"Ranking Thomas Hardy's Books https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZncMXTMcrxM"

Thomas Hardy
4 followers
Hi everyone, welcome to another Victober video. Happy Victober to you. It is the most wonderful
time of the year and I am just hoping and praying that I have some new favorite Victorian literature
that comes out of this month. But if I don't, it is okay because I am also rereading a couple of
books in there. Okay, I want to talk about Thomas Hardy today. A contentious topic on my channel,
I know, but I'm going to try to not be too snarky and I want to rank the Thomas Hardy books that I
have read. I'm going to be going from least favorite to most favorite and now coming out
two years after, no, it's closer to three years after reading Do the Obscure, I can now kind of
talk about it calmly. This book is sponsored by entitlement and victim culture. Jude in his life
is not happy with his circumstances. So much of the book is following Jude having a giant pity party
about how he wishes he could be taken seriously and in the academic world and have more social
cachet. Jude wants to study literature in college. Does he have time to read in his spare time on his
own as a hobby? Yes, he does. Apparently that is not enough for him. Then when Jude is not accepted
into a university, he is petulant and vandalizes the university gates with a scripture verse that
is completely taken out of context and I have zero sympathy for Jude. He brings all his problems
on himself and I have to say that your life is what you make of it and the circumstances that
you are in are what you make of them. People can live in hellish circumstances and still be able
to find some kind of good in them and if you are living in terrible circumstances, it would behoove
you to try to make things, if you're living in tragic circumstances, then try to make things a
little bit less tragic. Jude is so, um, Jude, if you want to know why are there so many problems
around you, I advise you to look within. That's what I advise you. Look within, Jude.
I just can't empathize with a character that is so focused on how much he is a victim and I don't
even really think of him as much of a victim, but I'm very biased because of the book and everything
that goes down. So I think some people, when they hear me talk about how I don't like Jude the Obscure,
they think it's because of a very tragic thing that happens 80% through the book
and that is not it. The reason why I don't like this book is because of the main
character who we're supposed to feel really sorry for. Also, I have to say a reason why
Thomas Hardy's novels will never rank as highly as others is that he really hates marriage.
He is upset about the institution of marriage and dare I say that just because there are couples
who are bad at marriage doesn't mean then that you just get to decide that the institution of
marriage itself should just be abolished. And just on the whole self-pity, I just feel like
that is Hardy being his most transparent in that book. So that's why his books will never rank as
high. That's really how you see the world, that if you don't like how your life has turned out,
it's everyone else's fault. It's just life is unfair. It's really hard living in a fallen world.
Things are often not fair. People are often dealt a bad hand. That's just life. And you know if
I'm going to link this man named Nate who was born without arms and legs and goes around the world
and is a motivational speaker. I wish Jude could have had a talk with this man. Not that Jude is
real. Okay, I will stop talking. I will move on from this book. It's the only one that makes me
irate. So then next lowest is Tess of the D'Urbervilles. So I'd say that the pain threshold
is very much surpassed in Tess of the D'Urbervilles. It is, but it is also beautiful.
And the difference between Jude and Tess is that I have a lot of sympathy for Tess.
The problems that happen in her life are for the most part not because of her. And it's just
because she goes into the world so naive. I have a lot of sympathy and even love for Tess. So it's
basically because the book itself is way past my pain threshold that it's ranked down so low.
I just, I don't like a book that's going to ruin my week or my month. And I don't like,
it's a beautiful story, but I don't know if I'll ever work up the courage to read it again. It's
just, it really is like a month ruiner for me. I'm very tender hearted. And I think when you're
tender hearted, you need to guard your heart. And so that's something that it's just, it's
a fictional book. Like, do I have to subject, subject myself to it again? And please don't
leave any comments talking about how I'm completely wrong about Jude the Obscure,
Tess of the D'Urbervilles. I'm not open to dialogue about that. I'm just not. I'm not.
Like, I am allowed to dislike books. And here on the online book community, people get very touchy.
If I don't like a book that someone liked, if I DNF it, it's, oh, well, you didn't finish it.
If I finish it and don't like it, it's, oh, well, you read it wrong. So I'm just, I'm done.
This is how I feel. Okay. This is very opinion filled video. Then the next lowest ranked is
Desperate Remedies. And this one, I don't know how else to say it. This book is unnecessarily
weird. It's just bizarre. And there's two women named Scytheria, which is such an unusual name.
And it was Hardy kind of attempting to write a sensation novel. And I just think he didn't
stick the landing. It's just weird. I don't know how else to put it. So I came out of that just
being glad to be done with it. And felt I feel zero desire to ever read it again. I gave my
copy away. And I'm not upset about it. Okay, the next one is Two on a Tower. Two on a Tower.
Again, sometimes when a Victorian novel is very dramatic, I'm like, yes, I loved how deeply I
felt I couldn't stop reading. I wanted to know what was going to happen next.
And I'm on the edge of my seat, all that stuff, right? And sometimes I'm just like, rolling my
eyes at how dramatic it is. And this one was had me rolling my eyes. I, it just felt unnecessarily
dramatic. Like the things that happened didn't feel like they pushed the plot forward. Also
didn't really feel connected to the characters. And I was a bit bummed because the notion of
Two on a Tower and it involving astronomy. I loved like I love the study of the stars,
I think you can make so romantic in a novel. So I don't know if there's another Victorian
novel out there. I know that astronomy did have some big leaps and bounds that happened
during the Victorian era. So if you know of any Victorian novels involving astronomy,
then let me know. Then the next one was The Woodlanders. So this is one that I didn't
dislike. But I just really came out of it not being as wowed by it as other readers seem to be.
Yes, it was very sad, but it was not past my pain threshold. And I think it was just that I was like,
huh, after I finished. It's, yeah, it was just so-so. Oh, I forgot. In between Two on a Tower
and The Woodlanders I missed is Under the Greenwood Tree. And this is one where I much
prefer the film adaptation. It's probably the only party that I'm willing to, to watch regularly. I
watched Tess of the D'Urbervilles and now I just can't, I can't do it again. But Under the Greenwood
Tree, what made me so sad is that Fancy Day, I didn't really like her that much in the book.
There's this whole sinister undertone towards the end. I was just like, why? Why does this have to
be there? Why did it? It's a novel. It doesn't have to always be tragic. So that's kind of how
I felt about it. Okay, then we get to the top four. And these are all ones that I feel positive about,
and I enjoy, with one caveat. So the next one is The Mayor of Castlebridge. This is one that blew
my mind the first time I read it. I loved how pacey it was. I loved how I could not stop turning pages.
I loved just how much fun I was having as I read it. Now, what happened though, is I read it,
I really enjoyed it. Then, two years later, I read Jew the Obscure, and I really struggled
after that. Two years after that, this was voted as the group read on my Patreon. And so I tried
reading it again, and I was still too mad at Thomas Hardy. He was still in timeout and couldn't
continue with it. So I had to set it down then. And last year, when I talked about my complicated
reading room relationship with Hardy in the announcement video, I think people thought I
hadn't actually read The Mayor of Castlebridge. But I read it, and then tried reading it like
the fall before that, in October, and I just wasn't ready to try it again. Okay, then the top
three in third place, and a recent new favorite, and it encourages me to try an author's full
catalog, if there have been some promising books that they've had, is The Trumpet Major. And this,
to me, is in the same kind of category as The Mayor of Castlebridge. It's got really pacey
plotting, and it has some really confusing dynamics with romantic relationships. It has a love
pentagon that's very convoluted and over the top, and it has just a lot going for it. It's
very dramatic, and I really, really enjoyed this one. Also, it's fun variety because it's set in the
Napoleonic era, as opposed to, you know, when the book was written in the Victorian era.
And it was just a lot of fun, and it was way below my pain threshold. I was bracing because it was a
new-to-me Hardy. Like, what is he gonna do to me? Is my heart going to be blasted to smithereens?
And this one feels, it felt like Hardy had fun while he was reading it, as opposed to the book
that shall remain nameless. It felt like he feels just so petulant the whole time he's reading it,
and just snarky, and like he can't stand all his readers. So it was a really, really nice
reading experience, and I wasn't expecting to enjoy it as much as I did. I couldn't put it
down once I started reading. Okay, then second place is Far From the Madding Crowd. This is a
fan favorite. It's really, really beautiful. Even though I cannot stand Bathsheba Everdeen and how
she treats men, I love this book. This book is loved despite that. His writing is so eloquent
in this, and I just find myself so enamored with it as a book. Gabriel Oak, I will say,
out of all of Thomas Hardy's characters, you know, I say I don't really feel emotionally
attached after his books are done. Gabriel Oak is the one, though, that I'm like, okay, actually,
you are amazing. Like, I feel, I feel a kinship to you. Not like I feel like I'm as noble as
Gabriel Oak, but I just feel like you are good people, and I want to aspire to be more like a
Gabriel Oak, right? He's a wonderful character. So, all of that just makes it such a moving
reading experience, and it's one I'll definitely return to at some point. Then, lastly, in first
place is The Return of the Native, and this is one, it completely swept me away with how it has
this otherworldly sort of feel to it and atmosphere. It is pretty sad, but not past my
pain threshold, right at it, and it's just got such a sense of, sort of this kind of ominous
feel to it, and I loved that. I was in the mood for it. So, the amount of darkness in The Trumpet
Major, Far From the Madding Crowd, and The Return of the Native, those are all, like, I can totally
handle those. I can get on board. It's like in The Princess Bride, when he's in the Pit of Despair,
and somebody comes down and turns on the pain machine all the way to 50, and the guy says,
not to 50! So, these books don't go past the, you know, the proper amount of pain, and, yeah,
it's just, The Return of the Native almost has this sort of whimsical, tragic feel about it.
I really, really loved it. So, then that leaves, that I haven't read yet, The Hand of Ethelberta,
which I started a few years ago, and then just wasn't motivated to continue. So, I'll return to
that at some point, and then on top of that, what is it, A Pair of Blue Eyes, which I'm pretty
excited to read that one, and then that leaves, I think it's A Laodicean, which I haven't heard
anyone love, even very devoted Hardy fans. Yeah, so, those are my rankings. Let me know what you
think, and, yeah, let's dialogue. As long as, you know, you're okay with me disliking these books,
let's dialogue in the comments, and I hope you have a wonderful day. Bye!
