Philly City Council questions child welfare leadership after Malayshia Allford’s murder

Fox - Fox 29
15 followers
4 Video Views·Nov 21, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedPhiladelphia City Council held a hearing to investigate the systemic failures that led to the murder of 10-year-old Malaysia Alford by her foster mother. The session focused on the Department of Human Services' (DHS) lack of oversight and the failure of child welfare protections, with council members demanding accountability and leadership changes to prevent future tragedies.
A heartbreaking case is raising big questions about
who is watching out for Philadelphia's most vulnerable children
and today Philadelphia City leaders are looking for answers.
This is the news at six. I'm Dawn Timoney.
Philadelphia City Council members convening a hearing
to examine how 10 year old Malaysia Alford fell through the cracks
of the child welfare system. The young girl allegedly murdered.
By her foster mother.
Our Jennifer Lee is live at Philadelphia City Hall
with a look at what happened today.
Jen, who was on the hot seat?
Well, the commissioner of the Department of Human Services was up first
and council questioned her for about four hours.
And council members,
they grilled her about DHS's practices and failures.
Could we be here talking about
the horrific circumstances that DHS put her in?
I want to state plainly
that Malaysia's
life matters.
Commissioner Kimberly Ali of the Philadelphia Department
of Human Services in the hot seat for several hours
as city council members grilled her and her team about DHS's roles,
responsibilities, and failures.
What we did in the past apparently got us to this point that we are
here right now with the death of a child that should not have happened.
Ali says her department does not have access to a state database
called Resource Family Registry, which tracks foster parents.
She believes having access would provide DHS
with another cross-reference for child safety.
It seems like a lot of passing the buck,
passing the blame, in my opinion.
Saying Pennsylvania DHS is really
the responsible party as to how we got to this moment.
I just don't believe it. I don't buy it.
And I think that ultimately we are the responsible parties.
Currently, Community Umbrella Agencies, or CUAS, are contracted
by DHS to provide case management services for a child and family.
Councilmember Bass wants to redirect all of that back to DHS while
substantially increasing funding to keep children with their families.
Commissioner Ali was defensive,
saying DHS has made improvements under the current structure,
noting in 2017, over 6,000 children were in foster placement,
and today it has decreased to just over 2,000 children.
It doesn't feel like a real sense of urgency.
You can't pick up the vibe in the room.
You can't pick up the vibe that other people feel.
I feel anxious about this, concerned about this, frightened about this.
There is a sense of urgency.
Let's see.
As I indicated, this case has rocked us to our core.
And we are committed to making sure
that there are lasting changes.
And I believe, based on the information and the testimony today,
I did demonstrate some of the improvements
that happened at the department.
Also in the hot seat today,
officials from the School District of Philadelphia,
because the foster mother, Caprice Williams,
was a school teacher for a fifth grade class,
and council did want to ask the district how
the district checks for clearances and background
checks when they're hiring individuals,
and also if the district is aware of investigations
when there are allegations of abuse.
Now, Council Member Bass says the accountability
The accountability doesn't end here.
She is openly calling for
They're calling for a change at the top of DHS,
saying, quote, heads have to roll.
Don.
All right.
A lot more to come on this.
Jennifer Lee, thank you.
