The 65 Year Old Medicare Myth
31 Video Views·Jan 9, 2025
All right, we are officially back here on the live. If you are watching this live, feel free
to jump into the comments with any questions that you have around our topic, which is,
do you have to take Medicare at 65 years old? Now in the chat, we do have some rules, please,
please be kind. My wife is helping me on this chat. So she is off screen here. She didn't want
to be on screen. She's drop dead gorgeous. So I am sorry that everybody else doesn't get to see
her, but she wanted to be off camera. She's going to help me man the chat. She is not in the Medicare
world. So she isn't going to answer your questions, but she is going to make sure that the spammers
are kicked out. She's going to make sure that she highlights the comments that we want to get to.
I'm going to talk for about probably 10 or 15 minutes, and then I'll open it up to questions
and answers around what's going on. So thank you to her for moderating, which reminds me,
if you haven't already subscribed to our newsletter, that's something that I definitely
recommend. I'll actually show you where you can see that on our website here. I tell silly stories.
And the most recent one was about how we met and kind of our love story. But we'll share retirement
tips with Social Security, Medicare, all kinds of retirement things. There's a book recommendation,
and then goofy stories from life. So here's where you can sign up for the newsletter. If you haven't
already on the retirement nerds.com. All right, let's get into this. So I am going to talk about
what I think is the most common myth in the Medicare world, at least it's the one that I get
most often, we get 1000s of people reaching out. And this is the one that we tackle more than any.
And that is the myth that you have to take Medicare at 65 years old. And there are a lot of
variations on that that we're going to cover here. And so that's what I want to talk about here. Now,
millions of Americans should not take Medicare at 65. And they will not be penalized. So I'm going
to go over who should consider delaying Medicare past 65. After I talk about who should go on
Medicare at 65 to avoid penalties. And avoiding penalties is the big condition in this statement,
because we want to avoid penalties. And we're talking about the Medicare Part B as in Bravo,
and Part D as in Delta or drug penalties that are associated with not taking Medicare at the
appropriate times. There are four situations where you must take Medicare at 65. Or you will
face penalties or problems. And the first is going to be if you don't have any health insurance at
all. So if you're not covered by any health insurance plan, once you reach 65 years old,
if you don't take Medicare when you should, there will be penalties associated with that if you
decide to pick up Medicare later. The second is if you are in an ACA, so the Affordable Care Act,
Obamacare, there are a lot of different names for it. But an ACA marketplace plan,
whether that's an individual plan, or a family plan on the ACA marketplace, you lose any subsidies
that are related to the ACA plans once you become eligible for Medicare. So you would want to move
off of the individual plan on to a Medicare arrangement. The third is going to be if you
are covered by COBRA. So if you've lost coverage from your employer, whether that's your voluntary
leaving, or you've been terminated, and COBRA coverage is what you have, you're going to want
to move on to Medicare when you become eligible for Medicare. Otherwise, you'll be facing penalties
if you don't and you stay on COBRA past your initial enrollment period for Medicare.
And finally, the fourth is if you are not actively working, and you are covered by some sort of a
retiree plan. Now many employers have these retiree plans in place for their retired employees.
They're less common now, but there are still people that are interacting with them. So if
on one of these retiree plans at 65, you're going to want to go on Medicare to avoid penalties,
and a lot of these retiree plans end up becoming secondary to Medicare anyway. And we're going to
talk about what happens when a plan like that becomes secondary to Medicare, and you don't
have Medicare in place. So these are all focused again on avoiding the Part B and Part D penalties.
I hear from folks all the time who bring up something around, you have to get Part A only,
or you just have to get Part A at 65. This is incorrect. There is no Part A penalty. There is no
problem for you postponing Part A past your 65th birthday. Again, in the situations that we're
going to cover the penalties around Part B and Part D. Part B is your medical coverage. Part D
is your drug coverage. Now people with TRICARE for Life, in order to keep TRICARE for Life,
you need Medicare Parts A and B. So I didn't mention this in the penalty list because it
isn't penalized in the same way, but you definitely don't want to lose TRICARE for
Life. So that's something where you would want to get Medicare Parts A and B.
Now let's talk about the situations where you do not need to take Medicare. And there are a
few reasons here, actually two of them. So the first reason is if you are actively working,
and you are covered by your employer group health plan. And it's important to mention that you are
actively working. So I mentioned those retiree plans where you're not actively working. In this
case, if you're actively working covered by your group health insurance plan, you do not need to
sign up for Medicare at 65. You don't have to sign up for Medicare Part A, you don't have to sign up
for Medicare Part B, you don't have to notify anybody about this, you don't have to go tell
Medicare, hey, I'm thinking of delaying, you just stay on your employer plan in the event where
your employer plan is stronger than your Medicare coverage. Now, as long as you are working, and
you're actively employed, you can keep delaying Medicare. Now the oldest that I've seen personally
is 93 years old, somebody went on Medicare for the first time at 93 years old, we'll get into
the social security side of things. So for social security benefits, they did have Part A, but they
went on Part B at 93 years old, there's no penalties because they were actively working
covered by that plan. So that's the first way that you can delay Medicare past 65. No penalties. The
second way is if your spouse is actively working, and you are covered by your spouse's group health
plan through their employer. In this case, it's going through the same rules here, you are not
going to be penalized, you don't have to go on either Medicare Part A or Part B, you don't have
to notify anybody, you can stay off of Medicare for as long as you're covered by your spouse's
insurance plan. And then once they decide to retire, or if they're let go and you lose that
health coverage, you have a special enrollment period where you can get on Medicare. Without
any penalties, you can get a supplement plan without having to go through medical underwriting,
you can get an advantage plan, all of those options are open to you once you've left your
Now, what I have experienced, at least in those who reach out to me is there are kind of three
main sources as to who is spreading these rumors, that aren't what I would say, they're more
intentional about spreading this rumor, right. So if you've heard this, and you're talking to a friend
or family member, that's one thing. But there are professionals in the world who are kind of spreading
this rumor more often than others in what I'm seeing. So the first would be and they all have
interest in what's going on here. So the first would be Medicare agents or Medicare brokers,
and they are telling people that they need to go on Medicare at 65, even though they are still
working. And I've mentioned this in other videos, that is because there is a very lucrative market
of people that we refer to as T 65, they are turning 65. This is the first time they're going
on Medicare. And this is a marketing opportunity for a lot of brokers, because they can just
purchase a bunch of lists of millions of names of people who are turning 65 and market to them like
crazy. And the commissions for somebody first going on Medicare are higher in that first year
than they are in subsequent years. Plus, those commissions, you're going to get more if you get
them started on Medicare early rather than telling them to delay a few years. So let's say that they
were supposed to delay till 67. Well, you're losing out on commissions from 65 66. And then
when they go on at 67. So brokers who aren't necessarily even maybe they don't know that
this is the real case, but they should. Those that's one group that is spreading this what I
would call myth or rumor. Now, the second would be insurance companies. And I'm going to loop this
together with that what they're called employee benefit brokers. So the way that employer groups
work is that if you're working for a company, most companies are working with a broker kind of like
how you have a Medicare broker who's going to help you shop different Medicare plans. The employer
groups also have brokers, employee benefit brokers that shop insurance companies for that group
health plan for all of their employees. So that insurance company and the employee benefit broker
would love it if those who are Medicare eligible, dropped off of the employer group plan, because
the employee benefit broker can then go to the group and say, hey, your insurance premiums aren't
going to increase as much because we got the Medicare eligibles off the plan. So they are
those who are kind of spreading this idea that as soon as you reach 65, you need to jump on to
Medicare and jump off of the employer group plan. And the third entity or group that is kind of
spreading this myth is related as well. And that's within the employer group, that's going to be the
HR teams or the HR professionals in these groups. And again, they're kind of going through the same
idea, if we can move people off of the plan, that's going to lower the premiums for all of
the other employees. It's important for HR professionals, or employee benefit brokers,
and any employees who are working for insurance companies, it is illegal for employer groups
with 20 or more employees to force the employee off of the group plan and on to Medicare. In fact,
they're not even allowed to encourage the employee to move to Medicare and move off of the group
plan, meaning they can't tell them, hey, we're going to give you a bonus, we're going to give
you a raise, we'll contribute HRA dollars to help offset the premiums. All of that is a big no-no.
And I've covered this in a lot of videos, just because there are things that are big no-no's
or illegal to do, it doesn't stop people from doing it. So if your HR person is telling you,
you're an employee of this company and you have more than 20 or more employees as part of your
company, they're telling you you've got to move to Medicare, that's a problem. And your risk or
your liability in challenging them in that is kind of on you as to whether you want to take that or
not. But in terms of the law and the rules around that, they are not allowed to do that. If you are
someone who's in HR, please keep this in consideration as you're talking to your employees.
I mentioned if you have an employer that has 20 or more employees, you need to transition to
what are called or referred to as small group employers, and that is those with fewer than 20
employees. So 19 or less, because the rules change for employers with fewer than 20 employees.
Small companies like this can encourage their employees off of the plan, and they can force
their employees off of the group plan and onto Medicare. And there's a reason why you're probably
going to want to consider that. And this isn't a penalty problem, which is why I didn't bring it up
at the beginning. This isn't you're going to get a Part B or Part D penalty. You could stay on the
smaller than 20 group plan and not experience those penalties. What becomes a problem is it's
a who pays first problem. So this is where Medicare and primary payer versus secondary
payer really come into play. So for employer groups who have 20 or more employees, they are
the primary payer. So if you get a bill, I'm going to move it over here. If you get a bill
that goes to your employer group first, 20 or more employees, employer group gets that bill,
whatever they don't cover goes over to Medicare to take care of from there. Now, when it's a small
employer group that switches. So the small employer group now becomes secondary payer,
and Medicare becomes the primary payer in this instance. Well, if you don't have Medicare,
that small employer group insurance company that is offering those benefits can see that
hey, we should be the secondary payer and Medicare didn't pay anything. They are well within their
legal rights to say, we're not going to cover anything. So we've had this happen with people
who didn't know this was happening. They're on an insurance company with their small group plan,
and then they're responsible for 100% of the cost because they become the primary payer
without having Medicare. So that's the real issue that you have with fewer than 20 employees.
If you're on a group health plan with fewer than 20 employees, you seriously need to consider
going on Medicare. And I say seriously consider this because it is up to the insurance companies
offering that employer group plan, whether or not they want to enforce this rule. So there are
insurance companies that don't necessarily abide by that, meaning they will still pay the claims,
even if you don't have Medicare. But you need to be very careful here. And you definitely need to
work with a broker who is familiar with that employer group plan to understand what's going
to happen because there are definitely insurance companies that will say we're not paying anything
until Medicare pays it. So just be very careful around that. Most instances, I'm going to say
that you're going to want to be on Medicare if you're on an employer group plan with fewer than
20 employees. So from there, I think we've covered when you kind of have to go on Medicare to avoid
penalties. Those two instances when you don't have to go on Medicare to avoid penalties. So again,
you're employed and you're covered by your company plan or your spouse is employed and
you're covered by your spouse's employer group plan. The other kind of caveat to this is that
if you are taking Social Security benefits before you turn 65, you are automatically enrolled in
both Part A and Part B. Now you can cancel or you can stop Part B, but you can't stop Part A. If
you're taking Social Security benefits, you need to have at least Part A. So if you're coming up
your 65th birthday, you've taken Social Security at 62, 63, 64, you're going to automatically be
enrolled in Medicare Parts A and B. And to postpone Part B, there's a form you can fill out
on the back of your Medicare card. There's some instructions there as well for you. You can stop
Part B if you're still working and you're covered by that employer group plan so that you're not
paying double. You're not paying for Part B and your employer group plan. And then once you lose
benefits through your employer group, you'd be able to pick up Part B again without any penalties
or without any worries there. That's kind of going through the Social Security aspect of it.
And then the other reason why it's a huge no-no in my mind to sign up for any part of Medicare at 65
if you're employed and covered by that employer group plan is if you have a health savings account,
so an HSA. If you have an HSA, you cannot contribute to it and neither can your employer
if you go on any part of Medicare, even Part A only. And that's the thing that we hear a lot of
again from HR people as they tell their employees, just go on Part A only. It's free. It's not going
to cost you anything. And that's true. Unless you have an HSA, it's going to cost you those dollars
that you would be able to contribute to that HSA tax-free and the employer contributions.
So that's the reason why Part A only. If you don't have an HSA, take Part A only. There's no
consequence for you taking Part A only at 65. But if you do have an HSA and you're wanting to
contribute to it, don't take Medicare at 65 because you're going to have to stop those contributions.
Now, we've talked about just because you are covered by an employer group plan and you're
eligible for Medicare, you're still going to want to compare those benefits. Now, in our experience,
it's about 50-50 in the sense of about 50% of people are on an employer group plan that is
more expensive than what they would experience on Medicare. If people are considering an Advantage
plan, that kind of math equation becomes even more favored towards the Medicare side of things. But
Medicare Advantage plans have their weaknesses. So I'm not telling you to go get a Medicare
Advantage plan. Supplement plans just have a higher upfront cost in terms of monthly premiums.
But again, 50% of people will see lower costs on Medicare. Another 50% are seeing equally or better
costs on their employer group plan. And so they can still stay on the group plan or consider moving
to Medicare depending on your costs. The other thing to think about when you're going through
this idea of the employer group costs is that if you do have a spouse, a lot of employers
will contribute more towards your premiums for the employee, but not as much for the employee
plus the spouse. So let's say that I'm employed with a company. My spouse and I are both on that
employer group plan. We're both eligible for Medicare. If she drops off and goes on to straight
Medicare, more of my premiums would be covered than it would be for both of us. So that's another
math equation that you just got to kind of think through. The other thing related to spouses is now
let's take a difference in age. So let's say that I am older than my spouse and I'm eligible for
Medicare. And maybe Medicare is better for me personally in terms of cost and coverage than
my employer group plan. But if I lose, if I leave my employer group, now my spouse is responsible
to pick up an ACA individual or family plan if we have kids, but an individual plan if it's just her.
And oftentimes those will be even more expensive. So that's something that you just got to kind of
work through, find a broker, find an agent that can help you with that. They can run the math
around what you would experience on Medicare versus what you would experience with your group
plan and the timing of everything. So that's kind of what's going on from the Medicare employer
group side of things. So your age of your spouse is important. The benefits on your employer group
is important. There's a lot of variables there. I'm going to wrap up with the penalties and then
I'll open it up for questions and answers. We have a few things here. So the Part B penalty,
if you decide to not get Medicare when you should, you're not covered by an employer group.
And it's those four reasons I talked about. The Part B penalty is a 10% penalty for every year
you did not take Part B when you should. And then if you decide to get it later, this penalty does
last the rest of your life. It is a dollar amount that also increases as the Part B premium increases.
So for example, in 2024, the Part B premium was $174.70. In 2025, it's $185. So that Part B premium
increase for everybody and that percentage penalty is on every year as it increases. It's not set
when you first take Medicare. So that's something to keep in mind if you don't take Medicare for
two years, you have a 20% penalty. The Part D penalty works a little bit differently. That is a
1% penalty for every month that you do not have creditable drug coverage. That 1% is based off
of the national base Part D premium amount this year. That is $36.78. So it's 1% of that
for every month that you don't take Part D when you should. And I mentioned a creditable
drug plan. This word is very important. Creditable coverage comes up a lot in this conversation.
Creditable coverage is only referring to prescription drug coverage. It is not referring
to your health or your medical or your hospital coverage through your employer group. If you plan
on continuing to work and delay Medicare, you want to verify with your employer that the plan drug
coverage is indeed creditable. Employer group plans are required to provide you with a letter
of creditable coverage or certificate of creditable coverage that would tell you that you have that on
that employer group plan. If they don't, they can also tell you. So talk with your HR benefits
manager. Ask them if the drug plan is creditable if you are planning on delaying Medicare past 65.
So again, it's not the health plan itself that needs to be creditable. It is the Part D drug
plan or sorry, not the Part D drug plan is your employer groups drug coverage through their plan.
If most employer group plans are creditable drug coverage, there are some and several that are not.
If your employer group plans drug coverage is not creditable, what your options are is you
could pick up a Medicare Part D drug plan, but in order to do so, you need to have at least
Medicare Part A. So that's something that is working through there. If you don't have creditable
coverage, the definition of creditable coverage means that it's equal to or better than what you
would experience on a Medicare Part D plan. And with the Inflation Reduction Act putting into
effect that two thousand dollar maximum out of pocket on drug coverage, that's kind of changing
the rules here. So in 2000, moving into 2026, we might see more employer plans become not
creditable from their drug coverage. So just keep kind of tabs on that. Of course, as that happens,
we'll make more videos on that or reach out to your broker and keep in touch with your HR managers
as that's going through. All right. How long? That took, I think, 19, 20 minutes. So that went
longer than I thought it would. But now it's time for question and answer time. Let's go through
and we have some questions. The first, what is Tricare for Life? So this is those who have earned
benefits through certain federal or the armed forces benefits. So you think of like your
politicians are going to be dealing with Tricare for Life federal benefits that are not FDHB.
Tricare for Life is dealing more with a different type of federal service that earns health
insurance coverage that is different than what the rest of us have. If you do have Tricare for Life,
Tricare for Life with Medicare is the best arrangement that you can have. So don't let
anybody talk you out of giving up your Tricare for Life in that instance. Buzz's Retirement Garage.
What's up, man? It's good to see you. If you're still here, he has a great YouTube channel where
he goes through his experience retiring. It doesn't hurt to sign up for Medicare Part A,
though, right? So this is going back to that conversation. I'm not sure when you jumped in.
If you have an HSA, a health savings account, and you want to contribute to it,
it does hurt to sign up for Part A because you cannot have Medicare Part A in place and contribute
to an HSA. Or if your employer is contributing those free money dollars to your HSA, that has
to stop as soon as you go on Medicare Part A. If you don't have an HSA and you're not worried about
contributing to it, then you can take Part A and there's no problem with that. All right.
What if you're eligible for Medicare November 2025? When do you need to stop your HSA? In March
or October, I'm on retiree health coverage. This is going to depend on when your 65th birthday is.
So is your 65th birthday in November? And I'll talk through those situations. If your 65th birthday
is in November, Part A has a six month look back on when it will start. And the rule is it's going
to go back to your 65th birthday. It's going to go back six months or your 65th birthday,
whichever is closest. Part A will not start before your 65th birthday if you're eligible for Medicare
with the normal reasons, right? So people can get Medicare pre-65 if they're disabled, if they've
been diagnosed with ALS, or if they've been diagnosed with end-stage renal disease. So kind
of push those off to the side for a minute here. If you're qualifying for Medicare at 65, you would
need to stop your HSA contributions the month before your 65th birthday. If you're going on
past 65, let's say you're 67 years old, and you want to go on Medicare in November of 2025,
they're going to do a six month look back from when you sign up for Medicare. So not even when
you want it to start. If you're going to sign up for Medicare, you want it to start in November.
You're probably starting that sign up process somewhere in August or September. And that six
month look back is going to go when you sign up for Medicare. So six months back from that August
or September, whenever you decide to sign up, not November. That's something to keep in mind. You
want to stop your HSA contribution six months back. And the timing of when you stop HSA contributions
is important, but it's less important than the amount that you are contributing. So you have
your HSA maximum contribution limits for the year. And they do what is called prorating for those
contributions. Meaning if I was eligible for an HSA for six months out of the year, I can make
six twelfths of the maximum contribution amount for that year. And I can make those contributions
up until I file my taxes in the next year. But it's that window of when you're eligible for an
HSA that you're allowed to make the prorated amount for those contributions. If you're over
55, remember, you do get a thousand dollar catch up contribution as well. That is also prorated.
Hopefully that answered that question there. If you are turning 65, stop your HSA contributions
the month before you turn 65 and you're going on Medicare, you're going to Medicare after 65.
Be aware that there is a six month look back. James, thank you for this. I don't have a lot
of experience with the Native American healthcare system. So that's something that I think is a great
reason for me to do a little research on this and figure out what your benefits are and how they
interact with what's going on from a Medicare perspective. I don't have a lot of experience
on that. I've just got the cops. So if you hear that, she's alive though. All right. I think I'm
going to hang out here for anybody on if you have any questions around this, I'm happy to answer
them. I think we got through all the questions that we have so far. And then I've got about
six more minutes to answer questions. Otherwise, I can let you leave this live stream. So thanks for
being on here. And thanks for my wife for managing those comments. I think she took a drink and it
went down the wrong, wrong, wrong pipe. I do have the so we just talked about an HSA. I've just
finished the HSA video or actually draw some things out. And I'm going to put that HSA video
out probably Monday or Tuesday of this next week, that goes into a complete deep dive into how much
you can contribute to an HSA, when you're allowed to make contributions, when you need to stop
contributions, and what the penalties are associated with that. And if you have making made
a mistake with your HSA, how you can fix those mistakes. So stay tuned. If you haven't subscribed
to the channel already, go ahead and do that. I highly encourage that. But that video will be
released probably Monday in the afternoon. Alright, if we don't have any other questions,
I'm just going to end it there. And thanks for spending time with me here on your Friday evening.
And make sure that you are understanding of when you are allowed to postpone Medicare past 65 and
save yourself a lot of money if you're employed or your spouse is employed. I'm under my spouse's
health coverage through work. I'm 65. He is 64. I signed up for Medicare A and B. Okay, so in
general, what we would recommend here is that you're kind of double paying. So if you're covered
under your spouse's health coverage through work, I'm assuming that it has 20 or more employees.
So if you can comment in there, Terry, does it have 20 or more employees from his employer's
perspective? If so, then you're double paying kind of for Part B. So there's no reason for
you to pay for Part B and have him be paying for you on his health insurance plan. So it'll kind
of boil down to a math problem there is how strong are his employer group benefits? And would it make
sense to just go fully onto Medicare or to stay on his group plans and then stop Part B? And then
once he loses his group benefits because he retires or he moves to Medicare, then you would be able to
pick up Part B again at no penalties with no problems doing that. So that's something to kind
of consider there. So I'm going to revolve around that 20 employees or 20 or more or fewer than 20
employees. Yeah, 20. If you have more than 20 employees, then yes, you don't have to have
Medicare Part B in this instance. It is paying secondary to your group plan. So if you have
incredibly high costs with your health, and you don't have to put that on YouTube here, but if you
have high health care costs, because there are some problems going on, then Medicare would act
as a secondary payer to your group health insurance. The costs there would have to be
relatively substantial to make that cost worth it, depending on what your employer group plan
looks like through your husband's work. Thank you, Kathy. Appreciate you for being here. Thanks for
tuning in. Got a lot of familiar faces here. Clinton, thank you for being here. You're great.
Fantastic. I appreciate all of you. Okay, I am going to jump off. Usually we go for like an hour
and a half. So I'm glad that we're able to get some time here. I got to go spend some time with
the family. So thanks for being here. And if you have any questions, my email is let me pop that
up real quick. This is my email, it goes straight to me. It's not some bot. It's not AI. It's not
somebody else. If you have any questions around this, just send me an email and I'd be happy to
help however I can. Okay, we will see you later. Enjoy your evening as well.

