Tony Kinnett sits down with historian Raymond Ibrahim, author of *Sword and Scimitar*, to talk about what he calls "fake history." In Ibrahim's view, that's the story that casts Christian crusaders as the aggressors and leaves out centuries of jihad and Christian martyrdom. He walks through forgotten episodes like the Georgian martyrs and America's fight against the Barbary pirates, and argues that the same patterns of persecution go on today. He also explains why getting the history wrong shapes how the West sees itself now, and where to start reading if you want the real story.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
Ray Ibrahim and his interlocutor discuss the dangers of \"fake history\" and the systematic erasure of the violent history of Islamic expansion. They argue that modern narratives often invert the roles of aggressor and victim, leading to an intellectual rot in the West. Ibrahim emphasizes that the persecution of Christians continues today in the Islamic world and warns against the artificial distinction between Islam and Islamism.
A treat to be joined by the great Ray Ibrahim.
A blast to have you speaking here, of course.
But you have done something more important to me than almost anything.
You stroked my ego when you
also went on an eloquent kind of a tangent on America's...
...greatest naval tradition, sinking Islamic pirates,
and being one of the first to cast off the European tradition
of paying off Muslims to leave us alone.
No one seems to remember this history.
I mean, again, forgive me for saying why are we
in such a cool club here, but what is it that kind
of puts you past just taking the history revisionist narrative?
The revisionist narrative, which I call fake history,
because that's exactly what it is.
Correct.
And it's very dangerous, because as I often say,
fake history is much worse than fake news.
Fake news is ephemeral.
It creates damage, it goes away,
but fake history creates overarching narratives that you see reality.
It erodes the very foundation nothing can stand.
It becomes, history is premise one.
And if your first premise is false,
everything you're going to build on it is going to be also false.
So if we believe, for example, the fake history that...
Muslims were tolerant, and it
was the evil Christian crusaders who started conflict.
Well, you can build atop of that how, oh,
the West owes it, it should apologize.
Oh, the West needs to be less suspicious.
It should make up for its sins, ancestor sins, et cetera, et cetera,
which is the kind of way of thinking.
They're not even good revisions, though.
I mean, it's like the Pope woke up one morning and said,
I think I shall take Jerusalem.
Well, that's exactly how it's portrayed.
I know.
That's how silly it is.
I just gave a quote from John Esposito.
Who made it sound like everything before the First Crusade,
you know, four or five centuries of non-stop jihad.
We were just trading croissants of two kinds of wheat.
Nothing was wrong.
But then when the First Crusade happened,
everything, that's the problem.
It's truly, we talk about the erasure of culture often as well.
And of course, the Americans are lambasted
for destroying so many great cultures with their imperialism.
And this is something that Khrushchev later said
was one of his greatest successes, was...
Making Americans ashamed of their own history through the Cold War.
And we never stopped to think about the North African countries,
about the Southern European cultures
and civilizations that, as you said,
were scattered into the highlands.
Or butchered and raped,
and the very first pseudo-guillotines ever created
was through that first caliphate's brutal sweep through Europe.
No one ever sheds a tear for those lost peoples and the cultures.
It's amazing. I was looking at, for example,
the Orthodox and the Catholics.
They have martyr feast days.
Right, right.
And it's like almost every day there's a martyr, and you look into it,
oh, he was killed by a Muslim, he was skinned alive, he was beheaded,
he was crucified because he wouldn't renounce Christ.
All right.
October 31st, which recently passed, rather fittingly, being Halloween,
there's something like, they're called the Georgian Martyrs,
where Muslims literally killed,
according to the sources, 100,000 Christians
because they would not spit on the icon of Christ,
and they beheaded them.
Where's this history? Why don't we ever hear this?
You'll hear of anything and everything that can make the West look bad,
but this sheer carnage has just completely all been removed.
And you can see the damage that that kind of thing does.
There would also be something that stokes
the flames of Western civilization
for young men and women of this country to remember
that in the New Testament,
Paul and Peter talk about the strength of the Holy Spirit
through severe persecution, meaning up until death.
It was tried immediately
in the first millennium after Christ's time on earth
in which they were, how many countless thousands of Christians
were told, spit on the icon of Christ.
Or you will die.
And they stayed resolute to the last.
That is a heritage of Western civilization
that Jewish and Christian individuals in our civilizations
have carried the torch of through blinding persecution,
that the mockery of, again, as you pointed out today,
not just Takiyah, but under the other certain kinds of Islamic,
the open flattery of dishonesty,
that this mockery is a greater insult,
not because of their laughter,
but because of the blood it is built upon through history.
Yeah, and it's a non-stop bloody trail from day one up until the,
literally, till the present.
You know, if you look at, I always say,
if you want to know what Islam's about,
don't look at what Muslims say
and do in the West where they know they're under infidel authority
and they have to behave a certain way.
Look at how Muslims speak and behave in the Islamic world.
And if you do that, let's say,
one of my focuses is the persecution of Christians.
I've written a book about it.
I've been following it every month for 16 years.
And you will find that...
The top ten nations in the world that persecute Christians,
about eight are Muslim.
And furthermore, some are black, African,
some are Arab, some are East Asian, some Iran.
And so you have this disparate group of races
and cultures and languages and governments,
and yet you find the same exact patterns
of persecution of religious minorities.
What's the common denominator? Well, it's Islam.
So even in the modern era, we still have it, but we still...
Just like we refuse to see the past, we refuse to see the present.
Well, and in that present, we see Europe once again echoing the past
of just trying to whistle past
the graveyard of accepting this cultural...
...of this cultural disease to infest the continent once again.
And it's something that is truly terrifying
because when I look at the number of, again,
journalists, of course, the New York Times reporting
on the French now investigating
one of their own, the author,
who had the gall to criticize the treatment of those under
the Islamic State.
But when we look over here,
we have our own brand of quislings as well who say things
Well, I don't know why anyone would even be concerned about Qatar.
That kind of nonsense.
Christians are happily fine.
And he just blatant nonsense from true traitorous activity
that isn't about defending Western civilization.
It isn't about putting America first.
It's about making an excuse needlessly for, again,
the cruelest thing to civilization that we've spawned as a people.
Yeah, one of the quotes I read
was from Hilaire Belloc, great historian,
and he basically said, Islam is our greatest enemy.
From the beginning up until now
and at any time it can become another great enemy.
And he said that when Islam was at its absolute weakest.
People laughed at that quote.
They were like, what are you talking about?
Give me a break.
If there was a problem, it's over.
Even Franklin, not too long after,
remitted his earlier remarks about his Philadelphia,
The, uh, uh, the...
the grouping house.
It wasn't a church.
It was that...
Mm-hmm.
Congress should create, you know, the auditorium,
essentially, where he said, oh, well, even
the muftis of the Ottomans,
he recanted that later in his life at a time when supposedly
the Islamic world was also, again, at its weakest.
Yeah, yeah, it's an unwavering, similar story,
and all that's left is how we interpret it
and how we understand it, and for whatever reason,
we're understanding it in the antithesis
of what it is.
We've made the aggressors the victims,
and we've made the victims the aggressors.
And that's what's leading to the sort of intellectual rot
that is paving the way and enabling Islam.
Remember, Muslims are weak today.
They're refugees. They're coming begging.
Okay, how can that person take your land over?
Well, that's a reflection of you.
Okay, when I...
It's one thing when they were coming with swords
and you're fighting them and you try to resist them.
Well, also the family relational marital policies
hasn't necessarily helped either.
Well, yeah, exactly.
Exactly, but...
Also, just not, look at us.
We're still at a day and age where we
separate between Islam and Islamism.
We've created an artificial distinction.
Oh, yeah.
No one in the Islamic world knows what that means.
Well, first suggested in the old Baghdad house of wisdom, of course.
I mean, some things never change.
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
So a final question here
that is not necessarily where I was going to go,
but I think it's deeply important, Ray.
So many things.
It's so much fun to talk about.
The deep history points with someone else who studied it.
A lot of my audience, a lot of our friends at the Daily Signal,
the Heritage Foundation and across,
they want to know how to get into it.
Because if you just go looking around online,
you're just as likely to find the crazy maniacal laughter stuff
or the AI-generated slop rather than what really hooks you
in on the good stuff.
What do you recommend off the top of your head here
for those who just want to start getting in
and may not be able to dive into the Library of Congress as you have?
Well, first of all, you're right about the AI
because I have wars with AI and because I'm
well aware of history, I ask you questions and it just lies.
And when I finally call it out,
it goes, oh yeah, yeah, yeah, I forgot to mention that.
But if you want the solid
primer on everything we're talking about,
because it was built on the Library of Congress,
it's my book Sword and Scimitar, which I wrote.
Actually, I started researching for it when I was
I was in the Library of Congress.
And it really documents the long war between Islam
from day one up until the present.
But it's also not written like a history syllabus, so it's not so dry
that you feel like you're dragging your face through sandpaper.
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
Yeah.
Raymond Ibrahim, cannot tell you how good it is to have you here.
Again, I encourage each and every one
of you to look at some of these lectures,
not because he's here next to me
and would hit me if I said don't listen to the lectures,
I tease, but because they're substantive and they're engaging
and they are exactly what's needed for a country that is exchanging
the importance of solid history for the cheapness of flashy models
and temporary safety.
Right.