Two of the best entry doors into German watchmaking are Junghans and NOMOS, who both take a lot of inspiration from the Bauhaus School of Design. However, given the often substantial price jump between the brands, it can be challenging to understand the tangible differences between the watches themselves. In this video, we'll do an in-depth comparison of two of these brands' most popular models to see how their approaches to Bauhaus design language differ as well as taking a look at what you're really getting for your money in each instance.
This video compares the Junghans Max Bill and the Nomos Orion, two German timepieces rooted in Bauhaus design. By analyzing their history, wearability, aesthetics, and movements, the presenter highlights the distinction between Junghans' mid-century purity and Nomos' contemporary refinement to help collectors choose the right minimalist watch.
The two of my favorite watch brands from Germany that just had a large
impact and progression of my taste are Nomos and Junghans.
Like two of these brands are really known for their more contemporary
approach to design and utilizing principles from the Baha school of design.
Now with the linkage in their influence kind of being shared, there's many
collectors that I think just develop an affinity to their styles and then they
kind of get confronted with this idea, like which watch is better suited for them and why.
So in this video, we're going to look at three primary points, first
examining a point of design influence of both of these brands, then moving
into a detailed comparison of both of these leading models from these
respective manufacturers.
And finally, at the end, just some closing thoughts, which watch is better
for which type of individual, and maybe just some points of consideration when
looking in the direction of these two manufacturers, but guys, let's jump
into the video.
So to begin with looking at both of these manufacturers, I think it's
important to understand the backstory of them in order to really demonstrate
where the direct parallels fall and then where they diverge from a shared focus.
Now with both of these manufacturers descending from Germany, there are
certainly going to be some shared elements, especially when looking at
these dials straight on, but their inceptions began at two very different
periods with Skramberg-based Junghans being founded in 1861 with a history of
many twists and turns, just given the cultural rollercoaster for lack of a
better term of Germany in the century and a half since their start.
And then the other hand, you have Nomos Glashütte being a young company,
relatively speaking for watches that is, that was founded just in 1990 and
has quickly gained ground as the largest manufacturer in Germany by total
output of production and has amassed a collection of their own in-house
calibers to add on top of that.
Yet, despite the disconnection of years between their launches as brands, they
share a common point of influence from the Bauhaus school of design and the
predecessor to that movement with the Deutsche Werke.
Now the idea of Bauhaus is one of those terms that does get thrown around quite
loosely at times.
I've been guilty of this, but in the short 14 year existence of the Bauhaus
school from 1919 to 1933, the school managed to establish not only an
anomalous approach to design, but way of life to the overly traditional norms
being clung onto by German nationals of the period.
So the principles of Bauhaus certainly battled the status quo, but also it did
it with some underlying purpose to fuse individual expression on one side with
function through a framework that did not obfuscate individualism, even through
the intended enhancement of the possibility of mass production.
Now, by developing a workspace that encouraged craftsmen as well as artists
and designers to collaborate together, the influence of the school was carried
far beyond the time the school was forced to close its doors with the help of alumni
and its adoption by nearly all aspects of contemporary design as well as
industrial design with its impact being felt in the typeface of some of your
favorite brands, the chair that maybe you're sitting on or the device that
you're watching this video on right now.
One of those graduates that had a heavily influence on the world of watch
making and particularly Junghans was Swiss designer Max Bill.
Now Max Bill was originally commissioned by Junghans during the 1950s to create
wall clocks for the brand and followed up on their success in the 1960s with
adopting his designs to that of a wristwatch, a design that now has become
synonymous with the brand and will serve as our point of reference for this review.
Now on the other end, Nomos was a brand that arose in the year 1990, and this
was a period notable in Germany, especially given the fall of the Berlin
wall just prior to this.
And this really helped usher in a heightened embrace of individual
expression and culture, and Nomos in many ways followed this momentum and
adoption in an approach to design that both looks back towards the early
principles of Bauhaus in a really contemporary form as exemplified by this
Orion here.
Now in this video, we're gonna be looking at both of the 38 millimeter
options of these watches, of course, we'll look at some of the details,
things to consider at the end.
Also, if you're liking what you're seeing from these watches today, we are
a full authorized dealer at TeddyBallDresser.com, so we'll leave links
in the description down below, if you are in the market for them, full
authorized dealer of the brand, as well as full factory warranty, completely
covered there, TeddyBallDresser.com.
Starting off with a conversation on wearability of these two German dress
watches, we have a set of smaller dimensions in both cases that are
similar in diameter.
However, that doesn't really tell the entire story here.
Starting with the Junghans, we have the signature 38 millimeter diameter
paired with a set of very short lugs for that diameter, which also are neatly
tucked up against the case, equaling out to a lug to lug distance of just 40
millimeters, making for an excellent under the radar dress watch wearing
experience, which I think can be worn in casual environments, as well as
in more dressing environments.
Like other Maxwell designs, this almost total lack of a bezel and angle to the
dial design ensures that this watch still has a presence on the wrist, despite
its overall smaller dimensions.
And even with that automatic at a 2824 within a highly domed acrylic crystal,
the case thickness is just a spelt 9.8 millimeters that should slide underneath
pretty much every dress cuff.
Also, I do want to mention that there are Sapphire versions of
this actual crystal available.
We also have Sapphire retrofitting on our site.
So just want to put that in as a side note.
We'll talk a bit more about that in a bit when looking at the dials.
In terms of finishing, the Maxwell is polished pretty much everywhere you
look on his saucer like case that works cohesively with the other design elements.
Now, along the three o'clock side of the case, it comes with a push pull
unsigned crown that operates in a typical fashion, moving over to
this Nomos Orion on the wrist.
It's important to know that we are taking a look at the 38 millimeter
variant of this watch, as opposed to the also available 33 and 35 millimeter
incoming in a variety of pneumatic versions as well.
Now with the 38 millimeter Nomos Orion, we have a case that despite the 38
millimeter diameter, feels substantially larger than that of the Maxwell.
Like the Junghans, we again have a very narrow bezel that aids in the
perception of the visual size, but the lug to lug of this 47.6 millimeters
is the main reason for his larger presence.
And this is the distinctive lug design and offers an unparalleled silhouette
that is easy to recognize from Nomos, in nicely contrast with the arguably
most restrained design Nomos have in the Orion.
Aiding in keeping the wear slim on the wrist, we have an impressive
7.9 millimeters in thickness here.
And this is enabled by that thinner Nomos alpha manual
caliber we'll get to in a bit.
As far as finishing, the Orion is like the Maxwell, polished all over with
elongated slender lugs and an overall curve presentation that does feel a
step up from Junghans, as you kind of hoped for, for the price.
Another highlight is the exhibition case back on this one.
So this is coming in both a Sapphire as well as a stainless steel back, but
given the alpha manual, just being probably one of the best looking
movements available under $3,000, I think it's definitely worth it to go
for the exhibition case back, but is a notable jump in price if you
didn't want to go that direction.
However, cases aside for a moment, considering that these two brands are
commonly known first and foremost for their design language, the dial is
definitely to be a highlight in this comparison.
With the Junghans Maxwell, it is important to remember its origins from
wall clocks and being a pioneer in mid 20th century design.
Now with understanding that, I think you begin to see how the valued
elements of a wall clock are still present here with a watch
meant to be worn on the wrist.
Here we have a clean silver surface set with easily distinguished
numerals to point out the hours and corresponding line markers to
assist even further with telling the time.
Also the use of lines and experimenting with typography were some of the, just
the key principles of Bauhaus design in general, and they are on full
display here in this instance.
I absolutely just love the numerals chosen on this watch.
One smaller point that I've just always noticed with Junghans as well, primarily
with the Maxwell honestly, is how the edge of the dial tucks backward and
kind of makes the, I don't know, it just makes you kind of really pull in.
It's more striking pulling in the viewer.
And it's a trait that was probably adopted as a result of the wall clock
influence now that you're kind of tying these things together.
And when combining this effect with the crystal, it really does
create an eye-catching effect.
And in this case, this is a plexiglass crystal kind of matching the original
as well as, you know, helping with that legibility and kind
of having that vintage hue.
But if you did want a Sapphire version, those are available as well.
Junghans did a pretty good job of matching those acrylics with their Sapphires.
At the center, we have pencil style hands featuring loom to match these
small dots of loom at the dial's quarter hour marks, which adds a bit of utility
without sacrificing the elegance of the piece in general.
In the world of watch dials, this is one of the simplest dials out there.
However, it finds completeness through absence rather than feeling deficient.
And I think that's one of the best things about the Maxwell.
Now, while the Maxwell appeals to a mid-20th century approach, the Orion
is a bit more contemporary while still upholding a healthy sense of minimalism
of utilizing omittance as an asset.
Now, in its execution, there are noticeable steps up in finish that are certainly
apparent with applied golden hour markers, tempered blue hands, with the sub
seconds at the six, done with a fine circular finish only fully appreciated
when getting very close, especially here with this macro lens.
Many of the same shared attributes of the Maxwell are here, legible markings
that are non-descript doing their job, a less pronounced domed crystal, but a
domed crystal nevertheless, a balance in its use of space, and a unique take on
typography that of course feels familiar given its inclusion on Nomos's pieces.
Now it's hard to declare a true winner here in the area of the dial, given both
are approaching their execution slightly differently.
However, the movements within these watches are probably going to be the number
one point of differentiating these two from one another, and is going to be the
main reason for the price jump of the Nomos compared to the Junghans watch.
To follow the traditional order so far, the Junghans operates with a straightforward
third-party caliber, the most ubiquitous one that you can find with the ETA 2824.
It's perhaps the most respected workhorse watch caliber out there on the market
today, and if you're interested, I covered basically all the third-party movements,
including this ETA 2824 in a recent video, kind of just giving a lay of the land of
all the third-party movements out there.
While it's nothing sexy and lives under a closed case back, the ETA 2824 is
frankly never a bad choice, and is a principal reason for the accessible
price point of this Junghans Maxwell.
It offers peace of mind through its serviceability and regulation, while also
having decades-old of a track record in the market to offer really proof to its
acclaim.
In terms of specs, we're looking at a 28,800 vibration per hour beat rate, 4
hertz, hacking and handwinding, so hacking stopping the second hand when pulling
out the crown to the farthest position, and has a power reserve of 38 hours.
One point of emphasis though, this one does have a go state, which is a little
strange, so when you pull out the crown to the second position, it will have at
least the activation of, as if you were changing the date, but there is actually
a date window on this variant.
So a little bit weird, doesn't actually affect the wear at all, but could be
confusing for some people.
Now being an automatic watch, you could maybe frame an argument for how the
Junghans is, say, more practical in some respects compared to the Nomos, but it's
important to understand the full context around the Alpha Manual again, as it is
really a fantastic movement and a huge just accomplishment in Nomos' just short,
but impressive history.
Before 2005, a watch like this from Nomos would have had utilized a Peugeot 7001.
It's a well-regulated ETA made hand-wound caliber that has been around for 40 plus
years.
However, in recent time, ETA's supply became an increasing issue for brands like
the size of Nomos, considering their production volume and tendency of ETA just
simply kind of just run out of production with sometimes not the fairest of warning.
Now with this in mind, Nomos set out to produce their own calibers inspired by the
design of the Peugeot 7001, being produced in-house by Nomos themselves.
Now, apart from its accomplishment, it does come with an incredibly slim 2.6
millimeters in thickness, helping to achieve its thin case of 17 jewels,
glass-suited waves across the surface, glued screws, and perlage finishing on the
main plate.
Now the Alpha Manual comes in with a 21,600 vibration per hour beat rate, 3
hertz, features hacking and hand-winding, and has a power reserve of 43 hours.
Now when looking at the Alpha Manual caliber, of course it is going to be
inspired by a Peugeot 7001, but what this movement really meant for Nomos was a
ton.
I mean, it really opened the floodgates for them to produce now well over a dozen
in-house calibers and doing incredibly impressive things in that world as well.
And from a finishing standpoint, I think this is one of the best looking movements
you're going to find for under $3,000.
So Tudor unveiled those BlackBerry 58s with their movements on display.
Looking at this movement compared to that, and this isn't even the DUW
movements that Nomos makes, this thing looks absolutely great for the money.
All right, so now that we've looked at both of these pieces, let's look at some
general just things to consider.
So when I look at Junghans versus Nomos, and why I'm trying to talk about the
Bajas influence of two of these pieces, I think there are many shared principles
and understanding of where they arise that allows these two to be similar, but
also very different.
For Junghans, it's a brand that's been around since the 19th century, of course,
and has changed quite a bit, but the Max Bill, I think very much personifies the
brand and where it currently sits, arising from that mid 20th century form of Bajas
design.
And with that, you're going to have a window into this brand that is very
different than that of Nomos, which is much more contemporary and where it rose
up in terms of its growth as a brand, very different period for the country in
which it occupies, as well as just a different approach in terms of its overall
direction towards its influence in Bauhaus.
With that being considered, I don't think you necessarily consider both of these
watches as completely the same.
When I look at Junghans, I look at mid 20th century design.
I see that influence from the wall clock.
It's minimalism as a pursuit, not minimalism as absence of thought.
The same thing can be said for Nomos, an excuse of just lines and open space and
how it's executed, but I love how both of these watches do kind of go against the
grain in many ways.
Maybe not as much nowadays, just because there are a lot of this influence in
industrial design where some people might see these as kind of plain or sterile in
terms of their approach, but I don't see it as that at all.
And I think if you kind of dig a little bit deeper into these brands, if you can
have that type of appreciation in terms of looking at them side by side, which one
is best for which type of individual.
I don't think price should be the main consideration because again, the designs
are very different in what they're going for.
Mid 20th century versus more kind of modern avant-garde with the lugs and
everything about the Orion.
I see them as more apples and oranges and I see them apples to apples, despite
many people asking, which one should I go for?
Of course, price is going to be a limiting factor, but if you want to get into true
Bauhaus design, I think Junghans, of course, is going to be a little bit more pure
to that.
If you want something a bit more contemporary, I would certainly go for the
Nomos Orion, as well as maybe some of their other dress watches that might have a
different just approach to it with subtle differences.
I think for wearability, they both wear a little bit larger for kind of some
different reasons.
For Junghans, it's more of that heavily domed crystal, thin bezel.
Nomos, a lot of those shared attributes there, but also on top of that, you have
those very long, striking lugs on this.
In terms of which one to go for, 35, 38, that's really going to come down to you.
I think 38 is going to be good for, I would say, more people out there.
Honestly, if you're a smaller wristed individual, like just more classic wear of
a dress piece and you want to have this be more of a dress watch, 35 is probably
going to be a better choice for you, but I like both of these watches.
They kind of walk that line of casual versus dressy, and I think that's great
for a modern context.
Then finally, what is the reason for the price increase?
I think it became pretty apparent.
The finishing on the Nomos is going to be elevated.
You are getting a nice return on that if you are looking at the details of the
actual dial surface.
You got applied markers, a fine finish within the sub-dial, and of course, the
movement.
That's going to be the main reason why the price difference here.
Whether or not you think it's actually worth it, that's up to you, but I don't
think it's a matter of saving money in this case.
I don't think it's a matter of just looking at both of these as the same thing.
They both do a great job, and if you understand the ethos of what Bauhaus is
all about, it's about going against the grain, collecting different ideas, and I
think both of these kind of do that in different ways.
Nomos arrives from the 1990s when German culture was changing so much, followed
the Berlin Wall, and it really was about going against the traditional norms and
kind of following that pursuit.
And in terms of Junghans, of course, being very true to traditional Bauhaus, having
a Max Bill actually designing this piece, you can't really get more Bauhaus than
that, and when adapting from a wall clock to a wristwatch, there's just a lot of
the elements, going against the grain, being unique, using minimalism as a
pursuit rather than absence of thought, using space as an actual tool in actual
design.
I think it all is here, and I love these watches.
I think they're great windows into this world of casual and dressy watches in
2021 still.
But alright guys, I'd love to see your comments down below.
Which one of these two watches would you go for, and why?
Please leave comments, I'd love to see them down there.
Also, if you did enjoy this video, thumbs up, subscribe, and hit the bell icon.
I really do enjoy both of these watches, and if you do like them, I will have links
down below to purchase these watches on TeddyBauhaus.com, a full authorized
dealer, full factory warranty, you're completely covered.
Anything goes wrong, full peace of mind when going in your direction, and also
allows us to make this content all possible.
Also, if you want to stay up to date with giveaways, as well as just stay up to date
with the content, of course, subscribe here, hit that bell icon, but also follow
me on Instagram, I have some cool photos of watches going on out there as well.
But guys, thank you again so much for watching.
Be well, and I'll see you all very soon.