This episode of The Book Club features @MichaelKnowles joined by @MikeBenzCyberOfficial executive director of the Foundation for Freedom Online, to discuss Herman Melville’s Moby-Dick. Together, they explore Ishmael’s restless voyage to sea, the novel’s many biblical allusions, and the question at its center. Is Captain Ahab a madman consumed by revenge or a great man of history with an indomitable will? Knowles sees in Ahab the dark side of individualism. Benz makes a contrarian case for the captain who would risk everything to face the whale.
Moby-Dick offers a timeless challenge for young men who may feel adrift in today’s culture: Find a mission bigger than yourself, and choose carefully what kind of man you become along the way.
Call me Ishmael. No, call me Michael.
I'm Michael Knowles. We're back with the book club. And
this month, we will be discussing perhaps the great American novel,
definitely one of the
contenders, Moby Dick by Herman Melville.
I am very pleased to be joined by another Michael,
Mike Benz, the executive director
of the Foundation for Freedom Online. Mike,
thank you for making me finally do Moby Dick.
It's a ride, isn't it?
This book I picked up years ago.
I really enjoyed it.
I'm from New York.
A lot of this takes place in and around New York,
some of those old whaling towns, Sag
Harbor, talks about Manhattan.
Thank
And I never finished it.
I got bogged down somewhere in the middle
of the discursive encyclopedia of whales in
the middle of the book.
Before we get into the meaning of this extremely rich book,
you
just rife with symbols.
very
What is the plot of Moby Dick in 60 seconds?
The plot is very simple, actually.
much.
It's a...
Essentially, a guy decides that he wants to get to sea,
he's feeling a little listless,
maybe depressed, it's a little unclear, he feels a little unfulfilled.
He decides he's going to go on some sort
of merchant sailing mission and then meets a
cannibal named Queequeg,
who then convinces him to go on a whaling mission because he's
never been whaling despite all the times he's been sailing.
Once he's aboard the ship, he learns that the captain, Ahab,
has a mission to hunt the great white whale,
Moby Dick, who had bitten his leg off.
And away they go on this adventure to hunt the white whale.
Things do not go particularly well for the crew.
Effectively, in the mad quest to conquer the whale,
Captain Ahab is killed.
The ship is destroyed along with all the members,
and Ishmael survives to tell the tale.
He survives in the coffin of the cannibal
who roped him into the mission to begin with.
And that's the parameters of the book,
but the devil is in the details about it, and it's a fascinating piece.
Perhaps literally the devil in the details of this book.
The first line, which I mentioned right at the top of this show.
...is one of the most famous lines in all of literature.
Call me Ishmael.
Some years ago, never mind how long precisely,
having little or no money in my purse
and nothing particular to interest me on shore,
I thought I would sail about a little
and see the watery part of the world.
Right off the bat, we get this unmistakable biblical allusion.
Ishmael, one of the sons of Abraham.
Not the legitimate son, not Isaac,
who God calls to be sacrificed and then stops Abraham's hand.
Isaac goes on to produce the people of God.
But Ishmael, the castaway son, the illegitimate son,
the son who has to go his own way into the world.
Why Ishmael?
I think about this so much.
So, Ishmael, of course, is the firstborn son who is cast into
the wilderness and not in the main line, you know, heir, covenant.
I think many people in
the modern world, myself included, frankly,
experience the atomization, the feeling that
there is a kind of heritage around us,
a lineage of history, and something
in our generation has somewhat disconnected us from the main line
and there's an attempt to try
to be a part of the greater family,
but you have to sort of find your way yourself. It's not
automatically at birth.
The way I think the modern,
at least male life as I experienced it was, is you grow
up in your hometown, you go away to college,
you make your own way, you have to find your
own community as you go.
So you are...
Things are not...
passed on to you. You don't learn necessarily your father's trade.
You don't take over the
family business. Right, right.
And I think that there is a kind of Ishmael in the vast majority
of modern American upbringing at this point.
But there is a kind of exile wanderer aspect
of Ishmael. And in the context of the story, you have this
This direct parallel where he is not the star of the show.
The story primarily is about Ahab's mission to conquer the white whale.
And so...
Ishmael is a narrator, in a sense. He is a wanderer
who sort of ends up being kind of the sole surviving witness to this,
so that that story can be told to the wider world.
He's an outsider, as Ishmael is in the Bible.
He's a little outside the main storyline, and he's your way in.
I think you're totally right on the individualist aspect.
Melville lives right in the middle of the 19th century,
I think from the 1810s to the 1890s.
He writes the book exactly in the middle
of the 19th century, 1850.
So this is the height of Romanticism.
This is a great, dark, romantic novel.
You see much more of an emphasis on nature
compared to traditional religious dogma,
and that comes up a lot.
Obviously, a lot of scriptural allusions here.
The book opens with this.
These biblical names, then there's this very famous,
before they take off on the ship,
there's this famous sermon,
homily or sermon on Jonah and the whale, beautifully, sort of
hysterically told. But then you also have these allusions to nature.
I mean, he says right here
in that first chapter, he says, you know,
I go down to the sea, he puts it more eloquently,
he says, I go down to the sea because that's
freedom. He said, wherever men are,
you'll notice they go toward the water. The water seems to be,
whenever you get, start to feel a little listless,
you feel a little. Whenever there's a damp and
drizzly November in my soul.
Yes, I go, we go toward the water, even lakes, even lakes, even a
little pond. So you're seeing that emphasis on nature.
There's even a kind of philosophical
juxtaposition that comes in later in the book.
Where you have these two whale heads hanging off the ship.
And he says one of them is the Stoic.
You know, this kind of practical, ancient guy.
But the other one is the Platonist, a Platonian,
who even tends toward a Spinoza in his later years.
He said, what is this guy talking about?
How is he reading philosophy into these whales?
But that Platonist,
this man who's really looking beyond the physical world
to the realm of the forms and reading this kind of...
spiritual interpretation of the world into Spinoza,
who's a pantheist, you know, who's one of the
guys who gives us modernity.
It's this eminently modern novel and modern take on all the
scriptural allusions. Worth pointing out, too, Melville did this.
Melville actually did go on
a merchant ship. I think he went on a whaling ship. Yes. And
That part I remembered.
The thing I didn't remember was that this book was a flop.
And no wonder, you know,
you got these page after page on the right whale and the sperm whale.
So it was a total flop when he was alive.
And I don't think it became a classic until the early 20th century.
Yeah, decades later, it was basically picked back up
and became this kind of cult classic turned into a...
canon of American literature,
it is a sort of Vincent van Gogh, sort of not in his lifetime
sort of story. But there is something very time,
the fact that it took decades for it to be
appreciated, I think speaks to the timelessness.
There's a real warning here as well, which is I'm
of Sicilian extraction. I'm not quite
an oriental cannibal like some of the people on this voyage,
But close enough.
We have a little bit of a temper sometimes.
The Sicilians say revenge is a dish best served cold,
at least in America we do.
And the big warning in the book is...
That old cliche, if you set out for revenge, dig two graves,
and similar prophecies were told in the beginning of the book,
that this guy is so consumed by hatred and the demand
for vengeance against a dumb object. I mean, he is told, in fact,
in the book, it's not even like you're fighting against some evil man
who's unleashed malice on you. He's just a big, dumb whale.
I mean, it's like...
It's like the biggest, dumbest whale, actually.
The description of the whale's front reminds us
that the mouth is underneath this giant,
well, you see a picture of it on here, the giant head.
You get the mouth underneath, so you barely see the mouth.
The eyes are both on the sides of its head,
and the nose is on top in the spout, the blowhole.
So when the whale is coming at you,
it's just a big square wall of flesh that is not even bone.
It's just kind of this dumb, hard flesh that bangs against you.
So why would you go down, sacrifice your life,
sacrifice your time and your actual life
and your whole crew to get revenge on this dumb force of nature?
Well, as the pro-Ahab party in this.
Maybe you can tell me why.
You could say the same thing about Mount Everest.
You know, it's how many people died trying to climb.
K2 or Mount Everest or all these big implacable immobile forces
of nature that were there are
literally big white walls of death.
The white whale and the white wall. Yes and and you see these
you know there's um that's saying you know
why climb Mount Everest because it's there
and there is that it's not necessarily um even even
a story you know it's not that okay I want
I want to climb Mount Everest because.
It murdered my cousin or, you know,
I was in Nepal once and I got frostbite and I blame it on
me. There's something that calls man to do the impossible.
And whatever sort of motivation it
takes to get there,
sometimes that motivations can differ by their sort of positive and
negative energy. And there's a theme about hate in the book that is
It's something that today, I think,
is very useful to see how the different characters approach that.
We mentioned that the captain that had his arm bitten off by Moby Dick
and was chill about it,
whereas Ahab dedicates his life and the life of the crew,
hijacks it to go after that.
But this is a struggle with greatness.
I mean, look at someone like Michael Jordan,
greatest basketball player in history, completely fueled by...
Vengeance and the dark side of the force,
even to the point that when he's accepting his NBA Hall of Fame,
he's recounting all the people who slighted him along the way.
That does give you a certain power.
I mean, there is a...
Not to use a cliche Star Wars analogy,
but the dark side of the force is, in many respects,
stronger. There's a reason that Luke could
not compete in that first fight with that.
Everyone gets their motivation from different sources,
and there's a caution that it can't
completely consume you, but there's
also a kind of human struggle with the need to harness every
source of energy you can if you are going
to pursue something that is truly
It's seismic in scale in terms of your mission.
Well, to use your analogy, actually,
I think you've persuaded me of one thing.
If the white whale were like Jar Jar Binks,
I would sacrifice my life to kill him.
With no question about it.
So midway through, so chapter one is called Loomings.
And it's just the whole thing.
If you read nothing else, it's, there's a fabulous,
I think Jeremy Irons does the reading on the Audible.
It's about 25 minutes just to get through chapter one alone.
About midway through it.
He's pontificating as he is constantly throughout the novel.
You have him kind of projecting meaning,
almost drawing a Rorschach inkblot test on whales and various things.
And midway through, there's
a line where he's asking himself how he got chosen for this mission.
And he describes it on the Scrolls of Fate.
Grand contested...
Battle for the, I'm sorry, grand contested election
for the president of the United States.
Yeah.
One Ishmael whaling voyage,
great battle in Afghanistan and bloody battle in Afghanistan.
And it's so funny because, um, you know,
I, I had, I had read it in college, but I,
it wasn't until around the 2016 election that I picked it up and,
and, and read it in full.
And really it sort of the, the wave of it sort of hit over me.
And I just thought it was so funny because you had.
This grand contested presidential election
in 2016 that was playing out.
You have these bloody battles in Afghanistan.
And then sandwiched in between that, everyone in the space
was sort of making their own journey, a sort of side plot.
In a grander play.
Well, that might have been Fate,
that you picked it up precisely at that time.
And Fate obviously plays a big role in the novel.
It does seem like there's a story
that's already been laid out here.
And it's a story that unfolds in nature.
This great line, speaking of college,
he says, this whaling ship,
that was my Yale College and my Harvard.
Yes, yes.
Yes, and...
I thought it was very PDT.
Peter Thielish, it was, you know,
you don't need to go to college.
You don't need to go to Yale or Harvard.
No, no offense.
But you go to see it as a whaler.
Yes.
And there is kind of a drive to do that,
to get that hands-on experience,
which, but I'm sorry, we were.
No, well, so this is my question then.
On the sort of fate, the providence of it all,
who is Ahab?
Well, it's fascinating because, I mean, so.
It's natural to draw, I think,
the parallel between King Ahab, who from essentially the
Hebrew Bible, you have Ahab was married to Jezebel.
There was the famous confrontation with Elijah
and the fall of his entire house and lineage.
So he's this terrible king of northern Israel, marries Jezebel.
As a standoff with the prophet Elijah.
Yes.
Prophet Elijah says, hey, you know, you got to knock it off here.
And he's just a very terrible king.
And what's weird about mentioning Elijah is right
when we're introduced to Captain Ahab of the Pequod,
we're also introduced to this strange old sailor, Elijah.
It's been a pleasure.
Yes.
Yes.
So Elijah is the, I mean,
he comes across as a kind of drunken, half-crazed.
It's almost like a comedy movie today where
You know, some some drunk slurring guy sipping on a 40 ounce, you know,
tells you some, you know, tells the main character some piece
of information that they end up needing later.
But effectively,
so Elijah is is who Ishmael runs into prior to meeting Ahab.
And it's Elijah who warns him that Ahab is, you know,
affixed with his own visions and is, you know, not necessarily the
The safe bet for a whaling voyage that you might want to have,
the steady hand you might want to have as your captain.
But I actually have a complicated relationship with...
I'd heard all these things about Ahab being this evil and terrible,
you know, sort of villain in the book, so to speak.
Captain Ahab.
Captain Ahab, yes, I should say.
Not King Ahab.
You know, there is something...
I think when I began to really...
Take this book in and kind of fit it
into my own kind of sense of seeing the world.
Ahab does get the whale in the end.
And there is a kind of reality distortion field
that Ahab has that great figures of history have
and that is sometimes necessary to achieve any great mission.
When you say he gets the whale.
I mean, you know, it's not a happily ever after story.
He is stabbing from hell's heart at the whale
as he goes down to Davy Jones' locker.
Yes, yes.
But he does meet him.
He does at least get his chance at him, yes.
Right, right.
The whale represents this indomitable force,
this, you know, it's not even really a creature
so much as it is a kind of spirit of the universe
that has to be conquered in his view.
I see a lot of great figures of history
who have that Ahab kind of focus, and you can
sort of pick which character you want to be on such journeys.
I mean, with Ishmael, you see a sort of reasonable,
artistic, eccentric type fellow.
With Starbuck, you see this sort of steady hand.
So Starbuck is the chief mate.
Yes, the chief mate who tries to stop Ahab,
who contemplates murdering him, Ahab in his
sleep in order to save the crew from this mad mission.
But there are, you can imagine a world in which the whale truly
was a danger and someone had to go out and stop it.
And I'm not sure that men like Starbuck or Ishmael would have
the constitution to do what has to be done to confront it.
This is the neocon read of Moby Dick.
We have to go out across the world and slay the evil white whale.
Well, there's something intensely personal about it for Ahab.
And there is the fact that it is a whale
and it's not a kind of geopolitical, you know, I mentioned
the chapter one reference to the bloody battle in Afghanistan.
In that case, you had a British war in the 1830s and 40s,
the disastrous military campaign.
16,000 dead British soldiers and civilians,
and I believe there was only one survivor of one of the key battles,
and so Ishmael sort of echoes the survivor of that kind of in the book,
but I see both sides of it, the neocon and anti-neocon side,
in the sense that you could see a world in which both, okay,
you mentioned Father Mapple's sermon, which is like chapter nine,
it's this incredible, essentially there's a former sailor,
who just who becomes this famous local priest
and and gives this sort of the place sailors visit
even even the pulpit is kind of like
a ship he crawls up a rope ladder to the pulpit right
and he delivers this incredible sermon uh about jonah
and the whale and it gets at
there's a tension around why do you go to sea why do you go
Why do you go on the mission that you go on?
So Ishmael goes to sea.
In that sense, he is like Jonah.
You have, you know, Jonah was basically commanded
by God to go to Nineveh and, you know, tell
them of their wickedness, and Jonah did not want to do that.
He sort of chickens out, becomes an exile refugee,
tries to, you know, jump on a ship
to Tarshish, I believe, and is effectively...
The sermon very vividly imputes, you know, he's a marked man.
Everyone can tell he's guilty of something.
They don't know that he's a God refugee effectively.
But he goes to see, Jonah does,
to try to run away from what he's called to do by God.
Ishmael goes to see as a sailor to try to sort.
He's himself out effectively.
There's a damp, drizzly November in his soul.
He decides he's going to go to sea
as he periodically feels the need to do
to sort of work things out.
Ahab is going to sea on this, you know,
sort of mission to avenge a personal slight
from the whale having taken his leg.
There is this kind of, you could see a world
in which you need to partake, you know,
embark on this adventure.
To find your own place in the world.
You could see a world in which you go on this adventure
because you need to get out of some trouble you're in.
You could see a world in which you embark on an adventure
because you have something that you need to achieve
that may be bigger than yourself and a legacy.
well beyond yourself,
that you don't care if it costs you your life in some form.
Well, even think about Ishmael right off the bat. He says,
when I was given my portion of the eventual proceeds,
because beyond this mission of
revenge, what they're actually supposed to be doing
is just killing sperm whales and getting
oil and making a bunch of money.
But he says, the way that my pay was going to work.
I would be lucky if I could replace the clothes on my back.
But I'd get, you know, three years of beef and lodging, so that's fine.
He wasn't going there to make a fortune.
He was going there for some personal narrative.
He felt he was called here for his freedom.
And so you get this interesting double take on individualism.
On the one hand, the individualism that calls you into the great sea,
into the great inspiration
and the freedom to chart your course, come back, maybe tell the tale.
But then the dark side of the individualism,
which is that Ahab is not, he's not going
to go kill the white whale for the common good.
He's not going to go kill the white whale because God wants him to.
Quite the opposite.
He has diabolical imagery all throughout this.
He brings on these kind of exotic, oriental, secret.
crewmen to help him to kill the whale.
And in fact, right before the final battle, the three-day
chase, he crafts, he has the carpenter make him his new harpoons,
special harpoons to finally
pierce this whale.
And what does he do with the harpoons? He heats them up.
He baptizes them in heathen blood.
The harpooneers are all heathens.
The rest of the guys, most of the rest of the guys are white men.
But the harpooneers are these heathen cannibal types
with all sorts of fun names like Queequeg.
And he takes the pagan blood and he says in Latin, ego te baptizo.
But he doesn't say, I baptize you in the name of the Father,
as he says here, or in the
Trinitarian formula, in the name of the Father,
Son, and the Holy Spirit.
He says, I baptize you in the name of the devil.
I am on an overtly diabolical journey. This is for me.
This is the exaltation of the individual,
which is in fact the original sin.
At the height of individualism in the 19th century,
you see this dark side of individualism too.
Well, there's, I suppose,
a biblical parallel in the sense that Ahab himself is cursed to
basically die and have the dogs lick his blood,
and indeed, there is sort of that
That vignette of him being, I believe,
hit by an arrow in his chariot and the blood runs into the wheels,
and it is indeed licked up by the dogs,
and part of his defiance of God was ball worship, effectively.
So there's probably not an accident in that vivid scene,
but I guess there's...
And this is why I feel like everyone's experience
with Moby Dick is a kind of personal one.
There is a tension with the accomplishment
of a great journey around the level of sacrifice
that you are willing to endure to achieve it.
It's all a transgressing limit.
We're naturally constrained,
but we have this yearning to break free of all of those constraints,
which can have infernal results.
Yes, right.
The reality distortion field aspect of Ahab,
I think, is a really interesting thing.
I mean, many great figures of history,
and I mean great in terms of the capital G, regardless
of what you think of them, you know,
the Steve Jobs type, the Donald Trump type, the people
with like a sense of will, indomitable will,
they're going to do their thing, regardless
of whether you think it's good or bad.
But at the end of the day, there will be a dent.
On History Made, because of the force of that will,
I think there is something to the character
of Ahab that is more complicated than what
is the sort of common telling to me.
I mean, I...
You're very pro-Ahab.
You have the contrarian pro-Ahab take on Moby Dick.
I'm pro-morally dubious, morally ambiguous.
I guess I will...
I'll glibly accept the premise that I am pro-Ahab.
I think that one of the things, to me,
in my reading of the book, I didn't feel that
Ishmael, there's a common telling,
because the book is like 927 pages, and it's very
few people take the time to read through the full thing.
People get their impressions of Ahab from popular press.
And in my view, less from Ishmael's eyes
or your own eyes going through the whole journey.
And I can see a world where, you know,
because Ahab cost the lives of the crew and, you know,
obviously the level of collateral damage.
Yeah.
Even his, his poor, the first mate Starbuck,
he says at the, at the last moment, he says,
we can turn back.
We actually should turn.
You've gotten warnings from other ships that have come by.
Like we really can turn back right now and we should.
And I have a wife and kids at home is, is implied.
Yes.
And Ahab says, no, I'll get my damned revenge.
Right.
Sorry.
And in fact, it's the, I believe it's
the captain of the ship, the Rachel.
The Rachel, another, another, this is right,
I think it's the last ship, the last two ships
they encounter, the Rachel and the Delight.
And here too, we have another,
like with Ishmael, there's Ishmael and Isaac.
Ishmael is the unfavored of the sons.
And with Rachel, you have.
Rachel and Leia, Leia being the unfavored wife
and Rachel being the favored wife.
And the crew of the Rachel says, hey, turn back, cut it out.
Right.
And I believe there's a reference to the daughter
of the captain being potentially have gone
missing and asking Ahab's help in the search.
Yeah, the son, I think.
Yes, the son, yes.
And then Ahab turns it down.
You know, to be able to focus monomaniacally on the whale hunt,
then it is the Rachel that picks up Ishmael,
you know, from Queequeg's coffin.
Rachel, who is the mother of Joseph,
the son, one of the 12 sons of Israel,
who goes missing because his brothers sell him to the Egyptians.
Right, right.
You know, when you embark on anything dangerous,
and I'm getting back to my pro-Ahab position here, I guess.
When you embark on anything dangerous,
And you're going up against a force like the white whale.
Everyone around you will tell you not to do it.
Everyone, you know, your parents will have their own opinions,
your friends, your employer or former employers.
And
And I must point out, they would all be right to tell you not to do it.
They would be totally vindicated.
It depends on the whale, though.
Everyone's, and this is why I think this is just, it's a life.
altering book to read,
but I can't recommend it unless you are on a journey where, where these
seeing someone else go through it.
Can I put it less politically correctly? Yeah. It's a book for
boys. It's not a book for girls.
I'm sure there are exceptions. I'm irritated that I was never
told to read this in school.
I read other Melville books and people read Bartleby the Scrivener.
That's a pretty well-read short story of Melville's excellent.
We should read Moby Dick.
And I think my conspiracy theory
is that people don't read Moby Dick
as much in school anymore
because it's a boy's story.
Just like Treasure Island is a boy's story.
There's just certain books
that are really more for boys than for girls.
And I agree with you.
It's not for everybody,
but it's a marvelously engrossing book.
And I'm glad I finally, at 36 years of age,
finally made it through.
One of the other impediments to reading it, though, is...
He'll digress for who knows how many pages
in encyclopedic descriptions of whales or how to
boil the blubber of this kind of whale,
the right whale versus the sperm whale versus...
Why does he do that? Why is he giving me a guidebook to cetaceans?
This is one of the things that makes the book, I think, not as...
Because if it stays... Basically,
you have a book where the first 15 chapters
are totally engrossing, in my view. I mean, even...
Chapter one is just you inside the funhouse mirror of Ishmael's mind,
and it's just a fascinating place to be.
Chapter one, you get this unbelievably beautiful first line
that immediately draws you in, call me Ishmael,
and then you get cannibals, threats of death, you know, you're in it.
It's powerful.
You just have this vivid, you're sucked into this universe,
and then you're out at sea,
and then there's what's probably 40 chapters of just...
Very granular technical details of whaling,
shipcraft, the various materials made in
architecture, you know, these.
I'll tell you though, this is like people tell you
with War and Peace, they say, you're
going to hate these interstitial chapters
where it's just historical and philosophical
essays.
And then I was reading it in between the party
and the battle scenes, and I said, I love
these essays.
And same thing here.
I love the granular detail on how to get the spermaceti out of the head
and what kind of oil it's, and why some of the whales sink and why.
But, you know, he says something that isn't true.
He says in here, and it's a key point of the book,
he says the sperm whale is the biggest whale,
it's the biggest animal on Earth.
Right.
But it's not. The blue whale is.
Now, you might chalk some of that up to whaling being,
you know, an active scientific endeavor at the time.
I think he knows he's exaggerating a little bit here,
because the sperm whale is the biggest whale with teeth.
Yeah.
And that's pretty important for this apex predator of unclear,
of ambiguous will.
Is he just a force of nature?
Is he a personal force? Is he even down to...
One of these digressive chapters,
Melville talks about why white animals scare us.
And it's weird.
It actually arrested me for a moment because I said,
well, white is a nice color.
Purity and things that's right.
Yeah, purity, yeah, cleanliness.
I don't know, you know, it's angelic.
Yeah, gates of heaven.
And he admits that.
He says, here are all the reasons why white is nice.
But now I'm going to tell you why white is really scary.
The polar bear is scarier than other bears.
An albino person.
A person who you...
Things should have some color to him, but he's totally white.
It kind of freaks you out a little bit.
Why is that?
And he describes the infernal or sort of diabolical, demonic aspects.
What is it?
Because maybe it's the absence of life.
And so he goes into this labored,
tedious detail on all of these aspects,
and there is a kind of interpretive ambiguity to it.
I mean, that chapter to me is the example of Par excellence, which is,
Maybe.
Is it a good thing?
Yeah, you know, there is this very subjective,
to your point, which is, well, here's what
it means for me.
Maybe it doesn't mean that for you.
Gosh darn it, I even like Ahab.
And I think, well, that's not wholly unfounded in the book.
That's not wholly unfounded in romanticism,
even, you know, this subjective individual
view against these overwhelming forces of nature.
Yeah, no, absolutely.
Absolutely. And you can see his attempt to kind of justify his own.
I don't want to say psychoses, but idiosyncrasies,
like you could see that he feels this terror
and he's trying to work through why he feels this way,
or he feels pulled to do something
and he's trying to work through it.
And he comes to his own conclusion,
sort of showing his work through prose.
Think about how he does this with, with Queequeg.
You know, Queequeg is a great, he's the scariest guy ever.
And yet he's the best, he's the best guy in the book.
Right.
He jumps into the water to save people.
He's the best friend.
He's like.
You know, rubbing his forehead on Ishmael,
they share a bed together, and Ishmael walks
up to Queequeg, Queequeg is a Muslim cannibal,
and it's during his Ramadan, and he's worshiping
an idol, and he's just all, everything
that Christianity says, don't do.
And he says, better to lie, better to sleep,
better to lie with a sober cannibal than a
drunken Christian.
Yes, yeah, and he even goes so far, not just to justify the friendship.
He justifies idolatry. He says, well, look,
my religion tells me to do unto others as you would
have others do unto you.
And I would have people respect my religion. So I guess, you know,
if I'm a true Christian, I should.
Practice idolatry with this cannibal, right?
And you say look there are logical errors here
But he is showing his work and what he is also doing is leaving behind
Thank
Dogmatism right leaving behind even a perfectly rational logical view
of the world and throwing himself into this
you
Emotion this maelstrom literal maelstrom
These these forces that are are ineffable that you see in
for
Romanticism and that you see in in the ocean, right?
listening.
Well, that's and you see the same thing
Even in the figure of Ahab as the pro-Ahab counterparty.
Yeah, here we go. Wow, I did not expect it to be.
Let me use the pro-Ahab side.
But Ahab is a Quaker, and the Quakers are famously anti-war,
anti-militarism, and sort of dogmatically so.
And yet he is the one who, you know,
to come back to this sort of, you know, if you will, sort of...
neocon, anti-neocon, you know, frames here.
It's like, in this case, this would be the analogy of
the Quakers, you know, calling for a neocon.
In fact, not only that, who drags the entire,
you know, ship and everybody with them into it.
And so you have all these inversions along the
way of it. And this is why what I come back
to about the beautiful experience of reading this
is that you get to see.
Different starting positions that the characters have in this,
and you get to sort of get a holistic,
from all the different personality quirks of the folks on the ship,
to the hemming and hawing about whether or not to, you know,
go sailing or whaling or to, you know, all the different,
well, we could turn back now. We don't have to do this now.
Here's another great reason we could turn around or we could.
And you can almost see, I think,
in everyone's own kind of personal hero's journey,
whatever they are, whatever their white whale is or whatever
their spiritual development issue they're trying to work out,
just thinking they're going to sea, you can choose.
It sort of gives you vignettes to choose from.
Who you would want to be on this ship.
Even down to when he, early in the book,
when he goes up to the top of the mast for lookout,
and he says, this is a very bad place
for a man of a philosophical bent.
Because your mind wanders onto these,
Plato keeps coming up actually a lot.
But he says, because of that, your mind,
actually much like Plato, is in the realm of the forms.
It's up in the clouds.
So you don't actually see the whales.
And this is a theme too that keeps coming back.
You know, this is a job.
They have, there are investors in this ship,
Captain Bildad, Captain Peleg, and they want
to get their oil, but it seems like.
Everybody on the ship has some other purpose or some ulterior motive,
to the point that the first mate, Starbuck,
would have been justified in killing Ahab because Ahab was a usurper.
He broke the law.
He was turning this business to his own ends.
So there.
It's such hard, brutal, terrible work that for some people could
be lucrative, for most of them would not be.
And yet, none of them seems to be doing it really for the money.
Yeah.
Well, it's, and especially the main character.
I mean, it's, and this is a thing, something that I
think men, particularly men in their late teens,
twenties, and early thirties in particular,
have, as they're trying to find their own way
in a kind of atomized world, there is this
There's a, there's a search for something to give them meaning,
to be a part of some
journey that's greater than what's in their local classrooms
or what's on social media
or, you know, to find their place in something.
Closer to nature, closer to the primal experience of just being alive.
And that's what, I mean, it's one of the reasons that he says,
that Ishmael says that he goes to sea as a sailor,
is that he can breathe the air on the fo'c'sle deck,
that he basically gets to experience the sea.
He never spends any time in his cabin.
He's just on the deck.
Before we go, we open with one of the most famous lines in literature,
we close with one of the most famous lines in literature.
Am I cut off from the last fond pride of meanest shipwrecked captains?
Oh, lonely death on lonely life.
It's so apt that you mention how people reading today, especially men,
but everybody has this isolation,
especially accelerated by social media.
Well, they didn't have TikTok in 1850, and yet here we have it.
Oh, lonely death on lonely life.
Oh, now I feel my topmost greatness lies in my topmost grief.
This is my greatness.
My defeat is my greatness.
Ho, ho, from all your furthest bounds,
pour ye now in, ye bold billows of my whole foregone
life, foregone even in the sense
that we're talking about this individualism, and yet
the whole thing has been prophesied.
Ahab himself talks about the prophecy of losing his limbs and all.
Elijah, this prophetic figure in the beginning.
And top this one piled comber of my death, towards thee I roll,
thou all-destroying but unconquering wail.
To the last I grapple with thee, from hell's heart I stab at thee,
for hate's sake I spit my last breath at thee.
Sink all coffins and all hearses to one common pool.
I'll finish, and thus, it's too good, and thus neither can be mine,
let me then toe to pieces while still chasing thee,
though tied to thee thou damned whale, thus I give up the spear.
Great man of history.
Yes, and of course, here we see the whale.
Is the whale this figure of divine wrath, divine vengeance?
Is the whale this diabolical figure?
Well, here we see whale as death in this foretold life,
this lonely death, this lonely life,
his utmost glory and his utmost grief.
The whale is death.
The whale is his death.
And he is going down to it on his own terms.
He's, you know, not going quietly into that dark night.
Yeah.
There's this fascinating vignette where Ahab along
the way runs into another captain who
had, I believe, his arm taken, one of his arms taken by...
Uh, uh, by, I believe it was by Moby Dick as well.
And that you see this fascinating
alternate reality of a different way
that Ahab could have dealt with it, could have dealt with
it. Men will do anything other than go to therapy.
They will sail to the Indian ocean to fight the
giant sperm whale rather than just go to therapy,
a, a, a very therapeutic experience and a better
than therapeutic experience for young men.
is to read this book. I'm very grateful,
Mike, that you have told me and finally,
at 36 years of age, made me read it as well.
Call me, Michael, and I will see you on the
next episode of Book Club.
Thank you so much for watching this episode of the Book Club
on PragerU. PragerU is a 501c3 nonprofit organization,
so we rely on donations from
viewers like you to keep this content on the air.
Please consider making a tax-deductible
contribution today to help keep
this content coming. Thank you very much.