Shapiro Calls Massie a “Clown” — Here’s Why the Impeachment Articles Are Actually Serious

The FactFocal
1 follower
Nov 12, 2026
My stuff: SPOTIFY! https://open.spotify.com/show/1eEnWh7...
LOCALS! https://vivabarneslaw.locals.com/
HOT SAUCE! https://biltongusa.com/product/viva-v...
GET SOME! https://biltongusa.com/product/viva-p...
AI Generated·May contain errors
Thomas Massie filed articles of impeachment against Pete Hegseth.
I like Pete Hegseth, and I'm not going to apologize for it.
I disagree with decisions of the administration.
The idea that just following orders does
not defend FBI agents any more than it defends
secretaries of war, who,
if you believe they're waging an unjust war or an ill-advised war,
that's a little bit different than waging an unlawful.
War or committing war crimes.
I defended Pete Hegseth when he was being attacked for that
incident that occurred among consenting adults
at a conservative conference back in the day when
they were trying to slander him and besmirch him.
Ultimately, what I think of the Iran war,
what I think, you know, Hegseth runs a risk of impeachment.
I still like him. I think he's got
the image and the brand of what you need
for a secretary of war. It would have just been
awesome for his tenure had we not had this politically catastrophic.
Not war that is a war that's not never-ending,
but it's still going on with Iran.
Okay, Thomas Massie and Pete Hegseth are enemies, period.
People say you want loyalty in D.C., get a dog.
When you make an enemy, understand that they're going to be an enemy.
So people can, you can ---- on Thomas Massey all you want,
call him a grandstander, call him a phony, whatever.
He and Pete Hegseth are political enemies.
Pete Hegseth literally went to Kentucky
and campaigned for, arguably borderline improperly,
using federal funds to do it,
campaigned for Ed Gallagher.
They're enemies right now.
Don't expect favors among enemies,
and don't blame Thomas Massie for treating
what is an enemy to him the way you would treat an enemy.
So he filed articles of impeachment,
which didn't get passed,
but not necessarily for the reasons that some people think.
It was not to do with, from what I understand,
the weakness or the baselessness
or the legal untenability of the articles of impeachment.
It was because Democrats didn't show up to vote for it,
and so it failed the vote to get to the floor.
But for those who are catching up on the news,
and I'll give it to you, I think,
not without opinion, but without spin,
my understanding, if I understand it correctly,
it was not a resounding rejection of Thomas Massie
and or his articles of impeachment.
Apparently, there were some Democrats who didn't show up to vote,
and it didn't reach the required threshold for the time being.
And it looks like...
Until the end of this session, it doesn't
look like it's going to hit the floor again.
The only question is going to be not if,
but when these similar articles of impeachment
and arguably potentially even more emboldened
and with more charges hits the floor under
the new administration or the new House
and the new Senate when the Democrats take control.
House votes to effectively end
the impeachment effort against Pete Hegseth.
This is from yesterday.
The House has voted 211 to 204 to refer
the articles of impeachment filed against Defense
Secretary Pete Hegseth at the committee,
effectively killing the impeachment efforts spearheaded by
Thomas Massie. Today's vote short-circuits any potential floor vote
on the articles of
impeachment and virtually guarantees the measure will
not be taken up before the current session
of Congress expires.
The vote provided a surprise reprieve for President Trump's
embattled Defense Secretary,
who was facing an impeachment vote by the full House as early as Wednesday
Massey reintroduced the articles of impeachment on Monday,
accusing Hegseth of high crimes and
misdemeanors in connection to the war in Iran,
U.S. strikes, Iran, etc., etc. Let me just double
check one. You got the war in Iran,
the bombing of the schoolchildren, the blowing up of drug
dealers and or fishermen out of the Caribbean,
what some people call the kidnapping, other people
call law enforcement exercise of Maduro, a bunch of stuff.
Hegseth defended himself against
the impeachment effort during the rare press conference,
criticizing Massey as a disgruntled
and defeated congressman. For sure, you make enemies. I mean,
you don't get loyalty in D.C. You'll certainly get,
call it loyal opposition,
from people who are enemies. 11 Democrats did not vote.
211 to 204, 11 Democrats did not vote.
They were not voting according to the House rule.
The Democrat absences exceeded the final seven
vote margin. Julia, I don't know
if they didn't show up to not vote or whatever.
Explanation varied and included traffic delays near
the Capitol, including Senator a few,
Pelosi being in San Francisco for Veteran Day event,
and other scheduling reasons.
Some later indicated they would have voted against the referral.
Had the 11 Democrats voted no,
the motion would have failed 211-215 and kept the resolution live on the floor
So that's interesting.
Make with it what you want.
Politics is about spin as well.
So it says, I stand behind every one of those operations.
He says, I was proud to execute them, and I would do it again tomorrow.
This hopefully does not end up sounding like the,
you're goddamn right, I ordered the code
red.
On Monday, Trump expressed support
for Hegseth during a wide-ranging impromptu brief.
Impeachment measure was Massey's second attempt against Hegseth.
He first sought to bring impeachment resolution
to the floor in the midterm elections, prompting
Speaker Mike Johnson to call an early recess.
While the impeachment push may be quelled for now,
Hegseth's troubles on Capitol are not over.
Democrats have promised vigorous investigations
into Hegseth's Pentagon
once they assume the majority in January.
Whether they will mount another impeachment effort
remains unclear.
No, it doesn't.
They are obviously, definitively
going to mount an impeachment.
And I'll tell you why in a second
when I deal with some of Ben Shapiro's
interpretation of this.
But in an interview with NPR last week,
Hakeem Jeffries, who's expected to be
the next Speaker of the House,
said simply of Hegseth,
he's got to go.
Ben Shapiro.
Comes out with an interpretation, and I started watching it.
I'm going to play a portion of it at 1.5x,
but it's a weird thing where now that I fully
appreciate it, and I've lived through it,
I've seen it, I've witnessed it, I've commented
on it in real time, Ben Shapiro being the inverse of truth
and the inverse of accuracy
when it came to COVID.
You say, all right, well, that was just a one-off,
and everyone was panicking, deferring
to authority when he said, get the jab, dummies.
He was just...
Operating on the best information that they had at the time
because he was listening to the tyrants.
Okay, fine.
Now we've seen Ben Shapiro's political analysis
over the last 18 months as relates to the Iran War,
the opportunity of the Iran War,
the political popularity of the Iran War,
and he was wrong.
Wrong, wrong, wrong.
He, Mark Levin, all of the other war whores
are, I say, responsible for the destruction
of the Republican midterms.
And if you...
operate on the basis that, you know,
once upon a time, the Mark Levins of the world were
vitriolically anti-Trump.
You could say if they wanted to sabotage Trump while getting
their own political profit out of it,
their own geopolitical profit out of it, their own
financial profit out of it. What would they have done differently?
Egg on Trump to do this war in
Iran, support him, make him believe that he's got
the support of everyday Americans, make bank
through sponsors, make bank through your show,
make bank through your Fox News appearances,
reputational enhancements from Trump retweeting you.
And then it blows up in your face after a
year and a half of you spearheading this.
And now we're going to listen to your interpretation of
the impeachment, the articles of impeachment against Pete Hegseth.
I'll play just a little bit of this.
Definitely not the whole thing,
but it's worth listening to.
And we're going to put it on one and a half
so that we can do it a little bit faster than we otherwise would.
Representative Thomas Massie, who is on his way out,
remember that he was defeated in a primary in Kentucky
because he decided to run on the issue of Israel
in a district that has 500 total Jews.
Representative Massey, on his way out,
he needs some strange new respect.
He must have it.
He must have it.
And so, or vengeance against the man
who literally went to Kentucky to campaign for his opponent.
Maybe.
Or to grab a few headlines as the door hits him in the ass.
He has now introduced articles of impeachment
against Pete Hegseth, the Secretary of Defense.
Here is Representative Thomas Massey
making sure to grandstand one last time.
The form of the resolution is as follows.
Impeaching Peter Brian Hegseth, Secretary of Defense,
for high crimes and misdemeanors.
Resolved that Peter Brian Hegseth, Secretary of Defense,
also referred to as Secretary of War by
the administration, is impeached for high crimes and misdemeanors,
and that the following articles
of impeachment be exhibited to the United States Senate.
Now, also, pause it, and it's going to be
relevant as we go through this.
Do remember the entire argument we had during the first two
High crimes and misdemeanors.
people distinguish from crimes.
And if you're, you know, the argument was that if it was crimes,
it would have said crimes.
High crimes are not necessarily criminal crimes or codified crimes.
But during the first two impeachments,
the argument was made that it doesn't even have to
be criminal. The argument was they can impeach you
if they don't like the color of your tie,
because it's a political measure, not a legal one.
I happen to wildly disagree with that.
The terms have meanings, whether
or not the Supreme Court would ever adjudicate on it
and determine that which would constitute a high crime
and misdemeanor, we'll see.
You're dealing with the courts adjudicating
on a political measure for the removal of
someone from office.
That being said.
When it comes to Pete Hegseth and the articles of impeachment here,
it's not even close that
if you thought what Trump was impeached
for but not convicted were not crimes and they
were really bending the law and bending the Constitution,
that is not the case at all
when it comes to what Massey was putting forward
or is putting forward by way of articles of
impeachment.
We're talking about killing schoolchildren during war.
The only question is going to be,
do you think that's a high crime and misdemeanor if it's
done through negligence or through...
Okay, now, this is actually
a reintroduction of articles he filed back
in September before the recess,
but now, because the Republicans did so poorly in the election,
he feels like this is a great way of attacking the administration.
Now, what's kind of fascinating here is he doesn't go right to Trump.
Because he understands if he tried to impeach Trump,
then the Republican Party would stand up and say no.
So what he's trying to do is draw away a few sort of rogue Republicans
to his side to build on his nascent anti-Republican movement.
Again, I said this before the election.
There is a wing of the Republican Party that wanted
to watch things crash and burn so they could pick up the pieces.
By the way, if that's what you said beforehand, those same Republicans
might actually jump on an impeachment wagon against Donald Trump, Ben.
So you might want to think about
that in terms of what the impact might be.
Now, stating the obvious, yeah,
he's going after Massey before going after Trump.
Because, A,
You know damn well the Democrats are going to go after Trump.
He doesn't have to waste his political goodwill on that
if ever he wants to come back with some form of political aspirations.
But also, it's nice to say Massy, the enemy, Massy, the enemy.
Massie might be saying, you know,
this is what's coming for Trump on steroids,
so you guys had better start planning.
You can ---- on Massey all you want for what he's doing.
You know it's coming, and coming ten times harder from the Democrats.
And Ben, to the extent that there are Republicans
who want to watch it crash and burn,
why wouldn't they also vote for a conviction?
The goal. Many of them openly campaign for this.
It is not as though they're rooting for Republicans
and then Republicans will lose.
They're rooting hard against the Republicans
and were overjoyed when Republicans did poorly last week.
And somehow those people are going to be credited with what?
Republican resurgence here?
Okay, anyway. Thomas Massie.
He filed these articles.
These articles are nonsensical.
They are nonsensical.
Nonsensical is a conclusion.
And we'll see if that is a tenable conclusion based
on Ben Shapiro's own description of those articles.
I mean, we know what the articles are.
I got them in the backdrop.
There's no crime alleged.
Remember, impeachment is for high crimes and misdemeanors.
There's not a misdemeanor alleged.
There's not a hate crime alleged.
There's no crime alleged.
But the.
They're alleging the bombing and killing of 115 schoolgirls
in a double tap strike on a base that they obviously mistook.
That's not arguably, if you think it might have
been done based on inaccurate information
or negligence, that's not potentially,
if someone wanted to argue that, is a crime in
the misdemeanor.
Come on.
It's a bunch of stuff he doesn't like.
So Article 1 here is starting the Iran war without authorization.
Now, you may know that actually the person
who authorized military action was the president
of the United States.
They should be directed against the president.
But because Thomas Massie is still scared of the president,
he's going after Pete Hegseth.
What the argument is,
is that abiding by unlawful orders is itself impeachable.
And then if you do get an impeachment on that,
you then pivot to the war, which isn't a war
and was never got congressional
authorization being impeachable as well.
This point is irrelevant.
The argument is that Pete Hegseth followed unlawful orders.
I'm not, whether or not you believe it,
his argument that presidents have done this
throughout history. In fact, there's only
been one formal declaration of war. The last formal
declaration of war was World War II.
And you had Vietnam, the Korean War, you had kinetic strikes.
That's not the best argument, Ben, because
a lot of us have been saying from the get-go,
the fact that it's been tolerated doesn't make it.
legal and it doesn't make it not impeachable
and it's tolerated until they no longer want to
tolerate it for whatever the political reason.
He says that because Joe Pence said there was
no imminent threat, there must not have been an imminent threat.
Now, again, this is silly.
The president has constitutional authority
to order kinetic action without a declaration of
war or congressional authorization.
It happens literally all the time. Kinetic action doesn't
have the doesn't have the authority to declare
war without the approval of Congress or at least
beyond a certain point.
But again, semantics, this is an argument. This does not make the
The articles of impeachment, idiotic, as he initially said.
I know there are a lot of people who are saying,
what about the Congressional Declaration of War?
The last time Congress officially declared war,
like really not an authorization to use military force,
like a full-scale declaration of war was World War II.
We've had a few conflicts since then.
Are you saying this as a good thing or as a bad thing, Ben?
It might set the precedent that, yeah,
if you're going to get into prolonged war,
Iraq 1, Iraq 2, Afghanistan, Syria, Kosovo,
if you're going to do it,
you better get a declaration of war.
If you don't, we might impeach your ass afterwards.
You might want to think,
if that's the precedent set going forward,
maybe you don't have...
Endless, forever wars consistently for the last 100 years, 80 years.
Imminence, by the way, under the law does
not require a threat within hours or days.
Sort of vague.
Andrew Kent is a ridiculous figure who has
discredited himself a thousand times over.
So Article 1, nonsense.
Article 2 is defying a congressional order to withdraw from Iran.
Do we all think that Article 1 is nonsense?
I mean, I appreciate that's the argument.
That's the defense.
Nonsense means it's baseless on its face, untenable on its face.
He's made, I don't even know if it's a compelling rebuttal argument.
Well, because we've done it so many times in the past
that we get to do it forever going forward.
Not necessarily.
We're not talking about an impeachment over a phone call.
We're not talking about an impeachment
over a ******* truth social post or a Twitter post.
We're talking about an impeachment over a non-war
that's still going on in which a school was bombed.
Based, allegedly, on using AI to determine targets.
I'm sorry, it's not nonsense.
You might not like it.
It might not ultimately pass muster, or at least get a conviction.
Don't tell me that's nonsense.
At least there's an argument for, it's not a crime.
It's not a high crime or a misdemeanor to bomb a school on purpose.
Okay, well, it wasn't on purpose.
It was an accident.
Did that accident result from negligence?
It goes on like this for a very long time.
Let's do a couple more.
On June 23rd, Congress passed a resolution to remove forces from Iran.
We're having
rewriting
of the present
in real time.
We're not actually at war because there haven't
been kinetic hostilities since June.
So when Trump comes out and says, yes,
it's a war and I would have done it again.
He's saying, no, no, Trump, it wasn't really a war.
It's just now the straits are blocked.
That's all that's going on.
It's not really a war now because,
you know, there's no boots on the ground.
April,
if you go all the way back, I mean, a couple of sporadic strikes,
like full-scale warfare basically ended with a ceasefire in April.
And then the MOU collapsed in June.
And then it just turned back into blockade.
A blockade is not an authorization of war.
It doesn't require a congressional authorization of war.
Article three is the 60 day war powers clock.
So President Trump sent Congress a war powers notification March 2nd,
expired May 1st, and there was no extension of it.
But number one,
the War Powers Act violates the president's executive authority.
It's never really gone all the way up to the Supreme Court level,
but that's what would happen.
The idea that the Congress can claw back
the president's executive authority
under the Constitution is wrong.
And again, ongoing military operations does not mean war.
There are ongoing military operations for the United States all around
the globe.
I don't think Ben is actually fully appreciating
the consequences of what he's saying.
I mean, they're in violations of the War Powers Act.
We'll find out, potentially,
and you'll also find out
if that becomes an impeachable offense
if the people with the power to impeach say,
we don't want to live with constant ongoing war
because one man declaring it
and saying you guys don't have the power
to claw back my authorization to declare kinetic strikes.
It's not war.
You might actually rein in a new...
era of an empire if it's not done with political impunity
to constantly wage endless conflict in
the absence of a declaration of war.
You might not have wars of choice, kinetic strikes of choice,
if you understand you can get impeached for doing it,
but if they don't think that it was the right
thing to do or it became politically toxic.
Article four is an accusation that Pete Hegseth
basically is responsible for the hit
on the Manab elementary school in Iran, in which 156 were
killed, mostly children.
Who else would be responsible for that?
I'm going to end after this one because you'll
hear what Ben says here and then you'll decide
it's madness.
Again, this is just nonsense.
It's nonsense.
strikes on civilian targets are not impeachable.
I want everyone to hear that.
It's nonsense, right?
Saying things like maximum lethality, not tepid legality.
And restricting the Pentagon press corps.
Again, this is just nonsense.
Accidental strikes on civilian targets are not impeachable.
Accidental strikes on civilian targets are not impeachable.
That is just a normal feature of war, unfortunately.
We wish that war were totally antiseptic.
Obviously, we wish that no one innocent were ever killed.
That is not the way war works.
There is zero evidence of a systemic policy
to strike school children in Iran on purpose
without military target value.
There is zero evidence of a prolonged strategy
of attacking school children without military
targets.
I wrote it down because I couldn't actually believe.
that he was saying it with the amount
of qualifiers that he was saying it. Let me just
get to, I want to read it properly.
Accidental strikes on civilian targets are not impeachable.
Fine. There is zero evidence of a systemic policy
to strike school children in Iran on purpose
without military target value.
Let me just bring that up so you can actually see this
and understand the qualifiers in this,
because there's a number of them. And we're lawyers.
We know how to weigh words.
parse words and interpret words.
There is zero evidence of a systemic policy. All right. So
what that means is I'm not saying that's the case,
but words mean something. You could have
evidence of a policy, but it's zero evidence of a systemic policy.
to strike school children in Iran on purpose.
So there might be a policy of we'll act with a little bit reckless.
If it happens, it happens.
But it's not a systemic policy
to strike school children in Iran on purpose
without military target value.
That is the qualifier.
We might strike schoolgirls if we determine
that there's a military target value to them.
You might want to think that it's not black
and white and not nonsensical
for someone to argue.
If you struck a school knowing there were kids in it
while arguing that it had a strategic
military value, that might nonetheless be impeachable.
I'm sorry.
You can call it nonsense,
and you are clearly arguing from a conclusion and not towards
one, but calling it nonsense does not make it nonsense, man.
And now, once you've seen, over the last six years,
where Shapiro has relied on authority,
deferred to authority, and been wildly and hilariously wrong,
and now you're going to
sit here and say, oh, it's nonsense.
This is trying to get into the game of persuasion
as opposed to the game of actual debate.
Whether or not I think Hegseth should be impeached
for what is being alleged, to call it nonsense,
to argue from the conclusion that it was a bona fide accident
and therefore no culpability
either through negligence
or corruption is arguing from a conclusion and certainly not
the best rebuttal to articles of impeachment
saying, you can't impeach me over having bombed
double tapped a school twice because it's war.
Things happen in war.
Even though it's not war because it was never declared,
but we don't declare war anymore.
The bottom line, you might hate Massey for doing what he's doing.
On the one hand, hate him, but learn from him.
Because what he's doing is what the Democrats
are going to be doing version light.
You can hate him, and you might think it's wrong,
and it doesn't mean that it's baseless.
You might hate him, it might be wrong,
it might turn out to be baseless.
You can still learn from it.
Understand, look at what Massey's doing.
He has an enemy in Hegseth, and Hegseth has an enemy in him.
Fine.
This is what's coming.
And so agree with it or disagree with it.
Think it's politically unfair or not.
Prepare yourself for it in as much as you need to.
And arguing from the foregone conclusions,
well, it's not a high crime and misdemeanor.
Blowing up boats, arguably.
Extrajudicial assassinations, arguably.
Forever wars, arguably.
The fact that America,
or at least the military industrial complex,
has gotten away with it for the last however many years
doesn't mean it won't become an impeachable offense
when people have said we've had enough of it
and we want to set an example.
