Sound Mixing & Editing Explained

Movie sound effects
101 followers
Comments are disabled for this video.
Hey everybody, Andrew Nolette here with Prytt Entertainment Group and I am at the Nightlight
Cinema here in downtown Akron, joined by Curtis Hare, Executive Director of Nightlight Cinema.
Curtis, how we doing?
Really good, really good.
And today what we're going to be looking at is one of the more confusing technical categories.
And by that I mean, we're actually going to be talking about two categories, sound mixing
and sound editing.
Now I'm sure a lot of people at home are like, I don't really know what the difference is.
I see a lot of the same movies nominated for both, but then one's getting it for mixing
and not editing and vice versa, so I guess I'm a little confused.
That's why Curtis and I are here today, to explain that to the folks at home.
So the big thing to think about with sound editing and sound mixing is sound editing
is the recording of all audio except for music.
So this is dialogue between characters, then this is sound that's picked up in wherever
setting they're at, and this is also in the studio.
Say they need to re-record some lines of dialogue, that falls into sound editing.
If they want to create all these crazy sounds to, you know, put all these different animal
noises together and it somehow splices it all up into a computer to make a car sound
like they did in Mad Max, that would all fit into the bubble of sound editing.
Now sound mixing is the balancing act of all the sound in the movie.
You are taking all of the music, all of the audio, all of the dialogue, all of the little
sounds going around and everything, and how you combine that together to just make a beautiful
orchestra, if you will, Curtis.
You could call it an orchestra, but I think my pick, one of the terms that's been used
for what was done in Revenant, which is my pick for mixing, is a sound haiku.
And that's because you just have these layers, like a beautiful audio tiramisu, where you
have layers of what's happening in the real film world and layers of what's happening
in kind of the spirit realm.
It's almost like there are two stories taking place in the Revenant side by side that you
can only distinguish between them by listening.
And to me, that's pretty incredible.
Ina Ritu, the director of this film, did Birdman last year, and he brought back the same sound
crew to do this film.
And yeah, it's just a really, really intense and deeply layered film that I think warrants
a great pick for sound mix.
I think one of the things I'm most excited about with this category, with our predictions,
is not only did we disagree, but how we disagreed.
I think that this year it should go, sound editing and sound mixing should go to one
movie, Mad Max Fury Road, and you think that the two categories should be split up.
So this is going to be super informative to people watching at home.
I was lucky enough to have the opportunity.
I watched Mad Max and Star Wars Force Awakens, both, I think, two movies that do sound just
beautifully.
I watched them without actually seeing the movie.
I kind of closed my eyes and I just listened.
I think the thing with Mad Max...
That's a pro tip, by the way.
That is a pro tip.
Yeah, just cover the eyes and kind of enjoy the sound.
I think the thing with Mad Max is the visuals in Mad Max are so powerful and so intense
that we almost forget about the sound because they match so perfectly.
But they are just as impressive as the visuals in Mad Max.
And so looking at the sound editing, you have all these great records of cars and fire and
just the subtle dialogue.
You've got one character just yelling and screaming at the top of their lungs, and then
you have Max, who is very quiet.
You have so much contrast.
And all the audio is being used at the same time.
It's being mixed at the same time.
And that's kind of to tie in why I think it should get both awards is that they are taking
the sound editor for this said that at one given time he had 2,000 channels of audio.
For the folks at home, that is 2,000 different audio pieces at one time.
And you can see it in that opening car chase sequence of how much sound is being used.
And he was able to mix all of that, all this great dialogue, all this quiet dialogue, use
it all together, and then just subtly and abruptly just stops with the film and just
stops and goes to complete silence.
And I think that's one of the most powerful sound sequences, scenes that I've seen in
a movie in a very long time.
I mean, how many monitors do you think?
He had to stack on top of each other.
2,000 audio channels.
Yeah, it's crazy.
I can't even imagine it.
And to even wrangle that much in your mind and think about how they should be, it's insane.
And I don't disagree.
But when we talk about editing and you talk about this dialogue, I am looking back to
Star Wars, Force Awakens, and I'm thinking this series also has a great lineage in history
in terms of amazing sound editing, stuff that has become absolutely iconic.
Ben Burtt, who did a lot of the great sound effects, including the voice of R2-D2.
I wish I could do it for you here, but I can't.
No falsetto.
Beep, beep, boop.
And he also did the lightsaber sounds and stuff that was just, really, it was just new
and it set a whole new level for audio technicians.
And so coming into the Force Awakens, that was another piece that it kind of had to live
up to.
And I have to say, I really think it did.
And in addition to doing that, it did some new things.
So when you think about Kylo Ren's voice, there have been a couple instances of films
over the past couple of years where they're trying to nail the sound of this voice that
feels omnipresent.
I'm thinking of Tom Hardy's Bane and the Dark Knight.
And there are a couple other instances where it just doesn't quite work.
It ends up feeling muddy or it's like, it just doesn't work.
But I'll tell you, the first time I think it worked was in the Force Awakens with Kylo
Ren.
You get this really, really crisp, you know, frightening, but also, you know, what's the
word?
He's scared a little bit.
You sense all of that.
And it's kind of in your mind as if he's doing a force choke right there.
And so I have to give it to him for that.
In addition, there was a great kind of playing with tradition in terms of BB-8's sound.
The Saber sound for Kylo Ren was really cool because they modified the traditional sounds.
It's got more of a crackle to it.
It's a little bit fire-ier and not quite as cold.
It feels more dangerous.
Like there are sharper edges on this, whatever, I can't do it.
But anyway, that just kind of blew me away.
Star Wars was not my favorite film overall, but I've got to say the sound editing was
pretty intense.
And the thing that makes it really tough for me to not give Star Wars mixing is the fact
that John Williams' score is in there.
But I'm still going to stick with Revenant for that.
All right, Curtis.
I think the folks at home now understand the difference between sound editing and sound
mixing.
And when it comes to Oscar time, they'll understand why this movie was nominated for mixing or
why this movie was nominated for editing and why this movie was nominated for both.
So thank you for joining us today in our breakout video.
You can always check out our other breakout videos on our social media pages, print entertainment
groups, and the Nightlights, as well as after the Oscars.
Make sure to check out our social media pages because we will have a list of who did better.
Curtis seems confident, but I don't think he should be confident because I'll tell you
what, Curtis.
I think I'm taking it home.
I think my predictions were pretty spot on.
Time will tell.
All right, Curtis.
Thank you for letting us into the Nightlight here.
This is beautiful space.
Thank you, everybody, for joining us.
See you soon.
