Sugar alternatives are supposed to be safe and healthy low-calorie options that can be used in place of refined and processed sugar.
Their great appeal is that they allow you to eat sweet things without gaining weight. But they don't actually work as well as you might think.
Before we get into that, though, here are the best natural sugar alternatives for patients with Hashimoto's:
1. Monk fruit
2. Allulose
3. Stevia
4. Sugar alcohols
But here's why I don't recommend them:
1. They are all heavily processed.
2. They aren't considered real food.
3. They aren't side effect-free.
4. And they aren't the miracle weight loss treatment you think they are.
Instead, I recommend forgoing the natural options and using natural sweeteners like honey and maple syrup.
If you aren't willing to accept the calories associated with these sweeteners, they you shouldn't eat their low-calorie alternatives because it will just make you crave more sweets in the future.
Check out this video for more information on which fruits and fruit juices are best for your thyroid: https://youtu.be/kBWCcdIApbc?si=alN-WdoOYmu7wfQD
Download my free thyroid resources here (including hypothyroid symptoms checklist, the complete list of thyroid lab tests + optimal ranges, foods you should avoid if you have thyroid disease, and more): https://www.restartmed.com/start-here/
Recommended thyroid supplements to enhance thyroid function:
- Supplements that everyone with hypothyroidism needs: https://bit.ly/3tekPej
- Supplement bundle to help reverse Hashimoto's: https://bit.ly/3gSY9eJ
- Supplements for those without a thyroid and for those after RAI: https://bit.ly/3tb36nZ
- Supplements for active hyperthyroidism: https://bit.ly/3t70yHo
See ALL of my specialized supplements including protein powders, thyroid supplements, and weight loss products here:
https://www.restartmed.com/shop/
Want more from my blog? I have more than 400+ well-researched blog posts on thyroid management, hormone balancing, weight loss, and more. See all blog posts here:
https://www.restartmed.com/blog/
Prefer to listen via podcast? Download all of my podcast episodes here: https://apple.co/3kNYTCS
Disclaimer:
Dr. Westin Childs received his Doctor of Osteopathic Medicine from Rocky Vista University College of Osteopathic medicine in 2013. His use of “doctor” or “Dr.” in relation to himself solely refers to that degree. Dr. Childs is no longer practicing medicine and does not hold an active medical license so he can focus on helping people through videos, blog posts, research, and supplement formulation. To read more about why he is no longer licensed please see this page: https://www.restartmed.com/what-happened-to-my-medical-license/
This video is for general informational, educational, and entertainment purposes only. It should not be used to self-diagnose and it is not a substitute for a medical exam, treatment, diagnosis, prescription, or recommendation. It does not create a doctor-patient relationship between Dr. Childs and you. You should not make any changes to your medications or health regimens without first consulting a physician. If you have any questions please consult with your current primary care provider. Restart Medical LLC and Dr. Westin Childs are not liable or responsible for any advice, course of treatment, diagnosis, or any other information, services, or product you obtain through this website or video.
#thyroid #hypothyroidism #hashimoto's
the promise of sugar substitutes is that
you get to enjoy incredible sweetness
without any of The Unwanted side effects
associated with excess sugar in other
words you literally get to have your
cake and eat it too but is this really
true sort of and we'll talk more about
that later but the starting argument
that I'll make is this if you have
Hashimoto's thyroiditis and you ever
have the choice between using an
artificial sweetener or a natural
sweetener always opt for the natural
version
the reason is simple unlike their
artificial counterparts they are not
associated with an increased risk of
Hashimoto an increased risk of diabetes
an increased risk of weight gain and
changes to taste perception this makes
them the clear winner if you have
Hashimoto's but not necessarily the best
option for weight loss but hold that
thought for just a minute because we
will come back to it if you are simply
looking for alternatives to process
sugar and artificial sweeteners then
here are the best ones first is monk
fruit monk fruit is a natural sweetener
that is derived from the monk fruit tree
and is about 250 times sweeter than
table sugar compared to Sugar it
contains zero calories next is allulose
allulose is considered by many to be the
go-to sugar replacement right now given
its low calorie content and sweetness
profile that is very similar to table
sugar compared to Sugar allulose
contains 90% fewer calories next is
Stevia which is approximately 200 to 300
times sweeter than sugar making it the
sweetest on this entire list Stevia
extracts are usually available as re a
and these are also considered zero
calorie and the next group are the sugar
alcohols these are extracted from fruits
and vegetables making them a natural
source and include things like orthol
manitol and Xylitol compared to Sugar
they are about 60 to 100% as sweet but
very depending on which one you're
actually looking at in terms of calories
Xylitol contains 2. 4 calories per gram
which is about 60% of that of table
sugar and Athol on the other hand
contains zero calories so which one is
best and which one should you use if you
have Hashimoto's my opinion is that it
doesn't really matter and the reason is
that if you are asking this question
you're probably thinking about it all
wrong here's why the first reason is
that every single one of these is
heavily processed and when you look at
the data it's clear processed foods
should always be avoided and even though
you should never consider a these
substitutes as food it's clear that they
still undergo a lot of processing alos
for instance is made by breaking down
corn starch and other plant sugars by
specific enzymes and these enzymes at
least as far as I can tell come from a
genetically modified ecoli strain Stevia
is created through a seven-step process
which includes things like liquid
extraction purification and
crystallization and xylitol is created
through a five-step process which
includes hydrogenation I'm not trying to
suggest that just because these are all
heavily processed that they are
automatically bad but generally speaking
the more processed something is the
worse it is for your body and I have a
hard time accepting that compounds that
undergo this degree of processing are
somehow good for the body given that we
know processed foods are so bad for the
body second is that they are not
considered food at their core these
compounds are really just there to
enhance the flavor of food but there's
no real reason to consume them and I
would argue there's no no real benefit
to using them either and anyone who is
trying to suggest that they are
beneficial is falling into the mindset
that they are somehow medicinal as
opposed to supplemental for instance
even though there's some data to show
that allulose may help with weight gain
diabetes and high blood sugar are you
really going to start taking allulose as
a supplement to treat these conditions
and if not are you really trying to
suggest that swapping out sugar for
allulose in your homemade brownies is
somehow going to treat your diabetes
doesn't it just make a lot more sense to
not eat those brownies if you're trying
to fix that problem I think so which is
why the idea of using these substitutes
as a way to continue to make unhealthy
choices just doesn't make a lot of sense
the third is that they come with their
own set of side effects while these
Alternatives definitely have far fewer
side effects compared to their
artificial counterparts they are not
completely side effect free fortunately
their biggest downside seems to be their
impact on the gut where they commonly
cause symptoms like gas bloating or
diarrhea right now it doesn't appear
that these natural versions negatively
impact the gut microbiome like their
artificial counterparts but it seems
hard to believe that they can cause GI
distress without at least impacting that
gut microbiome by some degree but this
side effect is not as concerning as the
fact that they may alter your perception
to taste and it's this that may impact
the thing I want to talk about next and
that is the fourth they probably aren't
the miracle weight loss treatment you
think they are let's be honest for a
minute here the real reason that you or
anyone else for that matter wants to use
these substitutes is because you like
the idea of being able to eat something
sweet at a lower cost of calories and
because they are natural you probably
feel a little bit better about yourself
by making that choice compared to eating
something artificial if this is true
then theoretically eating more of these
substitutes would allow you to lose
weight without changing your lifestyle
to a significant degree the problem is
it just doesn't work that way it
definitely doesn't work that way with
the artificial sweeteners as I already
showed you the more of those that you
consume the more likely you are to be
overweight but what does the research
show for natural options like Stevia one
study looked at this very thing and
here's what they found in a randomized
control setting the use of stvf for 12
weeks did not result in any impact on
weight insulin or blood sugar compared
to Placebo they did find however that
those people who were taking Stevia did
not gain weight unlike those people who
weren't taking it so maybe at best we
can say that Stevia at least doesn't
promote weight gain but it's not a
weight loss treatment at least not an
effective one and I think the reason for
this is simple people that lose weight
and keep it off have one thing in common
they find a way to change their
lifestyle and they stick to it the
problem with most of these sugar
substitutes is that their use continues
to promote unhealthy choices at least
for most people this is why people who
swap out full sugar soda for diet soda
don't really see any benefits to their
health the real issue is the fact that
they're drinking soda not whatever it's
being sweetened with and there's even
some evidence to suggest that these
sugar substitutes may make losing weight
more difficult by virtue of how they
impact your preference for sweetness the
more sweet things that come into contact
with your tongue the more you want them
so in a very real sense you may be
self-sabotaging your weight loss efforts
right now by trading a small reduction
in calories for an increase in Sugar
Cravings later down the road who do you
think is going to win your willpower or
your biologically driven food cravings
we already know how this story plays out
and willpower does not win and in my
opinion this is probably the main reason
that none of these sugar Alternatives
really help people lose weight so what
should you use the best way to think
about this is in terms of priority no
matter what the artificial sweeteners
like Splenda and aspartame should always
be avoided there's really just no good
reason to ever consume these likewise
there's really no good reason to consume
processed and refined sugars like table
sugar or brown BR sugar either there's
plenty of evidence to prove that these
cause problems the real question is
whether or not you should use natural
lowc calor sweeteners like Stevia or
allulose instead of Whole Food
sweeteners like honey or maple syrup and
here's where I'm going to Buck the trend
and suggest that honey and maple syrup
are superior for thyroid patients not
only are these options considered Whole
Foods unlike even the natural ones we
discussed they are minimally processed
they contain plenty of beneficial bio
active compounds and they don't trigger
those sugar Cravings like the
substitutes do most important of all is
the fact that adding these to your diet
will probably result in a change to your
lifestyle which is great is there a
place for these natural alternatives if
you have Hashimoto I would say sure a
little bit here or there in moderation
isn't going to cause a big deal the best
use case is to swap out these natural
options wherever you would have used
processed or refined sugar otherwise
that might be things like adding it to
your oatmeal or maybe your coffee as far
as which one you use that one is more of
a personal preference they are all
pretty much equal so long as you're
using a low dose if you do decide to use
them I would think of them as something
that's more akin to a treat or something
that you only use occasionally don't
think of them as a way that allows you
to continue to make unhealthy food
choices just with fewer calories an
example of this would be eating
sugar-free ice cream every single night
if your main goal is to lose weight then
what you really want to do is change
your lifestyle cut out all sources of
artificial and natural sweeteners and
just eat real Whole Foods like fruit and
fruit juices as your sole source of
sweetness not only are these much
healthier options they can also improve
your thyroid and if you want to learn
which fruits and fruit juices are best
for your thyroid then I'd recommend
checking out this video next