Shell Shock in WW2

History of Relics
1 follower
3 Video Views·Dec 3, 2023
This documentary completes the two-part series on shell shock. Lessons learned from the First World War enable different approaches in the next conflict, but still the suffering of the combatants continued. Be sure to catch the first part - "Shell Shock 1914-18" - also on this channel. Uploaded for educational purposes only.
There was a very tough sergeant, and he was hit, and he was hit badly, and he was in great
pain, and he was wailing and crying, crying for his mother, mummy, and this absolutely
shocked me, to hear this man, who I'd always rather regarded as a tough, hard case, wailing
and moaning for his mummy.
Twenty years after the First World War, a new generation faced the stress and terror
of modern battle. Once again, combat would take men's minds to extreme limits. But this
time, new efforts would be made to treat the mental casualties of war, and get them fighting
again.
Army psychiatrists believed complete recovery was now possible, but first they had to try
untested and controversial treatments, from massive doses of new drugs, to electric shock.
The secrets of the mind were to be opened up to science, in the service of the military.
200,000 British soldiers had their first experience of battle in early 1940. Driven
back by the Germans across northern France, they were cut off at Dunkirk. Trapped on the
beach, troops waited desperately for a place on the evacuating boats. Many were raw recruits
driven to the point of breakdown by fear and panic.
We were terrified. There was nowhere to hide. You thought you could get into the dunes,
but the bombs were dropping everywhere. And some of them just laid down on the sand. They
kept saying, we shall never see England, we shall never see England again. I used to say,
let's try once more to get to the boats. But I knew it was hopeless trying to get to the
boats, because we could see the bodies in the sea. And I think that's what made them
crack up as well, seeing the bodies. Everywhere around you, there were bodies.
In the days after Dunkirk, the shattered men straggled back to the south coast ports.
There were just convoys and convoys of them. Some arrived on stretchers. They arrived clad
in whatever they could find, really. Some of them had semi-uniform, anything that the
people had given them. Some had their uniforms all in tatters. They were grimy, dirty, shaking.
Unable to speak. Rambling, some of them. Thousands of soldiers were in such a state
of shock that they had hysterical symptoms. They were blind, shaking, paralysed or mute.
Unable to take any more, their minds had shut down their bodies. The army was prepared for
the physically wounded, but not for these men. Stan Goldsworthy had the symptoms later.
Well, I was sort of very anxious, very anxious sort of thing. I'd lost my speech,
quite a bit of my speech at the time. And also, you had nightmares. It was right in the daytime,
but at night, as soon as you dropped off to sleep, all these things reoccurred in your mind. And
you've got these hot sweats. You've got very hot and sort of clammy. And then it won't be up and
you couldn't get any sleep for the rest of the night then, you see. The army had forgotten the
lessons of the First World War, that battle can drive men mad. After 1918, a government inquiry
into shell shock had recommended that all army doctors be trained in psychoneurosis and new
recruits screened in order to weed out those most likely to break down. But the report had
been ignored. In 1939, the army had only six medical officers trained in psychiatry. The
military felt that good men, well-trained, well-officered, wouldn't break down in large
numbers. They felt that maybe breakdown was something that happened in the past. It wouldn't
happen again, because under their sort of leadership and training, etc., that men would
in future resist the stresses and strains of battle. Totally unprepared for the flood of
traumatized men, the army had to commandeer civilian mental hospitals. As a result,
Dunkirk soldiers found themselves on a new front line, caught between competing ideas of how they
should be treated. The psychiatric establishment believed psychoanalysis was the answer, the so
called talking cure. But it wasn't practical to psychoanalyze thousands of distraught soldiers.
Younger psychiatrists wanted to try faster, more direct methods, using physical treatments. The
most radical of these doctors at Sutton Hospital in Surrey was William Sargent. He dismissed
psychoanalysis as useless talk when action was needed. He wanted to try drugs. Sargent gave the
soldiers massive doses of sodium amytal, a new sedative. The idea was to break the vicious
circle of exhaustion and anxiety by putting them into a deep sleep that could last three weeks.
I walked in, I could see them all there lying in these beds, receiving this stuff they call
jungle juice, which is a treatment to put you into a twilight world. And they were all like
sort of zombies laying in the bed, you know, nobody spoke and looked at you. I thought,
well, this is it, sort of thing. I've got to be like this, I don't want to be in here. But you
had to stay there because you were in the army and that was all there was about it.
He used to do this deep narcosis treatment, you keep them asleep for weeks on end and
they would just be woken up for an hour a day, you know, to be fed and washed and all that sort
of thing. He did that a lot, he had a whole ward of them, which was quite creepy, I found quite
creepy when I went there, to find all these people sound asleep with darkness and it's a
bit like that nocturnal animal part of the zoo where, you know, everything's dark, they make
it night and it's really day, a bit like that. His theory was that when they came out of this
deep sleep treatment that they were better and I think some of them were.
Sargent believed in what he called heroic doses. The usual error, he said,
was to give too little. He made a film about the methods he was pioneering. Sargent's hospital
footage is a unique record of wartime medicine. A different drug, insulin, helped soldiers gain
weight and so restore them physically. But the treatment had dangers. Insulin induced a coma by
lowering the blood sugar level. If it dropped too far, the consequence was irreversible brain damage
and even death. Sargent used drugs not just to make his patients sleep and eat, but to make
them talk. With drugs, they were made to recall the experiences that had triggered their breakdown.
The idea was that once the terrible event had been uncovered, the men would get better. The
treatment was for the most severe shock cases where men had lost their memory or power of speech.
I couldn't speak, I couldn't say thank you, I couldn't say anything. Whether I was frightened
to speak, I don't know. Not to this day, I don't know. But I just hesitated and tried to come out.
John Hanstock became a casualty while serving in the Navy.
The traumatic experiences that led to his breakdown came in the Mediterranean.
Month after month, his ship was attacked by German and Italian planes.
After the death of his closest friend, he was close to cracking up, but for weeks tried to
conceal his despair. Things seemed to be coming to a head. I was feeling this can't go on, you know,
it just can't go on this. I thought no one else knew. But the captain had noticed that there was
something wrong. John Hanstock was ordered to report to the ship's doctor. He came to me
and he looked in my eyes. I didn't like it at all. A kind word, I've not had a kind word.
Nobody does any forces. They don't know such thing as kind words. And the floodgates opened
and I cried as my mother would have seen me cry as a child.
Following his breakdown, John Hanstock was treated by narco-analysis, as pioneered by
Sargent. Men were given lower doses of the sedative drugs in pill form. The drugs opened
up their unconscious minds and they began to talk without any inhibition. Servicemen called it
the truth drug. Doctor, he said to me, I want you to tell me things about your service.
And he said, I'm going to relax you and give you this pill. And my word, talk, I did.
You've no control over the power of this drug you're taking. And you just talk. You just talk
because you're asked to talk. And you talk. There's no sort of dodging it. When I came out of
it, I was cleansed. It was clean. It was clear. I hadn't a buzz. It was marvellous. I had absolutely
no anxiety. Most doctors used the new drugs simply to provoke what they called an abreaction,
the sudden cathartic release of buried emotions. But Sargent was more ambitious. He led his
patients on, making them relive each stage of their experience and directing their emotions
to a new conclusion. The soldier would start telling his story about how his friend had been
blown up and blown all over him. Sargent would introduce the idea of the dreadful machine gunner
who'd done it. And instead of all the anger and fear floating around sort of rather aimlessly,
it would be directed against the wicked German. The patient would scream or shout or be very
distressed, shake from head to foot, all of these symptoms which had not been released
without the drug. It would be quite a noisy session. And then at the end of it, the soldier
would exhaust it and collapse back and Sargent would then tell him that he was in control and
he'd been a brave man who'd overcome the enemy. So his morale was restored. That was really the
object of the abreaction. Before the war, these men might have ended up in an asylum.
Their improvement seemed to vindicate all Sargent's claims for physical treatments.
You can regard those patients as guinea pigs. In a way, all patients are guinea pig. Medicine
and psychiatry is very much a hit and miss affair. And yes, of course, if you have suddenly have a
war and a lot of soldiers were damaged, this is a new situation and so you can call it guinea
pigs if you like. But nobody really knew what to do. The disaster of Dunkirk forced the army
to confront the problem of mental breakdown. From now on, they had to plan for it.
Some of the men who had broken down should never have been sent to war in the first place.
So the army looked again at the way it selected soldiers.
The very first psychological tests were introduced to probe recruits' personality
and intelligence. Which horse will be harder to hold? A, B, or the same? Which weighs more?
A, B, or equal? Men considered vulnerable to stress were weeded out and given non-fighting jobs.
Go!
200 psychiatrists were recruited and given the rank of major. They tried to get involved in
not just treating the sick, but every part of army life. Training, officer selection, discipline,
and morale. But the new experts met resistance. There was a fair amount of surprise and jealousy
perhaps at the growing influence of psychiatry in the army. Because before the army, psychiatry
was regarded as one of the Cinderella specialties. And this was quite a shock, I think, to many people
in the corps. So there was a considerable resistance to this intrusion, as they felt,
of psychiatry into a soldier's business, not a doctor's business.
Suspicion of the shrinks went right to the top. Even the Prime Minister, Winston Churchill, was
concerned, telling the War Office, it would be sensible to restrict as much as possible the work
of these gentlemen, who are capable of doing an immense amount of harm. It is very wrong to disturb
large numbers of normal, healthy men by asking odd questions.
You married a widow? Yes, sir. I see. How old is your stepdaughter? 20 years old, sir. 20 years old.
Yes. Had her father been dead for a long time? Thus far he was killed, sir. So that your wife
would draw a pension? Yes, sir. Until she decided that you were better than a pension.
The squatters' view of psychiatry was a fairly ribald one, I would say.
But there was a general kind of myth operating almost from the moment I got into the army
about working your ticket. It was a great way to work your ticket to fool the trick cyclists,
and it was a very easy thing to do. You just pretend you're mad.
In practice, I don't believe it was an easy thing to do.
But despite the scepticism, the army's pioneering commitment to psychiatry and psychology
was pursued with vigour. Then Poole. Poole is an odd sort of man. In civilian life,
he was very badly adjusted. In the personal sense, that is. He just couldn't mix, couldn't
make friends. Psychiatrists sifted through those already in the ranks, moving vulnerable soldiers
to more suitable jobs. With a desperate shortage of manpower, they tried to ensure no one's skills
were wasted. He just couldn't make it. An artillery barrage which outclassed the
preliminary attacks on Alamein and Maurit. At the battlefronts, army commanders felt
they had more immediate things to worry about. In North Africa, the 8th Army had begun to drive
Rommel's men back across the desert. Some generals refused to have psychiatrists with them,
regarding them as fifth columnists, who'd only reduced the number of fighting soldiers available.
And officers still found it hard to tell Shirkers from the genuinely battle shock.
As the campaign gathered momentum, the mental endurance of newly trained British troops
was put to the test. Raw, primitive, atavistic fear comes when you are actually in an attack
and people around you are being killed or maimed in very unpleasant ways and that you are likely
to be. And this fear is monstrously engulfing and it is personal and it is demoralizing and it is
dehumanizing and it is in a sense shameful because you know, I think you know, that you would do
anything really to escape from this monster.
Vernon Scannell was 18 when he was called out.
After five months of artillery and tank attacks, he was reaching his limits.
Our job was to go forward under cover of night and we dug in at the foot of this range of hills
and as it got light, the rest of the brigade passed through us and put in this attack.
We went up the hill shortly after they put in the attack and they were simply mowed down because
it was daylight. It was partly because these men, we'd actually seen them, they'd passed through
our positions as they were going up and we were sort of exchanging badinage and up they'd gone
and there they all were. And then I saw that a lot of our people, my own unit, my own friends,
were going around looting these bodies. And why it should be worse to loot your own dead
than the enemy, which I'd seen umpteen times taking watches and things off dead Germans and
Germans. Why it should be worse taking off their own men, but it was somehow and I didn't know. I
sort of thought I can't take any more of this and I turned around and walked away.
I was simply sick of them, of me, of it, of everything. I was simply sick of the whole thing.
Sick of what people are, what humans can do. I hadn't planned it. In a sense it seemed outside my control.
A strange dream. And when I remember it, I seem to be floating along rather than walking.
I just carried on walking and walked and walked and walked and covered something like a hundred
miles. I got back to Tripoli, which is a long, long way from where we were, before I was picked
up by Red Caps. Jeep came up and bundled me into it and took me off. And I was caught in Marshall and
sentenced to three years, three years hard labor. Scannell's temporary breakdown was interpreted as
desertion. There was no psychiatric examination at his trial. The North Africa campaign produced
the highest rates of breakdown and desertion since Dunkirk. Some generals were so dismayed
at the threat to discipline, they asked that the right to shoot deserters be restored to them
as a deterrent to others. But army psychiatrists had now concluded that after five days and nights
of continuous bombardment, any soldier would break down. Instead of shell shock, they used a
new term, battle exhaustion. It encouraged the idea that the condition was temporary.
If men were simply rested, they could recover and carry on fighting.
And army officers were taught to recognize the signs of stress.
Sandy, that fellow Rag of yours will be back in a day or two.
Oh.
He was a pretty good soldier, wasn't he, until he cracked up?
Yes, until he cracked up. But when a good soldier goes to pieces like that, well, there must have been a yellow streak in him somewhere.
Sandy, you're probably a very good soldier yourself, but you're a bloody bad doctor. Under certain circumstances, any man will crack up.
Particularly if he's got some private worry.
Well, had he any private worry?
Well, you should know. You're his platoon commander.
The war in the air produced its own unique stresses.
But the RAF met them with a steelier approach than the army.
With casualty rates so high, any notion that each man might have a breaking point was taboo.
There could be no backsliding.
Nobody had quite realized what a deadly business being a crew was.
What the expectation of life was, or death.
David Stafford-Clark was a medical officer with bomber command.
It was part of his job to look out for signs of stress in the crews.
The best way I can estimate the survival rate was by saying that it was generally understood, never really mentioned, except among friends in private, that they had a one in four chance of surviving.
They lived from day to day. They knew.
Next week, when I go on leave, which never said, because next week hadn't come yet.
Can I start the plane?
To fulfill the basic requirement, crews had to complete a tour of 30 bombing missions.
If they survived that long, many were then expected to do a second tour.
And the chances of seeing it through dropped still further.
Arthur Smith joined the RAF in 1942, when he was 18, and became a bomb aimer.
The fear of flying was never talked about, in my experience.
And I would never have dreamed of saying I was afraid, or didn't want to do this, because I'd be letting my crew down.
This sort of personal feelings of that sort, it wasn't natural to talk about them to each other.
You certainly realized that you weren't the only one that was frightened.
Quite obviously, other people were frightened. Some people could bottle it up better than others.
For some men, the near certainty of death became unbearable.
But if they showed any signs of wavering, they were classified as LMF, Lacking in Moral Fibre.
An RAF order set out what would happen to them.
If the Air Force decide that an individual must be categorized as Lacking in Moral Fibre,
there will be no question of his being given an opportunity to rehabilitate himself.
His services will be dispensed with.
It was an administrative label. Instead of saying, you haven't got the gun, you're yellow, or anything, it was LMF.
Stigmatized as cowards. They might have done 10 trips.
Nobody who'd done 10 trips couldn't have been a coward.
I mean, a coward wouldn't have done more than one.
Arthur Smith had flown 20 missions, but the tension was beginning to take its toll.
It was a night trip. Very sticky target.
The opposition from fighters and flak was expected to be very tough.
It was then that I said to myself, I don't think I can go on this.
I said it to myself, not to anybody else. I thought, I must stop now.
I still didn't have the courage to say to anybody, my crew member or to anybody,
I can't go on this trip, I don't want to fly anymore.
So I just went on, we went in the aircraft.
When your moral goes, everything about your nervous system changes.
As it were, as though you were dying inside.
You stop hoping, you stop expecting that you'll survive.
And at the same time, you can't get out of whatever your job is,
because there is no way out. You've volunteered for it, you've got to do it.
I worked myself up into such a frenzy, apparently,
that when we got up in the air, I just found I couldn't do anything, I couldn't talk.
I thought, in my own thoughts, I thought, this is it, I can't do it.
This is me telling myself, I can't fly anymore.
Hello, rear gunner, can you hear me?
I'm okay, skipper.
Our navigator, Mac, he realised something was very wrong,
because I wasn't doing anything and I wouldn't speak to him,
and I was shaking a bit, I believe.
So he said to the skipper on the intercom,
there's something wrong with Smithy Wag.
I don't know what, he can't do anything, he's ill in some way.
And after a little while longer,
they said, well, we'd better turn back.
So back they came.
And when we landed,
the medical officer came along
and he obviously examined me, found nothing physically wrong,
and I said, I don't want to fly anymore.
And then, of course, that was it.
I was sent back to my billet to pack my kit.
I wasn't allowed contact with anybody at all.
No goodbye to my crew or anything.
And a sergeant service police came along,
took me into a covered wagon
and drove me away to I know not where.
The authorities believed that LMF could be contagious.
Arthur Smith was taken away to another base,
where he was interviewed by a psychiatrist.
He told me exactly what would happen to me.
I'd be stripped of my rank, lose my flying pay,
be sent away to another station to do some menial job.
Everybody would know what I'd done.
My family would know what I'd done.
And I realised that I'd be branded a coward
for the rest of my life.
And the thought of this was absolutely shattering.
Arthur Smith was one of the few to be offered a second chance,
despite the official ruling.
The psychiatrist telephoned his station
to see if he could go back.
My commanding officer said,
yes, if his crew will have him.
So then straightway phoned up my pilot
on the squadron in the office
while I was still in the interview.
And my pilot had a very quick talk
with the rest of the crew,
who must have been with him at the time.
And they said, yes, 100 per cent,
they all want you back.
So I came back.
Between 1943 and 1944,
over 3,000 airmen
were stripped of their rank
and branded LMF.
Arthur Smith went on
to complete his 30 missions.
In 1945,
he was commended for bravery
after saving one of his crew
from a burning plane.
In 1942,
the army decided it needed
a special psychiatric hospital
attuned to military needs.
They took over an old Victorian
lunatic asylum near Birmingham
and sent their own staff
to run it.
They believed civilian hospitals
were not returning enough soldiers
to the front.
Northfield was to be different.
Organised on the principle
that once men had physically recovered,
they should be treated as soldiers,
not psychiatric patients,
however emotionally battle-scarred
they might be.
It was a regime not of drugs,
but of therapeutic confrontation.
One psychiatrist who developed
this new approach was
Lieutenant Colonel Tom Main.
His theory was that the army
allowed no place for grief.
Main believed that in order to recover,
soldiers had to be made to grieve
by whatever means.
He would take risks.
He would, for example,
allow a person to feel
just what a rat he was
and to bring him down almost
to a point where the patient himself
would either go under,
as some did,
or else of his own volition,
he'd begin to say,
look, I'm not this bad,
for God's sake,
I'm not what you're making out to be.
And then, of course,
he would, well, repair himself.
Vernon Scannell,
who'd been sentenced to hard labour,
later met men treated by Colonel Main.
Tom Main maintained
that those soldiers
in charge of a tank crew
who'd lost their tank
and their crews,
and they had been sole survivors
and were showing
an unwillingness to return to battle,
he said that they
had insufficiently mourned
the death of their crew,
which sounds to me like total nonsense.
He would then,
unbelievably, lock them up
into cells with only,
I think,
an hour or so of artificial light
daily,
in darkness otherwise,
and I think put them on bread and water,
the sort of punishment diet,
the way that the worst criminals
are treated in military prisons.
But there were
less threatening forms of treatment
at Northfield.
Art therapy was pioneered
by Sergeant Lawrence Bradbury.
He encouraged soldiers
to confront their hidden
feelings of shame, guilt,
or despair.
The aim was emotional release,
with paint,
not drugs.
It was, in miniature,
a therapeutic unit,
and the results that were produced there,
some of them really very interesting
and brilliant, but the hope,
if it were a success,
I probably was on occasions,
it was the doing of these things,
bringing up into the conscience
what otherwise would be haunting
and festering behind.
So instead of diverting their attention
as occupational therapy aimed to do,
they were allowed there to face up,
even though the grieving
could sometimes be heart-rending.
At other hospitals,
progressive doctors were beginning to experiment
with another, more hands-on
approach to mental illness.
There was a little cleaner
in the ward,
and she used to take a great deal of pleasure
in saying,
treatment day today!
Oh dear.
And the beds were all moved up
so we were touching each other
with the head to the centre.
So on my head, when I was back like this,
to the centre of the ward.
And then you heard the people
coming along, the doctor,
the sister,
and another nurse,
the staff nurse,
they came one by one,
and you hear this activity,
something on a trolley.
Electroconvulsive therapy,
ECT,
had first been used in Italy.
Many hospitals in Britain
had forbidden experiments with it,
but the war opened the way.
Two pads were put
on the patient's forehead,
and a controlled shock given
to induce an epileptic fit.
No one really knew how it worked,
but it seemed to relieve
chronic depression.
I stood at the head of the patient
and put the gag in place
to stop them from biting
their tongue,
or ingesting their teeth
if their teeth
met the two sets
they might break.
And then
I immersed the electrodes
in saline solution,
plugged in
the apparatus,
and handed them to the doctor.
And then they come to you.
Now there is
the hand stopped.
We're going to
just lay back gently like that.
We'll just put these on your head.
You feel the dump
of the thing on like that.
You had no idea what was going to happen.
Nobody told you anything at all.
And then
these figures all
came out of the darkness
of this room towards you.
And that was it.
You remembered no more at all.
In those days,
that was given straight.
You didn't have any muscle relaxants
like they do now.
It was quite dramatic.
They would give them a shock,
and they'd leap up in the air
and arch their backs
and have a full epileptic fit
and sometimes fracture their spines
and things.
It was very dramatic.
You could hear the bones cracking
and they just went off
like pistol shots.
You won't be sleeping in your bed
tonight.
And then you say to the nurse,
this is the
strange thing about it.
And many, many people I've asked
about this have said exactly
the same thing. When am I going to
have the treatment? And to be
quite honest, it did the trick.
But it was the most
difficult
thing to go through with.
I think, as I say, the thing I should never forget
is these figures
coming towards you,
ready to grab you.
They were far too much and
chose a lot of patients that weren't suitable.
But when you have a patient that
has a particular sort of deep depression
or something, and to see them come out of it
so quickly, instead of lying there for
six months or something, it is a very
remarkable treatment. But it's hazardous
and a lot of people are not very good at
choosing the patients.
The war was
providing an unprecedented testing
ground.
Psychiatrists were able to try out
a series of experimental treatments
on patients who had no say
in the matter. In drastic
times, drastic measures
flourished.
The D-Day landings in 1944
and the war's
final phase saw psychiatry
taken directly into battle.
For the first time,
the military had planned for the possibility
of huge numbers of emotional
casualties.
All medical officers had been
trained in the treatment of battle exhaustion.
And within a month,
an entire psychiatric hospital
was established in France.
The invasion
troops met fierce resistance
from the Germans, and breakdown
rates soared even beyond the
planners' predictions.
Within ten days of landing,
nearly a quarter of all casualties
were psychiatric.
Psychiatrists
now knew they had to treat soldiers
quickly before their symptoms set in.
So
exhaustion centres were established
just behind the front.
The centres had been
pioneered by army psychiatrists
during the fighting in Italy.
On arrival,
the men were washed,
fed, then heavily sedated.
These images
have never been shown before,
and are still considered so sensitive
that the men's identities
had to be concealed.
With the help of drugs,
they could rest,
and their symptoms of trauma might disappear.
Dr. Desmond Murphy
ran an exhaustion centre.
He told the men
there was no need to be ashamed of their condition.
Many of the soldiers
wanted to talk
because they were
worried about
why they broke down, how they broke down.
Some of them were
a little shameful of having
broken down.
Others were guilty
about other companions
or buddies who had been
wounded.
Guilt is a very common thing
in people who survive
battles or casualties.
And when there is a particularly
tragic
happening,
the guilt can become so intense
that it forms part
of the breakdown.
After their deep sleep
treatment, the men were put back
in uniform.
Military discipline was maintained.
They were not allowed to forget
that they were soldiers
and that their comrades back at the front
needed them.
I had to make judgments,
decisions on
who to keep, who to send back.
I was
never fully
certain that I had made
the right decision.
And in fact, I think I must have made
the wrong decision in some cases,
for good
or for better or for worse.
In 1945,
the war ended.
Five years of fighting had brought about
a complete change of attitude
to mental illness.
The army had realized
that shock and breakdown were
inevitable.
They understood that given enough stress,
every man had his breaking point.
Psychiatrists had proved they could get results.
And in the post-war years,
there would be an almost total
conversion to physical treatments.
In the brave
new world, drugs were
prescribed for almost every condition.
And ECT machines
hummed across the country.
But some scars would never heal.
For the rest of their lives,
men would live with the traumatic
events that had caused their illness.
Bill Hooper
had endured two years of
hand-to-hand fighting in Burma.
After his best friend
was shot dead beside him,
he broke down completely.
Even after he left
hospital, he was still troubled
by memories of the jungle.
Coming home,
everything was dead
and quite.
You'd been used to a life
over there,
where it was absolutely battered to hell.
You didn't know one day
from another.
It was absolutely traumatized, is my take.
And you come home,
settle in your house,
and the first thing you want to do is get out.
It was nothing for Bill,
especially if it was raining,
to be in the middle of his meal.
He wouldn't say anything.
He'd just put his knife and fork down,
get up,
go in the garden,
stand in the pouring rain,
come back in,
sit down, and finish his dinner.
And that happened quite often.
When I came home,
the first thing I said
my wife went through the front door,
which she would verify,
was, have you got a carving knife?
And she said, yes.
I said, would you please hide it?
The sole fact is,
out there in Burma,
we use knives.
We use bayonets.
So, you've got a knife.
Are you going to use it?
If it's hidden, you can't, can you?
I said, yes, I'll have the carving knife.
Well, actually, my carving knife
was one of my father's butcher's knives.
So I went and saw
the old lady next door.
It was super.
And I told her,
you knock three times on your kitchen wall
and I'll come out in the garden and give you your knife.
I said, right.
And when I want to hand it back,
I'll knock three times on the wall
and you can have it back again.
And that went on the whole time we lived in that house.
And that must have been three or four years.
And I think
the tragedy of it
for myself and many other people
was that no one warned us
what was coming home.
Even now,
50 years later,
memories still haunt.
Thousands of veterans are still being treated
for emotional wounds
sustained during their war.
And some traumas
have lain dormant.
Men who survived the war,
apparently unscathed,
are breaking down now,
in their old age.
The final part of Shell Shock
examines the traumatic effects of...
These photographs...
