Noam Chomsky: Finding a Common Language with an Alien Species

NatTech and Science
190 followers
I apologize for the absurd philosophical question, but if an alien species were to
visit Earth, do you think we would be able to find a common language or protocol of communication
with them?
There are arguments to the effect that we could.
In fact, one of them was Marvin Minsky's.
Back about 20 or 30 years ago, he performed a brief experiment with a student of his,
Dan Bobrow.
They essentially ran the simplest possible Turing machines, just free, to see what would
happen.
Most of them crashed, either got into an infinite loop or stopped.
The few that persisted essentially gave something like arithmetic.
His conclusion from that was that if some alien species developed higher intelligence,
they would at least have arithmetic, they would at least have what the simplest computer
would do.
In fact, he didn't know that at the time, but the core principles of natural language
are based on operations which yield something like arithmetic in the limiting case and the
minimal case.
So it's conceivable that a mode of communication could be established based on the core properties
of human language and the core properties of arithmetic, which maybe are universally
shared.
So it's conceivable.
