The Center Square YT: Mileage-Based User Fees: A Viable Alternative to the Gas Tax?

VideoNest - Topical News
2 followers
Oct 8, 2026
The price of gas is impacting everything, not just the product that you're buying at the pump,
or the products you're getting shipped, or whatever else is in the commerce sector.
It also includes state and federal gas taxes.
Now, U.S. President Donald Trump, he did order expanded access to dyed diesel fuel,
and that's something that's actually tax exempt, but it's not allowed on highways.
Now, the move comes as diesel prices remain elevated.
What is dyed diesel?
Well, it's typically used in really heavy equipment,
like backhoes for construction or different types of combines for agriculture.
It's typically used in things that are not on public roads.
Now, at a campaign rally Monday in Nebraska,
the president directed the U.S. Agriculture Secretary
to ensure farmers have access to dyed diesel in high-demand areas.
The president also instructed the Transportation Secretary
to work with states, labor organizations,
and fuel distributors to increase access to dyed diesel.
It's typically colored red so that law enforcement can see whether it's used on public roads or not.
Now, the Center Square Energy Industry reporter, Alton Wallace,
he reports that the order from the president temporarily waives
tax penalties on using dyed diesel on public highways.
Normally, there's a minimum of a $1,000 fine,
and that's going to go until December 31st, waiving that fee.
Now, under the president's directive, the IRS will also waive, through the end of the year,
the $24.4 per gallon federal excise tax charged on purchases of on-highway diesel fuel.
Now, that's undyed.
Now, the president said all this could help an average trucker save around $100 for every fill-up.
Now, will it make an impact?
I guess we'll have to see when the new economic numbers come out later on this year.
What about the states that have eyed or have already done fuel tax suspensions?
We see it in Georgia.
We see the idea being kicked around in Ohio and several other states.
Sure, that helps the pocketbook, but what about keeping the roads in good shape?
You don't want to keep hitting those potholes or seeing degraded roadways
when you're getting to work or getting your kids to school.
But all of this being compounded with the fuel economy being up in vehicles.
You also have the adoption of electric vehicles.
Now, EVs, they don't use motor fuel,
but electric vehicles and more fuel-efficient cars and trucks, they all use the roads.
Joining us to talk about all of this and what some states are looking into
is the recent Foundation Transportation Policy Analyst, Jay Derr.
Jay, thanks for taking time with us here on The State.
As you heard, I set it up, and as you wrote in your recent article,
looking at the mileage-based user fee programs in several states,
you've got the adoption of EV vehicles.
You've got fuel efficiency that's increasing over the years.
All of this leading to less fuel consumption, but also with that,
less fuel taxes being paid by the taxpayer and being collected by state governments.
So what's going on here?
So you really hit on the major notes here, Greg.
You really covered most of it.
But one thing that's also a factor beyond just increased fuel efficiency
and the adoption of electric vehicles is you throw inflation into that mix,
and you get a really, really eroded transportation budget for a lot of these states.
So essentially, what's going on is that a lot of the states have said,
okay, with these compounding factors and two of them
that really eat into the gas tax directly, we should look at alternatives.
And that's where this idea of a mileage fee really comes from.
It's states going, we need a new modernized way
to try and fund infrastructure, roads, bridges, and we need to find it somewhat soon.
So a lot of states have been doing pilot programs,
but my report specifically looked at the four that have permanent ones,
Utah, Virginia, Hawaii, and Oregon, just to see what states could learn from that.
So let's talk about this idea of the mileage-based user fee program.
As you said, Utah, Oregon, Virginia, Hawaii have permanent programs.
Other states kicking around the idea.
It seems to have been a different approach from what,
at least we saw in the state of Illinois several years ago,
where they doubled the state gas tax from 19 cents to 38 cents.
And then they also tacked on an annual increase every year thereafter tied to inflation.
Your assessments, which way do you think that states are ultimately going to be going here?
More taxes or looking at a user fee type of system?
I think I've seen states interested in both.
To clarify, I think generally the more forward-looking one is a mileage fee
because it just ties the actual revenue you're generating
from your fee directly to use of the asset.
So instead of, for example, a fuel tax, just because that's kind of what we are all used to,
instead of that where you're essentially paying per gallon,
that doesn't necessarily tie one-to-one with how much you're driving
and how much you're degrading the roadway, whereas a mileage fee does.
So that's really one of the big advantages of that.
The goal is to scale it right now to have collection costs that are
at least closer to the fuel tax than what they are currently.
All of the programs that exist right now are still struggling with that.
And I think that's the biggest barrier, the practical barrier to implementation.
There's also concerns of privacy that we can get into a little bit later if you want to.
But more than anything else-
How did you see my notes?
How did you see my notes, by the way?
I mean, it's like the last thing I want to hit on is the privacy component here.
Because I mean, that's what I've heard for a decade plus hearing about this idea
and seeing it in places like Oregon, where they've implemented a pilot program
and now they've got a permanent program.
And all these other states that are doing this
is that privacy component.
But we'll get to that in a moment.
I do want you to touch on how each one of these states you laid out in your reporting
and how they all each have a kind of a different flavor to them.
Talk about each of those if you can.
Sure.
So, I mean, they all do stuff right in some ways.
Some of them do stuff wrong in some other ways.
There's strengths and weaknesses to each of these programs, really.
For example, I think if you were to make the perfect program, you'd have Virginia's scale.
You'd have Oregon's privacy protections.
You'd have Hawaii's sort of built into an existing system
way of collecting the information.
And you'd have Utah's fiscal discipline.
And to clarify a little bit on what that means,
there's a lot of different ways that states can go about implementing these programs.
They typically have to pick some sort of level of
the way that they want people to report and record their mileage.
So that's really the biggest, I think, cost saver that a state can implement.
And it can change the cost of implementation for that state.
Hawaii is really forward thinking.
They also have the newest program.
So we'll see if this pans out the way they're hoping it does.
I think it's looking optimistic, personally,
where they already do annual vehicle inspections.
So they already have access to an odometer in a vehicle,
and they already log the miles on it.
So they can essentially look at that already in the way that they handle cars.
And they can say, this is how much we have to charge this person
for their mileage this year.
It especially works in Hawaii because they don't exactly
have an out-of-state mile problem.
So the geography there helps a lot.
I don't think we can tell every state to copy the geography of Hawaii, though.
So that's not the best practice for that.
Does that answer your question there?
Well, yeah, it does.
Because you touch on the idea of looking at the odometer.
I know in Illinois, when the former Senate president from years ago
tossed this idea around, he was thinking about having
some kind of transponder in the vehicles that would then track.
Because, again, you raise the issue.
It's not just within a state.
Hawaii is unique because they don't have much
by way of being able to get out of state with a vehicle.
But in Illinois, we're surrounded by other states.
You've got states all over the country that have bordering states
where people live on the border.
They live in one state.
They go to work in another.
They travel with their family across country.
How do you, I guess, weed through out-of-state versus in-state miles
for a state's levy on mileage use?
So the states that have programs right now,
they tend to take a couple different approaches.
But the real one that I think is worth touching on right now
is the mileage recording option.
So if they have a GPS-enabled option,
and this is where it'll obviously kind of naturally segue
into the privacy stuff we want to talk about,
that is essentially how you would go and figure out
which miles are in-state and which miles are out-of-state.
Those miles are essentially recorded,
and then they are stripped of personal identifiable information.
And it essentially spits out a number to whatever the state auditor
or whatever agency that's running this is that says,
this is the amount in-state.
This is the amount out-of-state.
Here's the amount that they owe, is the idea.
So your identifiable information is not retained or recorded,
and that's the gold standard
for that kind of transmission of information.
But that is typically the way you handle that.
For an odometer reading,
you really are limited in what you're able to do.
That's one of the trade-offs.
You have a higher privacy option, but you have lower precision.
Yeah, these things are obviously something to consider
as the states are looking to shore up transportation dollars
to ensure that those roads are safe and in good shape,
because that's a public safety issue for sure.
But getting back to this question of privacy
and having some kind of tracking device in the vehicle
to ensure that they can track if vehicles in this state or that state
and which state's going to get that share of the use tax.
What do you say about those privacy concerns?
Because ever since I've heard about this a decade plus ago,
that's been the chief concern raised by civil libertarians.
Yeah, absolutely.
And I don't think it's wrong to raise that concern.
I think that states need to be forward-thinking,
both in the way that they're trying to fund their roads,
but also in the way they're trying to protect their taxpayers.
And I think the way that you do that is Oregon is, again,
I mentioned this when I was kind of listing the strengths
and weaknesses of those programs.
I think Oregon is probably the gold standard
because they have in statute laid out
that there is mandatory data deletion.
So within 30 days of your payment being processed
or a dispute being resolved, your data is deleted.
They don't retain anything that's identifiable in any way.
They might keep, I think they keep some mileage information
for their internal studies of the program,
but it's nothing that could ever be attributed to anyone.
And it's more aggregate.
It's like how many miles were driven in state
on the MBUF program kind of stuff.
It's not super granular or anything like that.
The other side of that is that it's just essential
that you have a mandatory warrant
to access any information on this.
For example, if a police officer says,
I need to see mileage information, they need a warrant.
They can't just go into the MBUF program and say,
I'm gonna look at how many miles X, Y, Z drove.
You need to have that kind of statutory protection.
And then above all else, I really think it's essential
that these programs and all of these people
that are looking for pilot programs,
you need to put this stuff in statute.
I don't think that it's enough for people right now
in the current climate,
especially when it comes to privacy concerns to say,
we'll get to it later.
We're on a pilot program right now.
I think if you're doing a pilot program,
that's the time to start looking
to put that stuff into statute.
There is not a point where it's too early
to make sure that people's privacy is being respected.
And that's essential for that kind of information
to be processed and held by the state safely.
So I think that's really the gold standard
of what needs to be done here.
You need to make sure that the stuff
is protected at the state level.
And you need to be sure that, again, it's in law.
You can't just have it be an agency rule.
It really, really needs to be something
that they have to follow that.
So that's, I think, the biggest thing for privacy on this.
Well, Jay, one of the takeaways I had
from reading your research was,
it's still a little too early to know exactly
how these programs are going to play out.
You want to be able to get a lot more long-term data done.
But looking at these four particular,
with these permanent programs,
gives you a kind of a hodgepodge
of these are the guide rails.
These are the best practices, so to speak,
of what other states looking at this should do.
But final question here,
is it going to replace the gas tax
if this is implemented properly?
Or are taxpayers going to be paying triple tax,
in some cases, quadruple tax for the federal tax,
the state tax, the mileage use tax?
And then in Illinois, they also have that sales tax
on top of the gas tax.
That is a great question.
And I think that's also something essential
to the state should lay out immediately,
is that this is a replacement.
This is not a supplement.
This is not an additional stream of revenue.
This is a replacement for one
that is not working in the modern day and age.
The idea is that this is meant to be
the way that we do this going forward.
Some states are looking to just do it for EVs,
but yeah, it's a replacement.
I'm Jay Derm with the Reason Foundation,
transportation policy analyst.
Greatly appreciate you taking the time.
Good insights.
We'll definitely talk with him again in the near future.
What do you think?
Should the gas tax be replaced with a mileage use tax?
And should privacy be top concern there?
Or should the triple, quadruple taxation be a concern?
What do you think?
Love to see your comments in the comment section below.
Be sure to like and subscribe so you can come back
and catch more of us here with the states.
We'll be right back.
