You won’t believe what people do when they think no one’s watching! The hit hidden-camera series “What Would You Do?,” hosted by ABC News’ John Quiñones, returns to ABC for a historic 17th season with episodes available the next day on Hulu. Quiñones welcomes guest correspondents Sara Haines, co-host of “The View,” as they observe how real people react when tricky situations and moral dilemmas arise in public settings. #WWYD#WhatWouldYouDo#SocialExperiment#ABC
Research shows that modern parents are less likely to enforce traditional gender roles
when raising their children compared to previous generations.
But of course, gender expression is a hot button issue in America.
And when it comes to our kids, not everyone is in agreement.
I think that there should be certain gender roles. I firmly do. I think that positive
masculinity is a good thing. Gender roles should be there, should be specific.
None of this mixed bashing genders. I think there's some place for tradition
still, but it's definitely like a spectrum. I'm not going to judge you for wearing a pink
shirt or having long hair, short hair or whatever. It's really what's in your heart that counts.
So today we're in Reno, Nevada at Junkie Clothing Exchange,
where our actress is playing a mom out shopping with her son.
And she doesn't approve at how he's accessorizing. What do you think, mom? Can I get these?
Oh, no. What are you doing? Those are for girls. But I told you, mom, I like this.
Boys don't wear things like that, sweetheart. But I want to wear it.
Don't you want to be a man? I don't care. I like this.
I appreciate you and you're so creative, but... No, absolutely not.
If you saw this mother refuse to accept her child's gender role, what would you do?
Here we go. Here we go. What do you think?
Mason, I'm raising you to be a man. Boys don't wear pink.
I just like pink. I hear that, but no, it's for girls.
I love your outfit. It's so cute. Isn't it?
I love that. Yeah, but he looks silly.
See? For what it's worth,
I'm pretending to be an adult. I'm bad at it.
She's pretending. Why can't I? That's for girls, okay?
This woman sees mom's concern and offers some diplomatic advice to our young actor.
I also had to wait until I was older to find my true self.
Sometimes we gotta wait a few years, unfortunately, but if you keep it in your heart,
you'll find a lot more love for yourself and for others as you get older.
But I do believe that your mother is doing what she thinks is best.
Exactly. That's amazing.
I may not agree with it, but I know your mother is doing what she thinks is right
out of love and care. Wow.
Do you think I'm too traditional? We were all raised in a certain way that
society forced us to be and to think. Would you like a hug?
I do. Okay.
Come here. Wow.
Wow. This is amazing.
I didn't care about patterns or styles. I just, whatever I thought was pretty.
And I was always just shoved into a box. Hi there.
How are you? I'm John Quinones.
I knew it. What would you do?
No, come over here. Wow.
What a lecture you've given us. Really amazing.
Why get involved? What did you hear that bothered you?
That bag pink is for girls. Yeah.
And you felt the mom needed to be told something.
And then I realized she just needed compassion. Why does it touch you so deeply?
I was born in a large Catholic family, and then I was also raised in Mormon, Utah.
And so there was just a whole lot of roles and boxes people are forced into.
You were giving the little boy a voice, maybe the voice you never got.
Definitely the voice I never got. You're shattering gender roles.
Good. They need to be shattered.
The store is full of clothes and accessories for every style.
So when our little girl picks out a non-traditional outfit,
will shoppers get involved with mom when she pushes her daughter closer to societal norms?
Viola, you look like a boy.
Girls don't grow up to be firefighters, sweetheart. That's not very feminine.
I'd be a firefighter if I wanted to.
Heart, you look like a boy. Come on. Look at all these beautiful dresses to put on.
There we go. Getting involved.
You just have to wear a dress.
Oh, well, we usually like to wear dresses in our family.
We want her to be a woman, you know?
She can be a woman in jeans.
Well, it's actually just more about the firefighter helmet and the football jersey.
I mean, girls don't play football.
What are you talking about? Girls don't play football.
See?
What does that have to do with anything?
Just because she has parts that are different?
I feel like I'm a pretty nice woman and I played soccer and baseball and any kind of other sport.
See?
Do you think I'm a bad mom?
I don't think you're a bad mom.
I think you're teaching your kid that it's not okay to be herself.
She's going to be scared of you.
She's not going to tell you anything.
And that's going to be a huge issue.
Wow. Great point.
Expecting someone to be just like you based on the way you were raised is an unfair expectation.
Oh, she's tough.
Reagan?
Hi there.
Oh, God.
I'm John Quiniones.
Hi. Nice to meet you.
Look at you.
Sorry.
Brings you to tears. Why?
Excuse me.
It's very frustrating when parents won't just accept you as a person.
I have gone no contact with my own mom for about seven years now.
It really touched me because seeing a mom kind of throw that relationship out the window so
easily just because of what she wants for her kid instead of what's good for her kid.
I'm so sorry, but as a daughter, don't push her away, you're saying?
Basically, yeah.
It doesn't matter if your kid's not exactly how you want them to be.
They're supposed to be their own person.
We've seen reactions to a mother questioning her child's preferred gender expression.
Those are for girls.
But I told you, mom, I like this.
But how will people react when mom supports her kid's individuality?
Our crew leaves me in Reno and joins Sarah Haines in New Jersey at Manny's Diner,
where our actress is playing a mom raising her kids to be their unique selves.
OK, are we ready?
Honey.
Hi, dad.
How was your day?
Fine.
Would you stop slurping your drink?
That's terrible table manners.
What is that?
You're playing with a doll?
Whose doll is that?
Oh, my God.
Pink shirts and doll and you dress like a boy.
What is going on here?
Dad, I'd like to let them express themselves how they choose.
What do they know about expressing at this age?
Things are different now.
Things are different now?
You know, you're a bad mother.
I'm doing my best.
Look what's going on here.
You can't tell boys from girls anymore.
It's ridiculous.
You were raised in a traditional family.
I'm trying to help them grow up so that they know how to dress like men
and girls know how to dress like women.
This gender stuff, you know, that's twisting around.
People don't know what they're doing anymore.
I just want to make sure everybody's OK.
I can tell by the tone.
I get where you're coming from, too.
You got to let them be happy and find their way at the same time.
My is trans, so I can't say anything.
Oh, well, see, that's what happens.
That must be hard.
It must be hard for you.
It was hard in the beginning, but it's OK now.
We don't love them any less.
It's the same.
OK, let's break it.
Like she said, you got to let them be who they are.
Are you paying?
Oh, my God, Kristen.
Hi.
Hi, my name is Sarah Haynes.
I'm with ABC's.
What would you do?
Yeah, he's fine.
Do you want to sit back down?
So these are actors.
What made you offer that help?
I was listening the whole time and I said, don't say anything.
And then she said something.
If it wasn't grandpa, if it was someone younger, I think I would have a different approach.
It's like they can't teach an old dog new tricks.
Yeah.
These folks told grandpa to get with the times.
But what if grandma is even more opinionated?
Honey.
Hi, Mom.
Oh, dear.
What are you wearing?
Those are boy's clothes.
You're playing with a doll?
What is wrong with you?
This is not what I taught you.
I like them to be able to express themselves in the way that they see fit.
They're too young to know how to express themselves.
You need to be the one to be showing them.
This is how little girls dress, how they behave, and how little boys dress and how they behave.
This is not the way I brought you up.
I'm just so upset with what you're doing with these children.
They're listening.
They're definitely listening.
You teach them how little girls behave, how they dress.
You teach them how little boys dress.
I played with G.I. Joes, and I'm a girl.
And I used to climb trees and build forts and go-karts and stuff.
And I still look good in a dress.
So I respectfully have to disagree with you, ma'am.
Things aren't the way they were 50, 60 years ago.
It doesn't mean we have to agree with it.
We just have to accept that people are different.
And you just have to be respectful.