Shortness of Breath - Clinical History Taking - Dr Gill
Dr James Gill
407 followers
1K Video Views·Apr 9, 2026
Shortness of Breath - Clinical History Taking - Dr Gill
So this is a trial video search. The intention is to try and provide views with a clinical history, in this case a patient presenting with Sean's breath, and to allow them to come up with differential diagnoses which may be appropriate for that particular history.
If this is a effective video, and people feel that it is useful, then we can look at doing others in the series, and deep dives where upon we can look more into the history taking specifics
Hello and welcome back to the channel. Here's John myself and Dr James Gill for a trial video.
So what we've done is we've recorded a history-taking episode, specifically with regard
to a presentation of Shorts of Breath. And what I'd suggest with regard to this is that you guys
watch the video and come up with your own opinions with regard to the differential diagnoses
which may be present with what the patient is presenting with. And then if this has been a
useful video and you found a utility, we can do a follow-up where we break down what's actually
been discussed in the history and then look at what the questions are meaning and whether or not
this is something that is an effective learning tool for yourselves. So have a look at the video,
see if this is of use for yourself and please comment down below if you'd like us to do more
of these. With that in mind, keep your eyes and ears open and try and work out what you think
are the top three differentials before we get to the end of the history. Take care and I'll see
Hello. Hiya. Take a seat. Thank you. So, nice to meet you. I'm Atava. I'm one of the final year
med students. Before I start, can I just confirm your full name and date of birth please? Sure,
James Gill, 1st 1st 84. Perfect. So James, is it okay to call you James today? Definitely.
So James, I've been asked to ask you a few questions, maybe do an examination if required
and just find out what's been going on. Is that okay with you? Definitely.
So how can I help? I've been getting really short of breath. Okay. And how long has that
been going on for? It's probably been going on for a couple of months if I think about it,
but I've really noticed it the last four weeks. Okay. And with the shortness of breath,
does it come on quite suddenly? It's kind of there all the while at a low level, but when I try and
do something, I notice it's much harder and I really ramp up that breathing there.
And in regards with when you feel the shortness of breath, is there any pain associated with that?
If I'm pushing myself, there can be, yeah. Where is the pain would you say?
Quite central. And how would you describe that pain?
It's a tightness. It's a pressure. Okay. So not quite like a pinpoint pain. It's just sort of,
you feel sort of constricted. That's exactly what, yeah, constricted.
Fine. And when you sort of feel these symptoms come on, how long do they last for?
They're going to last for a couple of minutes after the exercise, or sometimes late at night,
it can be there for quite a while. When you say late at night,
is that sort of like the time when it's worse? Well, I notice regularly at night,
when I lie down, the breathing worsens. Okay. Do you find yourself waking up in
the night sort of short of breath? I have done. That's really worried me.
Fine. And what about pillows? How many pillows do you tend to sleep with?
Well, normally I just have one, but again, last couple of months I had two,
didn't think much of it, but the last couple of nights actually I needed three.
Okay. And sort of staying asleep or sleeping, are you getting good sleep, would you say?
No, I don't feel refreshed in the morning. It feels like I've been tossing and turning all night.
Although, you know, I've maybe worked once or twice, but I'd expect to feel better.
No, I can understand that must be very difficult for you.
Hopefully we can try and find out what's been going on.
I'll try and ask you a few of the questions. They might seem like they're out of the blue,
but it's sort of to make sure everything else in your lifestyle has been going okay.
Have you noticed any headaches at all? Yeah. Again, they've been sort of ramping
up with sleep, with the breathlessness. Is it sort of tightness in your head,
or would you say? Yeah, there's a definite tightness,
but it seems to be in the mornings when I wake up and once I get going, that tends to dissipate.
Fine. And have you taken any medications for this?
I've tried paracetamol, it's mildly effective. This is for the headaches?
Correct. In regards with sort of the shortness of breath?
I don't have anything to take for it. Okay, fine. And when you take paracetamol
and things like that, do the headaches seem to settle?
Helps it, but time seems to be the thing that makes it settle.
Fine. So as the day goes on, it seems to improve?
Fine. Any sort of changes in your vision that you've noticed?
No. No. Any sort of nausea or vomiting?
No vomiting, but I've got reduced appetite and I can feel like a low-level nausea.
Okay. Have you brought anything up? No.
No. Fine. And how are your bowels? Sorry, I should say.
Fine. Fine. Okay. No problems with stools?
No, normal for me. Any problems urinating or anything like that?
Not at all, no. Okay. Any weight loss that you've noticed?
No. Any weight gain?
Well, I mean, I'm getting a little bit older, so the scales are going up, but again,
the last sort of couple of months, it's gone up more than I'd expect it would have done.
Fine. And any sort of blood anywhere that you've noticed?
I don't think so. No, just anywhere sort of, you know,
when you're going to the toilet, have you noticed any blood in the bowels or any bleeding from
anywhere in your body that you've noticed? No.
No. Have you got any brashes or any scratches anywhere?
I mean, my legs are getting quite itchy, the lower parts, you know, and kind of,
I noticed a bit of redness down there. To be fair, I thought it was an infection because
the leg's swollen, but actually both legs have been swelling.
Fine. And would you say the swelling is constant, the size of them?
If I put my legs up at night, you know, if I'm watching TV or something, that brings the
swelling down, and if I've been walking around during the day, the swelling then gets much worse.
It then becomes not painful, but tight. Okay, now I can see what you're saying.
And in regards to the rest of your body, any new lumps or bumps anywhere else?
No. No.
Fine. Can I ask you a little bit about past medical history, if that's okay?
Are you diagnosed with any medical conditions currently?
No, I had asthma as a child, and no other problem for me.
Do you take any regular medications?
I'm really lucky now, I don't. I've been furiously fitting well, to the best of my knowledge.
Any allergies to anything?
Penicillin causes rash.
Any food allergies?
No. Nothing, fine.
And you said that you're quite active, would you say?
I think so, yeah. Well, I certainly was until this breathlessness started coming.
Do you feel breathless at rest as well? So if we're talking now, are you...
Not at the moment. Later on in the day, I was a bit breathless,
sat in the waiting room after going up the stairs, but sat for a while, walked through.
If I take a really deep breath, it doesn't feel like I'm quite inflating fully, but I'm okay.
Fine. I can see why you're worried, and we'll definitely try and see what we can do.
And so in regards with work and lifestyle, do you work currently?
Yes, I work as a machine operator for a car manufacturer.
And you're still able to function at work?
Yeah, but I'm standing all day using the machines, and again,
the legs are really swollen and tense at the end of the day.
I'm finding that over my lunch break, I try to put my legs up, because that helps a little.
Okay, fine. And in regards with social lifestyle, would you say that you drink a lot of alcohol?
I don't drink any alcohol.
Have you ever drank a lot of alcohol?
No, I've just never liked it.
Fine. Any smoking?
I have smoked in the past. I stopped about 20 years ago.
How many a day would you say you used to smoke?
Maybe back a day.
And any recreational drugs at any point?
No.
No. Okay. And so do you stay by yourself at home?
No, I've got my wife there.
And is she all fit and well?
She's fine. She's getting annoyed with me waking her up in the middle of the night when I wake up.
Fine. When you say, are you just waking up short of breath?
Yes.
You're waking up sort of needing to go to the toilet or anything like that?
No, it's just struggling to breathe.
Fine. And family history, are there any diagnoses of any medical conditions in the family?
Unfortunately, and that's kind of what worries me. My dad died of a heart attack. He was 50.
And my brother, he and I don't get on, and he actually left the country.
I know that he had a problem with his heart in his late 40s as well.
I don't quite know what it was. He's still alive there.
Okay. Fine. Thank you for sharing all that.
And just a final question, I should have asked it earlier, but eating and drinking well?
Reduced appetite.
Reduced appetite, but you are still eating okay? Would you say you have a healthy diet?
It's not bad. It could be better. I'd probably get four fruit and veg a day.
That's impressive. Okay. So James, in regards to everything that you've said to me,
do you have any idea as to what could be happening to you?
I'm worried it's something to do with my heart. I think there might be something
genetic in the family, and that's what I'm worried about.
Fine. There's a few questions that I just need to ask. Have you ever noticed
sort of your heart fluttering or beating abnormally?
Occasionally, it'll feel like I've missed a beat, but that's very rare.
You know, maybe once a week, something like that.
Is this sort of started when you started feeling the shorter breath?
Unfortunately, yes. Everything seems to be sort of coming together.
When you get the palpitations, can you recall as to what you're experiencing?
Literally just, I get an extra beat and then everything goes back to normal.
Fine. So it's very intermittent. It's not constant.
It's absolutely intermittent. Yeah.
Fine. Okay. And after everything, sort of all the information you've given me,
do you have any idea what could be happening to you?
I think it's probably something with my heart, because it seems to run out of family.
Is that sort of your main concern, that it could be something that's
affecting your family, is affecting you?
I think the main concern is the fact that, you know, my dad died young,
and my brothers had, you know, a big heart problem.
I'm concerned that, you know, I'm getting older and I've got a big problem.
Fine. And in the consultation today,
is there something in particular that you'd like us to do for you?
Look at my heart, you know, give me a scan or something?
No, absolutely. So thank you for all that information.
I think it's important that we have a listen to your heart and do an examination.
So we'll move on to that and we'll see what we can do.
Is that okay with you? Sure.
So based on everything that you've told me,
it seems like you might be experiencing something that's known as heart failure.
Okay. I know that might come as a bit of a shock,
but it's quite a common phenomenon that occurs.
And a lot of people, as they get older, can experience symptoms of it.
But to make sure that we're on the right track,
and we do think that it is heart failure,
we're going to run some tests and we're going to do a checkup on you as well, if that's okay.
So it could be other things?
It could be other things. Absolutely.
So it could be heart failure.
It could be something called obstructive sleep apnea, if you've ever heard of it.
Yeah. Actually, I had a friend that had that. He's got a mask now.
Exactly. So the way you're describing that you're waking up short of breath in the night,
you're saying you're not getting fully refreshed sleep.
So that could be the cause of it as well.
And another thing it could be is just, it could, like you say,
it could just be growing older and the tiredness and the weakness that you're experiencing.
Chances are unlikely, as this is something that I think
is due to heart failure or the sleep apnea that we talked about.
So it's really important that we investigate it further
to try and find out what's exactly happening.
Okay.
Before we move on to that, while you're in the practice today,
is it all right if I have a listen to your chest and have a look at your heart
and your lungs at the same time to see if there's anything that we can identify?
Absolutely, yes.
And we'll try and book you in for a few tests and refer you on if required.
Okay.
Is that okay with you?
Fantastic, thank you.
Any other questions?
No, really helpful, thank you.
Thank you.
So there we have it, a patient presenting with shortness of breath.
So with what was said, certainly a sleep apnea is a possible differential diagnosis.
Heart failure is a valid differential diagnosis.
And we could also think about respiratory issues, for example, COPD,
which can, in their own right, go on to develop issues as heart failure.
So it may have a bit of a blending of a diagnosis there.
We've also highlighted the possibilities of a cardiac arrhythmia,
so potentially with atrial fibrillation, or potentially ectopic beats,
which again, might have an interplay with regard to heart failure.
So what were the differentials that you guys came up with as you watched the video?
Put them down in the comments and we can have a chat about
how you came up with your differential diagnosis,
and crucially, whether or not you'd like us to do more videos about this.
Sort of approach to history taking for yourselves,
and whether or not you'd like us to do a deep, deep dive,
breaking down the questions and potentially the answers
that you're seeing in this and other histories that we can do.
Take care, and we'll see you in the next one.
Cheerio.
