OnePlus 6 vs Pixel 2 XL: In-Depth Camera Test Comparison

Science City
55 followers
40 Video Views·Nov 17, 2022
In this video, I look at how the cameras compare on the Google Pixel 2 XL and the OnePlus 6. Many view the Pixel 2 as the best smartphone camera right now, so I wanted to see how the newly released OnePlus 6 compared. I compared them in great lighting, challenging lighting, and low lighting. I also did a 4K video test and tested the microphone quality as well as the electronic and optical image stabilization of both phones. I also looked in-depth into the portrait modes of both phones.
Hi guys, it's MTG here and I just got back home from summer break and I've gotten a
chance to take the OnePlus 6 out for a spin and compare it to the best smartphone cameras
out right now.
In this video, I'll be comparing it to the Pixel 2 XL and see how the two cameras compare
in various lighting conditions, and I'll also look at the video and audio quality shot
on both phones.
Let's get right into it.
The OnePlus 6 has a dual camera setup.
The main camera is 16 megapixels.
The secondary camera has the same focal length, is 20 megapixels, and is said to help the
overall image quality and help with portrait mode pictures.
They both have f1.7 apertures.
The camera can record up to 4K at up to 60 frames per second, and 1080p at up to 240
frames per second.
The main camera utilizes both gyroscope-based electronic image stabilization and optical
image stabilization.
The OnePlus 6's front camera is an impressive 16 megapixels with an f2.0 aperture.
It utilizes gyro-based EIS and has auto HDR capabilities.
It can record video at up to 1080p at 30 frames per second.
The Pixel 2 XL has a single 12.2 megapixel sensor with an f1.8 aperture.
Using Google's AI and machine learning techniques, it can achieve portrait-style pictures on
both its front and rear-facing cameras.
The camera can record up to 4K at 30 frames per second, and 1080p at up to 120 frames
per second.
It has both optical and electronic image stabilization.
The Pixel 2 XL's front camera is 8 megapixels with an aperture of f2.4.
It can record video at up to 1080p at 30 frames per second.
Right off the bat, you can see that these two smartphone camera systems produce images
that are a lot closer than you would have expected.
The Pixel does tend to make pictures with more contrast, whereas the OnePlus 6 tends
to produce overall brighter and more saturated images.
We can also see the Pixel 2 XL does tend to have the cooler images between the two.
If we zoom into this particular image, we can see that the image processing on the Pixel
2 XL is able to pick up so much detail.
The OnePlus 6 also picks up a ton of detail, but everything is more pronounced on the Pixel
2's image.
This image shows how the pictures from the Pixel may become over-processed sometimes.
The Pixel 2 picks up a lot of detail once again, but the OnePlus 6 has the more true
to life colors in this image, while the Pixel's shot just looks too gray.
In many other instances, however, the Pixel 2's image processing creates near-perfect
images.
In this case, the Pixel's shot has the richer greens and more defined details in the sculpture
and concrete.
As we go through a couple more outdoor shots and great lighting, you can really notice
the trends of how the two phones process their images.
Some may prefer the contrast and detail focus of the Pixel 2 XL, and others may really like
the brighter images of the OnePlus 6.
Both phones no doubt perform great in great lighting.
But you aren't always going to have ideal lighting when you shoot pictures, so I also
want to take a look at how the cameras perform in more challenging lighting conditions.
I shot this picture to test the HDR capabilities of both phones.
In previous years, flagships struggled to capture quality images when light came in
through windows.
However, in this case, both phones did excellent jobs.
The OnePlus 6 has a slightly brighter foreground, whereas the Pixel 2 XL is able to capture
more detail in the wall outside the image.
In this image, the Pixel's post-processing shines.
It's able to maintain more detail in the top window, and is able to keep the foreground
brighter overall.
Again, this complex lighting scenario was handled well by both phones.
Again, the details look more pronounced on the Pixel 2's image, but the OnePlus 6 maintained
a brighter foreground and background.
In this video, I also wanted to take a specific look at the portrait modes of both phones.
Remember that both phones don't have their telephoto cameras, and although the OnePlus
6's secondary camera does help a little bit with portrait mode, both phones rely heavily
on software to create its depth effect pictures.
The OnePlus 6 takes wider angled portrait shots.
I took these two standing in the same exact spot.
I actually had to take a big step forward on the OnePlus 6 to achieve the same angle
on the Pixel.
Although the Pixel is able to pick up more detail in the subject's face, I think the
OnePlus 6 did a better job of distinguishing between the foreground and the background.
For some reason, in the Pixel's image, the top half of the hedge is blurred, but the
rest of the right side of the image isn't blurred at all, even if it is in the background.
This next image shows just what the Pixel 2's are capable of when they do get the blur
right.
The Pixel 2 XL is able to pick up great colors, great levels of detail, and I look perfectly
exposed.
The OnePlus 6's photo isn't bad by any means, but details on my face aren't preserved
as much, and I do appear to be slightly overexposed.
The Pixel 2 XL is able to pick up so much detail once again, but again, it doesn't
do as good of a job with blurring the background.
For some reason, the Pixel thought the entire ledge was in the foreground and didn't blur
it.
Also, the OnePlus 6's blur looks less fake than the Pixel 2's in this image.
Both phones have terrific selfie cameras.
The OnePlus 6 has the sheer megapixel count and HDR capability advantage, but the Pixel
2 XL exceeds that with pure image processing.
The Pixel 2's are even able to take excellent portrait pictures with their front cameras.
As I shift into video, note that the OnePlus 6 can shoot 4K at up to 60 frames per second,
but since I uploaded this video at 30 frames per second, that's what I set both phones
to.
Both phones have great 4K video quality, and both phones really tried to make the colors
pop.
In both cases, it may lead to videos that are saturated too much, but many people have
openly liked colors that pop, so I guess that's why OnePlus and Google went that route.
In terms of stabilization, they both utilize electronic and optical stabilization.
OnePlus appears to have the more aggressive stabilization algorithms, which makes for
steadier walking, but also for more jittery, less natural panning.
But a plus with electronic image stabilization is that it can be tuned later in software
updates.
Now I'm testing the front two cameras of both phones.
It's pretty great lighting outside, so I'm wondering how the background's picked up,
and how my face is picked up.
I'm also going to continue walking so you can see how the image stabilization of both
phones is.
Let me know in the comments section which microphone's better, and which front-facing
video camera's better overall.
Now I'm testing the front two cameras of both phones.
It's pretty great lighting outside, so I'm wondering how the background's picked up,
and how my face is picked up.
I'm also going to continue walking so you can see how the image stabilization of both
phones is.
Let me know in the comments section which microphone's better, and which front-facing
video camera's better overall.
OnePlus carries over its electronic image stabilization to its front camera as well.
This makes for a very stabilized video.
However, to achieve this, OnePlus has to crop into its image a bit.
The OnePlus 6 is able to pick up a lot of detail, whereas the Pixel 2 XL's colors look
more true to life.
In terms of audio, both phones have pretty aggressive noise canceling, which does eliminate
a lot of wind noise, but also makes for tinny audio.
In terms of overall volume, the OnePlus 6's audio is significantly louder.
All of the pictures I shot in low light were without flash, and I'd say that a lot of these
pictures turned out great.
Both phones were able to capture a lot of detail, and take in a surprising amount of
light given the circumstances.
In this instance, the Pixel 2 XL is able to process the image very well and produce the
brighter, more detailed image.
Both phones are able to minimize noise in the sky despite it being very dark at the
time, and both do a pretty good job of not letting light sources get blown out.
In this image, the OnePlus 6 handles the light strip better, but the Pixel 2 XL again is
able to produce the brighter image.
In this last low light shot, we can see that sometimes the Pixel can unnaturally brighten
the image.
The OnePlus 6 deals with all of the colored light better, whereas the Pixel 2 XL always
tries to simply brighten the image.
As you can see, this camera comparison was a lot closer than a lot of people expected.
I even had some people tell me not to even make this camera comparison because they thought
it would be so one-sided.
At the end of the day, the Pixel 2 XL probably still has the better camera.
But how much of a better camera?
I'll be comparing the two cameras fully in another video, but right now I just wanted
to see how the two cameras stacked up.
A lot of the preferences on image quality will come down to what you prefer.
Some people like the really high contrast images, while others prefer brighter, more
saturated images.
Let me know in the comment section what you think.
In the next few days, I'll be posting more camera comparisons with the OnePlus 6 versus
the S9 Plus and the iPhone X, so make sure you're subscribed and click the notification
bell to watch those.
That's all I had to talk about in this video.
Thanks for watching, and I'll see you in the next video.
