House Bill 2521 would remove the cap on firearm background check fees and give the Washington State Patrol open-ended authority to charge whatever it decides is “necessary.”
Reps. Jim Walsh and Travis Couture argue that the Second Amendment — and Article I, Section 24 of our state constitution — are not pay-to-play.
The bill is now in the Senate Rules Committee, where it could come up for a vote. You can send a comment to your legislators about House Bill 2521 here: https://app.leg.wa.gov/pbc/bill/2521
The Washington State Legislative Hotline: 1-800-562-6000
Hey everybody, this is Representative Travis Couture here with Representative Jim Walsh,
just coming to you to talk about some guns and firearms and your Second Amendment rights today,
the good, the bad and the ugly. We just got done on the House floor talking about a really,
really bad gun bill, probably the worst that's left here in the session,
and it's about firearm background check fees through the Washington State Patrol.
And essentially what we had before is an $18 fee, which fundamentally we disagree with,
because they're constitutional rights and they limit your access to your constitutional rights.
However, what the bill did is give the Washington State Patrol this unlimited authority
to raise fees ad nauseum. There's no cap on the fees anymore as this bill passed the House,
and we had a lot to say on that bill. Jim, what were your thoughts on it?
Yeah, it's a bad bill. It's a fee bill restricting your right to exercise your constitutional
right to keep and bear guns, firearms, protected by both the federal and state constitution.
As some of you know, I think the state constitution's protections of gun rights
are even stronger than the federal. So it's a problem on both those fronts. It was interesting.
It came through Travis's committee, the Appropriations Committee, where he's ranking,
not through the Judiciary Committee, where I'm ranking, which normally deals with gun issues,
but because it's a fee, the speaker put it through the Appropriations Committee,
but we caught that. Travis caught it right away. It's a gun issue. It's a gun bill.
And the idea is, especially with the escalator language in it, the legislature doesn't have to
take any further action. The State Patrol can raise the fee for the background check required
to buy or sell a firearm, and there's no limit on that. So it was $18 before. It could be $100
pretty soon. So we don't like that. And really, whether it's $18 or $100 or $1,000,
it's all unconstitutional. The case law and the statutory law, both at the federal and state level,
has consistently said you can't take away a constitutional right and then sell it back
piecemeal to people. You can't do that, and that's what this bill is trying to do.
Yeah, exactly. And we'll just check out some of the things we had to say about it on the floor.
Constitutional rights cannot be taken by the government and sold back in pieces
to individual citizens. There is no fee that is appropriate to be charged an individual
to exercise a constitutionally protected right. We need to focus on preventing the
criminals from getting guns or punishing them appropriately when they use a gun in committing
a crime, and we need to stop impairing your ability as a law-abiding citizen to exercise
your constitutional right to protect yourself and your home and your kids or grandkids and your
neighbors and the whole state. The brilliance of Article I, Section 24 of our state constitution,
which, as you know, I find superior to the Second Amendment protections in the federal constitution,
is it says explicitly our public policy should not impair your right to bear a firearm because
your exercise of your right to bear a firearm protects everyone. We're one of the easiest
states in all of the country, if not the easiest, to vote, but we don't ask the citizens to pay for
that because, well, it's their constitutional right to vote. And when they get in trouble,
God forbid, Madam Speaker, we don't ask them to pay for a public defender either,
but in an act of hypocrisy, the Washington State Patrol just has an unlimited, unchecked authority
granted to it by the legislature to increase these fees. And what I predict will happen,
Madam Speaker, is that they will just increase and increase and increase and increase and increase
and increase until one day it becomes cost prohibitive to even get a background check
and own a firearm. That's exactly the problems I hear from constituents in my district and across
the state who are legal, law-abiding gun owners who oftentimes need firearms as a part of their
way of life. This kind of stuff is wrong. So, Madam Speaker, I don't frankly care what burden
the Washington State Patrol or any other state agency has when it comes to people in the state
of Washington accessing their constitutional rights. I care about the burden we've placed
on people and their rights, and this bill is a burden on their rights. Please vote no.
What this system is, is a pay-to-play system, right, Jim?
Sure.
It really locks out low-income people from their constitutional rights, and that's wrong. We don't
ask people to pay when they get in trouble for a public defender. We don't ask people to pay
to vote. And I think, as you so eloquently said on the floor, this really mimics a poll tax.
It is structurally like a poll tax, and those are reprehensible. Those are terrible things.
Everyone agrees those are bad policy, unconstitutional, and this mechanically is
like that. So, we're so opposed to this proposal, and it does cut against working people and middle
class families. I mean, some tech bro can spend $1,000 getting a permit to buy a Glock, but you
shouldn't have to. It's a constitutional right that you can do that. So, we're going to defend
your constitutional right, and we're going to say, really, no to this escalating fee
for the background check to buy a firearm.
Yeah, and at the same time, the Democrats argued that, well,
poor Washington State Patrol could create burdens on them if we cap the fee or have no fee at all,
and we just simply don't care about the burdens of a state agency over the burdens of the
constitutional rights of our citizens. That's our first duty. That's our constitutional duty
to protect them and not the government. We're here to protect you from the government.
That's right.
So, here's the bill number right here. You should contact your senators because that's
where the bill goes next. Email them, call them, make your voices heard because that's
the only way we can stop bad legislation like this, and stay tuned.