Thai Central Bank to Weigh Recalibrating Neutral Stance

Finance Fortress
301 followers
3 Video Views·Mar 22, 2024
Bank of Thailand Assistant Governor Piti Disyatat discusses monetary policy, the state of the economy and the local currency. He speaks on "Bloomberg Markets: Asia."
We know that core inflation is easing,
and we have an economy that's pretty lackluster.
Growth was about, I think, 1.9% last year.
You have every reason to be cutting rates.
So, good morning, Hedlinde.
Thank you for having me back.
Yes, actually, we've had a slower recovery last year
than many people, including us, expected.
We pretty much had, like, back in February,
we anticipated the softness
in the last quarter of last year already,
and the numbers came out pretty much roughly in line.
But since then, I would say that the incoming data
at the last couple of months has actually been in line
with what we had expected back in February.
So, consumption continues to grow at a more moderate pace.
Tourist has actually, both in the numbers and the spending,
has been a bit higher than we anticipated.
And the manufacturing sector
has actually kind of flattened out.
The decline that we have seen for a long time
has actually seemed to have leveled off,
which is a good sign.
On the export front, that's still sluggish, I would say,
but recovering.
And the big gap is actually the fiscal spending
from the delayed budget.
This has been a rather big drag,
both in the last quarter of last year
and the first quarter of this year.
I would say two quarters together,
the drag is about 0.8% of GDP compared to normal.
So it's quite a significant drag.
But overall, I think the economic picture
is what we had anticipated back in February.
Can that pave the way for you to cut rates in April
when you take a look at the markets?
They're pricing in.
Big bets are that you'll be cutting rates.
If you take a look, Kenya yields down 80 basis points
since that peak we saw in October.
The sentiment out there is that you will be cutting.
What do you make of that?
Well, actually, our reading is that the market is split.
It's not completely unanimous.
And actually, I would say that the context is important.
So in the broad context, we went through a soft patch
in the second half of last year
that was partly due to cyclical factors.
For example, the delayed recovery
in the global electronic cycle.
But also partly some structural factors
that meant that we did not benefit as much
as we could have from the uptick in, say, external demand.
But looking forward, we actually expect
that softness has passed.
And in the near term, there is actually
a cyclical pickup in growth.
If you look at the guidance that we gave for this year,
2.5% to 3% of growth.
Behind that numbers, if you look at the quarter
on quarter momentum, it's actually around 1%
on average for the whole year, even if you come
in the bottom range of that.
So that's an annualized rate about 4% for the year.
The momentum that we and most other house expect
is actually not that bad.
The year-on-year figures may come in low
because of the base effects from last year.
So what the MPC will be doing at this next meeting
will be assessing the durability of this pickup
in near-term growth momentum.
And that depends on how strong the cyclical drivers are
and how big the structural drags are going to be.
So I think that's the main question in terms
of the policy decision.
Given what you're seeing right now
and given the growth that you're talking about,
is it reasonable to think that you
can maintain that neutral rate of 2.5%?
Does anything change that target?
Yeah, so the committee aims to be broadly neutral,
given where we are in the overall macro picture.
And broadly neutral is not an exact estimation to have.
It is true that there seems to be slower trend growth
than we had anticipated, maybe looking back a year or two
years ago.
So that would figure in whether there is a need or not
to recalibrate the neutral stance.
But that depends also on the strength,
as I said, of the cyclical recovery
that we are seeing coming in, at least
in the first half of this year.
So the first question is to decide
whether there is actually a need to recalibrate neutral.
And if there is one, then the timing
is the second issue, whether what
would be the appropriate timing of the recalibration.
So I would say it's hard to prejudge the decision right now.
But whatever is being considered is more like a recalibration
rather than an easing cycle to support the economy.
Because the economy is actually recovering, as I said,
especially in the first half of this year.
Kunpiri, it's no secret the prime minister
wants you to cut rates.
In fact, he says you should call for an emergency meeting.
How are you responding to that pressure
from the prime minister?
Yes, as I said, we've had a very constructive dialogue
with all parties, including the prime minister, the fiscal,
all those parties in the government.
We do listen to all the inputs, appreciate those inputs.
It's a judgment that needs to consider
quite a big set of factors, both in the short run and long run,
as well as the distributional consequences of our decisions.
So I think that input is useful and valued.
We have been talking about that.
But I think everybody understands
that we just want to deliver on our mandate of price stability,
sustainable growth, and financial stability.
And everybody respects the operational independence
that we have in terms of the monetary policy setting.
Kunpiri, I want to touch on the Thai Baht,
like last performance, second worst performer in Asia
year to date.
And that's mainly because of the outflow of funds.
How are you looking at the Thai Baht?
Are you concerned about the weakness?
Yeah, it has been a very short year so far.
So yes, we have had some weakness.
We are roughly at a level we had been back in September last year.
So it goes up and down.
Yeah, the last couple of months, the dollar had strengthened a little bit.
That made us weaker.
But we also had some domestic Thai-specific factors.
Basically, the GDP numbers, for example, came in soft.
And that was partly the reason why we had more softness
than other countries.
But as you're looking forward, I think it's important to note
that for us, and actually for many countries in Asia,
the current level of policy interest rates
are closer to neutral than, say, in many advanced economies,
including the Fed.
So if you look forward, the likelihood of policy adjustment for the Fed
would be a lot bigger than countries in Asia, including Thailand.
So I think on that front, and also given the recovery that
is projected, I think there is some support for the Fed going forward.
And the fund flows have been negative last year, quite substantial.
So far, the first couple of months has also been negative outflows.
But I think we have to take a bit more of a medium-term view of the currency.
So Kunpili, are you then saying that you're waiting on the Fed,
that movements by the Fed later in the year
would perhaps cause some weakness and a dull and hence support your currency?
Is that what you're waiting for?
I'm not waiting for that.
Just saying, in terms of looking forward,
the factors that could influence currency in the region,
and including the Fed, it is an important point
that our starting point in terms of policy is quite different.
Being closer to neutral means rates are likely to stay here,
or not far off from where they are right now,
so that if the advanced economies start cutting rates as is expected,
the differential will be a bit less.
That, at the margin, would be a supporting factor.
But that's not a main consideration for us.
The currency has not posed a particular problem in terms of stability
or in terms of growth.
It's helpful a little bit on the inflation front.
So I would say that there's no big policy issue in terms of currency level
right now.
What's the biggest risk to all your projections that you've made today?
Well, one big risk is actually, we hope, the budget disbursement.
You know, the budget has been delayed for around two quarters,
and it's expected to come in line in April.
So there'll be some make up, particularly in the investment,
public investment.
And the risk is that the execution of having
to make up or back load the spending in the scale that is required,
whether that can be implemented as much as forecasted.
So that's one big factor.
And I think in terms of the global picture,
it actually seems a bit more positive than, say, last meeting.
Yeah, I would say that that would be the main factor.
