OSSOFF VS VANCE 2028: You think?

Insight Daily
3 followers
8 Video Views·Nov 14, 2026
-- Betting markets currently point to a 2028 presidential race between JD Vance and Jon Ossoff, two young politicians whose awkward retail politics could define an unusual campaign
👖 Fair Harbor: Get 20% off with code PAKMAN at https://fairharborclothing.com/pakman
🤝 Become a Member: https://www.davidpakman.com/membership
📚 ORDER David's new book PAY ATTENTION https://davidpakman.com/attention
📧 Subscribe to our (FREE) Substack newsletter: https://substack.davidpakman.com
What if the 2028 presidential election comes down
to J.D. Vance versus John Ossoff? J.D. Vance,
of course, would be the Republican nominee
and John Ossoff would be the Democratic nominee.
Now, why do I bring this up?
I know we just finished the midterms. The presidential
election is basically two years away.
And historically, when you look two years out,
The likely nominees that far
in advance usually don't end up being the nominee.
So I'm saying that up front.
But something interesting is happening right now.
J.D.
Vance leads the Republican nomination betting markets
and John Ossoff leads the Democratic
markets.
And over the weekend, I was at Crooked
Con in Washington, D.C., where they did a straw
Draw a poll of attendees.
And John Ossoff won the twenty twenty eight
Democratic presidential straw poll as well
with 30 something percent of the vote.
Now, that's a progressive political conference.
It's not a representative sample of the Democratic Party electorate.
It just gives us an idea of, you know,
where is there some enthusiasm? Ossoff just won
reelection in Georgia by a massive margin.
That's a state Trump carried in twenty twenty
four. So for today, let's imagine this matchup Vance versus Ossoff.
Now, on the Republican side, J.D. Vance would try,
don't know if he'll be able to, but he
will try to inherit Donald Trump's coalition.
So it'll be like the MAGA base, the populist right,
the people who want Trumpism to continue
after Trump, maybe pull in like the kind of Tucker Carlson type people.
But J.D. Vance is not Donald Trump.
And whatever you think of Trump,
and I don't think much of him, he does have a sort of
charisma that includes an ability to kind of connect with supporters.
That wouldn't necessarily transfer to J.D. Vance.
And in fact, J.D. Vance is one of the least charismatic people
in the national political space that I can think of.
He's awkward and stiff and he's uncomfortable in situations
where you're kind of just supposed to be spontaneous.
We've seen it again and again, the donut incident and all of it.
There's also no guarantee that Republicans would even nominate him
because you've got
Marco Rubio who could make a run.
You've got Ron DeSantis.
You've got others that could make an argument.
We need a different direction.
We need something less directly attached to MAGA and Rubio,
if he does resign secretary
of state soon, would maybe be doing it to argue.
I am taking distance from Trump is I am not part of that.
Now, there could also be some pretty major disagreements
in the Republican primary about
foreign policy, including the Iran war,
what the priorities should be on immigration, economic
policy, how closely Republicans should remain tied to Trump.
So they're going to have some stuff
to figure out on the Republican side.
That's on the Vance side.
Now let's look at the Democratic side.
John Ossoff is a very interesting candidate.
I think he's excellent.
He's young, he's from Georgia,
he has an ability to win competitive states, he is increasingly
aggressive in his confrontation of the Trump administration.
Let me give you the downside to Ossoff that I'm hearing.
Over the last three to four months,
I've met casually, sort of coincidentally, a bunch
of big Democratic donors who have spent time with Ossoff,
and they universally tell me
Which is, Ossoff is really good at the prepared speeches
that they film with three cameras,
with the soft, blurred-out background, and the dramatic lighting.
He's really, really good at that stuff.
But when they've been with Ossoff in smaller rooms,
they all tell me the same thing,
which is, he's really socially awkward,
he struggles to connect one-on-one with people,
and he is so compelling on stage.
But in person, he struggles.
A couple also said he just seems really young in person,
even though he has a sort of different presentation in these speeches,
that in person, you're like, man,
this guy feels really young and inexperienced.
These are not my claims.
I've never met him in person.
I'm just kind of the messenger for what people have told me.
Now, you could argue the in-person doesn't really matter
because most of the campaign is through speeches and TV appearances.
So maybe it doesn't make a difference.
That may be the case.
I think Ossoff is great.
Now, this is their assessment.
But it's interesting
because presidential campaigns involve a lot of different kinds
of interactions.
And even though you might be working
to convince voters mostly through the TV screen or the
phone, whatever, the small gatherings
and the donor meetings and some of the unscripted
conversations and retail politics still
do matter, at least to some degree.
Now, if your opponent is J.D. Vance,
who has one of the biggest charisma problems I've
It might not really matter even if these folks are right about also.
But Democrats also have
other possibilities. You could see AOC if she runs.
I don't think she will. But if she runs,
she might consolidate the progressive left.
You could see other candidates who would be
more in the Ossoff wing politically competing for the same voters.
So it would be like Newsom.
Or Josh Shapiro, J.B. Pritzker, Wes Moore,
they would all be in the sort of similar area
politically as Ossoff. And they are really good in person.
Like I've been in person with all of
those people and they do connect really well with individuals.
So that's something to consider. Now,
a lot of the people we're talking about have said they're
not running. Ossoff has said he's
He's not running in 2028.
People are still speculating.
Wes Moore has said he's not running in 2028.
There's a lot of speculation that he will.
And what's interesting about this hypothetical
is that both parties would be confronting
pretty similar questions.
Do we want a candidate that signals ideological continuity,
or do we want a candidate that
signals ideological change?
Do we want to give priority
to those who have experience governing, or to communication
skills, or to somebody that can be more uniting to different factions?
What do we want?
And the other thing that is not knowable right now
is that we're kind of talking about this
in today's political environment,
but the political environment might be very different
by the end of 2027 or into 2028.
So I am not predicting Vance versus Ossoff.
I'm merely saying right now they're leading the prediction markets
and some of the polling,
straw polling in some cases, et cetera.
What would that look like?
The other interesting narrative would be.
Vance is like 40.
How old is J.D.
Vance?
Forty three.
Maybe exactly.
J.D.
Vance is 42.
And Ossoff isn't even 40.
If I recall correctly, Ossoff's thirty nine.
So they'd be forty four and forty one at the time of the election.
Two very young politicians, especially
when you're thinking about the presidency.
At the same time that their parties are trying
to figure out the future and at the same time
that voters are trying to figure out what's
the kind of direction that we want to go in.
So I want to open it to you. Is this a plausible matchup in 2028?
Will we be talking about completely different candidates six
or 12 months from now?
And who do you like?
Leave me a comment.
Send me an email, info at davidpakman.com.
And by the way, make sure you're subscribed on YouTube.
We are pushing, pushing, pushing,
pushing towards 4 million subscribers, which is an
insane number.
The weather is getting colder,
and I have been thinking about how much easier it is to get
dressed when you have a few comfortable pieces
of clothing that actually go together. That's where
our sponsor, Fair Harbor, has me covered.
They have a full lineup for colder weather with easy
layers that work for a weekend away,
a day outside, or just hanging around. Fair Harbor
Barbara sent me a long-sleeve polo, the Neptune cable sweater.
And the Horizon Pant in khaki.
This is the kind of lineup that makes getting dressed
simple. Versatile pieces you can mix and match without overthinking it,
no matter what the day
brings. The company started with a mission
to protect the places we love exploring. They turned
recycled materials into comfortable fabrics
and make clothing designed to be worn every season,
season after season. Go to fairharborclothing.com slash pacman.
And use the code PACMAN20 for 20% off your first full price order.
That is fairharborclothing.com slash PACMAN with code PACMAN20
so they know we sent you.
The link is in the description.
