In the late 1950’s a new threat emerged from the Soviet Union for which the Americans were seemingly caught off guard. The latest generation of Soviet nuclear-powered submarines could reach incredible speeds. The Alfa-Class submarine under development at the time would eventually be capable of travelling at 41 knots (76 kph/47 mph) while fully submerged. At such speeds, these submarines could follow American fleets while easily evading ASW ships. Large, fast, ocean-going hydrofoils seemed like the answer.
The principle behind a hydrofoil was simple enough; by using water as a medium of flight, much like an airplane uses air, a hydrofoil could ‘fly’ rather than plow through water. Using a set of underwater wing-like structures called foils, these ships could lift out of the water as they accelerated, significantly reducing drag and allowing for much higher speeds and efficiency.
The first practical hydrofoil was demonstrated in 1906 by Italian inventor Enrico Forlanini. In the decades that followed, hydrofoils were progressively refined and in the 1950’s the first passenger hydrofoils were beginning to emerge on rivers and lakes. Almost all of these early hydrofoils used a configuration commonly referred to as ‘surface-piercing’ where the foils operate along the surface of the water. The configuration is dynamically stable and self-correcting as a result of the foil’s shape (typically curved) and the position of the center of gravity in relation to the foil. A major drawback is that operation along the water’s surface makes surface-piercing hydrofoils easily disturbed by waves and rough conditions. Surface-piercing hydrofoils are generally considered unsuitable for open ocean travel.
In the 1950’s the U.S. Navy took significant interest in a second hydrofoil configuration commonly referred to as ‘fully submerged’. Unlike surface-piercing hydrofoils, fully submerged hydrofoils have foils that operate entirely underwater beneath waves. This makes them far more suitable in rough conditions and open water. A major drawback is that they are not dynamically stable and require continual adjustments to the foil angle of attack to vary the lift generated. For decades an automated method of controlling the foils remained elusive.
With new emerging technologies in the 1950's and 1960's, like sophisticated sensors, autopilots and computers, the fully submerged hydrofoil configuration became far more practical. The U.S. Navy saw them as a potentially ground-breaking solution, ideally suited for ASW. Research and development efforts would culminate in a series of prototype ships, the most impressive being the 320-ton USS Plainview.
Thanks for watching!
In the spring of 1969, the U.S. Navy begins testing its newest vessel.
But this is no ordinary ship.
It doesn't float on top of the water.
It can lift itself right out of it.
And because of that, it can do what no other ship can.
Move at unheard of speeds, operate in rough seas,
and outmaneuver anything else on the water.
60 years ago, the U.S. Navy set out to build ships that could fly.
In the 1960s, the U.S. Navy was the most capable in the world,
ready to project power to any corner of the planet.
But military planners were growing concerned about a new threat from the Soviet Union.
Soviet nuclear-powered submarines were becoming faster,
more capable, and being built in large numbers.
The latest generation under development would reach an incredible 41 knots fully submerged.
Speeds that would allow them to hunt down any ship in the U.S. fleet,
even outrun torpedoes.
They would also dive to record depths, making them extremely difficult to intercept.
With their new submarines, the Soviets could shadow American carrier groups anywhere in the world
and launch a devastating strike at a moment's notice.
Destroyers and frigates might detect the incoming subs using sophisticated sonar,
but they'd have no way of closing the distance to engage them.
The Navy would need to develop much faster ships.
And they'd do it by turning to a technology that was already 50 years old.
In 1906, an Italian engineer devised a way to make a boat go a lot faster.
Using a series of foils, essentially underwater wings,
his boat could lift out of the water as it accelerated,
reducing drag, allowing for much higher speeds.
It was called a hydrofoil, and a decade later,
inventor Alexander Graham Bell improved on the design,
building a hydrofoil that set a new all-time marine speed record,
demonstrating the awesome potential of the technology.
In the decades that followed, the hydrofoil was progressively improved.
And in the 1950s, commercial hydrofoils were entering into service.
But hydrofoils received little attention from the U.S. Navy.
Because, for the most part, they were only suited for calmer waters,
not out on the ocean, where the Navy needed them.
That's because most hydrofoils worked by skimming close to the surface,
a design that made them stable, but easily affected by waves,
limiting their use to calmer lakes and waterways.
But there was a second way to build a hydrofoil.
By positioning the foils entirely underwater,
they would be unaffected by the waves above,
allowing for smooth operation even in rough seas.
The problem was that design wasn't dynamically stable,
meaning somehow the foils would have to be continually adjusted to keep the craft level.
And it wasn't until the 1960s that the technologies needed to make it work
really came into existence.
It was around this time that the U.S. Navy realized that ocean-going hydrofoils
could be the answer to the Soviet challenge.
With their speed and ability to operate in virtually any condition,
hydrofoils could chase down Soviet subs,
making them ideal for anti-submarine warfare.
Plainview, the Navy's fourth hydrofoil,
was built to evaluate the potential of large ocean-going hydrofoils.
By 1970, the U.S. Navy had four prototype hydrofoils under evaluation,
with the two largest being the 110-ton USS Highpoint
and the 320-ton Plainview, at the time the world's largest.
But on the drawing board were conceptual designs for even larger ships,
ranging all the way up to 2,500 tons.
Destroyer escort-sized hydrofoils that could even be equipped with helicopters.
But before many of that,
each of the Navy's prototype ships would need to be put through their paces
to evaluate various foil configurations and propulsion systems.
Hydrofoils are expected to operate in the open ocean,
where they may be subjected to severe storms.
The ships were also fitted with the latest armament to test their combat potential,
including operating guns while moving at high speed,
launching torpedoes, and firing anti-ship and anti-aircraft missiles.
For the largely traditional Navy, hydrofoils were a radical departure,
involving new technologies that blurred the lines between naval and aviation.
And nowhere was this more apparent than on Plainview.
At hull-borne speeds, Plainview operated much like a conventional ship,
powered by a pair of 600-horsepower diesel engines.
But when it needed to get up and go,
Plainview's crew would hydraulically lower the foils
and run up a pair of 14,000-horsepower gas turbines.
The two jet engines were largely the same ones used on fighter jets like the F-4 Phantom.
They transferred power through an intricate transmission system,
which drove two super-cavitating titanium propellers at the end of each foil.
With this setup, Plainview could fly at over 50 knots.
But the ship was designed to be upgraded with an additional set of jet engines
and a super-cavitating foil system, which would allow for speeds of up to 90 knots.
The ship's foils were connected to an automatic control system,
which functioned much like the autopilot on an aircraft.
This system continually adjusted angle of attack to maintain level flight,
using readings from a sonic height sensor, accelerometer, and a set of gyros,
allowing Plainview to maintain high speeds even in 10-foot waves.
As the most ambitious of all of the Navy's experimental ships,
Plainview would help lay the groundwork for large, ocean-going hydrofoils.
The Navy issued requirements for Plainview in 1960,
with Grumman winning the bid for design in 1961.
Two years later, the project was transferred to Lockheed for construction.
And when the ship was launched in the summer of 1965,
it was hailed as a technological marvel, an exciting sign of things to come.
But beneath the surface, there was already a sense that things
weren't going to go according to plan.
For starters, a series of strikes at Lockheed shipyards delayed the program.
It meant Plainview wouldn't make its first high-speed test run until March of 1968.
And even then, it was plagued with deficiencies that
should have been sorted out at a much earlier stage.
By 1969, the ship was already three years behind schedule and 100% over budget.
At that point, the Navy decided to take matters into their own hands,
accepting the unfinished ship to try and work out the issues themselves.
But it would be easier said than done.
Each of the Navy's four prototype ships were one-of-a-kind experimental designs.
It meant development resources would have to be stretched across all four,
further slowing progress.
In May of 1974, the Navy sent Plainview to Dry Dock to undergo a major two-year overhaul.
Enhancements included a more refined hydraulic system and an advanced digital autopilot.
After the overhaul, Plainview was a better ship,
more capable out at sea, and much more reliable.
But many in the Navy had already grown impatient with the ship's protracted development,
while others wanted nothing to do with hydrofoils.
For all their advantages, hydrofoils also had a few critical drawbacks.
Compared to conventional warships, they were weight-critical, requiring aluminum hulls,
which were neither as strong nor as cost-effective to build.
Weight limitations also meant hydrofoils would be less armored and carry less armament.
Their complex foils and dual propulsion systems would make them
less dependable and more maintenance-heavy, consuming a greater share of the Navy's budget.
And when it came to anti-submarine warfare,
by the mid-1970s there were more practical alternatives.
The Navy had made huge strides in utilizing aircraft to track and hunt down submarines,
which were more effective and economical to operate.
It meant the case for large, ocean-going hydrofoils like Plainview
no longer seemed as compelling as it once was.
Pegasus PHM-1 was the first ship in a new class of hydrofoils.
After more than a decade of research and development,
the US Navy did eventually put a hydrofoil into production.
At 240 tons, the Pegasus class was significantly smaller than Plainview,
and nowhere near the size of the large, ocean-going hydrofoils once studied by the Navy.
Instead of hunting down submarines,
Pegasus ships were designed for coastal patrol on smaller seas like the Baltic.
At one point, there were plans to build 44 ships,
with German and Italian navies showing interest.
But after extensive research and development,
only six entered service with the US Navy,
and they were retired after just 10 years due to high operating costs and lack of a useful mission.
In 1978, the Navy's budget for experimental hydrofoil development
was suddenly cut from $2.2 million a year to zero,
sinking any prospects for further hydrofoil development.
In the 1960s, faith in technological progress was at an all-time high.
With an endless stream of fantastical concepts that would allow us to travel a lot faster.
But one idea that seemed destined to become reality was supersonic travel.
Billions were poured into developing technologies for a new generation of airliners
that would travel two or even three times the speed of sound,
making a round trip to any corner of the globe possible in less than a day.
In my next big project, I'm going to explore why the dream of mass supersonic air travel
never became reality.
And imagine what the world would have looked like if it did,
by creating an alternative universe and an entirely new kind of mustard video.
And it's all possible because of Nebula.
Nebula is where you can watch more mustard videos,
from fantastical concepts to iconic aircraft.
My most ambitious video to date covers the story of the legendary B-2 Spirit,
a plane engineered to fly into any airspace in the world,
no matter how heavily defended.
Nebula is full of exclusive content from creators like Real Engineering,
Wendover and Real Life Lore.
On Nebula, there's no algorithm that punishes creators for trying something new
or taking risks on big-budget projects.
And because Nebula is completely ad-free,
creators aren't limited to making content that YouTube deems advertiser-friendly.
Nebula is still free when you sign up for CuriosityStream,
a streaming service featuring thousands of award-winning documentaries.
A recent favorite of mine is Dornier, Pioneer of Aviation,
a fascinating two-part documentary that takes a deep dive into the story
of one of the most iconic aircraft builders of the 20th century.
Get unlimited access to both CuriosityStream and Nebula for just a little over a dollar a month
by going to curiositystream.comslashmustard
and use the promo code mustard when you sign up.