Missing on Mount of the Holy Cross

World Mysteries in 5 Mins
11 followers
6 Video Views·Nov 2, 2022
There is a mountain in the distant west that, sun-defying, in its deep ravines,
displays a cross of snow upon its side.
Henry Wadsworth.
Mount of the Holy Cross piqued the interest of masses when it was first photographed in 1873
by W. H. Jackson. The mountain attracted those wishing to pray from all over the United States,
and it gained so much visitation that, in 1929, it was declared a national monument.
These days, though, it is mostly climbers and hikers who visit the site,
and because the number of visitors dwindled over the years,
the mountain lost its monument status in 1950.
This mountain has also become somewhat famous for the disappearances that have
taken place on it, which we're going to get into in this video.
The mountain itself is actually surrounded by a lot of folklore too,
and at the centre of that are disappearances and people passing away unexpectedly.
Specifically, the folklore references those who would go to the site in groups,
and one of the individuals would split up from the group to go pray alone.
When the person didn't return, the others would go to retrieve them,
only to find that they're no longer with them.
Of course, I can't speak of the validity of folklore, but it is interesting nonetheless.
At any rate, let's travel to Mount of the Holy Cross and explore the first disappearance.
To begin, let's talk about James Nelson.
James was 31 years old when he disappeared from Mount of the Holy Cross, located near Vale.
James had planned a 25-mile, 5-day hike on the Fault Creek trailhead,
and was last seen on the 3rd of October 2010,
when two hikers had a conversation with him, but James would never return.
When he didn't appear to his family on the 8th as planned, he was reported missing by his fiancée.
It's worth mentioning that James was an experienced hiker,
and this was an activity he engaged in a lot,
though I don't believe that he had hiked in this area previously.
At first, the authorities told his fiancée that he would probably be back the following day,
but when he still hadn't emerged, the search was on.
The Colorado Springs Gazette reported that the Colorado National Guard
had dropped search teams all over the Fault Creek trail,
and had deployed helicopters over the site.
James had set off on this trip with proper gear and a lot of supplies,
which made the searchers feel hopeful that they would be able to locate him okay.
At this point, searchers had been in the area for three days alongside dogs and helicopters,
but they weren't finding anything of note.
The entirety of the trail had been scoured at this point,
which means that for some reason, James must have strayed from the trail, but why?
Of course, all wilderness areas have their dangers, but James was an experienced hiker
that engaged in this activity a lot. He wasn't new to following trails by any stretch.
It's not made clear as to when, but it seems at some point,
the weather had taken a turn for the worst in the area,
which officials said made the search a bit more difficult,
as the many boulders and rocks were now slippery.
At the end of the fourth day, the official search was called off,
as no clues were presenting themselves, and the search dogs had no luck in finding him.
Local fishermen and hunters who were in the area frequently were told about James,
and the message was spread to keep an eye out for him.
It seems to me that there was some debate and frustration and a lot of worry present
among the searchers, as James had taken a GPS with him on this trip,
so they didn't believe he could have just gotten lost.
That was the end of the trail, they didn't find James or any trace of him whatsoever,
at least until two years later.
On the 25th of May, 2012, a person that was scouting for campsites near Holy Cross City
came across one that had been seemingly abandoned.
This unnamed man found the top of a skull and reported the finding to the authorities.
The authorities once more descended on the area looking for clues,
and a cadaver dog this time managed to find James' jaw.
The authorities also found a journal left behind by James
that seems to indicate that he started to feel a bit sickly during his trip.
The authorities reasoned that he may have been suffering from altitude sickness.
It was then noted that his camera, GPS and camp stove were missing.
The finding of the remains reminds me of what was found in Jared Attadiro's disappearance,
reported by David Paulides and Jared's father in David's first missing 411 documentary.
That's the end of the information flow on James,
and the authorities couldn't determine a cause of passing,
and it's not clear where the rest of his remains ended up.
In the end, it's not really understood what happened to James Nelson.
Michelle Rae Vaneck, 35 years old, and her friend Eric Sawyer, 36,
arrived at the Half Moon Trailhead southwest of Minton at around 6.30am on the 24th of September,
2005.
Eric was an incredibly experienced hiker who had ascended 38 of Colorado's 53 14ers.
After this incident took place, Eric said that he had a bad feeling about that day,
and you'll come to see why.
Firstly, Eric had forgotten his lunch and water purifier in the car,
and almost immediately after starting their hike, they had started on the wrong trail.
Their initial plan was to hike the relatively easy Northridge route,
but they had gone up the more difficult Halo route.
Despite the mistakes, the two were enjoying their hiking session for the most part,
and after realising their mistakes, they decided to continue on,
as turning back meant that they wouldn't have been able to reach the summit.
Seven hours after starting, Michelle had run out of water,
and Eric's supply was starting to run low too.
Minutes later, the pair were very close to the summit, being around 400 yards away.
Michelle stopped in her tracks and told Eric that she couldn't go on and needed a break,
but insisted that Eric should continue on to the summit.
Eric did stop with her and said that they could turn back now,
but Michelle urged him to continue on, as I can only imagine
she may have felt as if she was ruining his goals, or the day in general.
Eric told her to wait where she was, or to walk the short distance
towards the East Cross Creek Trail, where he would meet her.
Around ten minutes or so had passed, and Eric arrived at the summit at 1.42pm that day.
The Denver Post reported this.
On the summit, Eric called his wife to say that they were running late.
According to witnesses, Bill and Julia Taylor, who were also present at the summit,
he was only there for around five minutes.
He seemed rushed because he had to get back to his hiking partner, Julia said.
Sawyer and the Taylors exchanged typical pleasantries and snapped each other's pictures
before he headed down. A short time later, they heard Sawyer yelling what they thought
were calls for help, but were actually his shouts of Michelle.
There was around a twenty-five minute time period between Eric leaving for the summit
and returning back down to Michelle.
This feels odd to me because Michelle said that she can't go any further and needed to take a
break. It's weird that she would say something like that and then just wander off and start
hiking again. Eric and the Taylors were all shouting for Michelle and searching around
the immediate area, but they couldn't locate her and she never replied to any of their calls.
Eric rushed to the East Cross Creek Trail, but she wasn't there, and I actually get
the impression that Eric himself was surprised that she had decided to move,
given that he was shouting for her almost immediately. The following day would see
more than 100 searchers on the scene and they found out looking for Michelle.
The Colorado Springs Gazette reported this on the 30th of September, 2005.
Rescuers found no sign of a missing 35-year-old woman during a search Thursday of areas near
Mount of the Holy Cross that were previously unreachable because of bad weather. The Sheriff's
office said its investigation continues, but said there is nothing suspicious to indicate that Eric
was involved. This was coupled with Michelle's husband, Ben, who also echoed that he did not
believe for a moment that Eric had anything to do with their disappearance, though he did lament
his decision to leave her behind. Over the course of seven days, over 700 searchers descended on the
very area that Michelle had disappeared from. Search dog teams scoured the location looking
for a scent, while around five helicopters, at least one equipped with thermal imaging technology,
were up in the air at all times. Climbers descended and ascended up the ridgelines
while volunteers combed the area, but absolutely no trace of Michelle was turning up. The Denver Post
reported that early during the search, a watch hanging from the branch of a tree was discovered,
which is odd in and of itself, and at first they believed that they'd found a clue that suggested
they were on the right track. It's not clear that they ever established who the watch belonged to,
but they did find that it didn't belong to Michelle. The Denver Post also reported that
at the very end of the first search day, searchers encountered a backpacker who refused to talk to
anyone. They said that he hid behind a tree and then ran down the trail. The searchers also came
across a tent with a light on, but whoever was inside would also not respond to questions,
nor would they open the zipper. The Denver Post continued on and stated that the following day,
sheriff investigators went ahead and met with this person, or at least the person they believed was
inside the tent. They questioned the man, and while he wasn't forthcoming, the investigators
didn't believe that he had anything to do with Michelle. The same night, the weather took a turn
for the worse and a storm brought heavy rain and snow down upon the mountain. Six days after the
search began, the effort was called off. Tim Cochran, one of the search leaders, stated this.
A lot of people coming out of the field on Saturday indicated that they were willing
to go back in on Sunday, and my comment was simply this. If you can show me a clue,
show me a reason why I'd crank this thing back up in a minute. We never found a ski pole,
we never found anything. Typically we do, and that would have sustained us for another week
if we had one tiny little bit of evidence. It's a true mystery, typically by now we have some
sort of clue or evidence indicating a direction of travel where someone might have taken shelter,
but we don't. The sheriff's department seemed to agree with this, as spokesman Bill Kaufman
stated further searches for Michelle Vaneck would likely not lead to her discovery.
The sheriff's department added that they fully believed that Michelle was still up on that
mountain, they just couldn't point to where. Reported seven years after her disappearance,
I found this final piece in the Colorado Springs in August of 2012. The largest search and rescue
operation in Colorado history failed to find a trace of her. She was last seen at 13,800 feet.
That's just boulder after boulder, some the size of a house. So, Michelle disappeared without a
trace at a high altitude in a boulder field. Absolutely no clues were left behind whatsoever,
and there was nothing to indicate that a struggle had taken place. Search dogs had completely failed
to find a scent. There was no thermal evidence of her presence, and over 700 searches came up
with nothing. What happened to Michelle Vaneck? On the morning of the 8th of August, 1994,
21-year-old Christian Burke told his roommates that he was going on a solo hike in the mount of
the Holy Cross Wilderness Area. He told them that he would be back by no later than the 11th,
which would be a Thursday, and gave him a good three days to spend in the wilderness.
Of course, Thursday the 11th had rolled around, and his roommates still had heard no word from him.
So, at some point that day, they reported him missing. A familiar name came up here,
and Tim Cochran was apparently a spokesman for the Vale Mountain Rescue Team at that time.
Of course, 11 years later, he would come to hold a leadership position
in the search for Michelle Vaneck. In any case, on the 16th of August,
Tim had told the press that the search had not been successful thus far, but was still ongoing.
It appears that there were around 100 searches present almost from the beginning, and over 150
at one point. The day afterwards, on the 17th, the Farmington Daily Times reported this.
The search for an Avon man missing more than a week in the mount of the Holy Cross Wilderness
Area was terminated Tuesday afternoon with no sign of the man, authorities said.
The search for Christian Burke, 21, who went hiking alone in the wilderness area on the 8th
of August, was launched last Thursday, and at one time, more than 150 searchers were in the field.
Eagle County Sheriff's spokeswoman, Kim Andre, said searchers did not find a single thing.
However, individual search team members will continue to look for the missing man as time
permits. A team of 14 ground searchers and a dog team scoured the area on the west side of
Mount of the Holy Cross between the summit and Cross Creek on Tuesday before being driven out
by an afternoon thunder and lightning storm. Christian's car was found parked at a campground
at the base of the Mount of the Holy Cross trail, and a log book at the summit indicates that he
reached the top on the 8th of August. I probably sound like a broken record at this point,
but I do want to clarify that at no point during the search did the dogs find a scent.
The next update comes three days later from the Cedar Rapids Gazette.
This is what they reported on the 20th of August, 1994.
The body of a former McGregor man missing for a week has been found on the Mount of the Holy
Cross in West Central Colorado. The body of Christian Burke was found Thursday at the 12,400
foot level of the Mount of the Holy Cross, about 1,400 feet below the summit. It seems that Christian
had been drawn to the mountain for a while, as the article also reported that his roommate said
that he'd been talking about making the trip to the summit for quite some time. Captain Ken Wilson
of the Eagle County Sheriff's Department said that the cause of passing was not established,
and that maybe he was struck by lightning. Captain Wilson stated that Christian had been
cautioned that there was going to be daily thunderstorms in the area at the time. Despite
the search ending, Christian was actually found by three Vale mountain rescue workers and two hikers.
If you follow TheMissing411 and David Paulides, you might have recognised a couple of things so
far, and will certainly recognise this next part. Christian's body was found in a boulder field
behind some of the boulders. It seems that this area had been previously searched and the family
had privately hired a helicopter equipped with thermal imaging technology to try to find their
son. That wasn't lingered on too much, though it is said that it's easy to miss a body in boulder
fields. It was also never clarified if the dogs were in that particular area. Christian's brother
Sean had also stated that Christian was outgoing, ambitious, very friendly, and was no novice in the
mountains, and that he'd been doing a lot of hiking. There was one major oddity here, and that
was the fact that a cause of passing wasn't established for Christian, and the Sheriff
thought that maybe he'd been hit by lightning. There's a 1 in 700,000 chance of that happening,
so obviously that is generally very unlikely. The way it was discussed, it seems that the only
evidence to point in that direction was the fact that there was bad weather in the form of
thunderstorms during his ascent. It's normally apparent if a fall has taken place for obvious
reasons, so it doesn't appear that was the case here and there were no injuries mentioned to
point in that direction. Also important to note here is that there was no mention of a struggle
or any kind of third-party involvement. If one is to pass away as a result of a lightning strike,
it is normally because of cardiac or respiratory arrest or both. Other common injuries seem to
include muscle pain, broken bones, confusion, hearing loss, seizures, burns, behaviour changes,
and ocular cataracts. The obvious things that could point to that conclusion here would be
burns, broken bones, and cataracts. It's tough to really know what they meant there when they
said that they weren't sure why he'd passed away, but he might have been hit by lightning.
It would have been interesting to know if any or a number of those indicators had been present.
This incident could potentially match the missing 411 criteria. Christian was alone in a very rural
area, the weather took a turn for the worse, and then he was found in a boulder field. There didn't
seem to be an obvious cause of passing, at least from the information we have present. Search dogs
never found a scent and the aerial searches failed. I'm not sure that the aerial search failure is
specifically listed by David as an area of interest, but it certainly catches my attention,
especially when thermal imaging technology is involved, coupled with search dog failures.
It's also worth mentioning that professional search and rescue personnel speak very highly
of the aerial components of the search specific to helicopters. Unfortunately and unsurprisingly,
it doesn't look like the data is collected anywhere of successful search and rescue performed by
helicopters. One would imagine that the number would be fairly high since they are heavily relied
upon and have been used in a search and rescue capacity almost since their inception. Anyway,
it's unfortunate, but that's where the paper trail ended for Christian, and it's not clear
what exactly happened to him that day. This next incident reminds me of Michelle's disappearance in
some ways, but thankfully had a different outcome. On the 29th of July, 1997, the Sedalia Democrat
reported about a lady named Kathleen Kinderfather who had gone missing on Mount of the Holy Cross.
At the time, Kathleen was 67 years old and was in great shape for her age as she hiked a lot.
Kathleen didn't actually go missing on the 29th, but rather the 26th. The press only seemed to
have caught wind of it the three days afterwards. The Farmington Daily Times then picked up on this
incident and was able to acquire some more details. That day, Kathleen had gone to the mountain with
one of her good friends whom she hiked with a lot. Their plan was to hike up the trail located
between Half Moon Pass and the Mount of the Holy Cross. It's not clear just how high Kathleen had
made it up. It's only made clear that, similar to Michelle, Kathleen couldn't quite make it the
entire way and stopped close to the summit. Her friend stopped with her, but again, similar to
Michelle, she encouraged the friend to continue on. I can only imagine that both Michelle and
Kathleen thought that they were ruining the trip for their friends. I'm a firm believer that
splitting up in situations like these is a major mistake, and if you ever find yourself in this
situation, I would urge you not to split up. In any case, the friend did continue on and made
it to the summit. The friend wasn't at the summit for long before coming back down to return to
Kathleen. Now, similar to Michelle, the friend just couldn't find Kathleen again. She came right back
to the spot she'd left her, but Kathleen wasn't present. The friend made the route around the
immediate area and was calling out for Kathleen, but there was no response. Not only had Kathleen
disappeared, but now there was about to be another disaster too. The pair had planned to camp in this
area, and now it was getting dark, and the friend couldn't make it out of the area to get help.
I can't imagine the friend slept much that night, but did wait at the camp hoping that Kathleen
would return. Early the following morning, and in a panic, which can also be dangerous at a time
like this, when still in potentially dangerous territory, the friend sped to the nearest Forest
Service office, but it was closed, which delayed the organisation of the search. The friend was
finally able to get a hold of the authorities, who then estimated that the search was delayed
by around a day because of the circumstances. The authorities took dogs to Kathleen's last
known location, but it doesn't appear that they could locate a scent. Alongside the dogs, they
had 57 professional search and rescuers at the spot she had disappeared from, as well as National
Guard helicopters. During the search, heavy rain and fog hit the area, making it all the more
difficult for the searchers. The search grew in size over a period of four days and nights, but
because they couldn't locate a single clue as to where she'd gone, they started to scale it down.
Kim Andre was the public information officer for the Eagle County Sheriff, and she said that they
are going to look at what they might have missed in the high probability area before deciding what
to do next. The search is focused on a seven square mile area between the Half Moon Pash Trail
and the Mount of the Holy Cross. Kathleen was found on the 30th of July 1997, and the Alamogordo
Daily News had this to say. Eagle, Colorado. A 67-year-old woman survived five nights in a boulder
field in the Colorado mountains by huddling in a space blanket, eating cereal bars and drinking
rainwater, authorities said. Tim Cochrane said that it's an epic story and that he'd never seen anything
like it in 20 years. It doesn't appear that searchers thought that they would find her in a
She was seen by a physician at the hospital, but that evaluation wasn't discussed unfortunately.
The medical center public information officer only said that she had suffered from dehydration
and that while she was awake and alert, she was very weak. This article states that the dog teams
eventually pointed searchers to an area near Cross Creek Drainage, but Kathleen wasn't there. It was
an army helicopter that spotted her red parka in the boulder field. It's not clear why the dogs had
picked up a scent at the creek drainage because Kathleen wasn't to be found there. The helicopter
found her around half a mile away from her starting location. Tim made it clear that without the
helicopter that day, she would not have been found. So I can only take that as though the dogs weren't
close to her. Kathleen stated that she wasn't sure how she got lost, but tripped and fell into a
boulder field. I'm not sure why Kathleen had decided to keep on hiking without a friend.
Similar to Michelle, she said that she was tired and needed a break. So why on earth she carried
on? I'm not sure. The friend also panicked as soon as he or she made it back down to where Kathleen
was last seen, which seems to indicate that the friend thought Kathleen was going to wait right
there. I can only imagine that the pair had discussed that while the friend was being
encouraged to keep going onwards to the summit. Ultimately, I'm just glad that Kathleen was found
in good condition in the end because that easily couldn't have been the case and wouldn't have been
if it wasn't for the pilot of that helicopter. Not to repeat myself too much, but a lot of these
disappearances that I find generally come after people split up and are alone. Decisions and
mistakes are made that could have been completely avoided had the pair or group stayed together.
So again, I know that I have a lot of viewers that love to hike and it's very healthy so it'd be great
if more people did it. Just please don't split up, especially in wilderness or just generally
dangerous areas. It's almost never a good idea and the bad outcomes are generally an order of
magnitude worse than any positives. On that note of being careful, this next incident isn't a
disappearance, but does serve as a good cautionary tale of the importance of preparation and foresight.
This incident was reported by the Philadelphia Times on the 16th of January 1881.
One of the most horrible adventures that has become the part of the Reporter to Chronicle
for the past few weeks is that which a party of prospectors underwent while seeking their way to
A party of four, consisting of messers, Parker, Benjamin, George Ross and Wilson, started out on
their journey under the happiest auspices. Full of hope with the brilliant prospect of wealth and
happiness that was before them, they proceeded to fight the boundless realm of snow that surrounded
the pass where they were obliged to go should they succeed in making their arduous trip.
After wandering around through the mountains for two or three days, they retraced their steps
in order to find a comfortable camping place and make a new start. They soon refreshed themselves
and started out anew on their perilous journey, when about halfway up the mountainside,
they encountered a sudden, heavy snowstorm which lasted for some time. Full of pluck and courage,
they defied the stormy elements and pursued their way bravely forward. The snow was falling
so thick and fast that it was utterly impossible for them to find their way. The wind blew with
such terrible and unrelenting ferocity that while seeking shelter in the woods, they became alarmed
and in order to prevent any possible harm, they cut down the trees in the immediate vicinity
of their camping grounds, fearing that the powerful winds would cause the trees to come
crashing down. They cut every one of the trees down in a distance of 40 feet. The weary and
unfortunate men could hear the ominous and terrible growling of the mountain lions around
their campfire at night, as if seeking shelter and protection of man during that fearful period.
In the evening, the baying of elk and the bleating of the mountain sheep could be plainly heard in
the dim distance, as if they were also seeking the men's protection. For three days and three
nights, the storm continued with unabating fury, and during the daytime, the men, driven to
desperation through contemplation of the horrible fate that was presented to them, strove in vain
to find their way out of the terrible dilemma in which they were placed by the action of the
elements. In vain did they seek for the pass, freezing their feet, hands, and face in their
efforts to find their way back to civilization. Destiny, however, fated the men to remain camped
upon the bleak and barren sides of the mountain, surrounded by an everlasting, endless mass of snow.
Finally, on the afternoon of the fourth day, Providence in its mercy tore the clouds of snow
and desolation. After many weary hours of terrible suffering, they finally found their way back to
Tennessee Park. They say that for all the gold and silver that might be found in the Mount of
the Holy Cross, they would not again pass through the same experience. Well, it's safe to say that
the group were lucky to have made it out of that without injury or worse. It's an old incident that
highlights just how fierce the elements can be and why it's absolutely vital to prepare. If you're
planning on going hiking anywhere or climbing, please check the weather and make sure that you're
well supplied. I've read too many of these disappearances where the simple act of not
being fully prepared or splitting up wreaked havoc on the lives of those involved and their families.
I'm not involved with hikinggearlab.com in any way, but they provide some great safety advice so
it might be worth having a look at what they've got to say. Anyway, on that note, thank you for
watching. I hope that you found this video interesting, and if you did, then please do
leave a like and subscribe if you haven't already. It helps a lot. And if not, then feel free to leave
a dislike. I'm just looking for your honest opinion, so do share. I'd also just like to say
a massive thank you to my patrons who help me to sustain the research and the production of the
videos, so thank you very much for your support. There's a fair few exclusives on my Patreon now,
so if you'd like to check that out and support the channel, then you can find the link in the
description below. I'm interested in hearing your thoughts on the disappearances discussed,
so do leave your thoughts in the comments below, I do read them all. I hope that you've had a great
day, or evening, depending on where you are. Be safe guys, and I'll see you next time. Peace.
