Masters of the Air: Fact-Checking the March 6, 1944 Mission to Berlin Narrative

The Globe Quest
3 followers
7 Video Views·Mar 9, 2024
In the Masters of the Air episode 7, the 100th bomb group took heavy losses during the March 6th 1944 Mission to Berlin. More 8th US army air forces bombers were lost on this mission than on any other mission during the war. The events characterized by the series will be fact checked for accuracy. Some of the issues found are nit-picky some are major.
the intent of this video was to review
the March 6th 1944 mission to Berlin
series portrayal with regard to accuracy
some of the episode inaccuracies can be
considered nitpicky some major context
and justification of the episode clip
challenge will be provided the March 6
mission to Berlin is significant as more
100th Bomb Group b7s were lost on that
mission than on any other Mission also
more eth Air Force bombers were lost on
that mission than on any other Mission
as Illustrated on this chart from a
Declassified 1945 Army Air Forces
evaluation board document titled Eighth
Air Force's tactical development the
x-axis is a date of the mission the
vertical lines represent the number of
bombers lost per Mission the mission
with the largest losses occurred on
March 6 1944 which is highlighted
here 72 bombers were lost this value
includes category e category e are
aircraft that are damaged Beyond
economic repair as defined in this 1945
statistical summary eth Air Force
operations document this is an example
of a category e B17 a summary of the
March 6 mission is shown on this page
from a March 7th 1944 eth Air Force
daily summary of operations document 812
heavy bombers were dispatched 504 b7s
and 226 b-24s from The Eighth Air Force
bombing accuracy was poor none of the
targets were hit the bombers dropped
their hik explosive and incendiary bombs
on greater Berlin urban areas with poor
results strong enemy air opposition was
encountered black was heavy and accurate
bomber Gunner crew claimed 93 enemy
aircraft shot down 44 probables and 66
damaged the definition of destroyed
probably destroyed and damaged and
accounting for the bomber Gunner over
claims have been covered in the
Channel's previous videos escort was
provided by 957 us Fighters and 31 RAF
Mustangs the fighter support is provided
in relays we will unpack fighter support
in the Channel's next video in this clip
the 100th Bomb groups Thor abits
homebased Tower and ground crews are
counting the returning bombers from the
March 6 Mission they stopped counting
when they reached
14
11
12
13
14 15 this page summarizes the
disposition of the 100 bomb groups 35
B17 sent out to support the March 6
Mission from the Tactical mission report
they were sent out in two groups A and B
the routes taken by the ab groups are
shown on this map from the post Mission
summary the location of flak enemy
Fighters and escorts are identified by
symbols on the map in addition to time
and altitude at Route points we can
process the text narration into a chart
outlining the end of mission status for
each of the airplanes dispatched six of
the 35 airplanes aboard the mission
another 15 were shot down and One landed
at another base due to
damage group A's 9 b7s landed back at
Thorp pbit starting at 4:02 p.m. and
group B's 4 b7s landed a half an hour
later total bombers Landing equates to
13 not 14 as B17 tail number 306 landed
at an alternate base this table
represents the 100th Bomb group's roster
from the March 6th mission to Berlin the
table is section by group a and Group B
The Columns represent the Pilot's name
Squadron number aircraft number the
three-digit aircraft number is stencl on
the bomber's vertical stabilizer for
example this plane's tail number is 767
plane 767 is represented by this
highlighted row bomb load out where 10 *
500 implies each B17 carries 10 500 lb
general purpose m64 bombs a cutaway of
the m64 is shown on this page from a
1945 us Naval bomb disposal document
titled bombs infuses pyrot Technics the
bomb's weight equates to 525 lb and it
contains 267 lbs of TNT these were the
most common bomb types dropped by us
heavy bombers in World War II the
destructive effect of various general
purpose bombs on residential housing is
shown on this image from a
1945 office of chief of ordinance
document titled terminal ballistics data
volume 3 the 500 lb bomb splash and
fragmentation level of Destruction is
shown on this row b7s have the bomb rack
capacity to carry 12 500 lb class bombs
as shown on this table from a 1945 aaf
air technical service command document
titled tactical planning characteristics
and performance chart to meet the range
requirements a load out of 10 were
carried during the 7h hour 54-minute
flight the target was the electronic
components plant at Bosch works if the
target cannot be hit drop your bombs
anywhere in the center of Berlin the 15
missing planes are highlighted in these
rows crew casualties where plane 767 had
no crew casualties only two planes
landed with Wounded plane 767 was not
one of them bomber battle damage three
bombers landed with serious damage and
at with slight damage this chart
describes a battle damage of tail 767
all of the damage was from ground
artillery fla holes were in the
supercharger oil tank tank door left
horizontal stabilizer vertical IC
stabilizer left wing panel and Leading
Edge none of 767 damage locations were
on the fuse LOD this is why none of 767
crew members experienced injuries given
the sequence of scene cut injured crew
members were taken from tail
[Music]
767 the clip should show injured crewmen
from Planes 807 and 306 not
767 this clip is interesting as a
medical Corman approaches bomber number
767 something is off the armband is on
his right sleeve but in an earlier clip
where the Medics are running towards 767
the armbands are on their left sleeve
since he is approaching the bomber from
the left side a trailing wire antenna
should also be visible but it is not
also the clip shows the AF crew door on
the left side it should be on the right
side all b7s were built with the crew
door on the right side the episode
editors mirror imaged the clip instead
of capturing the image correctly like
this the clip was miror imaged like this
where the features on the right side
become left and left right any film
editors care to offer a theory why this
might have been
done a major issue is that by March 1944
the B17 models would have mostly
transition from the F to the G to reduce
vulnerabilities to head on attack more
forward facing Firepower is required a
bendex chin turret was added as seen in
this image to mitigate this pH
vulnerability The turret's Arc travel is
shown on this page total ammo capacity
equates to 365 rounds per gun this image
shows the exterior features of the chin
turret from a 1944 b17g field service
manual the guns are controlled by the
Bombadier using a controller and gun
sight as discussed in previous videos
the chin turret increased the bombers
forward firing combat Effectiveness by
60% most of the hundreds B7 should have
chin turrets these started showing up at
the end of 1943 this image shows a B17
with a chin turret over Germany the
image is dated January 1944 this chart
lists of formation positions of the 15 a
group bombers and the g models are all
highlighted re indicates return early so
clearly the models portrayed in the
series are not the Next Generation G
models this is a big deal it would be
equivalent to showing Grumman wild cats
instead of grman hellcats engaging
Japanese naval aircraft during the
battle of the Philippine
Sea in this last clip a crewman laments
that Miner was shot down on his 25th
Mission and implies a German shot at the
parachuting crewmen under
25th went after our guys
in parachutes this image is miners
missing aircraft report the crew station
Personnel are listed with the number of
credited sorties Captain Miner has
completed 24 missions as has four other
crewmen their position within the 18
airplane formation is shaded here the
plane was lost to Fighters four
parachutes were observed The Narrative
does not indicate that they were fired
upon while in Parachute I could not find
any other documentation supporting the
premise this crew was fired upon during
a parachute descent it would have surely
been well documented in summary the
March 6th 1944 mission to Berlin
narrative did have some inconsistencies
that did not conform to what actually
occurred some are nitpicky some are made
they miscounted the returning bombers
counted 14 instead of the 13 that
arrived at Thor abbots from completing
the mission they mirrored a clip where
Medics approached bomber tail number 767
tale 767 is filmed as having crew
casualty when none were documented
correct period B17 models were not
represented most should be fitted with
the chin turrets none of the B7 shown
had chin turrets a crewman claims that
Miner's crew was fired upon during
parachute descent I could not find any
substantiating documentation confirming
this event if you've enjoyed this
episode Deep dive accuracy check review
please consider liking Andor commenting
on the video
