we've got a problem.
So where I used three ounce tacks to secure the canvas to the stretcher, I'm using one and a half
ounce tacks to secure the extra canvas to the back. And the weight of the tacks just goes to signify
the heaviness or the size of the tacks. Obviously a seven ounce tack is a bigger tack than a one ounce tack.
Having multiple tacks at your disposal is just nice. Now on this end, I'm going to fold the canvas
over twice because this is where the writing is. And it'd be pretty bad form for the client to tell
me not to remove the paper tape with the writing and then to go ahead and cover it up with my canvas.
So hopefully this will make the client happy. And I suspect that this client will be looking at the
back a little bit more than maybe some other clients because of course there were specific
instructions about the back. And I don't want to make my clients unhappy. It's not good business.
It's not good karma. So hopefully this will make them happy.
And I'm going to tuck in these corners and put them to bed all nice and tidy and hope that they
have sweet dreams because I think it looks really good. And well, that's it. I think it looks really good.
So once I'm done with all of the tacking, I can put the keys into this stretcher. And a stretcher
is different than a strainer because the joints where the pieces of wood connect aren't glued or
nailed. They're free floating. And they have a mortise here where I can stick this key in and I
can hammer it down. And it just adds a tiny bit of tension by expanding the joint. And we're talking
like 64th of an inch here. But even that little amount can make sure that this canvas stays taut.
And over time as the canvas may loosen up with humidity changes, well instead of taking it off
the stretcher and re-stretching it, we can just key it out a little bit. So that's why stretchers are
far superior to strainers. With all of the tacks in place, I can go ahead and cut some fishing line
and thread them through the key holes and bind those keys to the stretcher. And I'm not terribly
concerned about losing some of these keys. They're just wood. They can be replaced easily. And they're
not original, so it's not like any content is being lost. But I don't want them to become
loose and fall in between the canvas and stretcher and create a bulge. So everything is good to go
now. And all I have to do is fill in the damage on the front, which consists of a very small chip
and a very small scratch. And again, I am glad that the damage here is really minimal, because
every once in a while it's nice to have a painting that doesn't require two or three weeks of
retouching to complete. I'm going to use a putty to fill in these gaps, because I want the texture
to be the same. Even if the color is matched, if there's a divot, it's going to look goofy and the
client's going to see that. So I'll overfill, let this fill in medium dry, and then in a couple of
minutes, as it started to harden, I will use a dampened cotton swab to remove the excess. Because
I just want to fill in where paint has been lost. I don't want to overfill and feather it out. So
just where there's loss, I put putty. And with that, we're ready to go and retouch.
Now the retouching process is one of my favorites. Certainly the cleaning is one of excitement,
because I get to see what a painting truly looks like. But retouching is where I, the conservator,
get to put the painting back together and eliminate the damage. Now I prefer to retouch
against artificial light as opposed to natural light. And that's because natural light is
variable from day to day, time of day, season. And artificial light is consistent. I use two
LED boxes where the Kelvin is adjustable. And that means that I can change the color or temperature
of the light from about 2500 Kelvin, which is candlelight, very orange, very yellow, very dim,
all the way to like 6000, which is obnoxiously bright white, almost blue. And that helps because
sometimes clients, galleries, dealers, museums, even private collectors will tell me what light
bulbs they use in their home or museums. And then I can calibrate my retouching lights to what they
have in situ. And that means that it's going to give me the best chance of matching the colors
perfectly for the environment in which the painting is going to reside. Because under 2500
Kelvin, a color can look different than under 5500 Kelvin. So luckily, this is just a very small
amount of retouching. But that doesn't mean that it is fundamentally any easier. I still have to
mix the paint and match the color. Just because it's a small piece of damage doesn't mean I can
randomly throw a color up. I have to make sure that it matches because I don't want anyone to
see it. And these paints are fundamentally different than oil paints because, well,
they contain no oil. Now over time, oil, when exposed to oxygen, oxidizes. It cross links and
polymerizes. It gets hard, turns into a solid, which is why oil paints last for hundreds upon
hundreds of years. But hardened oil paint isn't removable. And so if I was using oil paint here,
in 100 years, my paint would become part of the painting, which is kind of against the whole
tenet and understanding of the ethics of conservation. So by using a paint with resin,
which dries through solvent evaporation, we can be sure that in 5, 10, 100 years,
if this retouching ever needs to be removed for whatever reason, it can be with the application
of solvent. And this resin has been laboratory tested for hundreds of years in simulated aging
boxes. And while it does get a little bit more difficult to remove over time, it still can be
removed, which is absolutely critical because nothing a conservator does should ever be
permanent. Hard stop. And so using these paints makes sure that my work can be undone.
Another benefit of these paints is that the resin fluoresces very strongly under ultraviolet light.
So if you take an ultraviolet or black light, yep, the same one that you did or maybe still
have in your room hanging above a poster, and you shine it on a painting that's got retouching,
you can see that old retouching. And that allows somebody, a dealer, collector, museum,
or an auction house to see the old work and to judge whether it was appropriate or excessive.
And in this case, they'll be able to see that I just put paint where paint was missing.
Totally appropriate. And the last step of any conservation is the application of a new
synthetic resin, ultraviolet stable, fully reversible varnish. So pretty much the complete
opposite of what was on here before. And it would be comical to spray this varnish on given the size
of this painting. So I'm going to use a brush. And even at that, this brush is comically large
for this small painting. Or is it? Using a bigger brush means I have to make less passes, means I
have less brush strokes, means I have more control. So using a big brush actually makes a lot of sense
on a small painting. So with just a couple of strokes, left to right and up to down,
I can apply the varnish to the painting. And that's just about it. Now I'm going to go back
and remove some of the varnish so that there's not so much. And then I'm going to let it start
to dry, let some of the solvent evaporate. And as it starts to get tacky, I'm going to go ahead
and go over the varnish and brush it out. And this is a technique that I've employed and kind of
developed for myself that allows me to add a micro texture to the surface of this varnish.
That is, if I don't want it super slick or super shiny, I can go back and forth and kind of scuff
it up, add some texture and diffuse the way the light reflects off of it. And so I can get a really
beautiful velvety satiny finish, which I think looks really, really good, which is why I continue
to use this technique. And after about an hour or so of letting the varnish dry, I can head over to
my table where I'm going to put it in the frame. Oh, hello. No, not today. So this is a padded
table to make sure that I don't do any damage when I'm wrapping up paintings. And look at that,
the painting fits perfectly into the rabbit. Now, instead of using big old tacks, I'm going to be
using screws and little Z or S clips. And these are just little metal brackets with screws that
will hold the painting into the frame. They don't do as much damage as a tack or a nail driven
through the stretcher into the frame. And they are super easy to install. And more importantly,
super easy to remove, which is always a good thing. And now, finally, after 35 minutes,
I can show you what you came here for, the final painting, which I think is why you watch these
videos. What do I know? Anyhow, from the painting as I received it, really not a painting at all,
a brown amorphous blob with no color differentiation, no detail, no sense of space to
a whole nother painting, one with a bright silvery sky, birds that couldn't be seen before,
trees that are really delicately painted, an entire image, a world opened up,
one that I think my client is going to enjoy for many years. This is ridiculous.
