A Princeton mathematician says wormholes cannot survive Einstein's equations, and the AI apocalypse is absurd. A solution that vanishes under a small nudge is a ghost, not physics.
Sergiu Klainerman is a mathematician at Princeton University. With Demetrios Christodoulou, he proved that empty spacetime is stable.
We cover: what makes a solution of Einstein's equations physical, why slowly rotating black holes pass the stability test and wormholes fail it, why shocks form no matter how small the perturbation, whether AI can reproduce a landmark proof, and why he calls the AI singularity absurd.
Mathematics is discovered, not invented.
CHAPTERS 00:00 Are wormholes real? 08:38 What happens at an event horizon 12:06 God does not know about coordinates 17:32 What Maldacena would say about wormholes 21:48 Why extremal black holes matter 28:56 Einstein and the 1919 eclipse 33:52 Terry Tao and Fermat's Last Theorem 43:04 Can universities be reformed? 48:16 What to tell a 19-year-old 50:48 Kip Thorne and the movies
Amazon affiliate disclosure: links above marked to Amazon may earn a commission for the channel at no cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
What's your opinion on wormholes?
From my understanding, they are extremely unstable.
If it's unstable, mathematically, in other words,
relative to small perturbations, it disappears.
Then it's like a ghost.
The part inside is pure mathematics now, right?
Because we cannot go there.
The AI is going to become more intelligent,
and it's going to reproduce itself at a huge speed,
and then kill us off.
It's just absurd. It's ridiculous.
Sergiu Klainerman is a mathematician at Princeton University.
More than 30 years ago, he and Demetrius Christodoulou
proved that empty space-time is stable.
That sounds simple, like almost a technicality.
But it isn't.
Every exact solution of Einstein's equations
has to survive that test before it even can count as physics.
Slowly rotating black holes pass, wormholes, they just don't.
And at the end, he takes the same scalpel to the AI apocalypse
that we're all confronting these days.
And it all started, one question, after a talk he gave.
I was in Berkeley, I came as a postdoc,
and Yao invited me to give a colloquium at Stanford, which I did.
And at the end, so I talked about my thesis.
At the end, he came to me and said,
Have you considered the stability of the Minkowski space?
For some reason, he knew about it.
I mean, even his own interest is also Riemannian.
It's not always...
But why would that be a question?
I mean, why would somebody think...
I mean, we don't think of Newtonian things being unstable.
So why would we think the Minkowski space would be...
Might be more difficult.
Right, because you could say...
There is a positive energy, the positive mass theorem,
which he actually, Yao, has contributed.
This was maybe a little bit later, but about the same time that he
and Schoen proved the positive mass theorem.
And indeed, from a point of view of physicists,
you could say, well, okay, that proves stability.
And in fact, actually, I remember later on when I was at Courant,
after we proved the stability of Minkowski space was Christodoulou.
Ed Witten gave a talk in which he said that
He had another proof of the positivity
of mass in general relativity, and he claimed
that this proved the stability of the Minkowski space.
So I went to him and said, what do you mean?
And well, you know, you have the dynamical systems,
you have positive energy, Hamiltonian,
that of course shows.
Of course, I mentioned to him the Burger equation,
right, you hear the Burger equation, it's
An equation in which you also have positive energy
and yet shock forms.
And he just smiled, superior, I remember.
And just...
And he didn't really answer the question.
That's the sort of thing.
I mean, you know, for finite dimensional systems,
Hamiltonian systems,
having positive energy is good enough.
But for infinite dimensional systems,
like the case of general relativity,
it's not enough.
Hey, I just found out that many of you
got unsubscribed recently in a YouTube update.
Make sure that didn't happen.
Please make sure that you're subscribed
and don't forget to leave a comment down below.
Thanks a lot. It really helps out.
What does that mean?
Fundamentally, that something is stable versus unstable,
starting with classical mechanics,
and then we can go into Minkowski mechanics.
Yeah, so that means that you have a solution
and starts to some initial conditions,
you perturb the initial conditions a little bit,
you would like overall, asymptotically for all time,
the new solution to be either converging
to the one you perturb,
Or to stay nearby, right?
So, stability would mean it stays nearby.
It doesn't change very much.
The profile looks similar, which is, of course, extremely important
because you never have exact solutions in anything, right?
In order for that solution to have.
Some kind of physical meaning, it has to be stable.
In terms of perturbing it, if you were to perturb it,
you could put mass in there,
or you could send in radiative, you know, excitations like gravitation.
That's a good question. Obviously, that depends on the problem.
So, stability can mean lots of
things. But within the context of a specific equation,
say I'm interested in compressive
Euler equations, right? So, I expect that I have shock waves.
If I perturb just the flat, the
Trivial initial condition,
stability would mean that you have solutions which stay nearby,
which stay close to constant, or, I don't know,
even converge to the original one.
Let's say zero solution, right?
So the solution is converged back to zero, or at least stay nearby.
But of course, that's not the case.
And the best example is the Burgers equation, right?
Which is the simplest possible compressible equation where shocks form.
So you're starting at constant.
Let's say I start u t, so this is the derivative of u with respect
to t plus u times derivative of u with respect to x in,
you have one space and one time dimension, so two dimension.
It's not a finite dimensional dynamical system.
And the shocks form no matter how small, you know,
whatever perturbations you make, no matter how small,
shocks will form, right? So that means...
That means the...
If we think about, you know,
shock waves and sometimes associated with turbulence or,
you know, Mach number, Reynolds numbers and things like that,
in an empty space-time, what is a shock wave in that case?
In Minkowski space.
You mean in the context of an equation?
Yeah.
No, physically, what does it represent?
Like, what would happen to an observer?
What does it do to...
Observers in covariant coordinates,
let's say you have a population of observers,
and there's a shock wave.
What is being shocked?
What's effectively, because this is classical, right?
Right.
So again, I mean, the Burgers equation,
that's a simple, specific example, right?
So you take initial conditions,
and the particles follow characteristics,
which are very simple, right?
They're just straight lines.
But the straight lines can change
depending on where you start from, right?
So it can be a straight
Line at an angle, if I start here,
so this is the line, I start at this point, I get
one straight line at this angle.
But if I go here, right, the same initial condition.
Then I get a straight line in this other direction.
So they obviously,
and the solution remains constant
along the straight lines, right?
So obviously at that point,
I have a solution with two different,
two distinct values, right?
Depending on the initial conditions, yeah.
Depending on the initial conditions, right?
So the value from the first line
and the value from the other line.
So obviously this doesn't make any sense.
There's something wrong that's happened, right?
So what happens is that in fact,
the first derivative of the solutions blow up.
...become infinite. And then you have
to continue the solution. So all the
shockwave theory is a way of continuing the solution past this.
And, you know, Riemann is
the first... I mean, people may not know,
but Riemann, among many things he did, he was also...
Played a very important role in the development of the shockwave theory.
I didn't know that, yeah.
I mean, we associate him with geometry,
and then eventually with relativity, general relativity.
But he also had a major impact.
That's very interesting.
Yeah, it sort of makes sense.
I mean, Mach was also very interested in shockwaves,
turbulence, sonic phenomena,
and he came up with Mach's principle,
maybe the last of the philosophical physicists
where you could do philosophy.
Maybe Einstein was the last.
You know, think philosophically and then derive
something interesting in the physical universe.
I mean, we physicists typically look down,
you know, with some derision at philosophers.
Oh, they don't do anything.
They don't produce anything.
Although now they're having a renaissance.
Your fellow, you know, professor at Princeton,
Tom Griffiths and others have written, you know.
Basically, philosophers are getting a renaissance now with AI,
which we definitely have to talk about in the context of how
do we actually know these 800-page proofs that you generate
and that is you're kind of the Kleinerman brand are valid.
And without tools like Lean and other things,
I want to get your impressions of, oh, we'll get there.
I think the first thing I want to do now is take
the reader through something more realistic,
add some mass to the problem, and you get a black hole,
get a Schwarzschild solution,
which was first, you know, represented by Schwarzschild,
you know, soon after the creation
of GR, and it was really kind of lay dormant,
and Einstein didn't really know if it would
ever have applicability, but what happens when you add mass?
When you add something, you add some point mass,
you add something that you can, you
still solve exactly, and then it also becomes unstable, correct?
Talk about stability in the context of general relativity with...
So you're talking about just
with the vacuum equations, or you add the...
Well, now I want to add a Schwarzschild matter.
Yeah, so the stability of a Schwarzschild solution.
Yeah, so the Schwarzschild solution, of course,
is still a solution of the vacuum equation. So
you are talking about the vacuum equation with no,
you know, there was no sources.
Physicists would say, oh, there is a source,
it's a point mass of some mass capital M, and that's...
I mean, otherwise you don't generate.
Yeah, so it's not perfectly imaginary,
but it's a delta function, right?
I guess the point I'm trying to make is, the black hole solution has
a mass, it's a point mass of the Schwarzschild solution, and then
you generate things like the event horizon and so forth, right?
This point of view of point mass and so on,
of course, I find it not realistic.
I mean, you know, the way we think about the black hole,
and I'm more interested in the exterior of the black hole,
so you have the black hole is separated.
It has a part which looks like Minkowski space, right?
So at least far away from the black hole.
It looks like Minkowski space,
but as you approach the black hole, if you are unlucky
to go in the direction of the black hole at some point,
you pass the event horizon.
So the event horizon is a mathematical boundary between
the visible part, let's say the Minkowskian
part in which
We live, we believe, right?
And the part which is in the black hole.
and of course as you pass the event horizon,
nothing happens.
You don't even know.
It's like passing the South Pole,
which I've done many times.
But once you are in, that's it.
You can never come out.
And then at some point,
there will be a singularity.
That kind of, the issue of that singularity
is more murky.
So the visible part of the black hole
is sort of seeing that.
You know, it makes sense astrophysically,
it makes sense mathematically, it makes sense astrophysically.
The part inside is pure mathematics now, right? Because we really...
You know, we cannot go there.
We cannot access it.
Right.
We cannot access it.
So if you accept that the Einstein equations are correct
and that you have these exact solutions of the Einstein equations,
then you can speculate what happens inside the black hole.
And one thing that you can easily see mathematically,
you can see that at some point there will be a singularity.
That singularity is, you cannot describe it as a point.
It's not a point singularity.
It's more like a space-like fact if you draw it geometrically.
I mean, you have to be very careful.
Once you are...
In this kind of extreme regimes,
you have to be very careful with your geometric description.
So, in reality, it's a space like hypersurface, right?
So, that corresponds to, I don't know,
r equals zero, let's say, in coordinates,
let's say, t, r, t dot phi, which are called the
So, in those coordinates, r equals zero,
the curvature becomes infinite.
So, obviously, something terrible has happened, right?
The problem with general relativity,
which is something that really bothered Einstein, I think,
Einstein had problems with it also, but many people had,
is that it's coordinate-dependent, right?
So, any kind of description, if you want to describe a solution,
you have to pick up some coordinate system.
But the coordinate system itself...
Can create problems, right?
Right.
Yeah, the Kruskal coordinates.
The Kruskal coordinates, for example.
That's the best example, right?
So, it took people, I don't know, 40 years.
Might be more, I mean.
In 1965, yeah.
It took 50 years to actually understand.
I'm sorry, it was bothered.
I remember that he was in Paris, actually,
where people were asking him about it,
and he looked very defensive.
They had a lot of issues with this.
Right.
So, there...
That's why I'm saying, so coordinates,
the geometric description is very much coordinate.
If you want to visualize things,
you have to pick up a coordinate system.
That's right.
And then you...
And then that's implicitly...
Philosophically, at least, committing, you know, hate crime against
the notion that all the laws should be coordinate invariant, right?
So, you'd like to think so, but in the universe as a whole,
you can't create such coordinates, right?
It's cosmology, there's no such thing, right?
And there is, I mean, God doesn't know about coordinates, right?
You could say, but we as humans, in order to solve a problem
that has to do with general relativity, we actually have to.
Look at the coordinates, right?
So, for example, the stability, both the stability of Minkowski
and even more stability of Schwarzschild
and Kerr, the coordinates play a fundamental role.
In the proof, the coordinates play,
the choice of coordinates play a fundamental role.
You couldn't do anything without them.
In fact, actually, I would say that maybe
the principal role, I would say, almost, I
mean, there are many things that go into the proof,
but one of the fundamental issues is
a problem of gauge.
Your description of stability is based on a choice.
of a gauge condition or a coordinate condition.
And there's no unique way to measure it?
That's highly non-trivial because you cannot impose it.
No, actually any proof presumably will have this issue.
You cannot impose it from the initial conditions.
You cannot say what the correct coordinate system should be.
You should be. You really have to.
You also find it dynamically, right?
As you solve the problem for long,
you have to solve the problem for a long time,
infinite time.
You, at the same time as solving for the solution
of the Einstein equation, you actually solve for the
gauge in which the solution is described.
That's what makes it very hard.
It's not that you choose the gauge
and then that enforces the form of the solution?
It's that the gauge will change?
The choice is dynamical itself.
In other words, you constantly change the gauge as you evolve.
So that's unlike any other approach.
I mean, in particle physics and electromagnetism,
you have one, you know, you'll choose a gauge,
you'll choose Newtonian, you'll choose whatever,
you don't, you don't continually dynamically change it.
So that's unique. That's at least
as far as I understand, I'm not an expert, but...
There's a modulation theory that people have used
also in describing as a kind of nonlinear equation.
I mean, it's a nonlinear fact. In
linear theory, you don't have to worry about,
I mean, you choose a gauge and you stay with it.
But for some nonlinear problems,
if you want to describe some non-trivial solutions,
you have to also do some modulation, which means sort of picking up
the correct mathematical description of the solution.
The solution usually depends on some parameters.
coordinates and so on. In this case, coordinates.
In other cases, it depends on other things.
In that case, you also have to find the solution
to get the correct modulation to describe.
But this was done usually for equations which are much,
much simpler than the Einstein equations.
Let's just hold it right there.
The choices are finite-dimensional. In the Einstein equations,
the gauge condition is infinite-dimensional.
So it's a fully coordinated...
The full diffeomorphism group, right, that means it's a monster.
You perturb this, as you perturb spacetime,
you send in gravitational radiation, you send,
you look at its behavior, its stability in space.
What if you sent in other excitations,
electromagnetic, gauge, you know, U(1) project?
So you, so that would be now, right,
so when you talk about stability of Kerr, right?
Stability.
That's the next level.
When you are talking about
the Einstein equations in vacuum, right? If you,
you can talk about Einstein equations coupled with,
say, Maxwell field, and then you have the
Kerr-Newman, instead of Kerr,
you have the Kerr-Newman problem, which, you know, it's
another problem where you would like to prove stability.
There's been some progress, but there is no yet a solution.
Like say, my solution is Jeremy Seftal and...
Alina Georgi and another student of, there are five papers.
I mean, anyway, it's a long project.
But the ideas from that one can, of course,
be used also for the case of the Kerr-Newman solution.
But you talked about, you know, these problems,
these problems of ghosts or artifacts.
What does that mean in an mathematician and a solution?
Is it what, you know, Einstein was saying, you know, the kind of,
you know, subtle is the Lord, but he's not malicious?
You know, what is a ghost? What is an anomaly?
What are these things?
Einstein used it as sort of a metaphor.
For instability, right?
So, you know, in that case, again, let's go back to stability of Kerr.
You have an exact solution of the Einstein equations in vacuum, right?
I mean, so mathematically, if you accept
Mathematicians always accept something, right?
I mean, it's always in the context of some system of axioms.
In this case, the axiom would
be that you accept the Einstein equations,
and therefore we are in the realm of general relativity.
Yes.
Right?
Classical general relativity.
We don't talk about quantum.
Right.
We talk about classical general relativity.
So in that context, you solve the Einstein equations,
you find an exact solution, which is the Kerr solution.
So it's exclusive.
This is for, as you say, it's a rotating massive black hole.
It's a stationary black hole, which you can write down explicitly.
You can check, right, either by hand, or you can use AI nowadays.
You can check that it's indeed a solution, exact solution.
So there is no issue.
The mathematical reality of the Kerr solution is uncontestable, right?
Okay.
But it comes up the question, is it physically relevant?
Yes.
So, my metaphor about that is that somehow,
If it's unstable, mathematically,
in other words, relative to small perturbations,
it disappears. Then it's like a ghost.
It's a physical ghost that doesn't have any
manifestation. It doesn't have manifestations,
right? So that would be the...
So let's talk about the Kerr black holes,
because it's going to dovetail into a conversation I had
when Juan Maldacena, your, you know,
fellow Princeton dweller, was sitting in that chair.
And it has to do with wormholes
and sort of the work that he's done, which does branch,
you know, away from, I would say,
what a physicist would call real or important even.
So talk about wormholes.
Let's stop there for a second. To build a wormhole,
It seems almost impossible.
It seems actually logically contradictory.
Even though they appear in movies,
and my friend Kip Thorne won the Nobel Prize
for his work with black holes,
but he's the one who popularized it for movies
like Contact and Interstellar.
So tell me, is a wormhole...
Not just possible, I mean, of course things are possible,
we go into the impossible here,
but is it a real object in the sense
that a black hole could be considered, whatever extent you
consider a black hole real, is a wormhole?
Because to build a wormhole, you need to build
multiple black holes, you need to sort of have them
be traversable, you need to have them be
stable, you need to have them emit, you know,
certain dynamical properties. But you can think
of a unicorn also, right? So just
because you can think of it doesn't mean it exists. So what's
What's your opinion on wormholes?
Are they...
Constructed out of Kerr black holes.
I mean, are these even possible?
You know, from my understanding,
is that they are extremely unstable, right?
So there are probably zillions of solutions
of the Einstein equations that are unstable,
mathematically unstable.
But of course, I think,
so in the context of what I said before,
classical general relativity,
they are clearly unstable as far as I can see, right?
So you can construct a solution.
I mean, even Gödel constructed some cases.
Rotating, ascending universe, right?
Clearly, it's unstable.
In other words, if you want to understand dynamically,
in the context of the dynamics of general theory,
it's clearly unstable, right? So,
So it's in.
classically, it doesn't make any sense.
Now, I think what Madhavendra would be saying is that
But quantum mechanically, they do make sense
and they are useful quantum mechanically, but of course
it's way beyond my grade.
I mean, I can't say anything about what he really wants to do
It's a good one.
quantum mechanically. I mean, I, you know, quantum mechanics is very,
it's not that I would be, if I had another life,
maybe I would be, but unfortunately,
you know, we are all limited in terms of what we can do.
Yeah. What does your taste say?
That makes a problem interesting to Sergio Kleinermann versus me,
Brian Key, an experimental physicist.
When do you get interested in a problem?
The part of mathematics that I think is interesting is the one
that has something to do with the physical world, right?
It's maybe a shadow of the physical world.
There's some complicated,
intimate relationship with the physical world.
I mean, I think all beautiful mathematics started like this.
I mean, even, say, numbers or geometry, right?
They all start from numbers and shapes, which are physical.
I mean, physical numbers, of course,
are abstractizations of physical things.
One, two, three, right?
And shapes are also there.
There's no triangle.
Give me a triangle. You can't do it.
Right. No, but geometry started, however,
with this need somehow to describe things which are physical.
But then it went to different levels and good.
mathematics started to follow its own logic
and you know you can start up with triangles
and circles and so on which have some connections
with the physical world but then of course
mathematics takes over and you know after a thousand years or more
you get to Riemannian geometry and then Lorentzian, Minkowski
All of a sudden, it has an enormous impact.
So what I want you to say is that, on one hand, I like the kind of
mathematics that has its origins in the physical world, but I also like
the freedom of mathematics to follow its own logic and its own path.
Hey, do me a favor. I know you're enjoying this on YouTube,
but make sure you follow me on Spotify, too, and leave a review.
That helps out more than I can tell you.
But you're not immune to it either. I mean, looking at your career,
it would seem to me I could predict with almost...
You know, a hundred percent certainty what you're going
to work on next, because there's
these unanswered questions from the real physical universe.
I'll just tell you, I think maximal black holes,
I think extremal black holes, and Kerr
black holes.
You haven't done that yet.
I mean, you've done an incredible job on that.
I'm like, that's it.
You've got it.
You did it for slow rotating black holes.
So explain why it's natural, not just because,
well, fast is better than slow, but why are
extremal black holes kind of the final, you know,
the event horizon of black hole stability
theories?
I mean, I think they're stable to start with.
The physics like them, yeah
Well, they seem to be relevant.
They seem to power black holes, jets,
accretion disks, quasars, and so forth.
Not truly maximal.
I don't know if truly maximal black holes can even exist, but-
Oh, close.
Close, close, yeah.
Oh, yeah.
No, large angular
Yeah, this is one of the major problems
that many people are still working on, right?
It's a stability of Kerr for large a.
So in principle, you could go all the way
to what is called the sub-extremal Kerr, right?
And your theory would still hold.
Your proof would still hold.
I think there's been a lot of progress.
My former collaborator, Jeremy Seftel,
has done some recent work which indicates that
the problem would be solved in a way
that you could prove the stability for.
The sub-extreme on E.
In classical mechanics, we have the notion of the Poisson bracket.
We can make a Poisson bracket,
we can take the conjugate variables, momentum and position,
and then we can form, you know, mixed partial differential,
you know, kind of relations between them.
And we get Lagrangians, and we get
Hamiltonians, and we get their dynamics.
And if you do that, in classical mechanics,
it works out and you get equations of motion.
And you can't do it in quantum mechanics without adding
the square root of negative one.
And it's just so bizarre to me that adding
in the square root of negative one,
now you get the Heisenberg equations, you get quantum mechanics.
Why should that be?
And then if that's true, Sergio, are there other levels of abstraction,
analogs of the square root of negative one,
quaternions, octonions, sedenions, or whatever comes beyond them?
Are they all manifest?
In other words, are all mathematical
objects manifest in the physical world?
I don't know if it actually is.
an essay about this,
which,
to which is big, so yeah,
so,
yeah,
we're doing it,
which I don't have a solution
of the bigness mystery,
as I say,
in the essay,
but I try to somehow
understand it on my own terms.
So,
one conclusion
that I got,
sort of reflecting on these things,
is that what we call,
concerning what we call reality,
what is reality,
right?
I mean,
you know,
you can start with things
that you can see,
touch,
and hear,
and you can share information
about it,
right?
I can see these flowers,
you,
So there is direct objectivity associated with it,
which is given by the senses.
So we call that real, right?
But then you go further, and you start talking about things
that are far away, and you need a telescope to see them,
or black holes, which are not even
bright. I mean, you're so clear.
You have very little direct information, or microscope and so
on. So those that we consider real also, why?
Because they are consistent.
With everything else that we started with,
so it's like cutting sort of circles of reality.
You have the first circle, which is the most direct,
connected with our senses.
Right.
And then the next one, which is...
further away, and it's all direct already,
but you can relate to a microscope.
It's reliability. You're bringing up an excellent point,
that when you have something that is
trustworthy, to an experimentalist,
it's always subject to falsification. But we don't have
Gödel in physics. We don't have an incompleteness theorem.
The best we have is falsification,
which means the violation of reliability, doesn't it?
That's exactly my point. So my point is that there
are these circles of realities which are
I'm further and further removed from...
The center, they're connected by, as you say,
reliability or consistency or what I call objectivity.
As they go further and further away,
they become more and more mathematical.
I mean, you know, surprise, surprise.
I mean, the...
More abstract.
They become more abstract.
Now, mathematics, okay, so this is on one hand.
On the other hand, mathematics is also very objective, right?
That we deal with things which, again, are very consistent.
Yeah.
So, do I have any right not to call them real?
Right.
You don't have concepts.
Real numbers, imaginary numbers, rational numbers.
And then mathematics develops in this very strange way, right?
I mean, it starts with numbers, and they...
you know, basic properties of numbers,
commutativity, associativity, and so on and so forth.
Then somehow for me algebra comes out,
equations, and then, you know,
we start solving equations,
and you get the i at some point.
The mathematics evolves through this.
But this...
It starts again from basic objects
like numbers and shapes,
but it builds up levels of...
I mean, these concepts, which seem apparently very far away,
I mean, you know, we talk about
an equation, I mean, where does an equation,
it seems like something very abstract, it
has nothing to do with something that we see.
Not to speak about the Einstein equation.
No, it's true.
E equals mc squared, even simpler.
But Pythagorean theorem seems much more real
than any physics equation, right?
Even though we can't touch a triangle.
Hand me a triangle, you can't do it.
You can think of it only in your mind,
which maybe segues to the next point,
which I want to talk about AI and computation.
Yeah, but just to finish this,
so anyway, for me, mathematics is real.
Not any kind of mathematics is directly connected
to the physical world.
Some people say that everything that is consistent
Mathematically,
Right.
It has physical significance.
Right.
I'm not going to go so far.
But everything that has developed naturally,
starting from the basic physical objects through,
I don't know, through the natural developments of mathematics, which…
I talk about it in this essay.
It's a clear idea about how, I mean, I should say clear,
but I have some idea about how this,
how this works out. So that's, that's,
that's the kind of mathematics that
It should not surprise us that it has a huge impact back into physics.
But it does shock one when you think that you're using Fourier's,
you know, theorems that he described originally to describe, you know,
heat flow in a metal plate in 1800, 1820, whenever he was working.
And then you're sending Fourier modes into a black hole.
I mean, that's kind of shocking that these things couldn't
be more removed on a physical scale,
and yet they have identical pedigree mathematically.
It is shocking, and I don't think anyone can really—I mean,
Wigner didn't answer it either, right?
The thing that doesn't answer, and actually he makes
a lot of opinion mistakes that many physicists make,
which is to claim that somehow mathematics has come up
with an invention of the human mind.
He says it very clearly. He says it
when he tries to completely reject it.
It's not an invention, it's discovery.
I mean, mathematics is discovered, right?
It's just like a physical.
World discoveries, we also, you know, mathematical discovery.
Let's talk about, you know, how we know what we know.
In the case of these proofs, some of which, you know,
are in excess of, you know, 500, 800 pages.
And it's not uncommon in mathematics.
I mean, first of all, it reminds me of what Einstein said, you know,
when they made the 1919 eclipse expedition, the Eddington expedition,
to see if the sun's mass bent rays of light from distant stars.
And, of course, he confirmed it.
And, and Einstein was asked, well,
what would you have done if they couldn't confirm it?
He said, well, I would have felt sorry for God because.
On the other hand, you know, four years earlier, he was wrong.
He had the factor of two wrong.
So it was a good thing that the eclipse
of 1914 was eclipsed by war in the Crimea.
Just a quick interruption from today's sponsor, me, Brian Keating.
Since it's Nobel Prize season,
I can't resist advertising my three books.
First book I wrote is called Losing the Nobel Prize.
It's a cosmology story mixed with a memoir of what it feels like
to do science at the highest level and, spoiler alert, fail.
But my next book, Think Like a Nobel Prize Winner,
tells the story of nine Nobel laureates
who will reveal their insights and actions,
how to take your science or just your job in general
to the next level.
It's full of insights and tips
that I never would have thought of.
And lastly, my book published last year,
Focus Like a Nobel Prize Winner,
is written for students of all ages
to learn the tools and the tricks
to compete with yourself,
which sometimes can be the hardest competitor of all.
Get all three of them, Amazon affiliate links,
in the description below.
And if you've read them already, I'd love it if you leave a review.
Every single review helps.
Now back to the episode.
But tell me, Sujit, when you look at this,
who could possibly check the proof?
And how is that possible?
And was that sort of the last human-checked proof of that magnitude?
Or are we just going to lean?
We'll talk about AI proof-checking, but who could referee such things?
Yeah, okay, so it's a long paper because...
For many reasons, in particular,
because we wanted to be very thorough, and complete,
right, without, I mean, many papers refer to other papers,
results from other papers. Essentially,
you can read the whole paper from beginning to the end,
it's completely self-contained,
so that's one thing. And also, we try to...
Put all the calculations, I mean, again, many papers,
people don't really put the calculations,
right? I mean, you just write down the conclusions.
So anyway, we want it to be very complete. That's
one thing. The second is that these proofs are very conceptual.
The only reason you can do a
proof like this is because it's very conceptual, right?
You can split it into various parts. Now,
Now, this is a non-linear.
Einstein equations are nonlinear,
which means that every part influences
Another part, in some ways, where you have to develop
a language of how to put these pieces together.
But it's very conceptual. I mean, at the end of the day,
it's very conceptual. That's the second answer.
The third answer is that many of these long proofs,
if a result is important, then the proof will
simplify in two ways. I mean, first of all,
some of the things that are used in the proof will become
standardized, right? So they are part of the field, right?
student that works in that field would have to know.
So in that sense it's
A paper later on would be simplified and instead of having 2,000 pages,
we'll have only 400 pages, right?
Which is what I expect to happen.
So this is, I mean, so that's my answer.
I mean, things to simplify in many, many ways.
But if the result is important, people will try to simplify,
will try to go beyond, right?
I mean, other people will take over and do something else
with the methods which we've used.
And that's how in time is, I mean,
It's the best way for something to be verified.
In the short run, I mean, if you are asking
how the paper was accepted,
obviously a lot of people looked at it.
Different people read different things.
In the future, it will become much easier,
as you say, because of AI.
I mean, I think AI is going to presumably be very good.
Maybe not to deal with the whole proof,
but let's say somebody who wants to check the proof
would ask AI to check.
First of all, we'll have to have some idea about the whole,
and then if that person would
be unsure about one thing or another, we'll ask AI to help.
So I think AI is fantastic from this point of view.
I think it would be a great...
What's the most complex proof that AI has reproduced?
Because we hear a lot about these Erdos problems.
I was pouring your coffee earlier and I said,
you know, we have to pay homage to Erdos.
You do fewer amphetamines than he did.
You know, he said to Ron Graham, who is my colleague here,
as you know, when Ron asked him to give up.
Taking amphetamines for a month that he did it.
And then he collected the $500 bet and told him,
Ron, you set back mathematics for one
month.
So you don't use math, but other mathematicians have.
But you like coffee.
But we hear about the Erdos problems falling every day now from,
you know, different models.
But to my knowledge, I talked to Terry Tao,
as you know, you gave me a couple of hints,
questions, and me prepped for that interview last year.
You know, he told me that it can't,
quote unquote, even do things like reproduce.
Andrew Wiles, you know, proof of Fermat's last theorem.
That's not something simple.
But what is the most, I mean, can it do the piano?
It can or it cannot?
It cannot.
He said it cannot.
I mean, if you know if it's changed since then,
it could have with the progress rate that's happening.
But tell me, what is sort
of the most impressive just reproduction of like the piano axiom?
What has it done that is, you know, beyond like helping you like
a good graduate student can help you, I'm sure.
And you must have brilliant ones.
But tell me, like, can it reproduce things?
We call, in the art world, it's called copywork.
Like, before you want to be the next Picasso,
show me you could paint everything he did
or Rembrandt or whatever.
Don't just start off with, I'm the great,
and we both know mathematicians
that think that they have theories of everything.
And before you do that,
show me that you can reproduce it.
And I don't know, is there anything that AI can do
that just straight up reproduce a proof
that a genius mathematician or, you know,
not prove the Riemann hypothesis,
but prove some things that have been landmark proofs
in mathematics without human intervention?
I mean, I would argue that that's...
Probably not possible, I mean, you know,
Peter Sarnak is my colleague, he has this,
called it alpha zero test, he calls it, which is,
so he connects this with chess. So, you know,
there are two ways now to automatize chess.
There is a procedure which is based on creating large
libraries of work.
Openings, that AI knows and is going to use.
And of course, it's so fast that it will beat everybody.
But then there is this AlphaZero model
that starts from nothing, right?
So you just give it the rules,
and then it starts playing by itself.
And then after a while, it beats everybody.
In fact, it beats even the best computers,
apparently, from what I understand.
So then this AlphaZero test is,
Can you give a...
To AI, give it just the Peano axioms, let's say,
and then develop whatever, you know,
whatever masqueradics.
I mean, that's the way AI do it.
Most probably not.
I mean, I have reasons to think, you know,
AI intelligence is remarkable,
as remarkable as it is.
I mean, it is impressive.
I mean, I'm using it more and more also myself.
And it's just pretty stunning what it can do.
But still, it's not.
I mean, to claim that somehow LLMs are at the same level
as what happens in the human mind,
it seems to me a huge stretch.
Yeah, I'm trying to do what I call the Einstein test.
If you take LLM now, if you take Claude or...
You know, OpenAI or whatever, and you say, you know,
tell me about the multiverse, or tell me about this and that.
It knows so much, not just from, you know,
the physics, but also from the culture.
In other words, there's movies about
wormholes, like we just talked about.
There's movies about, you know,
even Hawking and Hawking radiation, right?
So you can't even trust the training data,
which is a large fraction of what makes these things unique.
So we tried asking the following quote.
What if you gave an LLM a lobotomy?
What if you took everything about the physical world,
just trained it on stuff before 1900?
Could it come up with quantum mechanics and relativity?
And of course, there are other people working on this,
and there are people that have actually made these LLMs
and actually denatured them, denuded them of any...
Pop culture references after 1930,
but that's even too late for quantum mechanics, right?
And relativity.
And it really, we tried to do it with just giving it data
from the planet Mercury and just its orbital history
over thousands of years that JPL has.
And it gave us back, you know, it couldn't derive,
you know, the Riemann curvature,
couldn't derive the Ricci tensor.
What it gave us back is this very discretized,
you know, hyper fine resolution.
And it matched the planet, but it was just copying.
It was just mimicking it.
And I think until that's passed, I'm not going to be, because
you know what Einstein said was the happiest moment of his life,
was that in free fall, I wouldn't feel any gravitational field.
So that led to the Einstein.
That's the kind of, exactly.
How does it, that's the point,
you know, I wrote another thing to tabulate.
It's tabulate, yeah, I want to talk about that.
Thinking in the, yeah.
And that's exactly my, so I have,
I made various points about the fact that, you know.
AI, I could very well imagine that AI can do all sorts of things,
but it doesn't change
itself, right?
Yes.
You know, humans are able somehow to design something new.
I mean, can it design another version
of itself based on different principles?
Like, for example, when we invented the, you know, flying, right?
I mean, it was...
You know, an invention that completely changed the world.
I mean, you cannot say that it was continuous
of something else.
Or the same thing with Kepler's laws, for example, right?
You could imagine, based on periodic approximation,
the epicycles.
Epicycles, yeah.
So these epicycles, you could approximate everything.
Perfect, yeah.
It was better, you know.
Epicycles, you could approximate absolutely everything, right?
You say, but would you discover Newton's, you know,
Kepler's laws, and even more important,
Newton's laws, and Einstein's laws?
Come on, I mean, give me a break.
Am I right?
It's just not even close based on what we know so far.
And also you can go to more specific things.
Like, for example, it's pretty clear that our thoughts,
I'm not talking about all thoughts, but yeah.
But the one that matter, predate the language, right?
We have an intuition about something
and then we find the words to explain it.
Right.
It's like a proto-language, right?
I mean, that's something that AI doesn't have.
I mean, AI is completely based on guessing the next word,
the next token.
In other words, it's completely based on words.
Yeah.
Language, yeah.
Or language, right?
But as I said, I mean, I think our thoughts
are predate the language, right?
We have intuitions about things,
We have a physical embodied motion, like Einstein falling in space,
he doesn't, I don't have to tell, I can't describe that to you,
but you know exactly what it feels like to go on a roller coaster
or fall in love and whatever.
It's like his embodiment, right? Embodiment problem is huge.
I mean, how, you know, it's like, well, maybe we blow a capacitor,
you know, in the computer when it gets the wrong answer,
you know, how do you train it to have pain or loss or poignancy?
What does that even mean?
And then these absurd notions that people are having,
including very smart people, right?
They claim that somehow...
You know, we passed the event horizon of the...
Yeah, the singularity, they call it, yeah.
You are going to the singularity.
The AI is going to become more intelligent than everybody
and it's going to reproduce itself at a huge speed
and then kill us off.
I mean, it's just absurd.
It's ridiculous.
I mean, even this business was killing ourselves.
We can stop it in every moment.
I mean, if it becomes dangerous, we can stop it.
We can destroy it.
We could, you know, we just...
We just stopped the internet, and that's it.
Exactly.
And another thing, I always joke,
what's the first thing you do every morning that you use AI?
Push here to update to version 1.974,
and then you go to cloud, push the update to 4.32.
Every single day they're updating,
they're responding to attacks.
If there was, it's kind of like the grandfather paradox.
You know, if a time machine was possible,
you could go back and kill your grandfather,
which would prevent you from inventing a time machine.
Here, let's assume artificial super intelligence,
you know, the most powerful intelligence
that will ever be made.
It wouldn't make itself.
It wouldn't allow itself to be made
because the next thing after it,
version 1.9,
is going to be more powerful than it.
Turn it off.
And so, yeah,
I think these things are overblown,
but they do have a very important purpose.
Oh, no, certainly.
No, no, no.
The purpose is to generate revenue
for these closed model AI laboratories,
But they also scare everybody.
They scare everybody to get more money
so the government will protect them
as a national resource,
like uranium stockpiles.
No, but the problem is
lots of people are calling
for the destruction of data centers...
That's a separate issue, I think, yeah.
I mean, I think Musk has it very, very far, I think.
Yeah.
But does Musk really believe?
Well, if he does want to build, I mean, he changes his mind,
yeah, more frequently than my toddlers. But, you know,
it went from going to Mars, then it was going to the moon, now it's
not important anymore because we can have AI reproduce everything.
But sticking with, you know, kind of this thought about,
you know, where does humanity come in?
Your tablet essay, I think it does stress the kind of uniqueness
of humanity, but it's not something like, you know, Pollyanna,
you know, everything's going to be okay, everything's wonderful.
No, I mean, I think there's huge benefits, and you and I know.
How powerful it is and how fast science can change.
I guess we don't have that much time.
We both have other things to do later on today.
But I do want to talk about being
a professor nowadays in the age of AI.
Is it really worth being?
I mean, do students need to pay?
What is your tuition?
$70,000?
I mean, our out-of-state tuition is about that now.
I think Princeton's about that one of the highest levels.
But with all these tools, with all these wonderful things,
with self-teaching, with all the available things on the Internet,
including conversations with you and your writing
and the podcast and stuff that you do and I do.
Do we need to pay $70,000?
What are you really getting for your money?
No, no, of course.
I think it's ridiculous.
I'm in the university.
How would you restructure Princeton?
I mean, if you were, you know, I used to be more optimistic.
That's how I got more involved in reform.
I'm actually quite pessimistic that universities can be reformed,
except by creating new universities,
I mean, creating completely new institutions
that will have to compete with these other
ones.
I mean, science is not so bad, of course,
but I'm a firm believer that a good education
should involve also humanities and social sciences.
I don't think you can be a good scientist without sort
of a firm foundation.
You have at least some understanding of basic philosophical issues.
Anyway, so, yeah, I mean, to be a good scientist,
you also have to have a broad view.
Yeah, I said Galileo was one of the best writers,
period, you know, in human history.
And he happens to be, you know, a scientist as well.
Einstein was phenomenal.
Newton wasn't quite as good.
I mean, he's much more dry, I think, Newton.
You know, in terms of university, politics and so forth, I mean...
When you and I started university, you're older than me,
but when you started university, it was very different.
I mean, it was sort of the best job I could possibly imagine.
And nowadays, I don't know if I could advise
my children to become a professor, an academician.
It's not necessarily only the life of the mind anymore.
It's become so much more.
You know, I want to give you credit for inspiring me personally,
but also doing incredible work as a citizen, but also a scientist.
Speaking out on behalf of people that you don't agree with.
I mean, you're unique in that you,
I don't know if I have the same courage as you or
maybe the same intellectual honesty.
After October 7th, you said that like the protest,
the students should have a right
to protest and the anti-Israel, you know,
factions on campus were very vocal there.
And here, I mean, we had an encampment here
that lasted, you know, a couple of days and
I testified in Congress about how evil
and destructive and anti-intellectual it was.
But you wrote that they should have a right to protest,
but it should have limitations.
Let's talk about, what is your view
on students participating in protests?
I agree, they should. Students should.
I get concerned
when I see my colleagues doing it for different reasons.
But where do you fall?
What rights should students have to kind of advocate as they did,
that your university is racist or it should be more pro-Palestinian?
What level of impact do you seek to have in these debates?
You know, on one hand, yeah, I mean, it is the...
Freedom of thought is extremely important.
On the other hand, what do you do in a situation
where universities have become so unbalanced
in terms of what is being taught,
what is being accepted?
That, uh...
Kids really becoming more and more expressing radical ideas,
anti-American ideas.
I think the universities have lost
their ability to frame what their mission is.
I mean, they are completely confused about
their mission is to find the truth and to educate
I'm trying to educate the...
the kids in the best that Western civilization
or the world civilization has to offer.
None of this is true anymore.
I mean, kids are educated all sorts of crazy things.
about human nature lie.
I mean, truth doesn't seem to matter.
Ta-ra.
There is a lot of relativism,
a lot of political advocacy
for certain causes
which the left considers sacrosanct, right?
I mean...
Equity, diversity, inclusion.
I think this business with Israel, it's just ridiculous, right?
Singling out one country versus the hundreds of others.
Do you like me?
Huge deal about the situations where Israel was attacked, right?
By, you know, more than two, you know,
or Iran essentially surrounding Israel
by factions that really want to destroy it.
Anyway, it's, yeah, I have a huge problem.
I don't know where I am.
I do think that this is probably going to happen,
that universities will become more and more,
I mean, the university that we have today
will become more and more irrelevant.
Another thing that really bothers me
is that you would think that in a capitalist system
like the United States,
that if a university goes very much on the left,
then there will be another one that wants.
We get an advantage, right?
We get an advantage by going the other way, right?
Because it just doesn't happen.
I mean, how do you explain that?
How do you explain that all universities go in the same one direction?
Yeah, you're seeing it with capitalism.
You're seeing it in like Palantir
and you're seeing it in corporations that will, you know,
take the people that were, you know,
too unwoke for Google and hire them.
And there are also some of the people
that are supporting new institutions.
But yeah, I'm also pretty pessimistic.
The thing that made me most pessimistic,
I thought COVID would be the end of the current university system.
Going through that, charging the exact same tuition
for Zoom lectures that you could, you know,
basically get online for free from past years.
The fact that it was so resilient to that kind of just horrible product
delivery and service provided for the vast amount of money that it...
I mean, the amount of tuition that's being raised
at all of our colleges vastly dwarfs it,
and then the debt you take on can't be discharged in bankruptcy.
It's a cartel. I mean, basically,
we in the university system operate in a cartel system.
No, I think there's a lot that's troubling about the university system.
And like I said, I don't know if I'd—
I don't want to return to this life.
You know, there are other things you could be doing.
There are other things I could be doing.
But let's assume that there's a 19-year-old,
maybe not in Bucharest like you were in 1969,
but let's say there is some young person.
Maybe they're living in a slightly repressed, you know, state.
I like to ask the following question.
You know, what would you tell
that 19-year-old version of yourself to do
to give him the courage to do what you did,
to go into the impossible, the namesake of this podcast?
You have 20, you know, 20, 19 seconds
with a 19-year-old Sergio Klonderman.
What do you tell him?
Would you change anything?
In science, it's still the best place to go,
to go to the top universities.
I mean, it's still true, right?
I mean, it's true in astrophysics.
Even though, even there, you can see...
Signs of decline, right?
But if it comes to something else,
I mean, if you really want to do humanities
or social sciences,
I presume you have to do it on your own.
I say no advantage to go to university.
You can read the best books.
Now you have AI.
AI will direct you.
And the same thing with school, right?
I mean, even more radical, right?
What do you do with the kids?
Do you have kids?
Should you send them to school?
Or I don't know, maybe frame some kind of...
I think it's both.
I think you have to do both.
You have to socialize them.
They have to network.
They have to understand how to interact
and maybe do sports or athletics or arts.
And then there's stuff that, yeah,
I'm not going to let them, you know,
only learn in a public school, you know,
the basic mathematics.
You know, one of my kids is, you know,
taking advanced calculus now
and he's not even able to drive.
So, you know, but that's on us.
But all the great scientists,
they learn by themselves.
They're autodidactic, yeah.
The same thing with art,
the great artists.
I don't know,
maybe AI will help us
to go back to situations
where people have
personalized tutoring
and personalized things.
I think that's a wonderful thing
and it's a good place to stop.
And I just want to thank you again
for being the scientist you are,
the citizen that you are,
and the citizen scientist.
Those always don't go together.
And I think it's rare
and it's refreshing
that you take all these roles so seriously.
And that you're not afraid to go after these,
you know, monstrous, challenging, difficult problems.
And it just seems like you have no bounds,
no limits to what you're willing to take on.
I think that's a sign of your courage.
So, Sergio Claverman, thank you so much.
From Romania to the heights of academia and beyond.
Thank you for coming on the show.
Thank you. Thank you very much.
Sergio just told us that wormholes
don't survive Einstein's own equations
and that the AI apocalypse is, quite frankly, absurd.
If that changes how you think about what's real in physics, subscribe.
Turn on notifications and tell me in the comments
whether you think an unstable solution counts
as physics or only mathematics.
And for the man who put wormholes into the
movies, here's my conversation with Nobel
Laureate Kip Thorne, the man who worked
on Interstellar with none other than Christopher
Nolan.
Link right here.
Thanks for watching.