Samsung Galaxy S9 Plus vs iPhone X: In-Depth Camera Test Comparison

Science City
55 followers
14 Video Views·Nov 17, 2022
In this video, I conduct an in-depth camera review and comparison between the Samsung Galaxy S9+ and Apple's iPhone X. I test the cameras head-to-head in great light and low light. I also look at the video quality, image stabilization, and microphone qualities of each phone.
Hi guys, it's MTG here, and I've been reading a lot of your requests, and today I'm finally
going to be comparing the cameras found on the Samsung Galaxy S9 and the iPhone X.
These are inarguably two of the best smartphone cameras out right now, and there's also some
added competition because this is an iPhone and this is an Android device.
I'll be comparing them in various lighting conditions, and I'll also be taking a look
at their video and audio quality.
In this video, everything was set to automatic.
Let's get right into it.
The S9 Plus has a dual 12-megapixel camera setup.
The main, wide-angle camera can automatically vary between f1.5 and f2.4 apertures, whereas
the telephoto camera is a fixed f2.4.
The second telephoto camera allows for 2x optical zoom, and helps with the depth effect
pictures.
The S9 Plus can shoot 4K and 1080p at 60fps, and 720p at up to 960fps.
Both cameras have optical image stabilization.
The front camera is 8 megapixels and has an aperture of f1.7.
It can take portrait-style pictures using software, and can record video at up to 1440p
at 30fps.
The iPhone X has a dual 12-megapixel camera system, with a wide-angle and telephoto lens
at f1.8 and f2.4 apertures respectively.
The telephoto lens means that the X can also have 2x optical zoom, and can also take depth
effect portrait pictures.
The camera can record up to 4K at 60fps, and 1080p at up to 240fps.
They have dual optical image stabilization.
The X's front true-depth camera is 7 megapixels with an aperture of f2.2.
It can take portrait-mode pictures, and can record video at up to 1080p at 30fps.
Both phones have amazing cameras, and with each side-by-side I show, it's clear why
both cameras have been rated so highly by reviewers and consumers.
When we look at pictures shot outside in good, even lighting, the only real distinguishing
factor is the color temperature.
The S9 will tend to produce the cooler image, whereas the iPhone X will tend to produce
the warmer image.
In shots like this one, we can see that the iPhone does show more contrast, which allows
us to differentiate between the leaves a little better.
Again, both phones took excellent pictures on this cloudy day, but if we zoom in and
look closer, we can see that the S9 maintained more detail, whereas the iPhone X looked more
washed out.
The shot shows, again, the difference in the color temperature between both phones.
And it also shows how the iPhone might make its images too warm, making the white speckled
floor look orange.
But the warm color temperature could also make photos look clearer and more vibrant,
such as in this shot.
But whether somebody likes the look will come down to personal preference.
So I already know that phones will produce great pictures in perfect lighting conditions,
but I want to challenge the phones by taking pictures in more challenging lighting conditions.
In this image, I wanted to test each phone's auto-HDR capabilities, and both phones did
well.
The iPhone X was able to maintain more of the colors in the wall and on the bus in the
background, but if we look closer, the S9 was able to pick up more details on the man
walking in front of me.
This is an image that previous generation smartphones would not be able to capture because
of the light coming in through the windows.
Both phones do a great job given the circumstances, but the S9 was able to pick up a lot more
of the color of the sculpture.
This was another challenging shot because of the lighting.
The S9 is able to deal with lights from the fixtures better and does a good job of not
letting the sun overpower the image.
But the iPhone X is able to make the overall brighter foreground, which I understand if
people prefer that.
Again, both phones did a surprisingly good job with the lighting.
But Samsung has done a great job with its HDR in the new S9 because it is able to maintain
so much more of the colors at the door and the door frame.
This shot of the sunset was impressive on both phones, but I think the iPhone X did
the better job of capturing all of the colors in the sky at the moment.
Again, there is just more of a gradient in the sky in the iPhone X's image.
But in this image, we can see how the S9 simply handles the direct sunlight better.
We can even distinguish the outline of the sun while preserving the color and brightness
of the foreground of the image.
In this video, I also wanted to see how the live focus mode on the S9 compared to the
portrait mode on the iPhone X.
Both aren't pixel level, but both phones can produce some decent depth effect pictures.
The iPhone X is able to pick up more of the blues of the sky in the background in general,
whereas the S9 keeps the subjects brighter, maintaining more of the colors.
This next shot shows again that the S9 keeps the subject brighter, but if we look closer,
we can see that the iPhone X did the better job with edge detection and preserving overall
detail.
In this next shot, both phones had nearly perfect edge detection, but the iPhone X did
the better job of handling the incoming light.
Shifting to the front camera, we can see that the S9 has the wider angle, and although I
turned off any sort of beauty effects, the S9 still doesn't pick up as much detail as
the iPhone does.
When I turned on the depth effect modes on both phones, they both struggled with my hair,
and again the S9 softens out some details, which some people actually do prefer.
With the light directly behind me, the iPhone X again does the better job of preserving
the detail.
When it got dark outside, I was pleased to see that the S9 switched to its f1.5 aperture
mode automatically.
Right off the bat, we can see the effect of the S9 being able to let in more light.
More of the details and colors are preserved, while also eliminating any noise in the sky.
The iPhone X also seemed to struggle with lighting fixtures.
Lighting fixtures would consistently create flares like this, whereas the S9 managed all
of the different lighting sources well.
The iPhone's shots aren't terrible, but when put side by side with the S9's shot,
the difference in low light is very obvious.
The S9 is able to take in more light, better maintain colors, and always keeps noise to
a minimum.
The same trends are present in the Boston skyline shot.
The darker spots aren't too noisy, and the lights don't overpower the image.
Looking at the same picture taken with the telephoto cameras of both phones, we can see
that the iPhone X may have produced a better shot, because the S9's telephoto camera
has a fixed, smaller aperture.
But still, the S9 does a good job with noise reduction.
As I shift over to video, I wanted you guys to know that the S9 and the iPhone X are capable
of shooting 4K at 60 frames per second, but I set them to 4K at 30 frames per second because
that's what this video is uploaded at.
iPhones have had the best smartphone video cameras in the past due in large part to their
color reproduction and realistic image stabilization that doesn't make the video look choppy.
But this year, Samsung has made a drastic jump and has managed to make its image stabilization
maybe even better than the iPhone.
Looking at the videos produced from both phones side by side, it's safe to say that both
phones have incredible video quality.
The S9 seems to adjust to its different lighting from the sky quicker than the iPhone X.
However, I think the overall color reproduction is better on the iPhone X.
Yes, the colors pop more in the S9's video, but this also leads to skin tones looking
more orange and pink than on the iPhone.
Now I'm testing the front two cameras of both phones.
It's pretty bright outside, so I'm curious how each phone is going to pick up the lighting
behind me.
I'm also walking to test out the image stabilization of both phones.
I'm also curious which microphone picks up my voice better.
Let me know which front camera you think is better in the comments.
Now I'm testing the front two cameras of both phones.
It's pretty bright outside, so I'm curious how each phone is going to pick up the lighting
behind me.
I'm also walking to test out the image stabilization of both phones.
I'm also curious which microphone picks up my voice better.
Let me know which front camera you think is better in the comments.
The front video on the S9 has the better image stabilization, but it also means that the
image is cropped in and doesn't show as much.
The iPhone X has the more vibrant colors this time in both the foreground and the background.
The S9 is able to keep my face brighter, but everything looks more washed out.
In terms of audio, both phones have pretty solid microphones.
Both captured my voice well.
As you can see, both of these phones have terrific camera systems that can take excellent
pictures in various lighting conditions.
The S9's variable aperture takes great low-light shots with minimal noise.
The iPhone X takes some very solid portrait mode pictures.
The camera you prefer more will come down to the color temperature you like and the
scenarios you're more likely to shoot in.
In the next few days I'll be posting two more camera comparisons, so make sure you're subscribed
and have the notification bell clicked to stay up to date on those.
As always, thanks for watching, and I'll see you in the next video.
