Masters of Wine Review Costco Red Wines | 1 Hidden red wine

Red Wine Collection
1 follower
Today, we are doing Kirkland red wine tasting
From last video, you said there is a significant difference
between $60 and $10 bottle
I wanted to see if that's true
So these are all $10 bottles with the exception of one?
One is $60
And then also I wanted to see if any of the Kirkland brand
can keep up with that level or even close to it
to try to find a good quality Kirkland wine
More importantly, since you've already told me or told us
that they could be from anywhere in the world
What's even more important than
can $10 wines compete with $60?
They better not be able to
Is since they've come from all over the world
Each bottle has got an Appellation Controle
or whatever it is on it
Are they identifiable as wines from that place?
Exactly
For $10, that's a challenge
And for people who are watching this video
who are not familiar with the Kirkland brand
That's Costco's own branded wines
Those products deliver quality at a very good price
Now, when we're talking wine
Especially red wine
It gets a little dicier
One thing when we have un-oaked red wines
You can produce some delicious un-oaked red wines
When you start oaking them cheaply
You're in the realm of oak chips and oak staves
to get to that $10 price point
Now, there are better staves and better chips
and lesser staves and chips
And there are people who are really good at doing chips and staves
and people who are not
Generally, I can even smell the oak chips or the oak staves early on
and those tannins can be very hard
For the audience as well
a good friend and colleague of ours
is one of the people who sources Kirkland wines
But we're going to not let that bias us at all
because we don't know if any of his wines are here or not
and we'll just let the wines speak for themselves
Anything else to add before we taste?
I hate it when wines talk
Do not speak for yourself
I'll tell you when you can talk
Okay, alright, let's start
Let's do it
Michael Broadbent, well-known
He worked for Christie's for a very long, long period of time
He was fairly prolific in his writing
And he once said that ordinary wines were for drinking and not for discussion
Though I disagree with him
Because ordinary wines, they're an engine that drives the train of the business of wine
Many of them, I agree, are not wines for discussion at all
But finding wines that deliver value
and a sense of place, hopefully
certainly a sense of the variety
Those wines are worth discussing
Do you agree, Peter?
Yes, I do
But if we go into the tiers
You know, the sort of old hackneyed phrases
Are you talking about people crying?
No
The entry level is table wine, Vandertap
One step up from there is Vandersopage
Wine made from a specific variety
and therefore you need to be able to taste the variety
And the third one is Van der Terrois
So Van der Terrois is, in our context, not a specific piece of land
But Van der Terrois means, in a context like this
Does it speak of a specific place?
Chianti, whatever it might be
I agree with Patrick
But at the bottom of it all
Irrespective of whether they show place or variety
Because you just already told us
That with the exception of one wine, they're all around $10
Would you drink those other wines for $10?
Yes, that is the question
That is the question
Do you want to answer it for you?
Some of them, I would drink for $10
Certainly, if you were paying in the bar
There's only one wine here that I would dither with
All the rest, I would absolutely drink at $10
Surprisingly good quality across the board
I agree, absolutely
And the other question, can we discern a more expensive bottle of wine?
The proverbial $60 bottle of wine
I got it just by looking at the color, swirling
Looking at the legs that were pigmented coming down
I said, that is a no-brainer
There's one wine here that's hidden shoulders above the others
I hope you and I got the same one
And there's a reason for that
That the single characteristic that most determines price of wine
This is across the board
I mean, at a certain point when people are drinking label
Other things come into play, right?
And scarcity comes into play
But the number one thing, cost of the grapes
To have more concentrated grapes
Usually, you have a more specific site
A site that the land costs more
It may cost more to farm
And the yields tend to be lower
Which doesn't say that lower yields always...
Very, very, very low yields always yield better quality
Absolutely, amen to that
And so just looking at these wines
There was one wine that was more deeply colored
It had more concentration of flavor
More complexity, it had more length
But that said, I was surprised as to
How many of these wines showed variety and where they were from
Now, that's assuming that I was right
But we'll see if you're right
Shall we get the good wine out of the way?
Let's get the good wine out of the way, No. 3
No. 3, OK
So No. 3 is hidden shoulders above the others
Not just because of those things that Patrick said about
Concentration and all that
That was, of course, absolutely true
I mean, this is a really, really good wine
Was it easy to find, though?
Easy to find
And, you know, Patrick found it on the color
I didn't because you can do all sorts of things to mess with color
But I found it on it
You just can't make a wine like that for $10
35 or 40 years of experience and bullshit, it's that
You pay more, you get more
I shouldn't have told you that there was a $60 wine
And the reality is that if somebody said this is $10
I'd say, go out and buy as much of this as you know how to do
No, no, no, if somebody tells you that that wine was $10
Forward the guy to me because he's in serious need of consulting
And maybe psychiatric care
Maybe tooth work
Tooth work and perhaps in need of a bankruptcy attorney soon
So let's talk about that one first and then we'll do the other ones
No. 3, and we both agree
Deep purple garnet, opaque color, legs with pigment
The nose was tight, but there was cassis there
There was noticeable alcohol and oak
It was full-bodied
The tannins were full, but they had ripeness and elegance
There was a, not just quantity of tannin, but the quality of tannin
It was rich, well-balanced, very good length
I thought this was made from Bordeaux varieties
And I thought this was coming from France, from Bordeaux
100% in agreement
Let's see where it's from
Did you get more clue from the color or from your nose?
Initially, I got it just from the color
But again, when you are going to put your marker down, you do the whole thing
The color, nose, and everything combined
Alright, so No. 3, it's hard to read
It's a Chateau Marasco, I call it in Korea, Thank Dekji Berry
2020 Margot Grand Cru Classé
Great vintage, I loved wines from Margot, it was a precious wine
It's my favorite region as well, Margot
Let's get down to the essence of this tasting
$10, what do we get?
Wine No. 1 was very dark
Deep ruby, not quite opaque, no age showing
Obviously long legs because there's reasonable alcohol here
It's quite extracted
On the nose, it was kind of dusty
I thought I detected US oak
Entry was tight, very tannic
But I found it ungenerous
It was high acid, slightly short finish
Not bad wine at all, not charming
Not so faux oak
And by faux oak, you mean sort of fake oak?
Yeah
Not oak barrels?
Not oak barrels
How do you know though?
There's a character, and I don't always get it right
But there's a character to the oak
Which is a sort of, there's a greenness, there's a harshness
There's a sort of character there which sort of hints of having rushed it
So the question was, what was it?
In the end, I went for New World, probably Bordeaux blends
It's one of my lowest scores, I gave it 81
I got some pimento on this as well
Some greenness that again spoke to Bordeaux varieties
Higher yields gives you some of that greenness
I was also New World, Bordeaux varieties
I was thinking Cabernet Sauvignon more than Merlot
There could be a blend, probably from California
Let's see what it is
Number one is Bordeaux
It's a Bordeaux?
Yeah, Superior 2021
60% Cabernet, 40% Merlot
Well, it's good that we had that right after we spoke about the real deal
Now, Bordeaux Superior, or Bordeaux Soups
They are not superior to other Bordeaux
It's just the name of the classification
And these wines have improved dramatically with climate change
And they used to be abysmal
And this wine is reasonably drinkable
But again, it was one of my least favorite of the...
It was my least favorite of the line-up
I would drink it
Number two?
Yeah, this is the lightest in color
Light red, rim cleared
I didn't see any real sign of age on it
The nose was somewhat muted
I got muted berry with a hint of oak on the palate
Nice up front berry fruit
And then the oak took over, shortening the finish
There was a spiciness on the finish that reminded me of Zinfandel
So I played with it on that basis
I moved away from that in the end
I agree with the spiciness
I ended up thinking it was Pinot, but not Burgundy
And I had thought about Pinot as well
And that spicy note was what tipped me over
But you know, it's hard to find Pinot for $10
So that's the point
I've messed with things that could be lighter
Tempranillo, which is usually much darker
Tempranillo, got a nice sharp
In the end, I went with Pinot
Maybe out of New Zealand or something like that
Let's see
Alright, let's see, number two
Indeed, Pinot Noir, Caneros, Napa Valley though, 2022
Wow, that's amazing
Yeah, that's a pretty good value, $10
And in general, for people learning about wine
It's much easier to find wines expressive of variety
at price points substantially above $10
Oh, absolutely
When you get to the $10 range, it gets a bit tougher
Number four
This is also definitely red, sort of ruby, pale ruby, dark cherry, something like that
No age showing
Legs, but no extract
A little bit of earth, I thought I saw on the color
So that would be some age, but no, not really
Tannic entry
Well done, but just hard to do like at this price
Thoreau's European wine
To be honest, I thought this was Chianti
I love Chianti Riserva more than any other red wine on the planet
And so to try and, if this was Chianti,
to try and squeeze Sangiovese into this price point, extremely difficult
But that's where I am
I think we're drinking Chianti or something based on Sangiovese
And I scored the wine 86
I'm on the same boat as you, Peter
The light color, the berry fruit, but the earthiness as well
Combined with the bitter cherry
The bitter cherry, very nice acidity
I quickly went to Sangiovese in Italy
Hopefully, that's where we are
Alright, so No. 4, indeed, Chianti Classico Riserva
Riserva, give me a break
That is not a Riserva
But this is very popular in Korea as well
I'm glad that you both liked it
I'm glad we liked it, you know why?
Because if I'm at all known in Korea, it's for my love of Sangiovese
And it would be very good that I picked up the Sangiovese
OK, so this is wine No. 5
It was medium ruby red, though you could still see through it
I got coconut, dill and berry
The palate, I thought, was bitter than the nose
And I also got some lemon pledge and some earthiness
So the coconut and dill for me is American oak
The lemony notes for a red wine with earthiness is Tempranillo
So I thought this was Tempranillo from Spain
That lemon pledge, whose note was that?
It's mine
Is it your note?
I'm in Spain
I'm either Tempranillo or mostly Tempranillo
And I went to Rioja
Yes, alright, No. 5, Rioja
Too easy for you
Riserva
2019, Rioja
And without a matter of it could be Riserva
It's not too easy for us
Patrick and I are having a great day
I speak for myself, I'm having a great day
Well, on the side of the yard, we both stepped in shit
I was debating No. 4 and 5 for Chianti
Do they share any similarity between Tempranillo and Chianti?
Earthiness
But the Sangiovese is going to have cherry
The Tempranillo is going to have berry
The Sangiovese is going to have higher acidity
And the tannins are going to be a bit more stringent
And also, you're not going to get American oak on Sangiovese
From Italy, you're going to get it in Spain
Tempranillo can do much darker colors than Sangiovese
That doesn't mean to say that it is
But Tempranillo is capable of seriously dark color
Whereas Sangiovese, for the most part, is not
But if you have Rioja that has a good amount of garnacha,
the color can be lighter
Yes, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6
So No. 6, somewhat paler than the others
But not pale, no extract
Lots of legs, but not no extract, but almost no extract
I picked up oak here, an almost sweet entry
But then the attack was bold
I struggled with this one
In the end, I went with garnacha
So I don't know if that's Ribera or...
Because I thought it was Spain
Ribera del Duero or something with lots of garnacha
So that's where I was
And I think those are all good thoughts
But not with great confidence
So this one doesn't tell the place very well
And No. 6 is...
Oh, my gosh! Shut the door!
So what percentage of garnacha is that?
70% Greenache, 10% Syrah, 10% Morvedra, 10% Sinsol?
Sansol
Retasting it, it does taste like Chateauneuf or Gigonas
This is $20 bottle
That's a nice bottle of wine
And the last one
Last one
Medium purple garnet
The nose was muted to me
On the palate, I had firm oak-chiped tannins right out of the bat
Fairly nice fruit up front
And then I got this oak-chip or oak-stave
When you're a kid, having a popsicle
If you had a popsicle and it had a stick in your mouth for a while
It gave you this bitter tannins
Nothing screamed out of me
But based upon the fairly deep color and some berry fruit
I went to Syrah, Washington state versus Australia
I usually can pick a very, very cheap wine
Because I drink a lot of cheap wine
This one, I definitely thought it was like a really cheap wine
I thought this was a European wine
Took a long story short of all the bullshit
Based on Tempranillo
Let's see what it is
So basically, it's not telling you a place either
It's an Alexander Valley 2021 Cabernet Sauvignon
This one was very cheap
As well
Oh, $10! OK, that's $10
Rioja was $8
So Rioja, I would go with Rioja
Rioja was $8?
$8, yes
The Rissova
Here, just the way that they oaked it
Just got in the way
I would not have a second, you know
I would have a sip or two of that at a party
And say, sorry, let me try
Yeah, so it's hard
So we tasted seven wines
Six were Kirkland wines
And these wines, I think, showed for the most part
I would be more complimentary than that
I think they were very good value
And the wines were good enough in terms of representing variety
That we got them mostly right
You and I both basically got them
Right, yeah
And some were better than others
But some of them also showed a sense of place as well
So for $10, or in the case of the Chateauneuf-du-Pope, $20
That was pretty good
And we also showed that a well-selected
There are $60 bottles of wine that are harsh and difficult to drink
That Margot beautifully balanced a beautiful wine for $60
So we showed that if you've got some more money in your hand
And you know what you're buying
You can do something that's heads and shoulders, legs above these ones
But that all said, the Kirkland brand wines that we tasted today
Delivered quality and delivered value
And delivered it in spades
I thought that the Rioja was very good
The Chianti was very good
That Chateauneuf-du-Pope is bloody good for $20
So the Chateauneuf-du-Pope got my highest score
Not by much, but it got my highest score
So what does this tell you?
After all of this, pay more
You get better wine
But the important thing is
It's actually possible in 2024
To deliver $10 wines
That are very nice
From very, very well-known Appalachians
That some of them are identifiable
Yes, which is nice
So we're talking about the possibility of getting Van der Terrois
At stupid prices
I'm very impressed
Good news for the consumers
Live well, drink well
Give us a couple of thumbs up
Until the next time
Alright, cheers!
I want something in my glass
What are you drinking?
What do I have to do?
Just cheers with a glass
No, no, no
Where's the Chianti?
Number 4
Oh, you're in Turkey
I'm the Chianti guy
I'm Turkey Margot
Okay, 1, 2, 3
Cheers!
