Dr. Les Carter is a best selling author and therapist who has semi-retired to Waco, TX. In the past 40+ years he has conducted more than 65,000 counseling sessions and many workshops and seminars. He specializes in anger management and narcissistic personality disorder.
If you are interested in online therapy, Dr. Carter has a sponsor who can assist. As the need is there, please seek the help you deserve: https://betterhelp.com/drcarter We receive commissions on referrals to BetterHelp. We only recommend services that we trust. If you have any questions about the brand relating to how the therapists are licensed, their privacy policy, or therapist compensation model, check out this FAQ: https://www.betterhelp.com/your-questions-answered/
Hey, team healthy, glad to have you here today.
So, all right.
I, I see already that some of you are talking about this being my last live feed.
Uh, and the answer is yeah, that's right.
And I'm gonna explain that to you in just a second.
Uh, don't worry about it.
Cause I'm not going to be going away and all like that.
So, um, what I'm doing is, uh, obviously we, uh, I do these on Wednesdays and,
uh, next Wednesday is Christmas.
The weekend after that week after that is new year.
We're going to do a little change in format.
Uh, one of the, uh, one of the things that we found is that there are quite
a number of individuals who, uh, who don't even, um, access at all the live
feeds, uh, and there's a different tab for live, uh, than there are just for
the regular videos and then an extremely high percentage of the people who watch
the last feed, watch the tape recording.
You know, tape recording is just my way of saying I'm old because I don't know
what to call it when you do this and then you upload it and anyway, so we
do the tape recording, so that being the case, what I'm going to do is I'm
going to continue that because I, I, I'm going to continue receiving your questions.
One of the reasons that we began doing the live feed is because I wanted to
hear from you so that I could respond in a very specific way to whatever's
going on in your world in a very personal kind of way, and I'm going to
continue to receive your questions.
I mean, I pick up on, I don't know how many per week, but a lot.
And, uh, I'm going to start, uh, calling the series unbound, uh, you know, as
opposed to being bound in a trauma bond with the narcissist, uh, how
to break free from all of that.
So unbound and the new unbound, um, uh, presentations are going to be on
Wednesdays at 10 o'clock central time, as opposed to 11 central time us, uh,
on Wednesdays and then 10 o'clock central time on Saturdays, and so I'm going to
make them the same length as my regular videos and that way it's going to be
more accessible, frankly, uh, to a lot larger number of people and, but we're
still going to do the same thing.
And then in addition, what it does is it allows me to take a little bit more
time and, uh, to pull in some questions and, and elaborate it on a little bit
more fully than I tend to do here.
Cause I, I tend to have a larger number of questions here.
So, uh, the, uh, the unbound series on Wednesdays and Saturdays, uh, are
going to give me a chance to, um, to do the same thing, but in just a little
bit of a different format, so just, uh, let's, let's shift where we're just
simply, uh, growing and expanding and evolving and all, and that's part of it.
So, uh, uh, but I, I, I so like hearing from you and knowing your situation
is, I want to continue to do that.
So what it means is I'm going to be, uh, uploading regular videos on, uh, Tuesday,
excuse me, on Mondays and Thursdays.
We're going to do unbound with questions on Wednesdays and Saturdays.
And then the other day, so I'm going to be producing shorts.
Uh, those are the 60 second videos.
And so that's going to give, uh, some sort of, uh, uh, feed for you every
single day and, uh, hopefully we're just going to keep doing something going here.
So just, and it's going to begin on January the 4th, that's a Saturday.
And then I'll be doing that, uh, on and on throughout and we're going
to keep that up as a new feature.
So, uh, same concept of, uh, receiving questions, a little
bit of a different format.
That's all don't worry about it.
And you can still do your chats with that whenever I do all the rest.
So, um, I, I so appreciate you guys.
And, and, uh, frankly, those of you who are here on the live, uh, live
these y'all at the core of team healthy.
I hope you understand that.
Uh, I'm, I'm deeply appreciative of you.
So I have a good slate of questions here and I'm going to dive right in with you.
And we're going to see where it leads us.
Uh, the first question, uh, and, and by the way, you know, I like to do a theme.
The theme here that we've got is, uh, learning how to stay strong.
Even when narcissists offer you, uh, invalidation, it's like, yeah,
I'll feed you a lot to that.
I'm going to feed you some rejection.
I'll, I'll feed you some invalidation.
I'll feed you some, uh, some criticism, uh, uh, want some more.
I got lots of it.
So that's what we're going to be talking about.
This person said, dr.
C.
I could use some suggestions on dealing with mutual friends when the
narcissist tries to turn them against you.
What do you say without looking like I'm bad mouthing the narcissist
questions like what's happening with you and the narcissist and acquaintances
who they butter up and try to make me look uncharitable.
So this, this is not at all an unusual situation.
Basically you're referring to the narcissist tactic of trying to maintain
power through what we call triangulation.
Uh, triangulation means that I, I'm going to bring in other people.
So let's say that I'm the narcissist.
I hope I'm not, but let's say for pretend sake, I'm the narcissist
and I I've got it, I've got a, a grudge against you.
So what I'm going to do is I'm going to pull in this person over here and I'll
say, um, did you know that, um, something's going on here that I'm really concerned
about and that it doesn't feel good at all.
And then, so I'm going to let other people have a bad impression of you and
then sit back and just watch it play out.
And I may triangulate and do it with a whole bunch of different people.
And this is the hidden smear campaign and all the rest.
So then you wind up catching wind of that.
It's like, Whoa, wait a minute.
That narcissist is saying some really lousy things.
And someone comes to you and says, uh, I think we have a problem here.
So then your question is, well, how, how strongly do you defend yourself?
And, um, this is kind of tricky because, um, you have to know who you're talking
with and where they're coming from.
Are they being constructive?
Are they being inquisitive so that they can do some data gathering?
Are they flying monkeys?
Are they just trying to size up whether they're going to reject you or not?
I mean, so you, you kind of have to get a lay of the land there.
So there's not one fixed way that you can handle this.
So, uh, when you, when you know that you're being smeared by the narcissist
and then you're discussing this with the person who's receiving the
smear campaign, proceed with caution.
Now, one of the things that we don't want to do, uh, if, if you're involved
in something like this, is you don't want to go into a super high defensive mode.
What is the narcissist trying to accomplish by speaking ill
of you to other individuals?
And the answer is they want to make you look stupid.
They want to make you look foolish.
They want to make you look inadequate.
And so, um, uh, if you come across to that person who's being triangulated
in, if you come across as just unraveled and unhinged and agitated, then all
that's going to do is it's going to play right into the narcissist's hand.
Uh, that person is going to be thinking, oh, there's some, uh, there's some
real turmoil here that in dysfunction.
I didn't know about it, but I see it.
Maybe the narcissist is right.
And so you've heard me use the term calm firmness or calm confidence.
Uh, there, there can come a time where you're going to know, I
need to draw upon that right now.
I'm comfortable with who I am.
And even when I make mistakes or if there's something that I've said or
done that was not my, my finest hour, I'm quite capable of making
adjustments and learning from it.
So I know me well enough to know that, uh, that, that I do respond to
conflict or, or, uh, mistakes constructively.
Keep in mind the, uh, the mark of a healthy person is not the absence
of mistakes or the absence of, uh, of, uh, you know, uh, or the presence
of a perfection, but just knowing how to handle conflict and knowing how to
handle growth in a constructive kind of way.
So my first thing is I would go to that, or I would say to that person,
they're saying, Hey, Mr.
Narcissist, Ms.
Narcissist over here is saying some pretty disparaging things.
I I'd seek some assistance rather than saying, well,
that they're always complaining.
Nope.
What I'm going to do is, um, I'm going to say something like, and
this is the therapist in me.
Help me understand what we're dealing with because as a therapist, when I hear
stuff, I know there's a bigger backstory.
Uh, let's figure out what that is.
What's the context of what, uh, what you're talking about?
Cause I, obviously I wasn't there.
I don't know what the situation is.
Can you help me know, you know, what you're hearing and what your reaction
is and, and exactly what, uh, what the whole point of that conversation was.
Cause then I can, uh, discuss this with you more, uh, in an informed kind of way.
And what it does is it, uh, it puts that other person on notice.
It says, if you think you're going to do some sort of a gossipy, uh, or
tattletailing kind of a thing, I'm not into that, I honestly
want to be objective at this.
And then, uh, the more reasonable you are and the more objective you are, uh,
then you, you automatically, hopefully we'll have greater credibility.
And then it might be, and it all depends on the level of closeness or how much
you really care about that person.
Who's confronting you about what the narcissist says.
Uh, it might be that you will need to give some explanation.
None of us likes to feel defensive.
Uh, but there are times when you need to defend in the sense that says, uh,
may I offer you a different explanation?
And then you have to be real careful about how far you want to go.
Uh, I'm all into self-disclosure and, uh, and openness and vulnerability, as
long as I feel that that person in front of me is trustworthy.
And so there are times when it may be that you'll say, you know, uh, the
narcissist, I did in fact have some difficulty and, uh, and it didn't, it
didn't end well, or it may be that you'll say what you're saying catches me off
guard.
I'm not sure how I'm going to manage this.
I need to think it through, but you want to be very careful that you don't go into
character assassination and, and use the tactics that the narcissist will, uh, for
example, you don't want to just, uh, berate the narcissist and tell that person
how stupid that individual is and get, uh, and then put that individual in the
middle.
Uh, but it would be more appropriate to let it be known calmly.
Um, I appreciate you bringing your, uh, concerns.
Um, let me think it through and I want to just kind of gather my thoughts and
maybe, uh, get a little bit further information from where that other person
is coming from.
Cause, uh, cause inevitably, uh, you're not hearing the entire story.
Uh, but in other words, just be judicious.
So there's a combination of, uh, caution and openness, vulnerability, and, uh, and
um, uh, a certain amount of healthy defensiveness is there.
That's a tough one, but that's, that's, uh, that triangulation thing is something
that narcissists love to do over and over.
Uh, okay.
This is an interesting one here.
Um, why do some covert communal narcissists have an, an apparent dislike of someone
expressing appreciation?
Okay.
Usually it's, uh, they don't like, you know, you can express in content of
Oh, they, uh, they have a dislike for someone expressing appreciation when
they've done something that's actually helpful as if being complimented,
complimented is a negative thing.
It seems that they view it as an annoyance.
Okay.
This is a great question.
So you have a situation where that person who, uh, tends to have a reputation of,
uh, uh, narcissism has actually done something very nice and you
want to draw attention to that.
And you want to be an encourager and you say, Hey, when you did a, uh, that,
that really did help me out a lot.
I really appreciate when you do it that way.
And when you, uh, when you show some regard, thank you so much.
What you're doing is, is you're, you're bringing yourself into an open and
vulnerable kind of a place for that person.
Uh, and the narcissist is thinking, Oh, wait a minute.
Wait a minute.
You want me to match pitch, don't you?
You want me to show kindness in reverse.
Now that you're saying kind things to me, huh?
Is that what the deal is?
And they think competitively.
You've heard me say before that narcissism tends to be a
by-product of some paranoia.
It's like, okay, so what did you really mean by that?
Uh, so, so it shows how demented their way of thinking can be when you come
along and say, well, you see, I just have a compliment.
I'm trying to give you nothing more, nothing less.
If the narcissist could be honest, what they would say is, well,
to me, compliments are a tool.
Compliments are part of my gaslighting compliments are part of my, uh,
trying to get favor from you.
And, uh, I don't sense that that's what you're doing.
I don't think I like this.
And so you're inviting them into a more healthy and even
humble form of communication.
Uh, for example, if you do something nice, uh, it, it, um, the narcissist
is going to think I, by receiving your kind remarks, that puts me
in the subservient role that doesn't, but that's how they think.
And so it's a fascinating, uh, uh, box that they find themselves
kind of painted themselves in the corner.
Uh, I can be, uh, kind and friendly and encouraging because it's
just my love bombing and it's my gaslighting and it's all the, the
other, um, uh, manipulative stuff.
But when you do it and it seems to have it either, you're doing the
same thing to me, or there's an absence and I don't know how to do that.
And so, uh, in their competitive approach towards relationships, they forget.
There are some people we call ourselves team healthy, who, when they offer a
compliment, they mean it as a compliment.
There's, there's no hidden agenda.
And so, uh, you're, you're, uh, you're, you might as well be speaking
Swahili to them because it's like, I don't, I don't, I don't
do that psychological language.
So that's why you, you've received such an odd kind of situation is
humorous in its own strange way.
Because you're looked upon with suspicion for being healthy.
Uh, I don't do healthy again.
They don't have that kind of self-awareness and honesty, but
that's, what's really going on.
And it's, it's kind of interesting.
Um, so anyway, uh, I, I, I, I wanted to make sure I got that one on here today.
Uh, okay.
Now the next one we're talking about narcissists giving invalidation.
Um, this person asked, how can I say, stay strong in my own self affirmation
when the narcissist continues to tear me down, isn't it amazing that the
narcissist has decided, well, let's see in this relationship, we need a judge.
We need somebody who's going to pronounce correctness and
incorrectness, uh, right.
Then wrong.
Who's that judge going to be?
Let's see.
Oh, I volunteer.
And so they'll, they'll, they'll appoint themselves as being the judge over you.
It's not up to a vote.
It's, it's not something that they say, would you mind if I just judged you?
I mean, I've got lots of judgments.
They're not going to be that straightforward.
They've just arbitrarily assume the position I need to judge you.
And so part of what, uh, as you're trying to respond to their judgments,
which are inevitably going to be in their favor and your disfavor, you
first have to ask the question, well, wait a minute, because that person has,
uh, appointed themselves as judge over me.
Well, does that mean that I'm obligated, obligated to
receive that person's judgment?
Uh, you're the one sitting on the bench and I'm the defendant over here in the
dock and I'm supposed to defend myself against it and it's a game.
And so when you ask me, you know, how do I stay strong in myself?
Affirmation that when they're over there judging, they want to tear you down.
I think the question is, well, am I, did I even have a vote in this?
Uh, and now when you ask, how do you respond or how do you stay strong?
One of the first things you don't do is go into the point counterpoint game.
You said the narcissist says, well, I just think you're awful and you're
terrible, and then you feel like you have to defend yourself.
No, I'm not.
And here's the four reasons why, uh, or you can plead your case.
Uh, there's the three no's that I say that you don't want to
go into at a time like this.
No pleading, no coaxing, no convincing.
So the narcissist is over here, um, as tearing you down and this,
please don't do this or, uh, come on, we can do better than this.
And why do you have to talk to me like that?
Pleading, coaxing, convincing.
Instead you might ask, well, uh, just because the person has
pronounced themselves, the judge, uh, what is my obligation?
And the answer is not, uh, I don't have an obligation
to that person in that realm.
Um, what I want to do is I want to, uh, exercise my independent thinking.
And, and this, this takes a discipline on your part because the narcissist
is counting on you to get sucked in to the mood of the moment.
Uh, subjectivity instead of objectivity, objectivity says, well, let's see.
You deem me to be no good.
And as I examined myself, I think, well, I'm a bag of pluses and minuses,
but on the whole, I'm pretty pleased with who I am and I like how I process
things and how I'm committed to grow.
Therefore, I don't really think your judgment is a fair, uh, and being.
Wait a minute.
There's so many things about you.
We can turn around and judge you on.
It's just nonsensical.
Uh, and so I just don't feel the need to get into that game.
And then I'm hoping it, and this is a part of what we
described as your boundaries.
I'm hoping you can pull back and say, I need to have a predetermined,
uh, understanding of who I am, what defines me and what characteristics
that are going to be most central to my being, uh, how do I want
to engage with other individuals?
And so you have a well-conceived definition of a healthy you.
And so when the narcissist comes along and sit in their unhealthiness says,
well, I just, I need to tear you down so that I can build myself
up, which is what they're doing.
The object of person says, um, that that doesn't compute for me.
That's your game.
I'm not going to join you in that.
And so I'm hoping that you can, uh, uh, release the narcissist from the
requirement of dropping their judgmentalism because they won't.
Um, but I release you, uh, you know, you can judge all you want, but you see,
uh, I, I don't look at you at you as my judge, I, I I'm not into that.
And so it's a matter of you, uh, asking, you know, uh, where does
my sense of wellbeing comes from?
And it comes from your own internal reflection, uh, reflection that comes
from you having a sense of purpose and meaning that comes from other kinds
of resources, uh, not the job, the narcissist, the narcissist is not God
over you and they don't have the permission, uh, or the right, even
though they claim all of that to say, uh, my pronouncement is final.
No, it's not.
Okay.
Um, now this is another one because, uh, it, uh, it talks about covert
scapegoating and I want to make sure you understand what that is.
Uh, this person says, I'd really like to hear your thoughts about commonalities
and the long-term prospects for those who have been covertly scapegoated
from their family of origin.
Uh, mostly for refusing to enable any, uh, intergenerational, prolonged,
harmful, toxic behaviors within that family's dynamics.
So first of all, good for you that, uh, as you are engaging with your
extended family, that you've developed enough awareness, uh, where you think,
you think, you know, these people, when you talk about a communal narcissism,
these people have kind of decided, well, we're just going to go ahead and, and,
and participate in this strong group.
Think, uh, you know, there may be one or two primary narcissists and the
others are over there nodding their head.
And so, uh, there, there can be just this agreement that says, well,
we stand for bigotry.
We stand for judgmentalism.
We stand for, uh, exclusivity.
If you don't think like this and get out of here, you're not in the club and
you're over there thinking, well, you know, life doesn't need to be that way.
I don't want to be bigoted or, or prejudiced or, uh, judgmental or exclusive.
If you, and if you're not exactly like me, then you're not in my club.
I want to be open and I want to be kind and I don't want to just size people up
and criticize them and judge them like the rest of you.
And so when, uh, when you realize that, uh, that they don't care for you, then
first it says, but my response to you then is that good for you.
Now, when we talk about covert, uh, scapegoating covert scapegoating is,
uh, let's say you're not going to be included, you know, they, they
wind up having a gathering and you didn't get the, uh, uh, you didn't
get the invitation or it may be that, uh, that they'll talk about you behind
your back or, uh, they'll do some things that just make you look foolish.
Like, uh, you know, there, there's going to be a potluck dinner.
They don't tell you, Hey, you need to bring some vegetables.
And then when you show up with nothing, it's like, what's wrong with you?
You didn't contribute, did you?
I mean, that kind of stuff.
That's the covert, uh, escape scapegoating.
And they'll that guaranteed.
They will talk about you behind your back.
And so, uh, when you ask, you know, how, uh, how are you going to
respond to this covert scapegoating?
My, my immediate reaction.
I don't mean to be sarcastic, but I just, I mean it honestly.
Good.
You notice that I think differently.
You notice that I'm not in your prejudice or judgmental or finicky or
emotionally dysregulated, uh, uh, manner of life.
Thank you for noticing.
You don't need necessarily say that out loud.
And then I'm hoping there can be a mindset that says, I'm really
glad that I don't, that I have enough awareness that I
don't get sucked into that.
Uh, that's not something that I agree with.
If I'm going to be with people, my people, I want them to be
individuals who are committed to something other than deviousness and
self-protection at other people's expense.
And so I see that you've noticed that I'm not like you.
I'll take that as a backhanded compliment and move on.
And so, um, by the way, there, there's a word that, that, uh,
describes where you are that also describes what they're threatened by.
This, the word independence or another word is freedom, freedom
and independence, same concept.
Uh, they're threatened by your independent thinking.
I'm like, I might, my thought is, well, isn't that a good thing?
Uh, no, you have to lay down your independent thoughts and just, um,
pick up on our group think here and a good for you that you choose not to.
Uh, because, and then, and just know the price is I will be
scapegoated by them through lack of inclusion and all of that.
They're a little club that's like, okay.
Um, go remember the Groucho Marx comment.
Uh, why would I want to be in a club that where they want to choose me?
I don't want to be in that club anyway.
So that's kind of where we're going to be coming from.
Y'all know who Groucho Marx is anyway.
Okay.
Another question.
Um, this person asked, does a narcissist way relationships in terms of whether
or not the person is a liability?
Interesting.
Do you say liability as opposed to asset?
And the answer is yes.
Uh, and, uh, when I say interesting, I don't say it's the wrong thing.
Um, in other words, is there something wrong with you?
Are you going to hold me back?
That's the liability part.
Um, let's keep in mind that one of the most common patterns that we see with
narcissists, and it's pretty exclusive across the board is that they are
transactional in the way that they engage with you.
In other words, they want something from you.
And if, uh, if you give them whatever it is they want, they're happy.
And so, and if you act in such a way that builds up their fragile ego,
then it's like, this is a good deal.
And so when you come along and saying, uh, well, um, I'm my own separate
person, um, and, uh, we don't think the same immediately they hear one
word and that is rejection.
Oh, so you're different from me.
That means you reject me.
And your thought can be, no, I'm not rejecting you.
I'm just simply saying there are times when I have different preferences or
interpretations or opinions or priorities, nothing more, nothing less.
This is not a rejection.
It's just me, um, establishing my distinction.
And, uh, and then when, uh, when they feel like there's a gap as a
result between them and you, um, they're thinking, well, yeah, there's
a gap it's your fault, as opposed to saying, you know, I'm glad we have a
wide array of people inside our group here who think differently and, uh,
who, uh, have different perspectives or priorities, uh, and we can
probably learn from each other this years ago, there was an organization
that I was in and I had very high regard for the leader.
Uh, and one of the things that he said was when I have to set up committees
for blah, blah, blah, whatever kind of topic we're looking at, I like to
make sure that, uh, inside my committee, I have people on both sides of the
spectrum and lots of times, you know, where people come from, because I want
to make sure that we have healthy discussions about who we are and where
we're going, because sometimes we need somebody that comes in and says, well,
I've got a different angle as long as we can do it in a collegial kind of
way that we're going to get somewhere.
Narcissists think, well, when I get a committee, I want a bunch of yes.
And so if you come into my group, whether it's a family or work setting
or social setting, and you show yourself to being not willing to prop
them up, you are that liability.
And again, it goes back to that other one about, uh, the big, the
covert, uh, the covert scapegoat.
Uh, they, they think transaction, you're not giving me what I want.
Therefore, uh, you're, you're a drag on my life.
But in fact, it's like, you don't even see, I can actually be positive because
they're not secure enough to think that way they're, they're so insecure
that they have to have people say, uh, Oh, great master.
Uh, you're, you're the one who thinks, right.
Uh, if I ever deviate from you, I apologize in advance.
I mean, that's a, that's a bit of exaggeration.
That's kind of the way they go.
Uh, okay.
Uh, this next one, I haven't had one quite like this before.
Uh, although it gets into addictions.
Um, this person says, I'm curious to know if a child who has parents who
were frequently stoned from cannabis will experience trauma, it would seem
that this disconnect could be felt by infants, toddlers, little children.
Interesting question.
So apparently you have a mom and or dad, uh, who, and maybe there's a whole
team of folks who just sit around smoking weed and you've got these
little kids, uh, that are going around.
And, and, uh, mom and dad may be over there, just, um, uh, stroking out
over being high and just enjoying that.
And who knows what goes along with it?
Uh, can, uh, can this be considered abuse?
And the answer is yeah, it can.
Now, see, we often think of abuse in terms of loud shouting
and hitting and all of that.
That's certainly abuse and sexual abuse and things like that.
But, uh, there's, there's also such a thing as passive aggressive abuse.
Uh, and, and that's what you're referring to here.
Passive aggressiveness may not, uh, may, may come out and it's
like, uh, I'm not going to yell at you.
I'm just going to be over here and I'm not going to pay any attention to you.
You don't really matter that much to me.
Or if you have needs in the moment, I'll do the absolute minimum that I
have to, uh, because I'm into me and I'm not really into you.
And so the sense that I get from this question is, uh, you have
individuals, adults who are too into their, uh, uh, their own, uh, self
gratification that they just don't tend to the child.
And, uh, my response to all of that is keep in mind that everything
you do communicate something.
And when you are so busy getting high or doing your thing and being with your
pals to the extent that the kids are left behind, then, uh, it sends the message.
You're a bother.
I consider you to be a nuisance.
You're not worth my time.
Uh, I could help you, but why would I want to do that?
And, and all of that is, is in an unspoken covert kind of way.
And the child may not be, uh, uh, articulate enough to be able
to, uh, to pull it together like that.
But that's, what's being, uh, that's, what's being, uh, communicated.
Keep in mind that when we talk about the passive aggressive person,
it has the word aggressive in it.
And when we say aggressive, that, uh, that person who's sending the message
of disinterest is, uh, is establishing their needs while invalidating you.
Uh, it's just not in the loud kind of way.
Uh, and it creates a feeling of, uh, uh, punishment on the path of the child.
Why not matter or futility?
Uh, I guess it, uh, what I, what I do, who I am doesn't matter.
And so, uh, the, the adult can be conveying to the child, Hey, look, I quit.
I quit on you.
I'm just going to give you the minimum if that.
And so you get that message over and over and over.
Uh, and yes, it's going to be traumatizing.
Uh, many of you know that my brother's a forensic psychologist and he, uh, he, uh,
does testing with the bad boy cases, uh, in, uh, the criminal system.
And many of them were either on the receiving end of very strong overt abuse
and many of them were on the receiving end of neglect and sometimes it's all
drugs and who knows what, uh, for mom and dad, but that's a very common
theme, unfortunately with some people.
So yes, that's the same thing as trauma because the kid
doesn't know what to do.
They're just left.
They can have fear, they can have dread.
Uh, and, uh, all that goes into it, it's just brought to
them in a different kind of venue.
That's pretty sad.
And, uh, it makes you wonder, well, why do you bring children into this world
when you, uh, are not willing to, uh, to take responsibility at the whole other
story, but narcissism is all about people not taking responsibility and
just going their own selfish ways.
We just tend to have different ways that we do it.
Okay.
I've got another question here.
I don't know that I've addressed this or not.
Uh, I'm wondering how many of you have heard of EMDR.
I'll explain that in just a minute.
Um, this person asked the question, how do you recover after you get
away from the narcissist and what are some of the daily steps to take?
And then the question is, is EMDR helpful with trauma?
Now EMDR stands for eye movement, desensitization, and reprocessing.
Now, back in the good old days, we didn't have computers and things like that.
We had what was called the progressive desensitization.
I remember I had a professor back in my undergraduate days at Baylor, and he
would, uh, show us how to have, uh, desensitization works that you get
yourself in a very quiet kind of position.
And, uh, you just kind of go into a very relaxed state and you, uh, you
progressively, uh, uh, take yourself into relaxation and then in a therapeutic
kind of way, the, uh, the therapist then would say, let's talk about, you know,
you're going to be around this person or around this situation.
And they start bringing in the, uh, uh, the negative situation, uh, while
you're in that state of relaxation.
And then as you tense, then they bring you back down into relaxation and they,
they, uh, they teach you to learn how to associate, uh, uh, calmness
with the difficult situation.
It's a, it's a, uh, a multi-tiered kind of a thing.
I'm, I'm giving it in short term.
Uh, the, uh, the EMDR is a more sophisticated way to do that.
Uh, it's, uh, often it's done with computers where, uh, where you have
stimulations, where you have, you look over here and you look over here and you
look up and look down and you have these beautiful scenes and all, and then you
have a introduction of, uh, the same kind of thing, the traumatic kind of situations.
And then, uh, you, you learn to associate, uh, uh, your own
calmness with the difficulties.
And it, it, it kind of re rewires your brain, so to speak, and get you out of
that loop where the amygdala is just firing things off left and right.
Um, now, and again, uh, uh, I'm not giving it in the, uh, in the fullest
context is far more complicated than that.
Uh, is EMDR helpful in the, uh, treatment of trauma?
My approach now, I may not be the same as everybody else is.
Uh, I look at EMDR as an adjunct, uh, I actually, in the practice I had in, uh,
in the Dallas, Texas area, uh, for a while, we had a person, uh, who, uh, who
did EMDR and, uh, uh, reported good success with, uh, with patients like that.
And so, uh, and then I've had familiarity with other individuals that
has become pretty popular right now.
Um, but, uh, it's, it's kind of more of a behavioral technique, which is fine.
But then in addition, as you get yourself to the point where the, you
have a little bit less of that fight or flight kind of reaction, uh, and more
of a sense of calm, then I think it's also helpful and most necessary to go
into insight oriented therapy.
And so, uh, because that, that too is something that, uh, that needs to be
processed, so I don't think of it as, uh, uh, one or the other, but sometimes,
uh, different modalities of, uh, counseling can, uh, can be beneficial.
Uh, all right.
Now, the next question, we're going back and talking about, um, uh, uh,
narcissists when they invalidate.
This person asked the question, is it possible to be vulnerable in front of a
narcissist?
Um, for example, if they provide input, but you don't want to, to invite more
criticism.
So, uh, the question is, is it possible to be vulnerable in front of a narcissist?
Yeah, it's possible.
You can do it if you want to.
I think the deeper question is, is it wise to be vulnerable in front of a
narcissist, keeping in mind they're, they're game players.
Uh, for example, the narcissist gives you input.
Uh, and then, uh, as you are receiving that input and then you begin talking
about your reactions to it or your feelings about it, uh, you begin realizing,
uh, well, they've got an agenda here and I don't know if I'm saying the right
thing, I'm exposing myself.
And this may lead to or towards, uh, harshness or criticism or rolling of the
eyes or rejection of some form, some form.
So is it reasonable?
Is it wise to be vulnerable in front of a narcissist?
Unfortunately, once you begin realizing that this is an individual who's constantly
playing that one up, one down kind of game, then the simplest of self
revelations can come against you.
And so it really comes down to, is this a safe person?
Uh, I like the idea of being vulnerable.
Um, give me an example.
Uh, not that long ago, I was talking with a friend of mine who was discussing
a, uh, a family member who turned out to be an incredibly difficult person.
One of these, uh, people that had a real nice veneer, but behind the
scenes are a whole lot more going on.
And he was making himself vulnerable to me and explaining, you know, how it
affected him and other family members.
And, uh, and, uh, I like when somebody is that way toward me.
And if I had a similar situation where I felt like I needed to process it, I like
having a friend that I can sit down and say, Hey, can I talk to you about something?
And so vulnerability is part of developing intimacy.
Narcissists don't do intimacy.
They do transactions.
We go back to that.
Uh, and they're constantly trying to figure out what do I have to
do to be on the high side of you?
And so when you share your vulnerabilities, they're thinking, oh, I'm collecting
some data now and I can use this against me.
So maybe short term, they'll say, well, tell me more.
Oh, this is interesting.
Or, uh, what else happened?
What was next?
But then later on, uh, you might be shamed for it, or you might be a scorned line.
Well, you, you've got all these broken relationships in your life anyway.
Why would I listen to you?
And so your vulnerability can then later come back and bite you in the backside.
And so I'm thinking that if you know that this is somebody who, uh, who's
an exploiter and a user, then, uh, proceed with caution, uh, just keep it
functional, uh, now, if, if you, over time, if you've learned that somebody
has, uh, uh, has the ability to process with you and they're, they're willing
to be vulnerable in a very healthy way with you, then, uh, continue to go down
there, but this is why we say, uh, give yourself time before you, uh, you go
deeper and deeper into that vulnerability.
Narcissists like to suck you in pretty quickly.
Oh, please be vulnerable with me.
Tell me all the things.
They'll try to tell you some personal things, uh, like, uh, you know, things
from their past that didn't work out.
Well, uh, you only find out later on, it was just a complaint session about
the other person that they're the victim.
Uh, that's how they work it.
So just proceed with caution.
They'll take your vulnerability and, uh, it, uh, unfortunately, uh, they'll
take something good and turn it into something negative toward you.
I mean, isn't it sad that we have to think this way?
Uh, okay.
Another one, you know, that I talk quite a bit about anger with narcissists
and a part of my understanding of narcissism arose from me, uh, having
a deep history of doing, uh, anger workshops and books and then things like
that, this person asked the question, why are narcissists always angry at
something agitated, unsettled, then flying around like a chicken has no head
and mad and they act like everything is life or death when it doesn't even
matter, and then it just says weirdos.
They drive me nuts.
Okay.
I think I got your idea on that.
They drive me nuts.
They're weirdos chicken with a head got off.
Um, well, um, let's look at the core ingredients of narcissism.
Um, narcissists want to be in control.
Narcissists have to be superior.
Narcissists, uh, have to cover, uh, their, their, uh, real self.
And they've put up a veneer of false self.
They're highly defensive.
Uh, they manipulate people.
And so, uh, when you say why are they so easily angry?
Uh, well, when you come along and say, well, I'd like to do some
things that don't include that.
Uh, well, what you're saying is stop doing whatever it is you're doing
down at the core of your being.
Cause it doesn't work.
And they are so non insightful or so self absorbed that it's like in their
mind, they're thinking you don't have the right to ask me to be healthy.
I'm going to stay unhealthy.
And so the very unhealthiness that they are committed to in their lives just
makes them a guaranteed sitting duck for anger, uh, cause who wants
to be controlled by that person?
So when they come across in their controlling way, uh, somebody's
going to buck against it or who wants to be the, uh, the recipient
of their non-empathy and their insensitive insensitivity, I don't
get people are going to be annoyed at that.
And so, uh, and it's going to generate agitation in the narcissist.
And so by virtue of their unhealthy pattern of life and definition of who
they are and foundation, uh, it just makes them just highly, highly susceptible
to the anger and all the defensiveness and accusation that goes along with it.
Uh, it's, it's just, um, uh, their, their, their very being and doing, uh,
runs counter to anything healthy and it leaves them susceptible to the
unhealthiness, which is all of that, uh, unwieldy anger that you
get to be the recipient of.
Okay.
Um, yeah, one last question here.
This person says, Dr.
Singh with narcissists, it's all about power and control, passive,
aggressive behavior, shaming, criticizing, lying, and manipulation.
Pretty bad list.
With my ex-husband, he uses gifts to manipulate and in his
manipulation, he acts like he's about six years old, even though
he's a 64 year old man, what he can get in, uh, thinking about what
he can get in this transaction.
Could you explain the childish slash adult combination in this particular
behavior, because I don't understand.
Okay.
Let's understand that, uh, that narcissists are all about
collecting and keeping power and dominance and the position of control.
Now, how does that relate to a little child?
Well, children, a six year old child, uh, have, uh, often are sent the
message you're not in control here.
Uh, if you do the wrong thing, you're going to get clobbered.
If you give me the wrong answer, I'm going to be very disappointed
in you and you're going to be judged.
And so very early on that budding narcissist, uh, as they develop and can
have more and more cogent kind of thoughts, they begin thinking, all
right, I'm in the position where I'm the underling, how can I get control?
And so what they'll do is tell secrets or they'll deny, or they'll
throw a temper tantrum and it's their way of saying, uh, I don't want
you to just come down hard on me.
Uh, now, ideally as, uh, as adults witness this in little children, uh,
they can improve, uh, prove to be safe harbors for that child.
And instead of coming down and saying, you will not be that way, uh, the
adult can say, well, I can tell you're feeling hurt or frustrated or confused.
Let's talk about that.
And, uh, and I love talking with kids that way.
And, uh, because, uh, over time, if you establish yourself as somebody
who's safe, uh, at least in a high percentage of the cases, they can
come toward you and think, oh, how about that?
You're not going to yell at me.
And you're not going to call me names or send me to my room.
It's like, well, what I'd like to do is just talk.
I can tell you were frustrated.
Let's discuss that.
There might've been a really good reason for that.
What was your reason?
And let's take a look at your options.
Narcissist in their early development did not have that experience
or if they did, it didn't soak in.
And so here they are now an adult and they're still thinking, okay,
I've got to keep power.
And so I'm going to come up with all sorts of ways to, uh, to maintain my power.
In this case, so I'll give you gifts, I'll do you favors.
Uh, and so, uh, they're, they're like that little kid thinking, whatever I can
do to manipulate you not to reject me, then that's what I'm going to do.
And they haven't learned what we referred to or what I refer
to as emotional competence.
Um, instead it's all very reactive and it's very dependent
upon the person in front of them.
And so you have a 64 year old acting like a six year old because
they don't have inner strength.
They're constantly seeking it from other people, just like children do.
And children though, at least they have the vantage point where they
have a time ahead of themselves, where they can learn new patterns.
64 year olds, not all of them, but a high percentage of them are stuck.
Uh, sometimes you get 64 year old people that can say, you know,
I'm tired of this, let's do something different.
And they go into the healthier direction.
A lot of times they don't.
So it's all about power.
Uh, just like a little kid is seeking, you know, how to find a position of power
in their little powerless, uh, feeling that they carry.
All right, guys, I hope you have a good holiday season.
Uh, you know, here we are a week away from the Christmas time.
Um, and some of you, uh, sharing that same tradition there, I hope
it's a meaningful time for you.
Others of you may not share in that same tradition, but I know, uh,
you have a good time with family and then perhaps get some time off to relax
and, and, uh, relate well with people that you love and know.
Um, and now again, this is the last live feed like this that we're going to have,
but I'm going to continue to receive your questions and then just continue
to join me on, uh, Wednesday mornings at 10 central and then, uh, Saturday
mornings at 10 central as well.
And I'm still going to be fielding your questions.
I'll just be doing it a little bit of a different format.
I really like hearing from you.
And so know that, uh, that it's a, it's a major part of my, um, uh, uh, trying
to intervene in a, in a way that's hopefully a positive for you.
Um, I'm so glad we have team healthy here.
I love you guys.
And I love what you stand for.
And I love the fact that you're working hard at being a decent person.
Dignity, respect, and civility.
That's what we stand for, right?
Okay, guys, I'll see you next time.
And I hope you have a good holiday season.
Bye for now.