In this episode of Texas RoundUP, we sit down with Thomas Mustac, Senior Publicist at Otter PR and a specialist in crisis communication. Together, we delve into the high-stakes world of crisis management and how it diverges from everyday public relations. Topics include the Hollywood controversy involving Ryan Reynolds, Blake Lively, and Justine Baldoni, the role of public relations in addressing conflicts, the influence of mainstream media, and behind-the-scenes insights into guiding clients through high-profile dilemmas. Whether you’re a PR pro, media enthusiast, or just curious about Hollywood's messy moments, this episode offers an insider’s perspective you won’t want to miss!
How could one social media post determine your career that you've built upon for 15 years,
20 years? But people latch on to things and it's easy to forget stuff, but once it's brought to
fruition on a bigger stage like this is when people don't forget those little things. It's dangerous.
So can you give me a little bit about your background and what you do,
like the work you do at Otter PR?
Absolutely. So nearly half a decade in PR. Before Otter, I was at the Dr. Oz show in New York
Medical College doing some medical PR there. And then now at Otter, I've been here now three years,
basically working with a range of clients between tech, Bitcoin, it comes to your,
not just crypto, I mean, it goes all across the board. I feel like every day is another challenge,
but we have clients from many different backgrounds. I do a lot of our crisis work
as well whenever those challenges arise. So that's got to be interesting. And I guess,
in what ways, because I know they're similar, but they're different. How does crisis management PR
differ from everyday PR that you do for somebody? So yeah, everyday PR, we like to look at it as if
somebody has a story that they want to tell and it kind of comes back. I always pull my heritage
into it just because my folks are first generation immigrants in the United States. So it's always
the individuals that don't have the chance to spread their story. So we love to be storytellers
here at Otter. But with crisis, it's always, and I think we spoke about this before, it's a little
bit of you want to believe your client, but then you also want to also say that you want to plan
for the worst. And sometimes you don't have to use those worst case scenarios, and hopefully
you don't have to, but it's a little bit more of being on your toes, ready to change in a second.
Whereas when you're working everyday PR, you know, you're trying to push A, you push A,
you want to push B, you push B. It's a lot more hands-on, I would say, than traditional PR.
So you might have a situation like, so you might try to head off something before it happens,
but then you might also have to be putting out a fire once it does occur.
Exactly. And you're looking a lot more, I would say, into public perception. So when you're trying
to utilize those plans and look for your 1A, your 1B, and try to compare those two plans,
you kind of want to push a little bit of that plan and then see how the public reacts or how
the media reacts, and then always say, oh, well, maybe this from your other plan would work here,
and it's always like an intertwined web. So you always plan for the worst, hope for the best
kind of thing. And have some backup plans there too. Backup plans, some prayers, whatever it
takes to get the job done kind of thing. But also your client could determine it as well,
because you might be planning and say, oh, well, this is never going to happen. And when you say
that, the worst case scenario happens, unfortunately. But you always try to think of what
can happen, what won't happen, and try to work around it as best as you can as a crisis
professional and as a practitioner. And I know right now, I mean, Hollywood's had its share,
business and Hollywood, but right now there's that case right now is making the news,
and it continues to as Ryan Reynolds and Blake Lively, their actions towards Justin Baldoni,
but also his, he's saying they had actions against him, which led to a lawsuit on both sides.
So what's going on here? What are some of the key factors happening?
So this is a very unique one. Both actors, actresses, actor and actresses,
they're beloved by the public, and everybody loves the movie that they put out. It's been
getting many different reviews. But the point is, their backgrounds were usually clean.
Ryan Reynolds as well, he has a great background, everybody loves him from Deadpool.
But it's mixing a very unique take in the sense that we're looking at these Hollywood icons,
which we loved on big screen, we've made our, oh, they're the perfect couple picture in our head,
and nothing could happen outside that window frame. And now this crisis takes on a whole
other ballgame in the sense that we're seeing a little bit of the media weaponized, I would say,
because the second that Blake Lively put out her whole accusation, I would say, but it's not even
an accusation, it's a whole court case going on here where Justin might have potentially done
something. It kind of asks you who's telling the truth. So you're kind of pulling, well,
Blake Lively is the perfect picture child of an actress, she can't possibly have done anything
wrong here, maybe it's Justin. And then you kind of pull your own personal opinion on is it the guy
versus the girl, is it the girl versus the guy. And it's a very, I kind of say it's a psychological
take of who would you believe the most based upon their previous accomplishments. And when she put
out her accusation, she also had an article with the New York Times go live. And people started
to wonder, oh, well, maybe the New York Times article had something to do with the lawsuit.
And it was a little tandem there of attacking Justin's image. And also with Deadpool potentially
being that Justin was the picture person of one of the characters that was killed in the movie. So
it's a little bit of, we're seeing an actual court case unfold, but it's also mixing a public opinion,
and it's just a total mess, no matter how you look at it, which is really crazy.
I know. And the publicists are involved in all of these. They're also involved in the
lawsuit. I think there's some lawsuit against them as well. They're kind of
in the mix of this situation. So as a PR person, how does that play out for them,
you think? I know that's got to be difficult. Well, that's the thing too. So it brings in
ethics as a PR person as well, because you want to believe your client. You want to say,
especially something as serious as this, when it comes to the courtroom, you want
legal matters to play out in the courtroom, but you want to stay behind your client.
So it could be career-changing at the end of this, in the sense that
potentially that practitioner might be looked at differently if they represent the wrong side.
You kind of have to be the detective and say, are you defending the right person?
And if you find out you're defending the wrong person, you might have to come out to defend
yourself as a practitioner. So it's a very, very intense situation where you're going to have to
put your career on the line and go down with history in that sense a little bit.
And with this kind of situation, and not that they could prevent it in any ways,
but with stuff like that, how, as somebody in that crisis management, do you try to
put guardrails to prevent these kinds of situations? Is there anything you can do?
So usually I always say you want to know your client, if not even them as an individual like
this, it could be just their day-to-day. How do they go about what? What type of individual are
they outside of the big screen, outside of an office? You never know an individual truly until
they open up to you. So we always say it could be talk to your client about the family life,
talk to your client about what are they doing, whether it be going to the park, going here,
going there. I always try to break a barrier and try to get at least a good sense of how they are
ethically as an individual. The second you start hearing, oh, well, who gives XYZ? Who gives that?
I just want my name clear. It kind of gives you red flags and you start wondering, well,
if they said this, do they mean that? And that's where you start saying, well, maybe I should plan
a different way or start looking at it a different way. And you kind of learn from
previous crises. And that's where I'm a little bit of a nerd where I see a crisis like this.
It's a learning experience for me in the sense that it could prepare you as a practitioner better
to say, well, if it went wrong here, you could prepare XYZ in the future. If it went right there,
this is what you can take and utilize it into your PR plan. So you're always learning and
taking notes from other crises to prepare for your own or your clients as well.
And like we were talking about the New York Times, how did the mainstream media
play a part in this situation, do you think?
And this is where I said it previously, where it's weaponizing the media a little bit in the sense
that if there's a reporter, and I believe the reporter from the New York Times, she was well
known for being the actual reporter for the movement and the Shia movement in Hollywood.
It's an interesting, and I'm not a conspiracy theorist, it's just a lot of you watch these
videos of people taking it in and saying it's an interesting report to use for this type of
article. Because when Blake Lively came out for her court case and for her accusations,
it's an interesting investigative report to use in that situation. And then when you start getting
all this information about the movie, it just seems that you're trying to sway public opinion
in a certain way by using a certain journalist, using a certain publication,
just based on the reach. So I feel like it's a very, you see it often in PR, unfortunately,
in the background where you're like, oh, I want to target this outlet, that outlet. And it's just
because you're trying to get public opinion on your side. And whether that be your client is
trying to clear themselves from a crisis, certain outlets are utilized because it's the niche
publication, niche messaging for said client. And in this case, it was kind of more used towards,
I mean, it's a case going on, a lawsuit, but it was kind of being used as a derogatory thing
towards Justin. So it's kind of like he was, without being found guilty yet or without
anything happening, coming to play, he was kind of like a bad light was shed on him, I guess.
Exactly. And you're hoping with media relations, especially when you hire a practitioner or
a publicist, you always have those media relations to at least work your story into the media.
It might not be that the reporter even sees eye to eye with you. As long as you're presenting your
facts, it can completely change the narrative based upon who reads those publications.
And that's where I always say sometimes clients as well, even on regular PR, you might want your
Forbes, you might want your top tier outlets, your dream outlets. However, are they reaching
the messaging that you want? Because sometimes you're so niche where you're 10% of who you're
trying to go out to might not be reading your Forbes. You might want to go more for like a
localized publication or somebody that's in your industry. And that's where a little bit of PR work
comes into magic, where you want to work with your client to achieve their goals and get their
message out there. But sometimes their best interest, especially something like this,
maybe they are trying to target outlets where there might be women, moms, everybody that checks
those boxes of somebody that relates with LikeLively more than Justin kind of thing comes
into play. And there's definitely players in the background. I mean, I always say it's a game of
chess. You kind of move one step forward, and then you might want to try to move backward. It might
be too late. So that's where public opinion comes into play as well. And social media is another
animal in a sense, where it can take on a narrative and just people run with it. And that's
where this story, I feel like even once it's done in the courtroom, it's reputation management after
that. It's, well, this is the bad guy. And then now you have to maybe clear that image or maybe...
And that's where it's very dangerous now to especially take a side of Blake versus Justin,
because you don't know who's right. The courtroom is going to determine that. And that's where we
like to have lawyers, especially when you're working in a crisis, because you might have the
plan. You might always say, oh, well, we're preparing this way, that way, for said client.
However, the attorney is always going to have, well, that's the best interest for my client.
This isn't the best interest for my client. So you always want them involved in any crisis,
whether it be good, bad. It's a very interesting one, especially now with things are unfolding
before even the lawsuit unfolds. That is true. They're not even doing it in the courtroom
and I know you were talking about social media with clients as well. Do you have to watch that?
Because sometimes clients get on X or whatever, and they're just ranting and saying whatever and
not... Do they check with you? Is it helpful if they let you know before they start?
Well, there's another animal that I've been reading up in the industry as well, where there's
certain high-powered celebrities, certain high-powered company leaders, where they'll
hire bots in India and across Asia, where they'll just nonstop put comments online,
just to try to sway public opinion and try to get a narrative out there. So this is where social
media, AI is potentially going to be coming into this, where AI bots might just be constantly
putting out press there. Certain outlets have AI content out there. So it's a matter of,
you're always going to need human touch, but it's a matter of that individual putting their
opinion into the AI bot and then spreading this mass propaganda, whether it be good press,
bad press. And I'm actually surprised that it didn't come out in the election this time around,
where you might have election interference from other countries, even more potentially,
whether it be Russia, China, whoever. These AI bots are going to be another animal in crisis,
where you could actually sway an opinion real-time and it might happen. It might not be
this case, but it might be coming down the road as well on that end. So it's a very interesting
thing as well. Oh yeah, I think that is pretty... I know, I didn't even think about that. I know that
they were saying that also AI, and this is people who are up to no good, are also able to
act like they are that person, with them not wanting it. In this case, you're saying they're
hiring, but maybe they're not, and these things are actually coming out and doing things against
the person. Exactly. And this is where these outlets are going to be very handy. And I always
say, it doesn't matter if it's crisis PR or any PR, you don't want to use one news source. You
always want to be well-sourced on any angle before you make your determination. Because,
there's times when I even look online, you'll see comments on stories like,
oh, well look what people are talking about. And then you click open profile,
and it's a million people they're following and only one follower. And you're like, all right,
well, that's a fake profile. And then you start going through and you're like, well, what's real,
what's not real? And that's where I always say AI is going to get them crazy in that sense of
determining what's real, what's not real, and where's your real news, where's your fake news.
This is where we're going to be constantly, I say, crisis experts will never get out of a job,
because there's always going to be, well, public opinion here, public opinion there. And you're
always defending your client in some way, which is scary, because it could happen to anybody.
And then it's just a matter of who has the means to cover themselves in a crisis,
which is even scarier, because the little guy might be suffering more than the bigger
individuals who are better off.
With, yeah, financially, to be able to guard themselves, that's true.
And just in an overall sense, how, as a publicist, do you work with your clients to advise them and
just help assure? And we kind of talked a little bit about it, but what kind of game plan do you
kind of present when you're starting off with somebody?
Well, even our clients who aren't necessarily in a crisis, I always tell them, well,
it's always best to have a backup plan. You always have a framework, at least, of, well,
this is our, and I was using it going back to even my college days of, this is our SWOT.
This is our SWOT analysis. We say our strengths, our weaknesses, opportunities, and our threats.
And you work from that. It could be as simple as preparing for, I mean, if you're a small business,
well, what if you rip off a client? What if you rip off somebody short of a dollar?
As long as you have a basic framework of how to prepare yourself for a business, you could always
build upon that framework and go from there. And it can be as simple as, I mean, I always tell
people you could write on a piece of paper. So that's where I tell my clients every day, well,
who are your enemies? Who are your threats? Who are your competition? What could go wrong?
And then from there, they're at least somewhat of, once a crisis hits, God forbid,
you have that window of, well, this is the SWOT analysis we did back way when,
where could we go from here? You already have your messaging. You have who is your spokesperson. You
have that little bit to at least keep you prepared in that scenario. So that's where I tell my
clients every day. It's always the what ifs. And I mean, that little post that you put back from
when you were a teenager on social media might come to fruition because AI, I mean, you could
search AI for something that came out in 2010 and it'll come up. So that's where it's, you'll never
know what will come up. It might be something that you did in college when you were at those
college parties, sororities, whatever it might be. But you never know how it will affect you later
on when you're doing the career you love. And everything could go back in a snap of an eye.
So it's insane. So then it's just a matter of like, let's say that does surface, you need to
how are you going to frame it? And how it puts you in a better light and doesn't, because sometimes
you can't get rid of it, but you want to put yourself or that person in the best light possible.
Exactly. And that's where people are starting to dig up stuff from Blake Lively and from Justin
from way back when they started their careers. They're like, oh, well, maybe they did this. Maybe
they did that. Maybe they really weren't the good guy. And it's just trying to paint a picture,
paint a narrative, even though they might decide way back while I was in the early stage of my
career doesn't mean anything. So it's a little bit of damage control now, but there are people
as well to defend them from press that might have been from the beginning of their career.
And it might be a little, I would say like a little screw in this big house that they built
already that it's going to make people sway their opinion a certain way, no matter what it might be,
which is insane. Because how could one social media post determine your career that you built
on for 15 years, 20 years? But people latch onto things and it's easy to forget stuff.
But once it's brought to fruition on a bigger stage like this is when people don't forget
those little things. It's dangerous. Yeah, that it sticks with them. Yeah,
that's that's the times I don't want to. I'm like, I don't know if I'd ever want to be like
a Hollywood celebrity. Well, that's where you start to value your privacy and you're starting
to say, well, maybe I should have a public persona, a private persona. But again, in this
game of social media, AI and this technologically driven society, I mean, people post from where
they're on vacation, where they are. And it's very hard to not separate your work life or your
business life from your personal life. It's insane for sure. Very, very true. And if people want to
find out more about Otter PR, where would they go? Definitely. So you go to Otter PR's website,
it's just otterpr.com. There you'll see everything about social media management,
Otter PR, reputational management, regular PR. And we're also on every social media platform.
So as long as you put Otter PR, you'll see the Otter logo pop up there with a little otter and
we're there. All right. Awesome. Well, I really appreciate you joining us today. Thank you so
much for sharing your insight into this case and just, you know, the crisis management as a whole.
Awesome. Thank you so much for having me on. And I appreciate it for sure.