#History#Secrets On the ninth of July, 1873, a blast in the lock pit at Sault Ste. Marie, Michigan, broke into a hidden passage in the sandstone beside the St. Marys rapids. It ran two hundred and fourteen feet, dead straight and dead level, and at its end stood a gate of grey stone sixty-six feet high: two leaves meeting in one tight seam, thick stone lips stacked across each, and nothing on the near side to take hold of.
The army engineer who measured it had grown up on canal locks, and he saw what only a lock man would see: the gate was set to keep the river out. Four days later an old Ojibwe man came down the rapids in a canoe, asked three questions nobody could have answered for him, and left a warning in three parts. Do not knock on it. Do not build against it. Do not quiet the rapids. Within ten days the passage was walled up and entered on the drawings as a rock pocket.
This film sets six records side by side: an engineer’s blasting journal, a storehouse ledger and a time book, the words of a father and his son forty-nine years apart, a survey party’s field book from 1942, and a tape recorded in 1986. The ordinary explanation is given its full weight. In 1873 the seam took nothing. In 1942 it measured three and three quarter inches.
This documentary examines historical records, archaeological research, and Indigenous oral traditions. It presents documented findings alongside long-standing questions that remain open. Where accounts differ, both are presented. Nothing here is offered as a settled conclusion.
During the 1873 construction of the Sault Ste. Marie locks, workers discovered a massive, anomalous stone gate hidden within ancient sandstone. Despite warnings from the Ojibwe people and the structure's inexplicable physical properties, the government suppressed the find, walling it up and dismissing it as a natural rock pocket to avoid funding delays.
On the 9th of July, 1873, a blast in the lock pit at Sault Ste.
Marie, Michigan broke into a hidden passage in the red sandstone,
and at the end of that passage stood a stone gate 66 feet high.
Anders Strand carried the lanterns in.
He was thirty-eight, a hammer man from Norway,
and for three months he had worked beside the loudest water
in Michigan, the rapids of the St. Mary's River,
which fell past the canal works day and night.
About thirty feet into the passage, the roar of the rapids stopped,
all at once, as if someone had shut a door behind him.
The walls ran straight and flat on either side,
and the floor ran level into the dark.
Two hundred and fourteen feet in, the light reached the end.
Two leaves of grey stone, each wider than a house,
stood across the passage, and met in a single
straight seam down the middle.
They rose higher than any church steeple on Lake Superior. Across
the face of each leaf ran seven massive lips of stone,
one above another, each as thick as a man
is tall, and under every lip the stone was cut back
into a long dark slot, the way the gill
The steel covers of a fish lie over the openings beneath them.
the leaves were not built of blocks each was one piece
and they were set into sandstone that had been lying under the river
for close to a billion years the Ojibway already had a name
for that place and they said the gate was ancient long before
their own grandparents came to fish the rapids
The officer who measured it had grown up
on the locks of the Erie Canal,
and he saw something only a lockman would see.
The two leaves met at an angle,
and the point of the angle faced the rapids.
A lock gate is always set that way,
with its point toward the higher water,
so that the river itself presses it shut.
This gate had been built to keep the water out.
Whatever it was guarding lay on the far side,
and on the near side, where the men stood,
there was nothing to take hold of.
No post, no beam, no ring.
Four days later an old Ojibwe man came down through
the rapids in a canoe
and gave the army a warning in three parts.
Do not knock on it, do not build against it,
do not quiet the rapids. The army built against it within the week.
Before 50 years had passed,
other men had quieted the rapids.
Nothing in this file was ever locked away. It sits in six records,
kept across almost a century and a half by people
who never saw one another's pages.
Within 10 days of the blast,
the passage was walled up and entered on the drawings as a rock pocket,
but a journal in brown ink, an old fisherman's son,
and a Rodman steel tape kept something that the drawing did not.
The place to begin is the water,
because everything in this file comes back to the sound it made.
The Saint Mary's River is short.
It runs about 75 miles from the eastern end of Lake Superior
down to Lake Huron, and for most of that length it is broad
and quiet enough for a child to paddle.
At one place it is not. Where the river leaves Lake Superior,
the whole outflow of the largest freshwater lake
on earth pours over a ledge of red sandstone,
and falls about twenty-one feet in less than a mile over boulders
and shelves in a long white run of broken water
the French called it the Sault, the leap, the people
who lived beside it called it Baawating, the place of the rapids
Baawating was one of the great gathering places of the Ojibway.
In late summer and fall, whitefish crowded up into the fast water,
and men stood in the bows of birchbark canoes
in the middle of the rapids,
with long-handled dip nets, lifting fish out of the white water,
while a partner held the canoe steady against the current with a pole.
Travelers who saw it wrote that it looked impossible.
The French called the families who fished there the Saulteurs,
the people of the leap,
and the name followed the Ojibwe across half a continent.
People who lived at the Sault in the 1870s wrote
that the sound of the rapids never stopped.
It came through the walls at night,
it was there in the deepest cold of January,
when the river ran black between banks of ice,
because the rapids never froze.
Keep that sound in mind.
Everything else in this file turns on it.
Before we go down into the rock beneath the rapids,
a short word from us.
The real records behind our videos are now a book, The Old History.
Fifteen entries are free, as a PDF.
On theoldhistory.com, click Download the Free Sample.
Gumroad opens, and the price is zero.
Type your email, click Get, and the PDF is yours.
The full edition adds the audiobook.
Link in the description.
The rock under the rapids is very old.
The red and white mottled stone
that geologists call the Jacobsville Sandstone
was laid down as sand
and mud in a great rift valley around a billion years ago.
There were no plants on land then,
no animals with shells, nothing that walked.
The sand hardened into stone, the stone was buried and raised again,
and long after, ice sheets more than a mile thick ground across it
and left it scraped and bare.
The rapids are young by comparison.
When the last ice melted away,
the basins of the upper lakes filled and drained,
and filled again, as the land rose and the outlets shifted.
Around four and a half thousand years ago, Lake Superior,
Lake Michigan, and Lake Huron stood at a single level
and spread together as one enormous body of water.
Geologists call it Lake Nipissing.
There was no ledge to fall over at the Sioux then.
The water simply lay there, wide and still.
Then the outlets cut down, the levels dropped,
and Lake Superior was left standing higher than the lakes below it.
Its water had to go somewhere,
and it went over the sandstone at the Sioux.
The rapids began to run.
In geological terms, that was yesterday.
People were already living on these shores to see it happen.
The army arrived in 1820.
That summer, Governor Lewis Cass of Michigan Territory came up the
lakes with soldiers and demanded land at the Sioux for a fort.
The Ojibwe leaders refused,
and one of them raised a British flag over his lodge.
The meeting was saved from bloodshed by Ozar Washkodewikwe,
Susan Johnston, an Ojibwe woman married to a fur trader,
who sent word to the leaders in the night.
A treaty was signed that granted 16 square miles at the rapids
and kept for the Ojibwe the right to fish there forever.
Fort Brady went up beside the river two years later.
In 1836 at the Treaty of Washington the Ojibwe
and Odawa ceded most of what is now northern Michigan
and again kept their right to fish then came the metal
In the 1840s prospectors found pure copper lying in the rock
of the Keweenaw Peninsula and iron ore in hills near Marquette
every pound of it had to come down past the rapids for years it
was hauled around them by cart and wagon on a road through the town
and even whole steamboats were dragged on rollers along
the main street In 1855 a private company finished
the first canal around the rapids with two locks
of stone within twenty years the ore boats had outgrown it
In 1873, the federal government took up the work.
The Corps of Engineers began cutting a new
and much larger lock beside the old one,
deep in the sandstone of the riverbank,
under the direction of Major Godfrey Weitzel
at the district office in Detroit.
When it finally opened, it would be the largest lock in the world.
Today the locks at the rapids are known simply as the Sioux Locks.
The money for that lock came from Congress one season at a time,
in the yearly river and harbour bills.
When a bill was late or cut, the work slowed.
The lock that was begun in 1873 did not open until 1881.
That fact, the money arriving one season at a time, will return.
And one more thing about the paperwork.
The district office in Detroit managed more than one project.
It also kept the papers of the shipping channel,
through the St. Clair Flats, hundreds of miles to the south.
That detail will matter at the end.
The first record is an army book.
Captain Josiah Wren Abbott, of the Corps of Engineers,
kept the blasting journal for the lock pit,
and almost everything known about the first days comes from his hand.
Abbott came from Lockport, New York, born there in March of 1832,
in the town where the Erie Canal climbs the Niagara Escarpment
by a staircase of locks the townspeople call the Flight of Five.
His father tended those locks.
The boy spent his childhood on the stone walls,
watching boats rise and fall,
and he learned the rules of a lock gate
the way other children learn the rules of a game.
The two leaves hang on heavy posts. They close at an angle.
The point of the angle faces upstream, toward the higher water,
so that the canal leans on the gate and keeps it tight.
And a gate is worked from one side only, the side where the people are.
West Point took him in 1851.
He finished in June of 1855,
second in his class, which meant the engineers.
In the war he built pontoon bridges in Virginia
and siege lines before Petersburg,
and afterward he taught at the engineer school
at Willits Point in New York Harbor.
In the spring of 1873, at 41,
he was sent north to the St. Mary's Falls Canal.
The officers who served with him remembered one thing about him.
At Willett's Point, during a trial of underwater mines,
he discovered after the fact that he had set
a charge fourteen inches deeper than his own figures called for.
The trial had succeeded. Nobody else had caught the error.
Abbott reported it anyway, in writing, and lost a commendation for it.
His explanation, as one of them recalled it years later,
was that a number with a man's name under it had better be true.
At the Sioux, he kept his journal the same way.
It was a plain government book with oilcloth covers
and printed page numbers.
Each page opened with four entries.
The date, the height of the water on the gauge above the rapids,
the weather, and the wind.
Then, for every blast, the holes, their depth,
the powder, the hour, and what happened.
The ink is brown iron gall, laid down with a steel nib,
and for forty pages there is not a single correction.
On the 9th of July, the crew at Station 5 numbered 12.
Owen Trevale had charge of the powder.
He was 47, a Cornishman from Redruth who had learned
his trade underground in the copper mines of the Keweenaw.
Hiram Gage, 29, an Ohio man standing six feet one,
was among the drillers.
Baptiste Nolin drove the team.
He was 38, and Sue Bourne,
the son of an Ojibwe mother and a French-Canadian canoe man,
and he could pass from Ojibwe to French
to English in the middle of a sentence.
At the south end of the face swung Anders Strand,
38, a hammer man from Telemark in Norway,
not yet two years off the boat,
with a wife and two daughters in a rented room in the town.
It was Strand who first said something was wrong with the rock.
On the 7th, swinging his hammer at the south end of the face,
he stopped and told Treveil that the stone there answered differently.
Like a bell, he said, with a cloth over it.
Abbott entered it the same afternoon.
Strand reports ring at south end of face, tried with bar, solid.
Two days later the face was loaded with seven holes of black powder
and fired at twenty minutes before eleven in the morning.
Abbott's line for it is nine words long.
Round of seven at ten-forty.
Smoke came back.
Cold air.
What happened was this.
The blast threw the usual cloud of smoke,
but instead of rising and drifting off over the canal,
the cloud was shoved back toward the crew
by a wind coming out of the broken rock.
It ran low along the ground,
cold enough to raise the hair on a man's arms in July,
and it carried the smoke straight out across
the cut and over the river.
Treveil kept everyone back for twenty minutes,
his arms stretched across the cut like a gate.
He had carried men out of fresh smoke in the copper country,
and he was not going to do it again.
When he judged it safe, he and Abbott went in,
with Strand behind them holding the lanterns
and a hemp line paid out from a steel driven into the rubble,
so that they could feel their way back if the lights went out.
At the mouth, Abbott struck a candle.
The flame bent over and pointed back
the way they had come, toward the water.
There was no smell of gas.
Further in, the stone floor was clean.
No dust, though the cut outside was thick with it.
No droppings, no bones, no water, no growth of any kind.
Nothing on the floor to take a footprint, so they left none.
Then came the silence Strand would remember all his life.
About thirty feet from the mouth, the roar of the rapids simply ended,
as if a door had been shut behind them.
Abbott stood still for a minute by his watch,
and listened to nothing at all,
and then wrote one word, and gave it a line to itself.
Quiet. In the whole journal, no other entry describes a sound.
A cave was the natural first thought.
Water does work its way through sandstone and hollow it out.
But a water cave meanders, swells and pinches,
and its floor slopes the way the water ran.
This was a box.
The walls went straight up,
flat as a dressed wall in a cellar, and they paid no attention
to the stone.
The red and pale layers of the sandstone crossed them
and stopped at the surface as if sawn.
Water does not cut like that.
Abbott laid his tape across the passage at the mouth, 46 feet,
then at 60 feet in, at 120, and at 214, where the passage ended,
46 each time, never off by more than half an inch.
He levelled the floor in stations, as if it were a canal bottom,
and found that over its whole length it neither rose nor fell.
To a man raised on a canal, that was the plainest fact of all.
A floor without fall carries no water.
It was made flat because someone wanted it flat.
His compass put the passage a little west of due south,
aimed in under the rising ground behind the town.
At the end of it was the gate.
From that point on the page, the handwriting changes.
The ink is the same, but the letters grow larger,
and three times the nib tore the paper.
The first word below the line is gate, standing alone.
Then figures, and at the very bottom of the page,
the one question mark Abbott ever put in that book.
No post, no beam, no ring. Worked from the far side.
One other book noticed the day.
Silas Whitlock, the civilian superintendent,
kept the time book for the day labour.
On the 10th of July, he paid the station five crew a full day.
Abbott's journal shows no blasting at station five on the 10th.
Whitlock wrote, no reason. In the
margin there are only his initials, SW.
Abbott had put his question to the page. Four days later,
a man who had never set foot
in the passage would put almost the same question to him.
The second record is the gate itself, set down in Abbott's figures.
The passage opened at its end into a chamber of the same width
but far greater height,
so tall that lanterns lifted on poles lit only the lower half of it.
Treveil had brought a coil of magnesium ribbon
from a photographer's shop in Marquette.
Each strip burned for a few seconds
with a hard white light that filled the whole chamber,
and in those seconds Abbott sighted his transit on the top of the gate.
He took the angle from two stations on the floor,
a measured distance apart,
then burned a second strip and did it again.
Both times the answer was 66 feet.
Above the gate there were three more feet of rock before the roof.
For a sense of it, Hiram Gage, the tallest man on the crew,
Stood at the foot of the west leaf, and stretched his arms straight up.
His hands stopped short of the bottom of the lowest lip.
Each leaf measured twenty-three feet four inches across.
They did not stand in one flat plane.
They were set at an angle to each other,
so that the seams stood out about eight feet toward the river,
like the prow of a boat facing north.
Abbott worked the angle out on a page of the journal.
It came within a degree of the angle
of the gates on the flight of five.
For a lockman that settled one question at once.
On every canal he knew,
the prow of a gate points at the water it holds back,
because the water's own weight is what keeps the leaves closed.
This prow pointed at the river.
Whoever built it had meant to keep the river out,
and the side the crew stood on had been bone dry,
so the thing the gate was meant to protect was behind it.
Then there were the lips. Seven crossed each leaf from wall to seam,
stacked one over another from near the floor almost to the top.
Each stood out from the leaf like a mantel shelf, about 5 feet 8
inches deep from top to bottom, with a rounded, worn outer edge.
Beneath each one, the leaf was cut back into a long,
dark slot that ran the full width.
Gage pushed his arm into the lowest slot of the west leaf
to the shoulder and could not touch the back.
They tried a 10-foot rod. It slid into the end and met nothing.
The lips were spaced 9 feet 2 inches apart.
Abbott checked every one he could reach with a tape,
and the rest with the transit,
and the spacing held to within a sixteenth of an inch.
There was one exception. The lowest lip of the east leaf was missing.
Where it should have been, a plain flat band of the same
grey stone lay flush with the face, with no slot beneath it,
slightly lighter in tone,
its faint grain running crosswise to the rest.
Abbott's note is careful. Lowest lip, east leaf, absent.
Flatband in its place, different finish, as if repaired.
The leaves came down onto a sill,
a low ridge of the same stone that crossed the floor from
wall to wall, the way a canal gate shuts down onto
a sill of oak or granite.
Leaf and sill met with no gap.
The seam itself was a single straight line from sill to top.
Abbott tried his pocket knife in it at chest height
and could not start the blade.
He tried the corner of a sheet of paper
and could not start that either.
Two boards pushed together leave a line. This left almost nothing.
seam closed. Takes nothing, he wrote.
Nowhere else on either leaf was there a joint,
a peg, a tool mark, a carving, or a sign.
At the outer edges, where each leaf met the sandstone wall,
a thin, pale crust had grown across the junction,
perhaps an eighth of an inch thick.
such crusts grow where water seeps through stone and they grow slowly
but their rate depends on the water and the rock and Abbot honest
as ever put no number on it he noted only that the crust
was at the edges and not on the faces he took temperatures out
in the cut in the july sun seventy four degrees
In the chamber, 49. With the bulb of his thermometer pressed flat
to the west leaf for 10 minutes, 45.
The chamber was not cold because of the rock around it.
It was cold because of the gate.
Travail swung a sledge against the west leaf,
the way he tested rock in the mines.
There was no ring.
Abbott wrote that the blow died as though it had landed in wet clay,
and that the chamber gave back no echo.
Behind Travail, Strand spoke under his breath in Norwegian,
then repeated it in English for the captain.
Abbott took it down word for word.
At home they would say,
This is a door in the hill.
You do not knock on a door in the hill.
By then the knocking had been done.
Next they tried steel.
Three men drilled at the lowest lip
of the west leaf for a full hour by Abbott's watch,
one turning the steel, two striking, the rhythm of the lock pit.
When the steel came out, the stone showed nothing, not even a scratch.
The bit was dull, and its tip had turned
the dull blue of steel that has been hot,
though no one had felt any heat.
A cold chisel broke its edge on the first blow.
A file did slightly better,
and after some minutes,
Gage had scraped a pinch of grey dust onto a sheet of paper.
Abbott tipped it into a glass vial,
corked it,
and gave it the next number in his season's sample list.
Number nine.
His last bearing that day ran along the line the prow was pointing.
North, exactly,
across the canal toward the head of the rapids.
at the foot of the page he wrote one more sentence
and drew a line beneath it nothing else in the journal is underlined it
is shut from the inside next comes the version the public was given
and it fits in one sentence
the annual report of the chief of engineers for that year says
of station five only that a pocket of unsound rock met with there
was removed and the opening closed with masonry without delay to the
work that sentence could be right and the case for it is not weak
Jacobsville sandstone splits along flatbeds and clean vertical joints,
and a fresh blast can lay bare faces that look tooled.
Cold air does flow out of broken ground in that country,
winter air trapped in the rock and breathing out through the summer.
And Abbott was new to the post, raised on lock walls,
peering through powder smoke by lantern
and by seconds of magnesium light.
If anyone was likely to see a lock gate
in a wall of dark stone, it was he.
What the sentence leaves out is the rest of his page.
Walls 46 feet apart from the mouth to the end,
within half an inch, cut across the grain.
A floor dead level for 214 feet, 66 feet of height, sighted twice.
Thirteen lips set 9 feet 2 inches apart within a sixteenth,
slots too deep for a ten foot rod.
A drill blued without a mark to show for it,
stone colder than the air around it.
it also leaves out the letter that reached the Sioux in September
from the school of mines at Columbia College in New York where
sample nine had gone for testing not sandstone not granite
not trap heavier than any stone in our cabinet not determined
The storehouse ledger tells its own version.
On the 11th of July, Station 5 drew 16 barrels of cement,
180 cut stones from the pile dressed for the new lock walls,
one iron hatch frame two feet square, and one padlock with hasp.
Nobody puts a hatch and a padlock on a pocket of bad rock.
And the time book adds one more thing.
In the week after the 13th, two men from Station 5 are marked as gone.
Hiram Gage, one of them, with no reason, entered.
Owen Trevale asked in writing for a transfer
to the Lower Works, and got it.
Anders Strand stayed on.
Rock men do not walk off steady wages
in midsummer over a pocket of loose stone.
There is no need to imagine a plot to explain any of this.
The lock lived on yearly money.
A report that the line of the new lock ran
into a structure nobody could account for
would have brought inspectors and correspondents and delay,
perhaps a new route,
and a lost season meant a lost appropriation.
Congress was already grumbling at the cost.
And ten weeks after the blast, in September of 1873,
the banking house of J. Cook & Company failed in New York
and pulled the whole country into the panic of 1873.
Federal money for public works grew
scarcer than it had been since the war.
No office that must ask Congress for money each spring
reports a gate in its lock pit that nobody can explain.
It reports a pocket and it closes the door.
What the office did not know was that someone
at the Rapids already knew about the door.
The third record was never written by the people it belongs to.
It was carried in speech, by a father and then by his son,
and it reached paper twice, forty-nine years apart.
On the 13th of July, four days after the blast,
a birchbark canoe shot down the rapids from the
Canadian side and nosed in below the works.
An old man rode in the bow, a man of about 35
knelt in the stern, steering. Abbott gave them one line.
Old man from the North Shore,
Nolan calls him Kesic, Ojibwe, his son with him.
the old man came no nearer than the lip of the cut a hundred yards
or so from station five and sat down on one of the dressed stones
stacked for the lock walls he kept his eyes away from the breach
the whole time when he needed to refer to it he did not raise a finger
he tipped his chin in its direction abbot wrote as one does toward
a person who might overhear he talked in Ojibwe
and nolan turned it into english
first he had questions three of them and abbott wrote
the answers beside them do the doors lean toward the white water they
do on your side is there anything to pull on there is not
the bottom one toward where the sun comes up
is it different from the rest here the journal shows
a blot where the pen rested on the page too long then
None of the answers seemed to surprise him.
Abbott compared his nodding to that of a man
who asks the hour only to hear what he already knows.
Then the old man made four statements,
and Abbott numbered them in the margin as Nolan gave them.
1. It does not belong to us.
2. It was not us who closed it.
3. When the one water became two,
they went in through it and closed it after them.
4. It will open when the rapids go quiet.
Beside the fourth, Abbott wrote, not understood.
Through Nolan he asked what quiet rapids could mean.
The old man looked over at the white water, loud as ever
a few hundred yards off, and would say nothing more on that point.
What he would say was the warning, in three parts,
do not knock on it, do not build against it, do not quiet the rapids.
Abbott added a small note beneath, almost an apology.
Travail knocked, the ninth.
That evening Nolan told the captain what he understood of it,
and Abbott set down a paragraph.
The old people along this shore, Nolan said, spoke of a time
before the rapids, when the big lake,
and the lakes below it, were all one water, and a canoe
could pass from one to the next without a portage.
When the water dropped and the lakes were parted,
the river broke white at the Sioux, and beawating began.
neither man could have known that geologists would one day map
exactly such a time and name it lake nipissing collectors later
printed versions of that teaching none of them has a gate in it
the son was called joseph he was a whitefish man like his father
with a wife and children of his own on the canadian shore
He dip-netted in the rapids as long as the fishery lasted,
and in later years he worked the decks of oar-boats that rose
and fell in the very locks his father had warned against.
Most of his life he lived at Garden River,
a few miles down river, on the Canadian shore.
In the summer of 1922,
a University of Michigan graduate student, Ruth Ellingson, 26,
was collecting Ojibwe place names along
the St. Mary's for the university's new museum,
writing them into brown cloth notebooks.
On the 17th of August, she spent an afternoon
at Garden River with Joseph Keswick,
then about 84, the two of them on a bench by his door.
He used English for most of it, and Ojibwe, where English failed.
He said he had been the man in the stern of the canoe.
He went through his father's three questions
and four statements in order,
and then he showed her, with his hands,
how the old man had explained the gate on the paddle home.
He pressed his palms together, standing upright,
fingertip against fingertip.
He held them there.
Then, very slowly, he parted them,
until a hand's breadth of air lay between,
and he left them that way.
He told her the name of the place.
Ellingson spelled it as best she could,
and it will not be attempted here.
Next to it she wrote what he said it meant,
where they closed themselves in.
Then he recited what had been handed to him,
and she took it down line by line.
Every line began the same way.
They said the doors were there before the people came to the rapids.
They said the keepers of the doors lived under
the high ground to the south.
They said the keepers came out only when the water was quiet.
they said the water was quiet then because the big lake
and the lower lakes were one they said when the water fell
and the rapids started talking the keepers went in through the doors
and closed them and the people on the north shore heard the closing
they said the doors are cold to a hand
because a hand is on the wrong side of them they said not to fish under
the south ledge after dark they said not to point at the place
Last of all, he spoke his father's fourth statement exactly,
and Ellingson recorded it,
with no idea it had been written down once before,
in an army captain's book.
It will open when the rapids go quiet.
She asked the obvious thing. Waiting for what?
What is behind it? Her notes mark a long pause.
Then he told her that this part was for the
Ojibwe, and was not going into her notebook.
At the foot of the page, she wrote a single line.
Remainder withheld at the speaker's request.
She honoured that, and this record honours it too.
In the margin of the same page,
dated that day, is a short note of her own.
J.K. says the gates at the head of the rapids
were almost closed this week. Fish poor.
By 1922 the rapids were no longer the rapids of 1873.
Joseph Keswick had held the place name,
the three questions, the four statements,
and the movement of the hands for 49 years.
A government box can lose a page.
A man who carries a sentence for half a century does not
lose it. Nobody ever meant for these two records to meet.
Put them next to each other anyway.
One is a captain's journal, kept with a transit,
a level, a compass and a thermometer,
by a man who stood at the foot of the gate
and laid his instruments against it.
The other is a student's notebook from 49 years later,
about a place she had never heard of,
taken from a fisherman who steered a canoe that day
and never went into the passage.
His father stayed a hundred yards from it.
The journal describes two leaves closing on one seam.
The fisherman pressed two palms together.
The journal says the prow of the gate faced the river,
built to keep the water out.
The fishermen said the doors were closed at the moment the water fell,
and the rapids began to talk.
The journal says there was nothing on the near side to open it with,
and underlines that it was shut from within.
The father asked whether there was anything on that side to pull,
and said the keepers went in and closed it after them.
The journal sends the passage south, under the high ground.
The fishermen put the keepers under the high ground to the south.
The journal records stone colder than the air.
The fisherman said a hand on it is cold
because it is on the wrong side.
The journal records the lowest lip of the east leaf missing
and a flat band in its place.
The father asked about the bottom one on the sunrise side
before anyone had told him what the gate looked like.
some of this may be chance and that should be said all lock gates have
two leaves and all of them point at the water they hold Nolan had
been in the cut on the ninth and might have repeated what
the crew said each of these can stand alone as an explanation
the sunrise question cannot it came from a man who would not look
at the hole and it came back in the same order forty-nine years later
from his son to a stranger who had never seen the journal
There is one last visit in the journal before the passage was closed.
On the 19th of July, Abbott took Treveil
and Strand back in for a final round of measurements.
When the tape was rolled up, Strand went to the seam,
tugged off one glove, and pressed his bare
hand to the stone at the level of his eyes.
He left it there. Without intending to, Abbott found
himself counting the seconds.
A minute went by with nobody speaking. Treveil had his hat in his
hand. So, Abbott realised, did he,
though he could not remember removing it. When Strand stepped back,
he said one thing, and Abbott wrote it inside quotation marks.
there is someone on the other side listening, Abbott
then laid his own palm on the seam and described the feeling
the only way he knew how as an engineer cold even like
the push of standing water against a gate but there is no water
a little lower he copied out the old man's fourth statement a second
time in quotation marks as though copying it might unlock it it will
open when the rapids go quiet under it a short line in his own voice
the rapids here never go quiet by afternoon the masons were at work
Forty feet in from the breach,
they built a wall of the cut stone across the passage
and bedded it in cement from the sixteen barrels.
Low in the wall they set the iron frame,
two feet square, hung a plate in it,
and snapped the padlock through the hasp.
The key went into Silas Whitlock's pocket.
Rubble was shoveled back into the breach,
and the new lock wall rose over the top.
On the drawing for Station 5,
a draftsman shaded a little rectangle behind the wall and lettered it.
Rock pocket filled.
The next morning, the journal moves on to station six.
For station five, it has one closing line.
Pocket filled.
Work resumed.
Sixty-nine years would pass before anyone opened that hatch.
The fourth record was made by men looking for something else entirely.
In the spring of 1942,
the lock begun in 1873 was 60 years old and too small for the times.
The United States was at war, and most of the iron ore
for its steel came down from Lake Superior through the Sioux.
The government treated the locks as one
of the most vital places in the country.
Troops guarded the canal around the clock,
barrage balloons hung above it,
and taking a photograph there was against the law.
To move more ore, the Corps of Engineers would demolish the old lock,
And build a bigger one on the same ground,
to be named for General Douglas MacArthur.
New walls could not be poured beside old ones,
without knowing what lay behind the old ones.
A hidden cavity behind a lock wall can give way
when the chamber is full.
So a survey party walked the old walls, sounding for voids,
and the original drawing sent them straight to Station 5
and its shaded rectangle.
Rock pocket filled.
The man in charge was Raymond Kessler,
an assistant engineer, 44 years old.
He had been born in Duluth in 1898,
had served with the engineers in France in 1918,
and had spent the 20 years since on harbours
and channels around the upper lakes.
He kept his notes in pencil,
in standard field books, and kept them well.
His rodman that spring was Leo Paquin, 40,
a Sioux man who had carried a rod
for the Corps every working season for nearly 20 years.
On the 14th of April 1942,
they dug the fill away from behind the old wall at Station 5
and came to the masonry, and in it the iron hatch.
The padlock had rusted into a single lump,
and Paquin had to saw it off.
Behind the plate, the passage ran exactly where the drawing put it.
Kessler had never heard of Abbott or his journal.
All he had was a drawing that said pocket,
so he measured like a man who expected a pocket.
Passage width, 46 feet.
Breach to gate, 214 feet.
Height of the gate by transit, 66 feet.
Lips, 7 on the west leaf and 6 on the east,
a flat band where the east leaf's seventh belonged.
Thermometer against the stone, 45 degrees.
Figure after figure he wrote down
the same numbers Abbott had written sixty-nine years before.
Two men, neither aware of the other,
came out of that passage with the same numbers.
Unlike Abbott, Kessler carried an electric flashlight.
He did not need it to find the seam.
The seam had opened. The leaves now stood apart, edge parallel to edge,
from the sill all the way up.
Kessler ran a steel tape across the gap at chest height.
Three and three quarter inches.
He put the flashlight to the opening,
and the beam went in and stayed in.
It lit no back wall and no floor, and came back off nothing.
Paquin fed a ten-foot rod through the gap to its full length
and swung it back and forth.
It touched nothing.
He let a pebble drop through.
Neither man heard it strike.
Air moved through the gap, cold and dry and without any smell.
But this time it was not blowing out at them, as it had in 1873.
When Paquin lit a cigarette, Kessler watched the smoke flatten,
slide along the floor to the opening,
and slip through it in a thin grey line.
Later that day, an old woman came down
to the lock from a house on Portage Avenue.
Her grandson worked in the canal office,
and he had mentioned that the government men had opened
the old pocket at Station 5.
She was 73. Kessler let her look through
the hatch from the mouth of the passage.
She stood a long while,
then told him that her father had worked on the old lock in 1873,
and that all his life he had said one thing about it.
Kessler wrote it down in her words.
It was shut when I put my hand on it.
Her father was Anders Strand. Kessler's field book sets two
entries side by side without comment.
Strand, closed 1073, seam now three and three quarter inches.
underneath he did what an engineer does with two numbers
and a span of years he divided and got a little over
a twentieth of an inch a year then he struck the figure through
and wrote next to it rate cannot be assumed constant
That night, a telegram went to the district office in Detroit.
Void at Old Canal Station 5 contains stone structure,
two leaves 66 feet high, now open about four inches.
Request instructions.
Detroit answered by morning.
Structure outside scope of lock construction.
Seal and proceed.
Schedule governs.
So it was sealed, the hatch plate was welded shut,
and concrete was poured behind the old masonry.
On the drawings for the new lock,
at the spot where the old wall would disappear into the new one,
a draughtsman hatched a small rectangle and wrote beside it,
Old Void, Sealed, Not Explored.
Kessler added one more line in pencil
in the margin next to the entry for the 14th.
He knew nothing of Keswick or his son.
He knew only what any engineer at the Sioux knew in 1942,
that since the gates across the head of the rapids had been finished,
the white water ran at a fraction of its old force,
and some weeks scarcely ran at all.
His line reads,
As if it knows the rapids have gone quiet.
The MacArthur Lock opened on the 11th of July, 1943.
Kessler never wrote about Station 5 again.
Leo Paquin worked for the Corps at the Sioux until he retired,
and spent the rest of his life within sight of the locks.
Decades later, someone asked him about that April,
and he answered in one sentence.
It comes near the end of this file.
The fifth record is not at the Sioux at all,
and that is why it matters.
A fair listener may ask whether all of this belongs to one gate,
one journal, and one family.
It does not.
The first piece is the water itself.
The Ojibwe teaching says the lakes were once one water,
and a canoe could pass between them without a carry,
and the geology says the same.
Few oral traditions anywhere line up
so closely with something written in the rock.
The second is copper.
On Isle Royale and the Keweenaw, the first American miners
of the 1840s found thousands of old pits sunk into the copper veins,
some with stone hammers still lying in them,
worked between roughly 7,000 and 3,000 years ago.
Early accounts say the Ojibwe told
the miners plainly that the pits were not theirs.
Once more, something was left in the rock by someone who came before,
The third is painted on a cliff of Lake Superior,
at Agawa Rock on the Ontario shore.
Among the old red figures there is Mishi Peshu,
the great horned underwater lynx of Ojibwe teaching,
a powerful being of the deep water,
who was said to guard the copper of the lake.
A guardian under the water, behind the rock.
One more piece cannot be verified, and it should be treated that way.
In June of 1883, when the lake stood higher than anyone
at the Sioux could recall,
A local newspaper ran four untitled lines.
A rapids fisherman, it said, had heard in the high water
a sound out of the rock by the canal like a heavy door swinging to.
He was described as a sober man.
The next item in the column is an advertisement
for an 18-foot birch canoe,
in good order, to be seen at the landing.
The sixth record is a record of losses.
No fire, no shredder, no order to destroy.
Each page simply wandered off in the way paper does.
Abbott's journal was filed at the district office
in Detroit with the other papers of the season.
But it was bound into a bundle that also held
his survey notes from a short assignment that
spring on the St. Clair Flats channel,
and the clerk who labelled the bundle wrote only
St. Clair Flats. That is the detail from the beginning.
Anyone looking for the Sioux Canal
looked under St. Mary's.
The journal sat under a channel 300 miles away.
Decades later, the whole bundle went to the Federal Records Center
in Chicago, still under St. Clair Flats.
The vial of Sample 9 had been tied to the journal
with a length of string, alongside the letter from New York.
When someone untied that bundle in 1976, the letter was still there,
and so was the vial, its cork pushed tight.
There was nothing in it.
Ruth Ellingson's notebooks went to the University Archive.
On the spine of the one that held Joseph Keswick's words,
she wrote an abbreviation for Bewarting.
A cataloger read it as Bayfield,
and shelved it with the papers from Bayfield, Wisconsin,
at the far end of Lake Superior. It is still catalogued that way.
Kessler's report reached Detroit Complete.
The final version does not mention Station 5.
In the carbon copy, in its place, is one typed line.
Section on station 5 omitted as not pertinent.
His field book records nine photographs taken inside the passage.
The district file holds six.
The three of the open seam were taken by the officer
who reviewed all photographs
at the locks under wartime rules, and no record says where they went.
The journal surfaced in 1976.
Martin Doyle, a history graduate student at Michigan State,
was combing the Chicago boxes for a thesis
on dredging in the Great Lakes, and halfway through
the St. Clair Flats bundle, he opened an oilcloth book.
A sheet of Canal Works letterhead was folded
into the back cover. It was dated the 10th of July,
1873, the day the crew drew pay for no work.
Captain, fill the pocket and enter it as rock.
Pay the men for today.
I have spoken to them.
Nothing to Detroit until the money is voted.
S.W. Doyle copied it all and wrote to the Corps.
The answer was polite.
There was no record of any structure at Station 5.
He became a teacher in Marquette and kept his copies in a drawer.
The last voice belongs to 1986.
A volunteer for a historical society in Sault Ste.
Marie was taping the memories of older residents,
and one of them was Leo Paquin, now 84.
Most of the tape concerns his years on the canal.
Toward the end, the volunteer asked
if he had ever been inside the old lock.
There is a long silence on the tape.
Then Paquin says this.
Soon as we got in there, we taped that gap.
Three and three quarters.
Before we sealed it up, Mr. Kessler taped it again.
Same tape, same spot.
Three and seven eighths.
We'd been in there an hour and thirty-five minutes.
Both numbers are in Kessler's field book.
The first sits in the morning entry.
The second is on the following page,
in the list of closing measurements,
with nothing written beside it.
Only the first went into his report.
Sixty-nine years had opened the gate three and three-quarter inches.
Ninety-five minutes opened it another eighth.
For more than forty years those two figures lay a page apart,
and no one compared them.
A reporter who learned
of the tape asked Paquin what he believed he had seen down there.
Paquin answered him the way he answered everyone, with one sentence.
We closed it because we were told to, not because it was done.
there is a version of all this that settles into comfortable categories
and it deserves its strongest form the Jacobsville stone breaks along
flat beds and straight joints cold air pours from hollows in it
and an officer raised on lock walls could see
a gate in a face of dark layered rock
Magnesium light lasts seconds,
and a transit read in seconds can be wrong by several feet.
For 1,873, there is only one written witness.
The old man's words passed through an interpreter
who had been in the cut himself.
Joseph Keswick spoke 49 years later,
and memory gathers what the world adds to it.
An eighth of an inch between two tape readings
at the end of a long day underground is within
the error of a tired hand.
A vial can be emptied by a careless clerk. Every one of those points
is reasonable, and none needs bad faith,
but each one removes a single record and leaves
the others standing.
The joints explain the walls, not a level floor over 214 feet.
The interpreter explains the two doors,
not the question about the sunrise side from a man
who never looked at the whole.
A tired hand explains an eighth of an inch,
not three and three quarters, in a seam that
would not take paper.
And all of it could be settled cheaply,
with one borehole through the south wall of the
Macarthur Lock.
In more than eighty years, nobody has drilled one.
The MacArthur Lock still lifts ships at the Sault,
beside the Poe Lock, and a new lock
is being built beside them.
Every winter the locks close,
and some chambers are pumped dry for repair.
A maintenance note from February of 2019 records one thing in passing.
Along the south wall of the MacArthur Chamber, near its western end,
a strip of floor about 46 feet wide did not take ice,
though the air in the chamber stood below zero for nine days.
Cause not determined.
The rapids still run, but not as they did.
The sixteen gates at their head, finished in 1921,
decide how much of Lake Superior goes over the ledge,
and in most seasons it is a fraction of the old river.
The great whitefish fishery of Bewarting is gone.
Where the water once ran white from bank to bank,
much of the ledge now lies bare.
The Ojibwe are still here, on both sides of the river.
The Sioux St. Marie tribe of Chippewa Indians,
the Bay Mills Indian community, Garden River, and Batchewana.
Children at the Sioux are learning Anishinaabemowin again,
and Ojibwe fishermen still set nets in these waters under the treaties.
What Joseph Keswick's family knows about
the place where they closed themselves in
still belongs to them, and they have not chosen to give it away.
On a calm morning now,
a person standing on the lock wall hears ship engines, gulls and wind.
The rapids are a low murmur off to the north.
In 1873, the seam took nothing.
In 1942, it measured three and three quarter inches in the morning,
and three and seven eighths by afternoon.
That was the last time anyone held a tape to it.
The easy explanations are all still on the table.
Jointed sandstone, an engineer's training,
an interpreter's kindness, an old fisherman's memory.
The Ojibwe name for the place uses none of them.
It does not say cave, and it does not say rock.
It says what happened there, where they closed themselves in.
Families at the Sioux kept more than the government did.
Letters home, a grandfather's time book,
a photograph of the old wall before the new locks swallowed it.
If something like that has come down to you, write it below this video.
Abbott wrote that the rapids here do not stop.
They have been nearly silent for a hundred years.
Before we close this file, one more short word from us.
The real records behind our videos are now a book, the old history.
15 entries are free as a pdf.
On the oldhistory.com click download the free sample. Gumroad opens
and the price is zero. Type your email, click get and the pdf is yours.
The full edition adds the audiobook. Link in the description.