North and South: Penguin Classics by Elizabeth Gaskell · Audiobook preview

Elizabeth Gaskell
6 followers
6 Video Views·Jan 22, 2025
Brought to you by Penguin North and South by Elizabeth Gaskell
Read by Gemma Whelan Introduction
New readers are advised that this introduction makes the details of the plot explicit.
Elizabeth Gaskell's own working title for her novel, first published in Dickens' Household
Words between September 1854 and January 1855, was Margaret Hale. Under pressure from him,
it was changed to North and South, though it is uncertain who devised the name. As Dickens wrote
on the 26th of July, North South appears to me to be a better name than Margaret Hale.
It implies more, and is expressive of the opposite people brought face to face by the story.
As this comment shows, titles like headlines are directives as to how to read what follows.
The new version suggests an interpretation in which Margaret Hale's story is secondary to a
broader theme of class conflict. Though the usual assumption is that it was not Gaskell herself who
thought of the title, it does accurately capture the meaning of the events as she narrates them.
On the surface, and with the title, Margaret or Margaret Hale, it is construable as her story,
a romantic tale, in which, to quote the contemporary Guardian reviewer,
Margaret Hale, by her womanly influence, is able to calm hatred and real sorrows.
This safely categorizes the narrative as belonging to a genre in which class hostility is displaced
onto divided lovers whose reconciliation is offered as a figure for class harmony.
An example of the type is Charlotte Bronte's Shirley, 1849, where Robert Moore's harsh
treatment of his workers is paralleled by his rejection of Caroline Helston, who,
though he loves her, is too poor to be useful to his business prospects. His change of heart,
and marriage to her, coincides with a more paternalistic attitude to his workers and a
happy marriage translates into industrial peace. What the title North and South underlines in
Gaskell's novel is that in this text the conflict is intractable, not an idea found in Dickens's
hard times. The conflict is not subordinated, as in Shirley, but is the central statement about
society made by the narrative, and the making of this statement involves a subversive rewriting
of the typical middle-class heroine. The North, in mid-Victorian fiction, is not merely a place
but a figure for capitalistic values, for which Manchester was often the symbol.
These ideas cluster around the perceived virtues of entrepreneurial skill
and unremitting self-interest. The latter was famously celebrated as socially and morally
valuable in Self-Help by Samuel Smiles, 1859. He noted approvingly that through its pursuit,
rising above the heads of the mass, there were always to be found a series of individuals
distinguished beyond others, who commanded the public homage. The division onto which
this society is structured is visible here. The masses as opposed to the successful,
whose very success is a demonstration of their superior gifts.
Industrial novels were read as necessarily supporting one side or the other,
and Gaskell's first Condition of England narrative, Mary Barton, 1848, had been thought by some to do
very great injustice to the employers. She was assumed to have taken the other side,
to have contested the justice of Smiles's view, and misunderstood and over-sympathised
with the plight of the workers. She had evidently failed to see that they suffered
immiseration in the necessary cause of their master's profit. The South, on the other hand,
was, in industrial novels, another country, not only physically distant, but unrelated.
It was merely the natural location of the educated and comfortable middle class.
Its exclusion from such texts was a denial of the fact that middle-class status and comfort
depended on keeping the social status quo intact and on perpetuating the working class
on which commercial success was based. One attempt had already been made by Charlotte Bronte in
Shirley to reconsider the relationship between North and South. It flounders into confusion
as she first tries to equate the North with Yorkshire working-class virtue, and then gives
way to the more conventional view of unrelated communities. Gaskell went further than this,
and alarmed some contemporaries, including a reviewer in The Leader in 1855.
As relates to anything special to either the North or the South, or to those two districts
in contrast, it is, not to mince matters, a failure. We affirm that the Hales, father,
mother and daughter, the Lennoxes, Mr. Bell, and all that here represents the South,
represent simply the well-bred, unmercantile middle classes of England, and not any class
peculiar to any district or county. While on the other hand, the Thorntons, the Higginses,
and others, as well as the incidents laid in Milton, are no fair picture of the cotton realms
of which Manchester is the metropolis. This attempts to blur the discussion of how the
unmercantile middle classes situation relates to Northern industrial misery, and to re-inscribe
industrial society in positive terms as the potent figure of empire. What is innovative
in North and South, and presumably the source of this reviewer's discomfort, is that in it,
Gaskell takes a heroine from the unmercantile South, educated, refined, with a taste for virtue,
beauty, and comfort, thrusts her into the ugliness and conflict of the North, and allows her to go
native. Usually, as Keating points out, the representative of the South is the middle-class
narrator, and an inscribed collusive reader, who undertakes a dangerous voyage of discovery
into an uncharted working-class world, from which he eventually returns with a
fully documented report of his adventures. Usually the return is accompanied by some
token of improved conditions for the working class, implying that all is, will be, or can be,
well. North and South proceeds differently. Margaret Hale, originally the symbol of the South,
in all its detachment and superiority, is transformed by her life in Milton into a
person, both as an individual and as a woman. Her very presence when she returns to the
Southern luxury of her aunt's house in Harley Street is a denial of middle-class values,
and the idea of inevitable class separation. She embodies the unbreakable link between
Southern prosperity and Northern misery. She is now both South and North. Her exile in the North
is brought about by her father's defection from the Church of England on conscientious grounds.
This causes him to find work in Milton Northern, Manchester, as a private tutor.
Margaret's distaste for every aspect of Milton—landscape, manners, smoke, dirt, clothes,
and wallpaper—reveals values formed in the house of her aunt Shaw in Harley Street,
and in the lush countryside of her father's Devonshire living. In the eyes of the local
mill owner, Thornton, she epitomises the perfect middle-class woman to whom a successful,
self-made man like himself can now aspire. Marriage to such a wife would move him into
the class which is the natural reward for commercial success. It would take him out
of his own apotheosis of working-class domesticity, for his household is handsome,
ponderous with no sign of feminine habitation. It has drawing-room furniture, as Margaret
snobbishly perceives, bagged up with as much care as if the house was to be overwhelmed with lava.
Great alabaster groups under their glass shades, and smartly bound but unread books arranged
like gaily-coloured spokes of a wheel—his own mother's household concerns are cleanliness
and ostentation. She is prepared to expend care and labour, but not to procure ease,
to help on habits of tranquil home-employment, solely to ornament, and then to preserve
ornament from dirt or destruction. By contrast, Margaret produces out of the hill's poverty,
pleasing chintz, ornaments of trailing ivy, pale-green birch and copper-coloured beech-leaves.
Their drawing-room contains books, hastily put down, and not cared for, on account of
their binding solely. Thornton rapturously decodes this elegance and comfort as
habitual to the family, and especially of a piece with Margaret. Angel and domestic heaven are
equated as she serves tea. She looked as if she was solely busy with the teacups, among which
her round ivory hands moved with pretty, noiseless daintiness. He even reads Margaret in this role
as offering a glimpse of her sexuality and its delights. She had a bracelet on one taper arm,
which would fall down over her round wrist. It seemed as if it fascinated him to see her
push it up impatiently, until it tightened her soft flesh, and then, to mark the loosening,
the fall. But well, Thornton is proud.
We hope you enjoyed this preview. To continue listening to this audiobook on Google Play Books,
use the link in the video description.
