Nautical Mart 15 Inch Buckler Review and Comparisons

Eternal Shield
2 followers
1 Video View·Jan 11, 2026
Continuing my buckler reviews and going large, with mixed results. I apologize for the sound--my mic driver got sabotaged by an update.
Okay, continuing my quick reviews of some of the bucklers that I've picked up in the last
several months as I've been exploring sword and buckler in my HEMA studies.
Well, we started the series a ways back with my review of this 9-inch Get Dressed for Battle,
and one of the things I mentioned in that video is, well, I didn't necessarily feel
terribly safe behind it. I was thinking maybe I should get something a little bit bigger,
try that out. So, went up to an 11-inch, and this is the Armory Replicas I reviewed recently,
talked about the differences in not only size, but weight and handling characteristics,
as well as differences in quality and build. But, of course, while I was out shopping,
I was thinking, well, what about the next size up? So, in this case, I selected a 15-inch
nautical mount buckler. Is it too big? Okay, I'm doing this one pretty much back-to-back
with the review I did on the 11-inch from Armory Replicas, and in that video, I mentioned that
I tweaked my knee a little bit. So, I'm taking it easy from the waist down, working more on my
upper body conditioning, which it turns out bucklers are really good for. I talked about
that in the last video. Let's do a quick comparison, because I want to talk about
not only the differences in size and weight, but handling, build quality, and, well,
potentially function. The first one I got, the 9-inch Get Dressed for Battle,
one-piece construction, 14-gauge steel, weighs one pound, 12 ounces. Pretty handy, and I talked
about what I like about it. And the one thing I wasn't terribly comfortable with, which is just
the amount of protection it potentially gives me because of the size. It's certainly within
historic range for application for arming sword and buckler. If you go back to 133,
usually bucklers are between your 8-9 inches and, say, 12 inches. Okay, going up one.
Armory Replicas. Now, this is listed as 18-gauge steel, but I think they got the steel counts
backwards in terms of gauges. This one feels thicker, weighs two pounds, 12 ounces. Yeah,
feels a lot more solid. Also, two-piece construction as compared to one-piece
construction. And I did a little demonstration in the last one that I'll repeat today,
where I was a little worried about the shape of this thing potentially deflecting the point of
a blade into me, just off the buckler and right into me. And I showed that the rim of this will
actually catch something, potentially. This one has a beefier square rim around the edge and
definitely has more potential for catching and maybe even holding the tip of a blade in the
thrust. So, bonus. Also, the flatness of the body of it. Yeah, different surface angle to impact
against. Seems to make a significant difference. This one gets me back to that one-piece
construction with, again, the sloped semi-conical body. Now, it does feel like it has kind of a thin
rim. This is listed as 14-gauge. Feels as thick as this one. But because this is a larger shield,
it kind of also feels a little thinner. Not flimsy. Not in any sense of the word. It's held
up to impacts, hitting stuff against it, hitting stuff with it. I haven't had any issues that way.
It's held up just fine to what I've been doing so far. Weight. 3 pounds, 14 ounces. Yeah, significantly
heavier. Heavier, in fact, than pretty much all of my swords. So, quite a workout to hold an extension,
but with the balance grip feel not unwieldy. Let's talk about that a little bit. Now, surface.
You have these little strips on here, which could potentially bind a blade or a tip, and we'll talk
about build quality in a second. You do have the folded over rim, which looks a little thin, but
it'll catch the tip of a blade. So, that's fine. Let's look on the back.
This one, as I mentioned, came bare steel. Has some pretty sizable rivets
through the two sides of the handle, but again, people are worried about that potentially breaking.
This one, I talked about how it came painted on the back, and I had to immediately strip it off
because the paint job was just so horrible. Just flaking off all over the place. Thinner rivets
holding the handle on. Again, they haven't failed yet. I can certainly replace them with bolts if I need to.
This kind of has more of this one going for it, in certain ways. Looking at the back.
All right. So, this is what the matte black paint job probably should have looked like.
There are a couple of nicks in it from use, but it's not bad, especially as compared to the
condition the other one came in. So, at least they got the paint on and it stayed on.
Now, you'll notice you also have the wooden handle, where you've got the metal strip and then
two wooden scales. Now, this one has two really skinny little pins through those wooden scales,
and I told you I had to reshape this one entirely because it was so bad, just to keep it from giving
me splinters. This one I had to round a little bit, not much. It's got thicker rivets through it.
It gives me a little bit more confidence, but it also gives me a squarer grip. It's not as rounded
as the other two, so indexing it is very different. I can still rotate it if I need to, but, you know,
given the extra weight, it's not hard at all to hold steady. I feel like I have a beefy grip on
something, and when it comes to, well, other kinds of weapons, if I have a good grippy, beefy grip,
it helps mitigate the weight. If that makes any sense, if you've experienced something similar.
So, yeah, this doesn't feel as heavy as it is, but it's still a workout, especially if I'm
holding it extended. So, rivets on either side of it, though, they're kind of small.
Gets me back to worrying about it shearing off. Height of grip. Talked about how that
changes the balance and handling of it. This has a grip that's very close to the boss.
This one's got one that's very high. Moves my hand away from the mass of it, so it's hard
to keep it still, but it flips quickly. This one, well, between the square grip and where the
height of the handle is sitting in that cone, it does lean a little bit more to stability over flip.
But, as I showed you, I can still move it around. Now, one other concern I have with build quality,
and it's kind of a minor nitpick. Use the same rivets all over, including putting the handle
together, which is the same thing they did on this. Does that mean the rivets holding the
handle together are too small and weak? Well, we'll see. But when they put these strips on here,
three rivets, right? Let's do the count. One, two, three. One, two, three. One, two, three. One, two.
See it? There's a dent. It looks like they came in with whatever tool or
jig or whatever they were going to use to put it in there, and they either didn't drill the hole,
or they didn't push it, or things got deflected. So, it left a little impression. Yeah, there's
no rivet there, so I may have to drill that out and put my own in there just for symmetry.
I've resisted the temptation. But also, the edges of these little strips are curled up a little bit
here and there. I didn't do that with the use. They kind of came that way. It's not bad.
It could actually give me more little edgy things to catch blades with, so that could be a bonus.
But then, on the other side, when those rivets come through, you don't have the rivet heads on
the other side. They're just kind of cut off, and some of them are cut off that they leave pretty
jagged little stems. Now, none of them have come anywhere near close to my handle arm,
so I haven't felt the need to do anything about it. But yeah, the quality control on these bits
kind of bugs me. It's a little disappointing. The rest of the shield is fine. Speaking of shield,
let's talk about size. Okay, so 133 sword and buckler, recommending something between, say,
8 and 12 inches. This is a bit big for that, and yeah, it does feel a bit big. It doesn't feel like
I have the freedom of movement for some of those techniques. Not as bad if I go up to something
like a side sword for, say, you know, bolognese style, or I use this actually in a quick
demonstration in place of a targe in a previous video where I showed it along with a back sword.
Broad sword. It's not a targe because it's a little too small to be a targe,
and it's not a strap shield. I don't have a good targe. I don't have a targe yet.
Planning to get one in the future, but in the meantime, it's functioning in its place okay.
Speaking of which, I've also been working with this in combination with a Viking-era sword
because I don't have a Viking-era shield, which is a boss grip shield, but, well,
significantly bigger. But at least for now, this gives me something to practice moving my sword
around a shield. So, it's kind of in between a buckler and a larger shield. So, in a way,
sword of the best of both worlds or weaknesses of both. Yeah. Would this be a useful thing for
your practice? Well, it kind of depends on the style you're studying, the techniques you're
using, the weapon sets you're using. I've been making a lot of use of this. Not necessarily
purely traditionally, but it did spill some niches until I get some, well,
more appropriate gear. And when I do, I will certainly do more reviews. Now, I do have one
more review coming of a buckler, so I'll get to that as soon as I can. But until then, if you
have any questions about this one, any of the others, if you have a buckler shield that you
like or one that you bought and you loathe, tell me about those in the comments, as usual.
But until I do, well, well, whatever I get myself into next, as usual, thanks for watching,
following, subscribing, sharing, liking, commenting, and I'll see you back for, well,
at least one more buckler review.
