Solifl'Art- Georges de la Tour- La Diseuse de bonne aventure-

Georges de La Tour
9 followers
And this morning, for the Soliflar,
well, once again, 15 minutes on a work
that appeared to me yesterday morning,
and here it is,
the 10 bones of Bonaventure by Georges Delatour,
which is at the Metropolitan Museum in New York,
which is a work that, from the first look,
tells you that there was a cut somewhere.
Here, you can see that the character on the left is cut.
In fact, we know that at the time of its existence,
this work was, unfortunately, cut on the left side.
Which means that the central character,
which seems to us to be slightly out of focus,
was indeed innocent.
So we have a close-up composition of five characters,
a young man, let's say a young gallant,
and four women, three young women and one much older,
who is precisely the 10 bones of Bonaventure,
which gives its title to the work.
Before going into the details, of course, of the work,
I would like to point out that it is part of a period
that we call the Diurnal Period of Georges Delatour,
and that it corresponds to an artistic movement
that we will call Caravagism.
This may seem a little surprising to us,
because here, precisely,
we are a little bit outside the clutches of Caravagism
when it comes to the very strong contrasts
between shadow and light,
where we will always have a very brutal lighting system
that will give a monumental character to the character.
But if you look closely,
you have a lighting from top to bottom,
we see it with the shadows,
and we will come back to the different elements in a moment.
Georges Delatour is also known
for his very, very dark period,
which we call the Nocturnes.
So we have this contrast between nocturnal and diurnal.
And here I present to you very quickly
this Saint Joseph Charpentier,
which is in the Louvre.
If you have never had the opportunity to see it,
you really have to see it in real life,
because the light coming from this candle
is absolutely incredible.
I'm just trying to give it to you a little closer here,
as you can see,
with the child who actually supports his father.
Note one thing,
that Georges Delatour is a Lorraine artist
who is actually part of the Kingdom of France.
He was born shortly before the reattachment
of his birth town to France.
He spent part of his career in Lorraine,
and he is influenced by different elements.
In my artistic terms,
he is influenced by the art of Caravaggio,
I'll come back to that.
But in his life, he is also influenced
by the reality of the Thirty Years' War,
because the city in which he settled
at the beginning of his career
is unfortunately ravaged by the war.
This implies a certain number of visions
in Delatour's work.
Note that we really have two periods,
daytime for the beginning of his career,
and nighttime later on.
As for the subject that interests us,
La Diseuse de Bonaventure
is truly a subject that is honoured
with this work by Caravaggio,
which is also found in the Louvre.
Once again, it depicts a young man
who is very well-dressed,
a nice man, probably,
who carries a sword on his side,
who has taken off his glove, as you can see,
to make himself known as the Bonaventure
by this young woman.
This young woman at Caravaggio's
wears all the characteristics of the Bohemian,
which can also be called Gitane,
if you really understand it like that.
With this garment, you see,
which is asymmetrical,
this kind of large coat
which is knotted on a shoulder,
and which is characteristic of the Bohemian
in the 17th century.
What is also characteristic
is the lighting at the top left
which forces the line of shadow and light,
even though Caravaggio's work
is also quite luminous.
And you see that there is a game of gaze
between the two characters
which ultimately places this work
less in the realm of divination
than in the realm of seduction.
There really is that at Caravaggio's.
However, at Caravaggio's,
we know that this Bonaventure storyteller,
who is almost 40 years ahead
of Delatour,
who will occupy us,
we systematically associate this work
with another Caravaggio work
from about the same period
called Les Tricheurs.
This is how we estimate
that in Delatour's work
there is also a pendant
which can be either
the tricheur at the ace of clubs
that you see here
and which is in the United States,
in Texas,
whose dimensions correspond
to those of the work
that interests us,
the Bonaventure storyteller,
or this one,
which is the tricheur at the ace of diamonds.
Look closely,
it's exactly the same composition.
There are simply differences
in the clothing.
But this work, which is in the Louvre,
is slightly larger than the previous one.
So there are several possibilities.
Either it would be two ensembles
and we would miss one of the works,
or they are isolated copies.
There is a bit of a mystery.
I will not dwell on these tricheurs at the ace
and I will come back, if you like,
to the work that interests us
and we will spend a little time on it.
First, the dating.
The Metropolitan Museum
dates back to the 1630s.
There are difficulties
because precisely whether it is
one or the other of the tricheurs at the ace
that is the pendant of this work
implies a different dating.
Either we are in the 1632s
or we are after 1635.
We are not so interested
in understanding this work.
What is important, however,
is first of all to note the size
of the signature,
which is very, very imposing.
In the signature,
Georges de Latour indicates
that it is he who is at the origin of this work,
but he mentions the name of the city,
that is to say, Luneville,
Lotharingie, therefore Lorraine.
Be careful, it is possible
that he made this work
after his departure from Luneville,
but that he wanted to sign it from Luneville
for a reason x, y,
as we said, being perhaps
installed in Luneville.
Now we will focus on the details.
So what we see
is this group of characters
whose composition,
the choice of colors,
will allow us to be interested
first in the young man.
We are first attracted
by the young man's gaze.
Why? Because in fact
this brown and pink mass
is enclosed
by the white masses
of the right sleeve
of the first gypsy
and the hair
of the one
in front of us,
as well as the oval of his face,
which is very, very white.
You will also notice
that there is,
in the representation
of the fabrics,
look at the finesse
of the lace here,
a concern
that is absolutely fantastic
in the restitution
of the fabrics,
of the patterns.
And this one is really a masterpiece,
this hairstyle
of the old bohemian.
Specifically,
it is this old woman
who reads the Bonaventure.
So look, the young man
holds his left hand,
but she will not read
the lines of the hand.
In the 17th century,
reading the lines of the hand
was reserved for an elite,
in a way, intellectual.
Bohemians, they,
read the lines of the hand
using a small piece
which has been given,
of course, by the one
who wants his future to be read.
They will mark a sign
in the hand of their,
how to say, client,
and then they keep the piece,
usually of silver or gold,
for retribution.
Everything is fine so far.
You will notice
that we have a simplification
of the face of this Bohemian
who faces us,
but whose gaze is turned
to the right of the painting,
so the left.
For us, it is turned
to these two other young women.
The young man looks at the old woman,
the old woman looks at the young man.
But in truth,
what we need to look at
are the hands of the three Bohemians,
a little too beautiful,
who explain that the young man
does not look exactly
where he should look.
In fact, he is a little busy
making the beautiful look of nothing
to seduce these young women.
But what are they doing?
Look at the game of hands.
The one on the right is stealing
his bouquet.
The one on the left,
in the background,
is stealing a gold medallion.
You see, she is busy cutting it.
There are several elements
in this work.
First, there is
the diffusion of a motif
that is quite traditional
in the 17th century
concerning the Bohemian woman.
In general, it is rather the Bohemian woman.
It is that
they are thieves.
It must be said.
All those who are now called
in a very generic term
the people of the voyage,
who were called Bohemians at the time,
even if they did not come from Bohemia.
We can also call them gypsies.
There is an infinite terminology.
Well, they are assimilated
to thieves.
We will recognize them systematically
by the violet garment.
And you see systematically
this stuff that is tied
asymmetrically on one of the shoulders.
These are actually carpets
that are put here.
Moreover, it is the motif of a carpet
that Delatour certainly saw.
The old woman is busy
to divert the attention of the young man.
It is probably
a form of moralization
to call young people
to be aware
that we must beware
of the too great beauty of young women.
We must not let ourselves be seduced
by the sirens
of youth and beauty.
To finish on this painting,
I wanted to tell you that
it disappeared
for a very long time.
When I say disappeared,
I mean that it was
in a particular collection
and that Delatour
fell into oblivion
for several hundred years.
His work was ignored.
It was after the Second World War
that one of the family members
who owned this work,
who had been imprisoned
in Germany,
had seen
engravings
on works
by Delatour.
He recognized
this painting
in his attic.
He did not recognize the painting
because it was not documented,
but he recognized the style.
He talked about it
to members of the Louvre
after the Second World War.
This is how the conservators
of the Louvre negotiated
to buy the painting.
The purchase was not made.
A well-known collector,
Vildenstein,
bought the painting
for a relatively ridiculous sum
of 7.5 million
old francs.
For ten years,
he was forbidden to sell the painting.
He kept it.
But in 1960,
suddenly,
the painting appeared
at the Metropolitan Museum in New York.
Vildenstein did a very interesting
He sold the painting
for between $650,000 and $800,000
in 1960,
which is a very significant increase
and made it
one of the most expensive
paintings of his time.
However, there was a scandal in France
because one of the conservators
of the Louvre signed the authorization
to sell the painting abroad.
At the time,
Malraux, Minister of Culture,
had to take account
of the loss
of the painting
when it was sold abroad.
This means
that at the time,
the conservators of the Louvre
doubted the authenticity
of the painting.
Of course,
they no longer doubt it.
But since then,
restorations have allowed
them to consider
that it was an asset.
All this to tell you
that attribution problems
are sometimes very complicated
because you have to have a source
and that a signature does not
have an authenticity,
even if it is a step towards
this authenticity.
I wanted to show you
this work
which is truly
captivating.
It almost fits
the theme
I am going to talk about
with the representation
of old age.
We have a characteristic throne
which also refers to the witch
I was talking about.
The nose is almost crooked,
the chin moves forward
with this pronated jaw.
There is always a way
to represent old age
which is very particular.
This work was also presented
during an exhibition
held at the Grand Palais
a few years ago
entitled Bohème,
on the representations
of Bohemians
but also of artistic Bohème.
I encourage you to see it
if you have the opportunity
one day to go to New York.
That's it for this short
story of Bonne Aventure,
small or not so small,
it's a rather large format.
For the rest of the events,
this Friday,
I left 10.30am,
sorry, it's 8.30pm.
Aurélie will meet you
to present the Jean-Jacques Ener
Friday, December 11th at 8.30pm.
I insist, there is a cookie.
I will meet you again
on Sunday at 10.30am
for Gauguin
and for the end of the year
the Château de Chantilly
on Tuesday, December 15th at 10.30am.
That's it for this.
I will stop the recording.
