Reading Thucydides' Peloponnesian War -- Book II, chapters 69-92 (Winter Year 2, Spring Year

History TV Epic
4 followers
"Today we will be reading and going over chapters 69-92 of Book II of Thucydides' Peloponnesian War, which deals with the Winter of the 2nd Year and Spring of the 3rd. #war #history #politics
For our reading for this series of Reading Thucydides' Peloponnesian War, we are using the Landmark edition of Thucydides' Peloponnesian War.
The Landmark Thucydides: A Comprehensive Guide to the Peloponnesian War Robert B. Strassler (Editor), Richard Crawley (Translator), Victor Davis Hanson (Introduction) (Free Press 1998, Touchstone editions)"
Hi there, I'm Clifford Bates and welcome once again to our reading of
Thucydides' Peloponnesian War. We're now still in book two, where we just covered in the last
session the, I think it was the spring of the second year, and now we're going to be covering
we'll see the winter is going to be, the chapters on the winter of the second year
are going to be kind of brief, maybe even too brief, and we'll have to go to the spring of
the third year, the summer of the third year. So let's go on, starting where we left off,
we left off around 69, 69, 70, chapter 70, I think we start with, we'll start at 70.
Yeah, 70 will be the, 69 will be, we'll be at 69, where we will, we left off at,
right here, here says, such were the events of the summer, again, again, just to remind you,
we're using the landmark Thucydides edited by Strassman, which is the probably translation,
I make corrections in here, as we go through, we're using Google Books' version that you see
on the screen. Let's turn to the chapter 69, such were the events of the summer,
and the ensuing winter, the Athenians sent 20 ships around the Peloponnese, and
under the command of Thuramonol, who stationed himself at
Naupactus, and kept watch against anyone sailing in and out of Corinth, and the Carassian Gulf.
Six others went to Chara and Lachian, under Lysander, to collect tribute in those parts,
and prevent Peloponnesian privateers from taking up any, their station in those waters,
and molesting passage of merchantmen from Perilous and Phoenicia, and the adjoining continent.
However, Melander, going up the country into Lycia, with a force of Athenians and ships,
in Athens, was defeated and killed in battle, with the loss of a number of his troops.
So he went inland and got killed by Melander.
Now, next chapter, 70, that same winter, the Padians at length found themselves no longer
able to hold out against their besiegers. The inroads of the Peloponnesians into Attic had not
had the desired effect of making Athenians raise a siege. There were left no provisions left, and
so far had the stress for food gone in Padia, that beside the number of other horrors,
instances even occurred of people having eaten one another. So in this extremity, they at least
made proposal for perpetuating the Athenian generals in command against them. Xenophon,
son of Euripides, Aristodos, son of Aristocles, and Panomachus, son of
Kallimachus. The generals accepted their provisions, seeing the suffering of the army,
and so expected a position beside which the city had already spent two thousand talents
upon siege. The terms of surrender, capitulation, were followed, a free passage out for themselves,
their children, their wives, auxiliaries, with one garment apiece, and the women with two,
and a fixed sum of money for their journey. Under this treaty, they were sent out to
Chaldees and other places according as was in their power, and the Athenians, however,
blamed the generals for granting terms without instructions from home, being an option that they
could have gained control of the city without granting terms. They afterwards sent settlers
of their own to Padia and colonized it. Such were the events of the winter, and so ended the second
year of the Caliphate, the second year of which Thucydides was the historian. So in other words,
he ends the second year of the war. Now, I think we should go on. I'm going to go on. I'm going to
I'm going to do winter of second year and spring of the next year. Here it goes. This is chapters,
you know, 69 and 70 was clearly aimed at the winter. It's very short, two entries, two chapters.
Now, the summer of the third year. The next year, the next summer, the Peloponnesian allies,
instead of invading Attica, marched against Plataea under the command of Archidamus,
and king of the Spartans. He had kept his army and was about to lay waste to the country when
the Peloponnesians hastened to send envoys to him. They spoke as follows. Amadeus,
Archidamus, and Spartans invading the Peloponnesian territory, you do what is wrong in itself,
and worthy neither of yourselves nor your father to beget you. Panoassius, son of Cleobrotus,
their countryman, after freeing Hellas from the Medes, with the help of those Hellenes who were
willing to undertake the risk of the battle fought near our city, offered sacrifices to Zeus,
the liberator, and the Agora of Plataea, and calling on all the allies together, restored
to their Peloponnesian city and their territory, and declared it independent and invalid against
aggression or conquest. Should any such be attempted, the allies present were to help
according to their power. Your father has rewarded us thus with the courage and patriotism,
zeal, that we displayed at that perious epoch, but you do just the contrary,
coming with our bitterest enemies, the Thebans, who enslave us. We appeal therefore to the gods
to whom the oath was then made, to the gods of your ancestors, and to at least to those of our
country, and call upon you to refrain violating our territory, and transgression the oath, and let
us live independently as Panoassius decreed. Okay, now we go to the next, this is somewhere
of the third year, the Spartans have that thing, this is that map up there, you can go check it
on the text, if you have the text. The Peloponnesians had got this thus far when they were
there is justice violation in what you say, if you act up on your words, however, according to
the grant of Panoassius, continue to be independent yourself, and join in freeing those who,
of your fellow countrymen, who after sharing in the perils of that period, joined in oaths to you,
and others now subject to Athenians, for it is to free them, and the rest,
that all this provision in the war has been made. I wish that you would share our labor, and abate
by the oath yourselves, it is impossible for, if this is impossible, do what we have already
required of you, remain neutral, enjoying your own, joining either side, we see both as friends,
and neither as allies of the war, with this we shall be satisfied, such was the word of Amadeus,
the Plataeans, after hearing this, what he had to say, went to the city, and explained to the people
with what had been passed, and presently returned for the answer, that it was impossible for them
to do what he proposed, without consulting the Athenians, with whom their children and wives
now were, besides that they had fears for their city, after his departure, that what was to
prevent the Athenians from coming, and taking out of their hands, or the Thebans, who would be
included, who would be included in the oath, from taking advantage of the proposed neutrality,
to make a second attempt at the city, upon these points, he tried to reassure them by saying,
you have to deliver over the city, and the house to us Spartans, to point out the boundaries of
your land, and the numbers of your fruit trees, and whatever else can be numerically stated,
and yourselves, and withdraw wherever you'd like, as long as the war should last,
where it is over, we will restore to you, whatever we received, and in turn hold it,
when they heard what he had to say, they reentered the city, and after consulting the people,
with what they said, wished first to appoint the Athenians, and the event of their proving to exceed
it, in the meantime, they asked to grant them a truce, and not lay waste their territory, he
accordingly granted a truce, for a number of days requisite for the journey, and meanwhile abstained
from ravaging their territory, the Athenian envoys went to Athens, and consulted with the Athenians,
and returned with them, the following message to those in the city, the Athenian says,
that they have never since we became their allies, on any occasion abandon you to an enemy,
nor will they now neglect you, but you will, but will help you according to their ability,
and they solemnly call upon you, by the oaths which your father swore, to keep the alliance
unaltered, next chapter, chapter 74, on delivery of this message, the envoys, the petitions resolved,
not to be unfaithful to the Athenians, but to endure, if it must be, seeing that their lands
laid waste, and any other trials might come to them, and not send out again, but to answer from
the walls, that it was impossible for them, to do as the Spartans proposed, as soon as it,
as be, as soon as he, again this be, this is a typo, I don't know what's going on here, and he had received
this answer, king Archidamus, proceeded to make a solemn appeal, to the gods and heroes of the country,
in the following words, ye gods and heroes of the Athenian territory, be my witnesses,
and not an aggressor, which way, nor until these had first departed from the common oaths,
we did invade this land, in which our fathers offered you their prayer, before defeating the
Medes, in which you made favorable to the Hellenic arms, not, nor shall we be aggressors, in the
measures, to which we may now resort, since we have made fire proposals, to have but not been
successful, graciously accord, that those who were the first to offend, may be punished for it,
and the vengeance may be obtained, by those who right, righteously inflict it, after the appeal
to the gods of, to the gods, Archidamus put his army into motion, first he enclosed the city with
a palisade, formed by the, with a palisade formed of the fruit trees, in which they cut down, to
prevent further exit from Pelida, next day they threw up a mound against the city, hoping that
the largeness of the forest employed, would ensure the speedy reduction of the place, they accordingly
cut down timber from the Chitalon, and built it up on either side, laying it like lattice, to serve
as a wall, to keep the mound from spreading abroad, and carried to it wood, stone, and earth, and
whatever other material might complete it, they continued to work as the mound for 70 days and
nights, without the commission, having divided into relief parties, to allow some to be employed
in caring, or others to sleep and take a freshman, the Spartans officer attached to each contingent,
keeping the men, the men to the work, but the Plataeans observing the progress of the mound,
constructed a wall of wood, and fixed it upon the part of the city wall, against which the mound
was being erected, and built up bricks inside it, which they took from the neighboring houses,
and timber served to bind the building together, and prevent it from becoming weak, as the,
as advanced in height, it had also a covering of skins and hides, which protected the wood,
against attacks of burning missiles, and allowed the men to work safer, thus the wall was raised
to a great height, and the mound opposite, made no less rapid progress, the Plataeans also thought of
another expedient, they pulled out part of the wall, upon which the mound abutted, and carried
the earth into the city, discovering this, the Peloponnesian twisted up the clay, and
rattles, and reeds, and threw it in the breach, formed in the mound, in order to give it constancy,
and prevent it from being carried away, like the soil, stopped in this way, the Plataeans changed
their mode of operation, and digging a mine from the city, calculated the way under the mound,
and began to carry off this material, as before, this went on as long at a while, without the enemy
outside, finding it out, so that for all they threw on top of the mound, made no progress in
proportion, being carried away from beneath, and constantly set down, but the Peloponnesians
fearing that even thus, they might not be able to hold out against the superior force of the enemy,
had another invention, they stopped working on large buildings in front of the mound,
and started at either end of the inside of the old low wall, build a new one in the form of a
crescent, running in towards the city, in order that the event of the great wall being taken,
this would remain, and if the enemy had to throw up a fresh mound against it, as they advanced,
they might not only have trouble over them, but also be exposed to missiles on their flank,
while raising the mound, the Peloponnesian also brought up siege engines against the city,
which was brought up on the mound, against the great building that shook,
then here, that shook down a great piece of it, and to no small amount of the pollution,
others were advanced against the different parts of the wall, but all were lassoed and
broken by the Peloponnesians, who also hung up a great beam by long iron chains from the
either extremity of the two poles laid on the wall, and projecting over it, and drew them up
at angles, whatever at any point, which threatened by the engine, and losing their hold, let the beam
go with its chain slack, so that it fell freely, and snapped off the news of the battering ram.
Now, 677, after this, the Peloponnesian, finding their siege engine affected nothing,
and that their mound was meant by the counter work, concluded that their present means of
offense were unequal to the taking of the city, and prepared for its circumventilation,
which means go around it. First, however, they determined to try the effective fire, and see
whether they could or not, with the help of the wind, burn the city, and it was not a large one.
Indeed, they thought of an even possible expedient by which the place might be reduced without
the expense of a siege. They accordingly brought bundles of bushwoods, and throw them
from the mound, and first into the space between the walls, and this soon became full from the
numbers of hands at work. They next heaped up the faggots as far into the city as they could
reach from the top, and they lighted the wood by setting fire to it with sulfur and pitch.
The consequence was a fire greater than anyone has yet produced by human agency,
though it could not, of course, be compared to the spontaneous
conflagrations known to occur sometimes through the wind rubbing against the branches of mountains
forced together, and this fire was not only remarkable for its magnitude, but also at the end
of somber perils, which an ace of prevailing could be fatal to the
Latins. The greater part of the city became entirely inaccessible, and had a wind blow upon
it in accordance with the hope of the enemy. Nothing could have saved them. As it was,
there was a story of a heavy rain and thunder having come by, which the fire was put out,
and the Peloponnesians left the portions of their forces on the spot, dismissing the rest,
and built a wall of circulation around the city, dividing the ground among the various cities
present. They ditched being made within and without the lines from which they got their
bricks. All being finished by the raising of arcturus, they left men enough to man half the
wall, and rest being manned by boteans and drawing off their army dispersed to several cities.
The Peloponnesians, before they sent off their wives and children and the oldest men,
and the masses of non-combatants to Athens. So the number of the besieged left in the place
comprised 400 of their citizens, 80 Athenians, and 110 women to bake their bread. This was the
total sum of the commencement of the speech, and no one else within the walls, bond or free.
Such were the arrangements made for the blockade of Petlitia. The same summer,
in simultaneity with the expedition against Pletya, the Athenians marched with 2,000 hoplites
and 200 horse against the Chalidians in the Thracian region, and the Boteans,
just as the corn was getting wet, under the command of Xenophon, son of Eurypides,
with two colleagues. Arriving before Spotylus, a Botean, they destroyed the corn and had hope
of the city coming over through the intrigues of a factual event. But those of a different way of
thinking had sent Olynus and a garrison of hoplites, and the other troops arrived accordingly.
Those issuing from Spotylus were engaged by the Athenians inside the city,
and Chalidonia's hoplites and some of the auxiliaries of them were beaten and retreated
into Spotylus. But the Chalidian horse and light troops defeated the horse and light troops of the
Athenians. The Chalidians already had a few Pallas from Thracia, and presently, after the battle,
were joined by some of the Olynos. Upon seeing the light troops of Spardas emboldened by this
extra force, and by their previous success with the help of the Chalidian horse and the
reinforcement just arrived, again attacked the Athenians, who retired upon the two divisions
which they had left with their baggage. Whenever the Athenians advanced, their adversaries gave way,
pressing them with missiles the instant they began to retire. The Chalidian horse also
ride up and charging them just as they please, which at least caused a panic among the routed
and pursued with their dangers. The Athenians took refuge in Pataedema, and afterwards recovered
their dead under truce and returned to Athens in the midst of their army. 430 men and all the
generals have fallen. The gladiations and the belations set up a trophy, took up their dead,
and dispersed to the several cities. The long summer, and not long after this,
the abrasions and the collisions having desirous of reducing the whole of Arcania
and detaching it from Athens, persuade the Spartans to equip a fleet from their confederacy
and send a thousand hoplites to Arcania, arguing that if a combined movement was made by land and
sea, the coastal Arnacheans would be unable to march, and the contest of Zakardinus and
Cephalina would follow easily upon the possessions of Arcania. Thus the cruise
beyond the Peloponnese would no longer be so convenient for the Athenians. Besides which,
there was also a hope of taking Nalpaktos. The Spartans accordingly at once sent off a few
vessels with Keraminos, who was still admiral, and the hoplites on board, and sent round orders
for the fleet to equip as quickly as possible and sail to Lucretius. The Corinthians were the most
forward in the business, and the Embraceats being a colony of theirs, while the ships from Corinth
and Siram and the neighbors were getting ready, and those from Lucretius and Embracea, which had
arrived before, were waiting for them at Lucretia. Okay, so I'm going to return now. I mean,
we had a little emergency. I had to stop for a second. Well, we were talking about at this moment
the Corinthians. I'm going to go back to line two, line three, the Corinthians.
In other words, the ships from Corinth and Siram and neighbors were getting ready,
and this is line three, Anticorinth and Embracea. Lucretia, Anticorinth, Embracea,
had arrived before waiting for them at Lucreia. Crimea and thousands of hoplites had run into the
giving the slip to Ptromenos, the commander of the Athenian squadron stationed off
New Pactos, and begin at once to prepare for the land expedition. The Hellenistic troops with him
consisted of the Embraceats, the Lucretians, and Anaptorians, and a thousand Peloponnese
whom with him he came. A thousand barbarians, Glenasian, who bringing to a nation that
has no king, were led by Protene and Nicanor, and two members of the royal family to whom
the chieftainship for that year had been assigned. With the
cleonations came some
Thessarontanians led by Saboliphenus, the guardian king of
Tharaps, who was still a miner, and some
under the king of
Oroindos, accompanied by a thousand Orestes, subject to king Antipas, and placed by him under
the command of Oroindos. There were also a thousand Macedonians sent by
Perdiccas without the knowledge of the Athenians, but they arrived too late.
With the force, Camnus set out without waiting for the fleet in Corinth, passing through the
territory of the Amphilianagos, and sacked the open village of Luminia. They advanced to Stratus,
the Amachian capital, convinced that once this was taken, the rest of the country would
speedily come over. The Arcadians, finding themselves invaded by a large army by land
and from sea, threatened by the hostile fleet, made no combined attempt at resistance,
but they remained to defend their homes, and sent out for help to Parma, who replied
that when a fleet was on point of sailing from Corinth, it was impossible for him to leave
Neopactus unprotected. The Peloponnesian meanwhile and their allies advanced upon
Stratus in three divisions, and the intention of encamping near it and attempting the
wall by force, but they had failed to succeed by negotiation.
An order of the march was as follows. The center was occupied by the
Leonatians, and the rest of the Barbarians, and the Lucidians, and the Ante-Anactorians,
and their followers on the right, and Calmus, and the Peloponnesians, and the Emperors on the left,
each division being a long way off, and sometimes even out of sight from the other.
The Hellenes advanced in good order, keeping a lookout until they encamped in a good position,
but the Calenes, filled with self-confidence and having the highest reputation for courage
among the tribes of that part of the continent, without waiting to occupy their camp,
rushed on with the rest of the Barbarians with the idea that they should take the city by assault
and obtain the glory, the sole glory of the Anteplan. While they were coming on, the
Stratians, becoming aware of how things stood, and thinking that the defeat of this division
would considerably dishearten the Hellenes just behind them, occupied the
invines of the city with ambush gates, and soon as they approached, engaged them at close quarters
in the city and in the ambush gates. The panic, seizing the Calenes, great numbers of them were
slain. As soon as they were seen to give way, the rest of the Barbarians turned and fled.
Going to the distance at which the Allies had proceeded, neither the Hellenistic division
knew anything of the battle, but fancied that they were hastening on to the camp. However,
when the flying Barbarians broke in upon them, they opened their ranks to receive them, brought
their division together and stopped quiet where they were for the day, the Stratians not offering
to engage them as the rest of the Archaeans had not yet arrived, but contending themselves with
slings at them from the distance. They distressed them as they could not move without their armor.
The Archaeans are thought to excel at this mode of warfare. As soon as night fell, this is now
chapter two, as soon as night fell, Candemus partly drew off his army to the river Annapolis,
about nine miles from Stratus, recovering his dead the next day under truce, and being there joined
by the friendly Oeneida and fell back upon their city before the enemy's reinforcement came up.
Hence, from each, hence, each returned home and the Stratians set up a trophy for the battle
with the Barbarians. Meanwhile, the fleet from Corinth and the rest of the Confederates of the,
Crypsean Gulf, which, to which, to have cooperated with Candemus and prevented,
prevented the coastal Archaeans from joining their countrymen in the interior,
was stopped from doing so by being compelled about the same time at the Battle of Stratus to fight
with Phobos and 20 Athenian vessels stationed at New Pontus. They were, for they were watched as
they coasted along out the Gulf by Phobos, who wished to attack in the open sea, but the
Corinthians and their allies started for Archaeus without any idea of fighting at sea, and the
vessels were like transports for carrying soldiers, besides which they never dreamed of 20 Athenian
ships venturing to engage their 47. However, they were coasting along at shore, their own shore,
there were Athenians sailing along in a line with them, and when they tried to cross from
Paria and Achaea, the mainland on the other side, on their way to Anarchia, they saw them coming
again out of Carolus and the river Evenus to meet them. They slipped from their moorings in the
night, but were observed and were at length compelled to fight in mid-passage. Each city
that contributed to the armaments had its own general, and the Corinthian commander were
Mathenon, Isocrates, and Agathothardias. The Peloponnesian ranged their vessels in a large
circle as possible without leaving an opening, and the Prows outside and the Sterns in,
and placed all the small craft company and their five best sailors to move out of the moment's
notice and strengthen any point threatened by the enemy. The Athenians formed a line,
sailed around and around, and forced them to contact their surface by continually brushing
past and making as though they would attack at once. Having been previously cautioned by Pramos
not to do so until he gave the signal, his hope was the Peloponnesian would not retain their order
and force, like a force on shore, but the ships would fall afoul of one another and the small
craft would cause confusion. And if the winds, which usually rose towards the morning, should
blow off from the docks, an expectation of which he kept sailing around them, he felt sure that
they would not remain in an instant. He also thought that if it rested with him to attack
when he pleased, as his ships were better sailors and the attack time by coming of the wind would
tell best. And when the winds came up, the enemy ships were now in a narrow space, and with the
winds and the small craft dashing against them, all at once fell into confusion. The ships fell
afoul out of ship. The ship fell foul of ship. While the crews were pushing them off with poles
and were shouting, swearing, and struggling with one another, made captain's orders and
through being unable to want to practice to clear their oars in rough water,
prevented the vessels from obeying their helmsman. At this moment, Thermos gave the signal and the
Athenians attacked, sinking first one of the commander's ship and then disabled all they came
across. So no one thought of resistance, thought of resistance for the confusion,
but all fled for Parnia and Demetia and Achaia. The Athenians gave chase and captured 12 ships,
taking most of the men out of them, sailed to Molikrinum, and after setting up a trophy on the
moratorium of Molikrinum and dedicating a ship to Poseidon, returned to New Parthas. As for the
Peloponnesians, they once sailed for their remaining ships along the coast from
Demet in Patria, to Cilene, to the Ilian arsenal, where Clemenus and their ships from Lyra that were
to have joined them also arrived after the battle of Stratus, hence the picture in this trinity.
85. The Spartans now sent the fleet of Clemenus three commissioners, the Cretaceous,
Baracites, and Lycopha, with orders to prepare to engage again with better fortune
and not be driven from the sea by few vessels, for they could not at all explain their defeat,
unless so, if it was the first attempt at sea. They fancied that it was not that their navy was
so inferior, but that there had been misconduct somewhere, not considering the long experience
of the Athenians as compared to their little practice which they had themselves. The
commissioners were accordingly sent in anger as soon as they arrived to set work with
Clemenus to order ships from different cities and to put those which had already had
infighting in order. Meanwhile, Forminus sent word to Athens of their preparations and his
own victory and desired as many ships as possible to be sent to him, as he stood in daily expectation
of battle. Twenty were accordingly sent, but instructions were given to their commanders
to first go to Crete, for Nicias, a Cretan of Gorthi, who was a proxenist of the Athenians,
had persuaded them to sail against Clemodon, promising to procure the reduction of that hostile
city. His real wish was to be able to oblige the Philocreatian neighbors of the Philodeans.
He accordingly went with the ships to Crete and accompanied them at Philolection,
laid waste to the lands of the Pleiadians, and what with adverse winds, stress of weather,
wasted no little time there. While the Athenians were thus detaining Crete, the Peloponnesians and
Plinia got ready for battle and coasted along Pennomos in Achilia, where their land army had
come to support them. Thromino also coasted along the Malkraeum and anchored outside it with twenty
ships, the same he had fought with before. This Uranium was friendly to the Athenians,
the other in the Peloponnesians lied opposite to it. The sea between them is three quarters
of a mile broad and forms the mouth of the Cretan Gulf. At this, the Acta Morinum, not far off
Pennomos, where their army lay, the Peloponnesians now cast anchor with seventy-seven ships,
when they saw the Athenians do so. For six or seven days, they remained opposite each other,
practicing preparing for battle. The one resolved not to sail out of the Raymond to open sea for
fear of the disaster which had already happened to them, and the other not to sail into the
enemy to fight in the narrows. At last, Krinos and Bredas and the rest of the Peloponnesian
commanders being desired to bring on the battle as soon as possible before reinforcements arrived
from Athens, and noting that the men were most of them cowed by their previous defeat,
out of hot of the business, first called them together and encouraged them as followers.
The Peloponnesians, the late engagement which may have made some of you afraid
of the one now, in prospect really gives no just mounts for the apprehension. Preparations for it,
as you know, were little enough, and the object of our voyage was not so much to fight at sea
as the expedition in land, besides as the chances of war were largely against us,
and perhaps also an experience that had something to do with our failure at the first naval operation.
It was not therefore cowardice that produced our defeat, nor the determination which
force has not been quite, but which still has a word to say with its adversary.
But admitting the possibility of a chance miscarriage, we should know that the brave
hearts must be always brave, and why they remain so can never put forward an experience as an
nor are you so behind the enemy in experience as you are ahead of him in courage, and although
the science of your opponent would, if valor accompanied it, would have the presence of mind
to carry out in an emergency the lessons that it learned, yet a faint heart will make all art
powerless in the face of danger, for fear takes away presence of mind, and without valor art is
useless, against their superior excellence set your superior daring, and against the fear induced
by defeat, the fact that your having been unprepared, remember too that you have always
had the advantage of superior numbers, and of gauging your own cost, supported by your own
hoplites, and as a row number and equipment gave victory, at no point therefore is defeat likely,
and as for your previous mistakes, the very fact of their occurrence will teach us better for the
future, stairmen and sailors may confidently attend their several duties, none quitting the
station assigned to them, for as for ourselves we promise to prepare for the engagement at least as
well as your previous commander, and to give no excuse for anyone misconducting themselves, should
any insist on doing so, we shall meet with punishments he deserves, while the brave shall
be honored at the appropriate rewards of wealth, the palpanesian commanders encouraged their men
after his fashion, from and on while being himself not without fear for the courage of his men,
and noting that they were forming in groups among themselves, and were alarmed at the odds against
them, desired to call them together and give them confidence, and consult in the present emergency,
he had before continually told them, and had accompanied their mind to the idea
that no numerical superiority that they could not face, and the men themselves had long been
persuaded that the athenians never need never retire before any number of palpanesians, at the moment
however he saw that they were dispirited by the sight before them, wishing to refresh their
confidence, and called them together, and he spoke as well, i see my men that you are frightened by
the number of the enemy, i have accordingly called you together, not liking you to be afraid
of what is not really terrible, in the first place, the palpanesians are already defeated,
and not even themselves thinking that they're a match for us, and have not ventured to meet
us on equal terms, but have equipped a multitude of ships against us, next as to upon that which
the most rely, the courage which they suppose constitutional to them, in other words inherent to
them, their confidence here only arises from the successes which their experience in land service
usually gives them, and they fancy will do the same for them as they
believe that they will do that same for sea, but this advantage will at all justice belong to us
on this island, if to them on that, as they are not superior to us in courage, but we are
each of us more confident according to our experience in our own particular department,
besides as the spartans use their supremacy over their allies to promote their own glory,
they are most of them being brought into the danger against their will, or they could would
never have such a after such a decided defeat have ventured upon a fresh engagement,
you need not therefore be afraid of their dash, you on the contrary can on the contrary inspire
a much greater and better founded alliance, both because of your late victory and also be of their
belief that we should not face them unless about to do something unworthy such as an outstanding
success, unless do something worthy of such an outstanding success, an adversary numberly
superior like the one before us comes into action trusting more in strength than to resolution,
while he who voluntarily confronts tremendous odds must have very great internal resources to
draw upon, for these reasons the Peloponnesians fear are in irrational audacity more than they
would ever have done a more consumerate preparations, besides many armaments have
before now succumbed to a inferior though want of skill and sometimes of courage,
neither of which defects certainly are ours, as to the battle it shall not be if I can help it
in the straits, nor will I sail there at all, seeing that this is a constant between a number
of clumsily managed vessel and a small fast well-handled squadron want of sea room in a
is a undoubled disadvantage, no one cannot run down a enemy properly without having a sight of him
a good way off nor can one retire at need when pressed, one can neither break the line nor
return from upon the rear the prop the proper tactics for a fast sailor, but the naval action
essay becomes the land becomes a lambda in which numbers must decide the matter,
for all of this I will provide as far as can be, do you stay at your points by your ships
and we shop at catching the word of command and the more we are observing one another
from short so short a distance and the act and the action thing order in silence all important
quality is useful in war generally in naval engagements in particular and behave before
the enemy in a manner worthy of your past expert the issue you will fight
the issues you will fight for are great either you will destroy their the naval hopes of the
Peloponnesians or will bring nearly to reality the Athenian fear of losing control of the sea
I and I may once remind you that you have defeated more of them ready and beaten men
not beaten men do not face a danger twice with the same determination such was the
exhortation of formula the Peloponnesian finding that the Athenians did not sail into the gulf
and the narrows in order to lead them in where they wished or not put out at dawn informing
four abreast sailed inside the gulf in the direction of their own country the right wing
leading as they laid it in this way they will place 20 of their fastest ships so in the event
that formula was thinking that the object was neoprotos and coasting along tither to save the
place the Athenians might not be able to escape onset of getting outside their wing but might
be cut off by the vessels in question and they expected promenades an alarm for the place
at the moment emptied by its garrison as soon as he saw them put out reluctantly he buried
him back and sailed along shore the messian's land land forces moving along to support him
the Peloponnesian seeing him coasting along with his ships in a single file and already
inside the gulf and close and sure as they so much wished at one signals a sudden turn and
bored down in line and at best speed on the Athenians hoping to cut off those quadrant
the 11 the 11 leading vessels however escaped the Peloponnesian wing and all of us and and
its southern movement and reached the more open water but the rest were overtaken as they tried
to run through driven ashore and disabled much of their crews being slain as they had not swum out
some of the ships uh some of the ships the Peloponnesian lashed their own and towed off
empty one they took with its men on it others were just being told off when they were saved
by the Messalines dashing into the sea with their armor and fighting from the decks that
they had boarded uh thus far victory was uh with the uh thus far victory was with the Peloponnesian
and 20 ships in the right wing being uh meanwhile in chase of the 11 Athenian
vessels that had escaped their sudden movement and reached the more open water
these with an exception of one ship all sailed uh sailed them uh and got into
informing close in the shore opposite of a temporal Apollo with their prowls facing the enemy
prepared to defend themselves in case the opinions were shared against uh should sail
in shore against them well and a while the Peloponnesians came up uh chanting the pan
for their victory as as they sailed on a single Athenian ship remaining being chased by the
Lucretian far ahead of the rest but there happened to be a merchant man laying at anchor
on the roadside which is which the Athenian ship found time to sail around and struck the
Lucretian in chase a midship and sank them and an exploit so sudden and unexpected produced
a panic upon the Peloponnesian and having flown out in order and of excitement of victory some
of them dropped their oars and stopped uh uh uh their way in order to let the main body come up
an unsafe thing to do considering how near the enemy crawlers while others ran a ground and
shallows of their ignorance of localities elated by the incentive the Athenians gave one word
at one word gave cheer and dashed at the end who embarrassed by the mistakes and disorders
in which he found himself only stood for an instant and then fled for a penumbras with
which he had put out the Athenians followed on their heels took all six vessels nearest them
and recovered uh those of their own which had been disabled close to the shore taken in tow
at the rest beginning of their action they killed some of the crews and took other prisoners
on board Lucretian the Lucretians which went down with the merchant men uh uh uh uh uh uh
with the Spartan Timocrates who killed himself when the ship was sunk and had cast up in the
harbor of Neapopolis the Athenians on their return set up a trophy on the spot from which they had
put out and turned and turned the day picking up the wrecks and the dead that were on their shore
gave back to the enemy their dead under truce and the Peloponnesians also set up a trophy
as victors for the defeat inflicted on the ship they had disabled at shore and dedicated the
vessel to which he had taken at Anakion Ream side by side with the trophy after this the
apprehensive of reinforcements expected from Athens all except the Lucretians sailed into the
Chrysidian Gulf for Corinth not long after their um their retreat 20 Athenian ships um
20 Athenian ships uh uh uh with which were to have joined Formos before the battle arrived at
Neapolis so that finally the ship that was supposed to come there earlier now finally came
um uh this is uh and we're going to stop at 93 the 93 is the thus the winter ended right
so that we're going to stop here this ends the summer so the third year so we're going to end
here if you have any questions put them on the comments below i will get them in the comments or
you know things like it thumbs up it uh if you don't like it always thumbs down uh put your
comments and items in there below i will respond um if you liked it share it with a friend subscribe
encourage your friends to subscribe um if um follow you can follow me below on social media
if you have um if you want and also you can always join my subscribe star um
if you wish to help contribute to make these more uh make them better and learn from them
um well the semester is coming up and uh you know i have to go back to teaching on my two days
i have to teach two days at university um and therefore i i will have less time to do this
but um i'll still do it okay um and i have to do research too so
i have to write something i have to get one two more things written
okay now i'll shut up and i wish you all a good day bye bye
