Jensen Huang is out as Nvidia CEO. But as Elon Musk and Donald Trump weigh in on his future, a bigger question is emerging: Have AI companies become more powerful than the governments supposed to regulate them? Huang helped turn Nvidia into the driving force behind the global artificial intelligence boom. His sudden resignation has shaken Silicon Valley and intensified questions about the world's dependence on a handful of powerful technology companies. Before his departure, Huang was asked whether the AI industry's dependence on Nvidia had become a systemic risk. His response: "They don't depend on us, they choose us." But how much choice do governments, businesses and ordinary citizens really have? DW's Brent Goff speaks with Virginia Dignum, Professor of Responsible Artificial Intelligence at Umeå University in Sweden, about the global battle for AI talent, the rivalry between the United States and China, and the growing political and economic influence of Silicon Valley. #nvidia#jensenhuang
AI Generated·May contain errors
Last Thursday, NVIDIA announced the resignation of Jensen Huang,
the man who co-founded the
company 33 years ago
and turned it into the driving force behind the global AI boom.
His departure followed reports of extramarital affairs, including one
with a businesswoman that the U.S. suspects of spying for China.
NVIDIA says it has no
reason to believe that company secrets
or that U.S. national security were compromised.
Last week, when a social media user urged Elon Musk to hire Wong,
Musk responded,
that would be an honor.
And then U.S. President Donald Trump chimed in on his social media
platform Truth Social and offered some personnel advice,
saying there's only one man to replace
Wong, former Apple CEO Tim Cook. He wrote, a legend replaces a legend.
Well, when the U.S. president gets involved in corporate headhunting,
you know there's more at stake than just a job.
Just weeks before his resignation, Huang was asked by Bloomberg about
the risks posed by the AI industry's dependence on NVIDIA.
I want you to take a listen to what he said.
So at what point does that dependence
on one single company become a systemic risk?
Well, they don't depend on us. They choose us.
Yeah, they choose us. Are we talking about dependence
or choice here? How much choice
do governments still have?
The race for AI supremacy is a race for human talent,
but it's also a race for political
and economic power on a global scale. So
is the competition for AI human talent,
is it the 21st century's new arms race?
Joining me now is Virginia Dignam.
She's a professor of responsible artificial intelligence
at Sweden's Umeå University.
She has advised both the United Nations
and the European Union on how AI should be governed.
Professor, it's good to have you on the program.
So we just heard what Jensen Huang said.
Is he right?
Do we still have a choice
or have we already allowed ourselves to become too dependent
on a handful of AI companies?
We always have a choice, but at the same time,
yes, we are maybe a bit too much dependent
on the narrative of the AI companies.
He says they choose us, but at the same time,
yes, this is the center of a network of a
circular economy in which Nvidia borrows money
to other companies to buy Nvidia products.
So the choice, who has a choice to do what
is a bit strange in the words of Jensen Huang.
I was going to say, during the Cold War,
world powers, they competed for the best nuclear
scientists, and today they're competing for the best minds in AI.
Would you say is this the new geopolitical arms race?
I talk in terms of race and in terms of geopolitics, probably, but I
think that there is more to it than just a geopolitical arms race.
First, if we talk about race, we are talking about something
that has an end point at which we can decide who wins or who loses.
I don't think that in technology advance,
in scientific advance, there is an end point.
The ones who are winning today might very well be the ones
who are losing later.
The ones who are now exploring other alternatives might be the ones
which come up with the next
generation of AI.
And we are too much focusing on the AI developments that we have today.
And for
Focusing on the line of development that it's part
of the narrative of a few very powerful
and very big companies, but still very few.
And there is much more to AI than what they are pretending that it is.
They made a choice for one type of AI
and they are making us all believe that this is it.
So you're saying there's a little delay there, I'm sorry about that,
but are you saying that there's a different type of AI
that could be developed that is not being developed on purpose?
Sure. I don't know if it's on purpose,
but there is much more to AI than what we are.
So large language models
and generative AI is one of the many approaches that we have in AI.
I believe that the next step and the next really big paradigm shift
in AI will not be the one of scale that they are trying us to believe,
that more data, more compute will get us to better AI,
but will be one in which we are going to be able to combine
And to interlock many different approaches,
many different models, many different types
of technologies and theories and approaches.
So it will be a much more distributed
and much more participatory development than this
one in which they are trying to make us believe
that by putting all the data together and
all the computing power together, we will get to a better AI.
That is definitely not in terms
of the scientific quality of what is coming out,
but it's also a huge sustainability
and environmental disaster waiting to happen.
You know, what we're seeing, though, is with the current,
you know, version and vision of AI that we have,
we're seeing tech companies offer AI researchers compensation packages
that are worth hundreds of millions of dollars.
I mean, you're a professor
of artificial intelligence. You're an academic.
How can universities and governments,
how can they possibly compete with these huge sums of money?
By exploring the alternatives.
Like I say, this is not the only way to do AI.
It is, in my own opinion,
quite a boring way to do research and to do science by scaling only.
So if governments,
universities provide the researchers the expert alternatives
and the support to explore
alternatives, to really try to find out the new paradigm in AI,
the next big thing in AI,
That's what what makes researchers think
and not only the the huge amounts of money that are being offered.
So if someone like Elon Musk offered you a compensation package
of let's say five hundred million dollars a year
Would that not be enough to pull you away from academia?
Probably not, but I'm also in a different stage of career.
My next step in career is probably retirement.
But money has never been my concern.
And I have had, not $500 million, but I have had offers from companies.
But in a sense, for me, the academic freedom is much more important
than whatever the money they're giving.
And I agree that it's not the same for everybody.
And so if we go from money to power,
have some AI companies, have they already become
more powerful than many national governments
when it comes to shaping our future?
In terms of economic future,
maybe we see the amount of valuation of companies being
larger than GDPs of many countries, including Germany.
But I think that our future is not just shaped by economics.
It's also shaped by other values and by other opportunities.
And when we talk about the regulation of AI,
we are mixing a lot of things together.
For instance, a comparison with cars,
even if technology and cars are not the same,
cars keeps moving and keeps being extended and explored,
we still have the capacity to
enforce laws that say that whatever speed
this car can in principle reach, if it drives
in front of a school, we demand it to drive 30 kilometers per hour.
So, in terms of regulation, we can,
in AI, look at the same type of things.
What do we want?
What are our values?
What really matters to us,
independently of the capabilities of the technology?
And then demand organizations to do that.
We do it in every other sector.
Somehow, we got to believe
or we were led to believe that AI is different, but AI is
a technology like any other technology,
and we can and we should and we need to demand
the same type of responsibility
and accountability that we see in other sectors.
So what do you make then, Professor, of what we're seeing right now?
You know the rivalry, the competition between
the United States and China when it comes
to AI.
U.S. President Trump.
He says that he will not discuss AI
when he meets this week with Vladimir Putin and Xi Jinping.
I mean, if that is true, is the U.S. president, is he making a mistake?
Is he wasting a valuable opportunity
to talk about things such as regulation of AI?
I think so. If anywhere in the world AI is being regulated
and being innovative at the same time is in China.
We might not be agreeing with all the, let's say,
the principles and the purpose of regulation in China,
but AI regulation in China is working.
It's working according to their values and their principles.
So if someone knows how to regulate AI, it's China.
If Trump wants to learn anything about regulating AI,
then maybe he's making a mistake of not
talking about it with Xi Jinping.
Well, before we run out of time, let me just ask you,
is China, do they have a model of
regulating AI that...
That we could copy that is worth copying, is that what you're saying?
I'm not sure if we can copy it
because our democratic values and our democratic principles
are quite different from the principles and priorities in China,
but within their own system
they have a regulatory regimen for AI that is working
and that is being followed and that is
Supporting the innovation and the development of AI in China.
So all of us, including the European Union,
we should look much more to what China is
doing in terms of regulation.
Yeah, fascinating to hear that opinion.
In your book, Professor, which is The AI Paradox,
you challenge the notion that AI is inevitable.
I mean, most people today would say AI is our destiny.
Who benefits from making us believe
that we have no choice when it comes to AI?
Big tech. The tech bros. It is...
There is a choice. There is options. We have options.
And the choices and the way that we are shaping AI today is depending
on the choices that we are making, the choices that we are not making,
and the choices that we are letting other ones make for us.
And if we don't really keep talking about that and being clear about
the choices and the options that we are taking or not taking,
we are being led by the choices of others.
And I think that's where our governments need to be much more strong
and much more upfront.
They are making choices by not choosing.
Professor Virginia Dignam, we appreciate your time.
Fascinating discussion with you
and refreshing to hear your point of view.
Thank you very much.
Thank you very much. Have a nice evening.