Phillies KNOCK OFF Braves To Advance To 2nd Straight NLCS I CBS Sports

CBS Sports News
1 follower
2 Video Views·Oct 13, 2023
Get some instant analysis welcome in former MLB executive of the year Jim Bowden CBS Sports MLB writer Matt Snyder
We said before the series that we would not be surprised if the Phillies won this series
We are not surprised now that they have completed it Jim your reaction to what you saw here in this game for Nick
Castellanos Trey Turner and an incredible bullpen
Yeah, and the fact that Nick Castellanos becomes the first player ever in baseball history to have multiple homers and back-to-back games was incredible
But I think you nailed it on the outset Rob Thompson was the player of this game not Trey Turner's
Homers by Castellanos, it was Rob Thompson and he managed with urgency. He had his matchups
He wanted to go with he had his pockets
He wanted to deal with and he wasn't afraid to bring in his top two
Relievers in the sixth and seventh inning wouldn't matter the most he wanted Alvarado to make sure he put Olsen down
He wanted to make sure he had Kimbrell in there at the most important time and look for the Atlanta Braves
They had the bases loaded the seventh inning and they had the MVP of the league at the plate
And Ronald Acuna jr. And he hits the fly ball to centerfield and it's caught out there a nice catch in centerfield
He made it look more difficult than he had to to be honest, but here's the play right here
He kind of hesitated and kind of jumped
It was really an easier catch than he made it look but that was the game right there
So Acuna had the shot bases Chuck couldn't do anything with it
But again, I love what Rob Thompson did and he wasn't afraid to have the game
But who would have thought the game would finish with Matt Strahm against bond Grissom?
So look we covered the Phillies last year in the playoffs and in the World Series and the one thing that stood out
Was the kind of human beings that are in that dugout and how competitive they are and this is a really really close
group
Reminds me a little bit of those 84 Red Sox way back when
This is a really really tough group, but there's no doubt in my mind
They're gonna be the favorites to get back to the World Series when they get ready to face, Arizona
Yeah, I actually think that they're the favorites to win at all. I would take them right now over both the Rangers and the Astros
I know that's a tough call for many because the Rangers offense look so good and the Astros
I mean, they're the Astros, you know, they're there every single year
But I need to see the odds right there. I'm riding the Phillies on that one
I there's built so much better for the postseason than the regular season with the two horses atop the rotation
Ranger Suarez
Gives you those five innings that you need as they're kind of number three
Starter with the way they want to operate in the bullpen and again as Jim said masterclass by Rob Thompson and I the power
How about the power up in the lineup? They've got Castellanos in the seven hole
You know, it's they can do it from any spot in the order at any given time
It was funny seeing the Bryce Harper get the intentional walk there in the first inning tonight before and he runs around the board
We like, you know, it's that's how good he is. It's a big playoff spot
You don't want Bryce to hurt you but they can hurt you from any spot in the lineup right now and man Trey Turner
What can you say about how hot he is right now?
He is out of his mind hot ever since that standing ovation when the Phillies fans wanted to cheer him out of his slump
It actually worked. He's been insane ever since then
What a fun team to watch and let's also point out that they completely
Controlled this series the one game that the Braves did win the Phillies led for most of that game and they were up before nothing
Going into the bottom of the six there. They still had a lead going into the bottom of the eighth in that game
They actually the Phillies almost took the lead back in the top of the ninth
It took a great play by Michael Harris to prevent that so the Phillies really controlled this thing
Basically right from the start of game one all the way through the end of this game
Braves had their chances. They just didn't get it done
I don't know how much we can lean on the rest thing when the Braves just didn't hit at all in these two games in
Philadelphia where they should have you know knocked off the rest by then I
Love that you brought up the fact about the standing ovation for Trey Turner in August signs his monster contract Nick Castellanos has said
Hey
Philly fans are gonna. Love you. Okay. You come here and play and they're gonna. Love you. They help Nick Castellanos
He got booed last season they pick him up
They do the same for Trey Turner the first Philly with four hits in a playoff game Nick Castellanos
First player as we mentioned in MLB history to hit multiple homers and back-to-back postseason games
We talked about how the Braves
Were relentless all season long the Phillies are now relentless
Because it's an unselfish club
That plays with a lot of heart a lot of emotion
And then you see because I don't want to gloss over this we mentioned it
But Jim what you saw Rob Thompson doing this game was textbook. He didn't necessarily
Look at analytics. He went to the right matchups. I mean this was a
Clinic in the postseason for Rob Thompson
I know you said he's a player of the game
But explain for people to realize how like it's great that Nick Castellanos and Trey Turner show the home runs
But this is clinic
postseason managing
Yeah, it certainly was I mean look did to bring Alvarado and Kimberlin that early
I mean that's not something he's done really in the regular season whatsoever
But he had a plan and let's give Dave
Dabrowski the president of the of the Phillies credit because he loaded up his bullpen with four left handers
They used all of them tonight
But in the right spots and they knew exactly when they wanted to match up and you know
Rob had the real good feeling when the score was 2 to 1 and 3 to 1 that hey
I better not wait to the ninth inning. I can't let this game turn
That's one of the things that Rob keeps telling me, you know
When he's making this move instead of saving Alvarado and Kimberly 8 to 9
His feeling is the game is gonna turn Atlanta has chance to do damage. I have to stop it here
I'll worry about the ninth inning when I get there and I still have other pitchers like Soto and Strom
And Hoffman that I can go to later
So just being able to get the guys he wants in the matchup at the time of the game
We need it the most and we saw Rob do it last year in the postseason. We're seeing it now
I do want to point out something is very interesting, right? Three of the four teams left standing are all wildcard teams
I will absolutely argue that the five days off has something to do with that
I don't care what anyone says I was a GM for 16 years and I can tell you the three-day the all-star break
I was always worried as a GM let alone the four-day all-star break
I was concerned about the timing of hitters and a lot of times that affects it that being said I also want to mention this
Look at the managers that are left standing
Bruce Bochy's gonna be a Hall of Fame manager Dusty Baker's gonna be a Hall of Fame manager
Rob Thompson's one of the best managers in baseball and I think Tory Lovello is as well
But look at look at three teams are 90 and 72
Exactly the same record Houston, Texas and Philadelphia regular season 90 and 72
They all have elite managers as they're sitting here at the end
And by the way for people that want to know the tiebreaker if there's a World Series if Texas is in
They will have home field advantage
If they play Philadelphia and if Houston ends up playing Philadelphia Philadelphia won't be able to advantage
Matt we heard what Jim said right there about the layoff and it's it's not ideal
But you got to show up that that's this is a tournament
So you earn that first round by and we know that baseball is an everyday sport
So it is hard those layoffs are difficult and we know that that's a fact
But you got to find a way to turn it on
Ronald Acuna didn't turn it on Matt Olsen didn't turn it on the the numbers here for Acuna in the series
2 for 14 no RBI's Matt Olsen 4 for 16
No RBI's
You can't have this like this this is the kind of stuff like Acuna had a 40-70 season and Matt Olsen
Had 54 homers at 139 RBI's so give credit to the Phillies team also look at the other series, too
That's exactly the two biggest stars in the top two teams in National League
Mookie Betts Freddie Freeman to combine one for 21 and I'll do the quick math here for Acuna and Olsen
6 for 30 in this series the stars have to be the stars Matt and the stars were not the stars for neither
LA or Atlanta
It's true and for the Astros they were the Astros guys showed up right from the get-go Jose Altuve hit a home run right away
Jordan Alvarez had a huge game and game game one for the Astros
So they actually know what they're doing with it
Whatever it is that there you know
The Astros went 7-0 on the AL side of the playoffs last year after that by they came out and win game one then they
Won games three and four and they advanced with relative ease
They're the ones that somehow haven't figured out after that five-day layoff. I'm in favor of consolidating it
Just to be clear. I understand that several days off. You might it might mess with your timing, but
Having to win an extra round is still a much bigger disadvantage in my opinion because you could have upsets
I mean, I think the Milwaukee Brewers would gladly
The Tampa Bay Rays would gladly go and say hey, we'll trade places with you guys and we'll take the buy and we'll give it
a go
it's
Look, there's always funkiness in the postseason and I agree that it once you get up to five days off
Then it is like hey
If a player was injured for five days now you start talking about if he needs a minor league rehab assignment before jumping right back
Because he needs to get his timing back. I get that
But we have upsets a lot the Tampa Bay Rays won 99 games and they got their teeth kicked in against the Rangers in two
games at home and they kicked the ball around the yard and
If that would have happened after a buy we would have said oh, hey, they're rusty
Look, they can't even feel the ball, but it happened with the exact same number of days off as the Rangers had
So it's I for me. I
Small samples, I mean we saw the Braves lose two of three to the A's this year
We saw the Braves lose two of three at home to the White Sox this year and those were not after five days off
They were just in the middle of the season funky stuff happens in small samples
And I will say and Hakim we talked about this earlier the thing about the Phillies is they're built sure
They're built for 162. They won 90 games
they're a good regular season team, but they're much better built for the postseason and
They showed it last year up until the World Series and they've shown it so far this year. I
Mean look, you had the three 100 win teams. They've all gone home. But look we understand
Philadelphia beat Atlanta because their pitching is better
Then you know, I don't think there's any doubt that the hitters weren't quite right
But I'm not so sure Philadelphia doesn't win that series
Anyway, Texas was a better team than Tampa Bay Tampa Bay didn't have Wander Franco at shortstop Brandon Lau and second base
And they didn't have a healthy Jose Syria, although he did play in in one of those games
in Texas against Baltimore
Look, it was Baltimore's first time into the postseason. A lot of their guys had no postseason experience whatsoever
Grayson Rodriguez didn't pitch like Grayson Rodriguez in game two
I think we understand how Texas could be Baltimore, but I do think five days is too much
I'm not saying that's why the teams are advancing. Look LA had no rotation left, right?
Gonsolin I am
Dustin May I L Julio Arias
Administrative leave Kershaw had his worst outing of his career, which was a nightmare Walker Bueller never got back from Tommy John
So they won 100 games, but we understand why gallon and Kelly and Corbin Carroll were able to beat them
So we're not taking anything away from the team's advancing at all
But I do think we have to look at this postseason and say this
Last two years in the wild-card series seven of the eight were sweeps seven of the eight just make it one game
two out of three is not making much of a difference make it one game and
Shorten it up. So it's two or three days off not four or five days off three days off is fine
I think they need to correct it and I'm not saying the results would be any different and I think we have an
Unbelievable exciting postseason. I love the fact we have 390 team
90 win teams left and I'm so excited about the man the four managers left standing are all elite managers. I can't wait
yeah, I
Jim, you know this and I don't really have to tell you it but
Extra games for TV. I mean we know who pays the bills
Yeah, we know why things are done the way they are
We know why the NBA contracts are out of control because the networks have control and that's how it works
So in the framework of that we enjoy what we see and we have four teams with less
than 91 wins
354 combined wins with the four teams still standing. That's the fewest among the final four ever
90 win Philadelphia Phillies 90 win Rangers 91 Astros and 84 win Diamondbacks
So if you're the Braves here who won a hundred and four games best record in baseball
Led baseball nearly every offensive category. What do you do going into the offseason Jim?
what are you doing if you're Alex Anthopoulos and you just
Resigned Brian snicker to a contract and you've got all these young guns and you came up short. What do you do?
I'm gonna keep working on the starting pitching, right?
I saw I'm you know
It's not their fault that Kyle Wright had surgery and was out for the year Max Fried had a blister
When he did come back, he walked four guys in his five innings
He wasn't ready and he hadn't pitched in September 18th. We didn't see Charlie Morton because he had a finger injury
You know, that's three-fifths of your rotation right there, right?
And the other starters the rookie Bryce Elder and of course Spencer Strider who pitched good enough to win
I mean that the problem was the lineup didn't perform that being said was the lineup perfect in Atlanta
I don't think it was, you know, Kevin Pilar was starting in left field tonight
I had a conversation with Alex Anthopoulos twice during the year ask if he was gonna upgrade left field
He was very comfortable with what he had but that that was kind of an issue for me with that team
So look, I think this team is better than what we saw in the postseason
They they were the best team in baseball in the regular season not by a little but by a lot
But if you don't pitch in the postseason you're going home
Freed wasn't able to pitch Morton didn't pitch Wright didn't pitch
They went home Dodgers didn't have Buehler or May or Gonsolin or Arias and they went home
Milwaukee Brewers, they didn't have Brandon Woodruff. They went home
I mean if you get to October you better have your pitching lined up Philadelphia and Wheeler
Noller Nola and Suarez and they all pitched well and here they go
Evaldi pitch like he did when he won a world championship in 2018 with Boston
Jordan Montgomery era of two in a regular season two in the postseason. They're gonna keep on going
Verlander look great. Framboise look good. Javier look good. Arkady look good. Houston's gonna go on
Let me tell you this in the NHL have the goaltender in the playoffs
You may run the table win a Stanley Cup in MLB
Have the starting pitching if you want to run the table and win a world championship
