Matt Gaetz amplified a claim that Trump could use the 1952 McCarran-Walter Act to bar Muslims from public office, days after Abdul El-Sayed became the first Muslim elected to the U.S. Senate. The problem is basic constitutional law: Article VI explicitly prohibits religious tests for public office, while the 1952 immigration law governs entry into the country, not whether an American citizen can serve in government. The same claim has circulated for years, and its return immediately after El-Sayed’s victory follows a campaign filled with attacks on his religion. Ring of Fire's Josh G. explains.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
The speaker condemns a social media post by Matt Gaetz that suggests using the 1952 McCarran-Walter Act to bar Muslims from public office, specifically targeting Senator-elect Dr. Abdul El-Sayed. The speaker argues that such a move is unconstitutional, based on a recurring Islamophobic hoax, and serves as a baseless attack on a democratically elected official.
Matt Gaetz posted something horrific Monday morning,
and I shouldn't be surprised because
I have seen this from the MAGA types since this election.
But first, I want you to remember who Matt Gaetz is,
the guy who resigned from Congress
just ahead of an ethics report dropping
that showed that he allegedly paid underage girls
for disgusting conduct.
But even after all that, he was Donald Trump's pick
for attorney general for about eight
days, and then he ended up with his own show on OAN.
And his Facebook page still says, quote,
Congressman Matt Gaetz two years later.
But he posted this.
President Trump is reportedly moving
to revive the 1952 McCarran-Walter Act
and bar Muslims from public office.
The question is whether
the Constitution still allows ideological tests for power.
And under it, a photo.
Of Senator-elect Dr. Abdul El-Sayed, who a week ago became
the first Muslim ever elected to the United States Senate.
What a great moment.
And I think I saw that he's an Arsenal fan.
I love that guy.
But the post from Matt Gaetz, absolutely awful.
And that's without getting to the horrific comments under it.
But I want to take Matt's question seriously just for a second.
Does the Constitution still...
Allow religious tests for office.
Article 6, Clause 3, no religious test shall ever be required as a
qualification to any office or public trust under the United States.
Ever.
That's 1787.
It is in the original.
Ever.
They didn't write until further notice
or until a Muslim that we don't like runs for office.
Hell, back in 61, the Supreme Court said Maryland couldn't even make
a notary public swear he believed in God.
A notary, and it was a unanimous decision.
And this is from a guy who seemingly went to law school.
He passed the bar. He swore an oath.
To the Constitution,
every time he got sworn into Congress and he's out here asking whether
it still applies, like asking if someone still takes a Groupon.
Is that still a thing, by the way?
Anyway, Gaetz's source here is a screenshot
of a tweet from an account called Lloyd Carter
Maga, blue check and everything, and I didn't.
Dig into who the hell Lloyd Carter is, but look,
as for the law, the McCarran-Walter Act
is the Immigration and Nationality Act of 1952.
It's about who gets to come into the country.
It doesn't say who can hold office because it can't.
Again, see Article 6 of the Constitution.
And again, Senator-elect El-Sayed was born in Michigan.
He's not an immigrant.
He's the son of Egyptian immigrants, a Rhodes scholar, medical degree
from Columbia, taught epidemiology, ran Detroit's health department.
So they're floating an immigration law for a guy from suburban Detroit.
And nobody needs to revive this law either. It is still in place.
It's the law that Donald Trump used for his travel ban back in 2017.
And yeah, unfortunately, the Supreme Court upheld that.
So, the revive part is gibberish,
and the bar Muslims from office is unconstitutional,
but that's what Matt Gaetz is calling national security policy.
And look, this exact hoax has been going on forever.
November 2018, Ilhan Omar, Rashida Tlaib, they get elected,
and suddenly everybody on Facebook is posting
a 1952 law bans Muslims from holding office.
Factcheck.org, they killed that.
PolitiFact, they killed it twice because it came back up again in 2019.
And then it came back around this summer with all
of the wonderful Muslim candidates contributing to our government.
And now, the week that a wonderful, awesome candidate,
a Muslim in Michigan, wins a Senate seat,
Matt Gaetz bringing it back just like it's Jason Voorhees.
Every time a Muslim wins an election,
this law climbs back out of the way.
But really, look at what was said.
National security policy has always included limits
on who may hold office inside the system they reject.
Are we not allowed to criticize our government?
The record of the doctrine is public.
The choice to reapply the standard is the remaining variable.
Hey Matt, Boyd, who the hell actually wrote that for you?
Just wondering.
But really, all this is,
it's more of the same Islamophobia from MAGA types.
You don't look like them.
You don't pray like them.
They hate you.
Two weeks ago, Port Huron, Michigan,
that rally that Minaj was at
where Donald Trump called El-Sayed
a jihadist Muslim brotherhood member
and said he was there at a rally
to stop him from becoming a United States senator.
He said Dr. El-Sayed would have to go through
a metal detector before he's allowed
to go into the Senate.
But here's the deal, Donald.
Listen, I'll go through a metal detector
if you'll sit for a lie detector.
My first question, Epstein.
Second question, did you win
the 2020 election?
So that's the deal.
I'll go through a metal detector every day.
You sit through a lie detector one time.
That's the deal.
The same day on Truth Social, Donald Trump,
using the man's full name as if it's offensive,
Abdulrahman Mohammed El-Sayed,
and said he wants the country to go in Sharia law.
And if it ever does, he should be the first that's tried.
And it's a whole thing.
Back in August, J.D. Vance called him very, very evil.
Trump on Glenn Beck saying
that he'd absolutely prohibit Sharia law thing.
And Bishara Baba, a founder of Arab Americans for Trump,
keep that in mind, said this about
Donald Trump's comments.
They are crossing a red line.
They are racist.
This is a guy who supported Trump.
And we saw what happened.
Michigan voted.
Dr. El-Sayed wins by six.
And the next move out of MAGA World, with the seat already gone,
is Matt Gaetz fighting to stay relevant by putting out
an Islamophobic religious test to try to keep him out anyway.
Let me be clear here.
I don't care if you disagree with Dr. El-Sayed on Medicare for All,
on taxes, on anything in his platform.
Go after it.
But if you go after how the man prays, you are a bigot.
I don't care how many law degrees you have.
And the people who wrote the Constitution saw people
like Matt Gaetz coming back in 1787 when they wrote it.
Senator-elect Dr. El-Sayed gets sworn in January 3rd
on whatever book he wants by J.D. Vance.
I absolutely love that.
Okay, look, that was a heavy topic.
I want to ask you guys a lighter one
for the comments because I need it.
Who's the worst congressman you've ever had
and what are they doing right now?
My worst congressman ever has his own show on OAN.
Drop yours below in the comments,
hit subscribe on your way out and that join button if you
want to become a member and support us, it's right there too.