Through a series of high-profile public engagement projects, Oxford’s Institute for Digital Archaeology (IDA) has time and again shifted public opinion and government policy on key issues relating to heritage preservation. More broadly, by altering perceptions about the importance of protecting and promoting heritage, the IDA has created a new paradigm for leveraging history as a tool for achieving positive social change — including both legal reforms and recalibrated national financial priorities. In the process, the IDA has provoked broad debate around the issue of humanity’s connection to culturally significant objects, especially our emphasis on physical possession. Is possession, in this context, an inherently colonial concept that necessarily implicates issues of erasure and misappropriation? Or is the assimilation of cultural artifacts an inevitable and salutary part of defining national identity? All of these issues and more will be examined through the lens of some of the IDA’s most recent projects, including its highly successful Elgin Marbles repatriation campaign. Roger Michel ’84 is the founder and Executive Director of the Institute for Digital Archaeology (IDA). He served as a government lawyer for nearly three decades and was an adjunct Lecturer in Law at Boston University Law School for 25 years. Mr Michel is a graduate of Williams College, Harvard Law School, and the University of Oxford. He is the author or co-author of dozens of articles snd books on a wide range of legal and historical topics. The IDA is a UK-based NGO that operates globally, undertaking a broad range of heritage projects, many of which employ novel imaging and 3D fabrication technologies. Its principal partners are the UN, UNESCO, major research universities, museums, and local and national governments. The IDA’s heritage preservation efforts have received numerous accolades and significant media attention. In 2016, the New York Times named the IDA’s Palmyra Arch “Public Art Installation of the Year” alongside Christo’s Floating Islands. Other IDA reconstructions have been displayed at the Venice Biennale and are part of the permanent collection of the Victoria & Albert Museum. Featured in scores of public exhibitions including at the Bodleian Library, New York Public Library, Oxford’s History of Science Museum and Italy’s Archeo Museo, the IDA’s work has been documented in virtually every major media source in the world. This event is sponsored by Phi Beta Kappa and will be especially geared toward anyone interested in art history, English, anthropology, history, political science and economics.
Sorry about that. Is that better? Good.
Janet, can you hear me okay? Perfect. Thank you. I was just saying while I was muted,
I wanted to thank not just Professor Miller for hosting me, Phi Beta Kappa, Williams College,
but also for the intrepid folks who made it here in the snow today. It is an extraordinary blizzard
happening outside, so much appreciated folks who trekked through the snow to get here.
It's great to be back. I've been a member of the Phi Beta Kappa chapter here at Williams
for exactly 40 years. I was elected the fall of my senior year. I'm class of 84.
I actually wanted to wear my key today. I invested in this thing and haven't got a whole lot of use
out of it, and somehow I managed to leave it back in Oxford. However, what I hope was a good
omen, I chanced upon this key at a flea market in New York City. Per the inscription, it belonged
to a fellow called Oscar Erlandson. He was Princeton class of 29. This guy was a remarkable
person. He was one of the first people hired by Grumman Aircraft in 1930. His employee badge
number, number 47. He rose to become Grumman's chief designer. His last project was the lunar
module that ferried Messrs. Aldrin and Armstrong and Collins to the surface of the moon. Every
Phi Beta Kappa key has an image on it. It's an outstretched hand pointing to the stars.
Mr. Erlandson, obviously a very literal guy, but also a great example of the high standards
people in this society set for themselves. I'm hoping that perhaps Phi Beta Kappa will
help me get this key back to the Erlandson family someday very soon. In the tradition of Mr.
Erlandson and Grumman, at least in spirit anyway, my own organization, the Institute for Digital
Archaeology, or the IDA, is about to launch its own space program. It's on a much smaller scale,
both figuratively and literally. I'll say a little more about that later. Let me start by quickly
introducing the IDA. We're an academic consortium in Oxford with a long and deep connection to the
university there. We're perhaps best known for our reconstruction of Palmyra's triumphal arch
destroyed by ISIS in 2015. That project grew entirely accidentally out of an op-ed piece
that I had written for the Times about possible responses to ISIS destruction of heritage assets
throughout the Middle East. Over the course of a late August afternoon, this 300-word
letter to the editor grew into a 3,000-word front page cover story. It was the lead item the
following day on the BBC World Service. It was picked up by just about every major newspaper
in the world in dozens of languages. It made it to the cover of Newsweek. The idea that the
destruction wrought by ISIS and their sledgehammers and their dynamite could be reversed in a matter
of weeks, it somehow captivated people's imagination. It was an optimistic response, I think,
and empathetic communities everywhere really responded. It didn't hurt that we had these
incredibly adorable robots helping us with the project. I think I've got an image of the
robots here somewhere. There's one of our robots working on one of these objects.
Having told the world that I was going to rebuild Palmyra's iconic arch, suddenly I had to do it.
At least I had the foresight to say that it might take a couple of months. We bought ourselves a
time. But how my incredible partner, Oxford's Dr. Alexi Karanovska, secured 30 tons of Egyptian
marble, trucked it over land through a hostile country to our workshop in Carrara, and then,
having created this superb 3D model of the arch from tens of thousands of crowdsourced
images, convinced our friends at Tor Art to carve a two-story duplicate of Palmyra's most
famous landmark, shipped it to England, and erected it on Trafalgar Square, all within 56 days.
Are things that I guess at this point I have no special desire to tell in detail. The point is
this. We did it, and the world came to watch. When my old Oxford classmate, Boris Johnson,
and I stepped out onto Trafalgar Square, it was under the watchful gaze of 231 credentialed media
sources, more than 600 journalists from CNN to TASS. It's a total that Boris later assured me
that he would never again match in public office. The lesson here is be careful what you promise to
in print. But the media interest wouldn't have mattered very much if it didn't create
positive social change. Shortly after our arch rose on Trafalgar Square, Mr. Johnson, having
become UK foreign secretary, courageously advocated for sanctions against Russia for its role in the
Syria conflict. I'll note here that most people in the West, including Boris's US counterpart,
John Kerry, urged restraint. We know, of course, in the fullness of time who was proved right on
that front. Within months, the reconstructed arch had drawn praise and support from governments
around the world. Let me see here. I think I have. There's Boris under the arch, looking pretty
sharp. His hair is as messed up as ever. Here we are under the arch. Here is Christine Lagarde,
the IMF, Irina Bolkova, the Director General of UNESCO, three Middle Eastern regional leaders.
It was simply weeks and weeks and weeks of time, but that's all. Suddenly, you get the heads of
the IMF, regional leaders, all pledging funding for Syria reconstruction. They all came through in
the end. Then in early 2017, the arch was invited to stand at the G7 in Florence. We addressed the
gathered ministers there alongside UNESCO, advocating for support for the general concept
of reconstruction of heritage objects destroyed in conflict zones and natural disaster. It marked
a major shift of policy for UNESCO. Just months earlier, during a very memorable meeting in Irina
Bolkova's office in Paris, UNESCO had explained that they were fundamentally opposed to the idea
of reconstruction. Not long after the G7 gathering and our joint presentation, the UN
hosted our arch at the Place des Nations in Geneva and showed its support in every possible way for
the project, and for Syria as well, and for the concept of reconstruction in the context of
conflict zones generally. A few months after that, I spoke at the United Nations General Assembly Hall
alongside the presidents of both the Security Council and the General Assembly. Within a month
of that appearance, the General Assembly passed Resolution 72191, the most sweeping condemnation
of the Assad regime ever adopted by that body to this day. The resolution condemned the
continued widespread and systematic gross violations of human rights and of international
humanitarian law. The vote was very lopsided, about 122 to 13, I think. Notably, in light of
the subsequent events, the resolution was sponsored by the USA and Ukraine, so a different time, but
the seeds were there. While this was the UN's resolution of the work of many people,
the massive media focus on the arch unquestionably expanded awareness of suffering
in Syria. A few weeks later, the New York Times named the arch alongside Christo's
floating islands as the public artwork of the year. The following year, we were invited by the
House Foreign Affairs Committee to install the arch outside the U.S. Capitol, again during General
Assembly week. Significantly, the invitation came from both the Republican chair, Ed Royce,
and the Democratic ranking member, Elliott Engel. The two men spoke, I have to say,
beautifully under the arch on the National Mall, pledging support to Syria. Less than a month after
that, and despite an atmosphere you cannot even imagine, or I guess you can, of extreme partisanship,
the issue then was the confirmation hearings of Justice Kavanaugh. In that atmosphere,
Congress approved, on a voice vote, a sweeping Syria bill called the Caesar's Syria
Civilian Protection Act. It was co-sponsored by Royce and Engel, and it was an astonishing,
at least in that moment, example of bipartisan cooperation that is today almost unimaginable.
Among other things, the bill declared it is the policy of the United States that all diplomatic
and coercive economic means should be used to compel the government of Bashar al-Assad to halt
immediately the wholesale slaughter of the Syrian people and to support an immediate transition to a
democratic government in Syria. That same month, Congress passed, again on a voice vote, the Iraq
and Syria Genocide Relief and Accountability Act, a bill which contained financial provisions for
providing the relief in Syria for genocide victims and for persecuted ethnic and minority groups.
In the wake of that legislation, Mr. Engel didn't stop there. Engel eventually became the chairman
when Congress changed hands. He lobbied for the Trump administration and got it,
significantly increased funding for both the State Department and USAID relief efforts in Syria,
and saying the fight against al-Qaeda and the Islamic State is not over. He wanted to quote,
the highest possible funding. As of last year, under those provisions, $16 billion
have been appropriated for food aid, medical supplies, emergency health care materials,
shelter, clean water, you name it, for millions and millions of people across Syria.
Five years have passed. In part because of the success of the Palmyra Arch Project,
reconstruction has become a ubiquitous and respected tool for community rehabilitation.
In the aftermath of either violence or natural disaster, UNESCO has sponsored a huge number of
projects around the world along these lines. The Mosul Project, a good example, just completed,
which was done in collaboration with our partners in Dubai in the Palmyra Arch Project. It's a great
example of the potentialities for these kinds of efforts when they're executed thoughtfully,
as the UN has, to improve the lives of local stakeholders and the impact on livelihoods
in Mosul in the tens of millions of dollars. At the IDA, the Arch Project gave way to a
number of other high-profile reconstructions, including the statue of Al-Lat, which was an
iconic figure in the Syrian pantheon, also destroyed by ISIS. We displayed that at the
UN General Assembly Hall as well, under the auspices of the Italian Permanent Mission.
We also, with the help of the late Queen Elizabeth, she gave us a couple of dozen
ancient oak trees from Windsor Grape Park, reconstructed the Sutton Hoo ship,
this extraordinary vessel. Anyone who's read Beowulf knows what I'm talking about. If you've
been to the British Museum, you've seen it. Also the Herculaneum scrolls, charred by the eruption
of Mount Vesuvius, when it blew its stack in 79 AD. And just most recently, this extraordinary
Torgiano terracotta sculpture in Westminster Cathedral. Torgiano was the guy who broke
Michelangelo's nose, had to flee. Italy went to England and created some astonishing artworks
and we're working on the reconstruction of this Torgiano altarpiece.
With the benefit of these experiences, our skill set seemed perfectly suited
to the challenge of doing something about Britain's 200-year-old dispute
with Greece over the possession of the Elgin Marbles, a collection of about 130-132
statues and friezes, chiseled from the facade of the Parthenon by Lord Elgin,
between 1804 and 1812 or 1813. To the Greeks, you have to understand the Elgin Marbles are
a family heirloom, the stolen family heirloom. It's their crown jewels or their Statue of Liberty.
And their removal under these circumstances and their subsequent retention by the British is
a stain on their national pride. And obtaining their return has been one of the holy grails
for successive Greek governments since the creation of the Hellenic state, really, in 1822.
The British, however, have not been keen to let these things go for reasons that I'll explore in
a couple of seconds. We thought, look, if two people want the same cake, an obvious possibility
is to bake a second cake. And we knew just the robots for the job. And it was against this
backdrop that the Greek ambassador, Ambassador Reptakis, a wonderful guy, appeared together.
There's Ambassador Reptakis at Keats' house almost exactly a year ago, January 28th of last year.
We have poet laureate Simon Armitage was there. It was a celebration of the Grecian urn and Keats'
famous poem. We were marking the 200th anniversary of the death of John Keats.
And after some, not so much discussion, you have to understand the Greeks are primed for this
already. Ambassador Reptakis and I announced our plan to reconstruct the Parthenon sculptures. That
is to say, the Elgin marbles, the sculptures that are currently in the British Museum,
we would create exact duplicates using the same rare pentelic marble as the originals with a
degree of accuracy that exceeds human visual acuity. So these are perfect visual duplicates.
And we proposed beginning with two proof of concept objects, the famous Selene horse,
and a metope depicting the centuromachy. And for whatever reason, zeitgeist or otherwise,
just like with the arch, the media response was truly extraordinary. The day after we announced
our plan, the Telegraph ran a piece. It's one of Britain's three leading national dailies,
a long favorable piece about the project. And the story immediately got picked up by all of the other
UK national dailies and virtually every print radio and TV media source in Greece. We attended
long strategy sessions at the Greek embassy with some great Greek food and some great conversation.
And then on Valentine's Day of last year, February 14th, the Times,
after 200 years of opposition, of staunch opposition to repatriation of the Elgin
marbles, ran a full page story on page three about our project, great photos. But more important than
that, they ran a 500 word lead editorial in their editorial section, strongly endorsing
our reconstruction project as a likely and reasonable solution to the Elgin dispute.
And the Times went to pains to point out how these very special copies would allow the British Museum
to fully discharge its public function, that is to teach people about the art of ancient Greece,
but also at the same time, allow Britain to do the right thing and send these statues home.
The Guardian immediately followed suit, the other main UK paper, and the story went viral
and appeared in stories all around the world. In early July, the New York Times ran a full page
in front of the Science Times, the back page of the Science Times, 2,000 words on the story.
The Washington Post followed suit, BBC World Service, TV networks here and there, that is to
say the UK and the US, ran stories. So it became this media juggernaut, which helped keep it top
of mind and helped to ensure that the public debate around the Elgin marbles continued with
a degree of purpose and intensity that they had never seen before. And again, as with the Arch
Project, all this media attention would have meant essentially nothing had it not resulted in
some positive real world impacts. Our proposal was favorably debated in the House of Lords
almost immediately. Poll numbers swung wildly on the back of these discussions. Suddenly 80%
of Britons were favoring repatriation, and this is after centuries of stalemate. The Greeks and
the British agreed to talks, and then just a few months later, the British Museum's relatively new
chairman, former UK Chancellor, a fellow Oxonian, George Osborne, dramatically announced there is a
deal to be done. You have to understand, 200 years of deadlock, those are the words the Greeks have
been hoping to hear for centuries. Throughout the summer and the fall, momentum continued to build,
again in part because of the regular pace at which these stories appeared about our project
and the work of others as well. And then events in the fall slowed things down a little bit. Of
course, the UK has had three prime ministers over the last year. Queen Elizabeth passed away. The
Greek PM has had some troubles, but nonetheless, things marched on. We came up with a novel legal
concept for speeding things up. We found provisions in the British Museum Act of 1963, which allow,
we believe, and apparently the Charities Commission in the UK believes as well, would allow the
British Museum to act unilaterally in returning these things, which had been a matter of hot
dispute. Many have alleged that an Act of Parliament would have been required, which,
of course, would have taken additional time. I think we've clarified that point now.
And then finally in November, so just a few months ago, the former head of the National Trust
and the editor-in-chief of the Times, a few more articles about this, Simon Jenkins on the left,
former head of the National Trust, editor of the Times, and I unveiled our first pentelic
reconstruction of one of the Elgin marbles, that is the Selene horse. And like our initial project
announcement, the event was heavily covered by the press. Again, all the UK national dailies, BBC,
ITV, Euronews, Reuters, AP, Times Radio, etc., etc., etc. It was front page news in every major
newspaper in Greece. And best of all, the reviews were uniformly positive. Our reconstruction had
absolutely nailed the original. It was a perfect copy. The day after, the very day after the
unveiling of our copy, Mr. Osborne, the chair of the BM, made his strongest statement to that point
in support of repatriation. He announced some of the BM's greatest objects, Mr. Osborne declared,
could soon be seen again in the communities from which they came. If Greece is ready to
find common ground, then so are we. I mean, it doesn't get much more clear than that.
And finally, last month, almost exactly a year to the day after the Times
published its editorial, endorsing our plan, Mr. Osborne announced a tentative deal
for the return of the Elgin marbles, an arrangement that he described as a cultural
partnership that would, in his words, permit the marbles to be seen both in London and in Athens.
So incredibly optimistic now that a deal is at hand. All that remains, I think, at this stage
is for the parties to select the perfect moment for this to happen. The Greek elections are
scheduled for next month, and so the hope is that once those are out of the way, repatriation
will happen very quickly. Given the duration and the complexity of this struggle, lots of folks,
especially here in the US, ask why the Elgin marbles have been such a sticking point between
these two countries, NATO allies, longtime friends. I mean, King Charles is the great
grandson of King George I of Greece. I mean, these countries are practically joined in the hip.
And on top of that, I don't think there's any cultural artifact in the Metropolitan Museum,
the repatriation of which would occasion any particular excitement or emotion among most
Americans. In fact, the Metropolitan has been repatriating significant objects for several
years now, including several Benin bronzes, and has attracted very little domestic attention here
outside of museum circles anyway. And the answer to the question of why the British mindset in
this regard is so different than ours is not only interesting for what it says about the
culture of the UK, but I think it's also interesting for what it has to say about
why our public engagement projects have appealed so strongly to people's imaginations.
Okay, so what's behind Britain's, I'll call it a fatal attraction to the marbles?
Through the extravagance of its, and people see this every day, through the extravagance of the
UK's public ceremonies, its focus on aristocratic titles, its other indicia of pedigree and peerage,
and perhaps, I guess, most publicly of all, its emphasis on the hereditary monarchy. We're coming
up on a big coronation ceremony. Britain works very hard to project an image of long history,
deep rooted heritage. And a point of fact, Britain, at least in terms of being a legal entity,
is actually about 25 years younger than America. The Act of the Union, which created
the United Kingdom, was passed in 1800, the same year, coincidentally or not, that Elgin arrived
in Athens and hatched his plan to bring the marbles over to England. The UK also acquired
its national flag in that year, the Union Jack, so it's a generation younger than the Stars and Stripes.
But England's newness goes beyond legal constructs like the Act of the Union or the flag.
England did not even acquire the pretense of a national identity. Nobody was saying the word
England until Aethelstan became king of England in the 10th century and declared himself as such.
And until that time, you got to understand, the island was a home to warring factions of
self-governing tribes. There were Danes, there were Celts, there were Picts, there were Saxons,
and each one had its own heritage, each one had its own customs, each one had its own
history. And to confuse matters even further, 60 or 70 years after Aethelstan came along,
suddenly it's the Roman conquest, and that scrambled things up again. So compared to
its continental peers, England was and is the new world. America really is just the newer world.
But compared to Italy, France, its European peers, it is a new world. And even more significant,
I guess, than the objective sense of newness around these legal definitions of what constitutes
being a nation, being a nation-state. There was comparatively slow development of culture
in the UK, at least as compared to the great civilizations of the ancient world. I mean,
think about it for a second. When Phidias was carving the Elgin Marbles, Britain was still
in its Neolithic period. When the amazing temples and palaces of ancient Athens were erected,
Britons were primarily living in rustic earthworks, a native literary tradition. I mean,
did not arise in Britain until much before the 8th century. It's 2,000 years after Aeschylus
wrote the Oresteia. So by 1800, Britain had established itself as a dominant, I guess,
the dominant global economic and military power. It stood at the forefront of the
industrial revolution that was starting to unfold. The country had a new name, it had a new flag.
And not unlike Jefferson, Madison, Hamilton, who had a generation earlier and an ocean away,
looked to ancient Greece for a sort of cultural pedigree, early 19th century British elites did
exactly the same thing and decided that ancient Greece would be a great way to backfill, at least
culturally, their shiny new enterprise, Great Britain. Gave it a backstory. And in creating
a strong link to the aesthetic and to the intellectual traditions of Greece, provided
England with all the provenance and prestige that it needed for the idea of building a sense
of nation state. And so within a few short years, that is to say by the first decades of the 1800s,
Greek style had pervaded Union Jack, there's Ethelstan. And by the 1830s, Greek style had
pervaded every aspect of British life. Everything from, I don't know, Wedgwood plates to Chippendale
furniture, from ladies hats that folks were buying at Liberties to King George's crown,
from the Pall Mall clubs to the Houses of Parliament. Suddenly, Greek style, Greek
iconography was everywhere. And the ease with which Hellenic culture, represented by the Elgin
marbles, was absorbed by Britons was due at least in part to the literal ethnic cleansing
that these sculptures endured. Rigors that included acid washes, steel brushes. The
BM curators were well aware that the marbles originally had been brightly painted,
really garishly painted. And in fact, they'd commissioned a study to confirm the presence
of surface color in the first years of the 1800s. But anything other than pure white skin tones
would have undermined the conceit of cultural community, I guess you would say, the possession
of the marbles provided. And so they were displayed in this form, in this stark white form.
As an anthropologist that I know wrote, the absence of color allowed for the blurring, even
erasure of ethnicity, making it easier for Britons to project themselves onto the marbles.
The ruddy browns and reds and phidias used to depict great Greek male skin would have diminished
the possibility for largely white Britons' personal engagement with the sculptures. To Elgin's
native contemporaries, the lack of color allowed the figures to seem claimable. In short, through
their whitewashed appearance, the marbles were primed for absorption into the British
national narrative. It was a pre-packaged foundational myth that could be, and was,
slotted into this inconvenient and embarrassing, at some level, historical void.
And aiding this process of assimilation is the fact that the marbles, at least in their
current battered state, are little more than fragments. If you've been to the British Museum,
you've seen these things arrayed on the floor of the Duveen Gallery, and it's bits and pieces,
broken fingers, broken legs, missing noses, decontextualized from the building on which
they originally were affixed. And the idea of the fragment, I think, is interesting and important
here. Freud had a lot to say about the unique mutability of fragments in his discussion of
fetishes in Totem and Taboo, the shoe fetish. Fetishism, he said, is pleasure in fragments.
The point of the fetish, he said, is that it offers up the potential for what Freud called
hidden histories. It is about the search for something that is missing, and through that,
opportunity for reconstituting lost moments of perfect happiness. He couldn't have summed up
Britain's reaction to the appearance of the marbles in London any better. The hidden histories that
they discovered within these objects provided them with this perfect template for British culture
that would survive for two centuries. So much so, and do I have a picture of this? Yes, there he is.
So much so that when Boris Johnson, my dear friend, and now my next door neighbor in the
UK, when he was departing office as prime minister in 2023, so just a few months ago,
he likened himself to Cincinnatus. It wasn't Churchill. It was Cincinnatus that he channeled
on his way out the door in 10 Downing Street. It shows you the extent to which this is deeply
ingrained, at least in a certain element of British society, this direct sense of connection to
Greek antiquity. It's worth noting that the fragmentation that defines the fetish
is as much with us now as it ever was. I think this helps people put it in perspective.
I would argue that because of digital life, it's probably even more true today.
I read recently in one of the art magazines, a critic that I like said,
today, the clip is preferred to the film. The aesthetic fragment is preferred to the whole.
The ubiquity of TikTok testifies to the power of this impulse. It encourages a personal attachment
to fragments, moments, gestures, rather than a collective way of looking. In so doing,
it confers a significant narrative authority to the viewer. That's exactly the same authority
wielded by these English cultural reformers 200 years ago. The same critic said,
fragmented consumption of art objects gives the viewer control over the spectacle. This
was exactly right. This was exactly it. It explains to a large degree the sense of
effrontery, I think, that the Greeks feel, because they understand what's going on here.
It wasn't simply stealing the objects. It was pirating the culture and that sense of control,
narrative control, over the story that those objects tell and the extent to which that story
was co-opted to tell the story of a country 1,200 miles to the north that had no geographical,
historical, or other affinities with the homeland of these Parthenon sculptures.
To sum it up, whether through this unconscious psychology of storytelling and the sleight of
hand the fetish allows, British elites successfully recast these Elgin marbles as essentially,
I don't know, pre-national objects presenting ancient Athens as some kind of mythologized
utopia, disconnected from the modern Greek state completely. They are purveyed simultaneously as
belonging to everybody, but at the same time to nobody in particular. For 200 years, this has been
the organizational position of the British Museum, and it's been a cornerstone,
as that picture of Mr. Johnson attests, a cornerstone of Britain's national identity.
However, everything eventually comes to an end, and the zeitgeist around cultural piracy has
changed dramatically in recent years. Part of it's the war in Ukraine, part of it's a sense of
ownership around cultural constructs in general, and it's also because the legal landscape has
changed considerably around looted objects with the result that museums everywhere are sending
pilfered treasures home. If Mr. Osborne has his way, the British Museum will soon follow suit,
and we're already looking forward, I have to tell you, to the big party in Athens, which we hope
will happen as soon as May. History, as always, teaches important lessons, and this incredibly
strange story of the Elgin Marbles, really unique around the world, has forced us to think at the
IDA deeply about how people form relationships with heritage assets. Although the outward focus
is invariably on the object itself, its provenance, its physical characteristics, the reality is that
creating a relationship with a monument, really with, I guess, any artwork, is a highly personal
process of projection. The meaning that you have in experiencing, the experience you have in the
presence of heritage objects, it comes from inside of you. It's not special magical rays that are
being projected by the object itself. It's absorbed from without, not from, I'm sorry, it's not absorbed
from without, it comes from within. And to turn back to Freud for a second, he explored this
phenomenon throughout his life under the rubric of what he called object relation theory. He concluded
that an evocative object is one that, he says, resonates with personal and cultural significance,
producing chains of association, inciting emotional responses, and impelling imaginative activity.
So take this concept a little bit further. The fact is we form these strong embodied connections
to objects like this, objects that we encounter in important places and communities and places
around the world, these heritage sites, and we enter into relationships with them that allow us
to express personal idioms that are important to us. And in doing so, we make a shared use of these
cultural resources, shared throughout the community. And this highly personal conception of object
assimilation, whether it's monuments or whether it's artworks, aligns absolutely with my own
experience, and particularly my experience around our public engagement efforts at the IDA.
My relationship with our reconstructed Arch of Palmyra is derived almost exclusively from these
strong personal associations that I developed in little moments here and there over the course of
our work in that area. Without question, for me, the most memorable installation of the arch stood
in Dubai, it stood in New York City, it stood in Washington DC, it stood in London, in Geneva,
all around the world. But for me, the installation that I'll never forget was one that we did in
Arona, Italy, on the banks of Lake Maggiore. We were joined at the unveiling by the two sons of
Khaled Al-Assad. Dr. Al-Assad was the chief archaeologist in Palmyra. He was murdered by
ISIS for refusing to disclose the location of the city's hidden treasures, and his body was placed
on public display by ISIS, by the terrorists, to send a message. And it was in significant part,
on behalf of his two sons, that we undertook the arch project in the first place.
And whenever I look at the arch, I see it through the lens of that night and through the lens of
those two men. And I have to say, it was by no means the case that I was the only one who
came to feel this way about the arch. And in fact, wherever we went from Dubai to New York City,
visitors were always at pains to tell us what the arch meant to them. It was an important thing
that they felt they needed to do, to seek us out and explain why the arch was important to them.
And I always remember that on the night of the Trafalgar Square installation, that very first
installation, we wandered over to the arch. It was after midnight to see who might be there.
And we found a group of young Syrians standing under the arch, and we spoke with them briefly.
They had come from Paris by car to see the installation that had been so much covered
by the world press. And they couldn't believe that the obscure but iconic architecture of their
beleaguered country, sadly still beleaguered today, was being celebrated in such a conspicuous spot
and in such a conspicuous way. And one of the young women told me that she had grown up
just a few miles from Palmyra, but had somehow, whether it was school field trips or whatever,
had managed never to see this famous artifact when it still stood in Palmyra. And here she
had traveled 13 hours by car to see the reconstruction. So I asked her, why?
And she told me that our arch, representing as it did, I guess, in her eyes, friendship and empathy
of people who had no direct connection to her, people far away that she had never met and would
never get to know personally, and had no direct connection to Syria, had done this for her and for
her country, that it meant infinitely more to her than any Roman arch ever could. And she said to her,
this reconstructed arch was a powerful monument in its own right. And that was a message
that we heard over and over again. So anybody that ever doubts the power of a copy to embody
something more than just, I don't know, what it purports to replicate, needs to rethink it, in my
opinion. It's an amazing process, and it's one that we were really privileged, I think, to witness
firsthand. And the story, these stories and these moments always recall for me the words of
this fellow, Johann Winckelmann. And he's the man who did more than anyone in Regency England to
popularize Greek culture. You got to understand, the 18th century Greek culture
was too sexy, there was too much nudity, it was too debauched, it was not appealing
to Englishmen. Suddenly, Winckelmann comes along, he recharacterizes it with a sense of asceticism,
he emphasizes the athletic dimension, emphasizes the literature, the philosophy,
and suddenly Greek culture becomes very interesting to folks in the UK. He really,
I would suggest, is more firmly at the root of the Elgin dispute than just about anyone.
But he set up copies, quite interestingly, what is imitated, if handled with reason,
may assume another nature and become one's own. And that's exactly right. And that's certainly
been our experience of treasured monuments wherever we have gone. And on the subject of
going places, and I promised I'd come back to this at the very end here, and with a fond tip
of the hat to Mr. Erlandson, wherever he is, and his contributions to Apollo 11, the IDA is poised
to enter into a space race of its own. Let's see what we have here. Oh, here we have the
Archon Arona, and there are the two sons of Professor Al-Assad, one in a wheelchair himself,
shot by ISIS terrorists. Here are the folks, those young folks from Syria who made their way
from Paris to London on that night when everything got started. There is Winkleman, who I guess
started all the trouble, at least as far as the Greeks are concerned. But here is an interesting
photograph, and it's intentionally obscure. This is the very first public viewing of this object.
But the IDA is poised now to enter into a space race of its own. We fabricated tiny copies of the
Selene horse that measure from nose to ear a little less than the diameter of human hair.
The features of these minuscule horses are smaller than the smallest wavelength of visible light,
meaning that they can't be seen with any optical system. A scanning electron microscope is required
to view them. However, these microscopic repositories of cultural heritage, I think
the smallest sculptures perhaps ever produced, contain every bit as much detail as the original,
and they will in time form part of the IDA's Space Museum. It's a collection of more than 100
miniaturized icons of human artistic achievement that will travel beyond our solar system and bring
the best of our race to whatever audiences might be found in deep space with a projected launch date
of October 2024. So stay tuned. I'll end now with a quote from one of my favorite books,
a book that I first encountered here at Williams College many years ago, in Anita Sikulski's, one
of Anita Sikulski's English classes, Tres Tropiques, the great, great classic by Claude Lévi-Strauss,
no longer read, I don't think very much, too bad. But this quote from Lévi-Strauss actually sums up
perfectly everything that I do not believe about cultural heritage. And so, as is often the case
with dialectic, it shares the twin virtues of being infinitely illustrative while at the same
time being infinitely concise. And here is what Lévi-Strauss said in my very poor translation,
objects are what matter. Only they carry the evidence that throughout the centuries,
something really happened among human beings. First of all, what an incredibly strange thing
for a structuralist to say. But leaving that aside, I would suggest it's just the opposite.
People are all that matter. Whatever value monuments hold for people comes without question
from within them. And as the disputes around heritage assets soldier on, we would all, I think,
do well to remember this. Thanks again to my host here at Williams, to Professor Miller,
to Phi Beta Kappa, to the Greek Embassy in London for their extraordinary advice and support,
to our Italian fabrication partners, Tour Art, to our very dear friends at the Freud Museum,
where our Celine horse still sits today. Go and visit it if you're in London. And thanks especially
to my partner, Dr. Alexei Karanovska, without whom all of this would have been completely
impossible. So, thank you very much, and I look forward to seeing you soon.
I'll unmute you. Any questions, please feel free to ask.
So, it's a little bit later than that. And there are two famous arches in Palmyra. There's always
confusion about this. There's the famous, even larger arch part of the colonnade in Palmyra,
the so-called Arch of Baal, which had religious associations, religious resonances. And then
there was the Arch of Palmyra that we reconstructed, which was actually almost certainly a secular
structure, a part of the marketplace in the center of Palmyra. Historically, weddings would
take place under the arch. So, the interesting about it, because of the fact that it was built
so late, the artistic styles embodied by the arch are incredibly varied. It really is this amazing
mishmash of... And of course, if you know where Palmyra is, it's right in the midst of the Silk
Road. So, people are coming back and forth there all the time, bringing with them artistic ideas,
cultural ideas that become embodied in the art and architecture of Palmyra. And certainly,
that was the case with the arch. So, as an art historical object, it actually is fascinating,
both for its anthropological associations, what it meant culturally to the people of Palmyra,
but also what it embodies more broadly about the art, the artistic traditions of that time period.
And it's a visible proof of the migration of artistic styles that came along the Spice
Road, along with everything else. I mean, the Spice Road is the greatest misnomer of all time.
It was technology, it was philosophy, it was science, it was everything. The Spice was the least of it.
So, we have a question from the audience out there.
So, the robots are absolutely extraordinary, designed by our partners in Carrera.
The company's name is Torart, T-O-R-A-R-T. They have a great website. They have now formed a
second entity called Robator, robot with O-R at the end. And if you go to Carrera, the city is
littered with enterprises that purport to make carved reconstructions of things. You provide them
with the model, they'll provide you with the new carved object. As is the case with lots of
different kinds of technology, it exists in many different forms. Torart and Robator really stand
alone at the absolute top of the heap. It's a function both of the hardware and the software.
The fellow who runs it is an absolute wizard when it comes to this. And a level of craftsmanship,
resolution, et cetera, that they're able to achieve is clearly, and you see it immediately,
a cut above everything else that exists. I mean, to give you an idea, Damien Hirst, Jeff Koons,
all of the great sculptors around the world who work in marble, all of their work is done at
Torart. Cheek by Jow with our Saleem Horst with these amazing creations from Jeff Koons. They
haven't yet been displayed publicly, so I won't do much to describe them. I will say that when
you have the opportunity in New York or in London, once they are, you have probably the
most beautiful marble carvings I've ever seen, but they were carved by the same robots in Carrera.
And I say carved by the robots, and I'll just say something quickly about that. Much of the story
has been a story of John Henry versus the steam engine. People, I think, have become fascinated
because these art objects, exquisitely beautiful, carved by machines. And what does that say about
where humanity stands in relation to technology? But the truth is, that seldom gets reported,
is that, and I always tell people the story, but it just doesn't find its way into print for
whatever reason, is that the robots carve 95% of these sculptures. The last 5% is done by human
beings, and they have extraordinary artists and craftsmen in the Toart facility, just steps away
from where Michelangelo had his studio in Carrera. And the quality of their work is what really
brings these things to life. And it's a great, I think, it's a relief to people who want to
believe there's something about art that needs to be human. And I have to say, it is that kind
of difference that you see in what the robot produces versus what the humans produce. There
is something that is alive and vital about the finished product once the human beings have had
to go at it versus what the machine does. And I'll also say this, finally, which is that Phidias
himself absolutely would have used this technology if he had access to it. Phidias was known to be
an early and eager adopter of whatever technology was available to produce as much sculpture as he
could produce, because this guy was building things literally by the ton. I mean, when you're
called upon to decorate a building to the scale of the Parthenon, if someone said to you, hey,
I've got some robots out back that can carve these things for you, he would have been on top
of that in a New York Minute. So the notion that this is somehow, I don't know, a sharp right turn
from the artistic tradition that it purports to embody, absolutely not. I would suggest that it
is 100% in the tradition that has existed since the time of antiquity.
I'd like to know, my stuff is not going to be picked up by
people in Sweden and Swaziland. I'm familiar with Thomas Eakins and his technology as well,
absolutely. My question is, what are you looking at for your future projects? Are you going to be
inspired by the success of your craft here on the world stage in terms of what you're going to do?
So the question is, what are we going to choose to work on next? What kinds of projects? And I
have to say that this, again, is part of the story that we always tell, but not a story that
necessarily finds its way into the stories that get written. We don't select our projects. We
wait for folks to come to us, because I think it's been crucially important to us to have all
of our projects be stakeholder-led. I think it's something that we always knew, but it was a point
that UNESCO really drove home in those very early meetings in Paris before we ever reconstructed
the Palmyra Arch. They said to us in no uncertain terms, Roger, we can't get behind this project
unless it's stakeholder-led, unless there are people in Palmyra who want this to be done,
who feel like it needs to be done. UNESCO did not realize because we hadn't talked about it very
much for a whole host of reasons, but we had gotten the message loud and clear from the folks
in Palmyra that they in fact wanted this project to be done. And it was great advice to receive.
It was a lesson I think that we already understood, but it was great to have it
reinforced because I'll never forget that on Trafalgar Square, CNN, and you can Google
Palmyra Arch CNN today and still watch this exquisite piece of film, the CNN reporter came
over to me right after Boris and I finished our speeches and said, isn't this cultural appropriation?
You're from America. Your crew is from either Italy or from England. And I said, well,
they got to understand this is not our project. It's the project of the folks at Palmyra.
And there's Dr. Mahmoud Abdul Kareem, the Director General of Antiquities and Monuments
in Syria standing right over there next to Mr. Johnson. Go ask him about why we did this project.
And I will say to CNN's credit, they went over, chatted with him and wrote a story that was 180
degrees different from the story they had come there to report. It was a story in which they
captured I think all of the intentionality, both on the part of the Syrians and on the part of us
at the IDA. So it's a very long-winded way of answering your question, which is to say that,
and the same has been true of the Elgin Marbles. It was the Greeks that came to us. The same was
true of the reconstruction of Westminster Abbey. It was Westminster Abbey that came to us.
So our mantra is always to be stakeholder-led because only then can you have authenticity
in the projects. Only then can you sleep at night sure in the belief that what you're doing is
helping at least someone. And so we're, I guess, anxiously waiting for the phone to ring with a
project to come along that I think is a good match for our skills, but also one that somebody
has a strong belief and a credible belief that it needs to be done. And I think there's some folks
in Scotland who have an idea in mind. So our next project I think is going to take us up to Edinburgh
and it's going to involve a reconstruction of a very famous structure up there, which we will
identify in due course. Thank you. Just a really quick question. Is the goal eventually of bringing
this to Palmyra? So we made a promise to the folks in Palmyra that originally, I guess I'll use the
word commissioned this project, and to the sons of Dr. Al-Assad that this monument would be brought
to Palmyra once it was safe for us to do it and once it could be secure there and it would
stand outside the archaeological museum that Dr. Al-Assad ran. And our fervent hope is that
the notion that it's now 2023 and things don't look any more certain on that front than they did
in 2017 is tragic and sad. And so we await with optimism the opportunity to do exactly that.
Yes.
Yes, please. So the question relates to work we do in the area of olfaction
and poor Dr. Karanovska became very famous for sniffing the Magna Carta. And that image of her
sniffing the Magna Carta somehow went viral and ended up on television, print media all around
the world. So you're the girl who smelled the Magna Carta. And the question was, where we're
headed with those? What was the most interesting or most memorable? And I think I know the answer,
I'll let you provide it. Yeah, I have to say, I think, I mean, sniffing into, there are really
two questions there, you know, what's the most memorable thing you've sniffed? Which is a
question not many people ask me, which is probably, I think the answer there is probably the Magna
Carta. But in terms of memorable smells from books, we had, so we did an exhibition at the
Bodleian last year, I guess. And we captured odors from a collection of books and then made
those available. We recreated the smells and made them available to the public. And I think
my favorite of those actually was this incredible Ethiopian gospel that had been sitting on a lectern
somewhere in a church, in a Catholic church in Ethiopia. And over the centuries, it had soaked
up the odor of the incense. And it was, I mean, it was an incredible smell. It was really,
really, and quite a challenge, actually, from the reconstruction point of view. But yeah,
that's probably my current favorite. For me, there's no question. It was the smell of the
Great Stink of 1858. We made a wonderful documentary with a great fellow called Sir Tony Robinson. You
may know him from The Black Adder. He was, anyway, a fascinating and interesting guy.
Baldrick. He was Baldrick. Baldrick, absolutely. Great guy. And he and I and Dr. Karanovska and a
film group from the BBC went in search of the Great Stink. We found archaeological evidence
on the foreshore of the Thames. We drilled down to the 1858 stratum and we extracted material,
which still was kept in an anaerobic environment, so still harbored this incredible odor.
So the Great Stink of 1858, things in London had basically come to a head, literally. Too much
waste, human waste in the Thames, too much industrial waste in the Thames and in the air of
London. And in a hot summer, humid summer's day in 1858, this cloud of gas erupted and hovered over
London for a period of weeks. It would strike people down in the streets. It was that noxious.
But led to a positive outcome, which was the sanitary laws, which became global standards
in the mid-19th century, emanating from Britain, were a direct result of the Great Stink.
We found the Great Stink, brought it back to our laboratory in Oxford, formulated the
scent experience of the Great Stink, and Sir Tony came in and smelled that. I'll just tell you very
quickly that while we had him in the studio and when we're getting ready to set up the shot for
him to actually smell the Great Stink for the first time, the director said, hey, is there like
another, sort of as a starter course, an hors d'oeuvre, is there another smell you have sort
of sitting around that Sir Tony can take in to kind of get his nose ready for the Great Stink?
And I said, I've got just the thing. And we had extracted the odor of a, was it a bear? Was it
a bear pit? Yeah, bear pit. So we extracted the odor of a bear from a blanket that a bear was
using at a local zoo and produced, I think, a pretty credible bear smell. And we had Sir Tony,
without telling him what it was, had him smell it. And I'll never forget, he took in the odor and
made this face, memorable face. He's very expressive, great actor. And he said, I can't say
what that is. I have no idea what that is, but I can tell you. He said, I feel it inside. I'm scared
when I smell it. And I said, whoa. I said, well, Tony, it's the smell of an enormous predator. I
said, that's it. You nailed it. It happens to be a bear. And it really was an amazing thing. And I
think it really, at some level, great film, great theater, but also it was just a testament to the
kind of subtlety that Sir Tony brings to every project. He ran something called Time Team for
many years, a program in the UK, which every UK archaeologist cites as one of their formative
experiences. The reason they got into archaeology was Sir Tony and Time Team. Here he is not a
trained archaeologist, but knows as much about history and archaeology as anybody, but also just
a very subtle and intuitive guy. And it was never more on display than it was that day. So yeah,
for me, it's The Great Stink. For you, it's The Magna Carta. Or no, the Ethiopian Gospels. But I
should say, smelling these books is more than just fun. It tells you things about how they're
constructed, the history. We had some of Tolkien's books with the pipe tobacco, Tolkien's pipe
tobacco infused into it. The Magna Carta spent time in a swamp, or this particular Magna Carta
did. And all of the life of that document came through the odors.
And it was an amazing thing. And look, we are people who exist in multiple senses.
You walk into the Museum of London, where we will be adding some olfactory experiences when they open
their new facility at Spittlefields in a few years. And the truth is, you walk in
and look at images of 19th century London, and you see all this. You've got to understand,
when Mark Twain steps off the boat in The Innocence Abroad, the first thing he writes
about is the smell of the stench of London. When people were carrying around those days,
they would have to carry perfume-soaked handkerchiefs next to their nose to navigate
the streets of London. Opium dens, flower markets, everything was there. And the smell experience,
that was the experience of London. When you see those pictures, you're only getting,
it's like the Elgar marbles. You go on the British Museum, you see them denuded of color,
decontextualized. You have no idea what it was like to be in 5th century BC Greece seeing that.
That teaches you the opposite of real. And to some degree, by the same token,
walking into a museum that shows artifacts from mid-19th century London,
you're not getting the full picture. You're getting the picture in one sense. And the
smell was really what it was all about. And that's kind of what we hope to bring to some
of these exhibitions. Thank you. Thank you very much.