Representative Paul Santucci (R District 53 - Smithfield, Glocester) and Auditor General David Bergentino testify before the Senate Finance Committee in support of 2026 Senate Bill 3127. This legislation amends audit compliance requirements, giving the Auditor General the authority to oversee municipal contributions to Other Post-Employment Benefits (OPEB) and requiring municipalities to fund these benefits at an actuarially determined rate to address long-term liabilities.
Senate Bill No. 3127 BY Raptakis, Burke, Quezada, LaMountain, Thompson ENTITLED, AN ACT RELATING TO TOWNS AND CITIES -- AUDIT OF ACCOUNTS AND INSTALLATION OF SYSTEMS (Amends the audit compliance requirements for municipalities' contributions to pension plans under the budget of accounts and installation of systems chapter.) {LC4503/1} » http://webserver.rilegislature.gov/BillText/BillText26/SenateText26/S3127.pdf
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Again, on behalf of the Auditor General, this bill, this act,
would amend the audit compliance requirements for, like you said, municipalities' contributions
to pension plans under the Audit of Accounts and Installation of System Chapter of the General
Laws. And I, this time, Mr. Chairman, if there's not any questions, I'm going to pass it on over
to the two gentlemen to my right to add additional testimony and comments. Thank you. Thank you,
Senator. First up, we'll have Representative Paul Santucci from the House, and then we'll
go to David Bergantino, Auditor General. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Welcome. Thank you,
Mr. Chairman. This is a companion to a House bill that passed last year and just passed again
about a week ago. And I'm speaking tonight relative to my experience as a town council
president and then also when I was on the Charter Review Commission in the town of Smithfield.
And really what this bill is about is one number and a promise. The promise for municipalities
is roughly a $7 billion liability, gross liability. The net liability for those municipalities is
about $2.2 billion. And that promise is for teachers, police, fire, and municipal workers,
and has nothing to do with the state's own system. The number in this particular case,
Mr. Chair, is found right here on the bottom of page 106. This is the comprehensive annual
financial report for the town of Smithfield, and it lists the liability. We do have a trust in the
town of Smithfield, but not every single community does have a trust, and some are pay-as-you-go,
and I'll have the Auditor General speak to that. I think what we're trying to do is shine a light
on what this liability is, and that's basically it. Thank you very much. By the way, this is your
second time in finance, correct? We're not going to pay you twice, but you're doing a good job.
Senator Aptakis will give you some of his income to do that.
General, over to you. Chairman DePalma, members of the Senate Finance Committee,
my name is Dave Bergantino. I'm here to testify today in support of Senate Bill 3127.
My office for years has been overseeing that municipalities make their pension contributions
at an actuarily determined rate. This bill essentially would give my office the authority
to do the same thing for OPEB benefits. How would that work? Essentially, it would work by working
with the municipalities to create a trust if they don't already have one, to collect resources to
pay future OPEB benefits, but one quarter of the plans currently do not have a trust.
Next would be working with them to get valuations completed and funding projections completed,
so they can determine perhaps what the best path forward is to make contributions at an ADC amount.
Lastly, it would be finalizing with them a funding plan which would serve as a management tool to
help them get to an ADC level. So just in recognition of the funding challenges for
many municipalities right now, I have to be clear as to what this bill does not mandate,
so there's no misconception. It does not mandate the municipality to fund at the ADC level.
That decision remains a local budgetary decision regardless of whether or not they have a funding
plan that we've worked on that gets put into place. That funding plan is really just a management
tool. It does not mandate a time period by which the municipality must complete the funding plan.
Again, it allows them flexibility based on their current funding challenges. Thankfully,
many, many municipalities have already started this process and are working their way towards
100% contributions, but there are certainly ones that are in far worse condition and will need a
seriously long-term plan to be able to address this. Finally, once a municipality achieves
contributing at the ADC level, what does this bill do? This bill requires us to surveil
and determine when a municipality drops below the ADC amount. At that point, we reach out,
we work with them to get a plan to work back up to a full ADC amount so that the funding shortage
short-term does not get sustained. A lot of benefits to funding an OPEB plan at the ADC
level would decrease their unfunded liabilities reported, would achieve a higher investment
return, which would allow them also to not only reduce their liabilities and their financials,
but also lower their actual contributions in the future, would improve their bond ratings
as the liabilities reduce, and it would provide budget stability
as opposed to what they have now where they're at the whim of their health care consultant
telling them annually what their increase is. In some cases, I know I have municipalities
this very year that have double-digit percentage increases in their health care costs.
Lastly, it just improves financial transparency and overall confidence that these promises made
will be able to be funded in the future. Why now? Well, the simple answer to that is the longer any
municipality waits to do this, the worse the problem is getting. There's approximately 50
different municipal OPEB plans when you roll in regional school districts and separate plans for
school districts. Only 10 of those right now are more than 50% funded. 12 plans are currently
funding at their actual cost, which means they have zero dollars put away today to fund future
benefits. And to give you some idea of the significance of the challenge, the magnitude
of OPEB liabilities for our five largest municipalities is approximately $1.7 billion,
with a B, today. So in conclusion, I support this bill so that I can bring further attention to this
important funding issue. We simply can't ignore this much longer. We can't continue to promise
retirement benefits to employees and hope that the next generation will be able to fund them when
they get there. Thank you for your consideration of the bill and happy to answer any questions.
General, thank you very much. Senator Acosta. Thank you, Chairman. I want to start off by
noting two things. One, this might be my favorite Raptacus-Biller initiative that he puts forth on
a yearly basis. Two, people don't say this often, but I really like the Auditor General. I really
love and appreciate what you do. The way that y'all came up here and spoke was very clean and
polished and professional. I appreciate that. And I think for people watching at home, it's
important, at least in some ways of a translator, for me to explain the quotidian hood politics and
economics behind how we got to this problem. Because it's a problem we've had for a long time.
When I first got into this building, I very naively asked, actually, the gentleman to my right, maybe,
and other folks, like, how do we allow this to happen? How has this happened for decades? And
there were at least two dynamics that I put in conversation with each other that I think have
really led to a runaway train with this problem. One was suburbanization. And so there was a point
in time, and I would argue that my colleague, Gordon Rogers, and I share a perspective on this.
There was a point in time where a lot of labor lived in the communities where they worked. And
so there was this natural check and balance to rent-seeking in labor negotiations. And
there came a point in time where people who started looking different than the people who
were working in labor started moving into some of these communities, and labor ran away to the
suburbs. But they were still rent-seeking in their negotiations sometimes. And so you lost the
natural check because they're no longer paying property taxes in order to pay for their benefits.
And so with that leaving, you start having politicians, savvy politicians, making promises
on two sides. You're going to promise your bargaining units that you're going to keep
making their benefits better and better, which is going to cost you more and more money. And then
you have those same politicians looking at their voters and saying, we're not going to raise your
taxes. This problem was predictable throughout the 70s, 80s, and 90s when it was getting bad.
And people just kept looking the other way. It is ridiculous that it has gotten this far. And I feel
like what you're proposing is so even-keeled, is so responsible, is so polished that I just, I can't,
I can't say, I don't have more better anecdotes to say how much of an important step this is.
I would come in way more aggressive and say, hell no, y'all can't do this no more.
But this is just such, I think, a responsible way to go about starting to address this problem,
to making sure that we get people the benefits that they've worked for, but also that the
municipalities can afford them. So I applaud the sponsor. I thank you for all the work that you do.
And I really appreciate that hopefully we can make, get some traction on this issue.
Senator, thank you. Senator, thank you very much. Senator Zerrier.
Thank you. I applaud the intention of this bill, but I have some concerns about how it applies to
the city of Providence. The first half, the pensions, that's very important. Providence
entered into a consent judgment with its retirees that they have, Providence has to put in,
I think it's 95%, or else they violate a consent judgment, which might have even more teeth
than what this bill provides. My question though is about the OPEP. I believe the last time I
checked that Providence's unfunded OPEP liability was over a billion dollars out of that billion
seven. I also understand that my understanding of FASB, I think it's FASB 75, is that you're
not required to fund the OPEP, you're just required to report it as a liability on your
balance sheets. And what Providence is looking at is that over the next five or 10 years,
they're going to fully fund their pension, and there's going to be an enormous amount of pain
involved in doing that. When that happens, suddenly, once they're 100% funded, if they
get there, and I hope they do, then suddenly the annual contribution will go way down because
they're no longer paying off the legacy. And at that point, if Providence is still around,
at that point, they could start addressing the OPEP. But do you really think that right now with
Providence is facing the medium term, that it should be setting aside money for the OPEP? I'm
pretty sure they'll pay as you go with the OPEP token amount. So Senator, I agree with everything
you said. They are definitely a community that this is going to be a process, it's going to be
a long process. And I guess the question I have is, I don't think anybody would come up here and
realistically be against OPEP funding, right? It's the timing. The real discussion is Providence
needs revenue to make more things happen, whether or not we're talking OPEP or we're talking other
things. That challenge is real. Nobody looks at more municipal financial statements than I do.
I'm very aware of the challenge, and Providence is not alone in that. But I don't see how that
changes the argument in the fact that the longer you wait to get started to come up with a plan,
the worse this gets. So again, I think that's the discussion. That's why this bill has no teeth in
it. It's the communities like Providence that are going to have to decide how to address it
and erase some good issues possibly with the pension. They do fund their pension at 100% of
their ADC every year right now. That plan though, right now, I believe is maybe only about 30%
funded. It's a long way away from being 100% funded, so that challenge isn't going away anytime
soon. So it's a different discussion, but I don't think realistically not focusing some attention on
it is the right way to go. I totally acknowledge the funding challenge, and it's why I proposed
this the way I did. It's to leave the funding decisions with the municipality, with the elected
officials, but I just ask that they work with me. I work with municipalities on a whole host
of different issues, whether it's deficits, and it tends to work because they all share a common
goal. They ultimately would like to leave their municipality in a better place, and some of that
requires some long-term planning, and that's what this bill is designed to do. We need to start
thinking a little bit of long-term. Right now, there's no discussion of it. There's no looking
at it. It's on the back shelf. No one wants to talk about it. I get it. It's a funding issue,
but you have to start somewhere, and that's what I'm looking to do with this bill.
Would you agree, though, that the pension has to be a higher priority in the OPEC?
I basically would say if you're making a promise to an employee today, I don't know which ones
are more important than the other. You're making a promise today to an employee that they're going
to have something in the future, whether it's dollars or whether it's health coverage. I don't
know how to answer that. I don't know which one's more important, but clearly, they're both
important. Someone's relying on them for when they retire, so I think at some point, ignoring
that they're both there, I don't see how that moves the discussion forward. Certainly. I'll try
to clarify. Would you agree that pre-funding the pension is a higher priority than pre-funding
the OPEC, given the difference in the way that the FASB treats the two?
The actual accounting standards are the same for both. The accounting standards were designed to
bring transparency to the issue, not to cause someone to have to fund or not fund. It just
brings transparency. If you're not funding, they work exactly the same way. They're both
liabilities. I doubt the bond rating agencies look at debt that differently. If you've got the
liability, they look at it. Your point is valid. This is a serious problem in our largest
municipalities. I'm just as concerned about the pension as I am the OPEC. The difference is,
I have the ability on the pension side to make sure they stay contributing at an ADC level.
I don't have that on the OPEC. I can't bring the discussion up because I don't have the
authority to do it. The General Assembly has not asked me to do it. I stay within the bounds of
my authority that this General Assembly gives me. Thank you. Thank you, Senator. Other questions
or comments for David? David, I also want to piggyback on Senator Acosta's comments on your
work. It's exceptional. We've had several conversations over time for the cities and
towns that I represent and others. We need more of you in doing what you're doing. Having been
on the Council, we bit the bullet and got to the point where we fully funded OPEC. For those
unfamiliar with OPEC, other post-employment benefits for those watching are predominantly
made up of health care. Pensions are critical. Health care is critical. For some folks,
they can get to the point where health care is even potentially more critical, given the
situations that they have. The other important part about some of this is the concept of
return on investment, compound interest. If something goes in over time, it's going to build.
You just have to start. Once you start, you build on that in the budget. There are challenges that
cities and towns have with regards to where all their costs are and what they do. I think it's
important. The Auditor General has done a great job in his duties. We come from the same community,
Coventry. The prior administration lacked on giving the financial statements to the Auditor
General and fell behind. The Auditor General came into his position and pushed the town of Coventry
to get up to date. I think these are important issues. They cover what he's doing. He's doing
a very good job in his position. That's why we're introducing this piece of legislation.