A lot of the music is: Local Forecast - Elevator Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com) Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 3.0 License http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/ Our content is intended for teenage audiences and up.
I'm not an expert.
This is one of my favorite things about myself.
I love learning new things.
I'm not so good at continuing to learn old things.
When they coined that phrase about being a jack-of-all-trades master of none,
they were talking about me.
But even though I'm not an expert,
being, as they say, in the sauce about Greek mythology
for the better part of a decade
has inadvertently given me something of a feel for the terrain.
So when I'm out in the wilds of the Internet
hunting down fun new stories to tell,
sometimes I get a little bit of a whiff.
You know, just the faintest smell of bullshit.
Every field of art has its forgeries,
works that their creators thought wouldn't be impactful enough
if they were presented on their own merits,
so instead they have a whole historical context
stapled onto them after the fact.
This painting isn't just nice,
it's a lost da Vinci.
This story isn't just a fun little tale,
it's an ancient Native American legend.
This bite-sized anecdote isn't just a slice of good advice,
it's an ancient Chinese proverb or something.
There are so many of these and they make me so mad.
Not just because their supposed ancient origins
are frequently blatantly chosen for their trope-y exoticization
to make them seem foreign and mystical
and hard to contact the supposed source to corroborate,
but mostly they make me mad because they're lies.
They muddle an already extremely complicated field to research
and if I get duped by one,
which has happened,
I end up perpetuating misinformation.
So I've developed a bit of a spidey sense
for when a story feels a little too new to be true.
The time-traveling goatfish we discussed back in the Zodiac video?
Too many bits of that story
that just did not fit the tone of the classic Greek greats.
The Greek goddess of torture and punishment
that Tumblr made up for funsies?
Smelled that spiral-bound notebook doodle OC a mile off.
But, I'm not an expert.
And that means sometimes I stumble into something
that sounds too good to be true
and when I go digging,
it turns out to be real.
And that is such a rare joy for me
that I cannot wait to tell you about this one.
So today let's talk about Astraea,
the goddess of the constellation Virgo,
which is now available in our Crowdmade shop
as the latest installment in our
glow-in-the-dark Zodiac enamel pits collection.
Get em while they're gettable!
To start our journey,
I'm gonna do the one thing you're never supposed to do.
I'm gonna read you a few lines
from Astraea's Wikipedia page.
I just want you all to understand
why I started off suspicious.
Astraea is the virgin goddess of justice,
innocence, purity, and precision.
Astraea, the celestial virgin,
was the last of the immortals to live with humans
during the Golden Age,
one of the old Greek religion's
five deteriorating ages of man.
And last but not least,
according to myth, Astraea will one day come to Earth,
bringing with her the return of the utopian Golden Age
of which she was the ambassador.
So, this is fine.
Everything here is totally plausible.
Except it's got this vibe that a lot of fake lore,
which is what it's called, which I love, shares,
which is this sort of surprisingly modern set of tropes.
For one thing, Astraea's godly domain
is extremely thematically coherent
while still covering a decent amount of ground.
A god of both justice and innocence makes a lot of sense.
Those two things are connected.
And looping in purity plays well with the rest of it too.
The thing is, real mythologies frequently do not do that.
Zeus is a god of the sky and storms,
but he's also the god of divine hospitality
and the maker of heroes.
Poseidon is the god of the ocean
and also earthquakes and horses.
In Greek mythology, it's very common for gods
to either have about a million
seemingly unrelated divine characteristics
or to have one single concept as their entire deal.
For instance, Eos is the goddess of the dawn
and that's basically all she does.
But modern day fictional deities in fantasy settings
are purposefully written and world-built
to cover a single neatly partitioned slice of the universe.
And they usually get given a tightly woven set
of godly duties that all thematically resonate
with one another or a singular gimmick
that gives them a nice simple personality to play with.
A quick scroll through the gods in D&D
communicates that pretty cleanly.
You want a god of justice?
Human-shaped or dragon-shaped?
We got you covered.
You want a god of the sea?
We got like three of them.
If you don't mind a bit of a crowd,
we can bring in all our gods of war.
So Astraea's extremely thematically clean divine domain
was a little bit sus.
And the thing about her being the last immortal
to still live with humanity was also,
to my eyes, suspiciously modern.
It implied, again, some hard world-building
that just generally isn't found in classical mythology,
which was built up slowly over the course
of thousands of years of changing generations of people.
In Greek mythology,
the gods aren't walled off from humanity.
The only time a no-interference clause
comes up explicitly is in the Trojan War.
And even then, it's constantly ignored.
Throughout the entire rest of the corpus of Greek mythology,
the gods are constantly dealing with humans,
popping in to help out directly or sire more kids
or spawn a few monsters
in case everyone was getting a little too cozy.
So this idea that the rest of the gods
had dipped out of the mortal world early on
while Astraea, this pure, wonderful goddess of goodness,
had lived with humanity through their waning morals
but had eventually reached her breaking point
and reluctantly turned her back,
it felt, to me, very unusual.
In fact, what it really felt like was reminiscent
of some of the stuff Tolkien got up to in the Silmarillion.
That's right, bitches, I've actually read it now.
It's fine.
Anyway, I was getting big fall of Numenor energy
off this bit, and I wanted to know more.
So of course, the first thing I did
was go looking at the sources.
And to my genuine surprise,
all of this stuff is mythologically supported.
So it probably had Tolkien energy
because Tolkien had read the same things I did.
Eratos' Phenomena, a book of constellations
and general astronomy information
written between 300-ish and 250 BCE,
lays it out pretty clearly with a few bonus details
provided by Ovid's Metamorphoses a few centuries later.
Astraea, an immortal goddess,
makes the unusual choice to live among humans
in their earliest days, a pastoralist golden age
where the land is bountiful, conflict is nonexistent,
and everything is wonderful all the time.
Hilariously, one explicit way the writers communicate
that this is a simple age of bountless idealism
is that nobody has even considered building a boat.
Don't go into the ocean, everyone.
That's where the sin lives.
Ovid adds to the detail that this golden age
was when the Titans ruled the world under Saturn,
aka Kronos, father of Zeus,
who of course overthrows Kronos
and ushers in the age of the gods,
which embarrassingly is considered a downgrade
from a golden age to a silver one.
Zeus nixes the eternal springtime
and introduces a seasonal breakup,
forcing the fledgling humans to start constructing homes
to shelter during extreme temperatures
and invent agriculture to not starve.
Astraea is not super happy
with the events of the silver age,
and she's disheartened that humanity
is becoming increasingly more conflicted.
Her primary godly move is to advocate for mercy
and understanding when justice is called for,
but she's not happy with the silver age,
and she likes its sequel even less.
The bronze age, quickly followed by the iron age,
sees humanity discover the evils of war and money,
which from Eratos' perspective
is just war with extra steps.
Disgusted with humanity's newfound penchant for violence
and, even worse, seafaring,
Astraea finally turns her back on humanity
and retreats to the heavens above,
becoming the constellation Virgo.
And that's all fine and dandy.
Ovid's source alone is good enough for me.
He may be biased, but this isn't the kind of story
he tended to dubiously embellish from nothing,
and Eratos' source just adds even more legitimacy,
proving that Astraea wasn't just a Roman concept
and dated back to ancient Greece.
Plus, these stories have some fascinating implications
about the vibes the writers were living through.
Eratos and Ovid both were firmly of the opinion
that they were living in the shitty, terrible iron age.
The world had once existed in this beautiful,
primeval, pastoralist state
where the land provided everything humanity needed
without requiring any work,
but a divine overhaul and a tragic downfall
into petty selfishness and greed
had left humanity constantly at war with itself,
miserable and hungry and cruel.
And sailing!
Are there no depths to which we won't sink?
And there's a lot here that I think is super interesting.
Like, again, getting back to the trope perspective,
when a modern Western writer wants to communicate
that an empire is unimaginably powerful
and decadent and wealthy,
they make it look like Rome.
Aesthetically, we associate it with an empire
at the height of its glory.
And the writers from that civilization were like,
this is disgusting,
I wish we could go back to eating berries in the woods.
Amazing.
I guess the grass is always greener
on the other side of the course of empires.
But okay, we've got that settled.
Astraea was a real deity,
she was associated with justice
and innocence and purity and stuff,
but it was really that last bit about Astraea
that made me profoundly suspicious.
You know, the prophecy.
See, there are some mythological prophecies
that perpetuate out into the modern day,
but there are not many of them.
Most of them take the form of,
this true king is buried in this mountain
and he will rise again
in his country's greatest hour of need,
which is conveniently self-non-fulfilling.
When, in response to whatever current crisis
is rearing its ugly head,
the dead guy fails to bust out of his mausoleum
with sword in hand,
it just kicks the greatest hour of need down the road
and implies he won't wake up
until things find a way to get even worse.
So these prophecies can hang around
in cultural perpetuity without too much trouble.
In myths, prophecies are usually short-term tragedy bait,
whimsical little bites of the near future
that only exist to doom their hapless protagonist
into meeting their destiny
on the road they take to avoid it.
Prophecies are one of those things
that modern writers cannot get enough of,
but they are, in my experience,
very unusual in mythology.
I mean, you can tell,
because I haven't used that
the prophecy musical sting joke
in eight real years.
That's a good bit and I just never get the chance.
And the reason why this mythical figure
has an ongoing prophecy about them
is especially suspicious
is because it's the kind of thing
people love co-opting to support
whatever social, cultural, or political agenda
they think they can most convincingly staple it to.
Especially one as vague as,
her return will signify the dawn of a new golden age.
Bitch, that could mean anything.
But shockingly, this bit is also real.
Virgil's fourth eclogue says it in plain Latin.
Virgin Justice, aka Astraea, returns,
and with her, the reign of Saturn, again Cronos,
and an accompanying golden age.
Even more than that, Virgil's funky little prophecy,
credited to the Cumaean Sybil,
says that this ringing in of a new golden era
will be accompanied by the birth of some amazing kid
who will personally lead this world to paradise.
And he was coincidentally writing this around 40 BCE,
so within a few scant decades,
this little tidbit was going to reach
its first pile of people really, really eager
to explain how it totally applied
to their personal choice of Messiah.
The popular read, for the record,
is that Virgil was actually writing
about the predicted future kid
of Mark Antony and Augustus's sister Octavia,
a union that would have handily stitched
two-thirds of the triumvirate back together,
but this is what happens when your prophecies are vague.
They get Jesus'd.
Which, not to criticize,
I feel like a good oracle should have probably seen coming.
And it somehow managed to get even vaguer.
See, once the Renaissance started
and there was a whole crop of powerful queens
popping up across Europe,
it became extremely hip and cool
to conflate every single one of them with Astraea,
returned in the form of this one lady
to usher in that new golden age everyone was talking about,
and to prove conclusively that their empire
was just as amazing and wonderful
as the great empires of the ancient past
had been in the glory days.
The Holy Roman Empire hasn't fallen off, guys.
It's just as good as it used to be.
And now it's got holy in front of it.
Anyway, the short of it is,
I was right to be suspicious of this prophecy thing,
not because it wasn't a real part of the early mythology,
but because its prominence in the story of Astraea
is 100% the consequence of it being so politically
and religiously useful so many times,
which is also dishonest,
but the classy kind of dishonest that cites its sources
and makes me even angrier.
Pardon the way that I stare
There's nothing else to compare
The sight of you leaves me weak
There are no words left to speak
So if you feel like I feel
Please let me know that it's real
You're just too good to be true
Can't take my eyes off of you