Spear and Shield combat! | Responce to Scholagladiatoria

Eternal Shield
2 followers
1 Video View·Jan 25, 2026
Greetings traveler, I'm Snapjelly and I don't know how well you guys can hear me because
I didn't bring a microphone.
I'm in my club, I wanted to make a quick video talking about something because I saw a video
from Scholar Gladiatoria where Matt Easton talks about grip switches on spears.
Basically how when you use a spear with one hand, how you would switch from an underhanded
grip to an overhanded grip easily, different ways.
And he says one thing, just one thing that I don't particularly agree with.
So if you haven't seen his video, you can click the link in the description below and
go to it.
But if not, let's just get straight to the point.
So the spear, the shield, that's what we're talking about right now.
And the point of this video is basically talking about the effective ways of switching from
this position with my hand to that position.
And what I want to say straight off the bat is, as Matt Easton said, tossing it in the
air is possibly the simplest way to do it.
It's very simple.
You don't need to practice it.
Everybody does it instinctively.
And most likely this is the way that most people would have done it, just standard.
Because that's the thing that people do.
When they switch grips on a spear, they toss it in the air, just like this.
You don't even have to look to do it.
You don't have to practice.
It's not very hard.
But it does have a little risk of fumbling it.
Basically because you do release your spear from your hand as you throw it into the air.
And if your opponent spots that and basically just taps the spear, you'll lose control of
it.
You'll fumble.
It might fall on the ground.
And you don't want that.
So that's a downside.
However, I must say that this is probably, most likely, the way that people did it.
It's very loud.
Basically, the thing that Matt Easton says that I don't agree with is one way that he
describes is by either resting your spear on your shield or holding it in your shield
hand.
He says it's quite awkward and it's not very effective.
I disagree.
I just think he's doing it wrong.
And I will explain why.
A problem that Matt Easton had was that when he rests his spear on the shield, he was using
a different shield than I was.
He was using a kite shield, I think, and I'm using a center grip, round shield, like a
Viking shield, basically.
He found that when you put the tip of your spear on your shield, that the back, the butt,
basically, it just falls down due to gravity, which it does.
And he was stumbling this way and he thought it was awkward.
The way around that is simply by resting it on your elbow or on your shoulder.
So you have it in an underhand grip like this.
You've got your shield.
Whatever shield it is, it doesn't really matter.
It works with any shield.
You basically, instead of holding it this way, trying to switch the grip, what you do
is you lift up your spear first to this position.
It's still an underhand grip, but you kind of just lift it this way, right?
You raise it up, raise your shield, and you rest it on your elbow like this, right?
That way you can switch grips easily.
Same with going the other way.
You rest it on top of your shield.
You can put it on your shoulder if you want, and there you go.
You can switch grips safely.
Now, I think this is one of the best ways to switch grips, basically because it doesn't
get rid of any danger for your enemy.
This combination of weapons was mostly used, people at this time, at the time that this
was used, didn't have gauntlets.
They would use bare hands or have thin gloves at most.
So they have full mobility of the wrist, basically, right, when they do this.
Basically, in this era, everybody, most soldiers would carry a shield and a spear of some sort.
So probably the enemy that you were going to face was also going to be wearing a shield
and a spear.
And the ways around a shield and a spear are either you go over your opponent's shield
like that, or you go under it.
I would say over it, going over it, either this way, whoop, or that way, right, is probably
more beneficial, does more damage, because you hit people in areas that do a lot of damage
like the upper chest and the face, right.
But it can also be very beneficial to kind of just poke at people's feet.
There's differences there.
Also, if you have an overhand grip, you can, of course, chuck your spear if you want it.
You can throw it.
So the point is that most of the time, though, people are going to have their spears raised
because they want to stab over their opponent's shield.
There are certain benefits to stabbing high if your opponent has a shield.
One of them is, of course, hitting people in areas that do a lot of damage like the
face and the upper chest.
But also, if they want to block it with their shield, they're going to have to raise their
shield and that effectively blocks their field of vision and opens them up for attacks down
below if they have a small shield like this, right.
So you want your spear raised, basically.
Just have a threat to your opponent that you can stab.
So if you toss it in the air, your opponent is going to be able to see that you tossed
it in the air, right.
If you do it this way, by resting it on the tip of your shield, you basically, from the
perspective of your opponent, he can't really see clearly when you are going to stab or
switch grips if you're going to switch grips.
You're here, you're threatening with your spear, if you have it here, you're still threatening
with your spear.
And if you switch grips like that, you never kind of release the threat from having the
spear up high right there from your opponent when you switch grips this way.
So that's a huge benefit, I think.
Also something that I want to say is that most spears had a butt spike of some sort.
This one does not.
But a butt spike was a small gap, usually a little pointy on the end, which prevented
the wood from splitting as you used it to walk and stuff like that.
Some people argue, I've argued that it could possibly be used as a weapon, secondary perhaps.
But something that a butt spike could be used for is simply stabbing your spear into the
ground.
When you have your spear and your shield, you're walking with it, and you need to switch
grips, just poke it into the ground, and then you can grab it whatever way that you want.
You don't even really have to poke it into the ground because, you know, I just did it
and I didn't poke it into the ground.
But you could poke it into the ground, switch grips, do whatever grip that you want, and
reset.
Very simple as well.
Also I think that that, the last one that I've mentioned, is the best way to switch
grips in a formation if the formation is already locked.
So if you're in a shield wall, a shield formation, and you have your spear in an underhand grip,
but your shield is already locked with the people next to you, then you can't raise your
spear because you're interlocked with shield, right?
So the way to do that is quite simple.
You either stab it into the ground, or you just put it up against your foot or something.
That way you can switch grips safely, you can lift it, there you go.
That's how you do it.
So just some thoughts, basically, I hope you guys can hear me properly, and if you stuck
around this long you might as well subscribe.
Also follow me on social media, links are in the description below.
And subscribe to Scholar Gladiatoria if you haven't yet, alright?
That's it, bye.
Alright, I'm back, because there's something that I forgot to mention.
One more thing that I want to say is that this method of grip switching is not immune
to fumbling, and I don't have a large spear over here so I'm going to use this little
stick and a buckler, right?
But this way, obviously it's a lot easier to do with a smaller spear or stick, right,
than it is with a large one.
And that's basically what I wanted to say, is that the main problem with grip switching
a spear, if you use it one-handedly, is there's always quite a large chance that you mess
it up and drop your spear.
The problem with that is basically, it can be detrimental in a formation if you drop
your spear, obviously, but the problem is that a spear to use single-handedly and a
shield is kind of a clunky, like how do you say it, it's like, it's a cumbersome weapon
set to use, or like a bulky weapon set essentially.
Even if your shield is not very heavy, if it's big, it's still going to be like sort
of a lug thing to move around, and your spear as well, it's just very long so it's going
to be difficult to move it like agilely, to be able to move it in an agile way.
I know how to talk, shut up.
And another big problem with this is that this combination of weapons was always used
in formations, right, so you have people next to you, behind you, and possibly in front
of you that you have to worry about as well.
And this limits your options in mobility quite a lot.
So Matt Easton showed a way of grip switching that I think is the best way to do it in terms
of it has the least chance of fumbling, right, it's very fumble resistant, that's basically
like this, you spin it around and you tuck it under your elbow, this is not your elbow,
you spin it around and you tuck it under your armpit like this, because then you can just
hold it and you can switch to whatever grip that you want, and again, it's not very hard,
it looks very flashy but it's just you spin it around and you tuck it under your armpit
like that.
The problem is though that you can't really do that when you're in formation, right, so
I think that the most secure way of switching grips is by sticking it in the ground.
That has the least chance of you ******* it up and not being able to, you know, grab your
spear again.
But like I said previously, it's this way, it keeps the threat on your opponent always.
Because you have your point in line always and you can switch around when you feel like,
when you feel comfortable, when you feel like your spear is secure, when it's rested secure,
you can flip the grip whenever you want, basically.
So that's all I have to say about it for now.
And now it's really the end of the video.
